Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kalyug mein kirtan "PARDHAANA" ?? how

Kalyug mein kirtan "PARDHAANA" ?? how

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 12 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh. from another Forum.. Gurbani says..Kalyug mein kirtan Pardhaana... The Traditional way this tuk has been interpreted is that in KALYUG..Keertan is Pardhana..that is BEST way of doing Bhagtee../Simran/Naam Japp... But the other unusual interpretation ........inspired that ONE of the "qualities" or attributes of KALYUG is that Keertan becomes Pardhaana !! just may be true..looking at the Kirtan Darbars, Mahaan Kirtan Darbars, MEGA Kirtan darbars, movies, VCDs CDs DVDs...ALL the MASSIVE COMMERCILISATION of "kirtan of Gurbani" going on Means it is PARDHAAN in KALYUG. Now a days simple gurabni kirtan out of Pyaar/nishkam seva is NO MORE.... every third grade kirtan jatha promotes itself to be HAZOORI RAAGI...and have RATES to perform..no "free kirtan" !!! The way the Gurdwara parbhandaks run after the raagis...indeed Kirtan is PARDHAANA...super highway to riches..and increased GOLUK....Everybody just discusses the latest raagi, latest CD/VCD/DVD...latest tune, fantastic video....NOTHING ABOUT GURBANI....AUTHENTIC RAAG....??? What an interpretation ?? What do the readers have to say Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi

Re: Kalyug mein kirtan "PARDHAANA" ?? how

jss · 12 Jun 2005

i think the true meaning is the FIRST interpretation... i think your second interpretation is being derived MORE from what you are seeing happening, rather than from the gurbani itself...i guess that sucks of our time...that we have degraded things such as kirtan by commercializing it taht people are forced to look at the meanings of gurbani in different ways.. by the way...jarnail singh ji... when you say there is not nishkaam seva of kirtan...i feel you are wrong about that...there is a lot of nishkam kirtan programs going on all the time... in fact, i have been attending sangat/samagams all my life....i've probably never attended a kirtan program that wasn't nishkam seva....except when i go to the gurdwara and listen to the ragis there....but even those guys aren't really advertising..they're just doing kirtan..and we give bheta out of respect that they spend their whole time in doing that.... but yes...probably on the whole...you are right that ther is a lot of commercialization of kirtan...perhaps it occurs more in singapore/malaysia than here in canada...you should just pick up and move here...

Re: Kalyug mein kirtan "PARDHAANA" ?? how

.. · 13 Jun 2005

Kirtan should always be done in Raag whenever possible. I am ashamed to see the way most people do Kirtan, shouting as if God is deaf.

Re: Kalyug mein kirtan "PARDHAANA" ?? how

jaswant singh · 13 Jun 2005

At least they aint making bhangra videos, they are doing kirtan, alteast when these kirtan darbars are happaning alot of sangat come to the gurdwara. Their time is not wasted by listening to kirtan, uppar likhia janda hai. All your actions are written down, if there were no kirtan dabars then the sangat will probably be at home watching tv or wot not. So its beter than staying at home. The ragi's do get into homay (ego) but that is their own karam and they will pay for that in the court of the lord. If you can organise a kirtan darbar where the kirtani's perform for free and they do authentic raag, then sangat will glady be happy to come and listen. But everyone needs to make a living. Kirt Karane, Vand Ke Shaknaa and Naam Japna. So is better working in a factory or a desk all day? or isit better doing kirtan and naam simran all day which will help in your next life. Think about it. do not say baad things about ragi's or any other people that means u are just doing nindia. At least parchar is being done by all these tapes and vcd's and there are those in the sangat who DO listen to the gurbani.

Re: Kalyug mein kirtan "PARDHAANA" ?? how

Can't think of a name.. · 13 Jun 2005

'Raag it up' [%sig%]