Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Don't want to give it · 18 Jun 2005

Greetings to you. I am a Muslim woman doing my post-secondary studies. I have been discussing and debating some points with friends of mine who are Sikhs (only females). Some of them have passed on to me postings from this site so I have come here at times to see for myself. I am very disappointed that some people on this message board have started saying things like "we are not Muslim!" which is trying to say that being a Muslim is so bad. Is it? I will answer this question here. You people say such things about Islam and the holy way our Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) has taught us when we separate males and females. You Sikhs think this is wrong. The SIkh girls who I have spoken with say this as if it is a bad think. I want you to give me this opportunity to show you the error of your judgments and reveal to you the truth of our path. It is true that we Muslims marry our women at a young age. Is this wrong? Your SIkh girls have said it is wrong. Now look at the truth if you will. We are engaged after puberty when Muslim women enter full womanhood. We are engaged to a single man. Unlike the SIkh girls we do not go shopping around for boyfriends and partners. Our parents whom we respect will arrange the partnre and we will have a choice. But this is our engagement not a dating scene. Now take my case. I was engaged at 15 and now we are getting married at the end of this summer. I am 18 years old. During all of my high school years while other girls like the SIkh girls were looking for boyfriends and flirting and dating with other SIkh men I had only 1 future husband who I was engaged with. I never dated or looked around. My future was set. Now is Islam practise better or yours? Muslim women know who their husband will be and they dont need to look around. But SIkh girls date and flirt with so many boys. Some of my friends who are SIkhs and wear your SIkh turban have dated. This is forbidden in Islam. Even if it is forbidden it is impossible. How will an engaged girl date? How will an engaged boy date? We come from respectable families and our families would find out and the marriage would end. It is like cheating. Who wants to cheat on their future husband? This is why you will never hear of a Muslim girl wearing hijab or full burqa who dates because she is already engaged. But SIkh girls date and flirt with boys and talk to them online and chat with them because they have no future yet. Which way is better? Islamic. Also we are all adults. We know the thoughts that go through a teenagers mind. In Islam we do not have teenagers. We only have children and then adults. There are no teenagers. Teenagers is a white man's word for when they can have premarital sex. Once puberty hits you are an adult in Islamic thought so you should act like one. We don't marry children rather we marry adults. That is why voting age in Iran is 15. Have you ever heard of a Hijab girl dating? Or even cheating on her future husband? But we hear all the time SIkh girls who wear your turbans who are cheating. Why do they always have boys on their chat rooms? WHy do they sneak out of the house to meet with their boyfriends? Has a hijab girl ever got caught having sex? But you read on this message board and talk to SIkh girls that so many have to seek forgiveness from your leaders. Because our Prophets and wise learned elders knew of these problems so they made a strict system which saves us from committing evil. I know I will not burn in the fires of hell because I follow Allah's path. On this message board you have SIkh girls laughing and joking about playing with boys and doing sports with them and tug of war and other flirting things. Does any Muslim girl do that? Never. We would never dishonour ourselves like that. Men should stick with men. And women with women. We will never touch a man. Or talk to a man that is not our husband or fathre or brother. Your girls play and flirt with boys and men all the time and then they pretend to call them their older brother. Only later I found out this is a lie they are not real brothers but juts lying to cover up their dirty deeds. I don't mean to sound harsh. Let Allah judge on the judgment day. I have only said this because you people especially SIkh girls attack our faith and say you are not like Muslims. My question to you is don't you think your Prophets should have blessed you with a path like ours? You would be better off being like Muslims. Instead of committing these sins. THank you for letting me say this. May Allah Bless all.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Mkhalsa · 18 Jun 2005

Asalam Alaikum Bhen Jan, Dating is AGAINST sikhi and any Sikhs who date are morally dubious. Therefore the whole argument you have made is pointless. I entirely agree with you on early engagements etc to stop dating, these were Sikh traditions not too long ago. The problem is a lot of people who think they are Sikhs (but arent by any long stretch of the imagination) go around doing quite a few bad things. Our gurus told us of the four worst sins a sikh can commit, they are haram: 1) Premarital Sex 2) consuming drugs/alcohol/or tobacco 3) eating meat 4) cutting hair if any of these are done, the person is no longer a Sikh until they ask for forgiveness. such things as flirting, dating etc are big taboos and no gursikh would be caught dead doing them. I am sorry you have gotten a bad image of Sikhs by seeing so called sikhs running around doing things like this, but Sikhs dont do that.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Mkhalsa · 18 Jun 2005

Also, when I was younger I knew a girl quite well who wore a headscarf and sometimes full hijaab. She was married at 16 to a man in another country. Before that she had a boyfriend here who she kept until her husband came. And at the same time she would still date around and go to clubs. So saying there are no muslim girls that do this would be a lie. I have only known two muslim girls in my life and both of them were flirts, and I know of many muslim guys that date around and treat women like worthless objects. I could make the same statements you have made but about islam, but you do not beleive it to be true. From my experience, this is all I have seen is people who do all this stuff.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

singhsation · 18 Jun 2005

you've mentioned some legitimate points but there are major inaccuracies and misrepresentations of your interpretation and understanding of sikhism, in this subject matter i think our beliefs are close to similar than apart, we sikhs dont believe in a better path either, every path to God is equal. from your post it doesnt seem you carry the same belief, and you've shown a lot of pre judging or prejudice towards our religion before understanding it, and im sure even a true devotee of islam would condemn that. the sikhs on this message board will give you an ear full on explaining my point further

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

singhsation · 18 Jun 2005

just for notation purposes can you also make refrence to the posts within this forum are discriminatory (being antisikh) towards your great relgion of islam?

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

khalistani · 18 Jun 2005

vaheguru bhenjee our religion does not allow the hate for any religion we love all becuase vaheguru is in all and he created everything and everyone in sikhi flirting is not allowed it is clear in guru granth sahib je and rehitnamai and bhai gurdas jes vaars we are to see women as our mothers and sisters just because some do not follow this does not make guru sahib wrong just like some muslim freinds of mine drink and eat non halal dont make that ok in islam www.whyichoosesikhism.com www.searchsikhism.com and go to compare religions bhenjee we do not hate mohamaad or his path love vaheguru, alahh, raam with all ure heart the truth will b revealred directly from akaal himself love for one is the answer jin prem keeo thin he prabh paaeeeoo i do not kno much, and have very low avastha so forgive me for my mistakes bhula chuka maf

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; · 18 Jun 2005

why do you feel early marriage is an "islamic" system thing? nearly all sikhs used to marry young my gran married my grandad when she was 14 and he was 19. They look quiet cute in the black and white wedding pics. This is an age old tradition of most cultures marrying young, but some muslims if not all have retained it this does not make it islamic. I know muslims marrying much later on. My grandparents wanted me fixed up with a gurl when i was 16 and i am a lad. I felt i was too young and not ready, i declined it i wanted to study and further my life, the prospect of marriage i kind of dreaded i was still growing up. So they relaxed it for more years. i have heard of and actually know plenty of hijab gurls who have dated and still do but that does niot reflect a true dedicated muslimah female who i actually respect. one of my friends is a cop in his 15 years of service in a muslim area of the uk, there is a law that prohibits fornicating in public, boatloads of muslim couples have been caught fornicating in cars in disused car parks, deserted areas, tunnel archways, when taken out for questioning the gurl would have the jiljaab covering and hijaab when the car was being searched, or they both had the islamic gear . Obviously this does not mean this is the general rule or that all muslims do that or in fact that they are muslims ( they are just in name and not by the teachings of Peer Mohammed Ji who you will find sikhs respect). But wearing religious robes does not mean anything just as much as wearing a turban does not unless you actually practice the faith. If you are obvlious to this then you have not seen what goes on. However i think you are trying to say sikhs are corrupt yet us muslims are so pious because of the bottom line religion but you have yet to study sikhism! On my last visit to the canary wharf i was surprised to see very pretty pakistani pathan looking gurls in hijaabs hugging and kissing openly in the ground floor with bengali mundey. Although i am a sikh this hurts me, this is what the world has come to feeling the same pain when i see a sikh doing the same. That is someones daughter, sister, will one day be someones wife and mother. "I know I will not burn in the fires of hell because I follow Allah's path." Allah is a name of God. We now the same formless God as Waheguru and many other names. We also follow the path of the God, a true person does not fear heavens and hells for them the devotion of Gods worship inside their heart is true paradise whether they be at the bottom of hell or in the high heavens. Heavens are a result of the grace of Gods divine order, true men and women do not hanker for heavens as long as they are steadfast in their faith and devotion to God the results rest with Gods justice. I actually agree with you this tug of war and too much male female contact is wrong and i hope it can be amended by event organisers. My personal belief is we should not organise mixed gender camps with youth for this can distracts people from their end goal. This is also not part of sikhism, it is a failure and allowing of creeping westernisation. The reintroduction such a singular system around the youth would not soak in too well with a lot of sikhs who are now brainwashed by liberal attitudes in the west. But this does not happen on the borders of punjab with pakistan , borders punjab with rajistan where strictness is maintained, and outside hareeana sikhs like being in punjab going back 100 years where the functions of men and women are kept seperate, women covering heads at all times outside or where male members of the family are present.Basically what you see in the uk is a very small portion of an urbanised diaspora out of which very few are true sikhs, the rest succombs to external pressure to conform to western idealism. There is nothing wrong in males and females talking on certain respects depending what their intentions are, for example, if in a masjid you have a duty to carry out you may need the communication of other muslim male sevedars in certain areas to fulfill your duty. It comes down to the level of islam walking with your life inside you and the person talking to you. Touching people is not the done thing in sikhism. this is an ignorant statement sister, it seems you are pointing fingers instead of asking sikhs is this what sikhs are taught? or do sikhs have a teaching that allows this? but looking at your essay i would say you pretty much know touching people is kind of a wrong thing yet you are implieing its almost part of sikhism like a subtle way of saying my islam is better. Sikhs are not muslims, just like muslims are not sikhs. Our sikh gurus have blessed us with so much i cant even ut it into words just how much sister i am wonderstruck. The path we have is beautiful, you have not seen it yet sister because you are veiled with ignorance which leads you to attack it in a very subtle way. What you have seen is dodgy people and blamed sikhism for it instead of studieing sikhism, is it fair to blame the religion? why dont you read up on what sikhism has to say through our holy guide guru Granth sahib ji? www.sikhitothemax.com it is only then you will understand what you are missing. I thank you for coming to this site, and hope you actually read up on sikh teachings before you accuse all sikhs of being dodgy. Allah waheguru God bless you sister stay happy p.s il make a deal with you il read the quran if you agree to study the guru granth sahib - deal?

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Guru ka Singh · 18 Jun 2005

*****Tapoban Moderators : i request u to plzz post this without editing a single letter or word. It is a sincere request***** First of all, you CANNOT blame an entire community for the doings of a stupid few. I know people from YOUR Islamic middle east who are not worth calling humans, forget about being called Muslims. I am an ex-Hindu who converted to Sikhism and grew up all my life in YOUR Islamic middle east so i know u guys inside out. i was myself gonna become a muslim at the stupid age of 15, but i thank God a million times i didn't. Dont try to teach us coz i know u guys to the core. [i]Unlike the SIkh girls we do not go shopping around for boyfriends and partners.[/i] yea u just allow ur men to marry 4 times...why are u guys gender biased? we Sikhs dont have any sort of gender bias in our religion. [i]Now take my case. I was engaged at 15 and now we are getting married at the end of this summer. I am 18 years old.[/i] Good for you, and does that make u think all muslim girls are like u? and YOU take my case...i was bullied and beaten up as a kid by ur homeless palestinian hooligans who called me a "Kafir"...so much for "true religion". [i]During all of my high school years while other girls like the SIkh girls were looking for boyfriends and flirting and dating with other SIkh men I had only 1 future husband who I was engaged with. I never dated or looked around. My future was set.[/i] Thats coz ur muslim brothers were being encouraged by ur religious leaders (in UK) to go around converting Sikh girls, who unfortunately are not taught anything about their great religion. You cant blame the girls totally, its the diabolic nature of ur guys as well. [i]Now is Islam practise better or yours?[/i] Better for you. [i]This is why you will never hear of a Muslim girl wearing hijab or full burqa who dates because she is already engaged.[/i] Say what? Do u know what kinda nasty stuff goes on in so many "muslim" countries? Don't even start me here! [i]But SIkh girls date and flirt with boys and talk to them online and chat with them because they have no future yet.[/i] Yes coz we are not the Taliban who consider women nothing better than animals. Our girls have the freedom to choose their own life partners and if the parents agree they are set. [i]Which way is better?[/i] The highway! [i]Have you ever heard of a Hijab girl dating? Or even cheating on her future husband?[/i] Lets not go to what all i have heard. [i]But we hear all the time SIkh girls who wear your turbans who are cheating.[/i] Yea u hear that stuff from ur maulvis in mosques who pay and encourage ur guys to go and spoil underage Sikh girls. [i]Why do they always have boys on their chat rooms?[/i] coz they are out there to learn about their religion and visit sites like http://www.whyichosesikhism.com so that the filth shoved inside their head by ur brothers can be removed. [i]Has a hijab girl ever got caught having sex?[/i] They been caught doing loads of nonsense. [i]But you read on this message board and talk to SIkh girls that so many have to seek forgiveness from your leaders.[/i] Atleast there is forgiveness in our religion even for the worst sinners. What about yours? [i]I know I will not burn in the fires of hell because I follow Allah's path.[/i] And i know the sun will rise form the east for the next million years. [i]On this message board you have SIkh girls laughing and joking about playing with boys and doing sports with them and tug of war and other flirting things. Does any Muslim girl do that?[/i] We have muslims also posting on Sikh forums. So now do i take that they come here looking for Sikh guys n girls? [i]We would never dishonour ourselves like that.[/i] What about Pakistani actress Meera? Isn't she a muslim? Don't u know what kinda films she does? [i]Men should stick with men. And women with women.[/i] Right! and u know what they call those people? [i]We will never touch a man. Or talk to a man that is not our husband or father or brother.[/i] Even if u were a doctor and had to save someone's life urgently? Man this is so inhuman!! [i]Your girls play and flirt with boys and men all the time and then they pretend to call them their older brother.[/i] and u guys marry your own cousins. i find that severely disgusting. [i]Only later I found out this is a lie they are not real brothers but juts lying to cover up their dirty deeds.[/i] better than having an evil eye on ur own blood brother/sister, which is what went on in the middle east before Hazrat Muhammad Sahib. [i]I don't mean to sound harsh. Let Allah judge on the judgment day.[/i]good deal! [i]I have only said this because you people especially SIkh girls attack our faith and say you are not like Muslims.[/i] and we thank God we are not! [i]My question to you is don't you think your Prophets should have blessed you with a path like ours?[/i] We are thankful to them for having blessed us with the very best of divinity that ever came down to earth. [i]You would be better off being like Muslims. Instead of committing these sins.[/i] and commit sins much worse? like circumcision? killing women and non-muslims? blowing up buildings? no thanks!!!!!! little one, u r just 18...wait till u grow a bit more older...18 is not the right age to judge an entire community.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

wow · 18 Jun 2005

Think about this. Just like how you believe Islam is the Truth , and you have full faith in your prophet...WE FEEL THE SAME WAY. You have 100% faith that you are right, and we have 100% faith that we are right. It's a never ending cycle if we argue. How can we ever agree? Lets just learn to love each other, God has a plan for everything. You pray to God, and so do we. Allah is one. There is no point in arguing.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; · 18 Jun 2005

why do you feel early marriage is an "islamic" system thing? nearly all sikhs used to marry young my gran married my grandad when she was 14 and he was 19. They look quiet cute in the black and white wedding pics. This is an age old tradition of most cultures marrying young, but some muslims if not all have retained it this does not make it islamic. I know muslims marrying much later on. My grandparents wanted me fixed up with a gurl when i was 16 and i am a lad. I felt i was too young and not ready, i declined it i wanted to study and further my life, the prospect of marriage i kind of dreaded i was still growing up. So they relaxed it for more years. i have heard of and actually know plenty of hijab gurls who have dated and still do but that does niot reflect a true dedicated muslimah female who i actually respect. one of my friends is a cop in his 15 years of service in a muslim area of the uk, there is a law that prohibits fornicating in public, boatloads of muslim couples have been caught fornicating in cars in disused car parks, deserted areas, tunnel archways, when taken out for questioning the gurl would have the jiljaab covering and hijaab when the car was being searched, or they both had the islamic gear . Obviously this does not mean this is the general rule or that all muslims do that or in fact that they are muslims ( they are just in name and not by the teachings of Peer Mohammed Ji who you will find sikhs respect). But wearing religious robes does not mean anything just as much as wearing a turban does not unless you actually practice the faith. If you are obvlious to this then you have not seen what goes on. However i think you are trying to say sikhs are corrupt yet us muslims are so pious because of the bottom line religion but you have yet to study sikhism! On my last visit to the canary wharf i was surprised to see very pretty pakistani pathan looking gurls in hijaabs hugging and kissing openly in the ground floor with bengali mundey. Although i am a sikh this hurts me, this is what the world has come to feeling the same pain when i see a sikh doing the same. That is someones daughter, sister, will one day be someones wife and mother. "I know I will not burn in the fires of hell because I follow Allah's path." Allah is a name of God. We now the same formless God as Waheguru and many other names. We also follow the path of the God, a true person does not fear heavens and hells for them the devotion of Gods worship inside their heart is true paradise whether they be at the bottom of hell or in the high heavens. Heavens are a result of the grace of Gods divine order, true men and women do not hanker for heavens as long as they are steadfast in their faith and devotion to God the results rest with Gods justice. I actually agree with you this tug of war and too much male female contact is wrong and i hope it can be amended by event organisers. My personal belief is we should not organise mixed gender camps with youth for this can distracts people from their end goal. This is also not part of sikhism, it is a failure and allowing of creeping westernisation. The reintroduction such a singular system around the youth would not soak in too well with a lot of sikhs who are now brainwashed by liberal attitudes in the west. But this does not happen on the borders of punjab with pakistan , borders punjab with rajistan where strictness is maintained, and outside hareeana sikhs like being in punjab going back 100 years where the functions of men and women are kept seperate, women covering heads at all times outside or where male members of the family are present.Basically what you see in the uk is a very small portion of an urbanised diaspora out of which very few are true sikhs, the rest succombs to external pressure to conform to western idealism. There is nothing wrong in males and females talking on certain respects depending what their intentions are, for example, if in a masjid you have a duty to carry out you may need the communication of other muslim male sevedars in certain areas to fulfill your duty. It comes down to the level of islam walking with your life inside you and the person talking to you. Touching people is not the done thing in sikhism. this is an ignorant statement sister, it seems you are pointing fingers instead of asking sikhs is this what sikhs are taught? or do sikhs have a teaching that allows this? but looking at your essay i would say you pretty much know touching people is kind of a wrong thing yet you are implieing its almost part of sikhism like a subtle way of saying my islam is better. Sikhs are not muslims, just like muslims are not sikhs. Our sikh gurus have blessed us with so much i cant even ut it into words just how much sister i am wonderstruck. The path we have is beautiful, you have not seen it yet sister because you are veiled with ignorance which leads you to attack it in a very subtle way. What you have seen is dodgy people and blamed sikhism for it instead of studieing sikhism, is it fair to blame the religion? why dont you read up on what sikhism has to say through our holy guide guru Granth sahib ji? www.sikhitothemax.com it is only then you will understand what you are missing. I thank you for coming to this site, and hope you actually read up on sikh teachings before you accuse all sikhs of being dodgy. Allah waheguru God bless you sister stay happy p.s il make a deal with you il read the quran if you agree to study the guru granth sahib - deal? [%sig%]

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Guy · 18 Jun 2005

Do Muslims believe that a person who wakes up early in the morning everyday and sings praises of God for hours, and then reads scriptures that talk about how Great God is for hours, and spends the whole day serving the poor, and is always repeating "WAHEGURU" or "God is Wonderful" 24/7...Do you really think he is a kaffar, and going to hell? Do you think that the same God he/she dedicates their life to, and sings praise after praise about is going to send them to hell? Think about this with an open mind please.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

no · 18 Jun 2005

Can i Just say the ''sikh girls'' you mention who date, have boyfriends etc, are NOT sikhs. It seems you've only met ''sikh girls'' who rnt actually sikhs therefore you have the completely wrong idea. Sikhs get married by arrenged marriages, which are arranged by there parents or family members. It is also against sikhi to have pre maritial relation ships of any sort.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

no · 19 Jun 2005

muslims for some strange reason bleeding their meat before eating it to make it halaal. cud u tell me for what demented reason they do this. causing such pain to living creatures? oh yeah and how about your prophet marrying a 9 year old??? was she classed as an adult as well?? plenty of muslims flirt and b dodgey with boys so i dont know where ive got the strange idea that mulsim girls are perfect and will never mix with boys. the "sikhs" u mention hu flirt with boys are not sikhs for by flirting with boys they have gone against the religious code for sikhs and r no longa considered sikhs. also ur post makes u seem like a hypocrit u say dnt bash muslim faith and then u urselff try to bash the sikh faith

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Anon · 19 Jun 2005

If that was an attempt at harmony between Sikhs and Muslims so we didn't question Islam that wasn't the best way to go about it. Firstly in Sikhism having a boyfriend/girlfriend is prohibited. And marrying people off at a young age does not address the fundamental problem of lust, rather it just channels it to somewhere seen as more acceptable. I live in UK and I have seen Muslim girls wearing headscarf going to CLUBS. This is not a lie because I have seen it myself! You cannot judge a religion by unserious adherants because I know of Muslim men in who walk around in kurtas but they also sell drugs. There are plenty of young Sikh girls and boys who are very strict in their lifestyle and do not act like this with the opposite sex. My question to you is, if someone has excess lust, is the answer to put a large sheet/hajib over anything that may cause lust, or make the person sit down, clear their mind and meditate in order to burn the sin from it's base? The reason I am not a Muslim, is because as Guru Gobind Singh Ji has said in Bachittar Natak, Prophet Mohammed started with good intentions but ego took him over. This is evident when reading Saheeh Ahadith which do not always show the actions of one who is completely in line with those of a true Prophet of God.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

sikh · 19 Jun 2005

take some of your own advice and stop bashing the sikh faith. Dont judge the followers go and read gurbani and enlighten yourself on sikhi. i challange you to read gurbani and find me even one pankati (verse) that is wrong. Sikhi unline any other our own Gurus have penned and authorised it hence no corruption. This is the most uptodate religion on earth. I have a feeling if you researched it you would fall in love with sikhism. Your defences make you hit at sikhs with cheap shots. Living in a muslim area muslim girls are not quiet what you claim they are. They are just like others and fall subject to prey like others including hijabans. hijabans too wear tight clothes, chek guys, mess around. Break your own defence barrier down and come towards the real truth sikhism. i ask you to read with an open heart.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Anon · 19 Jun 2005

PS. You have blurred the concept between a cultural and religious practise. The concept of an arranged marraige is cultural and has been associated with both Sikhism and Islam from their conception. Dating is a cultural practise of the west. Arranged marriages are cultural but are associated as the only viable way to be married by those who are religious. Many elements of Islam have attempted to isolate itself completely from modern day society (leading to increased tensions in communities and the type of attitude expressed in your above post) which is why dating is so firmly shunned within Muslim society. Conversely whilst arranged marriages are always the norm for religious Sikh families, Sikhs have integrated themselves more into western society than Muslims have (I don't think you can deny that). Generally Sikhs enjoy a better relationship with non-Sikhs than Muslims do with non-Muslims even if it does sound like a crass generalisation. This increased integration has led to a breakdown of barriers which would consider certain practises such as dating as taboo within Sikh society. Therefore, how can the founders of Sikhism be blamed for an increased integration into a foreign society caused by immigration 100s of years after the final living Sikh Guru? Please think rationally about the above rather than in a typical narrowminded manner.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

jugroop singh · 19 Jun 2005

Dear Veer/Bhain 'Don't want to give it', yopu wrote all of the following: 'Unlike the SIkh girls we do not go shopping around for boyfriends and partners' > 'Sikh' and 'Punjabi' are different...I am surprised you are unable to sepera 'During all of my high school years while other girls like the SIkh girls were looking for boyfriends and flirting and dating with other SIkh men I had only 1 future husband who I was engaged with' > good for you. But SIkh girls date and flirt with so many boys. Some of my friends who are SIkhs and wear your SIkh turban have dated But SIkh girls date and flirt with boys and talk to them online and chat with them because they have no future yet. Which way is better? Islamic Have you ever heard of a Hijab girl dating? Or even cheating on her future husband? But we hear all the time SIkh girls who wear your turbans who are cheating. Why do they always have boys on their chat rooms? WHy do they sneak out of the house to meet with their boyfriends? Has a hijab girl ever got caught having sex? But you read on this message board and talk to SIkh girls that so many have to seek forgiveness fro

Hijaab = Muslim + Turban = Sikh...???

jugroop singh · 19 Jun 2005

Dear Bhain 'Don't want to give it' Ji, A-Salaam-Aliekum, you wrote all of the following (my responses begin with '>'): 'Unlike the SIkh girls we do not go shopping around for boyfriends and partners' > 'Sikh' and 'Panjaabi' are different...you sound reasonably intelligent dear sister; i am surprised you are unable to seperate the two...for instance, would you say all Arabs are 'Muslims' (e.g. even those amongst the rich ones, who drink alcohol and sleep with Western prostitutes) and vice-versa? likewise, i am sure you understand there is no such thing as a practising or non-practising Sikh - you are either one or the other. 'During all of my high school years while other girls like the SIkh girls were looking for boyfriends and flirting and dating with other SIkh men I had only 1 future husband who I was engaged with' > good for you. you obviously have more intelligence than these girls. Allaah has indeed blessed you. but a small point; 'Sikh' men or women wouldn't date...once again; you are either Sikh or not - simple. to be Sikh, at the very least, is to not commit four major sins: cutting hair, eating dead animal carcasses, having extra/pre marital sex/relationships and taking any intoxicants; obviously here, the pre/extra marital sex/relationships directive applies. 'But SIkh girls date and flirt with so many boys. Some of my friends who are SIkhs and wear your SIkh turban have dated' > a Panjaabi girl does not a Sikh make...a man in a a 'turban' does not a Sikh make...Sikhi isn't as simple as wearing a Hijaab and calling yourself a Muslim or wearing a turban and calling yourself a Sikh; i am sure you understand this...or do you not..??? 'But SIkh girls date and flirt with boys and talk to them online and chat with them because they have no future yet' > if you look over my previous responses, i'm sure you'll guess what i'm about to write... ((((:-) >>> 'Which way is better? Islamic' > now that is a highly contentious debate - nonetheless, i am sure that the Deen of Islam, if practised with deep sincerity, humility and piety will surely get you to heaven where you will enjoy many sensory-based enjoyments...but it will not, by its very own definition and concepts, allow your Atma/Soul to unite with The Universal Soul - ParAtma (who is also known as VahiGuru, Allaah, Raam). please note that what i have stated is not an opinon - it is a self-declared fact. 'Have you ever heard of a Hijab girl dating? Or even cheating on her future husband? But we hear all the time SIkh girls who wear your turbans who are cheating. Why do they always have boys on their chat rooms? WHy do they sneak out of the house to meet with their boyfriends? Has a hijab girl ever got caught having sex? But you read on this message board and talk to SIkh girls that so many have to seek forgiveness from your leaders'. > i have known 'Muslim' girls who wear Hijaabs to flirt/cheat etc. in fact, when i was younger, and a complete moorakh/sinner, many would flirt with me and i with them...it was only relatively recently that i realised i was not a Sikh and they were not Muslim, at that time. again, appearances (i.e. Hijaab and 'Turban') can be deceptive...if only meeting our Beloved was that easy!!! 'On this message board you have SIkh girls laughing and joking about playing with boys and doing sports with them and tug of war and other flirting things. Does any Muslim girl do that? Never. We would never dishonour ourselves like that. Men should stick with men. And women with women. We will never touch a man. Or talk to a man that is not our husband or fathre or brother'. > complete segregation of the sexes would be completely impractical and complete integration of the sexes, in all things, would be completely inappropriate - i imagine you and i agree but i am sure in different ways and to different extents i.e. i certainly do not believe that Sikh women, like Muslim women, should a lot of the time end-up praying at home for 'practical reasons' and i certainly do not believe that a woman is not 'able' to lead prayer. 'My question to you is don't you think your Prophets should have blessed you with a path like ours? You would be better off being like Muslims. Instead of committing these sins'. > Sikhs (please note; 'practising' Sikhs i.e. the ONLY kind of Sikhs!) are indeed very blessed - just as you feel blessed so too do we; our paths are very similar in many ways but also very different in many ways. may Allaah bless you on your spiritual journey towards heavan, and may Allaah bless us on our spiritual journey to unite with Him eternally. Dear Bhain Ji, may i finish by stating that of the many 'Muslims' i have met or interacted with, i have always been left with the feeling that instead of proactively trying to belittle the faith of others, they should instead concentrate more so upon their own spiritual lifestyle, and try to experience a ever-incresing depth of faith, which is saturated with humility - this would be much more profitable and indeed make the reality of a life in heavan much more attainable; since their Nafs (false pride/ego) would be subdued to a greater extent. thanks for posting your msg - it has indeed raised some interesting issues - much like the 'Muslim' poster who recently took part in a thread elsewhere on this phorum. Khudaa-Afis

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Singhani · 19 Jun 2005

>>Greetings to you. I am a Muslim woman doing my post-secondary studies. I have been discussing and debating some points with friends of mine who are Sikhs (only females). Some of them have passed on to me postings from this site so I have come here at times to see for myself. I am very disappointed that some people on this message board have started saying things like "we are not Muslim!" which is trying to say that being a Muslim is so bad. Is it? I will answer this question here.<< It is a Sikh message board, do you expect people to say we are Muslims to make you feel better? >>You people say such things about Islam and the holy way our Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) has taught us when we separate males and females. You Sikhs think this is wrong. The SIkh girls who I have spoken with say this as if it is a bad think. I want you to give me this opportunity to show you the error of your judgments and reveal to you the truth of our path.<< Separating men and women is not wrong, but giving them unequal rights is. I have heard all the arguments from Muslims about the way they treat women equally, yet in Jannah every Muslim will have two 'houris' in addition to his own wife (if she makes it), all Muslim women have to cover up to avoid men becoming lustful, why can men not have the responsibility to control their own lust? (weakness), why do women have this task? We believe in dressing modestly, but not to the extent of covering our faces and even eyes, which is extreme and unnecessary. >>It is true that we Muslims marry our women at a young age. Is this wrong? Your SIkh girls have said it is wrong. Now look at the truth if you will. We are engaged after puberty when Muslim women enter full womanhood. We are engaged to a single man. Unlike the SIkh girls we do not go shopping around for boyfriends and partners. Our parents whom we respect will arrange the partnre and we will have a choice. But this is our engagement not a dating scene. Now take my case. I was engaged at 15 and now we are getting married at the end of this summer. I am 18 years old. During all of my high school years while other girls like the SIkh girls were looking for boyfriends and flirting and dating with other SIkh men I had only 1 future husband who I was engaged with. I never dated or looked around. My future was set.<< Congratulations on 'setting your future', but you are twisting around Sikhism in order to justify yourself. No Sikh woman is allowed to go hunting for boyfriends, clearly the ones you are friends with have not read and understood true Sikhi. Also, who said Sikh parents dont arrange the marriages of their daughters? They do and they should, as some Muslim women walk around half naked and without Hijaabs, sleeping with other men, so do some so called 'Sikh' women, but does that make Islam or Sikhism fault? Do the actions of a few make the religion false? Either bring proofs to destroy our religion or accept that you have none. You cannot attack Sikhism on the wrong actions of a few silly hormonal girls you are friends with. Marrying a 9 year old is fine? Maybe Aishah had begun menstruating, but do you know what a 9 year old child is like mentally? Is she grown up mentally? Look around at 9 year olds now and find out for yourself, would they have anything in common with 55 year old men? >>Now is Islam practise better or yours? Muslim women know who their husband will be and they dont need to look around. But SIkh girls date and flirt with so many boys. Some of my friends who are SIkhs and wear your SIkh turban have dated. This is forbidden in Islam. Even if it is forbidden it is impossible. How will an engaged girl date? How will an engaged boy date? We come from respectable families and our families would find out and the marriage would end. It is like cheating. Who wants to cheat on their future husband? This is why you will never hear of a Muslim girl wearing hijab or full burqa who dates because she is already engaged. But SIkh girls date and flirt with boys and talk to them online and chat with them because they have no future yet.<< Some girls may do that, can you prove Sikhism says its ok? I know many Muslim women who drink, smoke and sleep around, is this what Islam says? How can you justify your views based on what a few idiots YOU are friends with (wonder why you still remain friends with them). >>Which way is better? Islamic. Also we are all adults. We know the thoughts that go through a teenagers mind. In Islam we do not have teenagers. We only have children and then adults. There are no teenagers. Teenagers is a white man's word for when they can have premarital sex. Once puberty hits you are an adult in Islamic thought so you should act like one. We don't marry children rather we marry adults. That is why voting age in Iran is 15.<< I dont care about your voting age, a woman is forbidden to vote in some countries and you talk about Islamic ways being better. Also, unlike you we dont force people to believe in our way, you think everyone else going to hell anyway. You have no justification for a 55 year old man marrying a CHILD, mentally a child is a child, whether she is menstruating or not. I wonder why most Muslims haven't heard of the word psychology. >>Have you ever heard of a Hijab girl dating? Or even cheating on her future husband? But we hear all the time SIkh girls who wear your turbans who are cheating. Why do they always have boys on their chat rooms? WHy do they sneak out of the house to meet with their boyfriends? Has a hijab girl ever got caught having sex? But you read on this message board and talk to SIkh girls that so many have to seek forgiveness from your leaders.<< I have heard of one girl called 'Saima' who wears a hijaab, and when she leaves the house she goes to her english boyfriend to have sex, she smokes also. She only wears a hijaab because her parents force her. Also, many Muslim women have married Sikh men I know of a few personally. What leaders are you talking about? We dont have your Imams who sanction its ok to have sex with children, we have Guru Granth Sahib Jee to ask forgiveness from. Get your facts right. >>Because our Prophets and wise learned elders knew of these problems so they made a strict system which saves us from committing evil. I know I will not burn in the fires of hell because I follow Allah's path.<< You may not burn in hellfire but you will sit and watch your husband flirting with his two houris and playing with his little boy slaves, oh yes, that is a great reward for being a good Muslim housewife with no brain. >>On this message board you have SIkh girls laughing and joking about playing with boys and doing sports with them and tug of war and other flirting things. Does any Muslim girl do that? Never. We would never dishonour ourselves like that. Men should stick with men. And women with women. We will never touch a man. Or talk to a man that is not our husband or fathre or brother.<< You are interacting with Sikh men by posting here, so maybe you should ask for forgiveness from Allaah (astaghfirullaah). FYI, you cant play 'tug of war' on the internet, lol. >>Your girls play and flirt with boys and men all the time and then they pretend to call them their older brother. Only later I found out this is a lie they are not real brothers but juts lying to cover up their dirty deeds. I don't mean to sound harsh. Let Allah judge on the judgment day.<< Yes let Him judge, we shouldnt be posting on message boards attacking others with NO proof and only using the actions of a few messed up girls. Hold on a minute, dont you call all muslim males your 'brothers', yet you end up marrying one of your 'brothers'. >>I have only said this because you people especially SIkh girls attack our faith and say you are not like Muslims.<< We are not like Muslims because our father Guru Gobind Singh Jee gave us 5 gifts and the Amrit so we can never be mistaken for Muslims. I'm happy you know of Sikh girls who say they are not Muslims, that is why the Khalsa was created, to remain distinct from those who condemn half of the world to hellfire. >>My question to you is don't you think your Prophets should have blessed you with a path like ours? You would be better off being like Muslims. Instead of committing these sins.<< We cant all be Muslims, didnt Allaah say some have seals on their hearts and shall never accept Islaam, we are those Sikhs of Guru Gobind Singh Jee and we will always fight against people who force others to change their faith. You should stop interacting with men on this forum which is haraam for you. >>THank you for letting me say this.<< No problem, anytime 'sister'. >>May Allah Bless all.<< He wont, he doesn't bless disbelievers (Kuffar).

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 19 Jun 2005

What you have written is absoloutely baseless. You have only based your beliefs about the Sikh faith on what some 'Sikh girls' have told you, I encourage you to learn the truth about Sikhism. You might know of 'Sikh' girls who date, I must let you know that this is also contrary to the Sikh beliefs. I highly encourage you to look into Sikhism, and then come back and post on this Phorum, it looks like the Sikh Girls you have talked about are not practising Sikhs at all; even though they may look like one in appearance.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

singha di aan shaan · 19 Jun 2005

what are you talking about? i get asked out by muslim females all the time about 4 out of 10 are hijabwalis. they screw around all over the joint and you know it. a bit of cloth over the face does not mean your an angel. A mosque pardaan ( committee heads) daughter even asked me out at work , and told me shed take her pardah off to go out with me. But you know what? real sikhs are nothing without falling in love with God and his special immaculate commands sent through the ten holy GOD ordained bodies which passed the message of God the COMPLETE TRUTH through sikhism. We dont date as part of sikhi it is forbidden. I told her to reform her character or stop communication. its hard because no matter how many times we say no they dont listen like their obsessed, then its almost break point where you really wanna swear and even then they carry on. so what are we supposed to do? we cant hit girls. I get constant looks and mild gestures all the time from even married older hijabvalis with kids when i walk down town whats that say? that they obviously arent very content in their arranged marriages or they got married when they kids. My best mate is a 50 year old singh with half white beard, a blood pressure patient, with other limitations, part of his bussiness involves setting up pcs. A hijabvali jhelum muslim woman late twenties asked him to come round to sort her pc out. In his selfless spirit of helping the customer out assuming she would have her family around went there to fix her pc he went there two weeks later. She called him in, did not have any1 else in house, and then tried to seduce him by trieing to hold his hands when asking him if he anted a drink, getting close to him and trieing to brush herself against him while he was fixing her pc. In answering her advances he said " bhenji, the path to God is very sharp, what is life worth without Him"? she then realised her mistake. now you tell me what damned besti is that? how can you make out hijab walis are angels? in any asian area of england theres loads of cinemas, bollywood bowls, macdonalds, hang outs, when we drive in town we see lines of muslim girls outside them with hijaabs and the new sexily clad salwaar kameez revealing their bits. i mean whats the point even wearing salwaar kameez then? u must remember your mum and gran even covering up their chests with a chunni and wearing loose clothong on purpose? so wheres all this gone in the new lot? One of my pakistani doctor friends in manchester ( area of 250 000 muslims) tells me stories of adultry abortions everyday). Another arabic friend from abu dhabi settled in bradford ( 70 000 muslims) tells me how young pakistani kuria walk around in skirts, eat in haram places and go clubbing. To find true muslims is rare. your salvation lies in serving your husband. In paradise he gets 72 hooris, wheres yours? what do you get? how you gonna remember God up there after a pint of wine? would God not be angered by you getting drunk? like perhaps your dad would on this earth? how do you know you goin heaven? have you seen heaven or hell? have you thought perhaps Prophet Mohammed narrated what he saw limited by the blessings of Allah? meaning could there not be more than what he saw? today scientific findings are beyond what Prophet Mohammed narrated ie the world is round, the moon has been conquered with the american flag, next step mars. are you aware Guru nanak took a muslim disciples soul out of his body on his visit to mecca after a debate arose about how many realms are above? the soul was taken to countless realms far beyond what any muslim had believed in. How does it feel that you are covered yet your husband does not have to? would not another woman find him attractive? how does it feel that your husband may choose 3 more wives? to share the man you love who you saved this love for to share him with another woman??? do you only pray and carry out deeds like a credit system to reach heaven? then where is the love for God? do you really think God will reveal himself to a person who carries out obligations in a mundane ritual manner to attain heaven? is that real devotion? therefore i ask you to bein your real soul search towards finding eternal truth. I welcome you to join sikhism please convert my dear sister into a sikh it is the easiest path to God and the most rewarding spiritually with equal rights for women where you can reach a height of complete happiness through dedicated devotion with your breathes connecting to your heart in turn giving you a joyous experience in life throughout. if you want to throw stones look in your own bedroom. first. [%sig%]

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

..... · 19 Jun 2005

Dear, dont want to give it, I have read your post thanks for the free information, But I would like to say one thing, not that im trying to attack Islam or anything, but you keep repeating that 'Your sikh girls flirt etc etc'. For one persons actions you blame the whole Sikh Kaum?? I have seen many muslim girls having boyfriends, flirting sneeking, and even dating outside their faith. Ahh but then you would probably say 'that their not muslims because their not practicing their faith or wear the hijab/burka, their muslim just by name or family'. Couldnt the same be said about Sikhs. Then You said that our Sikh girls who wear 'turbans' do the same, I agree that their maybe one or two here and there & I wont deny it, but that doesnt mean that all bibian with dastaaran do that, just because one talks to a singh doesnt mean that they have bad deeds. What do you know what thoughts they have, when your claiming that they have dirty thoughts in their head when the call them brothers. Thats just plain stupidity to even think you know what their thinking. You then said you will neve see a bibi with a hijab or burka flirting dating etc. Well then you havent seen much of the world. I dont know where your from, but in UK i will say, & I swear by my faith that I have seen many girls who are in their teens YES TEENS that hold hands, sneak out of their homes, go to school with their hijabs on and when their parents go from the school gates they go to female toilets and take the hijab off and chill with their boyfriends, wear make up etc etc. I would also like to point out to you when I wasnt a practsing Sikh during college, a girl who wears a hijab was trying to date me, and her friends told me that she even tried some love potion on me :S what ever that is. I have also seen a hijab bibi who I saw on the tube and was definatly from India/Pakistan origin hugging and kissing AND Sitting IN THE LAPS OF A WHITE BOY, they were college students I was shocked by this. But ofcourse you will have some excuse or reasonale explanation for all of this as im sure you really close to the bibis I have just spoke about. lol The fact is one or two people let the side dowm in all religions, but your VERY narrow minded to say that this does not go on in Islam and that you will never see a muslim woman or girl do this, and that all Sikh girls go to date even the dastaaran valeea. Im sorry to expose your sisters like that, but I felt offened by your post and felt that I would advise you that yes it does happen is Islam and I myself have witnessed it, come to UK and you will see for yourself. And no I dont think our guroo should have blessed us with a path like Islam, Sikhi is soo beautiful... its perfect, you just have to find read about it (without being narrow minded and biased) : ) Sorry if I offened you May Akaal purkh bless all [%sig%]

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

harippa · 19 Jun 2005

i like the innocent catchphrase title. what do you think the paks v blacks fights were about everyday for years in walthamstow and leytonestone in the 1990s? pakistani muslim girls running off impregnated with affro carribean boyfriends. Then your intellectual think tank caught on they cannot control their women, hence began their propaganda to try to get girls from other communities often by brainwashing your lads with seducing tactics filling them with false propaganda in khalifa leaflets like "sikhs took our women away in 1947" "sikhs got our kashmir and gave it to india" (when in fact hari singh was a hindu dogar). Now you have sisters, your own women are becoming much more liberal. 1999 is gone, the world has not ended i am alive so are you, the hijaabs are slowly coming off again, pakistani girls dont want husbands who treat them bad and tolerate no beatings so now your guys are stuck. Your own girls are loosening up again and now this time you will not be able to do anything, the gov ways to corrupt your community has gripped even stronger into your lives and you have no spiritual defence because islam deals on worldly level while sikhism deals on spiritual level. Prophet Mohammed (pbuh) even said once those signs start thats it for you guys. Your power will reduce because your left in name only. Its how you choose to interpret the day of kayamat whether that means the end of a religion or the end of the world. I cannot see the world ending can you? 1999 nothing happened. true you make some converts out of people who do not understand their own religion and find this attachment to islam. But i dare to compare your religion in a wise way against any religion and i bet you will find many holes in your own yet youd love to poke your nose into others to coerce conversions. This is the word of God? Now you show me how you reach the conclusion the quran is the word of God? the 3 caliphs made it, kaliphs were royal bloodlines kings. Kings make and break religions. the difference with us is Sikh Gurus were not political kings they came as reformers of society. Read up on "bloodlines" most of islam is a rehash version of past civilisations created and followed by lemurians, atlantans, passing onto newer civilisations. A form similar to islam existed on earth in past ages with interbreeding extraterrestrial species. where do you think these noahs ark stories come from? its similar to mayan and hindu cncepts of a great flood around the world that took out the civilisation. The "royal bloodlines" the caliphs made a religion to create an empire they were not holy people. prophet Mohammed was a holy man can you even think that he would ask you to torture your new born baby with a chopped nob? or tell you to kill innocent people if they dont convert? the man was obviously gifted and his riddhia sidhia powers of seeing things have been dilluted with this new form of islam designed by the kaliphs who wanted an empire for arabia. Mecca only generates this energy level because it is built on top of a pagan site that sits on "ley lines" where energy grid lines cross flow, old churches have been placed on such sites too . Hence this feeling of a high you get from haj is really a work of nature on the planet. In other places around the world idenitifed by world govs such ley line crossing the grid have been marked over by motorways and bridges to prevent the energy flow from connecting to the peoples bodies energy fields hence another reason why the new world order will place mecca and madina onto its list of occupation sometime. I watch islam channel everyday on recitations of quran. It talks about believer go heaven and infidel go hell. Now how will that take you to your true spiritual capablities inside this god gifted body? you are the same person everyday. Sikhism changes us everyday if we follow it we feel the differences in our lives while you live in the hope of a promise to you when you have not even seen this heaven you talk about. [%sig%]

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Singh. · 19 Jun 2005

Actually, arranged marriage is the Sikh way as well. As for the date of the engagement for marriage, I believe that is set due to cultural circumstances. For example, in Canada it's usually after high school and usually after some post-secondary schooling. But I know that in Punjab even 50 years ago the arrangements would be made while the two Sikhs were very young. As for the people flirting and dating, it is wrong in Sikhi. If somebody chooses to do these things, I don't think it's fair for you to judge Sikhi by the actions of a person who doesn't follow it. If you want to judge Sikhi, then judge it on its own merit or by looking at a pooran Gursikh. I'll do the same for your religion of course. Your post is incredibly judgemental. Not once does it compare Sikhi on its own merits. You only look at the actions of people who don't follow it properly. By the way, I do agree that some Sikhs do judge Muslims unfairly out of ignorance, but the same can be said of Muslims.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Khalistan Zindabad · 19 Jun 2005

Answer this: Why is a muslim man allowed to have 4 wives? What were your Prophets thinking? Have you ever heard of a Hijab girl dating? Yes i have actually, at my SCHOOL! Another Question. If some guy came up to you to ask for help or anything would you not talk to him becuase hes a guy? I dont no wat kind of muslim you are but ive seen many muslim gurls and guyz communicate with the opposite sex Playing Sports with the opposite sex is considered dishonouring yourself? HAHAHA thats a joke Before critizing our faith take a closer look at your own faith, maybe you should be making sure that no more beheadings of innocent people be taken, and stop your extremist groups from killing thousands of innocent people. This post is full of ***admin cut**** lies,

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Singh · 19 Jun 2005

WJKK WJKF "Don't want to give it" My first question to you is... If you really think you knew the sikh faith then you would know a person can call him self a sikh, singh, singhni, khalsa, kaur until they know sikhi and are blessed with amrit and initated into the khalsa panth. One of the rules of sikhi is we cannot have girlfriends or boyfriends, one of the 4 bujjer kureihits (4 cardinal sins) are that you cannot have sex with a woman other than your wife. In sikhism a true sikh is he/her who has conquered his/her mind and not indulged in sexual desire i.e flirting with girls etc. NOW after saying all this about a sikh, then HOW can you say that a person who does whatever you have said, flirt with girls or boys etc HOW CAN THAT PERSON BE A SIKH. Its like calling a muslim a muslim but that muslim doesnt even read the Quran or believe in ALLAH. If a Muslim doesnt believe in allah or doesnt read the Quran or doesnt go to the Mosque... THEN how can you call him a Muslim. In the same way you cannot call that person a sikh who indluges in sexual desire, flirting with boys or girls etc. "y question to you is don't you think your Prophets should have blessed you with a path like ours? You would be better off being like Muslims. Instead of committing these sins." Our prophet is Guru Nanak all the way up to 10th Guru Nanak - Guru Gobind Singh and then the final Guru - Sri Guru Granth Sahib MAHARAJ. Who is prophet of all prophets. and YES he has blessed us with a good path the best path of all. The girls you debate with.. are they real sikhs? Do they wear turbans? Do they wake up 2am or ealier and have ishnaan (baths) and then do hours of NAam abiyaas (cotemplateing on 1 word WAHEGURU) do they wear 5 kakars? If they dont then how can u call them sikhs and why debate with them? Know one is attacking know ones religon.. If your a muslim be a good one at that. If we are sikhs we will try our best to be as saintly and god orienated as the muslisms.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Dogma · 19 Jun 2005

Don't Want to Give it Sister, I don't have time to fully answer your long winded post, as I am sure there are others on this forum who will contend each and every one of your points. But in short...not all Sikh Girls go out dating. Not all Muslim girls who wear hijabs are as pure and chaste as you think they are. I personally knew of a girl in my high school who wore a hijab and was dating a Hindu fellow. However, at the same time I knew of girls who wore hijabs who respected Islamic law and tradition to the letter! My point is that don't be so blinded to believe that everyone who follows Islam is perfect. Let me save you the trouble of realizing this....You're not perfect. To your final question: " My question to you is don't you think your Prophets should have blessed you with a path like ours? You would be better off being like Muslims. Instead of committing these sins. " ...My Guru Sahib has blessed me with the MOST perfect path. The rules and guidelines laid down by my Guru Sahib is PERFECT. There are NO flaws. Because ~I~ do not follow my Guru Sahib's teachings to the best of my abilities is MY OWN FAULT. Not that of my Guru Sahibs. I would think that you would come to the know the difference between knowing the Path and following the Path. As far as me being better off as a Muslim. Countless Sikhs have laid down their lives and NEVER took Islam as their faith.. They were offered everything under the sun to take up your faith and yet we were more than happy dying as Sikhs then " living" as muslims. So the answer to your question is a resounding " NO!~". Lastly, please be advised that this is NOT one of your typical Sikhi sites where there's one thread about SIkhi and the rest are about dating. Your propoganda regarding your faith will NOT fly here. There are TOO many learned Gursikhs here and TOO many dedicated youth here to even take one iota of your propoganda to heart. So to you I say, try your BEST...I guarantee the Gursikhs on this forum will shoot down every one of your "points".... Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

charanjeev singh · 19 Jun 2005

The path of Sikhs is not of 'showmanship'. We do not try to seem to the masses of being a particular way to win their hearts. Our paths is one of a direct relationship with the Creator. As sikhs we are forbidden to have a relationship with the opposite sex out of marriage. If some who appear to be sikhs are engaging in adultery they have commited a cardinal sin and are ex-communicated. However, everyone may be forgiven. Our path is of forgiveness and compassion. I have met a convert muslim woman who, I repeat convert muslim woman who was very adulterous. By your claims that all muslim women/men are not adulterous is absolutely misinformed. You said : My question to you is don't you think your Prophets should have blessed you with a path like ours? Our Guru blessed us with true wisdom and showed us the Path to be a True Muslim. If you should follow these teachings, you would then indeed be able to call yourself a muslim. Shalok, First Mehl: Let mercy be your mosque, faith your prayer-mat, and honest living your Koran. Make modesty your circumcision, and good conduct your fast. In this way, you shall be a true Muslim. Let good conduct be your Kaabaa, Truth your spiritual guide, and the karma of good deeds your prayer and chant. Let your rosary be that which is pleasing to His Will. O Nanak, God shall preserve your honor. ||1|| Ang 140 Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Our Guru saw through the disguises of the masses of people who claimed to be part of a religion through religious garb and sweet words, and taught the masses of the True Path. As a sikh we do not condemn anybody of any faith or belief. But as a Sikh we will sacrifice our lives, and everything else in between, but we will not budge on Our Path.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Singh · 19 Jun 2005

I think you are making a big blunder labelling some acts by Sikh Girls as a general act by all Sikh girls. That statement about muslim girls wearing hijab..I've seen them taking off their hijabs after entering school...i've seen them dating too....however i think its very wrong for us to label muslims as being bad also...

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

AA · 19 Jun 2005

So your are saying that no muslim girl EVER cheated or flirted with anyone?? And then u say no Hijab girl ever dates and u've seen sikhs dating, but remember, there is a BIG difference between a sikh person and a Gursikh. A gursikh would never do that. [%sig%]

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

gg · 19 Jun 2005

in my experiences i have found arabs to be friendly, respective towards sikhs genuinely. Now if arab girls liked me they would simply turn their heads, smile, look down wait as if they want me to approach them, then turn their heads again and smile again blush and look down and go red. They have at least some decency and morals reflective compared to pakistani girls. Let us bear in mind generally arabs are bred muslims, not factory churned out deobandis . However moving onto pakistani and bangladeshi muslim girls its a different story. They are used to an aggresive fast forward environment accustomed to the dating scene and lustufl advances . Just 3 weeks ago i walked past london guildhall university to get to work 2 muslim girls walking towards me smiling, saying something to each other, one pushes the other lightly, the pushed one acts as though she has been pushed hard and comes flying into me and trying to feel my chest up. a pak muslim female who used to be a good friend of mine asked me if i would marry her and bring up children as sikhs if i wished. Obviously i saw her as a friend and nothing else. This week i was walking home from work, a hijab girl kept looking behind to me, and then stopped bent over to sort her shoes or trousers and stopped me asking me for directions, then asked me my name pretending she knew me. I get this unwelcome attension all the time on trains too and its annoying where you just want to be left alone in your own peace. Now i have a caste problem in marrying a real sikh female, i acknowledge without shame frankly that sometimes muslim females look above average due to higher numbers, but never has it crossed my mind to be with any of them. Not out of hate, not out of anger but out of trying to follow this path of sikhism i have embarked on, we cannot date. I hope you can see the difference between what you saw with your own eyes and talking to sikhs who try to follow the commands set out for us. The great shame today for you is more and more pakistani girls are purposely trying to go for sikh and english guys. You can try all the seducing, conversions in the world. you have 1 billion followers and no power just a bargaining credit points first class ticket to janat. God is not behind you, Allah does not want a convert, he wants you to reach heaven via your love for Allahs devotion and not seducing men and women into conevrsions. Can you attain a degree without 3 years of study? can you reach Allah without loving him and just finding convert easy ticket to janat? If you buy this belief this "easy ticket" trap a convert works, then what kind of truth you are following? if it is not truth then perhaps you are misguided with disbelief. If you are really hungry for Allah then chant his name day and night. If you really worry about me burning in hell, do a dua for me daily in your prayer Allah will answer you ameen. Now we too have our share of converts, those converts do not see themselves as such. They do not advertise themselves, they are quiet humble sikhs on spiritual path and motivated by higher ideals with open minds. By trying to force peopel to convert islam pushes people away from non muslims, dominating them, brainwashing that non muslims are evil, coercing converts to run away with this new zeal for islam. However when that zeal wears down that person has just cut off from their entire stock, opportunities in life, to be left alone after the novelty of conversion wears off and all you cared about was your pass ticket to janat. Life is precious, the human contacts we have are a vital source of networking to survive, from the converts to islam i have met their situation is nearlike disastrous after a while their in a mental state. A real conversion is that which loves God in a selfless way without any reward. Let us talk about dozak. If my brother in spirit prays to god night and day never committs a sin in his life according to your belief he burns in hell for eternity. Yet if a muslim commits the same he goes to hell for a few days and gets a first class ticket to paradise. Is this justice? is this logic? You say God is Raheem merciful. do you actually believe in this Raheem quality of Allah? now why would Allah be raheem with the muslim not with my brother? seems like God has mood swings like a normal person, how can you reduce god to a mans level?that is taking the mick. God's qualities cannot even be fathomed. You can talk about heavens, you cannot fathom heaven, have you seen or experienced it?

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

singhsation · 19 Jun 2005

to my brothers and sisters no in particular, just because someone has bashed our religon doesnt give us the right to do the same. making derogatory comments towards hijab speaking woman in defence of our religion is equally wrong. im sure these woman are supposed to be better than this but just like any other religion right now in the world we are in the the dark. we have to stop making generalizations a group of bad muslims should not overshadow what is the great religon of islam. god bless allah, god bless guru nanak and any other messenger of God for it is him the TRUE lord.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

a.singh · 19 Jun 2005

Fateh. One critical point seems to be missing in most of the responses that I have briefly glanced at above. The original poster mentioned she believes only in the stages of childhood and adulthood. What happened to the youth stage? I don't think you can ignore it, it is important.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

singh · 19 Jun 2005

Wow! More than 25 Gursikhs have stood TOGETHER to post their responses and show the true teachings of Sikhi and defend the true universal message of Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Ji Maharaj. That is wonderful. As long as everybody is UNITED in this manner, and never takes BASELESS ATTACKS like these against their faith, we can grow and become stronger. Wow! Wonderful.

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

GURUVAH · 20 Jun 2005

I live in A MUSLIM country....there are even women who wear HIJAB and BURQA are cought by the religious police here commiting ZINA (fornication) !!!!...and u were saying there aren't any...U are still to young my dear...U don't mix around...when u do U will KNOW.......ONE MORE THING!!...no religion is bad!...ONLY PEOPLE ARE BAD, because of heir own deeds.....There have been ULAMA's here cought RAPING little girls who come for their reigious classes.....so does that mean ISLAM is bad............I have a question for u.....IN UR OPINON WHAT IS THE BEST RELIGION????????????(Think wisely and answer my question)

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

sa · 20 Jun 2005

who is a sikh? one that is baptized one that follows guru jis order one who does not commit adultery one who does not cut his/her hair one who does not eat meat one who does not smoke up one who wears kakaars those are the requirements

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

BikramjitSingh · 20 Jun 2005

WJKK WJKF Isn't it amusing that this lady titles her thread 'Please do not bash Muslim faith' and then proceeds to bash Sikhism!! Oh the Muslim mentality, they protest against some isolated cases of Koran abuse but are happy to see the Saudis shred Bibles, Gutkas and any other non-Muslim books found in Saudi Arabia. This post is typical of ones that float around the internet. My faith is better than yours attitude is so prevelant amongst Muslims that they cannot even dare think that another faith may have something better to offer Humanity. The basic error made by this post was that she took the worst examples amongst some people claiming to be Sikhs and compared them to the few good example available amongst Muslims. Typical attitude I see amongst Muslims, it almost as if their conscience is telling them that a true religion and a just God would never condemn those who do not worship him into hellfire forever. No matter how good a person can be just because he/she refuses to believe in Allah and Mohammed he/she is bound for hellfire. People like Bhagat Puran Singh, Mother Theresa and a host of others who serve humanity but stay true to their religion are bound for hellfire! This is why we have this Muslim lady trying her best to warn us about where we are heading! Something inside her, her conscience is telling her that maybe her way is not the truth so she needs to visit forums of other religions to try and sell her faith to them. It is easy to compare Sikhism with Islam and and show how Sikhism wipes the floor with Islam, but only the open minded can see this. Those who have already decided that we Sikhs are bound for hellfire have already closed their minds. For them we need to look to their future births for them to realise what true religion is. Most of the posters have related their experiences with Hijabi girls and unless our Muslim lady has been living on a desert island for the last few years she will know the truth of these facts. Only recently a Muslim girl who used to be a Hijabi was in the newspapers as the UKs first porno star! Looking at arranged marriages, why most Muslim girls go off the boil is because all their prophet has left in store for them is a life of servitude for her husband. This Muslim lady may be happy with her future husband although her posting seems to more like her trying to convince herself that she has made the right choice but most educated Muslim girls from the UK aren't too happy to be taken out of school at 15 and taken to Pakistan to marry their cousin brother who is the local big shot on the goat herding scene! But then again there is also the UK cousin who drives a mincab and claims dole on the sly! Quite a choice and no wonder many Muslim girls start to shop around and see what else is on offer outside the Islamic cage. The life after marriage is no better. If she is too tired to be intimate with her husband the prophet in his wisdom has warned her that the Angels will curse her all night! Even if she's busy in the kitchen she has to come to him at the click of his fingers! If she is seen to be obstinate in her husband's eyes then she can look forward to a divinely sanctioned beating! Anyway good try Miss 'don't want to give it' and all the best in your marriage ;) GurFateh Bikramjit [%sig%]

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

hawk · 20 Jun 2005

yep there are some sikhs who date just like muslims. believe it or not there are some sikhs who will kill people for dating. 956, 836 sikhs in hareeana living in a fusion of medieval values with the worlds best religion sikhism. Girlfriend and boyfriend relationships are not tolerated in the punjabi dominated parts of the region. The regional customs involving panchayts and punishments come into play. Girls and boys are bought up with a very strong sense of clan mentality and living with honour, so what they do affects their family name. If people are caught dating regardless what religion they are they are rounded up by the whole village. Panchayts usually order death sentances by throwing bodies into the ghaggar riverbed.This is how regional life is there not strictly only sikhs. If you had the same situation of muslim guys and sikh gurls u get in uk in hareeana i will definatly say one whole generation of muslim boys would have been wiped out by now and hizbut tahrir would have been turned to keema meat on the very first week they gave out leaflets against sikh women. The system of panchayats is collective and mobile where one unit of a village quickly merges with another, when they sense a threat they gather in big numbers. The natives are hostile towards a extra marital relations occuring in families which is considered a threat to family lifestyle. When the whole pind panchayt gathers you cant fight and win for material love because its a love for attachment of five elements and lust. common folk with families will die for somthing they believe in. the very birth of baratpur the only jat country in modern history was born from a moghul ruler raping native women. the natives fury at their dishonour gathered faujs and fought the moghuls till they themselves were sacrificed. Their own sacrifices born new spirit until their small country was liberated by the natives. Churamans words were something like you have dealt a blow to our hearts by raping our women now we take the battlefield to avenge or die. The first batch may have been sacrificed but thats the spirit when your women are taken away you fight and win or fight and die in the struggle ensueing to the next world where victory awaits. Sunil maan the new supermodel has taken the values of no gf relationship before marriage to the national media surprising the audiences who are usually fed bollywood kunjar scenes by saying "thats how things are where we come from". The same mentality exists amongst the poor and some sections of peasantry all over punjabi influenced domains. there are some relaxing with romance due to placing the attachment of their kid above traditions of the land. What you are seeing in england or america is dirty air polluting the concious of already urbanised people just like you get muslim gurls checking guys it doesnt mean all muslim gurls are like that. But i will confirm that when i was a kid it was mostly muslim girls who hit on me and other sikh guys in very forthright ways. [%sig%]

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

hehe · 20 Jun 2005

lollll "cant think of a name" has just beeen RIPPPPEDDD baddd...what uk uni are u from? the open university?

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Dandilion · 20 Jun 2005

Brilliant posts from everyone, especially BikramjitSingh. One small point, if a Muslim addresses you with a 'Asalam Alaikum' (as they invariably do) I think it is the duty of a Sikh to reply with a full blown 'Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh' [%sig%]

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

S Kaur · 20 Jun 2005

Waheguru j ila khlasa Waheguru ji ka fateh Before critisizing our peaceful religion what about your muslim girls with scarfs i broke up with 1 of my muslim friends because she was so obcessed with sex and boys, chatrooms so get YOUR facts ryt. You are causeing even more friction between the 2 religions so dont make it worse. Please watch what YOU say in future reference as this can cause a lot of conflict. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

BikramjitSingh · 20 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh The lady's argument has pretty much been demolished but what was interesting is her comparison of Sikhism with islam. She seemed to imply that just because in her blinkered 'never been out' view of the UK situation the Muslim girls were more chaste than the Sikh girls it implies that Islam is superior. Why not take this to it's logical conclusion Lets compare some other figures from the UK govt. 82 % of Sikhs own their own homes 52 % of Muslims own their own homes 14 % of Muslim men are unemployed 9 % of Sikh men are unemployed 31 % of Muslim men of working age have no qualifications 23 % of Sikh men of working age have no qualifications 23 % of Sikhs between the ages of 16-30 have a degree 14 % of Muslims between the ages of 16-30 have a degree 10 % of Sikhs between the ages of 45-54 were divorced 17 % of Muslims between the ages of 45-54 were divorced 1 in 965 Sikhs is in prison ( about 350 ) 1 in 230 of Muslims is in prison ( about 6500 ) As the Muslim lady said >>My question to you is don't you think your Prophets should have blessed you with a path like ours? You would be better off being like Muslims. Instead of committing these sins.<< GurFateh Bikramjit

Re: Please do not bash Muslim Faith

Admin · 20 Jun 2005

A special thanks to all of you for standing up for our faith. We are very proud of your contributions under this thread. We had to disapprove some of the messages and had to edit others because they did not meet the standards of this forum. By using foul language we lose credibility. So we must avoid it. It is against Gurmat to use foul language. Once again thanks for all these posts to counter the unfounded attack on our faith by a Muslim sister. We appeal our readers to keep vigil in the future too. Admin.