Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

The Saroop at Kartarpur

The Saroop at Kartarpur

Question · 20 Jun 2005

I request that Raagmala, Mool Mantar, Keski, Meat, Sant vs Bhai, Sant Ji's Shaheed etc etc any other issues are not brought up in this thread and directed elsewhere should they need to be raised. My question is pertaining to the authenticity of the Bir being held at Kartarpur which is claimed to be the original written by Bhai Gurdas Ji, as dictated by Guru Arjun Dev Ji. Could people please provide, clearly referenced reasons as to why/why this is not the original Bir. How about some photographic evidence.

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

Rashminder Singh Oz · 21 Jun 2005

good ideaaaa any one plssssssssssss

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

ONE · 21 Jun 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh !! Here is a darshan of the Aad Granth Sahib - known as the 'Kartarpuri Bir' - for the Sangat. [IMG]http://img7.echo.cx/img7/3860/maharajkartarpuribir3yr.jpg[/IMG] a detail of the above picture [IMG]http://img159.echo.cx/img159/7329/kartarpuribir8bd.png[/IMG] * pictures from 'Maharaja Ranjit Singh' - Mohinder Singh,Rishi Singh,Sondeep Shankar - UBSPD & NIPS - 2002 You can see the Mahavaak - Raag Suhi Mahalla 1 Chaupde Ghar 1 Siri Guru Granth Sahib - Ang 728 ik oa(n)kaar sath naam karathaa purakh nirabho niravair akaal moorath ajoonee saibha(n) gur prasaadh || raag soohee mehalaa 1 choupadhae ghar 1 bhaa(n)ddaa dhhoe bais dhhoop dhaevahu tho dhoodhhai ko jaavahu || dhoodhh karam fun surath samaaein hoe niraas jamaavahu ||1|| japahu th eaeko naamaa || avar niraafal kaamaa ||1|| rehaao || eihu man eettee haathh karahu fun naethro needh n aavai || rasanaa naam japahu thab mathheeai ein bidhh a(n)mrith paavahu ||2|| man sa(n)patt jith sath sar naavan bhaavan paathee thripath karae || poojaa praan saevak jae saevae einh bidhh saahib ravath rehai ||3|| kehadhae kehehi kehae kehi jaavehi thum sar avar n koee || bhagath heen naanak jan ja(n)pai ho saalaahee sachaa soee ||4||1|| One Universal Creator God. Truth Is The Name. Creative Being Personified. No Fear. No Hatred. Image Of The Undying. Beyond Birth. Self-Existent. By Guru's Grace: Raag Soohee, First Mehl, Chau-Padas, First House: Wash the vessel, sit down and anoint it with fragrance; then, go out and get the milk. Add the rennet of clear consciousness to the milk of good deeds, and then, free of desire, let it curdle. ||1|| Chant the Name of the One Lord. All other actions are fruitless. ||1||Pause|| Let your mind be the handles, and then churn it, without sleeping. If you chant the Naam, the Name of the Lord ,with your tongue, then the curd will be churned. In this way, the Ambrosial Nectar is obtained. ||2|| Wash your mind in the pool of Truth, and let it be the vessel of the Lord; let this be your offering to please Him. That humble servant who dedicates and offers his life, and who serves in this way, remains absorbed in his Lord and Master. ||3|| The speakers speak and speak and speak, and then they depart. There is no other to compare to You. Servant Nanak, lacking devotion, humbly prays: may I sing the Praises of the True Lord. ||4||1|| http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=2783 [%sig%]

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

Neech · 21 Jun 2005

I think the authenticity is not questionable. Many authors have proven this. However, I think that the Dhir Maliay have attempted to play tricks on the panth as to exactly what they have in their possesion. They have also been accused of changing the order of the pannay when the Aad Bir was re-bound. The reason for some of these accusations has been the fact that different people who supposedly had darshan of the same saroop came away and reported different things.

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

Manjit kaur · 21 Jun 2005

imho what neech says is right. The Dhirmalliyas are PANTH DOKHIS....and Jehangir gave them posession of Sikhe's greatest Treasure..and they may have made soe spurious copies to mislead scholars....and then there are the MC Leod's chelas scholars like Pashaura Singh etc who are also bent on MISLEADING SIKHS...by trying to "see" what is not there and saying blasphemous things like Guru Arjun ji changed Guru nanak jis bani etc.. BUT by the time of Guur Teg bahadur Ji, there were many Sroops of Guru Granth Ji all over the place and many Gursikhs had many banis memeorised..and when Guru Gobind Singh ji had the Guru Granth ji rewritten there was no mix ups or additions. All additions like raagmala came later.

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

A Singh · 22 Jun 2005

Wah Ji Wah! Manjit Kaur, great style you have...and oooooh, just couldn't keep away from the raagmala point could we! Shabash!

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

Anon · 22 Jun 2005

Quite to the opposite, spurious composions came in Birs from a very early stage.

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

Dogma · 22 Jun 2005

A Singh Jee, Some people will see a heap of cow dung on the road and be content to leave it alone and keep walking. Others will see that same dung and poke a stick at it, move it around, stir it up and then sit and fully enjoy the repugnant stench that they have created... of course, I imagine you know who I'm talking about ;) Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

tera baap · 22 Jun 2005

i guess thats ur smell eh dogma? so what if she sed raag mahla is she gonna die for that? its a valid piont in the context of this thread and u guys shudnt be ***admin cut*** and jut go syco cuz she metioned it. also dogma cud u give some examples if palces wher there is dung on the road, i mean even in india i didnt see this maybe its common where u live.

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

Manjit kaur · 22 Jun 2005

dogma jio,... and some people will TRY their LEVEL BEST to REMOVE the DUNG...so the Road will be clean and people wont get their feet soiled by stepping in it...BUT then Dogmatic "main na manuus" will come along and say..WHO are YOU to remove this dung..IS it YOUR'S ? is it your Cow's..What "proof" that it is Dung..My respected so and so says it is PERFUME Maala......you DO KNOW who I mean dont you ?? Let those who are trying to REMOVE the DUNG do their job.... the "dung" just doesnt BELONG..on this Path to Divinity...only FLOWERS and Beautiful Perfumes are normal.... WahegurujikakhalksawahegurujikiFATEH.

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

Dogma · 23 Jun 2005

Manjit Kaur Jee, Who says it's your job? I'm sorry but did I miss the memo where someone appointed YOU as the caretaker of the Panth? If you feel that this Raagmala issue has to be resolved then how about going to Akal Takhat and voicing an opinion there? Of course that would require some actual EFFORT on your part and not typing on some message board trying to convince yourself that you're some type of mahaan sevadaar for this Panth. Also, in case you didn't notice, the ORIGINAL post asked for that "Raagmala, Mool Mantar, Keski, Meat, Sant vs Bhai, Sant Ji's Shaheed etc etc any other issues are not brought up in this thread" If you feel the urge to talk about Raagmala there's already a couple threads OPEN on it. Please direct your comments there. At least leave a FEW threads on this board that don't contain the Raagmala debate. Some of us would like AKAL TAKHAT to resolve the question for the Panth instead of hearing every Tom, Dick and Manjit weighing in with their "expert" opinion. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: The Saroop at Kartarpur

N Singh · 23 Jun 2005

C'mon people... the original post asked not to bring in any issue such as Raagmala, Mool Mantar, Keski, Meat, Sant vs Bhai, Sant Ji's Shaheed etc. What will you get by ruining this thread? nothing. Let the discussion of this thread be only for the Kartarpuri bir. [%sig%]