Takht panel clears ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
Tribune News Service · 11 May 2005
Takht panel clears ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
Jupinderjit Singh
Tribune News Service
Ludhiana, May 11
A committee of eminent experts on Sikh religion formed by the Akal Takht Jathedar, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, has given a clean chit to controversial film “Jo Bole So Nihal” even as the outrage against the movie continues, with some organisations determined not to allow its screening at any cost. The committee has instead praised the movie.
Following the committee verdict, whose six members saw the movie at a special show screened in Mumbai, Mr Amarjit Singh, president, Akal Market Association and petitioner against the film, has withdrawn his petition filed in the Punjab and Haryana High Court demanding a ban on the movie.
Jathedar Vedanti has, in a communication to Mr Amarjit Singh, sent him the report of the committee about the movie. Mr Amarjit Singh said the report of the committee was the final word on the controversial movie by Akal Takht and he decided to withdraw his petition despite having some reservations about the movie.
The committee has not only issued a clean chit to the movie but has praised the makers and the hero of the film, Sunny Deol, for a realistic portrayal of a Sikh, besides upholding the true values of Sikhism in the film. The film is being distributed by liquor baron Ponty Chadha.
The committee members who saw the screening of the movie in Hari Kunj, Khar Mumbai, were Mr Gurjit Singh, Mr Sarbjit Singh, Mr Ajit Singh, Mr Prabinder Singh, Mr Joginder Singh and Mr Prithipal Singh.
The committee has listed eight points after watching the movie. It said that the film was not a religious movie; the hero had firm faith in the Waheguru and overcame all obstacles because of his faith and there was no attempt to hurt the religious feelings of Sikhs in the film.
It said a villain in the film, after assuming the attire of a Sikh, tried to consume tobacco but the mother of the hero slapped him and gave the right message to the viewers about the tenets of Sikhism.
The committee also noted that Sunny Deol, the hero of the movie, insisted on growing his beard and used to tie the turban afresh. He had also employed a Sikh to help him in tying the turban.
The committee has, however, directed the director and the producer of the movie to mention specifically in advertisements and promotions of the movie that it was not a religious film. It has also ordered that no poster or scene should be pasted or carried in the advertisements which did not correspond to the title ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’.
Re: Takht panel clears ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
Tribune News Service · 11 May 2005
HC tells Censor Board to review ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
Our High Court Correspondent
Chandigarh, May 11
The Punjab and Haryana High Court today directed the Censor Board of Film Certification (CBFC) to review the title of forthcoming Hindi movie Bole So Nihal and other contentious issues in the light of the objections raised by petitioners, who have sought a ban on release of the movie.
Giving this direction to the Censor Board, the Division Bench headed by Chief Justice Mr Justice D.K. Jain also directed the Censor Board to inform the court about its decision by tomorrow. The Bench said in case nothing wrong was found with the film, its release would not be stopped as per the programme on May 13.
Earlier, in their replies, film producer N.R. Pasichia and liquor baron Ponty Chadha, who has invested money in the movie, stated that a committee appointed by Akal Takht had cleared the movie. The committee, they claimed, had gone to Mumbai to view the movie and had asked the producers to write on the posters of the movie that it was not a religious movie. This suggestion, they stated, had been implemented.
Referring to the role essayed by Sunny Deol in the movie, the respondents stated that he was playing the role of a Sikh and all care had been taken to ensure that Sikh tenets were not ignored.
For this purpose, Sunny even grew a beard and an expert had been taken abroad to tie his turban.
Counsel, however, failed to convince the Bench as to why this title was being used for the movie.
Counsel argued that it was a "jaikara" and was used even by the Army. They also stated that movies such as Satyam Shivam Sundaram and Har Har Mahadev had already been made. Counsel said if Akal Takht had given its approval, there was no reason why anybody should not be satisfied.
The petitioners' counsel said one of the scenes they had an objection to was where the hero, Sunny Deol, has been shown smoking a cigarette, despite being a Sikh man. However, the respondents clarified that the same scene also showed his mother slap the boy.
A fax sent by the Secretary to the Chairperson of the Censor Board, which was produced in the court, also informed the Bench that the CBFC would review the movie.
Sikh bodies call for special screening of ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
Tribune News Service
Patiala, May 11
A section of Sikh organisations today urged the Central Board of Film Certification and Union Minister for Information and Broadcasting for arranging a special screening of the movie, “Jo Bole So Nihal”, so that a cross-section of the Sikhs from Punjab and other states could watch it and make a decision whether it contained any thing which was against the Sikh religion and its tenets.
Mr Karnail Singh Panjoli, Member, SGPC, in a press note issued here today said a memorandum in this connection was submitted to the Deputy Commissioner.
He alleged that the producer and director of the movie had played with the sentiments of the Sikhs by portraying Sikhs in a bad light.
He said representatives of different Sikh organisations had also demanded that release of the movie should be delayed as tampering with religious sentiments of the Sikhs could ignite Sikh anger, and if that happened the Central and the state government would be responsible for same.
He said they had also urged the Punjab Government to take steps to restrain the distributors from releasing the movie.
Re: Takht panel clears ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 May 2005
and then the Censor Board will step in and "ban" the film...and the "akal takhat" will be left holding the smoking gun....remember the Rapist Sant Piara case where the Akal takaht "cleared" him of all charges..BUT the COURT found him guilty and sent him to Jail..so who is the "good cop" in this case ??
This is the Way of the Chanikiya...buy off/disgrae/...with one hand...and be the hero/rakhiyak with the other...all the time central theme..DESTROY SIKHE.
Call me paranoid...or whatever..but I see the Bippar hand behind every move to "denigrate" Sikhe/Gurmat/Gurbani....
Re: Takht panel clears ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
singh ashamed. · 12 May 2005
Well, Well, Well.
Ashamed? i am.
Suprised by the verdict from Akal takht, I'm not.
Jarnail Singh ji is correct to say that they have turned a blind eye to all allegations made against sants with major flause in there character, and when sikh organistions are trying to ban this film, they whole-heartedly they praise it!
We all talk about what our guru's want from us. What legacy they left for us, and how we are to lead our lives. Enough of these jathedhars, enough of these 'bachorle' sants/babas, all we need is Siri Guru granth Sahib Jee. THATS ALL.
When are going to learn. NEVER...
The blind leading the blind my brotheres/sisters.
I'm so sick of all this crap, i'm ready to throw in the towel...
[%sig%]
Re: Takht panel clears ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
Manvir Singh · 12 May 2005
http://www.tribuneindia.com/2005/20050513/punjab1.htm
Vedanti’s volte face on ‘Jo Bole So Nihal’
SGPC writes to Censor Board
Varinder Walia
Tribune News Service
Amritsar, May 12
Even as the Jathedar, Akal Takht , Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, made a volte-face on the controversial film , “Jo Bole So Nihal”, and claimed that he had not given any clean chit in this regard , the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee has written a strong-worded letter to the Censor Board, ignoring the report of a sub-committee constituted by Mr Vedanti in this regard.
The letter shot off to the Censor Board by the SGPC secretary , Mr Dalmegh Singh ,on behalf of its president, Bibi Jagir Kaur, has made the position of Jathedar Vedanti awkward . Many SGPC members have openly criticised Jathedar Vedanti for the haste shown by him in giving a clean chit to the controversial film.
Jathedar Vedanti said his name was being unnecessarily dragged into the controversy and it was unethical on the part of the petitioner to submit his letter in the Punjab and Haryana High Court. He said Sikh high priests were above the court and hence the petitioner had “stabbed in the back” by submitting the report of the sub-committee, forwarded by him, in the court.
Mr Hardip Singh Mohali , an SGPC member, has expressed surprise over the “hasty step” taken by Jathedar Vedanti . He said it was intriguing that Jathedar Vedanti constituted a committee the next day after receiving the letter on May 4 . The committee visited Mumbai on May 8 and submitted its report the next day, which was submitted in the court the day after. He said while hundreds of petitions were lying unattended with the Akal Takht secretariat, haste was shown in the case of this film.
Mr Prithipal Singh Sandhu, non-official personal assistant and close relative of Jathedar Vedanti, who was not even a member of the sub-committee, also went to Mumbai to see the movie, which raised much suspicion. Earlier , Mr Sandhu was removed as personal assistant to Jathedar Vedanti by the SGPC on bribe charges.
Mr Manjit Singh Calcutta, a senior member of the SGPC, while expressing his surprise and shock over the developments, said the case pertained to the SGPC and not to Akal Takht. Mr Calcutta said he had gone to Mumbai to review film “Machis” but he and other members had spent the entire money from their own pockets . In case of “Jo Bole So Nihal” , the air tickets were arranged by the party concerned, which was against ethics .
Meanwhile, the role of Mr Charnjit Singh Chadha , president of the Chief Khalsa Diwan, also came under scanner for reportedly approaching the Jathedar, Akal Takht, in this regard . However, Mr Chadha claimed that he had not sought any favour for the film but simply suggested to him to constitute a permanent committee by taking members from the Chief Khalsa Diwan, the SGPC and the Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee for taking up such cases with the Censor Board in future.
The SGPC, in its letter to the Censor Board, stated that using of sacred slogans like “Jo Bole So Nihal” was bound to incite the sentiments of the Sikh community. The letter says that the SGPC could not allow the use of slogans from holy scriptures, which did not conform, to its maryada.
[%sig%]