Forum
Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Sadh Sangat of East London · 10 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!
"Guru Arjan Dev Ji Shaheedi Cultural & Sports Tournament" - 12th June 2005
Over 50 Naujawan & Experienced Sikhs representing Sadh Sangat met with the Committee of Sri Guru Singh Sabha London East and the Organisers of Tournament.
After conducting Benti Chaupai Sahib Ji de Paath and Ardas, in the presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, the Sadh Sangat when to the open meeting organised by the Committee.
The aim of the Sangat was simple in that the name of the Tournament must be changed as it is abuse to the memory & principles of Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji & Sikh Shaheeds.
Reasons behind why the Sangat want Guru Ji name and the term Shaheedi to be removed as the title of the tournament is that currently the tournament allows excessive drinking on the site, there are problems of law & order such as rowdy and violent behaviour, Bhangra & Giddha, Langar made from offerings by the local sangat is distributed alongside alcohol and meat, Gurdwara monies are used to fund this tournament, local residents are against the tournament for the above issues and the litter and disruption cause.
The Questions that arise from the current state of this Tournament are:
1) Is this how Sikhs celebrate the sacrifice of Guru Arjan Dev Ji?
2) Did Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji commemorate his father’s shaheedi in this way?
3) Are the activities conducted in this tournament what our Sikh Shaheeds gave their lives for?
All the above points were addressed to the Committee & Organisers within this open meeting.
There was a unanimous agreement by the Gurdwara Committee and Organisers that the tournament is an abuse of the memory of Guru Ji & Shaheeds. The organisers reiterated that they have been requesting the Gurdwara Committee to change the name for over two years.
The Sadh Sangat offered solutions to the committee and were willing to re-design and print posters, booklets and stationary. The sangat also offered to make new banners and signs for the day and help with any technical and legal issues.
The Organisers said there was no problem with the name being changed for this year’s tournament and highlighted the point that the Gurdwara Committee have to make the decision.
However the Gurdwara committee flatly refused to change the name for the tournament happening on the 12th of June 2005.
The excuses given by The Committee were:
1) There are legal issues:
• This is incorrect because changing the Public Name of the tournament has no legal implication.
2) It has been going on for 25 years:
• The current state of the tournament requires Guru Ji’s name to be disassociated with it.
• Members of the local Sangat have been trying to change the name for some years
3) The committee should not be made to feel that they have been wrong in what they do for the community:
• As in the form of Sangat we have the right to question any committee about their activities, where the offering and monies from the Sangat are used, and above all stand up against abuse of Guru Ji and our Shaheeds.
4) The committee members said, without any shame, that they partake in the consumption of alcohol during the tournaments
5) What about those outside organisations funding the tournament?
The Sangat was not satisfied with the poor excuses given by the committee. It reflects that fact that this committee have not love for Guru Ji. Issues such as funding from outside sources are the priority. Also it boils down to the point that who are the Sangat to tell the committee what to do?
The Committee disregarded the concerns of the Sangat, feeling that their decisions are correct and final. The committee are exploiting their positions using Guru Ji as a commodity who they can sell for monitory gains and political power. They have forgotten that the Sadh Sangat is Guru Ji’s form and are above any committee.
There is no reasons why a different name cannot be used for the Tournament, this year and following years, apart from financial gain and egoistical behaviour.
The Sangat demanded a decision and a timescale for when this decision will be made. The committee have asked for two weeks to call a meeting. This shows that Guru Ji beabdi is not an issue for this committee otherwise a decision would have been made immediately or within a shorter timescale.
Sangat Ji, this situation has highlighted blatant misuse of powers by a committee and has to be addressed.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Amar Singh · 10 May 2005
Perhaps Pradeep Singh "Bilga" should read this in response to his comments concerning "Singh Sabha" being the "proper" Gurdwara and upholder of Sikhi today.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Bhudysut · 10 May 2005
Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh
A quick question Ji. I do not live in East London (South London), but is there anything we can actually do on the day?
Can we get some local press involved and state that the 'Law abiding members of the Sikh community' are not involved with the function and actually discourage it.
I'd be more that happy to mobilise some South Londoners to get involved.
Dass
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Maanas Ki Jaat Eik Hain · 10 May 2005
Looks like the UK Khalsa Network is slowly beginning to grow.
I was present at the meeting on Sunday and it was very uplifting to see over 50 najawaans stand up against a modern day manmat committee.
With GuruJis Kirpa we can now all start tackling the huge amount of beadbi taking place all over the country from nagar kirtans to halls within Gurdwaras
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
PurathanSherSingh's Fauj · 10 May 2005
There was also commitee members that admited themselves that they actually consumed alcohol on the stage at the event that is under the name of Sri Guru Arjun Dev Ji Shaheedi tournament.
There was also a comitee member who looked like a bhamin and he was screaming his head of at the youth. The youth controlled themselves by not reacting in violence. If the youth wanted to they could have busted up the whole of the comitee, but they didnt because they have respect for Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, unlike the so called "Sikh comitee members"
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
... · 10 May 2005
You should al get together and overthrow the commitee
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 10 May 2005
First and foremost, I am very sorry I was not able to attend the meeting on that day,as I had a prior engagement with the Sikh Womens Conference,that arranged on that same day at East London University.
There are two issues, I could suggest.
1)Continue dialogue with the committee, tying them down at each meeting, narrowing the options and excuses they offer.Increasing the number of sangt attending the meeting.
2)Contact the Local press:-the Ilford Recorder, approach them for coverage, and how these tournament breaks every principle of the Sikh faith,yet the GURDUARA COMMITTEE is pushing for it.although the Sikh sangat of Redbridge is deadly against it, this will also increase the chance of other community groups supportiung us, rather than the Gurduara Committee , who also may be embarrassed.Council groups will take notice, hence funding could be withdrawn.
Approach Club Asia radio-I can seek through channels to get air time , as their best presenter ..MIZY D was at the Sikh womens conferance and would lend a hand to support such bad habits, like drunk husbands comming home after the tournament and beating wives,daughters and generally abusive is not an issue that would go well for this committee.
I am sure this happens.
3)Get OTHER SIKH GROUPS locally, like SIKHS IN ENGLAND,The SIKH study Forum, The SIKH womens ALLIANCE can be a major Support in this dharam Yudh,The Gurduara Karamsar Sangat, in addition ANT OTHER FAITH and COMMUNITY GROUP locally that has opposed this tournament to voice their opinion.
Remember the women are amajor factor , in the abuse by alcoholconsumming husbands.
4)Seek to set up a stall in the Ilford Square from the council and police, and leaflet the public.A few Naujawan Volunteers ,about ten would do on a Saturday morning.
5) Finally, stand against all these committee members at the next election,get rid of them.For the moment rein in those who are likely to oppose them at the elections...
Sikho, the opportunities are VAST to stop, the need is for determination, and some work.
The opportunity to go national with the press are there too.The committee wants a fight , give to them, they will not know how all these avenues can hurt them BADLY.NO violence at all.
I know some Singhs know me well , want guidance for panthic sewa?
Panth Ki Jeet
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
jss · 10 May 2005
i think it might help if you publicly anounce names of the committee members...name and shame them...that might coerce them into doing the right thing..
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
hmmmm · 10 May 2005
The turn out of the naujawans at the meeting was excallent, however i would like to say that their were not many singhs actually of east london that attended which is a shame, many singhs from other parts of london had turned up which is excallent, but where were all the east london singhs, I would say that around 7 were from east london. I know many Singhs that were not actally busy and could of attended if they wanted to, why werent they there, when we take amrith its like a promise we make to guru jee that when you need us, we will drop everything for you and be there, where were these singhs, that wear baana to rehensabaes?? promote their own jathebandis? organise keertan darbaars, work out at gyms etc etc, why werent they there, that had been the down side. but apart from that, if they wont be there then its up to them, but guru jees fauj will always continue
bhulchukmaf
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Holbras- Jatinderpalsingh · 10 May 2005
"hmmm" Why dont you leave a name with your message?
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
hmmm · 11 May 2005
that is my choice, juslt like im sure you dont always post with your name. Im sorry if I hit a nerve bhai sahib. But the truth hurts.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
..... · 11 May 2005
turn out was good.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
TavPrasad Singh · 11 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
The amasing bit of the whole situation the complete acceptance by the Gurdwara Committee that the name of the tournament is a abuse to our Guru & Shaheeds.
Secondly the Sports Committee who are the actual organisers were in full agreement with the Youth and have been asking the Gurdwara Committee for the last couple of years to change the name.
Thirdly the organisers so no issue why the name could not be changed immediately
Fourth, the naujawan are willing to design & print posters, banners, booklets on the new name so Gurdwara monies are not wasted
The Gurdwara Committee did not have a leg to stand on! The youth present saw in front of them a group of people who have no love for Guru Ji.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Jaspal Singh C · 11 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
Good point "hmmm".
I hope that we get to see some of the Singhs/Singhnis of East London become more physically active within the sangat. Too many people closed behind doors at the moment. We ain't hermits, please do come out once in a while!!
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Upkar Singh · 11 May 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa - waheguru ji ki fateh
1. It seems that Gursikhs (i presume) have the god given right to pass messages and judgements on others without having the guts to give their names.
2. If the organisers of this meeting would also like to explain how ,when and where they advertised this gathering.
3. i have knowledge of many singhs who are proactive in east london who had no communication or notification regarding this meeting.
4. i have spent 20 years campaigning against the abuses that go on in this tournament but never had any collective support from anywhere. So who are these individuals who suddenly have so much concern.
"The sleeping cat wakes up and tries to roar like a lion"
or is it a case of blind leading the blind
waheguru ji ka khalsa - waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Holbras- Jatinderpalsingh · 11 May 2005
"hmmm" Its not about hitting a nerve, you should stand strong in what you have to say, dont hide behind the bush. Let me assure you, i do always use my name.. i hardly post.
I agree with UpkarSingh...
Let me also suggest that those FRONT LINE active sewadars of East London do tell everyone including those they dont mix up with, or dont prefer to be around. We have such Chardeekalaa Singhs here who were not even approached and did not know a thing.
If you dont work together and expect everyone to just read from the internet then how do you expect those to come? Many elder Gursikhs that can represent and talk rather than those with big ego's and titles would love to be in the position to talk but we seem to have a new Jatha with new faces wanting "Choudar".
Anyway, you guys carry on doing your thing... Hopefully those who did not attend will be notified about the next meeting
[%sig%]
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Mankamal Singh · 11 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
We should not be going down the route of who attended and who didn't. This is a non-issue as far as the Naujwaan or anyone else involved in the meeting are concerned.
Some local GurSikhs were not made aware of the issue being taken up by the Naujwaan. Some local GurSikhs could not make the meeting, full stop. No one has the right to point fingers or pass judgement on them.
The author "hmm"'s view does not reflect the views of the Naujwaan who were present at the meeting to confront the committee.
The Najwaan's only issue is to disassociate Guru Arjun Dev Jis name and the term Shaheedi from the tournament.
If we start a slanging match between who was there and who wasn't then I am sorry to say we are no better than the committee.
We need to keep working together and resolve the panthic issues that keep arising.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Bundha · 11 May 2005
Sounds like sour grapes to me Upkar singh.
Don't be upset, if Singhs now have woken up and are trying to do something about it give them your full support.
[%sig%]
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
hmmm · 11 May 2005
bhai upkar singh thank you for calling us cats, one we hope to become rehit vaan lions like youserlf, we hope to follow to in your foot steps and carry on to continue with this campaign. Can you also fill the sangat with what has happened in those twenty years you have been campaigning against the comittee, i would pursume you knew gursikhs around you twenty years ago didnt they help you?
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Manvir Singh · 11 May 2005
whether we woke up yesterday or today should not be bothering us. For those who have been "awaken" -- wake up others.
Let's hold people who violate Gurmat in the Guru Ghar accountable for their actions.
Is it acceptable for drunkards to be part of Gurdwara Committees and then give talks on the Gurdwara stage under the influence of alcohol?
Is it acceptable that non-Amritdharis who are not following the principles of the Guru, to be running the House of the Guru and take responsibility of "leading" the Sikh Sangat?
Is it acceptable that people "compromise" and "give and take" (quoting from Barking Gurdwara Meeting) with Gurmat and Guru's principles?
"We will discuss the matter."
"We will have a meeting about this"
"We will take a vote on the issue"
When it is a question of "Gurmat" (the Guru's way) and "Manmat" (our own selfish way) then what is their to vote, discuss or talk about?
I thought it was quite simple -- 'if you are running the Guru's House and taken responsibility to lead, guide and inspire the Sangat then you will always side with "Gurmat", no question asked or no second thought'
Let's all unite.
We have become blind to what the Gurdwara's role is and the high expectations of Gurdwara Parbandhak Committees are no where to be seen. I praise and appreciate the efforts of the Gursikhs who have been active in taking a stand for Gurmat in the past and in the present.
A Gurmukh Piaara suggested the following action plan idea:
(1) Getting as many letters and petitions sent to the Gurdwara Parbandhak Committees who are violating Gurmat.
(2) Creating awareness of the issues in newspaper, internet, radio, and magazines
(3) Having an open meeting with Gurdwara Sahibs (inviting the youth and other Gursikhs to challenge the committee's manmat plans on an intellectual level rather than being rude, loud and threatening)
(4) Stage peaceful protests outside Gurdwara Sahib involving sangat. Invite Sangat from other towns and cities. Let the police know and invite local press, Panjabi newspapers and radio stations like Panjab Radio
(5) Personally phoning and speaking to Bibi Jagir Kaur (SGPC President) and Singh Sahib Joginder Singh Vedanti (Jathedar of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib) to issue a statement in support of protestors, and comdemning the Gurdwaras who are compromising Guru's Sikhi for convenience, personal gain and manmat. (Phone numbers available from www.sgpc.net)
Every Gursikh should be a Panthic activist who should recognise their duty to reform the wrong-doings happening within the Panth.
May others like me be inspired by the hard work, enthusiasm, high spirit and the love for Guru Ji and the Panth which Singhs and Singhnees have shown in the past and recently.
Keep up the good work
Daas,
Manvir Singh
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
ns · 11 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh
Absolutely spot on Manvir Singh Jeeo, those 5 points listed in your mail are vital tangible objectives for all to digest and act upon. If done so with enthausiasm then it could be a leading example to bring about change in the thinking of (the old uncle) types in the Gurdwara commitees up and down the country who have built Gurdwara's with gleaming marble but nothing else. They indeed have done their job or are doing it as in my town Gravesend but it's up to the upcoming youth have love for their Guru to rightly act on those points to bring about change.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Tarsem Singh · 12 May 2005
I dont understand why you all arguing amogst yourselfs?? If someone wasnt their dont worry, you dont have to explain, especially here. You dont have to defend yourselves here. 'hmmmm' maybe angry and i suggested you that you think before you write. Veer Upkar Singh im abit dissapointed with your comment 'So who are these individuals who suddenly have so much concern.' Isnt it a good thing that these individuals have become aware now, I can say that these singhs were mone before and still quite young thats why they wasnt concerned before. Infact this is the time for you to unite with them and tell the comittee that you have been campaiging for 20yrs and now these guys are also concerned so you should unite with them, maybe it may help get things done.
About havng being advertised it was all really word of mouth, because the singhs went down a week before to the comittee and they said come to the sports comittee. Im sure singhs in east london knew, I know jatinderpal singh knew, satvinder singh knew, knew, lakhvinder singh knew the sevadaars of this campaign also did go to the gym ,goodmayes majnit singh knew, so some how some way singhs all have contact. If you still didnt find out then nothing can be said. But I know you have contact with all the singhs mentioned above.
I know your very active and would have liked to be there, but im also dissapointed in your comment '"The sleeping cat wakes up and tries to roar like a lion"
Thats really harsh veer jee, the sevadaars singhs respect you and you come out with a comment like that?? and your also older and wiser than them, im abit dissapointed in that comment, i would have thought better.
Also the sevadaars do work together and are very panthic not concerend about jathes etc, and they dont want chaudor. Just because their new to the naujawans and are doing things staright away doesnt mean they want chaudor. As far as I know them they dont have a grudge with no one, they have a lot of piaar for everyone and not too sure whos got the big ego out of them. I think its a shame that we all cant get along and become sour if some new singhs started something. I think these comments about sleeping cat, new jatha of singhs etc is uncalled for. that just makes splits in the sangat we have. very dissapointed with these messages on this post.
If I have offended anyone sorry, I dont intednd to, just want this bashing of singhs stopped.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Holbras · 12 May 2005
Vaah TarsemSingh. Very different from what you were saying to me on the phone. Chullo we can talk on the phone. Let's excuse this thread. Oh and i only knew a day before when Bhai ............ Jee phoned and asked wheter i was going or not.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Heston Singh · 12 May 2005
Holbras,
Some of were only informed of the issue 2 hours before by the veerji's in Ilford.
Tyar Bar Tyar!!! I am sure Bhai Fauja Singh didn't need 24 hour notice.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Holbras · 12 May 2005
I have personal reasons why i did not attend. How can i be anything like shaheed Bhai FaujaSingh Jee?
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Heston Singh · 12 May 2005
Sorry Veerji. I went a bit out of context. Bhul Chuk Maaf
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Jindi SB · 12 May 2005
VaheguroojeekakhalsaVaheguroojeekifateh!!
Sorry to but in to this argument. Why are we pulling out excuses for attendance or non-attendance.
I personally feel that we should drop everything when it comes to an issue involving Guru Jees Baydbee. But you can't force everyone to be there, some people are not interested. Believe me, we've been here before, Trafalgar Sqaure, the Rep theatre, Baylis House
I agree, it is very disheartening when some people who you truly expect to be there don't turn up. But there is nothing you can do about it. It's all in Guru jees hands. Last Sunday felt like the beginning of something new. Hopefully tommorrow we will have more people willing to come forward.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 12 May 2005
I have written before, but for some rrason the mail did not get through.
I think, this nit picking on irrelevant issues should stop at one.Gurus sewa and kaumi farz start from different points and times for different people.The fact we are all ready to deal with this issue should be enough of a starting point for the sangat who wants to do something about this issue.It is not good sprinkling "shikkerr" all over each other.We cannot do things on our own.People who have been doing it for twnety years must just understand, it probably took others twenty years to wake up to it,the fact peop-le have now waken up is all that matters.
For the locals, and others please access the Ilford recorder, www.ilfordrecorder.co.uk where in the issue of the 28th of April 2005 , in the letters column, a Mr OP Shabbi has objected to the tournament, although citing some incorrect facts.
In todays recorder this has now been responded by the secretary of the SGS Sabha Secretary General SS Narwal who has reiterated that the Gurduara has NEVER withdrawn the support for this project, among a few other points that he tried to justify for the continuation of this event.
Satnam Singh, the tournament organiser too has tried to justify the continuation of this tournament and how the local Sikhs are seeking their equal share of the taxes they pay.
This is a good opportunity to oppose this tournament, unless it changes its name and disassociates itself from Guru Arjan Dev ji, and his shaheedi.
I have written in and I am sure the ilford recorder would dearly love to hear from other Sikhs and local residents.I can see this issue becomming a "hot issue locally".
My humble request is ..instead of going off the objective and trying to be holier than thou, and blaming everyone else for any little thing,please get TOGETHER TO ADDRESS this issue.
NO ONE can do it individually.We need to be UNITED.The Gurduara had a chance to chnage the name,BUT since they regarded the sangat as nothing more than wallabies
Let us voice to get it banned altogether.That will give them something to think about, since they feel they do not have to listen to the Sikh sangat.The Sikh sangat does not need leaders as such.
The ammunition is out there, Singho, instead of mouthing off each other and potraying such an infant mentality of Sikh psyche,GET ON THE BANDWAGON ,get this tournament banned altogether!!!
That will be food for thought for these hankare gurduara commitee ......can any one mature to this ..action ?
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
singhnee · 12 May 2005
Vaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh
Bhai Sahib Gurcharan Singh is right we should use local media, press to voice concerns over the tournaments name, however we must consider how many people read the recorder weekly and perhaps use other means and methods (those suggested by Bhai Manvir Singh) to make 'local' sangat aware of what is happening.
I am a singhnee who also lives in East London, and would gracefully join with other naujawan in East London to make a stand against the bebedbi that is taking place. However I and at least 10-15 other Singhs and Singhnee's had no idea (only found out by reading this post today) about this meeting despite having joined in seva together before with organisers of the meeting that took place with the commitee members.
My only pleed today is that we have to work as one to move forward, especially when it comes to changing ways of the commitee's in the UK. Communication in any form is vital when striking an opposition. Understandably this may of been a last minute meeting but for those Singhs and Singhnee's that were aware of the meeting please, as a benti make an effort to let us 'bana wearing, jathe promoters of East London' know of the next meeting, so we too can join with you and not against you to make this stand.
Perhaps we may not be your idea of 'true Saadh Sangat' but i do feel large numbers and unity against the commitee's weak arguments will possibly over-ride their stand.
I'm sure you have means of contacts for a lot more of the East London sangat that were unaware of this meeting so I and I'm sure others await to hear from you so that we too can put forward those suggestions put forward by Bhai Gurcharan & Bhai Manvir Singh.
Bhul Chuk Marf Karni Jio.
Vaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 12 May 2005
I am amused by Mr. SS Narwal's claim that Mr O.P.Shabbi does not believe in democracy.I wonder if he practices himself what he accuses others of ? He and his committee turned away with lame excuses, the large group of Sikhs, who attended the open meeting at Gurduara Sahib Singh Sabha, Barking on Sunday the 8th, to object against , and request the committee,( that has been elected by the Sikh congregation of Redbridge. to SERVE the Sikh congregation ), to either stop this tournament or change its name to something else,and NOT associate with the name of the Sikh Guru.
The use of alcohol,the bad and lowly holigan behaviour, and the expenses from the Gurduara which are actually donated for religious purposes do not represent the message of the Sikh religion or the Guru himself.
Mr SS Narwal's response was ..who is the Sikh congregation to tell the committee what to to do?He obviously applies one rule for himself and another to others, when he talks of democracy.
I can say this with authority most of the Sikh/Punjabi population in Redbridge is not in favour of this tournament, as the use of alochol and rowdy behaviour in the last few years does not correspond to the values of the great Sikh religion(GURMAT) and the Guru Sahib in whose memory it was named.
By particpating in such an event, where alcohol flows freely, the Gurduara Committee is violating the Sikh Ethics Code;yet SS Narwal and his committee are adament this tournament be supported by the Gurduara, and are oblivion to the Sikh Code.
In the same page Mr Satnam Singh's claims that it is an attack on Sikh community cannot be further from the truth.The only attack, I can see along with many in the community,and the larger law abiding community, is on the noble name of the Sikh Guru by the organisers and the Gurduara Committee, who are bent on supporting it with monies donated by the congregations.
Would anyone of these individuals appear in the presence of the Guru Sabad- Guru Granth Sahib and assert to Sikh congregations that the tournament indeed represents the memory of the Fifth Guru who was martyred, and is in line with his message of love and honest Sikh living ?
The tournament was started off in the memory of the fifth Guru of the Sikhs, Guru Arjan Ji, who was martyred for asserting the right to practice a religion freely.But what happens at the tournament these days and from the last few years. I would like emphasise does not represent the principles of the Sikh religion.
GS Kulim
Repton Park
Chigwell
The above is the copy of the letter I have addressed to the Ilford Recorder.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Holbras · 12 May 2005
I have spoken to those Singhs and Singhneeia that were unaware of the meeting. We will all be attending the next meeting if we come to know of it. Ill put aside my personal reasons for not attending the first one.
"Bana and Jatha Promoter"- Jatinderpalsingh
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 12 May 2005
Shabaash that will indeed be appreciated and PANTH KI JEET will be assured ...Sikho ,.drop all and every difference..let us start to reform not only this Gurduara BUT EVERY .......Unite ...into this sewa...
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Local Singh · 13 May 2005
Sadh Sangat Ji of East London,
It appears we might be bogging oursleves down with the 1 issue.
A strong step was taken and we sent the signals. So now move on! Focus on the bigger picture, after all the "Respect for Guru Granth Sahib Ji Campaign" started in East London. Most of us have worked successfully together before.
In the next few days the committee will either agree or not. Leave the rest up to Guru Ji. We just keep focusing on our Amrit Vela, Nit-Nem and Naam Simran and we will be OK.
Just be ready when we need to get together. It may be sooner than you think.
PANTH KI JEET!
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
singh · 13 May 2005
good to see unity. A request to admin, if there is anymore bashing or silly comments from anyone please stop this thread or dont put it through because it dosnt look good and breaks up the sangat of east london, even though im not from east london, but i know some good singhs there.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Jaspal Singh C · 13 May 2005
"Bana and Jatha Promoter"- Jatinderpalsingh.
It is so great to hear that you will be attending and joining all your Sikh brothers and sisters. I hope you are coming for Gurujee and not just to save face. Same with all the other Singhs and Singhnees who allegedly didn't know. East London is a small area word gets around, this was being discussed for over 2 weeks. Even the Granthis in Goodmayes/Barking knew. If you didn't come it was because you didn't want to be there, same with everyone who made up last minute excuses. That was what was upsetting, the lame excuses given.
And it's so typical for this to end up as a "jatha" bashing issue. This was not what it was meant to be!! Just wanted to bash the amritdhari Singhs/Singhnees that knew about the issue but didn't want to be a part of it. No one is holier than thou, we just need to see some more unification from our local singhs/singhnees old & young when it comes to blatant beadbi of Guru Mahraj. How else will things change!?!?
-----
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Local Singh · 13 May 2005
Good response to the letters Gurcharan Singh Kulim Ji.
I think that speaks for everyone. Will the newspaper confirm if they print the letter?
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
((Gurcharan Singh Kulim)) · 13 May 2005
They have not responded but I will be on their back, shortly...I feel they will, as they see the opposition from within the community ....to this event .
I feel that it is a strong stand, but I also beleive the Gurduara committee asked for a fight...let thm have it ...please no more bashing or pulling anyone about ...UNITY is the next stage and step ..to achieve justice for the name of Guru Arjan Ji.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
.... · 13 May 2005
i wonder who the other the 15 singh/singhnees are, who were baana that wasnt there?? im a bit dissapointed in jatinderpal singh to make this an issue like that, and claiming that other singhs didnt call the 'baana' wearing singhs on purpose. Jatinerpal singh, its a shame the way you write things because your so young and you can cause a big split within sangat by your MADE UP accusations.
All singhs older than you have unity and there is no issues within the singhs, its just your own thinking, and maybe because your young and have a lot of time on your hands you play on this. Please stop these false accusations, 90% of singhs in east london all get on, so why did you have to make such blatent jargon and post it here. You said it yourself you didnt come because of your persoal reason, its obvious that you may have a problem with someone, and then you wrote about 'new singhs/jatha' why dont you put your differences aside for guru jee. Jatha singhs/taksali singhs and all other singhs get on, please bhai jee dont make these issues in east london, via your post. benti to admin, if bhai jee does write something which you may think will cause a split in e.london please do not let it up. He may have already caused some stir, i hope your satisfied, i just i hope its because your young and not because you have all these false issues in your head.
bhul chuk maf to jatinderpal singh and any one else
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
((Gurcharan Singh Kulim)) · 13 May 2005
Bhai jatinderpal singh jio, UNITY does not come with people raking over qnd over the same dust.If someone has said anything wrong, that phaase was passed like four mails ago...to continue to rake it ....shows either one does not want UNITY ormaove on ....Bhai sahib ....no two fingers are the same ....UNITY is the only way forward here....Guru Gobind SINGH JI did NOT go back and argue with Bhai maha Singh ji , and the forty Mukte to what they did before they came back to fight for the Sikh cause.
YOu dont have to like me, BUT you will have to tolerate me, for a Sikh cause...I may not want to be part of your chat group, but I will for the cause of the panth.....it looks like there are not only one or two young people here,,there are many ..we all are ...and look as such when we argue over water gone under the bridge...instead why does not one say .....hey we had it wrong ,. a wrong start ...let us have a new start .....is it any wonder why some well educated Sikhs keep away from Gurduaras and politics .....bhai sahib ...I have a habit of speaking blunt....even my 450 staff tell me that ....in the NLondon Forensics department ...bhai sahib ...your opinions are highly valued...but UNITY is higher still that we need.Can every and each of you give that for the Gurus cause ...instead of worrying who said what ?
I see all agreed....thyen suddenly a hand grenade is tossed in now and then ...I may not be a good example of a Sikh, but I do care about my community .....and Guru. Want to join the the wagon ...of the TRUTH and Honesty ???
Otherwise there are many places out there where we can all gossip, reflect abouit all things negative .....and then wonder why Sikhs are always such ..when they are left behind ......and NOT move forward.
DR.GSK
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Holbras · 13 May 2005
<>
I will not go into Naming those 10 to 15 people that were left out. That post was posted by a Paanjee and she seems mature enough not to go naming people on a public forum.
<< and claiming that other singhs didnt call the 'baana' wearing singhs on purpose>>
Where have i claimed that? My point was that the new people have contact amongst themselves only and do not contact any of the other Singhs here that are local aswell. I've spoken to 4 sets of Singhs all local to me who were all unware and had no contact from the new sewadars.
<>
I wish you would have some bottle to post with your name seeing it seems like you know me so well personally. I dont think i can cause any splits within anyone. Im fully independant in what and how i do.
<>
Im sorry but i dont agree where Unity is mentioned within all the older singhs. There are so many people here who favour their friends over the others. I mean, you wont find people everywhere where they all agree on everything in the same light as you or your friends do. If you go over my posts, you will see how less of an issue they are as you and your friends are making them out to be. I simply posted back to the person hiding behind the post name of "hmmm" as it was an attack on those who are not part of their favourables who do Keertans and Simrans.
<>
I would discuss this part with you in person but the only problem is that your hiding behind a name otherwise, i probally would explain to you my personal reason(s) for not going.
<>
I dont have a Jatha, as for Taksali Singhs I didn't know we had any here, maybe one or two but didnt know we had more. The more the better. I am not making no issue here. I dont see where its showed you i have issues. My main point in my post was to keep the older sangata with you's too, so that they are not bashed after not knowing anything about what ever is going on in 'East London'.
I find it very strange how you can justify or excuse the post by "hmmm" as not offensive or "STIRING" within 'East London' but rather my posts.
<>
Admins, i am so sorry that all this rubbish all the way in East London has ended up on your Gurmat Forum. I do appologize that its happening on this Site. I didnt choose the venue, but im for some reason being shown as the bad one. Chullo, im happy with that... suits me fine.
<>
I think "hmmm" done all the stiring there was to be done. I have no false issues, the issues i do have, the very minor ones, are so small that they are being shown as massive holes. I might be young but not that young.
<>
Is there really any point of your "bhul chuk maf" after had said all that about me? Use your brain.
Other than that, im sorry to all the Sangata for having to read the little issues that are here which are being shown as such big ones. This happens to be my last post in this thread as advised by Older respected Singhs.
My email adress is available, and so is my number to those posting under fake names who obviously seem to know who i am.
Jatinderpalsingh.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
Holbras · 13 May 2005
Author: ((Gurcharan Singh Kulim))
Are you not telling the wrong person here? Seems like "...." decided to bring up the subject matter again.
Chullo, thanks for your intelligence. Guroo sahib kirpaa karan..
(my last post)
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
. · 13 May 2005
you are a good lad jatinder singh dont get wound up by anything.
do ardas for their souls so they may realise the error and ask god to bless em wid more chardi kala.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
upkar singh · 13 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh
Finally I see real gursikhs hitting the ground running.
I have no regrets in the previous post for everything that I said. As I said it with a clean heart.
I still resent so called gursikhs who have opinions but noooooooooo guts
And the sheer audacity to return with their sad faces into this forum without revealing them selves.
I sincerely did not know about the meeting as I have not been talking to anyone on this forum or names mentioned.
But my post was only to bring about the hopefully revealing of the RSS type that plague our forums and panth who love to stir and divide and rule our efforts.
“Such postings do not encourage unity.”
But these people need to be revealed.
With regards to my use of words I did not direct them at any gurbhai, jathebandhi or mittar.
Neither do I carry sour grapes as I have relentlessly carried on with what I see the only way to maintain gurmaryada and sanity.
How? – You can ask me face to face as you all know me.
I have had the pleasure and disappointment of working with all kinds of so called gursikhs and actual guru ji's gursikhs but always a minority against a majority.
I don’t have a problem with others organizing as long as they tell everyone systematically what is happening. (Especially as all my gurbhai’s did not feel that I was worth informing.
After my posting I spoke extensively with veer Mankamal Singh Ji about this meeting and the reasons that were mutually agreed upon for my non presence fortunately.
“I am involved with direct confrontation with this management at this moment in time”
This picture with the committee is a lot bigger than your imagination; I am willing to share it.
We have worked together before and as everyone who has worked with me know how I work. Without beating our drums you all remember the success of the Trafalgar event.
So rather than us bickering like a bunch of pandoo bibi’s please get organize a meeting and I shall be there.
Akhar vadh ghat - bhul chuk maaf
We are all gurbhai’s and get on with the Guru Ji’s mission and get together.
P.S. Naujawan Kirtan Dirbar - 4 June @ Seven Kings Gurdwara
I’ll be there if you need to get something off your mind or share something.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
upkar singh · 13 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
the picture is much bigger than what the naujawan have
singh sabha barking Pardan got beaten up today and put in hospital.
maybe we can a sensible meeting on how to move forward
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
singh · 14 May 2005
beating someone up is not the answer and will reflect back bad on gursikhs trying to make changes.
a peaceful protest with gursikhs in bana from both genders campaigning against the event would have helped more. I would love to see the sangats touched by shotey veers and bhains in bana. It will be like a mind mirror to those who drink and smoke. If we ca raise 2000 gursikhs from all over the country go there and campaign peacefully, do simran and paat so that we make a presence if all else fails to stop the events title being misused.
who gives a tail about who turned up who did not? thats unfair i dont think any past singhs singhnia thought like that, because all that counts is in the moment thats manifesting in front of you. Its not right to point a finger at people, if you feel they need change go and meet them, do ardas for them, give them the strentgh so they may stand strong like you. At such a critical stage of sikhism we should think along the lines of helping to resurface gurmat life amongst the masses around us. Each one of us has a spark of God inside us that needs lighting like a torch to another torch. If you dont get on with someone leave them be and just pray for them.
[%sig%]
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
revOLUtION · 14 May 2005
the committees will kill eventually each other off!!!
east london sangat please can you not argue anymore. it's getting boring!!
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
rsingh · 14 May 2005
Fateh,
ive just got of the phone
turns out the fight was internal commitie thing and nothing to do with Nujwan.
Re: Committee refuse benti by Sangat
jaswinder singh · 14 May 2005
if the sangat do not get along it is hardly rss types upkar singh it is a matter of communication problem and egos that need to be put aside for greater cause. If we fail to recognise that brush problem aside the grudges carry on every next time panthic problem arise.