Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Mehtab Singh · 25 Jun 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh i was wondering as to what the sangat thinks about GurSikhs accepting prasad (offerings made to Hindu gods/goddesses) from Hindus. Sometime in the past i have refused from accepting it from my parents (who are Hindus), but it hurt them as they never hesitated from eating langar at the Gurdwara, and this act of mine was offensive to them. Although i wasn't forced to have it, i did feel bad. After all, whats wrong in accepting it if its done only as a sign of respect for another religion? Not like i am a worshipper of the deity! i know some (infact many) are gonna argue that its against the rehit, but disrespecting other faiths is also against the rehit, isn't it? Another probable answer i am expecting is "talk to them and tell them that u are not supposed to accept prasad". Well if a Sikh does this, it only gives non-Sikhs reason to reject Guru ka Langar too, dont u think? and wouldn't i feel bad then? After all everyone loves their religion the same way. Its gonna sound so disgusting telling someone else "i am superior, so i cant accept it. But u are free to eat langar". i am not looking for any clearcut answer to this issue as i m pretty sure that there may not be one. People like me who have family members of another religion do have to take that extra step in being accomodative and accepting of each others' beliefs. It wouldn't be wrong if i say that i have already made up my mind on this issue, coz i have my own reasons and limitations, but i do wanna know what other Sikhs think/feel about this matter. thanks for ur time waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

charanjeev singh · 25 Jun 2005

it is Gurmat not to hurt anyone's feelings and/or to disrespect their religion. However, as a Khalsa one has to understand that Gurmat is the path of Dharam; and in this path of Dharm there can by no hypocrisy. It is important to understand that in this Path of Dharam; the Path of the Guru rejects the worship of any being; Only the Shabad of Waheguruu by the Grace of the Guru. One must have instilled in them the knowledge about the worship of dieties and the qualities that they posess; this understanding comes from the Guruu. When one comes to understand the qualities of the dieties; one comes to understand that they are not perfect in their qualities. And when one understands the qualities of the dieties that people might worship, that knowlegdable person will be able to give their reasons of why they do not accept any offerings made to such dieties. you may want to think first; why are the offerings made? and would you want to accept such offerings made to principles contrary to Gurmat? And by accepting these offerings, do you directly or indirectly accept the reason for the offering and accept that 'Mat'? One of the Path of the Khalsa is to remain Niaraa. Maybe there could be a loving way to say 'no thanks'

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

.:...:. · 26 Jun 2005

wjkk wjkf veer ji , i understand ur problem . but the thing is that amritdhari sikhs can't eat jooth . so when their prasad is offered to the deity it becomes jootha . so u might say that doesn't langar become jootha after bhog to guru ji . ? actually no , guru ji is god himself so how can his seet prasad be jooth, by eating it even the devi devtaas become mukt . Guru ji is above all . even the devi devtas ask for their charan dhoor .

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

jss · 26 Jun 2005

mehtab singh ji, i've been reading your posts on varaious message boards for the last year and a half...i firmly beleive that you are very mature in our outlook and your devotion to sikhi...taht said...i say follow what your heart tells you...for i believe that guru ji will answer your questions when you listen to your heart..

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

tera baap · 26 Jun 2005

so what if ur parents refuse langer it wasnt made for them, it was made for ne1 that wants to eat it. and why wud u want to eat sumthin that wasnt offered to you? but instead to a statue?

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Koi Bole Ram koi Kudhai · 26 Jun 2005

Veerji, I think you should honestly accept it, I am talking about it from an insaniat aspect, that religion is extremely important, however we must not cloud what religion is, its a vehicle for man to get closer to God. Is accepting prashad from a mandir wrong, no. We are all human, stop thinking of this and that, but as one people. If you cant' see God in all, you can't see God at all - Yogi Bhajan

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Mehtab Singh · 27 Jun 2005

Thanks for ur replies sangat jeeo :) On the issue of jootha, Bhagat Naamdev Jee says somewhere in his bani that a calf sips milk from its mother, the cow. So then even that milk we have is jootha? coz the calf (an animal) sipped it before us! Notice that the purpose is most important. I think i specified that my purpose was only not to hurt my parents who have accepted my Sikh beliefs, and not coz i m a deity worshipper. Its only natural that i respect their beliefs as well. thanks once again :)

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Singh · 27 Jun 2005

Everything is a case of whether or not it will harm your Bhagti or not - everything else is irrelevant. If you feel the parshad will damage your Bhagti then don't take it. The answer I guess will vary from person to person depending on their level of Bibek and own spiritual state. I personally wouldn't have a problem taking it. Offering it to a statue is not the same as someone making it with bad thoughts on their mind, negatively changing the quality of the food, etc. But for a Sarblohi and depending on the sitaution of your parents it may not be appropriate - there is no right/wrong answer, it depends where you are with your Kamai and Bibek I guess.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

~~~~~~~~~~ · 27 Jun 2005

bro your in a tight situation. whether the food is offered to a statue, or made by some 9 - 5 weekday pisshead come sunday religious sikh at a gurdwara the fact is the vibes entering the food too need to be taken into consideration. I have eaten in a hindu restaurant run by the hare kishan hari rams on a bussiness transaction basis because it is located near my workplace and offers wide choice vegetarion options free from eggs. the restaurant is run by religious converts mostly european who also pray over their food. The vibe seems to be positive, but not as powerful as langar made by gurmukhs. In my opinion if your parents are dharmi by nature gaurd their nine bodily gates, and concentrate on God the vibes cant be that bad. But ideally you want to be in a position where you can follow rehat to its written word where you only erat of amritdharis. But to counterbalance that God Almighty has placed you in a hindu family for reasons known to God himnself. Meaning everything happens for a greater reason. If you try to push reheta forward aggresivly and it cross conflicts yopul end up confused remember your talking emotions with family. I think at this point focus more on bhagti, nam simran, bani, knock that side off day and night from your soul. the day will come when everything else should start becoming a smooth flow. But please watch out and try to abstain from outside places and people your not familiar with especially anyone else that doesnt keep rehat because then their vibes will affect you. a wise singh told someone in a similar position " we do not choose our parents". your in a position where you have to balance as much bibek and rehat as you can along with living with your family. my personal opinion is if your rehat is rocking and you keep as much bibek as you can a minor trip like this should be ok. if you totally abstain and that results your rents getting hurt im not sure if new karm are born where a person gets hurt. i wudnt know what to do in that situation myself but i think its best to steer the boat as much as you can towards sikhi, but when it comes to parents do your best around them too as long as your not committing kurehet. Do ardas everyday bro that they accept you with bibek and maybe that might inspire them towards sikhi too. i dont know if i am wrong or right on this just speculating. But if in doubt please meet the panj and ask them.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

@@@ · 27 Jun 2005

we are only allowed to eat form the hands of an amrithdhari sothe amswer would be .........( drum rollll) ....NO !!!

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Dandilion · 27 Jun 2005

<<< Is accepting prashad from a mandir wrong, no. We are all human, stop thinking of this and that, but as one people. >>> If we take this argument a step further then what is wrong with something from a maseet or stuff which has had kalmaa said over it, would you eat that ???? The answer is NO, no matter what the situation you must not be bay-mukh to your Guru. [%sig%]

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

S Singh · 27 Jun 2005

Eat it if you want. What difference is it going to make to you ? You should see how many Singh buy that fried rice prasad from the shops outside the Darbar Sahib which is not prasad and is packed by peopel who do not wash their hands.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Kulbir Singh · 27 Jun 2005

Veer Mehtab Singh jeeo, -------------- i was wondering as to what the sangat thinks about GurSikhs accepting prasad (offerings made to Hindu gods/goddesses) from Hindus. --------- A Sikh is not to accept parshaad of any other deity. What is Parshaad according to Hindu tradition? They offer parshaad to their deity (Krishna, Rama etc) and then after the deity gives his indication of the acceptance of parshaad, it is distributed in their congregation. A real Khalsa can never accept any food cooked by non-devotees (non-Khalsa persons), let alone Parshaad of Rama or Krishna. Hindus believe that the Hindu Parshaad is jootha of their deity and this is why they consider it very sacred. Khalsa cannot eat anyone’s jootha, not even Krishna’s or Rama’s. So accepting prasaad from Hindus is out of question. This does not mean that Sikhs don't respect Rama or Krishna. They definitely respect their good deeds and so does Gurbani. --------- Sometime in the past i have refused from accepting it from my parents (who are Hindus), but it hurt them as they never hesitated from eating langar at the Gurdwara, and this act of mine was offensive to them. ---------- I understand that this act would be offensive to them. You could try to explain to your parents that accepting Aanmattee (non-devotees) parshaad is not in accordance with Gurmat. If they don’t understand, then accept it from them and chori chori give it to your younger sibling or other person who accepts it. If no person accepts it then respectfully place it in a creek, lake or canal. --------- Although i wasn't forced to have it, i did feel bad. After all, whats wrong in accepting it if its done only as a sign of respect for another religion? --------- Respecting other religions at the cost of your own religion is not good wisdom. One should have genuine respect for all human beings (actually all life) but this does not mean that one has to eat from all human beings. ----------- i know some (infact many) are gonna argue that its against the rehit, but disrespecting other faiths is also against the rehit, isn't it? ------------ As I said before, not eating parshaad that is against Gurmat Bibek, is not disrespecting other religions. ------------ Another probable answer i am expecting is "talk to them and tell them that u are not supposed to accept prasad". Well if a Sikh does this, it only gives non-Sikhs reason to reject Guru ka Langar too, dont u think? and wouldn't i feel bad then? After all everyone loves their religion the same way. Its gonna sound so disgusting telling someone else "i am superior, so i cant accept it. But u are free to eat langar". ----------- If they don’t accept Guru ka Langar, it is not disrespecting our religion and nor we should think this way. I have seen that on so many occasions, Goray people (Western people) come to Gurdwara Sahibaans and are apprehensive of accepting degh on bare hands. One Gora person asked me (I was sitting next to him) that what was being distributed. I explained to him that it was Parshaad, and that it was made of Ghee, flour and sugar. He did not like the idea of accepting degh on his hands, and I can remember that neither I, nor anyone else got upset at him for not accepting degh. It is their freewill and it is wrong to force anyone to accept degh (Karah Parshaad). And the reason for not accepting their parshaad is not because we are superior or inferior. The reason is simply that we must follow Rehit maryada that prohibits us from eating from non-devotees. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Singh · 27 Jun 2005

Having thought about this a little more, what would Guru Nanak Dev Ji have done? Guru Sahib used to show the hypocrasy of splashing water at the sun, praying to Mecca etc, wouldn't he explain, how can offering food to a statue mean the God has eaten it, and made it Jhooth for everyone else?

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Jun 2005

Veer Mehtaab Singh Ji, Why didnt you ask GURU JI.... GURU JI has the perfect answer. Read Sri raag..Guru nanak ji sahib tells us.....Jit khaddhe tan perriah mann mehn challeh vikaar.. IF anything that we eat..causes us physical "pain" and Mental anguish, and Vikaars rule our mann..then AVOID that food. Same answers to what we can WEAR, use etc are also given in these panktees. Aside from this Veer Kulbir Singh ji has given a most comprehensive and suitable reply to your query. I wouldnt eat anything that makes me "QUERY" ???? the very fact that we QUERY is our INNER CONSCIOUNSE...that LITTLE VOICE of AKAAL PURAKH deep inside each one of us...TELLING US >>>BEWARE<<<< bacha Sambhaal ke challo !!! Its when we OVER-RIDE that small voice and let our own "intellect" decide on basis..of..my friend will be annoyed...what will my mum think ??..will my action make my hindu friend angry ?/ etc etc ??? that we FALTER and FALL down.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005

I have a simple solution. Take it from your parents. let them give it to you as prasad and you can think of it as mithaai and eat it. Does that makes sense? I would've done this had I been in your situation.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

... · 27 Jun 2005

I remember when I was younger, maybe 12 years old, I was not amritdhari. I was walking in Little India and some Hare Krishnas were giving out some "parshaad" in little plastic baggies. My aunt forced me to take it and said "it's just different kind of parshad". I took the bag but then thought about it. What is parshaad? It is something that is "blessed" food and something that has been first tasted (symbolically or actually) by the person giving it. I stood there and thought whether I could really as a Sikh accept this knowing that it was accepting the fact that a Hindu God had the authority/power to give me parshaad (I being someone who considered Sri Guru Granth Sahib my Guru). I understood that eating parshaad of anyone is a way of expressing devotion. I realised that accepting this parshad would be turning my back to Guru Sahib in a way. I would eat from a restaurant at that time, but I refused to eat something that showed any devotion to any other being except my Guru Sahib. Later when an Udasi Sadhu gave me parshad, I also rejected it. As an amritdhari it is certain that we cannot eat food made by someone who is not a Sikh. But even when I was much younger, and did not have qualms about eating from other people, I realised eating 'parshaad' of anyone but Guru Granth Sahib is completely wrong.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

tera baap · 27 Jun 2005

Straight Arrow wrote: > I have a simple solution. Take it from your parents. let them > give it to you as prasad and you can think of it as mithaai and > eat it. > Does that makes sense? I would've done this had I been in your > situation. are u saying this from ahindu piont of view or a sikh piont of view?

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005

>>are u saying this from ahindu piont of view or a sikh piont of view?<< From a humanitarian point of view.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

tera baap · 27 Jun 2005

how does humanitarianism come into this, its a matter following ur own religion and upsetting ur parents or betraying ur guru but making ur false parents happy.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

ekta · 27 Jun 2005

joot shoot oye mehtaba, ur a smart man u know that, and u knwo its wrong 2 discriminate. GKD.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

sio · 29 Jun 2005

sikhs do not believe that there is any power inside a idol. if veer jis parents make an offering, mehtab takes a bite to please them knowing there is nothing inside it ,but just a bit of food rather than believeing that this has been jhoot by some devta then would he still be wrong? surely it comes down to state of mind in how he percieves the food to be. If its just a bit of orange or apple and bell ringing around it does it make it parshad? so we eat oranges and apples anyway. just a thought. either that or go full sarblohi then your parents wont be upset if you only eat from ur own hands as a rehat. But if you eat from others hands at the moment then i dont know how bad any hindu christian prshad would be if we do not believe there is anything in them anyway. Its not as if he go mandirs and he is an amritdhari sikh that says a lot by itself. i do not agree with straight arrow sikhs do not need follow sikhi to please humanity. But it depends on the weight of the reason behind certain things. tera bhaap put yourself in his parents shoes they have dealt with their child converting. Could you do that? Mehtab singh is over the first hurdle i respect his parents for allowing their kid to do that. How many sikhs here could bear their beautiful child grown from their hands convert into a different religion? Its easy to say well if that kid was in the best religion tyhen id say go. It doesnt work like that, because everyone believes theirs is the best anyway. Now they have given a bigger part of the compromise by letting him go into another religion and in return they just ask a tiny thing like eating their parshad to which mehtab sio knows there is no power in anyway because hindu dieties have no power in this age. Some of you may not hurt your parents in similar situation but analyse the reasons why is it because of pyar for rehat or to show pakhand? if you really have pyar for rehat youl have pyar for another person and understand their situation at its cause level. That one day mehtab will reach to this point where he will be like you and be able to do full blown sarbloh rehat. This time his soul is transitioning from one religion to another with family around him. Nobodies family is here forever, one day mehtab singh will marry a singhani, have sikh children and be in the position where you guys ar at now. There are certain things he can take to the front right now (simran nam bhagti ) and others he will be forced to put into the back seat for now, till God grands plan changes mehtab singh and mould him into the future protocol of the khalis jot. For his situation it requires step by step changes. mehtab singh big big respects to you and your parents stay strong in sikhi. Dont get pulled down with doubts, its all inside the heart. One day your baari will come. yes it is true parents are only temporary they are not really our parents, but this is how god has made it for you right now, where others have the granted luxery of having sikh parents. You take it in your stride singh just keep your bhagti booming and if you can do sarbloh do as much as you can. I would advise sikhs here to be careful on how they advise him too, the last thing we want is any distance or pangeh between mehtab and his family. So far it seems like good vibes they have accepted his conversion so we should instead boost this singh up. I would suggest singhs actually go and meet his parents before we start random thinking. It is a different case from most of us who started off without religious famnilies conflicting with asools his is a unique case of a singh from a religious hindu family. Bhai rama singh also came from such a family and they cut him off. We and mehtab singh are lucky that has not happened to him. Its easy for us to talk until we sit in his shoes.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Mehtab Singh · 29 Jun 2005

"sio" jee, i cant thank u enuff :) ...plzz do ardas that i become 1% of what u expect me to become! Guruji bless u :)

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

sio · 29 Jun 2005

singh jio this maha moorakh papi will do ardas for you although i am just a piece of dirt.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

advice · 29 Jun 2005

"This time his soul is transitioning from one religion to another with family around him." There should be no period of 'transition' after recieving amrit. That time has passed. Eating a Hindu devta's parshad is wrong. Plain and simple. Ask any rehitvan Singh and they will say it is wrong and should never be done. This is not a compromise a Singh can make. Mehtab Singh veera, you've come this far, don't cave on this now.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

beatbox · 29 Jun 2005

take your case to the panj pyarey mehtab singh. they are understanding and will help you. We cannot speculate what they will say but they have a better picture of your situation than any of us.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

sore · 29 Jun 2005

ikonkar satnam karta purkh nirbhau nirvai akaal murat ajuni saibhan gurprasad gurprasad GURprasad GURprasad [i]GURPRASAD[/i] [%sig%]

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

lost fool · 30 Jun 2005

i don think im gonna turn hindu by eating the parsad. i don believe in those gods. nothing rong wid it i went to see frenz fof a birthday, not my birthday, but i still got to eat cake n stuff cuz my frenz want to celebrate with me, my hindu frienz if they want to share their parsad with me i c it as friendship

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

tera baap · 30 Jun 2005

lost fool wrote: > i don think im gonna turn hindu by eating the parsad. i don > believe in those gods. nothing rong wid it > > i went to see frenz fof a birthday, not my birthday, but i > still got to eat cake n stuff cuz my frenz want to celebrate > with me, my hindu frienz if they want to share their parsad > with me i c it as friendship u are lost, its not a birthday party here, whats being discussed is parshad from his parents who want him to have it cuz they r hindu, not some next bumbo off the street giving this parshad as a token of friendship

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

((((:>>>>> · 30 Jun 2005

maybe a silly question, but what is the prasaad made of?

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

eman ruoy · 30 Jun 2005

You are what you are, Did you not see your Guru in that Idol? If not then why not? Is your Guru only visible in those who have the Sikh Attire? Is you Guru only Visible in those who carry the same beliefs as you?? Perhaps you should ask Bhai Ghanayia where his Guru is?? It is a matter of perception and you Bhaav that allows you change any situation to your benefit. It is we who limit own ownselves. What is Parsaad? Is it hindu, is it Sikh? Or is it just food that has been blessed thru different mediums, diferent faces of that One Faceless Divinity? As for someone above saying the Idols have no Power, yes it is true they ahve no power in themselves for they are simply a peace of Rock. But if a Bhagat like Dhanna jat exists then even an Idol, a peace of rock will become full of Life. I see those who want to remain strict to their 'Rehat' and exclude everything that is not 'Sikh'. Then there are those who move back and forth across the line. Then there are those who have transgressed the previous 2 stages and see no Line at all.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

tera balwan nana · 30 Jun 2005

"lost fool Date: 06-30-05 00:49 i don think im gonna turn hindu by eating the parsad. i don believe in those gods. nothing rong wid it i went to see frenz fof a birthday, not my birthday, but i still got to eat cake n stuff cuz my frenz want to celebrate with me, " putt cake check kittah si? kite andey oondey tani si vich?

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

paapi · 04 Jul 2005

there might be maternal paternal element flowing through this dilemna? perhaps its the only few ways his parents have left to express their paternal bonds with their devoted son by giving him their parshad. this might be something symbolic like "this is still our boy" to his parents considering most of our parents were pendus who dont all have degrees a levels gcse educations to develop in ways to express themselves. mehtab singh still has a hindu family, he has not severed family ties, he lives in the same house as those who clothed fed him and bought him up to be the strong man he is, therefore his jeevan is different situation. This is clearly a distinct case as compared to the average singh who has a sikh family. Therefore this singhs conditions around him are out of his control he can only react to them to the best of his ability. He is from a family who clearly dearly love their kid enough so that they were willing to accept his conversion. In my eyes thats give and take, and i know most of us would not have the heart to hurt our parents when they give us love. In that case we have to do ardas in that helpless situation. If that is weak then is hurting your own parents righteous and displaying strentgh of sikhi? especially wher they have leaned over backwards to acomodate you. essentially mehtab singh is anot just a singh amongst sikhs but also a convert he has to find his own way through this as his challanges are totally different in life. he is trying to follow sikhi the best he can. If he feels guilty as a result of us telling him not to take that parshad and he does not, can we expect him to stay in chardi kala if his heart is paining that his mother and father are hurt by his own actions whic were meant to make things right for him? would that develop or strentghten his sikhi? Most likely he will end up feeling more down, hurt, and if he gets no support from us then how will he feel? baically you will find its two roads for him, one way rejecting his parents feelings the other is accepting them for now with hope and faith in the strentgh of sikhi just like all of you live in the hope of reaching sach khand he too will have hope of following sikhi without huting his family and being in the same boat as you. When a singh like that enters sikhi you have to look at the bigger picture in how to support and properly assess their situation in order for that singh to grow amongst the panth and not become subject to the effects of how we individually would deal with it, because our own view is only from a punjabi sikh angle with sikh heritage. Put the steering wheel in this singhs hands so he may one day guide his gaddi to the same destination, and instil the convictions of it even if his gaddi is facing a bit of a wobbly time now. accept his situation its not his fault. His parents are brahmins but they obviously are not the same brahmins who betrayed guru ji or the panth in later years for these brahmins have accepted their prodigy to become a singh. Therefore we need to assess that closely and not try to feel they are pressuring back into hinduism. Neither are his parents typical of other hindus/bjp/congressis/rss/.shiv senas who try to prevent the growth of sikhi, they clearly gave him the go ahead to become a singh whioch shows they have a strong bond with him. I would urge mehtab singh red white and blue kaur amongst others to write about their experiences as converts so we can relate to their situation a bit more. [%sig%]

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

Sher Khalsa · 04 Jul 2005

My dear, Waheguru jee ka Khalsa,Wahegurujee kee Fateh. Thats why it is rightly said that half knowledge is always bad. The parshad is not offered to Guru as Shabad Guru cann't take the parshaad offered. It is done to take the permission of the Guru to distribute amongest the Sangat. If u offered the parshad to Guru and it had become seet( jootha) it the word gave ur are playing, Please if u don't mind, don't answer if u don't know anything. Can u explaine what is difference between seet and jootha. I think seet means taken by Gurujee and jootha taken by a Devi or Devta,according to U. Don't be childish. If u don't know anything leave it. It is not necessary to answer everything. I hope I didn't hurt ur feellings

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 04 Jul 2005

Dear Eman Ruoy..you wrote: <<<<<<<>>>> THIS has NEVER HAPPENED and NEVER WILL. Numerous Panktees in GURBANI in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB STATE CATEGORICALLY that stone/ idols are NIRJEEV..NO LIFE. Anyone who thinks the stone idol can help him swim across the Ocean of Maya is the Biggest FOOL...read GURBANI....PLEASE. The Bhagat Dhanna ji story is FALSE....and GURU ARJUN JI on aang 487 writes a SHABAD to prove this story FALSE. Please read the Thread on Dhanna Bhagat Ji for more info. Also read the viakhiya of thsi shabad on AAng 487 of Guru Garnth Drapan of Prof sahib Singh....www.gurugranthdarpan.com.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

JagjeetSingh · 04 Jul 2005

WaheGurujiKhalsa WaheguruJiKiFateh, As we all know the meaning of "Sikh/Gursikh/Gurmukh" ,is a soul who belongs to Dhan Dhan Dhan Sri GuruGranthSahibJi. SriGuruGranthSahibJi is (Jagdhi Jooth) alive in this present jug(Kaljug). Our present given life is our own past life deeds, in previous life times(Jug). If you accept prasad from previous hindu god and goddes of previuos times(JUG),you are not living in the present times. So be truthfull in your heart and accept prasad only from the present Kaljug's Guru(Dhan Dhan Dhan SriGuruGranthSahibJi) Pleas study the lives of Bagats, how they left their previous Jugs/times(Hindu matt) and met the guru of Kaljug(Guru NanakJi).Because this Bagats was thruthfull in their heart they met GuruJi and merge with Waheguru. Accept what is fated and make a truthfull transition from your present state to be with the living kaljug's guru(SriGuruGranthSahibji) The fact is we have SatGurujee Dhan SriGuruGranthSahibji and olso GuruPanthKhalsa which will help us break from our good and bad previous deeds, and help us & our love ones to be Sikh,Gursikh,Gurmukh in the present 'kaljug' time. Karaah Parshaad/Degh is a "DIRECT" blessing from(Jagdhi Joot)Dhan SriGuruGranthSahibjiuruJee in the form of physical, mental and spiritual. It can fullfill our desire or hunger in fullfilling the needs of our physical, mental and spiritual in the present times. With guru jee blessing(phog lana) and the equality in sharing the Karaah Parshaad with guru ji sangat(pangat) and eating the parshaad, helps keeps us healthy in our physical, mental and spiritual form. This miracle which is a link between our own self, guruji's sangat and guruji is so very powerfull in Kaljug. This miracle is for ever soul, whether it is a new born baby or in old age form.(without teeth) This miracle can destroy our weakness in the form of - physical(its ingredient are basic food to upkeep our physical body) - mental(its concept(pangat)of equality and sharing. - spiritual(the opportunity to see and experience the "DIRECT ALIFE" blesssing from guru ji) Dhan Dhan Dhan Sri GuruGranthSahibJi the present creator of all miracles. So be a Sikh,Gursikh&Gurmukh and play the game of love, not to hurt anothers aspecially your close ones. So, play this game of love and see how Waheguru will bless you and your loves ones with more love and peace in 'Kaljug'. WaheguruJiKaKhalsa WaheGuruJiKiFateh. WaheGurujiKhalsa WaheguruJiKiFateh,

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

eman ruoy · 05 Jul 2005

"""THIS has NEVER HAPPENED and NEVER WILL. Numerous Panktees in GURBANI in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB STATE CATEGORICALLY that stone/ idols are NIRJEEV..NO LIFE. Anyone who thinks the stone idol can help him swim across the Ocean of Maya is the Biggest FOOL...read GURBANI....PLEASE. The Bhagat Dhanna ji story is FALSE....and GURU ARJUN JI on aang 487 writes a SHABAD to prove this story FALSE. Please read the Thread on Dhanna Bhagat Ji for more info. Also read the viakhiya of thsi shabad on AAng 487 of Guru Garnth Drapan of Prof sahib Singh....www.gurugranthdarpan.com."""" First i never said they can carry you across solely. Second Why is this story false? Forgive me but your hindu phobia is blinding you from seeing the truth in the story of Bhagat Dhaana ji. Yes they are nirjeev, but my dear friend you obviously have never seen the power of Love and what it can do. Until you understand what love is what the power of this Prem, Sharda, Bhaavna and innocence can cause you will never understand the story of Bhagat Dhanna ji.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

domalla premee · 06 Jul 2005

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Dear Putr, Gurujee bestowed upon you a great gift. You will be challenged daily to choose between the Guru and the world. It is most agonizing when relations are involved. Now you know us both. We have travelled a similar road with both our sets of parents. Both sets for those who do not know were non-Sikhs. You can offer plenty of love to your parents in other ways that do not sacrifice your Gursikhi principles. "Dighai na dolai drir kar raheoo pooran hoey triptaanee." Don't waver, don't become ambivalent. In the end your seva will be complete. Be patient, steadfast and find opportunities to serve them well. My dear putr you have much more to lose then they do. Ok lets say they ask you to do this and...OK you do it. Tomorrow they ask you to do something else...and OK you do it and so on and so forth. Before you know it you have closer to them (moh maya...very sneeky pulling at your hearstrings) but now you have sacrificed one thing at a time till you become far from Gurujee. Before you know it you have left Sikhi. Is that what you want or do you want Gurujee more. Do you know how many such demands we have heard in over 20 years from both our families?? Yeah there have been some anger, irritation and tears from the family yet we found opportunities to give them love in manifold ways without sacrificing Gursikhi principles. They are ususally expressing frustration that you have changed through this rainbow of emotions. It takes some adjusting. Some never get it. In our case we did not move. By Gurujee's kirpa, some in the family are starting to glimpse the spiritual magnatude of Sikhi and one has taken amrit. Some will never appreciate it in their lifetime but them that is not our job is it? Putr, you will never be in the same place as your parents are because you have moved ahead. Love them for what you have in common but love the Guru more by obeiying His hukam. You parents will not be there for you in the end. Putr, I am at Gurujee's feet and everything has been done by His magnificent generosity. I can only request that He keep you in Chardhikala. Also when you have a chance please do email me.

Re: accepting Hindu prasad - what does the sangat think?

. · 07 Jul 2005

Simple answer : GO to the Panjb next time they're around you'r area or your around a Thakhat and ask them.. ____________________________________________________ Sikh is not to accept parshaad of any other deity. What is Parshaad according to Hindu tradition? They offer parshaad to their deity (Krishna, Rama etc) and then after the deity gives his indication of the acceptance of parshaad, it is distributed in their congregation. A real Khalsa can never accept any food cooked by non-devotees (non-Khalsa persons), let alone Parshaad of Rama or Krishna. Hindus believe that the Hindu Parshaad is jootha of their deity and this is why they consider it very sacred. _____________________________ EXACTLY - you said it right - HINDUS BELIEVE (want to make BELIEVE IN BOLD NOW) - SIKHS DON'T CORRECT?? _____________ Khalsa cannot eat anyone’s jootha, not even Krishna’s or Rama’s. So accepting prasaad from Hindus is out of question. ____________________ So do we accept that the parshad is made Jotha from Rama/krishnas statue?? _________________________________ As I said before, not eating parshaad that is against Gurmat Bibek, is not disrespecting other religions. __________________________________ I'm really sorry bhaji, but most people WOULD be offended, your opinion is your opinion and tuhanu mubarak e, but most people would be offended. _________________________ The reason is simply that we must follow Rehit maryada that prohibits us from eating from non-devotees. _________________________ does Akal Tkahat Rehit marayda or infact Taksal Rehit Maryada (which is meant to be stricter) mention this anyway? or do you have any other rehit marayda? __________________________________ sikhs do not believe that there is any power inside a idol. if veer jis parents make an offering, mehtab takes a bite to please them knowing there is nothing inside it ,but just a bit of food rather than believeing that this has been jhoot by some devta then would he still be wrong? __________________ EXACTLY WHAT I'm SAYING. Kulbir Singh veer ji mentioned that Hindus think it gets jootha, but we Sikhs KNOW THAT AN IDOL CANNOT MAKE SOMETHING JOOTHA, so where does the question of eating ooth come in? I'm neutral on the question of taking parshad from temples, as I personally PROBABLY WOULDn'T DO IT TODAY ( i did it when i visited a temple first timeever, when i was really small, even after saying i was a Sikh she insisted i take it) but i suggest you ask your panj about it or make ur decition on Gurbani :)