Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Panj Pyare

Panj Pyare

Mkhalsa · 20 Aug 2003

Waheguroo jee ka khalsa waheguroo jee kee fateh I dont know if this is a concern, or if anyone else noticed it, but lately i have noticed what i think is a dangerous trend. After amrit sanchaars, a lot of times newly initiated ones go and ask the people who were in panj individually for clarification on something. Many times, I have seen that many gursikhs will turn back on what they said when they were in panj.. such as if someone approaches them asking, "do i have to keep bibek?" they were clearly told by panj that they have to, but they ask an individual later, and the response they get is "try your best, if you cant, you cant" or sometimes they will say things like you dont have to wash your hair everyday, "it doesnt matter" or other minor things. But isnt this wrong? they are contradicting the panj, and the seeker is trying to get an easy way out by saying one of hte panj told me so.. what does sangat think of this? --Daas

Re: Panj Pyare

domalla premee · 21 Aug 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh An individual in the Panj Peeare infront of Guru becomes a part of the normal sangat once that person leaves that role. That person must pay attention to the instructions as they are given when they take amrit and follow them. During the Amrit Sanchaar, a tremendous currency of blessing and instruction is given to the initiate. The question is now, how does one invest or spend this currency? Is it used to further spiritual growth or frittered away in ego. Who do we follow, the Guru or our self made excuses? If the person really did not hear then he or she needs to ask other seekers who were there but no longer the individual sevaks who were in the Panj. Those who have done the seva need to remember their position in the sangat, they are no longer in that role and they need to humbly reflect the question or concern back to the questioner and take themselves completely out of the equation. Hope this helps a bit. dass

Re: Panj Pyare

sblk · 21 Aug 2003

"But isnt this wrong? they are contradicting the panj, and the seeker is trying to get an easy way out by saying one of hte panj told me so.." If the seeker asks the individual after the amrit sinchaar has concluded, then that individual is no longer "one of the punj". Thus what they say holds no real significance in light of what the punj pyaaray instructed the seekers to do. The instructions of the punj pyaaray, as the punj pyaaray, are supreme. "Domalla Premee" has summed it up quite well above by stating that those being asked need to remember that they are no longer in the position of the punj.

Re: Panj Pyare

Singh · 21 Aug 2003

I completely agree with SBLK And I would also like to add that any of the Punj Singhs who would give clarification would recognize that they were no longer part of the punj, and would just be giving advice as a normal gursikh would give. It's a shame some of the people who take amrit sometimes misinterpret what those Gursikhs say to not follow hukams of Guru Sahib.

Re: Panj Pyare

Mkhalsa · 21 Aug 2003

Thank you for your replies. This is what I was thinking. So I just wanted to raise awareness that if you have done this seva, please make it clear if you ever do clarify something that you are not a part of the panj anymore and its your personal opinion, or just say panj have told you already. I think thats best solution.

Re: Panj Pyare

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 22 Aug 2003

Waheguru ji ak khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. IMHO MKhalsa is right. The PANJ Piyarae are PP when in a group. After that they are individuals. Recently when the Head Granthi of Akal takhat Bhai Balwant Singh ( i am not sure the name is right) was relieved of his duties due to old age, He came out with a Statement in the Press that as a Panj Piyara of the Akal takhat, his "advice" was not followed by the jathedar when making decisions.....in other words he was saying he DISAGREED with certian decisions of the Panj Piyarae while he was a member but reluctantly agreed to majority decision. So the decision of the jathedar was NOT UNANIMOUS. This is also a new "thing" ?? Does the decision announced by the Jathedar have to be UNANIMOUS or can it be 3 - 2, 4 - 1, or in case of a TIE can the Jathedar cast a VETO VOTE. This is not an honourable thing. What the Panj do in PRIVATE should REMAIN PRIVATE ??? I am confused as well. Are we mixing "democracy" human rights etc notions with religion and spirituality ?? You tell me. Collective responsibility ?? dassan dass jarnail singh arshi gyani