Writings of Bhagat Singh
Kulbir Singh · 23 Jun 2005
Bhagat Singh was a declared atheist and not only that, he also wrote a long article named "Main Naastik kyoon haan” (Why am I an atheist). In this article he has used beautiful language to explain his side. It shows how mature he was and how well read he was. It is sad that his views were like this. I don't agree with his arguments but I think it is time that his questions get answered and his assertions are refuted.
It is a known fact that he met Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee in jail and after meeting him his views were changed. It is not known how much dent Bhai Sahib made in his views but from his letters it seems like he was very strong in his convictions.
He was very proud and cocky. He was very honest and his intentions were very good. He was against any compromise with the government and once when his father filed an appeal against his wishes, he wrote a very angry letter to his father. I have noticed that his earlier letters show a lot of high spirits and enthusiasm but a letter he wrote to his brother about 10 days before his death, showed helplessness and despair. This helplessness and despair was his property, his destiny because he probably failed to adopt Vaheguru fully in his heart.
The question I want to ask Sangat is if anyone has so far refuted his article on non-existence of God. If anyone has any information with respect to this, please post the same.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Satpurakh Niranjan · 23 Jun 2005
I didn't think very much to his article on God. He generally rambles on about various unrelated matters and fails to make his points with clear logic.
One of his points is to do with the question as to why God created a planet where there is so much unrest. This does not refute the existence of God at all. I think Bhagat Singh makes this point because he saw himself as cleaning up a mess which was God's job in his eyes. He therefore thought that an omnipotent God can not exist as He would have saved man from such suffering. I can't help feeling that Bhagat Singh just never really got to understand Gurmat. If he had the time in his short life, perhaps he would have been written about the existence of God rather than the opposite.
He criticises the 84 Lakh theory, but doesn't really make is point very well. He tries to support the Darwinian theory of evolution, but this doesn't oppose any Gurmat concept.
He said that man was capable of facing calamity in life without praying to God, which is true as many atheists do, but this does not mean that God does not help them anyway.
In short, his ego had the better of him. He was not God fearing at all, which was a huge mistake.
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Harminder Singh · 23 Jun 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh!
my naniji was the youngest sister of shaheed bhagat singh. The only living sibling living of bhagat singh, is his sister, prakaash kaur.
Kulbir singh, I am writing the following with no disrespect to bhai randhir singh, but to rather give the view that has been passed down and 'found' by myself.
My nanaji studied in the same university as bhagat singh. My nanaji had been approached by him and was in grist so he did not join the movement. He did note that bhagat singh was always doing simran. When he was in hiding he had made it to local gurdwaras and did bheta of a ramalla on each sangrand (this information is what his mother told my mother, while my mom visited her in her early teens at khatkar kalan).
Kishan singh (shaheed bhagat singh's father) was an amritdhari sikh who had actually insisted that his wedding be done as per sikh tradition (anand karaj). His father, arjan singh, was heavily influenced by the arya samaaji movement. Some members in the family claim that he was a pure arya smaaji, others say it was just his support for the movement (mind you, the majority of the family are of a more 'secular' nature....although there were disputes between the party they supported....so they stayed punjabi...even did sikh customs, but some of the brothers were married to
'hindu' ladies)....
This is the part people will not agree with, and I apologize in advance for any discomfort this may cause.
The picture of bhagat singh with kesh looking to his left was in 1919....well before he was martyred. According to the family, bhagat singh's views did not change by meeting bhai randhir sngh ji. I saw and read through his diary that he had in jail, and it in no place had any mention of bhai randhir singh. his last writings were of a socialist nature, and the belief was an empowerment of people through goodnes...(hence people see the communist views). Family members who had seen him prior to death all mentioned that he didn't have a joora at that time. He did keep his kesh out of respect for bhai randhir singh, prior to meeting him...after that I've been told he wasn't keshdari. There have been political issues that the certain members in the family had with kapur singh and with kairon which have been attributed to the lack of recognition of bhagat singh as a sikh (apart from him not being amritdhari).
Out of the brothers of shaheed bhagat singh, not one grew his kesh! further it was only the sons of the sisters who actually had. If a sikh is defined as being amritdhari and at least having faith in amritdhari ideals, I doubt anyone in his family apart from his father could be deemed amritdhari. Feel free to email me (as I have included it in this email). I have talked to many of the relatives to find out what the effect of bhai sahib bhai randhir singh was on bhagat singh and they say that he respected bhai sahib as a sant and a freedom fighter, but anything beyond that, nothing. I was 'told' that the discussion was actually relayed to bhagat singh ji's mother and that the family was initially shocked when they read jail chittian as the account they heard was very different.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Bhopinder Singh · 23 Jun 2005
I dont think Bhai sahib would lie ever.Why should he lie? What motive?
He needs no recognition.Lets look at his history in writings,Not a single lie.
question is of all his writings why is this one always questioned and his integrity always challenged ,Why?.Well it lies in the question itself.
Bhai sahib wrote this for a reason, for nothing hewrote without one.As the future has prooved our struggle for independence ( KHALISTAN) the biggest weapon of the enemey were communists and you all knoe how they were posted in all the educational institutions,media,polity and so on.
It is true Bhai sahib did change him because he says so .Indian intelligence and their bodies communists have tried their best to no avail.
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Mehtab Singh · 24 Jun 2005
Here is a paragraph from an article I wrote on Bhagat Singh some 2.5 years ago for a university magazine ([i]this is not the complete article[/i]).
[i]Many people are probably unaware of the fact that Bhagat Singh was an atheist. He had read a lot about Bakunin, Lenin, Trotsky and other
social revolutionaries of that era who were from other parts of the
world and who were also atheists. He believed that it was better to giveup ones life for ones country without any selfish desire, rather than expecting reincarnation as a king in the next life in case one believed in rebirth, or looking forward to enjoying sexual maidens in paradise for those who disregarded the rebirth theory and looked upon life as a one-time offer. He thus called his sacrifice as totally selfless without even the least bit of desire for personal pleasure, even if it was
meant to be procured after death. I have myself had a chance to read his article entitled Why I am atheist. Although Bhagat Singh makes a
brilliant attempt in clarifying why he was an atheist, [u]I have a feeling
that his atheism was more circumstancial than a strongly held notion.
The reason I call it circumstancial is because from this article of his,
he seems to have been frustrated at the way the British were treating
Indians in their own country. He questioned the existence of God by
demanding the Almighty’s intervention in giving the British a sense to
leave India. That never happened on it’s own, resulting in his becoming a disbeliever[/u]. Now since I call it circumstancial, I beg to be apologized for putting but one question here: What if India wasn’t under British rule? Even if it was, what if independence was achieved before Bhagat Singh lost his faith? Would he still go on to become an atheist? The answer most probably would not be yes, even though I don’t rule out its possibility. But hey, this is just a personal opinion. Even though I am not an atheist, I can still be wrong and don’t hesitate to stand corrected.[/i]
[%sig%]
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
............... · 24 Jun 2005
Sirdar kapur Singh in his biography, caled Sau sakhi specifically mentioned that Bhagat singh was very influenced by Bhai sahib, and he wished to take Amrit afterwards.
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Bhopinder Singh · 24 Jun 2005
HE died as SIKH no matter how hard you try. He was changed by Bhai sahib.
Brits knew this
Sikhs have big hearts ask the race that dominated the world for 1000 years ie Brits
Comarades can do anything even the very bases of their ideology have been routed distroyed,Bellsof churches are ringing in russia former USSR is filled with the bangs from the Masjids so is China.
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
.............. · 24 Jun 2005
sikhs just need to learn to pick better leaders......
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Harminder Singh · 24 Jun 2005
Again, I will reiterate,
sardar kapur singh had a vendetta against amar kaur (the eldest sister of bhagat singh).....if you are interested in a more first hand account feel free to contact professor jagmohan singh dhaliwal from the agricultural university ludhiana....
I have been told the story but do not feel it is appropriate to share it as I, for one, have a strong liking for sardar kapoor singh.
again, I reiterate....bhai randhir singh ji's affect on bhagat singh was not to the calibre that it has been presented. Had this been the case, his brothers, who emulated him would have followed in his footsteps (as it is already shown in the decisions they chose).
I'd say it is masalla, kulbir singh sandhu (eldest brother of bhagat singh) had issues with kairon...so the mixing in with sikhs from punjab as well him staying in faridabad, delhi.....also, it is human nature....the family adopted the "indian" view.....(probably because they were getting more out of it).
And to answer bhaaji's question, I have been told that bhagat singh's mother was very very strong.
I acknowledge everyone's stance, and will not be reiterating anything else. If someone does have a question, please feel free to email me thanks
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Kulbir Singh · 24 Jun 2005
Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh!
Veer Harminder Singh jeeo.
Thank you for a very informative post. I found out some very interesting facts from your email and most of what you have written is more authentic than anything else because it is coming from Bhagat Singh's family. I do however have some comments that I would like to make.
It is amazing to know that his father was an Amritdhari Gursikh. Great to hear this. I know that Sardar Arjun Singh jee, Bhagat Singh’s grandfather was an Arya Samaji. Could you please shed light on how Sardar Kishan Singh jee became an Amritdhari Singhs even though his father was an Arya Samaji? Sardar Arjun Singh tried his best to make Bhagat Singh an Arya Samaji but how did not not try to influence his own son Sardar Kishan Singh? What did Sardar Arjun Singh feel about Sardar Kishan Singh's Sikhi?
I am surprised to read some of the articles that Bhagat Singh has written when he was only 17 years old i.e. in 1924. He was born in 1907 and his article on Punjabi language and heritage is very interesting and it really surprised me to see such maturity at such tender age. I don’t fully agree with his notions in that article. He has written about the plight of the Punjabi language. He complains that Punjabi Hindus want to adopt Hindi and the Muslims want to adopt Urdu. He says that the language that Punjabis should adopt is Punjabi. He goes on to defend the Punjabi language and gives examples of Punjabi poetry to display the beauty of the Punjabi language. So far so good. Then he wrote something very disturbing that perhaps was written as the circumstances were in those days. While he advocates that all Punjabis adopt the Punjabi language, he severely criticized the Gurmukhi and Urdu script. He gives an example of the shortfall of the Urdu script but it seems that he did not give enough thought to the Gurmukhi script. I would have expected him to be a champion of the Gurmukhi script. In the conclusion of his article he goes on to say that it would be best to write Punjabi using the Devnagri (Hindi) script. It was a big disappointment.
-----------
His father, arjan singh, was heavily influenced by the arya samaaji movement. Some members in the family claim that he was a pure arya smaaji, others say it was just his support for the movement (mind you, the majority of the family are of a more 'secular' nature....
------------
I think Sardar Arjun Singh was a very strict Arya Samaji. Do you know what religion his Chacha Sardar Ajit Singh used to follow? Was he a Singh or an Arya Samaji?
------------
The picture of bhagat singh with kesh looking to his left was in 1919....well before he was martyred.
-----------
The picture cannot possible be from 1919 because in this year, he was only 12 years old. Communists claim that this picture is from 1927, when he was arrested for the first time. If you carefully look at the picture, his jooRa is not visible but he does seem to have long hair. If this picture had been from 1927, instead of 1931, he would have had a clear jooRa. After his martyrdom, the granthi Bhai Natha Singh who did his last rites, later told the press that Bhagat Singh had 6 inches long hair at his last moments.
To Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee he clearly promised that he would keep his hair and would never cut them. When he told Bhai Sahib that he would keep hair at his behest but he did not believe in God, Bhai Sahib told him that he now no longer cared if he kept kesh. After this Bhai Sahib very emotionally told him that he is going to come back and that he is not going to die. His atma would never die. Hearing all this from Bhai Sahib, Bhagat Singh was totally stunned and could not move. It was as if his beliefs had been shattered and at that point he promised to Bhai Sahib that he would never cut his hair and that he now believed that God exists.
Some say that it is not fair to assume that after one small meeting with Bhai Sahib, he totally transformed and became a Singh. His sangat in jail was not very good in the terms of religion. But Sirdar Kapur Singh, who was an ICS officer and had reach with big officers of that time has written that Bhagat Singh requested that he be served amrit in the jathedari of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee.
It should be noted that he met Bhai Sahib probably on night of October 6, 1930 and he attained martyrdom on 23 March 1931. He lived for about 6 months after he met Bhai Sahib. The notes that you see from him were the great sayings he found in different books he read and could have been from prior to meeting Bhai Sahib. As I said before, he may not have become a Rassiya of Gurbani but he was certainly influenced by Bhai Sahib. He reached out to touch Bhai Sahib’s feet but Bhai Sahib stopped him saying that only Guru Sahib’s feet should be touched.
Please add any more information you have about this great man Bhagat Singh.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Bhopinder Singh · 24 Jun 2005
you can fool some people all the time
you can fool all people some time
you cant fool all people all the time
life long argument of communists of the picture being taken in 1919 is not possible logically .If he was born 1907 to mature for the picture, direct agents for the Indian intelligence ( communists) and their lies have just fallen apart, torn apart i wonder what raw is thinking now.
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Kulbir Singh · 25 Jun 2005
Harminder Singh jee, please respond to my request in the last post.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
harminder singh · 27 Jun 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh!
I'm glad kulbir singh has asked the following questions, I just revisited this post right now after my last writing.
for the sake of absolute truth, I will confirm with my mother's massiji as to the exact date of that picture. I heard it from her son, and I will say...let it stand from kulbir singh's post and bhopinder singh's post that they are more right than I am as to the date of that picture.
I shall write soon and try to validate and authenticate as much information as possible.
stay in chardiankallah,
ps. th 6 inch hair length seems VERY probable as the family even till now will say bhagat singh only cut his hair to go into disguise.....,and the only people who say otherwise are the one's with an arya smaaji leaning... and I think that the arya samaaji leaning and its non acceptance of anything outside of its view of religion is 'possibly' what could have been seen by kishan singh...what I have said is not gospel and I am giving an opinion.
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Harminder Singh · 28 Jun 2005
kulbir singh jee,
I will definitely ask and try to confirm the answers to the questions which you have asked.
I asked my mother about the picture and she said he was "19" in that picture.....meaning that either I misheard, or my mamaji may have miscommunicated it....it is more likely the former than the latter as it is factual and can't really be swung to make an ideological stance.
hanji, as per ajit singh...I will ask again today what he was, but I do know that he died of a heart attack when india was split...he died right at that moment.
Actually, I just reread what you wrote about the shahmukhi and gurmukhi script, personally, I find that disappointing as well. My disappointment is 2 fold, firstly....guruji's benefit to society (for those who want to take a more secular approach) was one where guruji empowered EVERYONE and taught EVERYONE!!....I don't think the same can be said about devnagari....as a gursikh the reverance for gurmukhi script is beyond discussion...
From another perspective, I find the use of "devnagari" disturbing because shahmukhi is also categorically removed....(a person would be wondering, why is a sikh in favor or shahmukhi...) it isn't any pull towards shahmukhi as it is the fact that anything that it implicates that shahmukhi and gurmukhi are not suited to be scripts, and that only ONE script should take precedence....(this sounds very arya smaaji to me).
Again, I will ask around today as I feel I may get some quality answers, and for the sangat please feel free to ask me to relay whatever I can. I have no hesitation in relaying any information....where I sense biases from family I will mention it.
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Harminder Singh · 28 Jun 2005
gurfateh ji,
one last point before I head out.....
the book I read and notes I had seen were clearly from the day before he died...it was dated in his hand writing....now, I can't say from just looking at that book that that was his "only" book or that it was ALL his memoirs, so the possibility of him being affected and not being transcribed into that is very probable, the reason that I made the comment that he wasn't that affected is that it has been said over and over that sardar kapur singh fabricated stuff about bhagat singh (by family members)...also there is supposedly a letter that was sent back to his family regarding the meeting with bhai randhir singh, I will try to find out what I can though....
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Writings of Bhagat Singh
Bhagat Of Bhagat Singh · 01 Jul 2005
Please some one Help Me I have tried every thing to contact the family members of Bhagat singh If any of you can help me contact them i will be very much thankful to you.
with due respect
Bhagat of Bhagat singh