Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
'the singhni'-aka Taran · 04 Jul 2005
yup tht was me hu sed we shud concentrate on shabad. I mean if a chardi kala gursikh starts doing kirtan who has loads of kamai, but his voice isnt as great as you want it to be, wud u just walk out? and listen to bhai manpreet singhs kirtan insted. We shudnt pay any attention to the kirtani, we shud jus be concentratin on the shabad. During our conversation anuva gursikh was tlkin bout his voice he sed he wants to do body building but his worried bout his voice, he thinks it will change!!!!!!! he was also sayin summit bout practisin 2hrs a day doin sa, re ,ga ...... to make his voice good, he wants to make his voice nice for the sangat!!! Why waste all this time makin ur voice nice for other people. When u do kirtan, u shud do kirtan for and to vahiguru, voice doesn't matter. Just do kirtan with piyaar, concentration and correct pronounciation. Dont be worryin bout ur voice, and wether the sangat will like ur voice or not.
p.s) im not pikin on tht gursikh i'm just usin his arguments to tlk bout :-)
bhull chuk maaf karna
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Amarjeet Singh · 04 Jul 2005
i agree raags are important i disagree singing in raag is the quickest way to get sach khand. i also disagree that kirtan shud be sang differently depending on hu is there when you are doin a particular sabad
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
JSGyani "Arshi" · 04 Jul 2005
Asengh ji,
The words [GURBANI] inside the [] must be typed in "small font" NOT CAPITALS. I had to TYPE CAPITALS so as to remain in English..otherwise the Computer will change the Font to Gurmukhi for the entire message which is in English. Please type it like this [gurbani] "asal gurbani which you have cut and pasted... and the ending quote must have the [SLASH/GURBANI] mark infront of gurbani /gurbani enclosed by []
Thnaks for the effort. Then Please REVIEW the message in order to see if any mistake has ocurred before POSTing it.
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Jaskaran Kaur · 05 Jul 2005
Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
My opinion on this is voice does;nt metter as long as u got pyaar inside you. If a Keertania wount have pyaar but got really gud voice and sing shabad then i don;t think it ll attract people. As long as Pyaar is inside then doesn't metter if its a good voice or bad voice shabad will be sung as in beautifull way that sangat will also drag and attract people into shabad. I mean Some people got beautifull voice and when they do keertan people can tell tat they r nervous or they r not into shabad and then they just sitt there listen to shabad and think abt this stuff. Very rare Gurmukhs are out there who will still concentrate on shabad doesn't metter if the person who singing shabad is nervous or not into keertan.
Moorakh like me will sitt there rather then conentrating on shabad, will prefer to comment on tat person who is singins shabad. But if ther eis a keertania who got soo much pyaar for shabad and don;t got gud voice stilll we ll carried away wif it and ll b into shabad. sooo i don;t think Voice matters. Only thing matters is "HAVING A PYAAR FOR GURBANI INSIDE YOU WHICH WILL MAKE PPL TO AATRACT TOWARDS SHABADS".
Bhull Chukk Maaf.
Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
amarjeet singh · 05 Jul 2005
hu cares wat ur voice sounds like, watsa the point of wastin time in tryin to make ur voice sound nice, sounds like manmat to me
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Prabhdeep Singh BABBAR! · 06 Jul 2005
Wjkk Wjkf
Yo tarran I said I dont want no more posts from u and where the hell did U get 2 HOURS OF PRACTICE, U turban naighter firstly stop shavin ur eye brows loolllllzzz joke. I was only borred and thats Y i was debating with u for 2 hours! Tarran I dont think ill be sittin der for 2 hours goin saaaaaaaaaaa, another thing this post is for the sangat not just our debate, so STOP pickin a fight. Come to my house with that drunk banda and ME + ASENGH + MOW = Gurmat!!!!!
Sorry to the sangat for this post, I just need to get my own back, anyway Tarran dont send no more posts its for the sangat to look at, plz can we carry on having posts plz we need to get this debate sorted!
Pul Chuk Maf
Wjkk WJkf
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Amarjeet Singh · 06 Jul 2005
prabhdeep singh ****admin cut***** nothing u sed was related to the topic so if you havent got anything to say related to the title of this topic then dont post it stupid pwala. it doesnt matta how your voice sounds and if u do care what your voice sounds like its means too much haumai which =manmat therefore pwala = po
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Raag Naad Sabh Sach Hai · 06 Jul 2005
If gurbani was to contradict bhai sahib randhir singh who wud u chose 2 believe??
knowing about surs is essential to keertan...i mean yeah raaag is a part of it....but inorder to do raag u need to kno surs, and what is in tune and out of tune...
having a good voice means knowing what sur is...and if u dnt have sur...then that means u have no shardaa for the sur, which is required by raag...
can u follow that??
to sing in raag requires a good voice which requires sur...
if the voice is out of sur..then the raag is sung incorrectly..and i guess thats manmat....if bani was written in raag, that is gurujis mat there for you..right there...guruji chose to write shabad in raag, so we kno that is gurmat....
so a gud voice is needed either way....
and referring to the quote presented
''''The kirtan used to be natural, automatic and spontaneous, for the enjoyment of the kirtaniya himself/herself and not to please others or win recognition''''
Is it wrong if the keertani does it for him/herself but the sangat is still pleased by it...surely if everyone is happier as a result...there is nothin wrong with that...
''''''it doesnt matta how your voice sounds and if u do care what your voice sounds like its means too much haumai which =manmat therefore pwala = po'''''
So to have a gud voice means that u have humai?? Then guruji must have had humai, and so did Sata and Balwand....
'''you call your self akj and that is fine.'''
what is ok about callin urself akj??As tho the akj is the be all and end all of sikhi...surely it wud be better to say i am a sikh, or im tryin to be a sikh???
''''So if you want to ignore what Bhai Sahib is saying then that is a major paap ''''
If Bhai Sahib said something that was incorrect, wud it still be paap....was Bhai Sahib perfect?? and if yes, where is ur proof??Did u kno Bhai Sahib personally, or do u believe everything u read in a book??
''''''My point is answering your question, you said that you want a nice voice to attract sangat because you are supposed to do kirtan for the sangat, HOWEVER bhai sahib says no, we do kirtan for ourselves. Therefore becos we do kirtan for ourselves voice does not matter''''
What if u want to have a gud voice for ur own pleasure aswell?? Anything wrong with that??
Also id like to continue this theme of 'What Bhai Sahib said' or 'What Bhai Sahib would say' and id like to ask, what Bhai Sahib would think of you using such words as PO??
Also how can u refer to people as gurmat???
'''yOUR ANSWER is staring you in the face, but ur too full of yourself to just take a step back and listen to what i am sayin!''
Hold on, what happened to Mit Bolera Ji ???or didnt Bhai Sahib say that u shud talk to everyone sweetly??
Obviously if a person doesnt concentrate on the shabad, and jus concentrates on the raag or the tune, that is wrong totally...but that doesnt mean that voice or raag are irrelevant...or guruji wud never have written gurbani in that format...
There is also a maryada associated with keertan...
''whats wrong with tarans views.jus coz she's a bit hardcore.
buut i dont agree with what she said previously about practising the voice being a waste of time.
and RAAG is the best.''
Im in total agreeance
Im sorry if i have offended anyone
Bhul Chuf Maaf
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Amarjeet Singh · 06 Jul 2005
i dont understand how does singing in raag mean u have to have a nice voice?
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Raag Naad Sabh Sach Hai · 07 Jul 2005
thanks to * for explaining the neccessity of sur in raag....if u are be-sura, u are goin out of the raag...and out of gurus mat
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Prabhdeep Singh · 07 Jul 2005
Amarjeet singh and Taran, THANKYOU SANGAT............ I hope u two listened to what the sangat has to say bout this topic, this was wat I wanted........Amarjeet using bad words in ur post is not really gurmat.......also Taran I hope Raag Naad Sabh Sach Hai has answerd all ur questions.......Thank you!! too all sangat an plz every one listen to the sangat not to an indvidual and not a moorak like me!! 'Aap Japo awra nam japavo!!!!' This is from sukmani sahib do it urself and get others to do it with u aswel.........If we take this to an example, when doing an akhand path why doesnt the granthi reading mahraj just do it for him self in his mind? Reason being its for the sangat to listen and also him or herself......that was my point.
Sorry If I Upset any one!! PLz forgive this moorak.
Wjkk Wjkf
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Amarjeet Singh · 07 Jul 2005
i didnt not use bad words in my post prabhdeep so there (they werent swear words or nything) :) i would never cuss a wonderful singh like yourself (((((((((((((:)
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Prabhdeep Singh · 08 Jul 2005
Wjkk Wjkf
Sorry Taran jio, I did look at ur posts I didnt want to comment on them cuz I want other people to do so, as this is y the post was put up! 2 hours is over the top lolz I get wat u mean by ur posts and one should not look at there fame and reputation while doin keertan - as bhai randheer singh ji says,
''The kirtan used to be natural, automatic and spontaneous, for the enjoyment of the kirtaniya himself/herself and not to please others or win recognition''
Bhai sahibs says dont please other people and to win recognition, Bhai sahib says nothing bout sangat and nothing bout the voice!
Pul Chuk Maf!
Wjkk WJkf
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 08 Jul 2005
We should Jap as much Naam as possible, this way all the Raags, Naad etc walk behind us with folded hands. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh did not learn Keertan from anyone...once you have Kamaaee of Vaheguru Jaap then everything follows spontaneously.
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Raag Naad Sabh Sach Hai · 09 Jul 2005
I disagree with how someone can gain everything automatically by japing naam....however i put forward the point that doing the right thing is also naam aswell...
how can u do somethin like singin without learning...if u are unaware of sur how can u kno it?? doesnt make sense...sikhi is not magical its practical
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
amarjeet singh · 10 Jul 2005
naam is the key to every thing, with naam you can gain everything. raag is important but it isnt a major paap not to sing in raag if you dont know how to.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
oi freshy kaur · 13 Jul 2005
Just to say I was also there when this discussion was going on. In all fairness our veer Prabhdeep singh was only trying to pass time and get the whole group into the converstaion and take views from everyone as we were in a situation were we really needed to have a discussion otherwise we would have just collapsed in the heat.
Anyways back onto the topic, Veer Prabhdeep singh Ji, I appreciate your views and to a certain extent can comprehend with your views as when I first staring to listening to kirtan I listened to the tunes and thought they were fantastic and voices sounded loud and had grams in them, but after a short time I realised that this was not right. To be fair I persoannly don't like Manpreet Singh Jis voice, Veer Prabhdeeps voice is probably better. But like the previous posts outlined its personal preference.
I have learnt to listen to gurbani and the meaning of gurbani, don't get me wrong voice plays an important part to whos kirtan I listen to constantly, however other things play a bigger part, for example, the nimartha of the kirtanee, the amount of gian and pyar they have whilst reciting gurbani.
Unfortunately many members of the sangat have chosen to label kirtanees as popstars and have ranked kirtanees into specific categories. Which means that kirtanees have to compete and have the best voices otherwise they dont have achance. I hear some of you say that who cares just sit at home and do kirtan, thats exactly right, however if we all did this and didn't take into consideration what the sangat likes then we are not bringing together sangat. Many people have come into sikhi because they like a so called kirtanee, and loved the kirtan so much that they have become amrit dharee.
So at the end of the day what we should do and what we do do we all are aware of, but remember that we live in a word that has made things very difficult for people to succeed unless they have the "perfect image" and i agree with my respected bhen ji Taran kaur that we shouldn't be bothered about the voice but at the end of the day most of us are and we need to move away from that. Look at a persons good things and learn from others.
And if Veer Prabhdeep singh ji wants to practise for 2 hours that is dedication however 2 hours is a bit harsh.
Re: Keertan - having a nice voice!
Prabhdeep Singh · 13 Jul 2005
Wjkk WJkf
hahaha here we go again on the 2 hours.........U freshy only cuz ur husband has the best voice in the jatha.....Dont have to boast! Remeber Prabhdeep Is coming now in to the jatha of keertanis and will shortly competing with ur husband lolz Nah im only jkin......I love u all! Im honered that 'oi freshy kaur' has posted in this post.........keep it up, stay in chardikala! And ill c u all in the next rensbhai! GURROOOOOOO!! Is ur husband still angry with me, for calling him freshy? haha
Wjkk Wjkf