Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh scholars want heritage site status for Harmandar Sahib

Sikh scholars want heritage site status for Harmandar Sahib

Kulbir Singh · 15 May 2005

Sikh scholars want heritage site status for Harmandar Sahib Sarbjit Dhaliwal Tribune News Service Chandigarh, May 15 Two Sikh scholars — Dr Kharak Singh and Mr Gurdev Singh — who are associated with the Institute of Sikh Studies, have said that there will be benefits in seeking world heritage site status for Harmandar Sahib from UNESCO. In a signed statement sent to The Tribune, the scholars stated that though the executive committee of the SGPC had already taken a decision to withdraw the dossier that was submitted to UNESCO to seek heritage site status, it should be reviewed at the level of Panth that included various Sikh organisations besides the SGPC. “The decision regarding the dossier cannot be left to the SGPC alone. It should be discussed and decided at the level of Panth”, said the scholars. In the past three decades, Sikhs had faced important issues. However, no proper attention was given to those issues at the Panthic level. Owing to this there had been an increase in the problems of Sikhs. In fact, the two scholars said that the proposed international Sikh confederation should be set up soon to deliberate on the issues which had importance for the entire Panth. They said the Panth should decide whether the decision to withdraw the dossier was right. There would be no harm if Harmandar Sahib was enlisted as a world heritage site. In fact, if Harmandar Sahib had been recognised as such a site before 1984, the government would not have dared to order “Operation Bluestar” there, they said. If the non-Sikh population of the world wanted to give heritage site status to Harmandar Sahib and was ready to declare it as heritage of the entire world, the Sikhs should take pride in it, they added. There was nothing objectionable in it and the Sikhs would lose nothing. The apprehension that UNESCO’s control would be established once Harmandar Sahib was declared a heritage site was wrong. There were several religious places of various communities on the heritage list of UNESCO, they added. The control would remain with the SGPC. The two scholars said that they were of the opinion that the necessary corrections should be made in the dossier. “ The decision to withdraw the dossier by rejecting it in toto cannot be justified”, they added. “ It appears that the dossier has been rejected in haste without discussing the issue fully. It would have been better if the entire Panth had been taken into confidence”, they said. “ A conclave of various Panthic organisations should have been convened to take the appropriate decision”. Such a conclave could be held even now.

Re: Sikh scholars want heritage site status for Harmandar Sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. What "scholars"....?? Dr Kharak Singh has written not a single ORIGINAL book/Paper or done any research on Sikhi/Gurmatt/gurbani. I am not sure about the other one....he is an IAS officer..which doesnt make him a schoalr. The IOSS as it stands is no better than a just a HATH THOKA of the badal clique...it follows what badal and co. says to the letter. Dr. Gurdarshan Singh Dhillon has ceased to be an active associate! For the last 5-6 years, it is managed by few persons like IAS Gurdev Singh, Dr. Kharak Singh, Dr. Kirpal Singh, Bhai Ashok Singh Bagaria, Maj Gen Jaswant Singh, Brig Hardit Singh and rest for quorum purpose only. Dr. Kharak Singh has not written any original Book on Sikh Faith except editing others works or compiling presentations during annual seminars. They are now working under the directions of film directors like SAD President or his stooges. Hence the current newsitem is as if they were sleeping like Kumbhkaran and now awakened as it was still pending without their participation. They have now Sellers of their Quarterly Magazine and old books. Such so called Sikh scholars are equally guilty like fake leaders and derawallahs....for pushing Sikhe into the pit it now finds itself in... After everyone around the world lobbied to get this Dossier WITHDRAWN....these schoalrs now jump in and want to restart the whole sick episode once more...

Re: Sikh scholars want heritage site status for Harmandar Sahib

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 16 May 2005

Sorry, guys, that was long ago, when the dossier was rejected.....you should have set up your alrm at least to get up in time....who made them scholars?They themselves assumed they are scholars???More pertinently, I believ they are no scholars or scholars of Sikh religion. Real Sikh scholars are sitting on the shelves, and being pilloried by the mass section of the Sikh community. Let us review the picture a few weeks back ....all over the world there was a huge cry against this dossier, exxpcially by the Diaspora Sikhs.Suddenly, very cruelly Sikhs woke to realise the under hand tactics being used by the so called custodians of the Sikh institutions to push through this unread, un related and totally misrepresentated dossier, basically pawn the entire Sikh history and destiny into the hands iof a state-whose history shows far greater portion of unfriendliness/aggression than anything else to the Sikh kaum. Fingers of accusations started pointing at others, and against each other.it sudenly emerged that no one Sikh had actually read the dossier...and to add the salt to injury no one even knew whose original idea it was or what it contained at all...... to a degree Kiranjot Kaur was accused of being the "brains"(somebody ougth to explain the meaning of brainy brains to the Sikh clergy ), it is amazing even she finally admited that she did not know what it contained ...as R4,000,000 had been paid for some one to think about it all and put together for "THEM"-them meaning the BIG SHOTS of the SGPC ......can I just remind you all this is happening in the Punjab ,chandigarh is merely 180 kilometres from amritsar ......and THESE SCHOLARS WERE SILENT THEN .....suddenly when the water has gone under the bridge....though some still dont know what actually is the state of affairs with this dossier.because to withdraw it ..is within the realm of the indian government .... .........SUDDENLY they have AWOkEN up .......and want to rewrite the history of the dossier scandal as it suits them .......not as the facts state .....I would say with scholars of such quality.....they may just be good enough to be washed into the rains drains ......with the rest of the sewerage !I can provide a jet pump for that if you like ?