Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Death Penalty

Death Penalty

Newspaper Column · 10 Sep 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh There is a weekly "Ask the Religious Experts" Column in our local newspaper where a question is given out and different faiths answer it according to their teachings. The following is the next question that we need to answer on behalf of the Sikh faith: Question: (Due SEPTEMBER 16) Ontario premier Ernie Eves has suggested Canada should resurrect the death penalty for some premeditated crimes against children and law enforcement officers. What does your faith teach about the death penalty? We would greatly appreciate input on this question and lines from Gurbani. It is not what we personally think, but what Sikhi says... I understand the viewpoint of the sanctity of life, rehabilitation, social and racist injustices with the death penalty (more blacks and economically impoverished individuals given death penalty for the same crimes than whites and economically upper class ind.)... But how do we then explain for ex. the killing of General O'Dwyer, Indra Gandhi (could argue no other means for justice, punishment or rehabilitation) and other instances in Sikh history... Keeping in mind the readership is non Sikhs The answer needs to be between 300-350words, so we cannot go into great detail...

Re: Death Penalty

yo · 11 Sep 2003

May he who is w/o sin cast the first stone.

Re: Death Penalty

hmm · 11 Sep 2003

Death penalty for rapists!

Re: Death Penalty

Dasan Das · 11 Sep 2003

Vaheguroojikakhalsa Vaheguroojikifathe This is to "yo", what is the point you are making, that comment has very little basis. Everyone on this earth (excluding Brahgyanis...upon whose shoulders the whole universe rests) is guilty of some form of sin, whether against mans law or Vaheguroo's law. However, whilst Dharm Raj will judge evryone in Vaheguroo's court (as per the scribes of 'Chiter' and 'Gupt') criminals should face the actions of thier crimes whilst on this earth too, else criminals would run amock. The question of capital punishment I think has been set by Choji Preetam, Satguroo Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj, when the Masands were burnt alive (if I remember correctly, that couldron still remains.) That said, my second point is to "hmm". Veerji/bhenji, Im afraid its not as simple as that. We have to judge each case based on its individual circumstances. Allow me to refer you to a case in Africa where CNN reported 6 men were aressted for gang raping a baby girl...9 months old (Vaheguroo). Icidentally, they did this because of rumours that sex with a virgin could cure Aids. Now initially we would call for the death sentence, however statistics have showed that those who carried out such acts were themselves victims of abuse when they were younger, so this changes things a little (although not much). Humbly, Dasan Das Vaheguroojikakhalsa Vaheguroojikifathe