Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

ksr · 16 Jun 2005

i personally respect all jathabandia's n dnt want any one to be offended but when i go to AKJ rehansabhai's i luv the keertan n the way the sangat gets involved... BUT... then i get really offeneded when 'Waheguru' isn't pronounced correctly. Naam simran is done perfectly fine, fast and slow its just you always get sumone really LOUD chanting 'Waheguru' n after 'Wahe' comes 'Grooooooo' and not 'Guru'. i'v been raised that not pronouncing gurbani correctly ON PURPOSE is a paap n therefore manmat. im not saying the person(s) are doing it out of spite but maybe they get lost in the keertan and forget but shouldn't the sangat put them right im not saying 'Waheguru' can't be repeated fast, it can be repeated fast provided the shabd 'Waheguru' is still being ponounced correctly n not just mumbled [%sig%]

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Mkhalsa · 16 Jun 2005

Saying GRooo in the way you are thinking is proper gurmat vidii....... if u know what naam drirh is, ie naam taught by panj pyare and instilled in your heart, then you will understand why it is done that way. there are other mispronunciations done sometimes ie...WAHGO WAHGO WAHGO etc... but, if the person isnt doing it on purpose and not doing it out of show but this is what is coming from their soul, I really cannot comment on it, its not our place.

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Tee · 17 Jun 2005

maybe you should pay less atention to them, and listen to the gurbani kirtan.

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

me · 17 Jun 2005

proper gurmat vidii....... So it is part of Gurmat to distort the name of God? Interesting.

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

singh · 17 Jun 2005

if you are so concerned about the distortation of the gurmantar. please do read the following puratan granths: prem surag granth (written some time in the 1700s, unclear) sau sakhi (early 1800s, or guru gobind singh jis pen depending on school of thought) bhagat ratnavali (bhai mani singhs writing, so pre 1734) you will find references to the vidhi for simran. when this is repeated loudly, and quickly, to one who is ignorant of this vidhi, it will sound odd. if you are very offended by this "grrrr" you will certainly take time out to read the aforemented (all non akj) sources for guidance on repetition of the gurmantar. good luck in your research!

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

ksr · 17 Jun 2005

'Tee' ur 100% rite, i should be focussing more on myself n payin less attention to others. But it can be hard because they can be quite loud. hopefully Waheguru will do kirpa on me to do so i will surely do more research into this field, thank you 'singh'

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

me · 17 Jun 2005

I dont care about the 'above non akj sources', why distort the name of God? It doesnt mean anything when you pronounce it in such weird ways. repeated loudly, and quickly, Is God deaf? Or does he have no time? or maybe you dont have time to say it properly. It was this point that Guru Nanak Dev Ji made in response to the way the Mullah's shouted His name from the mosques. So go research that, and yeah..good luck!

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

singh · 17 Jun 2005

"me" had you looked at the above references you would see puratan granths tell the seeker to repeat the name of waheguru with a vidhi as is done by many singhs and singhanis at rensbais. as per sau sakhi reference is mata bhaag kaur and guru gobind singh guilty of using these "weird ways"? if you were to breathe in and out, repeating wahe and guru, does this mean you have distorted waheguru and reduced it to the sound of breath? or if you are jogging, and internally, you are saying wahe - guru every time your feet touch the floor, is this distorting the gurmantar into foot sounds! the gurmantar is the most powerful thing in the universe - it is not just a word you hear with your ear! it goes past what you can hear and into the realms of the anhad shabad! by gurus grace some people are blessed with amrit and they repeat naam until they are in such a state of anand and sometimes their voice may go extremely high (you may have heard keertanees reciting shabads in such a high voice before that it sounds "weird") and they are repeating the name of god with their swaas. by gurus hukam others do not experience the same maha anand. we should do ardas so that every being is able to get full lahaa from naam and bani! when a seeker is repeating the name of god with his swas he is not doing it for the benefit of people around him or to show a "meaning". he is doing it as his own abhiyaas. he is not worried about what other people think of him. many thought the bhagats were crazy or mad. we should do simran in every way all the time - sitting down standing up, whilst walking, running, driving, doing it slowly and silently, fast and loud, if we have pyaar then guru ji will bless us no matter where, when and how we do simran, if we are aiming to do it swaas swaas (with every breath) please correct me if i have made any mistakes

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Kulbir Singh · 17 Jun 2005

------- Is God deaf? Or does he have no time? or maybe you dont have time to say it properly. It was this point that Guru Nanak Dev Ji made in response to the way the Mullah's shouted His name from the mosques. ----------- "me", God is surely not deaf but our mann is very stubborn. It does not want to engage in the divine service of Vaheguru by japping Naam. It does not want to listen to Naam. Louder you say Naam, better it is and more concentration it gets. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written in his books that the use of Rasna for Naam Japna does not stop even in the highest spiritual states. True, Naam can be japped in Surthee too and that is how it should be done during the day when we are doing works of the world but when one is in the sangat of Gurmukhs and when Gurmukhs are doing Naam Abhyaas, there is no need to sit there being a "Ghugoo Matt" (silent spectator). That is the time and place to do Naam abhyaas as loudly as possible. Louder the better. As for japping Naam in open, during Kirtan of Gurbani Shabad, it is my humble opinion that it should be avoided. When doing Gurbani kirtan, Nirole (pure) Gurbani Kirtan should be done. Guru Sahib has written Gurbani in a certain form and sequence. Why should be add things from outside while singing the shabad? How is saying "Dhan Guru Nanak" or "Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Sahib" right, while in the middle of the shabad? How is doing "Vaheguru Vaheguru" during the shabad correct, when Guru Sahib has kept Naam gupt in Gurbani and it is not written in the shabad? As per puraatan Singhs, in olden times and during the times of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, the present form of dhuni (doing Vaheguru Vaheguru) in kirtan was not prevelant. Baaki Guru Sahib hee jaan de hunn. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 17 Jun 2005

We should do Simran in however way we find comfortable. At the end of the day, we want to Jap Athai Pehr. Obviously, the most affective way is doing it with the Swaas (breaths), however; this is personally speaking. Others may find that they get Ras another way.

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

RoopKaur · 17 Jun 2005

>Others may find that they get Ras another way.< Since there is only one naam, and only one bidhi that the panj pyarey teach us, which is saas saas, how can people get ras any other way? The only way to ultimate ras is the way that puraatan Singhs took, the way that Guru Sahib showed us how to take in this age, and that way is through getting naam drir and learning the bidhi of japping naam from the panj pyarey. Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee have written about the Gurmat Vidhi in his books. Bhai Mani Singh too has written about this Swaas Swaas, Ardh Urdhee Gurmat Vidhi. There cannot be another way.

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

me · 17 Jun 2005

Interesting Kulbir Singh, I agree with you about keeping Gurbani Keertan free of any Jaap etc. also.

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

BirRaas Singh · 17 Jun 2005

"singh", the Sau Sakhi chapter "Mata Jeeto Ji" goes into more detail about the way to do simran then just "breathe in wahe, breathe out guru", it mentions listening to raag kirtan prior to simran, the use of 7 chakras and trai kutiya concentration, do AKJ also teach the same technique or an expunged version of it?

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

singh · 18 Jun 2005

Kulbir singh I think you are wrong, maybe we should keep the kirtan akhand with nothing put into it i.e naam simran, but theres no harm in saying waheguru and especialy when you do it at the right time - say the kirtani is singing Jis ke vadbhaga laal rang tis ko luga, i think its more then better to do abiyaas after that shabad and then going on to the next line. You are wrong in saying that in bhai sahibs time they never done simran whilst kirtan. Even Master Niranjan Singh told us once whilst being UK that there was simran those days but not as much as it is now. Therefore there was simran in kirtan at bhai sahibs times. Dont be all perfect with all your raags and leaveing the kirtan akhand, we shud do kirtan for the utmost raas, "thakur gaiye ataam rang" obviously some factors such as gurmatar bestowed by guru ji in sas giraas form shud be kept secret, but whats the hard of enjoying simran after a buetiful tukh on naam.

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

domalla premee · 18 Jun 2005

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh 1)I would like to know what state of mind we are in when we enter the sangat in the first place? 2)When honest hardworking people with families, who do not make a penny from doing keertan, take time from their busy lives throughout their lives to learn to sing Gurbani and travel sometimes thousands of miles for the love of keertan and sangat......how many people really thirst to do this? One can be stunned into silence at the enormous effort being made year after year simply for the love of Guru and Gurbani. 3)When focusing on His Name with whom are we relating to?...If we are truly focused 24/7 then is there room for another human examplar? Is there room to dwell on anything else but Waheguru? If we are so busy comparing ourselves to someone who is dead or alive then where is truly our surtee? 4)When one is focused on One there can be no room for the other? All these worries, arguments and irritations find no room in the mind of one who is absorbed in God. From such a one, grace spills over even if the person does not say a word. Such peearey come with regularity by the grace of God and are not confined to the past. These peearey are deeply wounded that their lives are held up as examples to prove an argument as their lives are not devoted to themselves but to Waheguru. 5)Those who truly thirst to be engaged with Waheguru will feel the urge to persue Him and not be mired in doubts and what ifs. If you want to know just to know then what will you do with such knowledge. Is it not of limited purpose? Does it bring you to Waheguru or is it mainly to sustain curiosity or intrigue? Such persuits are fruitless and die themselves naturally. They make you no happier or more at peace do they? Those who are restless just to be with Waheguru...their purpose is clear and existense to serve a lifelong endevour. dass

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Rashminder Singh Oz · 18 Jun 2005

My uncle is from Bhai sahib time and took amrit when bhai sahib was one of the panj pyare sewadaar I asked him about waheguru waheguru dhuni at bhai sahib time, he told me that "Yes" they use to singh waheguru waheguru in kirtan but it was not as long as it is now.............. So its clear puratan singhs at bhai sahib time use to use waheguru dhuni in kirtan bhul chuk maaf Waheguru

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Rain drop · 20 Jun 2005

For the original post, I agree with Kulbir Singh Ji view point. For the comments by "singh" that ------ "especialy when you do it at the right time - say the kirtani is singing Jis ke vadbhaga laal rang tis ko luga, i think its more then better to do abiyaas after that shabad and then going on to the next line." The problem, here, is that Gurbani says, That man is "of Laal Rang" who is blessed. Kirtania with Simran, will convey, See, Look, I am blessed, you are blessed. I am of laal rang. You may be of too. That makes the wrong statement. That makes Gurbani Kirtan "Non Akhand".

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

@@@ · 20 Jun 2005

HAHAHAHHA "AVAAR KAAJ TERRAY KETAY NAAH KAAM, MILL SAAD SANGAT BHAAJ KEVAAL NAAM " VAHEGURU VAHEGURU VAHEGURU, IF YOU FEEL LIEK SHOUTING HIS PRAISES THEN SHOUT THEM AS LOUD AS YOU CAN IF YOU WANT TO CRY THEN CRY OTU LOUD LOVE THE LORD WITH ALL YOUR HEART DON'T WORRY ABOUT OTHER PEOPLE WHO LOOK AT YOU ODD

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Gurus Son · 20 Jun 2005

WJkk Wjkf @@@ - U are right forget wat ppl think if u no u are doin with ur heart and mind then who cares wat tapoban says or wat taxalis say etc, Kulbir singh I dont agree with the part where you say Bhai sahib didnt do simran in his keertan, Giani ji, master ji, Bhai jasbir singh not tapoban one the bujarag, also told us that they did simran but not as much as they do now. Master ji, giani ji, jasbir singh where all at bhai sahibs time, you lot were not, so y do they do it If they seen more and got more giyan then u guys? The tapoban Jasbir singh was also there ask him! About nam simran I dont even no why this post is up, doesnt a mother know what her baby wants, even by action, crying, even when a baby cant speak the mother understands the child. So why cant our mahraj understand what we are trying to do or saying! Which idotic person said, Is god def? are u thik in the head to even say dat! Who says we so simran path to our guru, waheguroo. We do it for ourselves, our mann. By u doing little or a lot does not affect mahraj ji! I think I spoke to much, pul chuk maf jio! Wjkk WJkf

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Roopkaur · 20 Jun 2005

Yes there was abhyaas done in keertan during Bhai Sahibs times, but this was not the self induced dhunee we find in our times, it was uncontrolled abhyaas that arose and could not be controlled by the keertaee. It was not like today where the keertanee practices at home exactly where he is going to add the dhunni in and then practices how he or she is going to go fast and slow. That dhunni was natural and and uncontrolled. There was none of the self induced dhunee we see today than, and many Singhs, including Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji will tell you this fact. Only guru ji can give naam, and the fact that the bidhi for gurmantr is not openly known, and that bani never tells the gurmantr directly, only uses keertani names in place of the gurmantr naam, implies quite obviously that naam is supposed to be gupt. I dont really see how you can call the dhunee done today gupt. Also, guru ji has only given the panj piyarey the right to give naam and show the technique of japping naam to Sikhs in this day and age. What right does the keertani doing dhunne have of getting others to jap naam after him or her, when only the panj were given this right? If a person gets so into keertan that naam automatically starts for them and they cannot control it, then there is nothing wrong, but how can anyone call the self induced dhunne akhand keertan? It is purposeful interruption of guru jis bani, something we have no right to do. If guru ji wanted us to say vaheguru there, then they could have written it in, what gives a keertani that right to interupt the flow of guru jis bani and add their own into it? If this practice is so right, it would have been practiced by puraatan Singhs as well. But we find no historical evidence from guru jis time or after that bani was inturrupted during that time. IF this had happened, surely someone would have recorded it.

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Raagi · 21 Jun 2005

umm same could be said for those who just sit on the bajea and do kirtan in simple tunes and not the raag the shabad is intended to be in, raag kirtan is of utmost importance but all this board does is argue about dhunne in kirtan, weird or what, also you write flow of guru jis bani ??? are you a kirtani, do singh the shabad straight through, or go from anthara to shiahi and back ???? isn't that breaking the flow ???? i think saying waheguru in the form it is in kirtan is somewhat different of sitting there and doing naam abhiyaas, a majority of kirtani stick to pronouncing the waheguru shabad in the enitirety, yes some sangat do get carried away and do it with swaas, also this argument can carry on forever, the fact is in a majority of smagams arouund the whole world this happens, so can 95% of AKJ be doing something totally manmat or as you put it adding their own bani to gurbani, also the last statment you made could be asked about many things discussed on this board, some times records do not serve our purpose so we ignore them, bascially its a case of live and let live, if you don't like or disaprove of it so much don't go, if you find that if gives you something go and enjoy it, at the end of day it comes down "jin prem kiyo tean he prabh payeo", Guru ji is bakanshar and knows what is gurmat and manmat and to repeat is name in saadh sangat well I say no more.....

Re: Waheguru @ rehansabhai's

Admin · 21 Jun 2005

Topic Closed. Admin.