Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Gurcharan Singh Kulim, MBA Phd · 02 May 2005
I have been just thinking ....some so called enlightend Sikhs living in multi racial society have fallen away so much from their faith that they think people who are monas, because they do so much sewa ,are entitled to be Sikh leaders.
Does this meatomorrow sikhs who have chosen to be patits, can also claim that they are MONA granthis, because they can sing well and know all the shabds??
What does the sangat think of this ?
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 02 May 2005
What is the definition of a Sikh leader?
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Question Bhai · 03 May 2005
Wow! What a great debate.
All I can humbly say is that Guru Granth Sahib Ji enforces the following so who are we to disagree ?
"Khatree, Brahmin, Sood, Vesh, Ko Japay Gurmantar Japaaney"
"Kabir Ekhas Sehee Preet Rak, Aan Dubida Jaye,
Paawe Lambe Kes Rak, Paawe Karad Manaye"
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 03 May 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh.
Dear Question Bhai jio,
The "problem" with your Pankatee is that Bhagat kabir is NOT PROMOTING "Karrad Moniyaeh"....
You see in the Correct CONTEXT of this panktee those who ..KEEP LAMBE KESH were Doing it as a RELIGIOUS REQUIREMENT ( some sadhus still do)..and THOSE who had SHINING DOMES ( kharrad mundiyaeh" were also FOLLOWING A RELIGIOUS REQUIREMENT...( Jains, Buddhist monks etc are REQUIRED BY RELIGION to be DOMED !!)
Bhagat kabir Ji is actually saying that BOTH types of groups following mere religious requirement BUT without any inside Kamaii are USELESS.
This panktee is NOT to ENCOURAGE the MONAY that they ARE SIKHS even if they cut their hair..because the MONAY are NOT CUTTING their HAIR under RELIGIOUS REQUIREMENTS ( whatever religion that is ) they cut their hair to look "cool".
I accept your argument that... just "keeping long hair" doesnt make any one a SIKH..BUT CUTTING HAIR CERTAINLY DOESNT MAKE ANYONE A SIKH also...a jain maybe, a Buddhis monk maybe..BUT NOT A SIKH..becasue no where is it religiously requirted of a sikh to cut his hair !!!
BTW i dont blame you..this panktee is used ( OUT OF CONTEXT) even by so called Moneh Academiciands and Profgessors to "support" their cut hair 'SIKHEE"...it just doesnt cut any ice...
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Question Bhai · 04 May 2005
My humble opinion is that until you don't have compassion towards all Mankind [ e.g. having the "eyes" of Bhai Kanehya ] then you will most definitely always "look down" on your fellow Mankind.
The majority of Mankind are ( "so-called" ) monas. If you say that they cannot become Sikhs then you are unknowingly saying that Sikhism is not Universal and Sikhism is not for all Mankind. This would make Sikhism like Islam -- only for the chosen few !?!
I believe Sikhism is for all Mankind. It is our narrow mindedness that makes it seem that we are somehow superior. What, with the mere growth of a little facial hair !?!
I personally find it hilarious that such "mona" Sikhs get ( "pessimistically" ) called "Patit Sikh". My Guru Granth Sahib Ji ( "optimistically" ) says, "Patit Udarhan, Sab Sukh Pawan". I'd be a Patit any day!
Don't get me wrong. I fight the same battle if/when "monas" try to put down anyone who has a full beard.
And, yes agreed, this is the message from Kabir Jio's Shabad -- Hair or no hair this is not the point. It is your spiritual progress that matters.
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Gurcharan Singh Kulim, · 04 May 2005
Redwhiteandblue Kaur ji what is the PURPOSE of your question....and tell us what in your opinion should be the definition.I know what it is, given a few metres this way and a few that way off the real leadership.
But just tells us what you think it should be defined as ?
I know for a fact it cannot be one WHO IS TOTALLY MONA, and does NOT understand a word of Punjabi or read Punjabi or Sikh scriptures.but of coutrse no one stops him doing the SEWA if he so wishes...but certainly does not quialify for the post of a LEADER of the SIKHS.
If that helps you to make your definition you are most welcome.Please also consider the SRM and the qualities leadership..... ...and one who is a Gurmukh ...and nimartta naal sewadaar...Gurfateh !
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 04 May 2005
The purpose for asking is because I am a total moorakh and I prefer to ask for clarification before I open my mouth and turn in to a bigger moorakh.
"Garanthee" is a a word that has a specific meaning. "Leader" has many meanings, and I will humbly admit that, even though English is my mother tongue, I was stumbling over the context of which the word was used.
Do I want to see more monas? Or a mona garanthee?
No...but...
We are part of the best religion in the world and the most inspiring thing we can come up with is...fingerpointing?
That does not strike me as responsible leadership, either.
Anybody can whine and point fingers. I can do it, too. It's easy. But inside, I want to see results. Ideas. Brainstorms. Plans. Actions.
I'd like to learn more about how Bhai Kulbir Singh ji and the Tapoban sevadars have inspired so many younger people to not just keep their roop, but to take amrit and wear bana. I'd like to know how they have made a difference in Ontario.
I'd like to know more about the sevadars that actually mustered every ounce of courage from within and approached someone that they didn't like, and made enough difference in that person's life to help them walk the gurmat path.
I'd like to understand more about what outreach we can do to help keep people in the panth, instead of relying soley on the westward immigration of desis to keep our gurdwaras populated and strong.
I'd like to see more about how real Sikhs that decided that fingerpointing is a waste of time, and instead put their mind to solving real problems at real gurdwaras. I want to hear more about the COURAGE that it takes to do something that may be no fun...and how they found the strength to do it anyway, how they overcame their obstacles, and how it was all worth it in the end.
These Sikhs that, when given a choice between "right" and "easy" or "right" and "popular" will choose the RIGHT thing to do, the gurmat thing to do, even if it is NOT easy or popular.
These Sikhs that DO. That LIVE. That SOLVE. That FIX. That REACH. That GROW. That RISKED and TRIED and SUCCEEDED. That believe in something deep enough and fiercely enough to STICK THEIR NECK OUT for it come what may.
These Sikhs that are not content with good over bad, but instead strive for EXCELLENCE over mediocrity.
These people, in my mind, are Sikh leaders.
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Gurcharan Singh Kulim, · 04 May 2005
Bibi, Ji This is NOT finger pointing ,this highlighting an abuse that is going towards sikhi, i you fiond all that things you have mentioned as qualities of leadeership, I see no problem with what you see .I am NOT pointing fingers at you, but here we have abuse going on and things being carried exactly opposite to what you have mentioned, I have my name clearly underneath that , and I am NOT hiding under any pen names either.as I stand by what I write.
Thank you for your interest but tapoban sikhs or organisation is NOT the issue in question here.
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 05 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Who can argue with Bhen Ji Kaur above....EXAMPLE...EXAMPLE...Leadership by EXAMPLE....JEEWAN...are the Prime words...people look at your jeewan..they attempt to follow
That is why I am surprised that our Naujawans are not attempting to follow the supreme jeewans of our Guru Sahibaans, great Sikhs and Gurmukhs...thats becasue in thsi modern world their "role models" are not SIKHS...but others...due to fashions, modernism, films, tv etc etc..
The "SIKHS' they see on the other hand are HOLLOW Mannequins...you enter a store and you look at a mannequin..then you go look elsewhere... same with our Raagis, parcharaks, Kathawachaks, Granthis, gyanis etc...Peoiple look at them once..soon REALISE they are just mannequins dressed like Sikhs but with NO JEEWAN..and then they look elsewhere..
WE SIKHS must attempt to LIVE the LIFe of GURBANi and show the Youth..they will follow naturally..This is the "secret" of tapoban
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
sarjitsingh khalsa · 05 May 2005
these things are happening because we do not have our country when we get our country we will have our sikh fbi to sought these problems so suppoert www.khalistan.com
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 06 May 2005
Gucharan Singh ji,
I agree with you that we have problems within the panth.
But are monay the PROBLEM? Or merely SYMPTOM of a deeper problem?
There are a staggering number of female babies that are being lost to abortion or murder in Panjab. This makes a global laughing stock of our values, but also threatens the survival of the people. There are other issues, too.
But what to do? Nod our heads in agreement that yes, there are problems, or do we harness the power that we have to communicate and share with each other to look for solutions? Results? Outcome?
Re: Mona "SIKH"Sewadars->MONA GRANTHIS???
Gurcharan Singh Kulim, · 06 May 2005
Sangat ji, we have all AGREED on the principles that should have not takeing place and it is not an example we can talk of proudly.
Bhai Autar Singh has quite readily summed up, even issues that were non issues anyway, but I think it would be a hasty action on part of the moderators to decide to end this thread, as we are stillawaiting to hear from the SNSM.
Otherwise I do not beleive it will do good for SNSMs image..to HOPE this will die away.....because while we have concentrated on one particular isse , there are some organisations who have similarly to account for. like the fac of Sikh leadership that was first forced upon the Sikh sangats during the 400th guru Granth parkash deharra.
I cannot see this dying away until we see some response.The response should be be simply on the issue in question and not anything else,as I do not believanything else was in question at all.We know the success etc,the education to other communities about punjabiness, more than Sikhness....
Seeing THAT exampleby the sant Atter Singh vidyala, the SNSM inadvertently, we believe allowed such similar non Sikh faced to speak for them on the vesakhi mela stage as well.
I am sure we are all awaiting to hear ....eagerly from the SNSM.
Guru Panth da daas
Gurcharan SINGH kulim