Re: Panj Pyare?
wannabesingh · 06 Jun 2005
i think its possible i mean look, guru gobind singh ji is JYOT, right - guru is a jyot, and perhaps that jyot will refuse to enter in punj pyare who do not keep rehit
Re: Panj Pyare?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Jun 2005
Dear Anon Jio,
The sceanrio you present CANNOT HAPPEN.
The Panj DO SHUDHAII of EACH OTHER... so an "unqualified" memeber cannot pass this shudhaii..and thus cannot be a PANJ..unless you are saying ALL the Panj are unqualified and they lie to each other about shudhaii ?? This is NOt right. This is an unwarranted attack on the panj system/Shudhaii safeguards are present to weed out unft.
Re: Panj Pyare?
Harpreet Singh · 07 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Anon wrote:
> Together they are considered Guru Ji himself.
I just have a point to make here. Many among us feel and think that 5 are guru ji. Please correct me if I am wrong, Panj, in presence of Guru Granth Sahib are the full authority of true Guruship during amrit sanchaar (Panth + Granth).
I don't think that even 5 pooran gursikhs can equate to Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib is only one i.e. Guru Granth Sahib. But yes Panj in presence of Guru Sahib have full authority as of a Guru. In absence of Guru sahib this authority is not full.
Does anyone wants to comment on this?
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Panj Pyare?
Amritpal Singh · 07 Jun 2005
Veer Harpreet Singh makes a very good point.
Just wanted to add, in absence of Larrivaar Sarooop the panj authority is not full either.
It is lacking......lacking Guru Granth Sahib Jee.
Re: Panj Pyare?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 08 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.
Veer Tarunjeet Singh Jio,
A MILLION "mistakes"..even if taken as NOT MISTAKE (right)..DO not make it RIGHT.
The Very FIRST and Most Fundamental mistake we as the Panth comitted was to accept the pad-chhedd roop as GURU and discarded the Laridaar sroop Original.
Then we COMPOUNDED this first mistake by having Amrit Sanchaars in the Presence of the pad chhedd sroop.
What was the "reason" for Pad-chhedd ? To make reading easier, learning gurbani easier. THIS could have been done by publishing Padd-chhedd GUTKAS/POTHIS alongside Laridaar gutkas/POTHIS. In this way students of Gurbani could LEARN Gurbani on Padd-chhedd...and then progress to laridaar. This sort of thing happens through out the "educational " world..We have "simplified" books for Class 1, kindergartens, and then slowly the books get tougher..BUT no one in his right mind discards the "tough" books in favour of the simplified versions...and just use this simplified version ONLY...as we have DONE. Each and Every PURATAN handwritten Sroop is LARIDAAR.....now a laridaar sroop is as difficult to find as bird's milk !!! Every Gurdwara in malaysia/Singapore/Thailand/Indonesia has Pad-chhedd only...and i doubt any Granthi/Paathi would be comfortable reading from a Laridaar sroop. Any Laridaar Sroops left over from the old days are Perpetually kept on SUKHASAN..as there is no point in parkash them as no one can read even the hukmnama from them.
The Laridaar is the Original Guur sroop and the Pad-chhedd is Man Made sroop. You make your own conclusion.
Now to further compound this already bad situation....many are coming out with calls fro "re-writign and rediting" Guru garnth ji sahib to REMOVE all those extra siharees and biharees aunkarrs etc WHICH these nincompoops think are NOT NECESSARY/UNPRONOUNCED...and the Biggest NINCOMPOOPS of all the DGMC parbhandaks gave a Grant of a few MILLIONS to a super nincompoop of an idiot a Madrassi called BHANU MOORTEE who took money of SANGAT and MUTILATED SROOPS of GURU JI by PHYSICALLY CUTTING OUT with a RAZOR BLADE all those "unnecessary siharees and aunkarrs etc". I go on the Forums daily and in many of them so called "modern sikhs" are calling on this rewriting thing with vigour...while others are calling for Guru Granth ji's in ENGLISH and other languages to be declared EQUAL GURU ( for those who DONT WANT to learn GURMUKHI SCRIPT)..
SEE where this pad-chhedd road is leading towards....??? Danger bells should be ringing..
Re: Panj Pyare?
Harpreet Singh · 08 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
True said Giani Ji.
This is a fact that currently we have lost our true guru. But I am of the view that bani is bani. No matter if it is just one akhar "In oankaar" or any other.
There are lot of times people say that pad ched saroop nu matha na teko and so on. I think this is disgrace. Well singhs, we should respect every piece of bani. "Matha te nitnem de gutke nu vi teko".
Bani is bani after all. Yes Ladivaar saroop is the true and complete guru. Daas has parkaash of Ladivaar saroop of Guru sahib here at our residence.
There are many pathis who are very well known in local circles here about their speed when doing akhand path roll. One of them by chance visited our home during some keertan program. Dass asked him to do the seva of taking hukam after samapti. To everyone's surprise that singh wasn't able to read. He started looking up down and got caught in a situation where he couldn't do anything. Imagine getting caught in a situation like this. You are well known pathi and you fail to read hukam in front of all the local sangat. In the end daas ended standing by his side to complete the hukamnama.
Do we want to reach a phase where we are unable to face our "BAAPU"?
Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak
Daas,
Harpreet Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Panj Pyare?
Amritpal Singh · 08 Jun 2005
Veer Tauranjeet
So in your opinion any amrit sanchar that has taken place without laridaar saroop is not valid???
Yes, thats what my opinion is. The Jot of Guru Sahib was not at that amrit sinchaar. There is only one jot of Guru Sahib and that is in the form of larivaar saroop Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee.
Guru Sahib has only one light, one jot. If you take two different Pad-chedd saroops and put them beside each other, you can CLEARLY see differences. No two different padd-chhed saroops by different publishers match with each other. So which one out of the two different pad-chedds is YOUR guru??
Do you just pick one one day and then another day you pick another?
One light. One jot. ONE sarroop
In the amrit sinchaars without Larrivaar saroop there was no jot of Guru SAhib present.
Re: Panj Pyare?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 08 Jun 2005
Author: Tarunjeet
Date: 06-08-05 06:34
would the laridaar saroop have to be hand written also ???<<<<<
NO. There are PRINTED LARIDAAR SROOPS.
WHY would we want to insist on handwritten ?? Then somebody may ask..do we have to use the Same paper too ?? or do we have to make the ink the same way too ??
GURU JI JYOT is NOT in the handwriitng, the paper, the ink....the GURU JYOT is in LARIDAAR STYLE of writing GURBANI.
We can PRINT, we can use the latest Art Paper, the latest non-smudgeable inks, the latest beautiful FONTS...in fact make an attempt to make GURU Ji as beautiful as we like... JUST BE LARIDAAR.
Re: Panj Pyare?
domalla premee · 08 Jun 2005
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
Just to remind everyone. Pad ched saroop did not start getting printed on a MASS SCALE till the late 60's or early 70's. Perhaps someone has the exact date however that is what I have been told bo some older Gursikhs. This is to remind everyone how quiclky Padched rose in popularity and how quick people were to discard the original saroop of their Gurus for this new version replete with countless printed mistakes and all. There are numerous printers who rush print and different types of mistakes in each printer's version.
Also,what have we done by altering Gurujee's saroop? The Guruship was bestowed by the 19th Guru on Guru Granth Sahib and the essense of all ten is thereby contained. Gurujee is not simply an academic work that can be edited to fit the times. There are things like going from horses to cars that change but the scriptures of our Gurus are not one of them.
Gurujee is a live being not merely words on a page. We are just blind to this reality because we see a printed book and nothing else. What is stopping us from learning to read the original scripture? I mean what really is? What excuse can we possibly conjure up? Fear that it is so incredibly hard? Laziness? Conveniece? Those of us who fear why not set fear asside and apply ourselves and learn how to read the original spricture by starting reading circles in various cities. It is not so hard as people fear. Besides as you start reading something wonderful happens. Gurujee starts revealing His kirpa in subtle ways and He teaches you and opens doors. Gurujee is not simply a book.
Laziness? No time? Convenience? For example how about cutting back fruitless persuits like chatting on the net for hours on end, and decrease TV and video games and devoting some time to learn? All it takes is rethinking and reorganizing priorities. If one's spiritual life takes the front seat then the ship sails in the right direction. If it takes a back seat, as an afterthought, then the ship of our lives sails rudderless.
f we are to keep Gurujee's Saroop in the home then it should be Lareevaar only. When there are Sikh ceremonies, Amirt Sanchaar and keertans, only original Saroop (Lareevaar) should be present. Then the powers that be need to be pressured to stop printing Padched altogether.
Nothing is personal here. I am simply asking you to consider what is possible. Please forgive me is I have offended anyone.
dass
Re: Panj Pyare?
Bijla Singh · 09 Jun 2005
"True Guru is lost"
All this time I thought Sikhs were lost from the path of Sikhi. Now, I know the true Guru is missing. So how many Gursikhs we have in the world who took "real" Amrit? let's see. tapoban and .... who else? couple here and there. rest who keep rehat and do Naam Simran in Amrit Vela are just pakhandees and not pooran Gursikhs because the Amrit they took is not "real". totally makes sense. then I guess a person can go to tapoban after doing bajjar kurehats and not get any tankhah if his first Amrit Sanchaar didn't take place in the hazoori of Laridaar saroop? Dhan Sikhi. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Panj Pyare?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Veer GURUVAH jio,
Read my post carefully....I didnt say there are NO laridaar sroops in malaysia. I said THERE ARE NO LARIDAAR SROOPS PARKASH in malaysian Gurdwaras..as even the Granthis and Gyanis CANNOT do paath on them. In fact the SROOP parkash at my house/my brother's house/ and my two sister's houses are all LARIDAAR and have always been laridaar.
My post above states: <>
I stay in SELAYANG....and i know for a FACT that NO GURDWARA in the Klang Valley PARKASH Laridaar sroops. ( In one or two places, the parbhandaks just take out the laridaar sroops for "airing" and this sroop is parkash at the side BUT all the Actual paath/Hukmnama/Akhand Paaths/Sehaj paaths etc is performed on the MAIN SROOP in the centre.
I distinctly remember a long long time ago when I was in Form Three and durign the December school vacation, a friend from KUALA PILAH contacted my dad and told them to send me as a short term "granthi" as their granthi had gone on holiday. When I arrived in Kuala Pilah, i met a self proclaimed "granthi" ( retired policeman) who was not too hapy that i had come to take away his "job". He gathered a few sangat memebers and told them he wanted to TEST me. There were TWO sroops parkash and in a hurry he occupied the tabiyaah of one and told me to take a Waak from the other sroop. The sroop that I read the vaak from was a Laridaar sroop and the one he was tabiah was a pad chhed sroop. Guru Ji's kirpa i had learn the paath well and sroop made no difference to me..but to him it was. He then Read out Barahmah on his sroop and told me to read out Vadhans Allahnniah. All went well. The NEXT MORNING, I switched the position of the sroops wehn I parkash them. As usual, he brought along his cronies and announced we will continue the TEST today. He occupied his usual position and announced to the sangat that he would read out Slok Sahskriti...and I would then follow up with Bhatt Swaiyahs. Till TODAY i remeber the TOTAL SHOCK on his face when he removed the rumalla and saw that he was tabiah of the laridaar sroop....surreptiously he tried to signal to me to change positions wth him, pretended to "look" for his spectacles, looking into this pocket and that...fumbling all over. I refused to budge and pretended not to notice. ...you know the rest.... that was the slowest and most jerky sloks i ever heard in my life..while on barra mahn he was going at supersonic speed..
I wonder IF the Gurbani Classes of the Sant Attar Singh Brahm Vidya Niketan that are going on in Tatat Khalsa are in LARIDAAR or Pad chhed ?? or the Sroop they parkash at their HQ are Laridaar or pad chhed ? I DONT EXPECT anyone else or any Gurdwaraa in Malaysia to have or teach Laridaar paath/or parkash laridaar sroops. If any veer or sewadaar from them could inform or enlighten us it would be great.
I am very Glad that the AKJ are in the forefront to restore the Rightful Position of the Laridaar sroop. All others who teach GURBANI should ensure they only "teach" on padchhed..BUT Final Paath should be on lariddaar.
Re: Panj Pyare?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Sewadaars of Sant Attar Singh Brahm Vidya Niketan....?? i asked ??
<<<
Re: Panj Pyare?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Dear AKD jio,
Thank you Jio. Warm regards and stay in Charrdeekala ji.
jarnail Singh.
Re: Panj Pyare?
Manjit kaur · 18 Jun 2005
NO RESPONSE from official sources of the Sant Attar Singh Brahm Vidya Niketan..on a simple query on Lariddar sroop.
Exposes their hollowness and claims to Gurbani Shudh paath Parchaar and Damadmai Taksaal maryada etc...as thet dare not even admit that they rely on Pad-chhed sroops.
We know it is NOT EASY to do paath on laridaar...and if you cant do it..its understandable...BUT if such an AUGUST and HIGH sounding NAME of a BRAHMGYANI is to be used....then the least they can do is USe the Laridaar and have at least the Granthi at their HQ know this Paath....MORE effort goes into Having a Large parkash of Japji sahib to accompany an Akahnd Paath !!!! ( this Pothi of japji Sahib is as big as the Guru sroop and Parkash at the Same Level...and BOTH pathis sit side by side..one reads akhand paath, the other reads japji !!