Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Sikhi · 08 Jun 2005

Sat Sri Akaal, I read and hear sometime that when Bahadur Singh got well known in Punjab he began to see himself as the 11th Guru of the Sikh Panth. Singhs even turn Fateh in something else. Is this really true? Because this shaheed was tortured so badly that only true GurSikhs can take.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

................. · 08 Jun 2005

he was a true gursikhs all the time. These stories were made up brahmin writer to give him a bad name.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

singh · 08 Jun 2005

shaheed amar khalsa jarnail baba gurbakhsh "banda" singh bahadur jee was the first jarnail of the khalsa panth and he was an amazing sant-sipahi. yes, he had some small weaknesses in some aspects, and some of his followers began to make a different sect away from the panth, but this was stopped after amar khalsa shaheed gyani bhai sahib bhai mani singh jee intervened. baba jee gave his life for sikhi and also his wife and son became shaheed for the cause of sikhi. anybody can make mistakes, surely we have made thousands more than baba jee. [%sig%]

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

S Singh · 08 Jun 2005

This is all brahmin inspired history for you. As public enemy once said "Dont believe the hype".

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

yo yo · 08 Jun 2005

anyone who can watch his sons liver being torn and put into his mouth with his own body tortured for the khalsa panth with no signs of pain or anguish, inspiring hundreds of other sikhs to jump forward one before the other for shahadat cannot be a bad guy.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ssingh · 08 Jun 2005

there was a discussiion on sikhnet about how banda bahadurs forces killed innocents = ripping babies out of pregnant women, etc. during the destruction of sirhind

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 08 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. It is not only the Brahmin/Bippar Combine that has been twisting our history..it has also been the COMMUNISTS ACADEMICS who have been so heavily infiltrated into the Universities in Punjab. These Communists ( KAUM-NASHATS) were SIKHS in APPEARANCE and LOOKS..BUT Deep INSIDE they are atheists and PURE POISON+HATRED for anything SIKHE/GURMATT. Therefore many of the so called new History Books and articles. research papers that came out of PUNJAB UNIVERSITIES in the past 50 years or so was TWISTED HISTORY... Guru Teg Bahadur Ji was also not spared....these new kaumnashat historians called Guru Ji a REBEL, a TERRORIST, a DAKOO etc who was then rightly "captured" by Aurengzeb and beheaded for his "crimes" In the similar vein..the glorious history of Baba Banda Singh Ji bahadur was MUTILATED and TWISTED by these kaumnashat historians...and now attempts are being made to hijack this Sikh Hero to become Hinduism's hero ( simply because Hinduism DOESNT have a SINGLE HERO !!!) by calling him bairagee !! Earlier they hijacked Bhai Khaniya ji this way..saying he was not a sikh but a hindu samaj sewak !!

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Bundha · 09 Jun 2005

Wazir Khan marched personally about ten miles out of Sirhind to give battle to the advancing enemy and the battle was joined on May 12, 1710, on the plain of Chapper-Chiri. Wazir Khan's troops fought with their backs to the wall and initially such was the consternation in Sikh ranks that the men who had joined them lured on by loot, fled the battle field. They were followed by a thousand others who had been smuggled in by Wazir Khan earlier. Seeing this, Banda himself leapt to the forefront and led the attack. The contemporary Muslim accounts of this battle are full invectives against the Sikhs who are called 'wretched and worthless dogs,' 'hellish infidels,' 'fanatical ruffians,' and their leader a veritable monster,' and yet they do not fail to admire the' reckless courage and spirit of sacrifice. Says Khafi Khan, "when the battle began, great bravery was shown on both sides but especially by the confederate sectarians. They advanced sword in hand against the elephants and brought two of them down. Many Musallmans found martyrdom and many of the infidels (i.e. the Sikhs) went to the sin of perdition. The Musallman force was hardly able to endure the repeated attacks of the infidels when a musket-ball made a martyr of Wazir Khan and they were put to flight." Bundha Singh Bahadhur, who in seven short years had so mocked the might of the Moghals with his victories that they could never again reassert their authority over the land they once ruled with such confidence. Though their numbers were tiny compared to the Moghal forces, Bandha and his men had taken control of extensive territories and established the first independent Sikh state complete with it’s royal seal, its own coins and an administrative system. In the absence of first hand written accounts by Sikh chroniclers, the reporting of Muslim and other observers has led to a very distorted picture of Bandha and exaggerated tales of atrocities committed by his followers , painted by people resentful of his meteoric rise. My user name is in honour of such a poorun gursikh of Guru Gobind Singh Ji [%sig%]

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 09 Jun 2005

Ironically, it is NOT only Brahmin inspired tales which discredit Banda Singh, but largely Jat inspired propaganda. How? Allow me to explain: Like many other key figures in Sikh history who were not Jats, there has been a steady and collaborated effort to undermine the status of Gursikhs such as Bhai Sukha Singh Shaheed, Bhai Mani Singh Shaheed and Jassa Singh (Ramgarhia) Baba Banda Singh Bahadur Shaheed. Given the contribution to the Khalsa Panth and to humanity in general by these great warriors of Guru Gobind Singh, it was not possible for pro-Jat propagandists to simply speak out against them and write them off, so instead they reverted to clever half-truths and cants by spreading malicious stories about these Gursikhs aimed to undermine their character. We are all familiar with such stories about Bhai Mani Singh, being reprimanded by Sikhs for altering the Guru Granth Sahib (in effect undermining his Shaheedi) and of Jassa Singh and Sukha Singh being excommunicated from the Panth for the killings of their daughters. These are the same low level works of those writers and propagandists who have also derided the name of Banda Singh Bahadur with baseless arguments about him not being a “Singh” (i.e. was not given Amrit by Guru Sahib), he was not given control over the entire Khalsa Army, established himself as a Guru etc etc. These are all deceptive lies, and the largest one being that he established himself as a Guru and created the “Bandai Khalsa”, the truth is that the title “Bandai” has been misrepresented. After his shaheedi, “sections” of the Bandai Khalsa begun to revere him as more than a leader and made him into a Guru and a split emerged, however the original ‘sache’ Bandai existing during his time were Gurusikhs of the highest calibre. The unfortunate truth is that what is now described in history books as being the rise of power of the true Khalsa –the “Tat Khalsa” is also misrepresented. In reality, the Tat Khalsa (whom the Singh Sabha founders of the SGPC sought to model themselves upon and whom the Buddha Dal claim to be the present-day descendents) had become stooges of the Moghul power and actually collaborated with the Moghuls in Banda Singh Bahadur’s defeat. This is also when the infamous incidence where the TAT Khalsa stuffed pork chops into the mouths of the "Bandai" Khalsa outside the Akal Thakt (Gurbilas P10). Many of the sentiments generated by these propagandists actually lasted into the the 19th century with British writers like Macaufille in his works on the Sikhs, indicates that the views expressed concerning Banda Singh Bahadur were curious and not favourable despite his positive contributions during the initial portions of his life. The incident regarding stuffing meat is also mentioned in Prachin Panth Parkash (Rattan Singh Bhangoo) and is perhaps one of the most pro-Jat accounts of our history. Pork chops were stuffed into the mouths of Bandai Sikhs outside the Akal Thakt –this took place after Banda Singh Bahadur was martyred. The Tat Khalsa and the Bandai Sikhs both were trying to control Darbar Sahib. It was agreed to have a wrestling match between the chosen wrestlers of either side. Miri Singh who was grandson of Binod Singh (one of Sikhs sent by Guru Gobind Singh to accompany Banda Singh) was at that time an employee of Lahore Governor, was chosen by the Tat Khalsa while the Bandai Sikhs chose Sangat Singh. the incident is described thus, “Miri Singh jab hath shuhaya, Turt Sangat Singh hethan aya.” As soon as Miri Singh shook or touched his (Sangat Singh's) hand, immediately Sangat Singh fell down under (Miri Singh). “Jhat kar jhatko layo mangai, Soor dala mukh chhadio paaye.” Quickly Jhatka meat was brought and a chunk of pork was stuffed into (Sangat Singh's)mouth. (Prachine Panth Parakash, page 169, ed. Bhai Vir Singh, Bhai Vir Singh Sahit Sadan New Delhi) Today, conveniently picking up the pieces created by these pro-Jat propagandists the likes of the RSS have also begun to claim that Banda Singh Bahadur was not Amritdhari. I am well aware that some may find what I have stated as offensive, however I would be grateful to the Admin for allowing this post and at the very least allow people to look into the matter themselves. The truth is that what begun as trivial slanders circulated to discredit Banda Singh Bahadur were nothing but a ploy on part of the then Government to quash the then very real possibility of a Sikh State in Punjab, similar to Marathas had in the South. Unfortunately, owing to the actions of the Tat Khalsa it does at times appear that in collaborating with the Moghuls against Banda Singh Bahadur resulted in loosing the chance to prevent the Khalsa thereafter to undergo tortures and miseries for another century.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

mitrah · 09 Jun 2005

fair enough you got this historical account to back up what you say. but why would tat khalsa wanna back up moghuls when the moghuls tortured the hell out of sikhs at a time when the moghuls had the price on a head of every sikh caught? you might have a point about the scholars bias. But there again majority of sikhs came from jatt backgrounds so the bulk of scholars would have been jatt anyway. scholars are known to be critical and have their own brain. Not all scholars are religious or spirtually guided which is why i dont really read much into these historical accounts, stick to the basics. Banda singh was respected loved and the first sikh king making the first punjabi territory free. Why would jatts from punjab go against him on a caste thing? It does not make sense that caste was the motive. Perhaps dodgy authors could have their own axe to grind, may be communists, or or something else not all sikhs were proper sikhs huna? so they might have had a bigger agenda to knock down sikhs. Banda singh had all the qualities of a lion, i can only think true sikhs would have loved him. I think you are too caste concious singh.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 09 Jun 2005

Baaba Banda Singh Ji Bahadur established the FIRST SIKH KINGDOM..the KHALSA RAJ..and that is a FACT which many new Hindutva/rss/Communists dont exactly love to relate. I agree with mitrah that caste was not that important a consideration especially asGURU GOBIND SINGH JI had just established the Khalsa...Singhs wouldnt have RETROGRADED so fast. I ahve seen MORE books by the so callaed LOW CASTES....trying to GLORIFY their own castes than books by jatt authors trying to prove their superiority. It is a fact that people of "superioruty complex" just behave that way...while those that have "inferiority complex" try and prove themselves as better. Books such as Mazhbhi Sikhaan da Ithihaas, whcih tries to prove that Mazhbhee Sikhs were mentioned BY GURU NANAK in His Gurbani, and then goes on to list Singhs such as Rangreta Bhai Jita Singh and many others...trying so hard to PROVE that Mazhbhee sikhs have ahigh place in Sikh History. The TITLE of the Book and the Subject Matter shows the author feels he has a point to prove...ALL along before I read this book i had no idea about the "caste" of many of the Singhs mentioned in the book..to me they were GREAT SINGHS. Now this author tries to CLAIM these Singhs as MAZHBHEES....and create division. Similar casea abound where people have Web sites and all GLORIFYING the CASTE of Jassa Singh ramghariah....NOT his SIKHEE..and many books doing the same thing...and now we have memebers of the BAIRAGEE TRIBE..trying to RIDE on the Coattails of baba banda Singh by claiming he was THEIRS and NOT a SINGH... IMHO all these attmpts are arising out of an INFERIRITY COMPLEX...i may be wrong though. These "caste" attempts are different from those of the Communist Academics...they have a different agenda...their agenda is to DISCREDIT SIKHE by discrediting SIKHS....ALL SIKHS from GURUS to maharaja Ranjit Singh.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Akaal · 10 Jun 2005

Tat Khalsa never backed up mughals. Tat Khalsa and Bandai Khalsa were separate groups fighting against mughlas to establish Khalsa Raaj. They had monor differenced. THey were settles and they once again joined as Dal Khalsa.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 10 Jun 2005

Dear Mitrah and Gyani Jarnail Singh “Dhillon” Arshi, Thanks for your feedback. I would like to make two simple points. 1. Mitrah, you stated that I was too caste conscious, yet you happily ignore that all the above posts have been happily slandering Brahmins indiscriminately –people it seems, are quick to forget gems of Sikhi such as Bhai Mati Das and Sati Das Shaheeds, Bhai Kesar Singh Chibbr and many others who were of Brahmin origin. Of course, now people will say, but they are Sikhs and not Brahmins and we are referring to Hindu Brahmins –well, I would encourage people to look into the history of Brahmins themselves, you’ll be surprised that some of the greatest and most critical works and movements against what we today term as “Brahmanism” or “Brahmin” or simply “Bahmana da kam” were in fact Brahmins themselves (mainly those who followed Vedic instruction and not the Purans or Simrities). Anyhow, take a look at the thread on Gyani Zail Singh and see what the “Singhs” have to say about him and how his wrong doings suddenly are generalised to cover all member of the tarkhan community –this is not surprising, we are ALL familiar with what happened with Dr Abmedkar and the so-called untouchables, thanks to no other than the Jats, let’s not hide behind ideals of caste-free society, it is very real and influences, unfortunately a lot of things and has influenced many things in our history. 2. Gyani Jee, I am aware that coming from a Jat background yourself, my words may be hard to stomach, but please be assured that I am not making this point here to vilify Jats, that would be simply ridiculous for many many Puratan Singhs were from such background, namely my personal hero Baba Deep Singh Shaheed. I concur with your views on the book your referenced on Mazbi Sikhs, this is not good literature, however this is exactly what has been happening with Sikh history for a long time, at the hands of Jats, as they rose to power through power of numbers and later as the political tool of the British Raj employment. I am more than happy to provide further historical references and rationale to illustrate this point, however clearly it doesn’t seem to hold value given the response provided above, moreover it is not the main point here…that actually is what you mentioned, BABA BANDA SINGH BAHADUR did in fact establish the first KHALSA RAJ in Punjab which could well have been maintained and flourished, however this was lost at the partly because of those Sikhs who chose to side with the Moghul forces –why would they do this? Well, why did Sant Jee INITIALLY support various congress politicians in Punjab? Why is Manmohan Singh PM with the Congress Party? Why do some tarkhans, as the post on Gyani Zail Singh states view Indira in a positive light? Why did the timid Gyani Zail Singh not do anything when the Army invaded the Darbar Sahib? Why did Sikh soldiers under the command of General Brar, himself a mona Jat Sikh proceed with their orders to attack the Darbar Sahib…I hope this illustrates the point… I am fully aware we have the likes of the RSS who (falsely) are seeking to undermine Banda Singh Bahadur’s role as a Sikh to give rise to the view that he was in fact Hindu, others like the Bairahi Tribe, I personally do not have an issue with, since they can link themselves all they want to Madho Das Bhairagi and his ustad Naath Uggardant, however Madho Das was a different person to Banda Singh Bahadur, who had left his Bairagi lifestyle to become a puran Khalsa. Then we have the Buddha Dal who seek to discredit Banda Singh’s latter life to pave way for Baba Binod Singh as the true and only General of the Dal Khalsa Panth. These are events today, look at the sources that many of these groups use to discredit Banda Singh Bahadur and you’ll understand my point about the role of Jat authors (such as Gyani Gyan Singh and Rattan Singh Bhangoo) in building up what I referred to as trivial rumours into something far more greater to actually bring a bad name to Baba Jee. In the end, Banda Singh Bahadur clearly was a great General of the Khalsa Army, was amritdhari and the first “Maharaja”, if you will, of the initial Sikh Kingdom, of course, today we only associate such terms with Ranjit Singh Sukerchakia. I do not wish for any tu-tu-mai-mai to begin here, so I’ll leave this discussion here and leave the forum to make up their own minds, hopefully by actually looking into these texts with an open mind. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 10 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Veer A singh writes.. <<

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Truth Sikher · 10 Jun 2005

A Singh you are a ****admin cut- No name calling****. Jatts are a ethnic group who share same decent as Rajputs from Scythians, Banda Singh Bahadur (Rajput) was heavily supported by Jatts and he his remembered as a great Sikh general no matter what authors may claim. Secondly you seem to think you are some sort of academic, then you should stop labelling Jatts as a caste instead of a ethnic group, a group which has its own history pre-sikhism. Thirdly, if you know your history so much you will know that Jatts are and have been the backbone of Sikhs, deny it all you want but the truth remains. Ambedkar and co wanted political power by becoming Sikhs not for the love of it, nothing can stop millons of Dalits becoming Sikhs if they choose to, actually lets blame the Jatts, just like the 80's. People like you are a joke. The rest of your post is waffle.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

jugroop singh · 10 Jun 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer 'A Singh' Ji, with Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa, your last post has shed a very well-substantiated and detailed light upon Baba Banda Singh Bahadur Singh. much appreciated. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

wannabesingh · 10 Jun 2005

Truth Sikher, Are you really a Truth "Seeker" or a False Propagandist ? There is no such case that an ethnic group or a caste or a clan could be the backbone of Sikhi. If you believe some CLAN is the backbone of Sikhi, then I wonder where your backbone is .. Some caste / clan / lineage / ethnic group cannot be the backbone of a religion and if you mean to say that Jatt People, Jatt Sikhs, were the most prominent contributors to the Sikh faith, 1) When taking khande-ke-pahul a Gursikh rejects all ethnic groups, cultures, and castes for the MAANAS JAATH, for the AAEE PANTHEE SAGAL JAMAATEE, and for the EIK UTHAM PANTH 2) If you believe that only people born as Jatts could be great Sikhs, then you will have to go back to history class because all of the Guru Sahibs were born in non-jatt families. 3) Jatt / non-jatt is not an issue -- ethnic group or not, NOBODY IS HIGHER THAN THE PANTH, and no ethnic group or caste or clan or lineage is the backbone of Sikhi --- Sikhi stands up on its own with the support of the Guru's bani, Naam, the Rehit of the Guru's Sikhs, and Universal Love wjkk wjkf

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Punjab Shera Di Khomb · 10 Jun 2005

where do jat come from? scythia where do terkaan come from? scythia? where do we all come from God? so fikkar not we the children of the matrix sit back and rejoice in the wonders of Mahrajs creation as a sikh. the beauty of being sikh is that we are one. Where you find someone too too much into jat terkhan stuff you find arguments and egos clashing because the truth is they identify their jeevs with external material body from 5 elements than their original connection back to God. They are not doing their simran and bani with dhyaan, if they were they would know life is temporary, the body is a jacket that will come off upon after the limited life breaths after which they may be put into another body for their soul journey. On the path of sikhi and what bani says one simply cannot have caste if they do they will form a barrier between themself and God. Whether banda singh was a rajput or jatt i dont think singhs would care about his scythian connection, they fought against oppression and were blessed with a leader with capabilities and good skills. They had a chardi kala singh on their side. beant singh was a singh from chammar background, if banda singh bahadur supposedely was not there a the time and beant singh was do you think the scythian singhs would have said " no sorry mate you aint one of us we cant have you as ours"? i think theres two sides to ambedkar episode. But we should not be bitter brothers and sisters, we should continue very sharply on the path of sikhi and help do our bit to unite. I am happy with sikh history, if we went into jat history what would we go into next? The world is very complex place. I am happy as a punjabi and a sikh. [%sig%]

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

tinkerz · 10 Jun 2005

a singh ji the writer seems to be pointing towards "kenyan terkans" rather than terkans inside punjab. I myself have not noticed any kenyan support for sikh homeland or sikh retribution against state atrocities. Idid find a couple of ramgharias being interviewed from southall after babri masjid riots broadcast over bbc saying what the hindus did to babri and muslims was their right by demolishing a place of worship. then infamous forest gate nagar kirtan held in support of hindus led by the panj pyarey of neville rd ramgharia gurdwara declaring " they were the armed wing of hindus and their duty was to protect hindus". This was Shortly after a number of singhs appeared on tv briefly even on talk shows to express solidarity with the muslims killed in india while others stated it was nothing to do with the sikhs. The ramgharia gurdwara committee deliberatly threw sikhs into a hate feud. This happened around the same time ludhiana underwent a big wipe out phase of amritdharis where singhs were picked up all over again, tortured, killed and raped. Soon after this broadcast overthe news, a number of gurdwaras were being attacked all over the uk in what was a dispute between muslims and hindus eventually the ramgharia guirdwara comittee allowed an act that threw sikhs into someone elses communal dispute. It would benefit the kenyan ramgharia wing to familiarise themselves with human rights abuses, actually going back to punjab and india and seeing the damage done to sikh families, statistics, eye witness accounts against the accepted white paper version in which sikhs under attack are declared to be fanatics. This has nothing to do with the thread but obviously the image of the ramgharia kenyan community does not appear to be panthic which is no reflection of terkaans as they in punjab faced the same onslaught as all other sikhs in india at the time.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ssingh · 10 Jun 2005

jarnail singh gyani arshi - could you elaborate about this "It is a fact that people of "superioruty complex" just behave that way"

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ot · 10 Jun 2005

i think thats as clear as it gets singh. If someone feels they are superior they do we admit that, but such people come in from every corner. One day it can be a jatt, one day a brahmin and if we had 200 rajputs on a panel it could well have been a rajput. I have seen rajputs with attitude too (or modern day ghoomars), but they happen to be less in numbers and dont try superiroity complex with jatts because their in a minority against majority, and compare themselves over others weaker than them, ramgharias and all others are no exception to this. I have seen how ramgharias really take the mick out of punjabi life trying to place themselves as very civilised, and modern. So this affects people across the board. But it does not mean that all history writers is discrediting the sikh being a different caste. Some people just happen to be very critical, name seekers, and not into sikhi themselves. If in any case they are doing it because of caste i am sure they will face waheguru jis punishment for cussing down shaheed singhs.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Jun 2005

ssingh jio, imho what i am trying to say ( and i may be wrong) is that those at the top of the "heap" (superior !! ones..) dont have to assert or "prove" their superiority... It is usually those at the perceived bottom trying to climb up, and with "inferirity complex" that try and prove they are equally "good" clever etc... hence the book mazhbee sikhaan da itihas..the author tries so hard to "prove" that historically the so called low castes have been KINGS, rulers, etc etc..they are just as brave as anybody else..blah blah blah. This book is written obviously to REASSERT the "strength" of the so called mazhbees who are perceived to be low class and therefore couldnt be rulers/kings/warriors whatever. As i said before, before this book, i never for a moment thought about Bhai Jeeta Singh, or many of the famous and dedicated Sikh warriors listed in the book as anything except as SINGHS..I had heard the phrase..Ranghreta Guru ka Beta... ( incidentally NO GURU JI ever said Jatt Guru Ka PUTT )..but never associated it with Jaat.... now even my children know that Ranghreta is a supposed "low caste"..and THIS AUTHOR is the guilty party for spreading that "info" which to me is "useless".... as Ranghreta Guru ka Beta is such a HIGH TITLE in my MIND that any "jatt" would die for...I WOULD. My sincere benti to all..DONT BRING in caste...into GURSIKHE. Those that GURU JI LOVES are much higher than any jatt or brahmin no matter how highup/clean/pure dna etc he may be... GURU JI's Pyaar Bhariaa Title is out of this WORLD.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ot · 11 Jun 2005

jarnail singh right on i agree with you, the whole tussle behind it was not caste it was the kenyan diaspora insistance of carrying on this "snaatan sikhi" which has left them very tied up with hindus and confused what to do in a 1984 situation help the sikhs or stick with the hindus who are considered in sntaan ideology as the same thing. The snaatan veers should ask themselves the question what would happen if another 84 came if their own families were targetted? 84 dealt a heavy blow to this sntaan dream, the only answer would settle at no less than sikhs contrlling their own lives. It is this sntaan friendship that leaves punjab and sikhs where it is, wityhout water, sikhs having to abondon punjab, millions dead, with bleak future. It has nothing to do with caste, sant bhindrawalas comment on his right hand man sodhi after sodhis death is a perfect example of singhs pyar and ekta with each other and the quam khadkus came to the call from everywhere the reality between the REAL singhs was there was no caste. Its about mentality. Modern savvy trendy sikhs would rather believe electronic media than visit the homes of those who have lost their children and loved ones.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

... · 11 Jun 2005

Shabaash! Now we've managed to respond to the topic ----- and another 1000 things not related to Gurmat! Good on us !i!

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ssingh · 11 Jun 2005

everyone feigns this desire "DONT BRING in caste...into GURSIKHE" these attempts, of which you keep selecting one bad example to slam, come in response to the ingrained imaginary superiority jaats claim, your own words as an proof you believe you are: "those superior !! ones dont have to prove their superiority." What stems from this inconsistent and flawed belief is not a more natural behavior as you say, but a constant need/"complex" to maintain these notions of superiority. As examples have been given of lower castes, so in kind I give as examples from the many forums, the slogan of the popular jattworld: "The Jatt Race is, for Manliness, Honesty, Strength and Courage, second to no race in the world." - L. Griffin

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ot · 11 Jun 2005

pyarey ssingh jattworld believes jatts are race. The gorey were neither sikhs, they fought 3 battles against sikhs and tried to subdue sikhi and control it through corruption and suppression. Why should we believe a goras account as much as a persians account of sikhs? Gorey also claimed sikhs gave pork chops to singhs at amrit sinchar, and only ate from brahmins in the jungles. I find theid accounts anti panthic and seemingly corrupt. If jatts were a race they would all be similar in height, skin colour and other attributes. Is this true?, jatts come in a balanced different shapes some dark some very light, a good number very tall while other jatts are small. Other punjabis also have similar facial attributes. The old Punjab is placed on frontier. For the amount of invaders we have had using punjab as a bridge to asia dont you think there was a lot of inter mixing causing breeding changes? Looking at lippens account of jatts honesty strentgh and courage was true then why was Guru Gobind Singh Ji needed? why was sikhi needed to instil these qualities if they already existed? what was the need of a kirpaan? looking at some dodgy sanatan account that the khanda had a rajput copyright then where was the royal warrior courage and strentgh when they gave their daughters away to moghuls? the compliments lippen was reffering to were actually born from sikhi it is the Guru Sahibs who gave us honesty through honest living, strentgh both inner and outer, and courage to stand up which remains unparralled in human history when compared over the world and even amongst other jatts. To illustrate that point further let us analyse how the sikh masses are moving away from sikhi are they as truthful or more couragious or more stronger as they cut their kes and become less sikh than they would have been if they took amrit and stuck on sikhi path? These jattworld groups are trying to make a jatt image. What they dont see is their positive characteristics they think are jatt are actually based on sikhism back then punjabi jatts largely stuck to sikhism in the past, if not now. Jattworld have a dream that all jatts from pakistan and india should unite, this is highly unlikely. But in a global fantasy dreams and mythical accounts seem real to hone in a created identity in a vain hope of uniting jatts regardless of religion. At this moment jattworld are trying to bridge a gap between pakistani jatts and punjabi jatts. What they will never get is pakistani jatts cudnt give a toss about being jatts or punjabis. . Their language is now urdu, they drop surnames and take on islamic surnames to create unity with their muslim brothers largely persian turkoh in west punjab. Hariana jats once migrating to hindu areas married to other hindus, changed their religion, supported hindus and even their mentality is hinduish and not punjabi while having the similar clan name as punjabi jats. So our own brothers should foster unity only with sikhs and see then feel the beauty of sikhi. the true failure is inside those jattworld brothers for failing to follow sikhi and trying to reinvent themselves in accordance to the lifesetyles away from sikhi for which their own babey fought hard for. ssingh there is no low or high caste in sikhi. But until we see that we refuse to accept that khalsa is a brotherhood. which means we are not living Guru jis sikhi, so then why would Guru ji bless a panth that does not reognise His teachings? So we have to corerct ourselves. There is no sukha singh kalsi, there is just a sukha singh. There is no jatt turkaan side to assali singhs. [%sig%]

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

question Singh · 12 Jun 2005

L. Griffin was an idiot with no brain for saying such a proposterous manmat thing. There is no race that is first or second, and anybody who believes in any race superiority other than 'aee panthee sagal jamaathee' and 'ik utham panth sunio gursangat' is a faithless agnostic arrogant ignorant moron !!!!

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Jun 2005

Dear Ssingh jio, I Quoted GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...."Ranghretta Guru ka beta"....and also proved that NO GURU ever said" "jatt Guru da Putt".. BUt you went ahead and quoted me a Gorah, jattworld and other utter rubbish....you have got the correct reply from"ot" above. Give me a quote from GURBANI or GURU Ji....about Jattas beign "superior" and I may consider a reply. All the other utter rubbish, accounts dont matter to me one iota. I a Guru ka Sikh first, a Punjabi second, and Malaysian third....jatt doesnt come into the equation.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ot · 12 Jun 2005

ssingh the amount of times we hear sikh movement as "jatt inspired" or khalistan as "jatt propaganda" mostly streaming from sanatan followers do you not feel it is a great insult to the shaheed singhs who fought for the panth? It is almost as if with these new labels our beloved shaheed singhs are wrongly made out to look as if they were proud of their caste and inspired by dodgy people instead of Guru Gobind Singh jis amrit like they were very far from sikh principles instead of dieing for them. So these one or two words like that do a lot of damage to the image of khalsas who fought bravely in a world that is so unjust and not registering to sikh sympathy. It was perfectly right to state the position of the kenyan diaspora given the situation. If the moghuls chose to wipe sikhs out at the time , a bunch of sikhs supported the official version of the moghul empire and did not support the sikhs fighting oppression and even went as far as declaring themselves with drawn out kirpaans that they will fight for the moghuls as their "eternal dharm" enjoins them to (reference to nevville rd nagar kirtan supporting hindu rashtra when singhs were getting tortured by the same rashtra) how would you feel as a sikh? This is nothing to do with jatt superiority. Others especially the paatra and punjabi singhs whatever caste vehemently spoke out against injustices and even fought alongside singhs in punjab. Yet the kenyans neither responded to the nagar kirtan outrage, nor held the nevillr rd gurdwara to boycott? or even collectively voicing their support for sikh resistance against human rights abuses in punjab. Instead we see the whole sikh movement getting tarnished. Then of course jatts being blamed for everything on the net be that punjab situation, banda bahadur singh, or writing. In fact we should educate ourselves that it has nothing to do with caste the underlieing problem is this sugar coated brahmin agenda called "sanatan sikhi" that stopped our veers uniting with us. Our memories do not end with 1984 every holocaust pushed onto singhs is remebered. The frank truth is a large number of sikhs also chose not to support singhs and stood back out of laziness, weakness and corruption. but the reason behind the kenyan diaspora was a religious version under thd fold of sikhism called sanatan. When such reason reflects on sikhi and therefater especially with the increase of internet use people spread propaganda about khalsas as jatt inspired would it be wrong to address the whole problem? The ramngharia misal comprised sikhs not of any specific caste, the missal was founded not on any caste basis by a non castist singh, jassa singh assumed the title after the singh before him on the successes of jassa singhs fauj and those before him in the missal. The kenyans felt the title belonged to all turkaans abd amulgated it to mean turkaan and more specifically the superior kenyan turkaans. Having seen pictures from 1950 of ramgharia sikhs one showed a number of ramgharia females dressed in very small shorts at a ramgharia "sikh" event. Is this reflective of ramgharia missal? i think not. Is caste reflective of the singhs in madhaan? no way. Did jassa singh build a seperate gurdwara for one caste? NO WAY. The paranioa surrounding the mere mention of kenyan ramgharias to suddenly have a caste tone to it does not make sense as the very same turkaans in punjab know felt and fought alongside other sikhs against the hindu oppressive regime. While other city dwellers in delhi, and other posh parts chose not to take the advice to keep shasters and thus became victims outside punjab by the same sanatan hindus they thoyught were their brthren.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ssingh · 12 Jun 2005

"ssingh there is no low or high caste in sikhi" i like everything you say pretty much in that last post, don't know why say that though

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Taksali Singh · 12 Jun 2005

Khalsa Jee, Amritworld has new PDF file which has good information regarding Baba Banda Singh Bhadhur. Please download this PDF file and read it. http://www.amritworld.com/pbi_articles/banda_singh.pdf

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 14 Jun 2005

How are Ramgarhias specifically "Sanatanists"? Notwithstanding the infamous Neville Road incidence, which even the author implies is not representative of all Ramgarhias or for that matter Kenyans (go to Ramgarhia Gurdwara in Slough, where they frequently hold AKJ Reinsubhais and also are pro-Khalistani and Bindrawale supporters and Kenyans!). Neville road need to be brought to account, but what a hand of Kenyans may believe to be the case in one part of London does not account for all Kenyan families whether they be Ramgarhia, Ahluwalia or Jats. The pro-Sanatan groups in any event, tend to be mainly Khatri or Jat, if one is to get specific (i.e. look at the Nirmala Deras and Nihangs, who are predominantly Jat, even if the latter is headed by an Arora and both actually are anti-Ramgarhias) and the RSS (Sikh Wing) are largely comprised of Khatris, who are well known to still inter marry within Hindu families and the infamous words of Master Tara Singh should spell out the disturbed rationale of the Neville Road congregation. Non-sikh movement like Udasis, who have been the cheif vehicle for introducing non-Khalsa elements into the Panth historically and today are also predominantly Jat. I am not a Kenyan, however I raise objection to the last threads, as we should not over look the role of key figures such as Baba Puran Singh of Karecho, who was certainly an East African Singh (as are many of the Nishkam Sevak Jatha sangat -who are in no way Sanatanists) and a great gem of the Panth. Also, the revival and rights to wear the dastaar in the UK was largely handled by Sikhs from East Africa, who didn't feel the need to visit the barber shop as soon as they arrived on British soil. Anyhow, this thread concerned Banda Singh Bahadur and I shall repeat, he was a puran Amritdhari Gursikh to the end. It is the false propaganda of the Bddha Dal Nihangs and other Sanatanists (who were Jat biased) who have historically tainted his good name. The modern day neo-Hindu fundamentalists have had their work cut out for them thanks to this work conducted by "Sikhs". It is not always Brahmin inspired conspiracies that we should be wary of, but internal enemies.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

.... · 14 Jun 2005

but how are you so sure its jat bias? could there not be other possibilities? banda singh was a don shera da sher singh of the panth. Anyone diss him need their head examined because if he was all those things he stood accused of then where did he get the shakti to lay a shaheedi like that? why would he bother fighting for sikhs if he wanted his own thing? how could he watch his son leave the earthly plane? surely banda singh must have been motivated by very very high spiritual ideals that had no care for material gain. When you recite bani sincerely all the answers will come. Sikhs should put down scholarly books and place their faith in gurbani or bhai sahibs work who may have been a scholar but at least gurmat centred on virtually every issue. Not all sikhs want to read bani, not all want to be real sikhs. Some just for name, family thing, etc. But real rehetvaan lions and lionesses will never buy the crap that slanders sikh personalities. the very first memory i had of banda singh bahadur is a book published by shera punjab on panjabee martyrs. I forgotten the name of the book but things were mentioned how corrupt hindus and corrupt muslims from high classes connived otgether to have this class system where they keep on screwing up people beneath them . That was partly why upper caste hindus married upper rcaste muslims. Aurangas mum i think it said was a hindu rajputni too. I think people have perceptions of castes like cussing down brahmins too. But brahmins have also become sikhs especially in jammu. Sikhs should not have a caste system, that will be the quickest way to destroy ourselves. Once people stop fighting about jatt terkan then punjab v delhi, if that stops then mulwa v majheil v duob if that stops then one jatha v jatha. People get so used to being something different and having this imaginary "i am this, you are that" they will eventually harm their bhagti. jat sites are mental, you will only find so called sikhs doing stupid sites like that, never muslims . azad kashmiri jaats and pak jaats in uk show us how much unity they like with sikhs in bradistan pure besti. I would like to invite lord jat to bradford to experience the warmest welcome of pakistani jaat. West coast Canadians and americans might have had the wrong parchar some years ago thats why we have caste stronger there. In uk we have a large number of punjab pak / azad kashmiri jaats whos elders seem to like sikhs and sikhs have fond memories of but the youth are hardcore wahabis bent on taking sikh kuris away, and bashing apney up.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 14 Jun 2005

Dear "...." Sikhs should NOT put down scholarly books -this is exactly what has been happening and why people are now unaware of our authentic history and reliant on the twisted books that have been subseuqently written. Let's not give up so easily!!!

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

.... · 14 Jun 2005

dont read the twisted books mere beerah

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

teek ah? · 14 Jun 2005

by believein in bani with shardah, soaking it in dil lahkai with dyhaan and same process with naam simran you will aquire sohji in matters. Therefore, when you come across twisted works your conciousness will help you decipher. by only reading books one does not attain liberation, or go far, the result like pandits and kazis discussing matters rather than doing what they should do.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Jatt · 14 Jun 2005

Hi guys, Guru Gobind Singh ji's zafarnama gives special mentioning to the Brar Jatts and their bravery, when they finally get inducted into Khalsa panth after agreeing to stop female infanticide... I think that says alot. For the rest, discuss on www.Jattworld.com this is a relegious website, not a secular one anyways.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

teek ah? · 15 Jun 2005

can you please post the zafarnama here so we can see exactly what it says cheers bro

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 15 Jun 2005

Dear "...." It is not me only reading the 'twisted' books, where do you think the katha you hear in the Gurdwara comes from and is based upon...PLEASE let's wake up and face facts as to what has been happening and is happening...

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

dara sio · 15 Jun 2005

let us do our bhagti when the time is right we will chalk out plans to take over gurdwaras in elections and replace the whole system with gurmat, and the resource centres flourish with gurmat articles approoved by the amritdhari sikh panth. for that to happen we have to become gurmat focused ourselves, meaning read more bani do more paat for chardi kala of panth and bring others to sikh path build sikh support and lets kick it. We cant be negative lets focus ourselves on the development of the sikh faith. the problems we are in are a result of falling number of real sikhs and sikhs in name only. when they become in name only they become empty pots and look at their fine bodies wealth big houses hundred acre property instead of the naam inside them.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 16 Jun 2005

Dara Sio, I appreciate the good intentions of your thoughts, however we are again confusing two issues. One is an individuals personal sadhana/bhagti etc and another is the corporate life of Sikhs. The notion that some "body" of Amritdharis will "approve" the books is already in place and little difference does it make! This is will only amount to censorship dependent on the views of those in power -it is not the issue here. We are not here to ban books or thoughts, but to understand them better and to seek out the truth -this is not related to an individual's bhagti.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

shan e punjab · 16 Jun 2005

a singh paaji what are your own views on zaat paat in sikhi? what best to get rid of it? y is it there in the first place? i ask you because you seem like a widely read kinda moonda but i do not agree about the tat khalsa bit. sahdei khalsa ne moghula dee shattiah phadeeya sara asmaan da rang lal khoon bich parkhe jinna tikher jitteh nei ja karbani lai.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 16 Jun 2005

Shan e Punjab Veer Ji, I understand it is hard to believe however, Miri Singh who was grandson of Binod Singh (one of Sikhs sent by Guru Gobind Singh to accompany Banda Singh and was descendent of Guru Angad Dev) was at that time an employee of Lahore Governor. Here are some quotes from History of the Sikhs… "In the schism of Banda's ranks into Tat Khalsa and Bandai Sikhs in October 1714, Binod Singh with 10,000 followers parted company from Banda. (at the instance of Mughals). But he was in two minds He wanted to obey Mata Sundari's command, and at the same time was opposed to fight against Banda. He remained at Amritsar, He was taken to Gurdas Nangal in the Mughal Army to fight on their side. There he tried to retire without fighting. No sooner had Binod Singh started moving away at the head of his 10000 men, than he was attacked by the imperialist on all sides. According to Khafi Khan three or four thousands of his men were massacred at once and extensive plain was filled with blood as if it were a dish. (History of the Sikhs, Vol 4, page 8, by Hari Ram Gupta) Now read the following which accounts for the massacre of Sikhs in Delhi –an account which we are all familiar with from the 1980s…as I said before…History WILL repeat itself if we do not seek to educate ourselves about it… "Under pressure of Emperor Frukh Siyar, Mata Sundari who was living in Delhi (why live there?) exocommunicated Banda Bahadur, and ordered the Sikhs to desert him. The first persons to obey her were Kahan Singh and his son Miri Singh. Binod Singh also supported them. Thus about 15000 men broke off from Banda Bahadur, They called themselves Tat Khalsa or true Sikhs. A body of 5000 Sikhs under Kahan Singh and Miri Singh took up service with Abadas Samad Khan, governor of lahore. Each horseman was paid Rs.30 per mensem and a footman Rs 5 a month, and a sardar Rs 5 daily. The remaining 10000 under Binod Singh were provided residence at Amritsar with free board and lodging. The entire revenues of parganah Jhabbal were reserved for this purpose. This took place in October 1714. Kahan Singh was ordered to join the imperial army in the siege of Gurdas Nangal against Banda. Kahan Singh declined. He was sent as a prisoner in the retinue of Banda in January, 1716. The massacre of Sikhs began in batches of one hundred each day in front of the Kotwali in Chandni Chowk. Mata Sundari resolved to save the life of Kahan Singh. The Mughal officers and guards were heavily bribed, and another Sikh was put in place of Kahan Singh. His (Kahan Singh's) later history is unknown. (ibid. page 9) The point on caste is that we have gone for the ideal without realising that ideals are exactly that ‘ideals’ rather like a rainbow, they don’t really exist, what ideals do provide however are goals and these are what is achievable. Now on the subject of caste, people can say all they like about it not existing, but that’s rather like saying race doesn’t exist so if one acknowledges different races, one is being racist –a rather absurd statement you will agree no doubt? So the deal with caste is simple, on a communal basis, yes there are social differences between Jats, Tarkhans, Khatris, Bhramins etc GENERICALLY speaking –of course there are exceptions, there are many Tarkhans I know who look, talk and behave just like Jats and many Jats I know who, as hard as this may be for some to believe, look and talk like Khatris. The issue we have as Sikhs with caste, is that it should NOT be used for purposes of discrimination in religious affairs (as was the case with puranic-following Brahmins), dharma is for all –so the issue is not to eradicate caste, for that clearly hasn’t happened –this is not my view, it is a observation of reality. When it comes to social engagements such as marriage, the caste issue often comes into play simply as those opting for the arranged marriage route will want to match homes as much as possible so that the boy and more so the girl (who bears the majority of the burden of adjusting overnight to new family life) are more comfortable -as far as the intentions are honest, I see no problem is such matters, problems arise when people start to take this to the extreme with caste becoming an overiding factor on a high-low basis -this is the case in the west where education has allowed a more level playing field and still certain people are unhappy have a Choora da Munda as their Doctor or a Tarkhan di Dhi as their consultant. The question is of understanding the each others sub-communities and when it comes to religious matters and politics not allowing these to bias our opinions (as is often the case with Jats, who regardless of how hopeless a candidate a particular person may be, will only vote for their “Jat-Bhra” and not some “choora” or “mistry” or “bahman”), hence the various factions we have such ravidas, ramgharia, etc etc gurdwaras. So, personally, on this level it’s rather like race issues, one cannot deny the existence of racial groups and certain general traits and cultures particular to each one, however when it comes to opportunities and/or religious matters, no one should be barred from participation. I have no quick solution! Ultimately, like the commonly quoted vedic text, one can only change the world by changing themselves…or from Jap Ji Sahib “Man Jeete Jag Jeet”.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Panjabi Dal · 13 Jun 2006

Going back to the original question. I think Rattan Singh Bhangu (whose grandfather apparently fought with Banda), said a schism took place because Banda changed the Khalsa uniform colour to red, changed the Jaikara to "Fateh Darshan" and some other stuff, I think forcing vegetarianism. This made Baz Singh, deputised by Guru Gobind Singh Ji as one of his Punj Piaray advisors, break away from Banda (i.e. the Tat Khalsa). Banda Singh's actions are probably the best documented of early Sikhs and although we are right to be careful to accept everything in Persian accounts, some of it is useful. They point at largescale influx of all castes in Khalsa under Banda, who seems to have truly achieved a jaatless society in his own time. Plus all the Singhs (whatever their background), sought shahadat. The Persian sources are useful because they contain accounts written by teh very people fighting against Banda, and we can often separate the propaganda from the truth. [%sig%]

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Panjabi Dal · 13 Jun 2006

Going back to the original question. I think Rattan Singh Bhangu (whose grandfather apparently fought with Banda), said a schism took place because Banda changed the Khalsa uniform colour to red, changed the Jaikara to "Fateh Darshan" and some other stuff, I think forcing vegetarianism. This made Baz Singh, deputised by Guru Gobind Singh Ji as one of his Punj Piaray advisors, break away from Banda (i.e. the Tat Khalsa). Banda Singh's actions are probably the best documented of early Sikhs and although we are right to be careful to accept everything in Persian accounts, some of it is useful. They point at largescale influx of all castes in Khalsa under Banda, who seems to have truly achieved a jaatless society in his own time. Plus all the Singhs (whatever their background), sought shahadat. The Persian sources are useful because they contain accounts written by the very people fighting against Banda, and we can often separate the propaganda from the truth. If you want I can try and dig some these accounts out and post them. Let me know.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

PTE SINGH · 14 Jun 2006

To Mr A Singh- It seems people enjoy banding and singling out all Jatts when it suits their spiteful motives but have a problem when we do it for pride and distinction. If it makes you feel better about yourself A Singh, you can blame all the worlds ills on us Jatts, we have broad enough shoulders and are fully aware of our contribution to our religion, nation and humanity. Any malicious and unfounded comment from you is not going to take any thing away from us. Be aware that a majority of Jatts actually come from peasant backgrounds that received their land in recognition of their will to fight for it. In fact Baba Banda Singh Bahudar is even more revered to all Jatts because he was instrumental in insuring that the Jatt peasants who flocked to his and the armies of our Guru’s became owners of the lands they worked.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 14 Jun 2006

PTE Singh, thanks for your comments – people enjoy banding and singling out all sorts of things, which is exactly my point! I can hardly see how I have in any way “blamed all the worlds ills on Jatts”, however it allows you an opportunity to tell everyone about our broad shoulders etc then all the power to you! As per Baba Jee being revered by all Jatts – let’s not get ahead of ourselves – have a look at the Sikh authors and historians who have predominantly spoken against him. Baba Jee belongs to the Khalsa Panth not to any jaat. Going back to Rattan Singh Bhangoo – yes he indicates that the schism took place for various reasons, however if we look at earlier texts such as Bhai Kesar Singh, he does not do nindiya of Baba Jee like Rattan Singh Bhangoo and others imply. The change of greeting (Fateh Darshan), red dress etc came about following Baba Jee’s death. The whole issue surrounding Baba Binod Singh (not Baba Baaj Singh, who fought under Baba Jee) leading his forces against Baba Banda Singh is quite crucial in understanding not only Baba Jee, but also the Budha Dal Nihangs and the era documented during the late 18th and 19th centuries by British authors who refer to Baba Jee’s memory not being held in high esteem by the then Sikhs. This is particularly important, since only recently have efforts been made to really address the true nature of Baba Jee, however many Groups even today are keen on painting Baba Jee as a volatile figure who in the end was anti-panthic, their arguments can be summarised as follows: - He committed murders of women and children in cold blood - He upturned graves of his enemies - He wasn’t amritdhari - He altered the diet, dress and traditions of the Khalsa - He is only supported by modern day Sikhs, because it represents their own personal agendas for extreme vegetarianism, khalistan, devoidness of Hinduism and use of brute force. The main protagonist of this thought is Dr Ganda Singh, who according to them rewrote history to support Baba Banda Singh Bahadur, making him into a Singh and a figure for all Sikhs and Hindus to rally around during the partition years as a force that previously resisted Muslim attack. Whilst the reading of Persian and Moghul accounts including Sikh texts like Bhangoo and Gyani Gian Singh together with British accounts may support such assertions, these are conclusions in my opinion drawn predominantly at face value. Baba Binod Singh is claimed by the Budha Nihangs to be their first Jathedar, however Giani Gyan Singh states that the Budha Dal wasn’t formed until much after Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s time? I will leave this point for now, since it will unnecessarily complicate matters. The truth is that Baba Jee did over turn a grave belonging to a Sikh women who was kidnapped by the Moghuls, in order to perform her last rites. Whilst all historic texts refer to Baba Jee as “Banda” this is no different to how today one may be Amritdhari yet known to many by a nick name which once stuck doesn’t go away, in any event Bhai Kesar Singh Chibbder clearly indicates that Baba Jee took pahul from Guru Sahib – to my mind that doesn’t really leave much confusion, perhaps others may disagree, so Baba Jee was Khalsa. As far as not eating onions and other extreme habits of diet that come from Baba Jee’s past as a Bairagi Sadhu (under the lineage of Uggarnaath), this is needlessly made into a big issue – it is much like myself today, who turned vegetarian during my teenage years not for any religious purpose per se, but as an Amritdhari today remain vegetarian, although I fully endorse that the Akal Thakt does not require this as a requirement only that one not eat Halal. Matters concerning red clothes and greetings relate to the Nakli Bandai who survived Baba Jee and elevated him to Guru status – this is no different to what happened with the Namdharis or with Baba Ajaipal Singh etc. It even happens today when a particular chardi kala Singh is considered by some of his followers to be more than just a Baba or Bhai Sahib. The khalistani issue seems to be a personal matter which has unnecessarily been brought into this and whatever one’s view of khalistan and the movement during the 1980s, one should bear in mind that Baba Jee did establish the first Sikh Kingdom and stuck a coin in the name of Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Guru Gobind Singh, so I can hardly see how he sought to make himself a Guru and moreover, on the issue of land and politics, a Sikh Kingdom during that time was no different to the kingdom that the Marathas had established in the South. Whilst there are undoubtedly many more aspects to consider, the sad reality is that had the predominantly Punjabi Sikhs not gone against Baba Jee, the Sikh Kingdom was have presented a chance to potentially avoid the coming century of horrendous deaths and tortures faced by the Sikhs as a whole. Gur Fateh!!! A Singh

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

some1 · 14 Jun 2006

jat and jatt 2 different things :S

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

holypakore!! · 14 Jun 2006

whats all this jatt biz? most jatts i know are far more liberal and open minded do not even rave on about caste as much as you see it amongst practicing sikhs whether anti jatt or for jatts its you so called sikhs in pagha who have that problem and pass it onto your kids real jatts have strong spirit simple yet powerful are nice people they are not namesake. just for the sake of it its jatts who got me a non jatt into sikhi. we can fight and die for each other theres no issues until you meet so called sikhs and sikh politics half of whom do not even resemble the shera prowess of the legends of punjab. banda singh was a wonderful martyr who filled the pages of sikh history with splendour. he created a new chapter and breathed new life into the hearts of martyrs thus forward a new era of warriors laying their lives flocking to the divine call of sacrifice defining the first sikh kingdom in sikh history. the kettle the sword anything contrary and slanderous should be chucked out. whats all this crap about lands? outside the punjab we all in the same boat people had land long before sikhism while others had to fight and die to attain rights where they were abused and treated as labourers on the jagirs of rajputs and moghuls. why do people have a problem with jatts? live and let othrs live. th longer you carry this anti or for jatt thing the more stupid you make sikhs look cos no one else has a problem except for so called apney sikhs when their in a bundle together.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

mushkil eh · 14 Jun 2006

banda singh bahadur was a beloved singh of the guru. dont believe in .. about shaheed singhs. first let such slanderer go and have his body treated as such sacrifice himself and his son and then dare speak ill of singhs who gave shahadi so in comparison check the jeevan of the slanderers with banda singh bahadurs life? if one has that much ego to defy and challange the all powerful Guru sahib then the question arise can such a being lay shaheedi even that in such manner under such circumstances? I strongly doubt it. one slanderer is capable of nindia but not of equal sacrifice? what kind of sikh nation is this where we can allow bullsh.. literature to spread in the panth? i have no idea who these scholars are, but just common sense is enough to settle it. whos next on the list on slander? the confusion these nindaks spread they probably would not stop at lieing about every other singh singhani who died for their faith. slanderers will speak with words, shaheeds will passionatly speak with actions and service that defy common perceptions of life.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

london singh · 14 Jun 2006

Nice post A Singh. I can detect an undertone of anti-Jatness but we all have our biases so that doesn't detract from the relevance of your post to this discussion. You are quite right that early Sikh writers placed many of their own biases into their works, it's wasn't solely a Jat Sikh preserve but other writers such as Bhai Chaupa Singh who was a brahmin and wrote that Brahmin Sikhs were better than other Sikhs and deserved more respect. This is why literature such as Janamsakhis, Rehatnamas, Gurbilases etc have be analysed through Gurbani and not just taken at face value. It is only the few sanatanists who treat such literature as gospel. So it comes as no surprise when a sanatanist takes an obscure sakhi from Bhai Mani Singh Janamsakhi and twists it in order to involve Sikhs needlessly in the Shia-Sunni controversy. As now it is unlikely that Sikhs at the time of that Janamsakhi cared less whether Abu this or Abu that was the true Imam or not. The same is true of Baba Banda Singh, the same sanatanist blames Babaji for a number of massacres but chiefly for killing of Shia Sayeeds at Samana. It seems that Shia Sayeed lives are worth more than others. Baba Banda Singh was unique among the Sikh leaders of the post-Guru period, he strove for and singlehandedly created a Sikh kingdom at a time when the Mughal empire was at it's height. Some Shia Sayeeds may have become collateral damage but that doesn't make Babaji into some kind of monster as the sanatanist has been trying to portray him. Babaji is also accused of forcibly converting Muslims to Sikhism. Putting aside the supreme irony of Muslims being forcibly converted there is no evidence that any Muslims were forcibly converted to Sikhism. There were instances of Muslims becoming Sikhs after the fall of Sirhind but there is no proof that it was forcible. In fact the newletters of that time which were reaching the Mughal emperor state that these Muslims were becoming Sikhs as they were impressed by the rising power of the Sikhs. Unlike other Sikh leaders Baba Banda Singh was not a sentimentalist, he fought against and killed Sher Mohammed the nawab of Malekotla who had protested the treatment of the younger Sahibzadas by Wazir Khan. Sher Mohammed had joined forces with Wazir Khan. Sher Mohammed also incurred the wrath of Baba Banda Singh as he has kidnapped a Sikh Bibi from Amritsar and she had committed suicide in order to save her honour.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

singh · 14 Jun 2006

perhaps these Singhs did not have these biases. It seems more likley to me that these wrong things were inserted later on by mischievious persons with their own ends in mind.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

PTE SINGH · 15 Jun 2006

Mr A Singh, I did not state that you have blamed all the worlds ills on Jatts; I merely stated that you might as well have with your flawed, objectionable and generalised statement: "Ironically, it is NOT only Brahmin inspired tales which discredit Banda Singh, but largely Jat inspired propaganda. How? Allow me to explain" Basically this means that because of a handful of authors (whom happen to be Jatt) that wrote spiteful things about Baba Banda Singh, that all the worlds Jatts are to be blamed? However if these authors were Sikh, would it mean that it was largely Sikh inspired propaganda, or perhaps largely male inspired, as they were all male? To even mention the word Jatt in a Sikh debate serves no purpose other than to cause division and uproar. I declare that your intention was to be spiteful and to offend enough to arouse the emotions of the Jatts on this forum. I am sure you will be glad to see that you have succeeded. [%sig%]

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ventura · 15 Jun 2006

i advise our friend a singh to be careful in his wordings. As a person who is not a jatt myself or amritdari i would like to say how most sangat think in terms of banda singh bahaudur in the gurdwara i attend in singh sabha . the sangat is formed from a cross section of castes, the very gurdwara was bought for and paid by the punjabi community in hard times. These times are relived with the bazurg sangat who attend to this day on crutches. Banda singhs picture hangson the wall, as we grew up we saw this picture evry other day, we read about him as a shaheed singh and his magnificent martydom. To jatts or non jatts banda singh is a beautiful heroic warrior whos love for sikhism passionatly manifested in his jeev. The problem is not one of castes out there . I feel perhaps a. singh feels a bias or some kind of bad memory he may have had with jatts. This caste emotion unfortunatly seems to attach itself to some of our veer jis post, which to a reader would appear like a plain attack on jatts. It may first be beneficial to us to understand where a singh is coming from whether he has had bad time in past. Most sangats do not have issues about jaat because we mould in together and share common struggles in life. This is purely from a mainstream angle not jatha point. The only contending issues seem to be when two love birds want to marry and they are different castes, or these caste gurdwaras which can be used as money making scams in the wrong hands ( grant funding) and perceptions held the entire community of one caste will put its daswand down but eventually stop attending as hardly any third generation people feel attachment to an ancient occupation and thus defieing the very existance of pangat. I have had sangat of both jatts and terkaans. The real problem is not of occupations, its more about culture difference between jatts from punjab and africi tirkans from england who have evolved differently living outside punjab and in africa. I myself have no issues we all sikhs, but first insight is tirkaans feel they are being discriminated against by jatts because jatts hold down a distinct identity. africi tirkaans have not experienced much punjabiat and find it hard to handle being around jatts. While for other punjabis we have grown up together whether one was a jatt or not. I, my family, my relatives have never experienced any kind of problem from jatts, it has in fact been contrary more like family bonds growing, where we have grown up together in two generations in our town. When i entered sikhi i had issues myself, the mainstream sangat were so supportive put their arms around me as if we were part of the same drop in an ocean, and said we will help you get off your feet in every way jobwise, support we have plenty of girls to get married as long as you follow rehat for no other reason than to meet god with a selfless love. The only point i make here is mainstream do not have problems like the way these neo sikhs try to make out on sikh websites to draw attension to their emotive thoughts. surely the ramgharias must look inward although in terms of organisation and punjabi classes they excel far above. every1 has their plus and minus points. I feel its needless to attack any castes. in fact i find it sinister why so many posts bash castes. There perhaps needs to be understanding between people. Jatt culture will not go away, and tirkaan culture will not either its a fact of life. The twain may not meet and become a ying yang partner but it sure can learn to co exist with each other as petals on the same flower. In jatha it seems caste is not an issue because the rehat just melts sikhs together if they are serious about sikhi. Going off topic slightly it might be an idea of the ramgharia cvommunity to more integrate itself into sikhism and the wider community. Because no one else seems to have a problem or complain about jatts. chimars have gone their own way with hindu names. So if we are going to keep seeing protests of tirkaans about jatts surely we should aim to work towards uniting everyone. Personally speaking i have had more problems trying to fit in with tirkaans than with jatts. Jatts its like one big family with arms around you, with tirkaans i cant make sense of things. maybe we all have bridges to cross but we must surely in the right manner. segregation breeds misunderstandings. Therefore the ramgharia gurdwaras and others are no better than governments and councils who segregate people. Its up to all of us to make a change. sorry to say it bluntly but the root of all this stuff appears to come from one or two people wtih the same grudge. But its not fair to use sikhism as a whip against anyone. This is what happens when people become seperated, misunderstanding grows and suspicion arises. Its interesting as to why the tirkans from india do not have the same grudge against jatts as the ramgharias from africa do. So we must all do more to fit in with each other. But its not going to be a turkha pot overnight

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 15 Jun 2006

PTE, I feel we are perhaps dragging something out unnecessarily - the whole purpose of that statement from me was that today we see an overwhelming occurence of blaming something instantly on Brahmins, without a second to think out it. Whether that something is a historical text, or if it is a custom (like Bibek), or a recent event that we may not like. The reality is, ALL authors past and present, retain their biases in one way or another - the difference is accepting this and not simply writing off an author or individual on this basis. It is very common to see 'highly qualified yet humble' scholars today write off the likes of Bhai Chaupa Singh, you I wholly agree wrote things which run counter to the theme of Gurmat in respect of his pro-Brahmin views, however the fact remains he was (a) an eye witness to many key events and (b) was very close to the Guru Ghar throughout his life until his end - I do not accept that we does cast him or his works out of our literature simply on certain parts of his attitude. I reason I highlight Rattan Singh Bhangoo (is other than his Panth Parkash being a favourite of mine), is that the very same people who disown the likes of Bhai Chaupa Singh, completely ignore that Rattan Singh Bhangoo not only does the same thing himself, but also introduces a whole lot of additional 'questionable' stories. This is not anti-Jatt, it is simply highlighting something. In any event, this thread concerns Baba Banda Singh Bahadur.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 15 Jun 2006

ventura, again, perhaps you can re-read my comments: Baba Jee belongs to the Panth, I never indicated Jatts are against him! Baba Binod Singh was Khatri and in the employ of the Moghul government when he attacked Baba Jee. I feel we are making a mountain out of a molehill here - let's get back to Baba Jee... did he or did he not turn against the Panth? Whatever the case, the fundamental issue that arises is that Baba Jee established Khalsa Raj in his Kingdom (NOT Maharaja Ranjit Singh, as many fantasists like to believe today). Not only did he establish Khalsa Raj, this would have easily prevented the subsequent century of pain, suffering and torture meted out to the Sikhs had they stuck together - what is the Sangat's views on this?

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Kulbir Singh · 15 Jun 2006

There is a lot of misunderstanding about Baba Banda Singh jee Bahadur. If he had deserted the Sikh Panth, he would not have been able to have such a glorious shahidi. A person who leaves his Guru can never have the spiritual strength to see his son’s chest ripped apart and heart pulled out it. The heart of Baba jee’s son was forced in his mouth. Baba jee still stayed in Chardi Kala. He did not give up his faith. Farukhsiyaar the Mughal emperor asked Baba jee what kind of death he wanted. Baba jee said to him that whatever kind of death he (the king) would want for himself. Farukhsiyaar did not know that he was talking to not an ordinary person but a person who had tamed his mind and was a player of high spiritual states. Anything that Baba jee said always came true. He had Vaak-Sidhi i.e. anything he said used to come true. This Sidhi came from his continued kamaayee of Naam and Gurbani. History is witness that Baba jee’s bachan did come true. Very short time after Baba jee’s shahidi, the emperor was over thrown by the Sayyid brothers. He was thrown in a dungeon and tortured there. His eyes were taken out. He pleaded and cried like a little puppy. No one heard his screams. Farukhsiyaar was eventually murdered after a long agony. Yes there was some opposition of Baba jee by some Singhs but this is natural in our Panth. We have always had infighting and the times of Baba jee were no different. Heck, Singhs did not even pardon Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj and deserted him at Siri Anandpur Sahib. Same way they deserted Baba jee in his dire need. But, then there were faithfuls too who held up with Baba jee till their last breath. 700-800 of them got shaheed along with Baba jee. The story of Baba jee’s companions forced to eat pork at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib is a fabrication of Rattan Singh Bhangu who it seems like was very fond of meat. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 15 Jun 2006

Kulbir Singh, Do you honestly believe the stuffing of pork into the mouths of the Bandai Khalsa is fake?

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ns · 16 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Kulbir Singh Jeeo , I very much agree with your points on Baba Banda Bhaduar Ji. Also A Singh Jeeo you raise some important points. I've actually heard there's another granth called Guru TAVAREEKH and in here there is all sorts of stuff on Baba Banda Ji. For example it mentions that Baba Ji never attained shaeedi his swaas had reached dasm duaar and reamined that way till the torture of his body ended.Then it goes on to say that Baba Ji settles down in another village somewhere and marries and raises a family and so forth. I can;t begin to beleive this, i.e for starters Baba Ji;'s Death was actually witness by a Chrisitan missionary , I can't remember his name but he has been mentioned by Amandeep Singh Ji Madra's book in " Warrior Saints" It clearly menitons that this christian missionary saw the whole events.After the moguls pushed his sons's heart in his mouth, they skinned Baba Ji alive and then cut his body piece by piece.Sikhs even disagree on the type of torture that happened to Baba Ji? I know I may be going off on another topic could someone advise of this granth Guru Tavareekh and who is the writer and their history

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 16 Jun 2006

ns - are you by any chance thinking of 'wareek Guru Khalsa' by Gyani Gyan Singh Nirmala?

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ns · 16 Jun 2006

A. Singh not sure I was told about it and will find out for sure and let you know.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 16 Jun 2006

Apologies - 'wareek' should have been 'twareek'.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Dogra · 16 Jun 2006

http://www.santsipahee.com/banda-singh-bahadur.htm "He was born in October 1670 in a Rajput family doing farming in village Rajouri, district Punch, State of Kashmir. He was named Lachman Dev. As a child he was very fond of horse riding, martial art, hunting and was expert in use of bow and arrow and other weapons used in wars at that time. " "It was not less than a miracle and was the magnetic like personality of Guru Gobind Singh at his 42 years of age that a 38 year old Rajput, at a place far away from his native, now a mystic, celibate, vegetarian, having occult powers, master of a big Ashram but very haughty and proud was turned into a devoted and disciplined soldier and made an army general by the Guru, who fell on the cruel rulers of Punjab like a storm and cloud burst." " In Oct. 1708, at Nander, Guru Gobind Singh sent Banda Singh to Punjab and advised him to: 1. Put a stop to the cruelty of Punjab rulers. 2. Punish the guilty and cruel misrulers. 3. To fight for human rights, uplift and strengthen the poor, the low and slave like people who could not even imagine freedom." "The English historian Conningham wrote that it was inhumane, unsocial and forest ruled activity of the victorious Mugals for having treated the sikhs in such ill manners. Such dreadful were the scenes, perhaps no body except those who saw could believe." Praise to Banda Singh Bahadhurji. His tremendous sacrifices cannot be forgotten. People can quibble, but look to his actions, at 15 when he killed the deer and so the unborn writhing in pain he went to the holy men and later set up his own Ashram. ps Jatt a separate race, sorry but makes no sense, as North India was already heavily populated before any invader came across the Hindu Kush. The minute number that came later could not have just stayed within their own circle. India had an advanced civilisation as proven by recent archaeological finds, and puts the Aryan invasion nonsense on the dustbin of history where it belongs.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ns · 17 Jun 2006

A.Singh jeeo exactly so "Twareek" that's the one do you know more about its author if so pleae meniton here.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 19 Jun 2006

ns - the author is the famous Nirmala Gyani Gyan Singh. He also authored the second (naveen - or "new") Panth Parkash and other texts. It is from his works that we take the Dohra (agia bahi akaal ki...Guru Maneyo Granth) which is recited at the end of the Ardas. He was a key figure at the times of the Singh Sabha era, although many would associate him with the "Sanatan Sikh" world owing to his Nirmala background. Namdharis love to quote his works given the commentary he has made about them (which is on the whole is quite positive, hence their support for it) although unsurprisingly they claim that he didn't write the 'Guru Maneyo Granth' dohra and that it was inserted by the Singh Sabhias like the famour poet and mystic Bhai Vir Singh (a belief also shared and propagated by the Sanatan Sikhs and Nihangs of the UK). Whatever the case, his contribution to Sikh literature is undoubted, however there are clear indications of bias as there with all authors - so as much as this is going to earn me the wrath of the pro-Jatt lobby, here it is for the record: Just like Bhai Kesar Singh Chibber and Bhai Chaupa Singh (two Brahmin Sikhs - and also let's not forget two Sikhs very closely associated with the Guru Ghar, one of whom also attained shaheedi for the Panth), do in their writings insert pro-Brahmin comments - the same can be said of Gyani Gyan Singh, in that he constructs a fake lineage for himself from Bhai Mani Singh Shaheed (who he claims was a Dulat Jatt - although this is incorrect) and that he is from his family line - this is a common theme observable even today amongst certain key Sikh personalities who love to construct for themselves family lineages where non exist.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

klm · 19 Jun 2006

i think peopl in general have a problem when they stop doing simran and nam their ego creeps in. Its not just punjabis most humans are like that. Gurbani can be very soothing it explains how we all come from one light and to see the same light shining in each other. If we get on with what wer should be doing no problem

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 20 Jun 2006

Veer Kulbir Singh - please could we discuss the pork chops incident outside the Akal Thakt. I personally believe this is true - I cannot see why Rattan Singh Bhangoo would have to lie about this - and I personally see it as a ket turning point in our history where for the first time, Sikh fought Sikh - this legacy continued through the Misl Period and to modern day time (including the events of 1984 where it is well known that Sikhs fought each other in many ways).

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

Harcharan Singh · 21 Jun 2006

To add. http://www.amritworld.com/pbi_articles/banda_singh.pdf

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

ns · 21 Jun 2006

A. Singh Jeeo many Thanks indeed.

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 21 Jun 2006

ns yaara, no problem! Gur Fateh!

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

b senghhhh · 24 Jun 2006

whos rattan singh bungu? he aint guru gobind singh guru sahib is your scholar whatever bani says is all you need. what qualities does meat eating produce? kaam and increasing ego obviously bungu is gonna puff his haumai more and justify his maas munches and lay that on shahids as well. banda singh bahadur wrote history with his own blood

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

A Singh · 29 Jun 2006

b sengggh, perhaps you would like to consider the following: 1. We are discussing history post-Guru Gobind Singh, so this is not contained within his Bachitr Natak. 2. Rattan Singh Bhangoo was the decendent of Bhai Mehtab Singh, who along with Bhai Sukha Singh decapitated Massar Ranghar and also preserved the authencity of the Sri Dasam Granth Sahib therein. 3. Meat eating and kaam/ego is a flawed argument - I've seen pros and cons for and against. In any event, this is not an issue concerning diet, but what happened in History and why...(and what we can learn from it, eating KFC or not is hardly the most intellectual or wise conclusions to draw from the actions of the great Khalsa...surely there is a lot more than this!)

Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?

singhnum1 · 30 Jun 2006

whats being a shahid singhs descendant have to do with anything? shaheed bhai mani singhs descendants converted to arya samaj. who preserved dasam granth?