Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Review of "Bole So Nihal"

Review of "Bole So Nihal"

Singh · 15 May 2005

Could some Sikh-minded person let us know what exactly in this movie "Bole So Nihal" is controversial? Those who have seen this movie, please let us know in detail the anti-Sikhi things in this movie.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 May 2005

First of all the TITLE. IT makes FUN of the Sikh JAIKAARA. It is not acceptable to have the Sikh jaikaara as a title of a film with half naked women in it dancing to filmi tunes adn that has absolutley NOTHING to do with any gurmatt/gursikhi/sikhi principles etc.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

confused · 15 May 2005

just imagine one thing taht i know, your dancing on a beach with half nude girlls saying "bole so nihaal"

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

Kulbir Singh · 15 May 2005

‘Jo Bole...’ director ready to cut scenes Tribune News Service Amritsar, May 15 Bowing to the pressure of Sikh organisations, the director and producer of the controversial film, ‘ Jo Bole So Nihal’ today agreed in principle to accept all recommendations of the 15-member SGPC panel regarding removal of objectionable scenes from the movie. The panel is likely to submit its report by May 19. It is reliably learnt that Rahul Rawail, Director of the film, has conveyed his willingness to accept the recommendations of the panel to Bibi Jagir Kaur, SGPC chief, on telephone today. Mr Himanshu Seth, Public Relations Officer to the Director, told TNS that the producer had no intention to hurt the sentiments of the Sikh community. He said the film was released only after getting a clean chit from Akal Takht. Mr Manmohan Singh, General Manager, Ginnies Arts, the main distributor of the film, said the director and producer of the film were open to suggestions. It is learnt that the director has agreed to change the title of the film even. According to sources, Mr Parmjit Singh Sarna , president, Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee, played a significant role to convince the Director and film distributor in this regard. Meanwhile, the Sikh conclave held at Akal Takht here today, served a five-day ultimatum to stop the screening of controversial film. A resolution passed on the occasion announced that Sikh jathas would march towards the cinema halls to stop the screening of the film on Friday (20 May) in Ludhiana, Sunday (22 May) in Amritsar and Tuesday (May 24) in Jalandhar. Interestingly, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Jathedar, Akal Takht, was not in the city as he had gone to New Delhi to attend some program. The Sikh conclave also sought ‘sacking’ of Mr Charnjit Singh Chadha as president, Chief Khalsa Diwan, for allegedly ensuring a ‘clean chit’ to the controversial film through Jathedar, Akal Takht. However, Mr Chadha has denied this. Earlier, there was little flutter during the conclave when a senior member of the Khalra Mission Committee wanted immediate ‘disowning’ of Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti as Jathedar Akal Takht. The five Sikh bodies Khalsa Panchayat , Dal Khalsa , Khalra Mission Committee ,Sikh Students Federation (Bittu) and Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar) resolved to physically stop the screening of the controversial film in case the Punjab government did not do so by Thursday. Mr Rajinder Singh, chairman of the Khalsa Panchayat, and Mr Kanwarpal Singh , general secretary, Dal Khalsa, asked the government to withdraw the cases registered against Sikh youths for demonstrating against the film in various parts of the state. Prominent amongst those who present included Bhai Ram Singh, Daya Singh Khakar, Anoop Singh Sandhu,Jagir Singh Wadala, all SAD (A) leaders, Dr Daljit Singh of Dal Khalsa, Mr Charanjit Singh Channi of Khalsa Panchayat, Mr Jaspal Singh Manjpur and Mr Prabsharanbir Singh from Sikh Students Federation (Bittu).

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

Kulbir Singh · 15 May 2005

Badungar wants film banned Our Correspondent Phagwara, May 15 Demanding ban on Hindi film “Jo Bole So Nihal”, Prof Kirpal Singh Badungar, former SGPC president and member of the Political Affairs Committee of the SAD today blamed intelligence agencies for their failure to give a prior intimation to government about the flare up that the screening of the film would cause and to advise it about the required remedial steps in the form of not screening the film at all. Talking to newsmen here before addressing a congregation at nearby village Narur, he also attributed the present situation to the Congress-led Central government’s continued apathy to Sikh sentiments and issues. “Jo Bole So Nihal” was a universally accepted religious war slogan of the Sikhs and it had been blasphemed by the film by using it for the purpose of a commercial title, remarked Prof Badungar. The film also had several objectionable scenes that hurt the religious sentiments of the Sikhs, he said. He cited the scene of a “paath” in which the person reciting hymns from holy Guru Granth Sahib was not “sabat surat” (baptised) Sikh as was mandatory as per Sikh maryada. The film should be banned before the situation went out of control, Prof Badungar said. Its ongoing screening in cinemas should be stopped forthwith, he demanded. He termed as unfortunate the delay in starting bus service between Amritsar and Nankana Sahib, the birthplace of Guru Nanak Dev. The decision to launch this new Indo-Pak bus had been postponed for six months, causing disappointment among Sikhs and those Punjabis who had been separated by Partition, he rued. Prof Badungar flayed the Central government for not properly taking up with French and Danish governments the issue of ban on turban in France and punishing a student in Denmark for carrying sword, both religious symbols of Sikhs. Prof Badungar later addressed a congregation at Narur village in celebration of the tercentenary martyrdom of 40 “muktas” (liberated ones).

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

Singh · 16 May 2005

seems like very few people have seen the film in the first instance. Who actually on this site has really seen it.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

can't think of a name.. · 16 May 2005

I might watch it, will let you know what I think if I do.. [%sig%]

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

informd · 16 May 2005

the first thing is that this movie is an attempt to take the piss out of the sikhs on the cover sunny deol is shown wearing an indian army uniform and sticking his middle finger out at sikhs its an attempt to take the piss out of sikhs sikhs need to take some action where they can hold there heads up with pride this is what sant ranjit singh is doing with the gatherings of thousands of sangat it makes the sikhs proud of there heritage with the khalsa cheta marches and glory of the punj pyaras. sant ranjit singh did explain this...

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

A Singh · 14 Apr 2006

The name of the film is "Jo Bole So Nihal". In the film Sunny Deol plays the character Nihal Singh, which means "What ever Nihal Singh Says". In other words it is like trying to promote double standards at the cost of Sikh panth. Above all Sunny Deol with trim beard and dancing around with half naked women looks disgusting. So banning the movie is justified.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

a singh · 15 Apr 2006

maybe if stupid singhs and kaurs stopped watching movies 1/2 of the problem would be gone. no viewers = less money = no more funny movies about sikhs. it is against guru gobind singhs haukam to go watch filthy movies, make that all movies.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

Sardar · 20 Apr 2006

i remember this one part form the movie when sunny deol's mother tells sunny that "Nanak Naam Zahaaz Hai, Jo Chare So Utre Paar", meaning that Nanak's Name is like a plane, whoever gets on it, he gets Mukti. So just when sunny deols mother says this sentence or phrase to sunny, a helicopter comes down, making fun of Gurbani because it talks about how Nanak's Name is like a plane.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

i've seen it and what a waste! · 02 May 2006

actually its not just the name that is the problem. there is a female 'officer' in the movie who is also supposedly sikh but she cuts her hair, wears bikinis and struts around half naked. sunny has double standards. his mother in the film wears a kirpan but sunny lets the female officer into his room at night - half dressed. there is is a song in the movie with the films title in it. furthermore after a drunken night (i think a drunken night... i didn't really pay attention to it...personally i was disgusted but determined to see what the fuss what about) he actually sleeps with the female officer and afterwards he is seen 'coming up for air' from under the blanket and his turban is still on his head but askew....as if it wear a baseball cap and not a turban. to top this all off he says he is a sacha sikh and uses verses from the guru granth sahib...actually so does his mother...but he's made an 'ullo' out of himself at every given moment. all in all it was a total waste of time but i thought it would be better for me to pass judgment on it once i actually knew what was being said was fact or fiction. personally this would never have gotten hand if a sikh member was part of the censer board. bhul chuk maak......kaur.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

just me · 02 May 2006

i think it is the most disqusting movie to watch for a sikh. i dont know why the filmy (india) channel keeps on showing again and again this **** and my family sits and watch it all the time. aggggrrrrrrrrr

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

J.A.T.T · 02 May 2006

a singh: Are you suggesting that Sikhs should boycott Bollywood movies? If so, then it's not going to make a big difference because majority of people who watch Bollywood movies are not even Sikhs/Punjabis.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

Freshy · 04 May 2006

J.A.T.T wrote: > a singh: Are you suggesting that Sikhs should boycott > Bollywood movies? > > If so, then it's not going to make a big difference because > majority of people who watch Bollywood movies are not even > Sikhs/Punjabis. sorry to inform u J.A.T.T. the States that determine whether a film is a hit or not is Panjab and Haryana, they have the most people that go to cinemas to watch these rubbish films.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

J.S. Sandhu Canadawala · 04 May 2006

"Could some Sikh-minded person let us know what exactly in this movie "Bole So Nihal" is controversial?" ----------------------------------- When I first heard all the commotion about this flick I decided that I had to buy my own copy of the movie and went out the very same day and bought it with the title as Jo Bole So Nihal. I bought it when it first released. There are some things that are offensive in his movie but not many. It is a poorly done bollywood movie for the most part. The movie is done in a way where there is a stereotypical Jatt (played by Sunny Deol) whose name happens to be Nihal. He is not very smart. They also equate Sikhs with Jatts being the same thing. The controversial stuff can be list as the following: -blacks, whites and others saying 'jo bole so nihal'. -There are some off colour remarks about sex in Punjabi. For example one person is saying FAX and the other thinks its SEX. or one scene where Sunny Deol says 'Hor Keel Haal Hai' where he actually means 'Whore Keel Haal Hai' etc. -There is a sex scene between Sunny Deol and the leading actress. -The line about 'No If..No But..Sirf Jatt'. While I myself don't find this controversial some people have made this out to be a caste issue. The Line is one that Sunny Deol's character in the movie says a few times when he's with the leading actress. - Showing Jatts and/or Sikhs as being not very smart people Most people probably won't have much of a problem with the movie except that where it talks about sex and other topics it also tries to mix in religious themes and songs of Sikhs. The actual religious footage in the film is very little other than the title song. The movie itself is nothing special. The flick is partly shot in Punjab and mostly the US although Punjabi is used in many scenes, this film is in Hindi. The story is nothing special. Yes a good part of it is shot in the US but other than that there is nothing really great about the movie.

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

J.A.T.T · 04 May 2006

Freshy: You can back up your statement with proof/evidence? Anyway, the movie was banned in Punjab while rest of the world got to watch the movie. If wasn't for the bombings, then the movie would have made a lot of money regardless if the movie was banned or not in Punjab because a lot of people living outside of India (in large numbers) watch bollywood movies as well. Also a lot of people buy bollywood movie soundtracks too. ---------------------------------------------------- I know this is a little off topic, but people need to realize Bollywood is popular in the west.............. “In the last few years, many Bollywood movies have begun to do remarkably well at the box office in countries like England and America. As a result, the money from overseas sales is now a significant part of the total income that any movie makes. In some movies, the overseas income is as high as 70-80 per cent of the income from India. But the actual income that producers get from overseas sales is in fact just a fraction of what they should. Piracy of Bollywood movies in England and America is so widespread that it is estimated to cause a loss of over 40 per cent of all overseas sales.” http://www.ndtv.com/morenews/showmorestory.asp?slug=Bollywood+battles+piracy+in+the+West&id=49393 [%sig%]

Re: Review of "Bole So Nihal"

jibble jabble · 18 May 2006

Sanagt Ji i wanted to ask a question... well actually its more of a comment but theres a question somewhere in der.... i think Taking the behzti issue or even this film issue... alot of people argue these things should not happen because they dissing sikhs.... but as we have seen many of these things are done by 'sikhs'.... therefore it is quite difficult to justify why a play cannot show a murder in a gurdvara, or a 'sikh' guy dancing wit women doing jakaare cos it happens..... so where is the problem... shud we be doing something about the people that dnt allow us to use the above argument (ie like knocking off chamkila as i read in a diff topic...sorting out the peeps that dance.. wit girls and wit sikhi saroop..etc) or do we say that the things portrayed are not in line with Sikhi and the people doing them are not Sikhs.... if this is the case where does this leave monai(non-kesdhaaries) and in broader sence, those that dnt stick to rehit and non-amritdharis in general? Do we try to highlight Khalsa Panth which has a lot less negativities associated with it in terms of what people may think when hearing 'Sikh' or 'Khalsa' Im gona sort of go off topic even more now...thus if or when Khalsistan is formed what difference will there be between Khalistan and any strict arab country.... because strictly dirty songs even shudnt be allowed... or will these laws only be for sikhs... or will each group have their own laws eg muslim and shariah law, sikh and rehit marayda....?? Please forgive me, cos i no ive made little sinse.. but if anyone can get my drift any sort of comments that can clear up my confusion would be helpfull... ps sorry for sort of going off topic....