Dasam Granth/Appendix
Khalsa Soulja · 09 Sep 2003
WJKK WJKF Saadh Sangat Ji!
I was wondering if someone could tell me something about the Appendix in the Dasam Granth. Is it Gurbani or an interpolation? Where can I read it? What evidence suggests it is real/not?
Thankyou for your time.
WJKK WJKF
Re: Dasam Granth/Appendix
Kulbir Singh · 09 Sep 2003
What appendix?
Re: Dasam Granth/Appendix
Balpreet Singh · 09 Sep 2003
The shabads appended onto to Dasam Granth like "Nishaanay Sikhi" etc. are not necessarily authentic. Some are considered fakes universally and others are debatable. The Nishaanay Sikhi one has been proven to be from much later, the rest are questionable.
To read the "appendix" you'd have to see different volumes of the Granth. The Chatter Singh Jeevan Singh edition has a pretty big one, but since the appendix is optional, it's not included in the same form or at all in all versions/editions.
Re: Dasam Granth/Appendix
Khalsa Soulja · 10 Sep 2003
WJKK WJKF
thanks bhai sahib!
is the one with the kakkars named (one being kesh?!?) a universally considered fake one?
which bir is this in? do u have any idea when it could be interpolated and how can we be 100percent sure it is not gurbani?
WJKK WJKF