Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Another attack by Kanjarwood

Another attack by Kanjarwood

Kulbir Singh · 08 May 2005

Khalsa jee, here is another attack from Kanjarwood (so called bollywood). What course of action do you think Sikhs from outside can take against this filthy and appalling act of Kanjarwood to insult and belittle Sikhi and try to defile the sacred Sikh slogan "Jo Bole So Nihal"? I propose, Sunny Deol be welcomed with a garland of old smelling shoes when ever he comes to your country. There should be protests around the world. Kulbir Singh Sikh groups write to Censor Board Oppose release of ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’ Tribune News Service Amritsar, May 8 In a communication to Sharmila Tagore, Chairperson, Central Board of Film Certification, Sikh organisations have threatened to launch a series of protests if the board failed to impose blanket ban on the controversial film, “Jo Bole So Nihal”, proposed to be released on May 13 . Taking up cudgels against the producer and functionaries of the Censor Board, Prof Jagmohan Singh, general secretary and spokesperson for the Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar), Mr Kanwar Pal Singh, general secretary of the Dal Khalsa, and Mr Rajinder Singh, Chairman of the Khalsa Panchayat, have said they would be demonstrating at district headquarters on May 11. They propose to burn effigies of the Censor Board for failing to withhold the movie when it came up for certification. They claimed that the Sikh bodies in Mumbai, Delhi, Bhopal and Chennai had also planned action programmes against the movie. They said Sikhs in Mumbai, under the leadership of Mr Kulwant Singh, executive committee member of Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Mumbai, are scheduled to meet Ms Sharmila Tagore tomorrow. The film that is slated for an all-India release on May 13 has agitated the Sikhs worldwide as they were of the view that the producer has misused the holy slogan (Bole So Nihal) of the Sikh community. Getting upset with the movie, the representatives of various Sikh bodies especially the SGPC, have already taken up the issue with the producer, Rahul Rawail. The use of holy slogans along with vulgar scenes could not be acceptable, warned Sikh leaders. Prof Jagmohan Singh has written a warning letter to the Censor Board and has sent copies of his letter to the Information and Broadcasting Ministry, giving details of how the movie offends Sikh sentiments. In his letter to Sharmila Tagore, Prof Jagmohan Singh has pointed out that the film is a violation of Section 5B of the Cinematograph Act, 1952. The Sikh bodies also sought the intervention of Dr Manmohan Singh, Prime Minister, in the matter. The Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar) has also sought that the Censor Board must have members from all minority communities so that such incidents do not recur.

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Kulbir Singh · 08 May 2005

Khalsa jeeo, I know many of you will not appreciate this but I really feel like calling this person Sunny Deol a Bastard. Why? Because he portrays himself as a Sikh everywhere and has received full support from so called Sikhs who watch movies but this person has returned the goodwill from Sikhs by making a mockery of their religious slogan. Shame on Sunny Deol. Kulbir Singh

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

jss · 09 May 2005

kulbir singh ji, by god, i think we might be in agreement on this one...

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

???? · 09 May 2005

I pray to Waheguru jee that he can bless us with singhs like we had in KCF, KLF, BTF, BKI. These singh would have done the right seva we are cartoon singhs we can write letter go to meetings and protest.

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 09 May 2005

I agree with Kulbir Singh- Sunny Deol is making a mockery of the Sikh religion, but the majority of so called "Sikhs" have become so distanced from the faith that they fail to realise this, The think just because the title is based on the Jaikara, it is brilliant because it's about "Sikhs"....this type of representation we can do without. On another note, what is everybody's view on Gurdas Maan's effort- Des Hoya Pardes?...didn't like the sound of the review when it said the story was based in 80's Panjab "when the state was experiencing turmoil at the hands of terrorists and fundamentalists"...I haven't seen the film, but is every Panjabi singer now jumping on the Hawayein bandwagon?...one good thing about that film was they did have the guts to show SOME good kharkoo Singhs.

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Nav · 09 May 2005

Dear Kulbir Singh, Sikhs have been apathetic to Bollywood's drivel for tooooooooooo long. The problem started with the very first Sardarji joke and should have been nipped in the bud a long time ago...and now these cheap Bollywood directors and have the audacity to make the Sikh jaikara "jo bole so nihal" into a "dhol mix" dance with lewd dancing. This kind of trash does affect the self-image of the next generation of Sikhs and needs to be countered. There are somethings that can be done so why don't the Sikhs get organized and do them? 1.) A boycott of Bollywood films, audio tapes/CDs/DVDs etc. and especially of films that portray Sikhs in a bad light. Make this boycott public and I am sure that if enough Sikhs in the UK, Canada, and US participate, we can hit Bollywood where it hurts the most: in the pocketbook. 2.) Call up/write to theatres that show these anti-Sikh movies and let the management know that you are not happy about these sort of movies being shown in your neighborhood. You'd be surprised at how sensitive management is about customer concerns. 3.) In some Western countries it may be possible to take legal action on the basis of defamation/hate speech. Why not sue them if possible? 4.) Get enough signatures and let the directors/actors in these movies know that Sikhs will boycott them forever it this kind of negative portrayal goes on. 5.) Let Sikh organizations that oppose these movies recieve our moral/financial support. But before any of this can be done, lets develop some sort of a game plan and get organized. regards, Nav

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 09 May 2005

vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!! #3 of the adjective list below: "resembling a known kind or species but not truly such" is a good definition of this situation, which is the situation of many HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of people around the world including myself, who call themselves Sikhs but are an outright disgrace to the Sikh faith and history. 6 entries found for bastard. bas·tard n. 1. A child born out of wedlock. 2. Something that is of irregular, inferior, or dubious origin. 3. Slang. A person, especially one who is held to be mean or disagreeable. adj. 1. Born of unwed parents; illegitimate. 2. Not genuine; spurious: a bastard style of architecture. 3. Resembling a known kind or species but not truly such. vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

just me · 09 May 2005

I personally think, no matter how outraged we are by these people, we should be civil in the language we use....

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 09 May 2005

wholeheartedly agreed..actually this family of deols is not sikhs at all but hindu arya samajists...the likes of veerinder who was killed in the 1980s for just this sort of thing... Now that the Lions are gone the choohey are out to play...not knowing young lions are growing up..time will come MK

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Patwant · 09 May 2005

i usually liked watching Sunny Doels movies, but this is way too much. He says he is sikh, and then he goes and does a movie that's an insult to it. i really don't know what these people are thinking. Any real skh would have tried to stoop them form using that name.

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Jinder · 09 May 2005

Actually Dharamendra is Sikh, I dunno where you got the idea, he is arya-samaji. He lives near my pind in Ludhiana.

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

kulmohan · 10 May 2005

I am surprised by the use of abusive words in this supposedly religious egroup. I feel we shall refrain from calling bad names on anyone. Manda kisey na aakhiyey par akhar eihey bujhiyey Talking of this movie in particular, I think we are jumping the guns here. Whilst we overlook/accept that the message contained in this movie and its songs is saluting the bravery of punjabis on one hand, we seem to take exception to the scence where the heroin standing alongside the sikh hero is dressed in a short top and mini skirt (a compulsory bollywood movie scene in almost all movies). Let me ask each of you if you don't watch other movies wherein the heroines may be dressed similarly ? Do you ever raise concerns/protests on other such movies? Why single out this movie for the only reason that it has got a sikh hero. Do we not have double standards in how we want to see the sikh hero and how we want to see the other heros? My dear friends we have a long path to cover before we realise 'Manas ki jaat sabhey eikey pehchaanboo' In one of the posts above this, there has been another point raised around the jokes that ridicule Sikhs. At times, I too have experienced a very strong feeling of protest against the jokes etc of that kind which intentionally ridicule a community, but then I try to tell myselves that I may not be able to change these unpleasent things. After all, all that happens in this world happens under the sweet will of GOD

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Question Bhai · 10 May 2005

Na Ko Mera Dushman Raheyo Na Hum Na Kisi Ke Bairaree Who cares two hoots for the Holly-Bolly-Lolly-Molly Woods ?

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Dogma · 10 May 2005

Kulmohan, You have given a well thought out arguement but nonetheless I disagree with almost everything you said veerji. First of all, Bollywood, in all it's stupidity, will never be able to make a Sikh hero. Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Jee was a Sikh hero...Sunny Deol is not. "Do we not have double standards in how we want to see the sikh hero and how we want to see the other heros?" ..HELL YES! I am SIKH, I'm not a Hindu or a Muslim. Of COURSE I will want to see Sikhs portrayed in a positive light that reflects the morals that our Guru Sahibaan gave us. If Bollywood made a movie called "Om Jai Jadish Haray" and portrayed a plot that went directly against the principles of Hinduism then I'm sure many Hindu people would have something to say about it. Please go to the following link: http://www.bollyvista.com/article/a/31/4691/1/ ...don't you just love it when Bollwood writers give thoughtful insight on Sikh history...aaahhh...lovely. In all honesty veerji, I don't watch Bollywood movies. I think they're a waste of time. But it seems that these days Bollywood's latest marketing tactic is to PURPOSELY make controversy. They did it with Veer Zaara...and now again with Jo Bole So Nihaal. Veer Zaara did VERY well, and I have a hunch that many people will go to see Jo Bole So Nihaal just based on the controversy that it has stirred. ...either way, it seems that Bollywood is doing a hell of a job humiliating the image of Sikhi in order to gain a few rupees.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

singh ji · 10 May 2005

IMHO. We Sikhs live in a fairytale world. We read sakhi's, here stories about a FEW good Sikhs around the time of 1984, and assume that that's whom we are. Look around everyone. Look at our establishments, those controlling our faith, are they any less than these actors from bollywood? The difference is this; bollywood does not hide behind religious garbs unlike our present day religious/spiritual leaders.right? This sikhi that some of you profess to, to me seems to be a dream, and wish, which will never, and I mean never, come true. no raag of the khalsa (this was not said by our guru's, but written by a writer - panthic parkash)The reality is that Sikhs of today's calibre (whether high or low), I firmly believe are of the same calibre, as those Sikhs around the time of our guru's! These comments may offend, but the truth is in front of your eyes. All the NATAK occurring at Akal takht sahib, and guru ji stays silent? Why? for how long? Focus on ones self, do not let petty things like this sway you off your path, for then be ready for a hurricane of disbelieve, that will surely knock you right off. If we begin to dig into the lifestyle of our sikh heads, then one will be utterly disappointed, with the results.. so why bother to dicuss sunny deol? sorry for rambling. IMHO.

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

Kulbir Singh · 10 May 2005

Sikhs livid over Sunny Deol's next May 10, 2005 19:32 IST The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee and various other Sikh organisations have urged the Central Board of Film Certification ban Sunny Deol's new film, Jo Bole So Nihaal. The film, titled on a Sikh religious slogan, is full of vulgarity, the organisations say. 'The title of the film gives an impression that it will be based on Sikh religion but the trailers of the picture show vulgarity,' an SGPC press release said. Sikhs would never tolerate this kind of 'nonsense,' it added. General Secretary and Spokesperson of Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar) Jagmohan Singh, General Secretary of Dal Khalsa Kanwar Pal Singh and Chairman of Khalsa Panchayat Rajinder Singh have said they would demonstrate on May 11 against the Censor Board for its failure to withhold the movie. 'The use of holy Sikh slogans along with vulgar scenes is not acceptable. It is an insult to Sikhs. It is the duty of the government of India to stop the screening of the film lest it forcesto Sikhs to act on their own,' the leaders said. They also said community members in Mumbai, under the leadership of Kulwant Singh, executive committee member of Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Bombay, will meet Censor Board Chairperson Sharmila Tagore to urge a ban on the movie. Jo Bole So Nihaal is scheduled for release on May 13

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

duniya di samaj · 10 May 2005

sunny deols grandad kewal kishan the father of dharmendra became arya samaj in young age. the tradition carried onto the rest of the family. dharmendra did an interview last year regarding his political ambitions he firmly stated he was a hindu.

Re: Another attack by Kanjarwood

stranger · 11 May 2005

All this rasied tempo is just giving the film the publicity it needs to make the producers crores of Rupees........ Do u all remember 'Satanic Verses' by Salman Rushdi? His book was utter pile of crap but hey it sold milliions because the fanatical muslims kicked up such a stink yet 99% of them had not even read the so-called insulting pages!!!!! Burning effigies just shows how illiterate we are ... look at Jerry Springer's show in London - people demonstrated against it but they did not go around burning things........ Sorry people all this is not going to make an ounce of difference but will make the actors/producers alot richer ........................!