women as panj pyara
nks · 13 May 2005
WJKK WJKF There have been a lot of debates pertaining to whether or not, women should be able to be a part of panj pyara. Why is it wrong for women to part take as panj pyara? WJKK WJKF
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
nks · 13 May 2005
WJKK WJKF There have been a lot of debates pertaining to whether or not, women should be able to be a part of panj pyara. Why is it wrong for women to part take as panj pyara? WJKK WJKFsingh · 13 May 2005
bhai nand lal jis varran say clearly panch singh amrit so dhaevaiDogma · 13 May 2005
asked and answered NKS Jeeo. :) please do a search of previous topics.Khalistani Singh · 13 May 2005
Did Guru Sahib Boycott women from panj Pyaree? Could Giani Kulbir Singh or Arshi vala Giani please enlighten the Gur sangat with there Brahm Vidya on this topic.jugroop singh · 13 May 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer 'singh' Ji, that's a big assumption to make, off the back of those words ('panch singh amrit so dhaevai')... as far as this sentence using the masculine in reference to The Punj Piyarae, grammatically-speaking, you've got a point...but it proves nothing over-arching and empirical 'singh ji' regarding the fact whetehr or not our mothers, sisters and daughters can do this Seva... if it was so important that females should not do this Seva, why is there nothing Puraatan, pre-Ranjit Singh, (to my limited knowledge) that clearly states this - if it was/is so important for non-males to stay away from the Amrit Bata, you'd think it would be explicitly stated so as to avoid any confusion; Amrit Sanchaar being such a fundamental bedrock of Sikhi practice. can anyone please share quotes from Puraatan sources, that may be discussed, analysed, rejected or accepted... VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!khalistani · 13 May 2005
thas y bhai nand lal jes vaars, an enourmus souce ofmaryada says singh.... this was to remove all doubt for furture this is maryada it is written as a soruce of maryada there is praise of guru gobind singh je also, but almost all of it is maryada bhula chuka mafBijla Singh · 14 May 2005
maajh mehalaa 5 || Maajh, Fifth Mehl: aao saajan sa(n)th meeth piaarae || Come, dear friends, Saints and companions: mil gaaveh gun agam apaarae || let us join together and sing the Glorious Praises of the Inaccessible and Infinite Lord. gaavath sunath sabhae hee mukathae so dhhiaaeeai jin ham keeeae jeeo ||1|| Those who sing and hear these praises are liberated, so let us meditate on the One who created us. ||1|| I think those are capable of determining who or which gender is Guru Roop and who isn't should discuss this topic. galaa karae ghanaereeaa khasam n paaeae saadh || he may talk as much as he wants, but he shall not be pleasing to his Master. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki FatehPrincess · 16 May 2005
If 'Singh' word in Bhai Nand singh jee's vaar can't be for both singh and singhniaa then how it could be for piaaray? We call Punj pyaaray not punj singh when there is Amrit Sinchaar and in Ardas too. In Gurbani, Guru Sahibaan has used different words for Gursikhs. Some times They called all Gursikhs naariaa(n)(women) and in some shabads They used other masculine words then it means (ccording to khalistani and singh jee) Singh and singhniaa don't have to follow all Gurbani. Singhs should obey only hukams where Guru jee used masculine words and those won't apply on Singhniaa. Does it make since? Here are some examples: Following shabad is sambodhan to bibiaan(sisters) not to men. Why male keertaryay sing this shabad? and why male Akhandpaathi read it if it is only for women? [gurbani] isrIrwgu mhlw 1 ] Awvhu BYxy gil imlh AMik shylVIAwh ] imil kY krh khwxIAw sMmRQ kMq kIAwh ] swcy swihb siB gux Aaugx siB Aswh ]1] krqw sBu ko qyrY joir ] eyku sbdu bIcwrIAY jw qU qw ikAw hoir ]1] rhwau ] jwie puChu sohwgxI qusI rwivAw iknI guxNØI ] shij sMqoiK sIgwrIAw imTw bolxI ] ipru rIswlU qw imlY jw gur kw sbdu suxI ]2] kyqIAw qyrIAw kudrqI kyvf qyrI dwiq ] kyqy qyry jIA jMq isPiq krih idnu rwiq ] kyqy qyry rUp rMg kyqy jwiq Ajwiq ]3] scu imlY scu aUpjY sc mih swic smwie ] suriq hovY piq aUgvY gurbcnI Bau Kwie ] nwnk scw pwiqswhu Awpy ley imlwie ]4]10[/gurbani] In following Shabad 'meet' and 'sant janhu' words are masculine: [gurbani] Awsw mhlw 5 ] Awvhu mIq iekqR hoie rs ks siB BuMch ] AMimRq nwmu hir hir jph imil pwpw muMch ]1] qqu vIcwrhu sMq jnhu qw qy ibGnu n lwgY ] KIn Bey siB qskrw gurmuiK jnu jwgY ]1] rhwau ] buiD grIbI Krcu lYhu haumY ibKu jwrhu ] swcw htu pUrw saudw vKru nwmu vwpwrhu ]2] jIau ipMfu Dnu AripAw syeI piqvMqy ] AwpnVy pRB BwixAw inq kyl krMqy ]3] durmiq mdu jo pIvqy ibKlI piq kmlI ] rwm rswieix jo rqy nwnk sc AmlI ]4]12]114][/gurbani] There are hundreds of examples. If use of faminine or masculine word rule applies on Bhai Nand singh jee's vaara(n) then it should apply on Gurbani too.Roopkaur · 16 May 2005
When we say Khalsa, are we only referring to the men of the panth? Do we call all the bibiaa khalseeaa? NO. So why would you argue that panj singh means just the men?singh · 16 May 2005
what u have to think about is, that if guru ji wanted to he cud of made the 5 piyare all women.. bet he never they were all men.. i think we shud keep the mariyada the same and not change it.Dogma · 16 May 2005
I haven't really formed an opinion on this issue.. I was wondering does anyone have any evidence of PURATAN Amrit Sanchars having women serve as Panj Pyaray?Socialist Guy · 16 May 2005
Many people say that no woman stood up when Guru Gobind Singh Jee was asking for heads. Well, who was the first Sikh? Who was the first person to recognize Guru Nanak Dev Jee for who he was (Satguru). According to Ithiaas... it was Bebe Nanaki. His sister. Then using your own logic... ONLY WOMEN CAN BE SIKHS. Because the nawaab person who saw guru sahib being shaded by a cobra came later. Bebe Nanaki was the first Sikh. And what an amazing Sikh she must have been.khalistani · 16 May 2005
ok look in banee bhai is just a metaphor for evryone guru es not literally saying men eveeyone agrees on this i think they are talking to everyone but bhai nand lal jes are stricltly referring to the REIGHT MARYADA OF THE KHALSA not to raise ure avastha directly but to give reight, in wat conduct we shhud live thus watever bhai sahib says is literall especailly in the shabad panch singh amrit jo devai theres a reason y singh was used, and not khalsa or panch sikh or something like that it is strictly panch SINGH in the litlerall sence forget purtaan even up to around 100 yeara ago no bibi was even seen in panj pyarai its only now our generation thinks women can be in panj bhula chuka mafSpeech Therapist · 16 May 2005
In japji sahib it says, Panch parvan, Panch pardhan, panchay pavai dargah maan. Here it clearly says 5 Gurmukhs. No gender. So why can't women do sewa in punj pyare? Guru sahib says that any panj gurmukhs are parvaan and if they are parvaan in the here after why not here as well. It is a logical extension. Besides the gender has no effect on your kamaiee. Also, Please explain how use of the word 'Singh' excludes any women from doing sewa. Because a lot of purataan rehitnamay use 'Singh' to mean Khalsa. Unless ofcourse only Singhs are supposed to follow rehit and Kaur's aren't. Your argument is riddled with inconsistencies. Please provide other reasons. I hope people refrain from saying something typical like b/c some so and so was a brahmgiani and he said so.Jps · 16 May 2005
Here's an example that teaches us that the word SINGH reffers to both, Bhai's and Bibiyaa. "aagae aavath singh j paavai || vaaheguroo kee fathae bulaavai ||" Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh Would this only be for men?Roopkaur · 16 May 2005
>it is strictly panch SINGH in the litlerall sence< What makes you so sure it is singh just for singhs? I know that when there is a group of singhs and singhneeaa, take the Singhs at tapoban, we do not say, the Tapoban singhs and singhneea, we just generally say, the Tapoban SInghs.Dogma · 16 May 2005
but I think Khalistani makes a good point here.. If in Puratan times bibiyan were not Panj Pyaray then how come they are allowed now? Isn't this also a recent trend? Can anyone supporting the position that bibiyan can do seva in the Panj please provide some direct evidence that this practice was implemented in the past?khalistani · 16 May 2005
ya wat proof do U have that panj bibis used to be in purtaan times?? hwo come suddenly this pops out of nowehere this HAS NEVER HAPPENED BEEFORE forget purtaan, this hasnt happeend int he last 80 years until NOW with the new generations this has never happeend before suddenly everyone thinks sall gud, were right, older generations and purtaaan jathas, purtaan maryada, everything wrong bhula chuka mafJugraj Singh · 17 May 2005
>>>> If in Puratan times bibiyan were not Panj Pyaray then how come they are allowed now? >>>> >>>> wat proof do U have that panj bibis used to be in purtaan times?? hwo come suddenly this pops out of nowehere this HAS NEVER HAPPENED BEEFORE >>> Reading the above comments, an old punjabi saying came to mind. Tobay da gavah dadoo. In anycase, how would you know women have never done sewa in punj before? You're claiming to have knowledge of every single amrit sanchar to ever happen and not just that, also claiming to know gender and names of the punj pyare during those amrit sanchars? This is total nonsense. Trying to say that you haven't read about it happening in history simply means that you've no logical argument with which to debate the issue. And your simply holding on to one argument that most people thought to weak to even bother answering. Just because YOU haven't heard or read of it happening doesn't make something anti-gurmat. Since you claim so vehemently that women can't do sewa of Punj Pyare then it's reasonable to assume that you know of something that women lack which prevents them from doing this sewa. I for one would like to hear what exactly it is that women are lacking that prevents them from doing sewa in Punj. Please, enlighten us.Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 17 May 2005
"khalistani " There has been a Singhnee in punj seva at the time of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji's time. Does that not count as purtaan times??? If this was wrong, i'm sure that Bhai Sahib would of had objected to this. Anyone that is a Khalsa can do seva in punj. If a Singhnee is tyaar-bar-tyaar, then there should be no reason as to why she cannot do seva in punj. We all preach about Sikhi being, equal. Well how is it equal if only Singhs are allowed to do punjaa dee seva. I know that many jatha's do not think bibiaan have equal rights a Singhs. At Tapoban Sahib, the Singh's and Singhnee-aa have equal rights. Bibi have been chosen to do seva at amritsanchars. Once again, only a KHALSA can do punjaa dee seva, and no where does it say that a Khalsa is a Singh only......Dogma · 17 May 2005
Jugraj Singh, I have actually made no conclusion on this issue yet. But I did notice that people were dodging Khalistani's point of puratan times not having women doing seva of panj (as you did veerji..:D) I don't believe that Khalistani has proof of every amritsanchar ever to take place. He's not a brahmgiani. But it is well known that we as sikhs today look to the Gursikhs of the past as leaders and we imitate them as over the years people agree that Rehit has been diluted by many causes. "Just because YOU haven't heard or read of it happening doesn't make something anti-gurmat" ..similarly, just because you believe in something doesn't mean that it IS Gurmat. My question was merely to point out that if having women doing panj dee seva is in line with Gurmat then how come I have heard no evidence of Puratan Singhs doing this? Are you trying to imply that Puratan Singhs didn't know what Gurmat was? I am not saying that women can't do seva of Panj. I'm asking for someone to enlighten me as to why I have never heard of women doing seva of the Panj Pyaray before modern times. CAN ANYONE PLEASE ANSWER THIS QUESTION?? Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 17 May 2005
Dogma Ji, As i have already stated bibiaan have done seva in punj in the past. Who does seva in punjaa dee seva is not talked about much. No one goes around saying "so and so person did punjaa dee seva at the last amritsanchar." If we look at all the purataan singhs, do we have reference to all the singhs that have done seva. The singhs that have done seva in amritsanchars in purataan times are not even remembered today, same goes for bibiaan. It should not matter who the person is, as long at theyare a Khalsa and are tyaar-bar-tyaar. We don't look at the punj pyaaray as a male or female, we look at them as our guru ji.Jamna Singh · 17 May 2005
Khalistani, how do YOU know that puraatan panj pyaras never included women? were YOU THERE? did YOU see puraatan times with your OWN TWO EYES? sikhi is not like Islam or Hinduism which gives women a lower status. In Guru Jees eyes they are equal. If Sikh women can lead armies in battle and give Shaheedia, why should they be discriminated against when doing Panja dhi seva? would you be brave enough to look into Mata Baagh Kaur Jees eyes and tell her that she is not good enough to do seva in the Panj Pyaras? I highly doubt it kall da jamya gallaa kardaa...Dogma · 17 May 2005
Dalraj Kaur Jee, I'm sorry I never read your post before. You stated that in Bhai Sahib Jee's time there was a Singhnee doing Panj Dee Seva. Was this written in one of Bhai Sahibs books? Where did you get this information from? Thanks! Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 17 May 2005
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!! the argument of "didn't happen in puraatan times" can swing both ways. somebody can say there were no Bibis in puraatan amritsanchaars - because there is no proof of such an amrit sanchaar. somebody can say, in response, there is no proof that there WASN'T such an amrit sanchaar - so how can you say for sure, if you weren't there? If a Taksali Singh sees Punj Pyare and one of them is a Bibi, it would not be right for him to "dispell" those Punj Pyare and say they are not authentic. There are a lot of inconsistencies in the argument that "Singh" means "Man" but only in that hukam. In other hukams Guru Sahib has used "Singh" too but for those, anti-Bibi-pyare people say "No that's for all Gursikhs" So there is no good argument AGAINST Bibiaan in the punj pyare. The Bibiaan as punj pyare Amrit Sanchaar has no flaws. People who took khande-ke-pahul in an amrit-sanchaar with Bibiaan still grow up to be beautiful Gursikhs. If you say the original five were men, therefore we must keep men, then the original five were also from India, so does that mean all Punj Pyare worldwide must be from India ?? , etc. etc. these arguments can go on forever and ever at the end of the day it comes to a matter of faith. We don't have faith in our Guru. We are sooooo good at these issues !!!! I am such a moorakh - these posts are so attractive to me!! Moorakhs like me are soooo bad at doing gurbani ucharan but so good at making long argumentative posts!!!! guru sahib kirpa karan please forgive my mistakes vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa VaaheguroojeekeefatehH!!!!!!!!Dogma · 17 May 2005
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa , I dunno singh...it's not that clear cut to me yet. I think I'll have to think on this a bit more. "We are sooooo good at these issues !!!! I am such a moorakh - these posts are so attractive to me!! " ..ditto.khalistani · 17 May 2005
the argument how do u know panj bibis wernt in panj doesnt hold up if they have been since purtaaan times, all these fights, that are occuring RIGHT NOW wud not have happened i have asked every single oldest singhni kno, they dont even know about this debate of bibis in panj this is a new thing and does anyone have proof on bhai randheer singh je allowing this? even if they did countless sants and gurmukh aside from bhai sahib have said no panj bibis all must be singh as per tradtion has been coming down in banee no wehre does it say that men can do everthing women can, and women can do everything men can thas a lie, a comeplete lie it says not to call women bad we arnt calling women bad at all its jsut the tradition of amrit sanchaars coming down just like we use sarbloh only and a khanda, and not kirpans, not katars, only a khanda the tradition of the first amrit sanchaar ha sbeen mantained even bhai nanad lal je says the in amrit sanchaars panch singh amrit jo devai this isnt a general term this is directly talking about amrit sanchaars directly and is telling us how it happens u can spin it anyway u want truth is infront of u and dont tell me this is a purtaan thing, this has started now b bhai randheer singhj es times is no where nea purtaan thas around sant gurbachan singh jes time thas n ot purtaan khalsa maryada thas like 60 year old new maryada this is a new thing ask ANY jatha that has any link with purtaan times nihangs, nirmala, taksal, ANYONE everyone even new dehras like nanaksar, rrara sahib, EVERYONE AGREES ITS ONLY MEN only singhs' this is a useless argument one side is giving banee, and traditon the other side is giving well wat iff, this is wat happened( withouit ANY PROOF WATSOEEVR), using examples of only things that happeend 60 years ago, etc. i guess we must know more than all the countless jeevs sent to earth to save it wat the heck is the point of them coming if u arnt going to listen jagat udhaaran saee ayae jin jan daras pyaasa bhula chuka mafRoopKaur · 17 May 2005
There has never been a Sikh prime minister in Canada or a Sikh President in the US, therefore, using the above logic, Sikhs can never be leaders in the country, because it never occured in puraatan times. Does this make sense? First of all, like mentioned before, the Sikhs that were panj piyarey for each amrit sanchaar are not documented, so you cannot base you whole assumption that bibiaa cannot be panj piyrey on this. Second of all, you should also remember that bibiaa do have to take care of children and had many social pressures against them, and these could be factors which affected this. There is still no solid argument for your opinion khalistani.Sister · 17 May 2005
Only Guru Sahib knows the whole truth! But I believe, if Guru Sahib didn't discriminate on the basis of gender than why should we...Dogma · 17 May 2005
RoopKaur, everyone.. I think it's important that not everyone get on Khalistani for his views. That's his views...whether you like it or not I doubt you will change them. I asked the question about Puraatan times because it was something I was wondering about. Khalistani managed to answer that to the best of his abilities. Dalraj Kaur jee says that Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh did witness women doing seva of panj, however she's gonna tell me where this is written still. However Roopkaur, this argument of yours of regarding social pressures is interesting. I understand that modern views have crept into the workplace and women are slowly being treated equal to men. Sikhi, of course, has always maintained an equality between men and women. But just a quick question...I think that everyone agrees that only able-bodied individuals are allowed to be doing seva of the panj. That is to say, that physically challenged people are not to be doing this seva. If the issue of women and men is about equality, then shouldn't this EQUALITY be UNIVERSAL? Why limit physically challenged people?khalistani · 17 May 2005
exactly wat now? haha im jokin i aint postin in this newmore, so im out the posts above have enough proof bhulka chuka mafSahajbirKaur · 17 May 2005
wjkk wjkf u should know that all of our gurus have said that women(female) and men(male) have the same rights as each other! They said u shouldn't make a difference between them when there is none. This is something that has been discussed before. Now people still ask this. I'm not saying that this not a question to be asked many times but the thing that people talk about this so many times on this site. It has ben discussed at the gudwara many times too and has ben asked many times on the site!! People think just because when guru gobind singh ji gave amrit there were no females that stood up to be one of the panj pyaraa doesn't mean that they can't be one these today. That's all i know!! wjkk wjkfDalrajkaur Khalsa · 17 May 2005
I dont get why Khalistani has such a problem with this issue. Tell me... Who do you consider a Gursikh and a Khalsa? Are singhnee-aa and singh's equal? Can you please provide me with the banee tuk that states that ONLY singhs can do punjaa dee seva and that BIBIAAN are not allowed. You are talking about tradition.....When an amritsanchar is taking place, the punj pyaaray are not male or female, and they are sure not the person that they really are (e.g: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji would not be Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji in an amritsanchaar). The punj pyaaray are guru themselves. This states that it does not matter who you are, as long as you are a KHALSA and tyaar-bar-tyaar. If you want to keep saying that only singhs stood up at that time, and it should be kept the same way. Then the same 5 singhs that stood up should ONLY be able to do punja dee seva. OR the punj has to be the same height as the original punj pyaaray in 1699. There dharee should be the same aswell. I mean that was the original form of the punj pyaaray, so we should keep that tradition don't you think. If you dont want to consider Bhai Sahibs time purtaan then that is fine, that is up to you. But tell me, what proof do you have that bibian did not do seva in punj in purtaan times (from what you consider purtaan times) Also tell me, should bibian be allowed to do akhand paath dee role, and also sit on tabyaa? I mean, a bibi did not write the guru granth sahib ji, and all the guru ji's were male. Also since our guru jis are the ones that wrote bani (which were singhs), should only singhs read bani? Those are just two stupid examples of how stupid it is to say that bibiaan can't do punjaa dee seva. And Dogma Ji, This story was told by Giani Harbhajan Singh Ji of Anandpur Sahib. You can contact him and ask him yourself. He is a purataan singh from Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jis time, and spent alot of time with Bhai Sahib Ji and the Jatha.Dogma · 17 May 2005
" And Dogma Ji, This story was told by Giani Harbhajan Singh Ji of Anandpur Sahib. You can contact him and ask him yourself. He is a purataan singh from Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jis time, and spent alot of time with Bhai Sahib Ji and the Jatha." ..Got his number? hee hee :) I believe you Bhenji, but I thought you were talking about a written source. Do you know if BSB Randheer Singh wrote anything about bibiyan serving as panj?