accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
Mehtab Singh · 25 Jun 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
i was wondering as to what the sangat thinks about GurSikhs accepting prasad (offerings made to Hindu gods/goddesses) from Hindus. Sometime in the past i have refused from accepting it from my parents (who are Hindus), but it hurt them as they never hesitated from eating langar at the Gurdwara, and this act of mine was offensive to them. Although i wasn't forced to have it, i did feel bad. After all, whats wrong in accepting it if its done only as a sign of respect for another religion? Not like i am a worshipper of the deity! i know some (infact many) are gonna argue that its against the rehit, but disrespecting other faiths is also against the rehit, isn't it? Another probable answer i am expecting is "talk to them and tell them that u are not supposed to accept prasad". Well if a Sikh does this, it only gives non-Sikhs reason to reject Guru ka Langar too, dont u think? and wouldn't i feel bad then? After all everyone loves their religion the same way. Its gonna sound so disgusting telling someone else "i am superior, so i cant accept it. But u are free to eat langar".
i am not looking for any clearcut answer to this issue as i m pretty sure that there may not be one. People like me who have family members of another religion do have to take that extra step in being accomodative and accepting of each others' beliefs. It wouldn't be wrong if i say that i have already made up my mind on this issue, coz i have my own reasons and limitations, but i do wanna know what other Sikhs think/feel about this matter.
thanks for ur time
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
charanjeev singh · 25 Jun 2005
it is Gurmat not to hurt anyone's feelings and/or to disrespect their religion. However, as a Khalsa one has to understand that Gurmat is the path of Dharam; and in this path of Dharm there can by no hypocrisy. It is important to understand that in this Path of Dharam; the Path of the Guru rejects the worship of any being; Only the Shabad of Waheguruu by the Grace of the Guru.
One must have instilled in them the knowledge about the worship of dieties and the qualities that they posess; this understanding comes from the Guruu. When one comes to understand the qualities of the dieties; one comes to understand that they are not perfect in their qualities. And when one understands the qualities of the dieties that people might worship, that knowlegdable person will be able to give their reasons of why they do not accept any offerings made to such dieties.
you may want to think first; why are the offerings made? and would you want to accept such offerings made to principles contrary to Gurmat? And by accepting these offerings, do you directly or indirectly accept the reason for the offering and accept that 'Mat'?
One of the Path of the Khalsa is to remain Niaraa. Maybe there could be a loving way to say 'no thanks'
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
Koi Bole Ram koi Kudhai · 26 Jun 2005
Veerji, I think you should honestly accept it, I am talking about it from an insaniat aspect, that religion is extremely important, however we must not cloud what religion is, its a vehicle for man to get closer to God.
Is accepting prashad from a mandir wrong, no. We are all human, stop thinking of this and that, but as one people.
If you cant' see God in all, you can't see God at all - Yogi Bhajan
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
Mehtab Singh · 27 Jun 2005
Thanks for ur replies sangat jeeo :)
On the issue of jootha, Bhagat Naamdev Jee says somewhere in his bani that a calf sips milk from its mother, the cow. So then even that milk we have is jootha? coz the calf (an animal) sipped it before us! Notice that the purpose is most important. I think i specified that my purpose was only not to hurt my parents who have accepted my Sikh beliefs, and not coz i m a deity worshipper. Its only natural that i respect their beliefs as well.
thanks once again :)
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
Kulbir Singh · 27 Jun 2005
Veer Mehtab Singh jeeo,
--------------
i was wondering as to what the sangat thinks about GurSikhs accepting prasad (offerings made to Hindu gods/goddesses) from Hindus.
---------
A Sikh is not to accept parshaad of any other deity. What is Parshaad according to Hindu tradition? They offer parshaad to their deity (Krishna, Rama etc) and then after the deity gives his indication of the acceptance of parshaad, it is distributed in their congregation. A real Khalsa can never accept any food cooked by non-devotees (non-Khalsa persons), let alone Parshaad of Rama or Krishna.
Hindus believe that the Hindu Parshaad is jootha of their deity and this is why they consider it very sacred. Khalsa cannot eat anyone’s jootha, not even Krishna’s or Rama’s. So accepting prasaad from Hindus is out of question.
This does not mean that Sikhs don't respect Rama or Krishna. They definitely respect their good deeds and so does Gurbani.
---------
Sometime in the past i have refused from accepting it from my parents (who are Hindus), but it hurt them as they never hesitated from eating langar at the Gurdwara, and this act of mine was offensive to them.
----------
I understand that this act would be offensive to them. You could try to explain to your parents that accepting Aanmattee (non-devotees) parshaad is not in accordance with Gurmat. If they don’t understand, then accept it from them and chori chori give it to your younger sibling or other person who accepts it. If no person accepts it then respectfully place it in a creek, lake or canal.
---------
Although i wasn't forced to have it, i did feel bad. After all, whats wrong in accepting it if its done only as a sign of respect for another religion?
---------
Respecting other religions at the cost of your own religion is not good wisdom. One should have genuine respect for all human beings (actually all life) but this does not mean that one has to eat from all human beings.
-----------
i know some (infact many) are gonna argue that its against the rehit, but disrespecting other faiths is also against the rehit, isn't it?
------------
As I said before, not eating parshaad that is against Gurmat Bibek, is not disrespecting other religions.
------------
Another probable answer i am expecting is "talk to them and tell them that u are not supposed to accept prasad". Well if a Sikh does this, it only gives non-Sikhs reason to reject Guru ka Langar too, dont u think? and wouldn't i feel bad then? After all everyone loves their religion the same way. Its gonna sound so disgusting telling someone else "i am superior, so i cant accept it. But u are free to eat langar".
-----------
If they don’t accept Guru ka Langar, it is not disrespecting our religion and nor we should think this way. I have seen that on so many occasions, Goray people (Western people) come to Gurdwara Sahibaans and are apprehensive of accepting degh on bare hands. One Gora person asked me (I was sitting next to him) that what was being distributed. I explained to him that it was Parshaad, and that it was made of Ghee, flour and sugar. He did not like the idea of accepting degh on his hands, and I can remember that neither I, nor anyone else got upset at him for not accepting degh. It is their freewill and it is wrong to force anyone to accept degh (Karah Parshaad).
And the reason for not accepting their parshaad is not because we are superior or inferior. The reason is simply that we must follow Rehit maryada that prohibits us from eating from non-devotees.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Jun 2005
Veer Mehtaab Singh Ji,
Why didnt you ask GURU JI.... GURU JI has the perfect answer.
Read Sri raag..Guru nanak ji sahib tells us.....Jit khaddhe tan perriah mann mehn challeh vikaar..
IF anything that we eat..causes us physical "pain" and Mental anguish, and Vikaars rule our mann..then AVOID that food.
Same answers to what we can WEAR, use etc are also given in these panktees.
Aside from this Veer Kulbir Singh ji has given a most comprehensive and suitable reply to your query.
I wouldnt eat anything that makes me "QUERY" ???? the very fact that we QUERY is our INNER CONSCIOUNSE...that LITTLE VOICE of AKAAL PURAKH deep inside each one of us...TELLING US >>>BEWARE<<<< bacha Sambhaal ke challo !!! Its when we OVER-RIDE that small voice and let our own "intellect" decide on basis..of..my friend will be annoyed...what will my mum think ??..will my action make my hindu friend angry ?/ etc etc ??? that we FALTER and FALL down.
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005
I have a simple solution. Take it from your parents. let them give it to you as prasad and you can think of it as mithaai and eat it.
Does that makes sense? I would've done this had I been in your situation.
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005
>>are u saying this from ahindu piont of view or a sikh piont of view?<<
From a humanitarian point of view.
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
Mehtab Singh · 29 Jun 2005
"sio" jee, i cant thank u enuff :) ...plzz do ardas that i become 1% of what u expect me to become!
Guruji bless u :)
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
tera balwan nana · 30 Jun 2005
"lost fool
Date: 06-30-05 00:49
i don think im gonna turn hindu by eating the parsad. i don believe in those gods. nothing rong wid it
i went to see frenz fof a birthday, not my birthday, but i still got to eat cake n stuff cuz my frenz want to celebrate with me, "
putt cake check kittah si? kite andey oondey tani si vich?
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
Sher Khalsa · 04 Jul 2005
My dear,
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa,Wahegurujee kee Fateh.
Thats why it is rightly said that half knowledge is always bad. The parshad is not offered to Guru as Shabad Guru cann't take the parshaad offered. It is done to take the permission of the Guru to distribute amongest the Sangat. If u offered the parshad to Guru and it had become seet( jootha) it the word gave ur are playing, Please if u don't mind, don't answer if u don't know anything.
Can u explaine what is difference between seet and jootha. I think seet means taken by Gurujee and jootha taken by a Devi or Devta,according to U. Don't be childish. If u don't know anything leave it. It is not necessary to answer everything.
I hope I didn't hurt ur feellings
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
JSGyani "Arshi" · 04 Jul 2005
Dear Eman Ruoy..you wrote:
<<<<<<<>>>>
THIS has NEVER HAPPENED and NEVER WILL. Numerous Panktees in GURBANI in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB STATE CATEGORICALLY that stone/ idols are NIRJEEV..NO LIFE. Anyone who thinks the stone idol can help him swim across the Ocean of Maya is the Biggest FOOL...read GURBANI....PLEASE.
The Bhagat Dhanna ji story is FALSE....and GURU ARJUN JI on aang 487 writes a SHABAD to prove this story FALSE. Please read the Thread on Dhanna Bhagat Ji for more info. Also read the viakhiya of thsi shabad on AAng 487 of Guru Garnth Drapan of Prof sahib Singh....www.gurugranthdarpan.com.
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
JagjeetSingh · 04 Jul 2005
WaheGurujiKhalsa WaheguruJiKiFateh,
As we all know the meaning of "Sikh/Gursikh/Gurmukh" ,is a soul who belongs to Dhan Dhan Dhan Sri GuruGranthSahibJi.
SriGuruGranthSahibJi is (Jagdhi Jooth) alive in this present jug(Kaljug).
Our present given life is our own past life deeds, in
previous life times(Jug).
If you accept prasad from previous hindu god and goddes of previuos times(JUG),you are not living in the present times.
So be truthfull in your heart and accept prasad only from the present Kaljug's Guru(Dhan Dhan Dhan SriGuruGranthSahibJi)
Pleas study the lives of Bagats, how they left their previous Jugs/times(Hindu matt) and met the guru of Kaljug(Guru NanakJi).Because this Bagats was thruthfull in their heart they met GuruJi and merge with Waheguru.
Accept what is fated and make a truthfull transition from your present state to be with the living kaljug's guru(SriGuruGranthSahibji)
The fact is we have SatGurujee Dhan SriGuruGranthSahibji
and olso GuruPanthKhalsa which will help us break from our
good and bad previous deeds, and help us & our love ones
to be Sikh,Gursikh,Gurmukh in the present 'kaljug' time.
Karaah Parshaad/Degh is a "DIRECT" blessing from(Jagdhi Joot)Dhan SriGuruGranthSahibjiuruJee in the form of physical, mental and spiritual.
It can fullfill our desire or hunger in fullfilling
the needs of our physical, mental and spiritual in the present times.
With guru jee blessing(phog lana) and the equality in
sharing the Karaah Parshaad with guru ji sangat(pangat)
and eating the parshaad, helps keeps us healthy in our
physical, mental and spiritual form.
This miracle which is a link between our own self,
guruji's sangat and guruji is so very powerfull in Kaljug.
This miracle is for ever soul, whether it is a new born
baby or in old age form.(without teeth)
This miracle can destroy our weakness in the form of
- physical(its ingredient are basic food to upkeep our
physical body)
- mental(its concept(pangat)of equality and sharing.
- spiritual(the opportunity to see and experience the
"DIRECT ALIFE" blesssing from guru ji)
Dhan Dhan Dhan Sri GuruGranthSahibJi the present creator of
all miracles.
So be a Sikh,Gursikh&Gurmukh and play the game of love,
not to hurt anothers aspecially your close ones.
So, play this game of love and see how Waheguru will bless
you and your loves ones with more love and peace in 'Kaljug'.
WaheguruJiKaKhalsa WaheGuruJiKiFateh.
WaheGurujiKhalsa WaheguruJiKiFateh,
Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?
domalla premee · 06 Jul 2005
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
Dear Putr,
Gurujee bestowed upon you a great gift. You will be challenged daily to choose between the Guru and the world. It is most agonizing when relations are involved.
Now you know us both. We have travelled a similar road with both our sets of parents. Both sets for those who do not know were non-Sikhs.
You can offer plenty of love to your parents in other ways that do not sacrifice your Gursikhi principles. "Dighai na dolai drir kar raheoo pooran hoey triptaanee." Don't waver, don't become ambivalent. In the end your seva will be complete. Be patient, steadfast and find opportunities to serve them well.
My dear putr you have much more to lose then they do.
Ok lets say they ask you to do this and...OK you do it. Tomorrow they ask you to do something else...and OK you do it and so on and so forth. Before you know it you have closer to them (moh maya...very sneeky pulling at your hearstrings) but now you have sacrificed one thing at a time till you become far from Gurujee. Before you know it you have left Sikhi. Is that what you want or do you want Gurujee more.
Do you know how many such demands we have heard in over 20 years from both our families?? Yeah there have been some anger, irritation and tears from the family yet we found opportunities to give them love in manifold ways without sacrificing Gursikhi principles. They are ususally expressing frustration that you have changed through this rainbow of emotions. It takes some adjusting. Some never get it. In our case we did not move. By Gurujee's kirpa, some in the family are starting to glimpse the spiritual magnatude of Sikhi and one has taken amrit. Some will never appreciate it in their lifetime but them that is not our job is it?
Putr, you will never be in the same place as your parents are because you have moved ahead. Love them for what you have in common but love the Guru more by obeiying His hukam. You parents will not be there for you in the end.
Putr, I am at Gurujee's feet and everything has been done by His magnificent generosity. I can only request that He keep you in Chardhikala. Also when you have a chance please do email me.