Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Hawyein = Propoganda

Hawyein = Propoganda

Charanjit Singh T.O. · 24 Aug 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I went to see this movie, to see how Bollywood portrayed the Sikhs, I came out of the movie not impressed at all. There are some points of the movie that annoyed me. * After the attack on Harmandir Sahib, our main character in the movie was busy chasing girls, dancing, and singing. I dont care where you were living, Operation Blue Star was a traumatic event. I will reckon to say that Sikhs were not dancing and chasing women, that was the least of their concerns, especially the ones that lived in India. I know that it is a movie and they need a stroy line, but stick to facts. * The depiction of the riots that massacred many innocent SIkhs living in Delhi was to the most part portrayed accurately. * I was quite surprised to see many Sikhs reacting in shock and sorrow after the Gandhis assassination, didnt they forget the attack she orchestrated on SIkhs. My bad, the Sikhs that lead the uprising where terrorists and bad men, they had it coming. * I am not going to say that there were not Kharkoos that took advantage of the situation and started to loot, threaten, and rape helpless SIkhs. But to say these Sikhs wanted Khalistan is obsurd. These SIkhs could care less for the movement, they were in it for power and money. In the movie the kharkoo sikhs worked alongside some muslim fanatic and wanted Khalistan. In the movie itself, it decribed those that wanted Khalistan as terrorists and terrible people. Far from the truth. Those that founded and died for the movement were nothing more than terrorists and criminials as far as the movie goes. The movie to me was comical and inaccurate, and did not do justice to SIkhs. First off, if you want to do a movie, of the events of 84 and after, stick to the facts, and make it a type of docu-drama. Secondly, the india censor board must be happy with the final product. If anything can be learnt from this, is that Gurdwara committees, businessmen, etc. must come together, raise money and approach a Western Director to tell the masses what really happened to Sikhs. These movies have no place in the market, if anything, they cease to misinform the public, and children that know nothing about 84, are sent to believe that India protected its country from bad terrorists. Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh

Re: Hawyein = Propoganda

domalla premee · 25 Aug 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh This is right. You cannot expect anyone to hand you good publicity about who the Sikhs are or wait for the other guy to do it. The community must invest in itself and speak for itself. I hope we have learned something from this. Those of you of university age consider a career in journalism, cinema and the multi-media world so that you may have the tools to do just that. Those of you looking for opportunity to give back to your community please do consider investing in counteracting such negative feedback and accurately portraying the great heritage of our Gurus. dass

Re: Hawyein = Propoganda

Knower · 25 Aug 2003

only "Matches" by Gulzar was a good movie on the Sikh militants...

Re: Hawyein = Propoganda

uk singh · 26 Aug 2003

Jarnail Singh never once called for "Khalistan", he was more interested in fighting for basic human rights and equality as per the Anandpur Sahib Resolution (Matta). Many authors have incorrectly assumed that Sant Ji, asserted the need for an independent state (even Cynthia Mahmood) Khalistan was declared in 1987.

Re: Hawyein = Propoganda

jindjaanpunjaaaaaab · 26 Aug 2003

if sikhs of the uk can raise 17 million for southall gurdwara and 10 million for the newly proposed glasgow gurdwara in just one country alone thats 27 mill why cant sikhs of the world get together for a common cause and put their money towards a publicity project and make a proper film on sikhs? it can be done if we sort ourselves out.

Re: Hawyein = Propoganda

jindjaanpunjaaaaaab · 26 Aug 2003

machis was gud to an extent but again that messed up when they showed scenes of singhs causing blasts on bus stands. i doubt true amritdhari singhs do dat and its a fact the black cat commandos disguised as sikhs to discredit the sikhs did just that. i guess every movement has its bad apples but rather than show scenes like that what about sikhs defending their rights and of others in gallant ways such as avtar singh brahma gurcharan singh monochahal etc. that scene with the bus stand just took the balance of a sikh grievancve away in portrayal and made sikhs look like terrorists.