Re: British india?
Bhopinder Singh · 26 Jun 2005
Not just sikhs, all races no matter from what part of british created India took part porbias or bhaias from up,bihar,mp,maharashtra were in the british army,Infact they fought against the sikhs in the angelo-sikh wars .
As sikhs were fighting the british in 1848-1849 even Gen Guff has written that the entire fate of the brit imperial army hangs in balance as the sikhs almost routed them and it is not just punjab but that the entire India they are going to liberate.
Soldiery of Sikh soldier was considered and is even to this day second to none written by Brits although poorbias and all races of the Brit created India were present in higher numbers than the sikhs nothing of the sort is written about them.
It is for those brave Sikhs that we were brought here by the queen.If you look at those times all over India dalits were not even allowed to show their face to oncomming highercaste not even allowed to settle towars the sun.we were no better then them ourselves,But as the times have changed so have the people .
[%sig%]
Re: British india?
singhdicate · 27 Jun 2005
If it wasn't for the Sikh Regiments (recruited from the Khalsa Army) siding with the British during the 1857 Mutiny, India would have been free at that time.
that is why their is a lot of underlining hostility towards the Sikhs from Indian nationalists, in my opinion they have never forgiven the Sikhs for this
The Sikhs have always been placed in high regard by the British, the India General Service Medal issued between 1895-1902 has a Sikh and British soldier standing side by side holding the Union Jack, they did this out of respect as they viewed the Sikh as a fellow comrad.
singhdicate
Re: British india?
Kulbir Singh · 27 Jun 2005
Singhdicate,
-------
If it wasn't for the Sikh Regiments (recruited from the Khalsa Army) siding with the British during the 1857 Mutiny, India would have been free at that time.
-------
You are misinformed. In the 1800s, there was no concept of Akhand Bharat or united India. 10 years before 1857, the British came to Punjab with Poorbiyaas i.e. soldiers from Bihar and UP, and they annexed Punjab. Many atrocities were committed in Punjab by Poorbiyaas. Shah Mohammad has written about the war between Sikhs and Poorbis i.e. residents of UP, Bihar, very beautifully:
Jang Hind Punjab da hon lagaah, doven Faujaan dekho bhariyaan neh |
Ajj hoveh Sarkaar taan mul paaveh, jo teghaan Singhaan ne maariyaan neh||
(Fight between Hindustan and Punjab began. Armies on both sides were very heavy. If Sarkar i.e. Raja Ranjit Singh jee had been alive today, he would have recognized how well the Singhs used their swords to slaughter the poorbis).
And
Jang Hind-Punjab da hon laga, Chare Hindustani-Purbi-Dakkhani ji.
These poorbis came to Punjab and took away the independence of Sikhs. Sikhs were very upset at the poorbis for assisting the British to annex Punjab. 10 years later, they were given chance and it is recorded in history that the Sikhs soldiers in British army at that time, settled the score with Poorbis and severely crushed their so called, fake war for independence.
First of all, it is foolish to call this mutiny the war for independence of India. There was no concept of India at that time and all kings who fought were fighting to save their own kingdoms.
Kulbir Singh
Re: British india?
singhdicate · 27 Jun 2005
Kulbir Singh,
the jist of my point was that without the help of the Sikhs, the British would have faced defeat, and who knows what would have become of India or the Sikhs.
you might not agree but Indian nationalists do support the notion that the Mutiny was an attempt to free themselves from colonial rule, it is their ammo, not mine.
They are looking at it in a nostalgic and romantic angle, which is far more powerful then the truth.
singhdicate
Re: British india?
JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Jun 2005
Dear sindhicate jio,
The Mutiny was a JOKE. The Hindus were fighting because the ammo was tainted with cow fat.... the Muslims were fighting due to ammo tainted with pig fat. BOTH these wanted to REINSTATE the MOGHUL EMPEROR.
Now just after becoming the Joe Boys of the British and helping them in DESTROYING the KHALSA RAAJ of Punjab, these mutineers wanted Sikhs to support the Moghul Raaj that SIKHS had fought with and DEFEATED, less than 50 years ago....the SAME moghuls who tortured and killed Hundreds of thousands of SIKHS just for being SIKH.... WHICH SIKH in his right mind would want a Moghul Ruler back on the throne of delhi.
And also all these mutineers were themsleves DIVIDED....the Nawab of Oudh was fighting for his own kingdom....not INDIA which didnt even exist.
All this double speak about SIKHS being responsible for "India becoming British" sounds HOLLOW when these same writers NEVER MENTION that PUNJAB was the LAST to come under British Rule, WAS the FIRST to RISE in REBELLION, and SHED the MOST BLOOD in the Fight for Independence..and SUFFERED the MOST when Independence came and has been suffering ever since. The British arrived in india during JEHANGIR's time...BUT they managed to set foot in PUNJAB only in 1850 AFTER Maharaja Ranjit singh ji died..INDIA was a slave for 300 years while Punjab only 90 Years...yet by 1870 just 20 years after annexation..Punjabi Shers like Maharaj Singh were already rebelling, and baba raam Singh namdharee was already threatenign the roots of the British Empire...IT was the SIKHS who WON the FIRST Battle for Independence in Guru ka Bagh morcha in 1920 and Gandhi said so in his telegram to Kharrak Singh Betaaj badsha of Sikhs at Akal takhat...and FROM then on the SIKHS never rested until the Brits were OUT...the rest of India just sat back and watched the show and enjoy the fruits of sikh struggles.
Re: British india?
Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 27 Jun 2005
Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh writes that if it wasn't for Gurmukhs such as Babu Mal Singh, Sant Maghar Singh and many other Rangley Sajjan (who were in the army), then the British Raj would have most certainly fell much earlier due to the number of jailed spiritualists.
Re: British india?
Kulbir Singh · 27 Jun 2005
----
Yes many Sikhs did suck up and join the British during the Raj, just like they did against Baba Banda Singh Bahadur with the then Moghul rulers.
-----
There were more Hindus and Muslims who sucked up to British. Bengalis and Sikhs were the only ones who got aware of their ghulami (slavery) and did something about it. The Congress party was a pro-British party and their leaders used to spend their evenings with the British high command.
Ghadaars (traitors) are not peculiar to Sikhs. All quoms have them.
Kulbir Singh
Re: British india?
Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005
Author: yo
Date: 06-27-05 08:51
sindhercate
singhs freed india in 1947. without singhs there would be no free india 97% shaheediya. Bhai randhir singh spent time in jail for you ungrateful indians to blame sikhs.
It is damn good the singhs taught the hindus a lesson by trying to take the sikh raj away.
even if hindus or indians died for this mutiny. they had no clear vision, no system to govern india thats why india is a screwed up state today. i see no sense fightng for a morally financially bankrupt nation do you?
Dear "YO"
97% of the shaheeds were Sikh? Now, I have great love for Sikhi and great respect for Sikhs but come on. I may agree with you that without Sikhs an independent India would have been diffcult but where do you get your facts from? Self-exaggeration.
What lessons have the Hindus been taught? Can you please elaborate?
India has been independent for less than 60 years. Give it time. America got its independence in 1776. Where was it in the mid 1800s? Fighting a civil war so look at it in the wider perspective instead of looking at it through a narrow, black and white vision. In the last ten years, the strides India has made economically cannot be denied, unless you live in a cave, and it is only going to get better - so much for financial bankruptcy.
Bhool Chook Maaf.
Re: British india?
Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005
<>
Gyani Jee,
Again, black and white. Sikhs are good, Hindus are bad. Sikhs are brave, Hindus are cowards. Same theme repeated again and again.
I agree with you that Sikhs are very brave and what you say in the first line is true BUT rest of India just sat back????? Which world are you living in? Have you never heard of Subhash Chandra Bose, LaLa Lajpat Rai, Mahatma Gandhi, Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Bipin Chandra Pal.
India was won by the struggle carried out by a multitude of communities. Although I agree with you that Punjabis were at the forefront of it, please do not belittle the struggle by making it exclusively Sikh.
Bhool Chook Maaf.
Re: British india?
JSGyani "Arshi" · 28 Jun 2005
Straight arrow ji,
you quote:
<<>>>
You read too much between the lines... Nowhere have i written the HINDUS ARE BAD.....or COWARDS.
What i am saying is the Punjabi Sikhs making up less than 1.0% of the population of India...put up a much bigger struggle than the 99% of Indians.IF there was Shubash Chander Bose..there was a Capt Mohan Singh and Gyani Pritam Singh right there beside him. Kartar Singh sarabha, Bhagat singh, Udham Singh, and the Gadree babeh...more tha n HALF the passengers on the kamagata maru ( Guur nanak jahaz) were SIKHS. Gyani pritam Singh was the MAIN man responsible for setting up the main INA and cooperation witht the japanese Fujimora in the East.
WHAT made the SIKHS rise up as a a NATION and Fight the British in the Gadar/Gurdwara Shudhaar Leht 1920's..WHY the Jallianwala Bagh in PUNJAB..and NOT anywhere else in INDIA ?? Why the Chase by Udham Singh to the Shores of England..and NOt by any other Indian although so MUCH more in NUMBERS.
You have NAMED a few..like MK Gandhi lalajpat Rai... JATHAS of 500 marched to jaito facing Brit GUNS and Lathi charges..jatha after Jatha UNIL the BRIT govt Admitted DEFEAT... NO SUCH Jathas were organsied by any other INdian State ??? How many MORCHAS in Punjab?? and How many MORCHAS in the rest of India ?? Please provide a few details.
have you ever heard of any RIOTS in Punjab.....where Govt Property is burnt, buses burned, etc NOT a SINGLE ONE until TODAY.... provide a few examples from EACH STATE in India..all have their Riots and strikes BUT NONE against the British. The struggle was NOT exclusively SIKH..BUT who cna DENY that SIKH PARTICIPATION is OUT of PROPORTION to SIKH population
Just take the Anti Indira Gandhi EMERGENCY MORCHA.... who stayed STEADFAST UNtil the VERY END....you guessed it..the AKALI/SIKHS of PUNJAB...and Indira was so PISSED off by thsi Challengfe to her rule that she plotted Bluestar to teach the Sikhs a lesson in which she lost her life...and learned a valuable lesson herself..DONT MESS with the SIKHS.
Double Edged Khanda.
Re: British india?
JSGyani "Arshi" · 29 Jun 2005
on the employment bit i have personal example that proves A Singh Ji right.
IN Malaya, during the British period..the SIKHS ( full amrtidharee), Musslaman pathaans etc were big time FAVOURITES as Policemn Army recruits etc.
I know of FOUR Hindu Brahmins from my own Village and nearby villages that Took Amrit and kept Kesh dastaar etc JUST for EMPLOYMENT. Once they reached retirement age all FOUR reversed to Hindu and are now pandit Jee instead of the previous sardar ji. Their children were never keshadharee from the beginning as the Brits left in 1947 and there was no need for teh sikh roop in their case.