Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Question Singh · 11 Jun 2005

Could some one please explain what all the different jatha's say about raagmala in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji - like what does AKJ say, Taksaal say...etc, i know for example the Babbar Khalsa believe it should not be put into Guru Granth Sahib Ji...... thanks........... WJKK WJKF!!!

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Gurus Son's brother · 11 Jun 2005

WJKK WJKF Why don't you search for the raagmala threads from previous on-going threads about raagmala. AKJ say raagmala isn't Gurbani but Taksaal it is Gurbani... WJKK WJKF

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

singh · 11 Jun 2005

it shud b ill giv reasoning in other posts i hav 2 find thukhs :P

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Jun 2005

Please read all those older messages on this subject....plus the excellent articles on the Tapoban Site. Then if you still have something new to ask..come back veer.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Akali Fauj · 11 Jun 2005

Missionary also say it is not bani.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

kabadi · 11 Jun 2005

Please Listen to this audio about raag mala http://www.gurmatveechar.com/audio/Sant_Kartar_Singh_%28Bhindran_wale%29/Sant.Kartar.Singh--Raagmala.Viakhya.mp3

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

nanaksar view · 11 Jun 2005

Gurfateh Ji, Nanaksar beleives it's part of satguru's ang. Every Puranmaschi, they recite ragmalla in the course of finishing up the akhand patt.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Khalsa_Force · 12 Jun 2005

>>>>>>>>>>>Nanaksar beleives it's part of satguru's ang. Every Puranmaschi, they recite ragmalla in the course of finishing up the akhand patt.<<<<<<<<<<<< and whts importance of PURANMASHI in sikhism? why only pooranmaschi and not other days? do these sects believe in importance of massia and punia like bahmans do?

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Moorakh · 12 Jun 2005

You know the handwritten Guru Granth Sahib that got stolen by someone in Guru Jee's time, did that have raag mala in?

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Mehtab Singh · 12 Jun 2005

Why doesn't everyone stick to what their Panj Pyaare tell them during Amrit Sanchaar?

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

GoodyTwoShoes · 12 Jun 2005

Rara Sahib Wale believe Raag Mala is Bani

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

singh · 12 Jun 2005

Also majority of the panth who is not associated with a jatha believes it is bani.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Jun 2005

The MP3 provided by kabadi is just a speech by sant ji....touching on different subjects and all here and there compare it to actual Viakhiya like say on Mool mantar of japji sahib or any other Gurbani....WHAT Gurmatt Philosophy can anyone attribute to a list of raag names...their wives and daughters sons etc... NO such Genealogy exists even of the GURU SAHIBAANS as it is NOT Gurmatt to include such details in Dhur ki bani Granth of Shabad Jyot. And the ref to Raags being humans having wives and sons daughters etc is unscientific..if that is the case what is ROCK music..their grand-sons..Hard Rock..their Great Grand sons or what ?? NOT a Single Panktee in Gurbani is UNSCIENTIFIC.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

nihang singh · 12 Jun 2005

nihangs believe RAGMALA is BANI, we have LINEAGE from GURU GOBIND SINGH, we follow puratan maryada.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

/ · 12 Jun 2005

Akj says that ragmala was added from alam's bani. But it could very well be that copied raagmala from Adi Granth. Still Guru Arjan Dev Sahib jee's shabad in aasaa raag ang 487 (m5 gobind gobind gobind sang---) in with they do not put nanak stamp at the end; is sung by hindus as a bhajan in temples. There are many shabads in which Nanak has not been added at the end of the shabads. A gursikh told me that ragmala is the creation of Guru Arjan Dev Sahib jee.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 13 Jun 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear Author:/ jio, The serious mickey that puts the spanner in your arguemnt is that the FEW PANKTEES of the "raagmaala appended to Guru garnth Sahib Jee" FIT in so well into the FEW HUNDRED PANKTEES that Alam Wrote in his BOOK. Now if someone takes out [gurbani] p P b B m [/gurbani] from the Paintee and appends it to some other place... and the entire [gurbani] a A e s h k K g G ..... p P b B m...... X r l v V [/gurbani] are in a DIFFERENT BOOK written by an AUTHOR....and Follow in PROPER SEQUENCE... Then somebody comes along and contends ( like you did)..maybe this writer stole the [gurbani] p P b B m [/gurbani] from US and FIXED it up in His Book...What would you beleive.... The Panktees of Raagmaala appended to Guru Granth Ji SAHIB are PROPERLY NUMBERED IN SEQUENCE in Alam's book..and appear in the MIDDLE of the Book... but in GURU GRANTH the COPIER forgot the numbering ( maybe to HIDE his COPY CAT ATTEMPT at FORGERY/PLAGIRISATION) and Numberd ALL the Panktees [1] from beginning to End. If you read Alam's Book..YOu will Find the raagmaala panktees in the middle, IN proper sequence and COMPLETELY IN PLACE with the rest of the POEM. IT is IMPOSSIBLE fro an author to write ABCDEF.....to Z in Proper sequenbce and then be accused of "stealing" JKLMNO....from some other composition. I would say the evidence point to the THIEF who stole JKLMNO from the entire ABCDEF...XYZ author. Get me an ANSWER to this RIDDLE..from Gurmatvechaar .com or any others

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

vichar · 13 Jun 2005

well said vir jarnail singh gyiani arshi, truth always makes sense.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

d · 13 Jun 2005

ahahahaha.wot is with all these raagmala posts.ppl seem to b gettin a bit bored so like to raise up controversial issues.i think the topic should be banned for ppl who dont have naam, bani kamaaayee..actualy those gursikhs dont even bother with these topics.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Amarjeet Singh · 13 Jun 2005

d, if you dont have anything intelligent to say keep it to yourself, discussing raagmala is good as it one of the major controversial issues in the panth and has to be resolved and the filth of raagmala has to cleared from the guru granth sahib ji as it is defiling the true form of the guru

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Dogma · 13 Jun 2005

Amarjeet Singh Jee, I personally found "d's" post to be quite intelligent as this topic has been discussed numerous times in the past few months and each time NO RESOLUTION to the issue has been found. However, perhaps discussing this issue AGAIN might somehow magically lead to all reaching a single conclusion and all accepting this as the truth...yes yes...now, come to think of it...I believe the message board on Tapoban.org will miraculously SOLVE this issue for the Panth. Who cares about all the scholars who have debated this issue in the past. I FULLY and FIRMLY believe that we as a bunch of "sikhitothemax scholars" have the knowledge and have performed enough research on this subject to FINALLY SOLVE this Panthic Issue. pssshhh...forget about Akal Takhat...who are they? Who cares if they're SUPPOSED to be authority on Panthic issues...I know that the message board on tapoban.org will provide the same unbiased objective view on this issue as Akal Takhat could. So by all means Amarjeet Singh jee, provide the sangat with some evidence regarding Raagmala (that we HAVEN"T heard before) that will make all of us reach an epiphany regarding this subject. Please...enlighten us. As you say discussing Raagmala is a "good" thing...and this issue has to be "resolved"...Please be kind dear sir and "resolve" it for the Panth...

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Singh · 13 Jun 2005

The vast majority of the Panth does not do enough Naam Kamai, keep enough Rehat or have enough Pyaar, so how does finding out what other people believe help you?

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Amarjeet Singh · 13 Jun 2005

No Dogma you are quite right, the fact that kachi bani is in the guru granth sahib is no problem at all we shoouldnt discuss it we should just ignore it, even though that the guru is the most important thing in sikhi it doesnt matter lets not discuss it lets brush it under the carpet and pretend its not happening, which is a paap letting guru ji being deformed. i didnt say i would solve the problem and if ur jus gonnah use the old "akaal takht say its bani" akaal takht say its ok to eat meat, which obiously is also incorrect. i am not saying i have evidence that ppl havent heard before and i can resolve anyting i am jus sayin ignorin the fact that kachi bani is in the guru granth sahib isnt helpin anything

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Dogma · 13 Jun 2005

Amarjeet Singh, Please realize that your whole arguement about kachi bani being in Sri Guru Granth Sahib is merely your opinion. Your opinion of a "paap" being committed is precisely that...your opinion. Please be don't be confused brother...I'm NOT saying this issued should be ignored. I'm saying that I've seen Raagmala be discussed COUNTLESS times on this forum. The views of AKJ, TAKSAAL, etc are EASILY accessbile to everyone via Internet. Tapoban has a very good article regarding their Anti-Raagmala stance. My point is only that tapoban.org is not the Panth. It's not even CLOSE to being a proper representation of the Panth. Instead of us fighting amongst ourselves over this issue .. WHY DO I NEVER SEE PEOPLE WRITING AND PRESSURING AKAL TAKHAT TO SIT DOWN AND RESOLVE THIS ISSUE ONCE AND FOR ALL????? We all agree that we would abide by Akal Takhat's ruling...so why not pressure Akal Takhat to give the Panth a resolution????? I just hate seeing fighting amongst my brothers/sisters regarding this topic when I know an END to the bickering can be accomplished by one edict by Akal Takhat. On that note...Amarjeet Singh, I apologize for replying to your original post with such sarcasm and negativity. My response to your post was not how a Singh should treat his fellow brother and for that I apologize to you and hope you accept my apology. Maaf Karnaa veerji.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh..

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

- · 14 Jun 2005

I personally think this site should ban all discussions on raag mala (for or against) and any other controversial subject matter that the panth has not come to a definite agreement on. Most of the people that post just seem to want to stir up trouble or showcase their "knowledge", funny how they can comment on things like this and spend so much time on the net and have the endless need to "advise" others whilst portraying such a gumukh style jeeven, you know who you are. raag mala this kes/keski that, meat vs vegi ect... its shameful, why don’t you ban these subjects? You think these subjects haven't been discussed before? The subjects have been discussed before most of us were even born. If you're all that bothered go in front of akaal thakhth and say it instead of sitting in front of ur pc's showcasing ur pointless and petty arguments. Sites like this should be used for inspiration, not fuel controversy. No doubt, there'll be people who'll reply to this and say something about the need to discuss these matters, to those I simply say again, if ur so bothered, go to the akal thakhth and voice ur opinions there first [%sig%]

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

Amarjeet Singh · 14 Jun 2005

dogma ji, i accept your apologies of course and offer my own vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

kkd · 14 Jun 2005

Dogma-you are a gangsta.totally agree with everything uve jus sed.

Re: Raagmala - opinions of the different jatha's

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 15 Jun 2005

Please read the e-book on this site.. http://srec.gurmat.info/srecpublications/aboutcompilationofsrigurugranthsahib/ You will be surprised at the info given....HOW EXTRA compositions were Cleverly added to Guru Granth Ji Sahib.... the "forgers" removing sheafs of 25 aangs....and RECOPYING them and their NEW ADDITIONS....so that the last sheaf would look like same ink, same paper, same handwriting....to confuse sikhs.... who would compare 25 aangs just to check if Raagmala is written by somebody else...people..even "scholars" just checked a few aangs backward and concluded the same paper/ink/hand etc...the Paper/ink/hand ONLY CHANGES about 25 aangs BACK !!! clever ?? you bet . Read WHEN these changes occured.. Read WHO was responsivble for these changes and WHY ?? Read all the Utter RUBBISH SAKHIS in the Totally SPURIOUS bhai bala janamsakhi....all of them COPIED from Original Stories word for word from MUSLIM SOUrces, King Solomon etc...only where in the Original it is King Solomon who Visits the Kingdom of the Ants...in this Janmasakhi it is Guru nanak Ji who visits KEERRA Nagar !!! Fantastic !!! A thoroughly good read...read with an open mind. http://srec.gurmat.info/srecpublications/aboutcompilationofsrigurugranthsahib/