Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Baba's doing their thing again!

Baba's doing their thing again!

those baba's · 03 May 2005

To all the sanghat, Who will be the 'checking gauge' for these baba's/sants. Who will tell the sanghat which ones are good, and which are BAD? How will this be done. LETS PUT A END TO THIS SANT ISSUE. WE ARE ALL HIS CHILDREN. NEVER MIND DIFFERENTIATING BETWEEN CASTE, THESE PEOPLE WANT TO CREATE LEVELS BETWEEN MANKIND! HOW MANY OF THEM WANT TO RASH THE TITLE 'SANT'? NONE OF THEM. I REST MY CASE. Plot to kill Khalsa Panchayat chief unearthed Tribune News Service Jagraon, May 1 The Jagraon police today claimed to have unearthed a plot to kill a senior leader of the Khalsa Panchayat with the arrest of a gang of robbers, contract killers and extortionists who have been found involved in 35 different crimes and were led by a self-styled saint. The Khalsa Panchayat is waging a war against dera culture in the state. The gang was also allegedly about to kidnap the son of a rich industrialist in Ludhiana The gang is allegedly led by a self-styled saint, Baba Amarjit Singh, who had allegedly joined hands with his guru-turned-foe-turned-friend to kill Khalsa Panchayat chief Charanjit Singh Channi. Jagraon SSP Rajiv Ahir told mediapersons that the gang functioned like a corporate office with the leader calling himself the chief executive officer. The gang has been accused of committing 35 different crimes in Ludhiana and Jagraon. Eleven members of the gangs have been arrested, he said. Mr Ahir said Amarjit Singh, alias Kala, alias Baba, a resident of Deharka village, is the leader of this gang. He is allegedly a hardcore criminal and has more than six criminal cases pending against him. He has been criminally active for the past more than five years.

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

S Singh · 03 May 2005

Thi shas been discussed many times but might as well repeat it. In Sikh history we have had some great mahan GurSikhs like Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai Taru Singh Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji. These great servants of the panth did immense seva. They were never given the title Sant. Today in Punjab there are an estimated 18,000 baba, sant etc. There are only about 14,000 villages in Punjab. So we have 1.29 baba per village. Sounds a bit strange to me that mahan GurSikj like Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji were never accorded the Sant prefix but today we literally have thousands in Punjab. Also there are a few thousand Sikhs in Pakistan so we would expect a handful of Sant there. But none there. In the UK there are more than 600,000 Sikhs yet no UK born Sant/Baba. Similar situatio in Canada. This begs the question why are there so many Sant in Punjab ? Some say it has just become a business and I tend to agree that most these people are in it for the money and the Sant tag is a great tag to help with this.

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Dogma · 03 May 2005

this is indeed EXTREMELY sad.. the way these fake sants have taken over Punjab is really shocking. When I was there just last year I noticed a fake sant dera every 2 miles or something. I hate to see people using the label of sant for their own greed. It not only put a black eye on Sikhi but a black eye on all of the real true Sants of the past that have done so much seva for this Panth. A true Sant will only lead people to Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Such was the case with Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee and even Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee. I think all Sikhs should be weary of Sants who promote themselves more than they promote Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee... Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Lord Singh · 03 May 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! I totally agree with all of you that Punjab is getting full or even crowded in some areas of fake Sants, but we must also be able to differentiate the true Sants of the Panth from the fake ones. If one is able to give Amrit Paan to hundreds or thousands and teach only the Guru's Sikhi, by also emphasizing the point that Sikhs should only bow down to Guru Granth Sahib Ji and consider it as the only living true Guru - then that person deserves to have the prefix "Sant" attached to their name. If on the other hand, a person does not teach the Guru's Sikhi, does not help people make the choice to have the 10th Guru's Amrit, does not emphasize the point that Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the only living true Guru of the Sikhs, but instead considers himself higher than the Shabad Guru and expects people to bow down to him - then that person is a complete fake "Sant" and has NO right to have the prefix "Sant" attached to their name. People such as these should not exist, but after all, it is Kaljug and all in the Hukam of Waheguru - that is the point of it all. In Kaljug, it is up to the Guru's Sikh to think wisely with the Power of Naam, and be able to distinguish the true Sant that deserves the prefix, from the fake, who has no right to have the Sant prefix. You must think - "Is this person Panthic? - What is this person doing for the Sikh Panth that will deserve him the prefix Sant attached to his name?" Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kaum Jugaee"

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Dogma · 03 May 2005

I agree with you 100% Lord Singh jee.. It's too easy to simply brandish ALL people with the prefix of Sant in front of their name as fake. However, the sad fact is that in recent times the commercialization of the word "SANT" for profit has been extremely troublesome for the Panth.

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

khalistani · 03 May 2005

weather u call em sant or not dont change the fact they are or not if u call radhaswami sant je, that aint makin hium a sant if u calls ant jarnail singh je bhai sahib or baba, fine, dont take nothin away from one, dont make em lower than sant avastha u can swear at the sun, it aint gonna stop shinin u can praise it, it aint gonna hsine more we shud expose fake sant there thugs, the bad meeaning but dont blame real jewels for the counteless fakrs remeber there only a few diamonds but so many fakes all around bhula chuka maf

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Niranjan Singh · 03 May 2005

>>> then that person deserves to have the prefix "Sant" attached to their name There is no precedence, pretext or justifiction in Gurmat for prefixing titles such as "Sant" or "BrahmGiani." Other than pumping out more Haumi to the benfeactor what else does this title provide ? Even the Catholics are smarter than us, they only give sainthood to those who have passed away. [%sig%]

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 03 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Niranjan Singh ji writes: There is no precedence, pretext or justifiction in Gurmat for prefixing titles such as "Sant" or "BrahmGiani." Other than pumping out more Haumi to the benfeactor what else does this title provide ? Even the Catholics are smarter than us, they only give sainthood to those who have passed away.<<<<<<<<<<, Since there is NO PRECEDENCE/PRETEXT/JUSTIFICATION as per GURBANI/GURMATT for any human being to use the word SANT/BRAHMGIANI/GURU in front of his Worldy name.....WHY do they do it ?? Dont tell me the "few "GENUINE ONES" like Dogma states above, CANNOT drop this title ?? Or dont they want to drop it ?? Dogma in an earlier message elsewhere quoted KABIR JI as a SANT......OF Course Bhagat Kabir Ji is a SANT....HIS GURBANI is DHUR KI BANI recorded in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...SO are ALL the GURU SAHIBAANS, and ALL the Mahapurakhs, SANTS, BHAGATS whose GURBANI is in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB. When I asked for "SANTS" from the 1469-1930 PERIOD..I meant those OUTSIDE GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB. Can veer Dogma ji, quote any GURBANI, these few "genuine sants" he knows of have written to EQUAL BHAGAT KABIR's position as SANT. Even the so called GURUS ( Radhasoamis/Namdharees? etc have failed miserably in their efforts to WRITE so called "gurbani".. I know they TRIED their very best..and came up with NONsense poems. The BEST SOLUTION is for all these "genuine snats" to COME BEFORE GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB and DENOUNCE FOREVER their false titles..and ADMIT that the ONE and ONLY SANT is ONLY GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...and from now on NO ONE human being should have this title.

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

S Singh · 04 May 2005

Lord Singh Ji. >>People such as these should not exist, but after all, it is Kaljug and all in the Hukam of Waheguru - that is the point of it all. In Kaljug, it is up to the Guru's Sikh to think wisely with the Power of Naam, and be able to distinguish the true Sant that deserves the prefix, from the fake, who has no right to have the Sant prefix. So what makes todays "baba" more deserving of the Sant prefix than Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji , Bhai Mani Singh Ji and Bhai Taru Singh Ji ? Are the "baba" who roam Punjab more learned and panthic than these great mahan GurSikhs hence why they deserve the "Sant" prefix ? I tend to agree with Niranjan Singh Ji.

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Amar Singh · 04 May 2005

It is funny how Sikhs today are so hung up on 'titles' and 'external appearences'...ultimately how some "Sants" behave and how some "Baba" or some "Bhai Sahib" or "Gyani Ji" behaves is rarely that different, other than the choice of word. Let's tackle the underlying issues, rather than get hung up on words!

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

those damn baba's · 04 May 2005

As it has been echoed in allot of your views, the so-called true sants, would not have any issues with REMOVING the title. That way no one is called a sant, but mind you, then these rotten apples will take the title of 'BHAI sahib' to the same LOW level, that sant now resides in! Lord Singh mentioned that if (I paraphrase) they give amrit, do parchar, and look like they are real sants, then a title of sant maybe given, but lets not forget mann of pehowa. He to rocked the world stages (though some would say it was because he was overweight) but seriously, after allegations made last year, the giant of a sant, has become a mouse of a man, not even able to respond to the allegations, not even wanting to step outside of India...remeber how he would fight off all other allegations like pouring water into a well, in dubai, and announcing it was now Amrit, when he was accused of having a D.I.G as his advisor/friend. Remeber how these accusations were blasted at, in the sanght! Yet all would have pinned the title of sant on his lapel, right? When our establishment is rotten, when those that make the decisions for our future are without character, then we are in serious trouble! just a thought!

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Friendly Singh · 04 May 2005

All todays titled "sants" are good for is promoting the latest model of Mercedes!!!

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Dogma · 04 May 2005

To Jarnail Singh Jee.. "When I asked for "SANTS" from the 1469-1930 PERIOD..I meant those OUTSIDE GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB" ..my apologies, you didn't specify this in your original question. However, the fact that BSB Randheer Singh also called Jwaala Singh Sant should also be taken into note. "Dont tell me the "few "GENUINE ONES" like Dogma states above, CANNOT drop this title ?? Or dont they want to drop it ??" ..Veerji, I agree with you. A Sant does not automatically CALL himself Sant. If you read Se Kineya you'll notice that the author clearly states that no one called Baba Harnaam Singh Jee "sant" to his face and nor did he announce himself as such. I am very cautious about people who openly call themselves Sant ____ _____ Jee. I agree with you about that. Sant Jarnail Singh Jee didn't call himself as a Sant, but that doesn't negate the fact that, in my humble opinion, he IS one. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh never called himself Sant however this doesn't negate the fact that, in my humble opinion, he IS one. For me this applies to Sant Attar Singh Jee, Sant Jwaalla Singh, Sant Baba Harnaam Singh, and a few others who have shown beyond any doubt their loyalty to Guru Granth Sahib Jee and the Khalsa Panth. Veerji, do you honestly think that these men OPENLY called themselves SANT? Hell no! I don't disagree with you about the word SANT. Calling oneself SANT doesn't make you one...however in the same token, being called a SANT by other Gursikhs doesn't mean that you're fake! (why can't you understand my reasoning?) I am NOT willing to simply say that EVERYONE in the HISTORY of Sikhi that has been called a SANT is an outright fake, which is what I believe you want other people to believe. Also, PLEASE NOTE, just because a person is NOT called a Sant doesn't mean that they aren't! (case in point: BSB Randheer Singh Jee) In actuality, your views and my views aren't that far off...(i think) I think the only thing is that you believe that there is no such thing as a Sant, whereas I believe that there is. NOT the TITLE. But the PERSON. Someone who personifies Gurbani itself is in my mind a Sant.

Re: Baba's doing their thing again!

Dogma · 04 May 2005

by the way, i think Jarnail Singh should read khalistani's post...i think it sums up everything quite nicely.