CHICKEN FLAVOURED CRISPS
@@@ · 15 Jun 2005
Is it worng to eat chicken flavoured crisps, I like the taste , no chcickens are harmed in the production !!
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
@@@ · 15 Jun 2005
Is it worng to eat chicken flavoured crisps, I like the taste , no chcickens are harmed in the production !!S Singh · 15 Jun 2005
Well side of packet states suitable for vegetarians. They use flavouring to get the chicken taste (which does not come from chickens, just like those hedgehog flavour crisps do not use hedgehogs to get the flavour ) so eat as many packets as you want. The only crisps you had to be wary of was cheese and onion as they had some animal rennat or something in them but even they are ok now so you can enjoy all flavours of crisps.Kulbir Singh · 15 Jun 2005
There is no need to eat chicken flavoured crisps. As the matter of fact whether the crisps are flavoured or not, still they should not be consumed by Gursikhs because eating from the hands of meat eating, hair-cutting, fornicaters, adulterer, or tobacco-consuming people is against Gurmat. So the best thing is to avoid eating from outside. Daas, Kulbir SinghGurus Son · 15 Jun 2005
Wjkk Wjkf But kulbir ji aint crisps made from machines and things like that? Wjkk Wjkfsingh · 15 Jun 2005
yeh but its hard to stop eating from outside - what else are u spose to eat - and anyway the food is factory preocessed.@@@ · 15 Jun 2005
I've worked in a factory where crisps are made and the only handling do by humans was packing them into the boxes everything else is done by machines.amarjeet singh · 15 Jun 2005
yeh but machines arent amritdharee as far as i know and we are only suppoesed to eat from amritdhareeskabadi · 15 Jun 2005
Author: amarjeet singh Date: 06-15-05 09:30 yeh but machines arent amritdharee as far as i know and we are only suppoesed to eat from amritdharees ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- hahahha oh mannn thats a classic....S Singh · 15 Jun 2005
Are cows amritdharee cus they biologically prepare milk and we drink it.Kulbir Singh · 15 Jun 2005
S. Singh, The concept of Bibek is that you can buy or get raw materials from anywhere but the cooking must be done by a Khalsa. Gursikhs buy daal, sabjee from outside but they cook it afterwards to get the mohar of Khalsa on food. This has been discussed many times before. I recommend that you go through old posts and then if you have any doubts, post your doubts. Kulbir SinghS Singh · 16 Jun 2005
Well Kulbir Singh Ji. So how you drink milk ? You got your own cow ? Milk is a raw product which does not require any cooking. So do you cook your milk and consume it as koya or do you add milkshake powder to keep within Bibek ?Kabaddi Singh · 16 Jun 2005
Can we eat grass as I know that none amritdaris have walked on it?? I think that the most important thing is your health.... If you lack somthing in your body then you need to get it... no matter what that means.... Your body is the first temple..... if you have good health then you can meditate.... work.... help others..... fight oppression..... Let's not be so niave and start looking at the bigger picture of how we can start making chicken flavour crisps ourselves then..... Get a life gents.... can you not think of a better topic..hmm · 16 Jun 2005
Can gursikhs take life-saving drugs that may have been manufactured by the hands of meat eating, hair-cutting, fornicaters, adulterer, or tobacco-consuming people? or are they supposed to make their own drugs from the basic ingredients? hmmstranger · 16 Jun 2005
Kulbir Singh Why do u hate non-sikhs so much '......meat eating, hair-cutting, fornicaters, adulterer, or tobacco-consuming people......? Guru Granth Sahib Ji does not teach hatred or treat people who are not the Sikhi paath as low life like your statement does............ People with this type of attitude are causing such hatred for faiths/religions around the globe.Kulbir Singh · 16 Jun 2005
------------- Well Kulbir Singh Ji. So how you drink milk ? You got your own cow ? Milk is a raw product which does not require any cooking. So do you cook your milk and consume it as koya or do you add milkshake powder to keep within Bibek ? -------------- Considering milk a raw product, I (like many other singhs) boil milk in Sarbloh before consuming it. In any case, what I do personally is not in question here. We are talking about Bibek Sarbloh rehit and not what Kulbir Singh eats and what he does not eat. Kulbir SinghKulbir Singh · 16 Jun 2005
------------- Can gursikhs take life-saving drugs that may have been manufactured by the hands of meat eating, hair-cutting, fornicaters, adulterer, or tobacco-consuming people? or are they supposed to make their own drugs from the basic ingredients? hmm -------------- There is a difference between eating food and taking medicine. From what I have learned, most Gursikhs avoid medicine but if some Gursikh does take medicine, it is not considered a defection from rehit. Don’t mix up bibek related to food with taking medicine for certain ailment. Daas, Kulbir SinghFYI Singh · 16 Jun 2005
meat eating, hair-cutting, fornicaters, adulterer, or tobacco-consuming people......? these are my fellow brothers and sisters...yes they do not follow the same religion that i do, but never the less, they too are gods children. Just becasue they see things differently, does not mean we condem them! Considering that some of my fellow brothers/sisters do SO much simran, boy-oh-boy, the simran is not kicking in....hatred is what it is, period! tunnel vision/wearing blinkers on ones mind eye/ can/will lead to the so-called 'talibanesque' attitides sometimes aired here on this forum. Makes me sick.Kulbir Singh · 16 Jun 2005
----------- Kulbir Singh Why do u hate non-sikhs so much '......meat eating, hair-cutting, fornicaters, adulterer, or tobacco-consuming people......? Guru Granth Sahib Ji does not teach hatred or treat people who are not the Sikhi paath as low life like your statement does............ People with this type of attitude are causing such hatred for faiths/religions around the globe. -------------- How is keeping bibek and not eating from non-amritdharis hating non-amritdharis? Gursikhs who don’t eat from non-amritdharis don’t do so because of hatred or other negative feelings but they do so because keeping bibek is a hukam of Guru Sahib (check other posts for more details). In their mind they have love for all creatures and hatred for none. It seems like according to your opinion, ones who eat from just anywhere and anyone don’t hate anyone and have love for the ones they eat from. If this had been true, then there would have been peace and harmony in the whole world but we all know how much peace is there. Kulbir SinghKulbir Singh · 16 Jun 2005
FYI Singh. ------------- meat eating, hair-cutting, fornicaters, adulterer, or tobacco-consuming people......? these are my fellow brothers and sisters...yes they do not follow the same religion that i do, but never the less, they too are gods children. Just becasue they see things differently, does not mean we condem them! --------- Eating from them does not do them any good. Not eating from them and by doing so obeying the hukams of Guru Sahib does not condemn them as you have written. It is your "tunnel thinking" and "maayiya vaadi thinking" that has prompted you to come to this conclusion. I suggest that you open the "khazaana" (Treasure, Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee) and read what our Guru Sahibaan have written about Bibek and association with manmukhs. ---------- tunnel vision/wearing blinkers on ones mind eye/ can/will lead to the so-called 'talibanesque' attitides sometimes aired here on this forum. ------------ If obeying hukams of Guru Sahib leads one to “talibanesque” then so be it. We have no intention of becoming milgobha Khalsa or some lallee-chhalee person. Guru Sahib has made us his Khalsa and has instructed us to remain “niyaara”. --------- Makes me sick. ---------- Makes me feel sorry for you because you are deprived of the true Khalsa spirit that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj. Kulbir Singhsikh wit it · 16 Jun 2005
Even though i do not keep bibek myself respected guriskhs in taksal and akj both have some form of bibek, has nothing to do with hating on non amritdaree people.boo · 16 Jun 2005
machines are sarblohi though :PS Singh · 16 Jun 2005
So whats Bibek got to do with Chicken flavour crisps ? I once went on a yatra and there was a person carrying their metal dishes and drinking glass around with them. Strange thing was they were always happy to eat ice creams etc but when it came to langar they wanted everything in their special metal dishes. Why is it ok to eat an ice cream made by non amritdhari (the desi ones on sticks) yet you cannot eat langar like rest of people in langar hall ?Hari Singh · 16 Jun 2005
S Singh, A Singh who kept bibek would only eat from amritdharis. If, as you claim, this person was eating ice-cream made my non-amritdhari then he wasn't a bibeki. To be honest, your story seems made up so you can show bibeki's in a bad light. If this is the case then it is bad karma for you to do nindia of sarblohi singhs.Kulbir Singh · 16 Jun 2005
S. Singh, There are two possibilities about your story. Either this story is a made up story as Hari Singh pointed out or this person who was eating ice-cream from outside in some metal bowl, must have been an ignorant person. Bibek comes before Sarbloh. You can't have Sarbloh without bibek and Bibek rehit does not allow you to eat ice creams from outside. Kulbir SinghS Singh · 16 Jun 2005
Thanks Hari Singh and Kulbir Singh for calling me a liar. The story is not made up it is 100% true. I do not know the womens name but she was from Coventry travelling with her husband and son. She eat ice cream and was even drinking juice out of a bottle. But for some reason Guru ka langar had to be in her metal dish. One of the days her metal drinking cup was rolling about on the bus floor and I picked it up and put it on the top luggage/bag shelf on the bus. Do you guys also take your metal dishes to use when eating Guru ka langar ?Kulbir Singh · 16 Jun 2005
---------- The story is not made up it is 100% true. I do not know the womens name but she was from Coventry travelling with her husband and son. She eat ice cream and was even drinking juice out of a bottle. But for some reason Guru ka langar had to be in her metal dish. ---------- 1) How did you assume she was a Bibeki Gursikh? 2) What was your purpose of narrating this story under this thread? 3) You did not specify if it was sarbloh. It seems like this "metal cup" you are referring to was not sarbloh. -------- Do you guys also take your metal dishes to use when eating Guru ka langar ? ----------- Why would we bring our "metal dishes" when eating Guru ka Langar? Aren't these provided when they serve Guru ka Langar? Whenever we are blessed with "Guru ka Langar", we have no qualms over eating it. Kulbir Singhtera baap · 16 Jun 2005
i thin the major hidden variable hear is the fact that most ppl are to lazy to keep bebik and therefore they insult it to make themselves look rite, or provide fake stories. this is called cognitive dissonance and it will lead to ppl to make any excuse they can, so they feel right even if they dont have a good reason to beleive what they do. why is that when someone brings up bebik all these stories just pop out of nowhere. And why the hell wud u want to eat chiken chips, what are u guys so attached to maya that u cant let go the taste of chiken?Can't think of a name.. · 16 Jun 2005
Its so sad when someone gets accused of lying and concocting stories when all the people who have suggested the story may be made up have no reason to suggest it may be made up.. It seems some people just aren’t prepared to hear anything that seems to be opposite of they believe is true. There’s no reason to not believe ‘S Singh’s’ story, say why you think its not true with evidence, S Singh saw it with his eyes, what proof do you have to prove its made up? Peace :-) [%sig%]RoopKaur · 16 Jun 2005
1. It does not matter whether the story was made up or not, there was no point in posting it under this thread as it does not prove anything. 2. A pedophile is also Gods child, will you happily eat out of a pedophile's hands? Gurbani calls those who are be amriteeay so bad that even their name is bad, so now is gurbani hating on Gods children? Is a person who obeys gurus jis hukam and keeps rehit more loving and kind, or a person who does not give two hoots about what guru ji has told his Sikhs to do and eats from any person more kind. 3. Sikhi is not an easy path to follow. Please stop trying to simplify it to fit your so called modern life. Just because in this day and age we can get everything instantly and have to do less and less work because of technology, does not mean we can simplify Sikhi, as Sikhi is beyond this age, it is perfect the way my guru ji made it, keep your man mat out of it. 4. If you cannot follow the examples of gurmukhs that sacrificed so much but did not give up their love for Sikhi, yet todays modern Sikhs cannot even sacrifice on a bag of chips, than the least you can do is do is stop from embarrasing yourself by talking against guru jis rehit. 5. What makes you better than my guru ji to say that what he said, ex. that all Sikhs should eat from amritdharees only, who give you the hak (right) to change my guru jis hukam? Kis mooh naal tu guru ji da Sikh kahaundaa aapney aap nuu? What kind of disciple turns his back on his guru ji and talks bad about his rehit? Do you think guru ji will pat you on the head with pyar for talking against his rehit and against his gursikhs who keep his rehit?Singh · 16 Jun 2005
The story may be true. I can give examples of Amritdharis who are Pakhandhees who do bad things. Does this mean being Amritdhari is bad? No. The foundation of Bibek is indeed Pyaar and without this Pyaar Bibek is an empty Rehat. With the Pyaar like all other Rehats it serves as a tool to help on the path to Guru Ji. When Singhs for the Panj Pyare are picked, are we hateful when we choose the most Gurmukh Singhs? If a Mona asks to do Seva in the Panj Pyare are we being evil and discriminatory because we say no? Ideal Gursikh would touch his feet and say Sorry Veer Ji but Hukam of Maharaj is most important to me. I know Bibeki Singhs who display such Daya to fellow human beings regardless of religion or standing, they would put you anti-Bibekis to shame.hey · 16 Jun 2005
hmm this must be some kirpa as me and my dad were discussing this the other day but came to no conclusions so sangat ji should be eat from ppl who are not guru valea ?UK Nihang Singh · 17 Jun 2005
Keep Bibek is a wicked Rehat, I really do feel sorry for the singhs that have a problem with it. Dal in Sarbloh batta is great, you guys should see Nihangs in Punjab cook they own food eat in Sarbloh batta... · 17 Jun 2005
Why would you want the taste of animal's in your mouth? yukAmarjeet Singh · 06 Jul 2005
To kulbir, you say that you keep sarbloh rehit, and you say that a bibeki should eat only raw food products, so i ask you this, how is supermarket milk which has been handled by manmukhs therefore making it jooth, made bibek by boiling it? how does boiling milk make it bibek it makes it more hygenic but not more bibek. if you want to keep strcit bibek milk you should milk the cow or at least obtain the milk form the cow before it has been proceesed to be oridanry supermarket milkKulbir Singh · 06 Jul 2005
Veer Amarjit Singh, First of all, please accept my benti. We should address fellow gursikhs by their full name. For you to call me “Kulbir” is against Gurmat. My name is Kulbir Singh and I like to be addressed by my full name. Please accept my benti. ________ To kulbir, you say that you keep sarbloh rehit, and you say that a bibeki should eat only raw food products, so i ask you this, how is supermarket milk which has been handled by manmukhs therefore making it jooth, made bibek by boiling it? how does boiling milk make it bibek it makes it more hygenic but not more bibek. if you want to keep strcit bibek milk you should milk the cow or at least obtain the milk form the cow before it has been proceesed to be oridanry supermarket milk -------------- I have made this clear before also and I will repeat it again. Bibek is about cooking food. Raw materials or raw ingredients can be bought from the market. In some cases cooked materials e.g. sugar, Brown sugar, oil, Desi ghee, etc can be bought cooked-up as well. Milk, in my opinion, falls under the category of raw ingredient. We buy milk from supermarket and boil it in Sarbloh and thus put the mohar of Khalsa on it. You write that I say that I keep Sarbloh Rehit. I have never claimed to be a perfect Sarblohi Bibeki. A mortal being cannot be Pooran Bibeki. Only Guru Kartar can be pooran Bibek (Baddo Bibeki, as written in Gurbani). As gursikhs, we should try to meet minimum standards set by puraatan Singhs. From what I know, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee did not used to accept milk from bazaar but he did not consider buying milk from bazaar, below the minimum level of Bibek. Bhai Jodh Singh has written that he used to buy milk from outside sometimes, and he was allowed to do sewa in Punj Pyaaray, during the time of Bhai Sahib. Same way, Bhai Atama Singh Panjokhra Sahib too confirmed that buying milk from outside does not violate the minimum standards of Bibek. Given the resources we have in these Western countries, we try our best to keep as much Bibek as possible. Just because we cannot get milk straight from cow does not mean that we should give up rest of the Bibek considering it futile. Daas, Kulbir Singh,,, · 06 Jul 2005
How about colgate? Do you cook it or make it at home? How about soap?Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 06 Jul 2005
It is a known fact that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji used to milk his own cow from his Jail Chitteeaa(n). This probably changed though when he got released from jail. However, Daas must say that Bhai Kulbir Singh is correct in having rightfully stated that we should live up to at least the minimum standards set by the Puraatan Sikhs. If we want to be pooran in this Jeevan, then we must 'learn from history'. Also, if one lives in Western Countries, then it is almost impossible to be Kattar (Strict) in the Rehat of Sarbloh Bibek.RoopKaur · 06 Jul 2005
>How about colgate? Do you cook it or make it at home? How about soap?< I dont know about you, but all the bibeki Singhs I know do not eat their colgate or soap.Amarjeet Singh · 06 Jul 2005
veer kulbir singh it is against gurmat to incorrectly spell my name, it is amarjeet not amarjit. and to ,,, do you eat colgate or soap? to kulbir singh please prove to me that bhai sahib ever drank milk from outside? when he was in jail one of the jail attendants was going to bring the milk for him but he didnt allow this as he wanted to get his milk himself. im not saying that because you buy milk from the supermarket you should give up bibkek altogther, of course not, we should all do the best we can, all im saying is that boiling the milk will not make it any more bibek. also why is it against gurmat to call you kulbir?... · 06 Jul 2005
Amarjeet Singh, you need to cool down. For your own sake I'll tell you that it is a serious bad karma to knowingly insult a Singh. Kulbir Singh never claimed that Bhai Sahib drank outside milk. He never did. Kulbir Singh doesn't claim that drinking outside milk is ok. It's doing the best you can in the situation you are in. If you think its very wrong and don't want to drink it, then more power to you. I'll consider you a stronger bibeki for it. I personally can't do that though.singh · 06 Jul 2005
wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh! Bhai Kulbir singh jee, ideally i hope some day to stop drinking milk from outside altogether essentially buying milk from outside in India in the olden days was okay because the cows were treated with respect even in this day they are treated with respect but in America or CAnada, 1) cows are hooked up to machines to be milked 2) so many chemicals are injected into cows to adjust their milk 3) so many hormones are injected into cows to make them produce more 4) the people milking the cow may be smoking or cursing while milking the cow 5) the atmosphere of suffering and pain around the cow probably affects their milk as well 6) because of all of these, we have so many illnesses in the West --- because all kids drink store-bought milk which is horrible hopefuly with guru ji's kirpa i will be able to buy Organic milk in the future if my family lets me. wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh!Kulbir Singh · 06 Jul 2005
My mistake Bhai Amarjeet Singh jeeo for misspelling your name. I have already written my stand on milk issue on the previous post. No need to repeat it. Kulbir Singhsingh · 06 Jul 2005
kulbir singh ji what are your thoughts re: my post above ? about organic milk ?