Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sants using kachi bani

Sants using kachi bani

suki singh · 04 Jul 2005

Have Kachi-bani singing sants managed to find a single shabad amongest the thousands in the Guru Granth Sahib ji that he can share with the sangat? I really cant understand why so called Sants need to resort to Katchi bani-this leads me to think that they wish to undermine the GGSJi. From 1430 pages...there is not one shabad that they can find thats suitable? What a shame ****Admin Note: Slight modification (edit) in the original message*****

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Gurus Son · 04 Jul 2005

Wjkk WJKf If u look at wat one of the babas said in there talks, was about kachi bani. He goes kachi bani is not wrong unless it is giving a wrong message! But if its a good thing then wats wrong with it, if the normal sangat can understand it beta including moneh, so wats wrong in dat I think its great. Tadis why didnt guru ji say nutin to tadis, tadis use kachi bani and dat was at mahrajs times. Also Baba jarnail singh sometimes used kachi bani.......nothing wrong in it! Wel unless its giving a wrong messege! Wjkk WJkf

Re: Sants using kachi bani

slow on the uptake · 04 Jul 2005

veer ji what a sant singhs is not kachi bani as dhaarna are not bani therefore it cant be kachi bani. on a side note kachi bani is something that does not come in line with praising guru ji.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Duki Singh · 04 Jul 2005

GGSji?! It is also undermining to refer to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj as GGSji.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Dandilion · 04 Jul 2005

Suki, If you are defering the Sant Ranjit singh Ji and their dhaarna kirtan, then since it is dhaarna kirtan and not baani, then how can you call it kachi bani, if it is not bani in the first place ???? If you go behind the thinking there is a logical reason for this. It was all to do with Sant Ishar singh who say that the farmers in the fields would eb singing geets and songs in very straight dhaarnas being simple folk. They told the farmers and workers rather then sing those songs why not change them and sing the praises of God. This is how this started.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

~~King po~~ · 04 Jul 2005

The thing is they don't think it's kuchi bani becasue they say it's darnaa and not bani ???hmmmm

Re: Sants using kachi bani

JSGyani "Arshi" · 04 Jul 2005

I just listened to a "fantastic...three hour video smagam....this and that of a famous sant Ji....FOUND he DIDNT QUOTE a SINGLE TUK of GURBANI during the entire 3 Hour marathon smagam...all kachi bani and kavitas throughout.. I am flabbergasted that what is so fantastic about this 3 hr long marathon speech by this sant and a few chamta banging chelas banging away at the kachee dharnaa tunes..He says again and agaian and keep saying it... Amrit chhako ji, Guru waleh bano ji. Guru Granth ji wich shadha rakho ji...BUT DOESNT QUOTE ONE SINGLE PANKTEE of GURBANI...shabad taan pareh de baat hai....in 3 hours he could have done kirtan of at least TEN complete Shabads...at the very least...still his chelas say fantastic diwan..thousands turned up..rass and what not..just looking at him ??? I think these sants know the art of Mass HYPNOTISM...they MESMERISE the sangats.....who sit there lsitening to their LONG winding dialogues, and personal stories....and all that hype...and then go away thinking wah wah so fantastic !!! feel sorry for these folks. The sant is using Gurbani/Amrit/Guru Granth Ji just as a Propoganda Stunt...and actually promoting only himself as a future GURUDOM...

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Amarjeet Singh · 04 Jul 2005

"From 1430 pages..." uve made 2 mistakes it shud be "from 1429 angs......"

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Tarsem Singh · 04 Jul 2005

According to this logic, that would mean that there is no such thing as "kuchee baanee" since nothing else could possibly be Gurbani. In other words, we could sing anything, and it would never be classed as kuchee. So what does "kuchee baanee" mean?

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Jasvir kaur · 04 Jul 2005

EVERYTHING that is NOT about SATGUR is kachee bani... Guru Amardass ji has already given us the criteria.... all BANI that is about SATGUR is pakee and all else is kachee....Satgur bina hor kachee banee ( some people wrongly translate this as bani from SATGUR Ji and then mean it to mean that bhgat bani is not bani since it is not from Satgur Ji...) Bhai gurdass Varaan, Kabits swiyahs, Bhai naand Laal Jis swiyahs are sanctioned by the Panth as valid...and can be sung as KIRTAN from the Kirtan Stage. The Dhadees sing HISTORY and VALOUR and are also sanctioned..that is a valid art form and also DURING GURU JIs time. but Dhaarna kirtan is a sant speciality.....various excuses..it is simple, its for the jatt folks, pendu folks, blah blah all mean the same thing..IT IS SIMPLE FOR the SANTS as well as not much effort required to learn any GURBANI..the Sant himslef is a pendu jatt background..so easier for him too and If he does GURBANI he will have to do AArths, Viakhiya...all a very DIFFICULT JOB....so they take the easy way out...just keep repating ucha dar baabejh nanak da....uch dar baabeh nanak da... at the back some ladies may even change it to .... oh chadar babeh nanak dee...but who cares....as long as the sant can pass the time. IF GURBANI is really THAT DIFFICULT ??? Why did the GURUS write it ?? Couldnt GURU NANAK and Mardaana Ji just sung two liners...AA giya mardana rabab farr ke. Ji......aa giya mardana rabab farr ke ji... ??? Bolo Sangato..AA giya Mardana...blah blah blah... WHY write the "difficult banis" ?? Were the people then any LESS Pendu, Jatt folks ?? were they all EDUCATED University Graduates able to "understand" Gurbani ?? all 1429 AAngs of such a HUGE GRANTH full of DIFFICULT GURBANI ?? Who is telling lies here ?? Is Gurbani really difficult or are the dharnaa singers LAZY ?? and dont want to bother learning Gurbani/aarths/viakhiya and Gurmat SANGEET raags etc. The Pendus buy just as much DVDS and VCDs of the Ragis and Kirtans...how come they can "understand" gurbani when they pay for it...I have seen Gurbani cds in many village houses.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Dandilion · 04 Jul 2005

<<< I just listened to a "fantastic...three hour video smagam....this and that of a famous sant Ji....FOUND he DIDNT QUOTE a SINGLE TUK of GURBANI during the entire 3 Hour marathon smagam...all kachi bani and kavitas throughout.. >>> If you are referring to Sant Ranjit Singh Ji which I am sure you are, then you are being economical with the truth. At the start of every divan Babaji goes into a long recitel of Guru’s bani. They sing unaccompanied tukha from Gurbani. Throughout their divan the quote many times from Gurbani, there is no doubt about this, it is a pity your ears seem to be closed to this. <<< I am flabbergasted that what is so fantastic about this 3 hr long marathon speech by this sant and a few chamta banging chelas banging away at the kachee dharnaa tunes. >>> It seems to me a little jealousy creeping in Giyani Ji. Watchout! What is so fantastic (which your ears cannot comprehend) is that Sant Ji has sooo much kumai within him and this is coming out with every breath, every word he speaks and the raas is unbelievable. This is kirpa of AkalPurkh which He bestows on his Mahapurkh. <<<< He says again and agaian and keep saying it... Amrit chhako ji, Guru waleh bano ji. Guru Granth ji wich shadha rakho ji...BUT DOESNT QUOTE ONE SINGLE PANKTEE of GURBANI...shabad taan pareh de baat hai....in 3 hours he could have done kirtan of at least TEN complete Shabads...at the very least...still his chelas say fantastic diwan..thousands turned up..rass and what not..just looking at him ??? >>> Again I would have to disagree with you here my dear Giani ji, BabaJi quotes many time and even some of there dhaarna kirtan is tukhs from gurbani. And what is so wrong with repeating again and again “Amrit chhako”, again it seems to me that your hatred towards men of God is so great that the message that they are trying to convey to the sangat is beyond you. <<<< I think these sants know the art of Mass HYPNOTISM...they MESMERISE the sangats.....who sit there lsitening to their LONG winding dialogues, and personal stories....and all that hype...and then go away thinking wah wah so fantastic !!! feel sorry for these folks. The sant is using Gurbani/Amrit/Guru Granth Ji just as a Propoganda Stunt...and actually promoting only himself as a future GURUDOM... >>>> Giani Ji, what you call “HYPNOTISM, MESMERISE” most gursikhs will call the ras of a person with Kumai a person who is totally pijaa with akaal bani and at such a young age. NO the Sant is not using gurbani as propaganda, he is promoting Guru ji’s message in a humble straight forward way. Giani Ji you are beginning to sound like an old record, one whose time has long since passed.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

slow on the uptake · 04 Jul 2005

which sant was it..can you upload the diwaan or tell us where we can get hold of it and decide for our selfs? + if a sant had the status 'bhai' im sure you wouldnt bash as much, maybe you should make this suggestions to this sant you speak off, show him the way? I mean clearly you have joined thousands with your teachings so it maybe an idea to suggest this to this sant

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Iminder Singh · 04 Jul 2005

Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh! >>>WHY write the "difficult banis" ?? Were the people then any LESS Pendu, Jatt folks ?? were they all EDUCATED University Graduates able to "understand" Gurbani ?? all 1429 AAngs of such a HUGE GRANTH full of DIFFICULT GURBANI ??<<< Wicked point Jasvir Kaur Bhenji. [%sig%]

Re: Sants using kachi bani

charanjeev singh · 04 Jul 2005

waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh it is my understanding that only the Baani of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee bhai gurdaas jee, and bhai nand (singh) lal jee could be sung in the saadh sangat. this too must be sung according to the measures assigned by Guru Sahib. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Singh · 04 Jul 2005

>>> side note kachi bani is something that does not come in line with praising guru ji. >>> "Satgur bina hore kachee hai bani..." Then to really stress the point guru sahib says again, "Bani taan kachee satgur bajhoan.." So any dharnas read by "sants" are kachee bani. Guru sahib says so clearly in ANAND SAHIB. (above panktis)

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Lord Singh · 04 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! Singh's listen - this is getting out of hand now - Panjab Radio and other Sant Bashers are really over doing this propaganda. Baba Ji is currently very upset about this and considering to go back to Punjab - One of the Gurdwara's in Southall were telling them that they want all the money from one of the diwaans and Baba Ji was like take all the money from all the diwaans, as he is not here to make money, but to do Sikhi Parchaar!!! - SHAME ON THESE SO CALLED "SIKHS"!!! The Indian Government, RSS...etc is all out there to divide the panth and cause internal problems - Panjab Radio has been given licences directly from the government to broadcast in India as well - PLEASE DO NOT FALL IN THIS GOVERNMENT AIDED AND PLANNED TRAP!!! - Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale woke the sleeping panth to stand-up to these agencies and their propaganda that was splitting the panth - DO NOT FALL ASLEEP AGAIN!!! - WAKE UP SIKHO!!! EVERYONE MUST take part in phoning Panjab Radio and emailing them to stop this nonsense at once!!! - It will be even better if people phone in live and tell them off - I certainly will be doing so!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kaum Jugaee" [%sig%]

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Singhani · 04 Jul 2005

>> by the Panth << Jarnail Singh said the Panth decided what Bani is, who the hell knows what the Panth is anymore? I wouldnt trust these people.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

...... · 04 Jul 2005

So anything that is not from Guru Granth sahib Ji , Bhai Gurdass Dian Varaan n Bhai Nand Lal Ji cantbe uttered from the stage hmmm i must be mistaken.. for have i not been to Rehansabhai's and they singh Dhan Dhan Sri Guru granth Sahib Ji.... oooohhhhh.. katchi Bani... @ rehansabhai's for this EXACT line is not from Gurbani.... hmmmm.. to translate Gurbani we use WORDS from panjabi & English on stage..... .oh NO katch Bani everywhere even the stage secetary speaks Kachi bani, how else is he/she supose to dialogue...Wot nonesense.. we are going over the top as a Veer has already stated.. if it is in praise of Satgur, it is OK

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Sher Khalsa · 04 Jul 2005

Guru Pyare Bibi Jasveer Kaur jio, Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Wahegurujee kee Fateh. I think that is a much much approriate ans. given by U. I did find any better explanation for this.U r very right in saying this that this is all because of Laziness of ths so called SANTS. If anyone go by their registers and see and try to count to how many they have given AMRIT , the counting goes not to LAKHS BUT TO CRORES of people but U can think that where they all have gone afer taking the AMIRT. Because everyone and anyone can be hipnotized by telling the stories for 3-4 days and making the to partake AMRIT but who will check them afterwards whether they had kept it or not. Onething I can say that ALL THIS PATIT PUNA IS BECAUSE OF THESE PSEUDO SANTS only. They don't wanna themselves to be called as BHAI. They think that they are SUPERIOR than the Sangat, themselves violating the Gurmat and doing all those thing banned by RAHIT MARYADA. If anyone goes by their JIWANS according to GURBANI they cann't be taken as SIKHS even leave about SANTS. They are propagating their own GURUDOM only. If people at the time of GURUJI who was less educated as compared to today ( ofcourse they were devotees of Gurus and not of any SANTS) can understand the Gurbani, why cant people understand today. Onething I wanna tell Every Gursikh that think why so called SANTS always say read these many ( 5, 25, 40 , etc) paths of JAPJI SAHIB, SUKMANI SAHIB ETC but U will never ever heard even a single SANT saying that go read the SATEEK( EXPLANATION OF GURBANI) of JAPJI SAHIB etc. They cant say this thing because they( PSEUDO SANTS) know that if people will start reading SATEEKS they will come to know the REAL INTENTION OF GURU SAHIBS and then will not follow these PSEUDO SANTS and even they will come to know who is called SANT. Te phir ohna dee Dukaan band ho javegee. SO MY LAST REQUEST TO ALL " BE THE SIKH OF GURU AND NOT OF ANY SANTS" That what I wanna say. Wahegurujee ka Khalsa, Wahegurujee kee Fateh.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

charanjeev singh · 04 Jul 2005

waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh i take bhai sahibs dharnaa to be katha; and since people are listening to bhai sahibs kathaa, and joining with Amrit that is a very big thing, and must be commended. Before one judges another, espcially those who are doing parchaar of Amrit, one should ask themselves 'hey, do people really listen to me when i ask them to take Amrit?' and then judge others. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Sants using kachi bani

JSGyani "Arshi" · 04 Jul 2005

Dear Author ji and others who wrote similar vein... IF we have Dhan Dhan Dhan GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB....a HUGE KHAZANAH of 1429 aangs writtten by GURU SAHIBAANS, BHAGATS, BHATTS, and others of every colour and hue, every place and direction, every language... WHY DO WE NEED any OUTSIDE worthless two liners ?? for heaven's sake man... its like the small child who given a 20 POUND NOTE refuses it by saying I like the SHINY PENNY More..... SHAME on those who say GURBANI is "DIFFICULT", "hard to understand"...blah blah blah..and we like the two liners of PENDU UNEDUCATED SANTS better than ILAHI GURBANI AMRIT ...and shame on those so called "sants" who deny their SIKHS this NAAM AMRIT by dismissing them as uneducated pendus..are we all really "uneducated pendus" ?? we can study at Universities get professional degrees and be professionals....but when we come to GURBANI we "sheepishly accept" this insult and admit we are too pendu for Gurbani..and let the sant practise/push his own ignorance of Gurbani on to us..WHAT for is the PARKASH of GURU GRANTH JI there..is it just for MATHA TEK/GOLAK COLLECTION ??...Since we are paying to listen to the sant sing his two liners dharrnas...and IGNORE GURBANI ( too difficult)..WHY have the Parkash of GURU JI at all ?? isnt it a shame ?? GURU JI is to Kept COVERED in Rumalls and KEPT QUIET....( we dont "understand what you are saying Guru Ji because you "talk" in a language too difficult for us pendus...we prefer to listen to this sant who himself is a pendu and talks our language !!!! PLEASE FOLKS just listen to yourself ???? IF...JUST IF we suppose GURBANI is "difficult" for us..is it going to become SIMPLER for our NEXT GENERATION....who are even less punjabi spraking than us...THAT is when the "SANT JI" replaces GURU GRANTH JI and sits on the Throne himself...as the radhasoamis have done ( at their early stages each radhasoami diwan always had a GURU GRANTH JI PARKASH...but always it was the HUMAN GURU...speaking and doing viakhiyaah....soon he dispensed with Guru garnth ji and assumed its position.. THIS is the Ultimate dream of each and every sant who says GURBANI is DIFFICULT...just listen to me.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

RAJ · 05 Jul 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ke fateh i dont normally post on any message boards but after reading what some of you have put i jus had to correct you all, there are 1430 angs and not 1429angs. and lets not get into the raag mala issue...as that will be something that we should agree to disagree on. how can you call it kachi bani?? if someone is not reciting bani then please tell me how is this kachi bani?? we all say things to express what GURU JI is telling us, if one way is through dharnaa then so be it. if people are coming into sikhi by hearing the veechars of sants or who ever then that is the best thing for panth...we should join together not sit around and people dis. The Indian Gov, RSS and others who are attacking sikhi will win if we fight amongst ourselves. bhul chuk marf. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Sants using kachi bani

search for tat · 05 Jul 2005

Just wondering when sant jarnial singh ever used kacchi bani? I have never heard him use it?

Re: Sants using kachi bani

- · 05 Jul 2005

I dont get it at all - the people that are arguing that people shouldnt use "kach bani" as a form as parchar are using so called "kachi bani" too by trying to convince others of the "evils" of "kach bani". some people on this forum have got huge egos [%sig%]

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Lord Singh · 05 Jul 2005

I have an audio file by Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Ji about this so-called "Kachi Bani" could someone email me or tell me on this thread about how I would be able to upload this somehow! Thanks in advance... Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!

Re: Sants using kachi bani

suki singh · 05 Jul 2005

Shame on 'lord singh' for bringing in the esteemed name of Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale into this issue of katchi bani and using it to defend the indefensible use of katchi bani on our stages in front of the Guru Ji. These false saadhs only flourished after the Sikh Freedom movement died down due in the early 90's. Before that where were they to be seen?? Where were the Saadhs when the Delhi riots were happening, or when countless false encounters were taking place and Sikh Bibian being raped in police stations? Why did all the saadhs spring up like mushrooms after a rainfall when the movement died down?? We have all seen the scene, with Guru Ji Parkash, illuminating the sangat with the Hukamnama with dhur ki bani, and then some saad comes and starts singing katchi bani for 2 hours and banging away on the chamtay. Just think a bit deeper- what respect ar we showing for the bani when we ignore it and instead do our own manmat with easy listening poetry. There was one saad who I heard of couple of years ago, and inbetween his katchi taarna, he espoused the doing of Sukhmani Sahib path. Many saads tell the sangat to continually read Sukhmani Sahib da paat. This is great, but what about the rest of the Guru Ji? Why do we NEVER hear a saad mentioning the great bani of Dhan Guru Nanak Dev Ji, Sri Asa Di Vaar!! Is it because this bani bashes these fakes saads in every stanza- there false ways, their corruption and their fake holy garbs??

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Jaskaran Kaur · 05 Jul 2005

Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Could'nt be said better then Jasvir Kaur and JSGyani "Arshi". But i will like to enter a bit more into it... that these SANTS says tat they sing KACHI BANI just to make ppl understand. Ok fare enough point been prooved. But what i can't understand is that, then why they still do KATHA???? If Kachi Bani is easily understandable then i dont see any point of doing KATHA. Rather then Sants singing kachi Bani and still doing katha, should'nt they be singing GURBANI (PAKKI BANI) and doing katha which even will make people understand tat wot msg is Guru Ji trying to give to us moorakhs who says that we can't understand Gurbani cause its hard to understand. i would like to say ONE more thing not to Sants butt surely to my dear Brothers and Sisters out there... that if we can go out and learn other languages then why can't we go and learn Gurmukhi????? Is Gurmukhi hard to learn?????? I don't think so. Gurmukhi got a essence of Punjabi which means its not hard atall for us lot to go out and learn. We being a Sikh and when we know punjabi properly we can learn French, Italian, German etc which are not even a bitt similar to english... for new learner whihc is totally like a alian language still learn that language excitingly then WHY NOT GURMUKHI WHICH IS SIMILAR TO PUNJABI????? Think about itttt My dear bro and sisters everything ll make sence. IF i have said anything wrong then plzz do Forgive me. Sarbatt Da Bhala!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Sants using kachi bani

moorak · 05 Jul 2005

i have been to all sant bhai baba ranjits singhs samagams in the midlands proud to say i have been , learnt alot of baanee heard alot of katha and yes sang dharnas , i do not see what peolpes problem is but i will carry on listening it is the only person i have heard speaking about respect for sggs and encouraging people to read as much baanee as they can, have commerciallly bought dvds of sant jarnail singh singing dharnas,people keep on saying that where were these sants in 84 i feel it is all directed at this one young man i dont think he was old enough to do anything, why is it when somebody speaks of unity he is dragged down, as bhai sahib says before we criticise anybody else look at ur own faults and then criticise this includes me too, as for me i am a 32 yr old sikh who was brought up in a punabi house hold like many others it was full of guru jis pictures but no baanee, who was i gonna turn to in coventry seven gurdwara that act as community centres for chit chat and fashion , i ask u who was i gonna turn to, no baanee classes aimed at young people when i wanted to learn , so with wahegurus garce i learned myself and i can now do the nitnem, i do not go to guru kar not because my guru is not there but because of alll these people that speak for my panth,, well people u do not speak for me as long as on the day of judgement i can stand infront of waheguru and account for my sins and make myself a better person that is most important. now as for punjab radio i held this instituion with great respect because when i was learning it was a good source ps i am still learning and will for the rest of my life god willing but it seems they have fallen into its own hankaar, when it sells paath and ardas for £200 its ok and rehit when they hold functions to clelebrate its birthdays its rehit even though they have folk singers etc etc, its ok for them to have their chela, but some other person cannot hypocrisy ,,, they now talk about respect guru granth sahib campaign that they were doing it all wrong when this campaign has been going on for years now they talk about beadbee these people are the charlatans of us mixing not kachi baanee with pakee baanee but punjabiat with skihi the two never have and never will mix, guru arjan said spread this around the world not just to punjabis,,,,,,,, sorry if this has gone i do not care if i have offended anybody but if i have errored waheguru , sgggs or the gurus may the sangat the panj piare and ultimatley waheguru forgive me

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Lord Singh · 05 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "SUKHI SINGH" VEER JI, Why is it shame to bring up the name of the great Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale??? - Why shouldn't we remember those who fought so braveley for the panth - to keep it alive - to wake it up and for it to unite as one!!! Did Sant Bhindranwale not say to fight against these oppressors - RSS, Indian Government...etc that are set-out to make divisions in the Sikh Panth??? - I think they did!!! - If you are disagreeing with me on this fact, I think your knowledge on what Sant Bhindranwale stood for is very small - I suggest you go and listen to some of Sant Ji's speeches, there's plenty on the internet!!! Should we not remember Sant Bhindranwale and their teachings??? - there were people during their time that said Bhindranwale is no Sant - But a true Gursikh knows he was!!! Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Ji told a story that when he was in Canada, someone while they were at a Premi's house said no one is a Sant, and there was a picture of Sant Bhindranwale, so Baba Ji asked him who was that person on the wall. This person could then no longer say anything and looking around the room where there were like 20 Singhs, he said Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. Baba Ji was like there you go!!! Are you saying that Sant Bhindranwale was also a "false" Sant then??? - I certainly hope not!!! You say I am using Sant Bhindranwale to "defend the indefensible use of katchi bani on our stages in front of the Guru Ji" - when in fact I am not, but merely stating the fact that we should not listen to organisations that are always trying to cause internal splits and problems within the Sikh Panth - What Sant Bhindranwale told us to beware of and avoid!!! Infact, you say I am using Sant Bhindranwale to "defend the indefensible use of katchi bani on our stages in front of the Guru Ji" - when the fact is that Sant Ji himself used to sing this so-called "kachi bani" as you call it - (but a person with more common sense would call it "Dharnaas") - in front of thousands of Sikhs and in front of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji - "Sir Jaave Ta Jaave, Mera Sikhi Sidak Na Jaave" - and the thousands of sangat used to sing this "kachi bani" with Sant Ji - "Eh Panchi Kala Hai, Edheh Magar Shikari Bauthe" - have you not heard this Dharnaa that Sant Ji also sang??? - I guess you have not, because otherwise you would not say that i'm using Sant Bhindranwale to defend "kach bani" (when in fact I was not doing anything of the sort anyway) - You are contradicting yourself "Suki Singh"!!! I think it is you who are "bringing the esteemed name of" Sant Bhindranwale into this "kachi bani" issue without a clue of their history and misusing it without the facts!!! I think the shame is on you "Suki Singh" for telling me not to bring up Sant Bhindranwale's name and remember what they stood up for and the "kachi bani" they sang!!!!! Bhull Chuk Maarf! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kaum Jugaee" [%sig%]

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Dandilion · 05 Jul 2005

Come on Jaskaran Kaur, Sher Khalsa, Jasvir Kaur and Arshi - I have also heard this dhaarna sung by Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale Ji. Are you going to critisize Baba Ji also, how low can you lot get ????

Re: Sants using kachi bani

search for tat · 05 Jul 2005

just wondering why these sants do not try and use only bani? works well enough for Sant singh maskeen and Bhai jasvir Singh khannewale... maybe it would work ever better for them?

Re: Sants using kachi bani

NaamRas · 05 Jul 2005

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! Add other great souls, like Sant Isher Singh Jee Rara Sahib Wale and Sant Attar Singh Jee Mastuana Wale alongside Sant Jarnail Singh Jee BhindranWale, as "Sants" who sang "Kachi Bani". Are these 3 great souls of the Khalsa Panth in the last century really capable of disrespecting GurBani, Guru Sahib Jee and Nirankar? If you think so, then we really have some truly spiritually enlightened souls on this Tapoban message board. Perhaps you people can cause a Revolution in Gurmat Parchar, through this message board, as these 3 great souls did for the Khalsa Panth in the last century. O spiritually enlightened persons of Tapoban message board, can I please see you criticise Sant Attar Singh Jee, Sant Isher Singh Jee and Sant Jarnail Singh Jee!!! Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguroo

Re: Sants using kachi bani

wow · 05 Jul 2005

where are the dhaarna sung by Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale Ji. Dandilion lets have them please post links

Re: Sants using kachi bani

gosh · 05 Jul 2005

i don understand what this thread is about

Re: Sants using kachi bani

Lord Singh · 05 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! Another one was "Ditya Baaz Nahi Rehana Dharam Sir Dittiya Bazz Nahi Rehna" - that Sant Bhindranwale also sang!!! Some people on this forum above think they are really big Sant Bhindranwale supporters and think they have the right to tell people if they can use and remember Sant Ji's name or not, when they themselves do not not know that Sant Ji also sang Dharnaas and then criticise them as "kachi bani", therefore contradicting themselves and their so-called "respect" for the mahaan leaders of the panth like Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale!!! If you support Sant Ji and respect him, then you cannot on the other hand call Dharnaas "kachi bani" - if you don't - then only Waheguru can help you and bless you to come to your senses!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kaum Jugaee" [%sig%]

Re: Sants using kachi bani

~~po punisher~~ · 06 Jul 2005

Sant Isher Singh Jee Rara Sahib Wale and Sant Attar Singh Jee Mastuana Wale alongside Sant Jarnail Singh Jee BhindranWale, as "Sants" who sang "Kachi Bani<<<< though these bhai sahibs should be respected for the purchar they did , at the end of they where only human , never equal to Guru ji thereofre there bani can never be sutchee as only Guru ji's bani is sutchee sathiguroo binaa hor kachee hai baanee || Without the True Guru, other songs are false. baanee th kachee sathiguroo baajhahu hor kachee baanee || The songs are false without the True Guru; all other songs are false. kehadhae kachae sunadhae kachae kacha(n)aee aakh vakhaanee || The speakers are false, and the listeners are false; those who speak and recite are false. har har nith karehi rasanaa kehiaa kashhoo n jaanee || They may continually chant, 'Har, Har' with their tongues, but they do not know what they are saying. chith jin kaa hir laeiaa maaeiaa bolan peae ravaanee || Their consciousness is lured by Maya; they are just reciting mechanically. kehai naanak sathiguroo baajhahu hor kachee baanee ||24|| Says Nanak, without the True Guru, other songs are false. ||24|| People who beleive that dharnaa are good try and justify it by saying it's not bani therefore can't be kutchee, but that makes no sense read the above shabad Guru ji says that without Guru ji ALL songs are false.

Re: Sants using kachi bani

JSGyani "Arshi" · 06 Jul 2005

What Lord Singh is trying to force down our throats is that "Sant" Jarnail Singh Bhinderawalh is ABHULL...EQUAL to GURU JI. We MUST either Take him 100%...or Not at all ??? Sorry Lord Jio, I only TAKE GURU JI 100%....no one else is equal to GURU JI. 1.Since we RESPECT Jarnail Singh Ji, and Honour His supreme SACRIFICE for the Guru Khalsa Panth..we MUST therefore BELIEVE that EVERY SINGLE ACT OF HIS AS GOD_TRUTH THAT is SUPREME SACRILEGE towards GURU JI. ONLY and ONLY GURU JI is ABHULL....GURU JI CANNOT and NEVER made any 0.00000000000000000001% "mistake"..... HUMANS like Sant Jarnail Singh Ji can and DID make many mistakes ( What mistakes only Guru Ji knows) BUT ONE SUCH MISTAKE is singing Dharnaas...as opposed to Singing ONLY GURBANI KIRTAN. Bhai gurdass Ji wrote so much poetry..NONE of it GURBANI standard....did he or couldnt he write any "dhaarnas" ?? A Dhaarna is the Simplest of the Simplest two line rhyming poem...any one with basic knowledge of Punjabi can write a few anytime !!! They are just "catchy" jingles we often hear on ADVERTISING RADIO/TV/selling things like Lux Soap, Vedic toothpaste and such. IS Sikhe that cheap ?? Sing jingles when we have ILAHI GURBANI from SACH KHAND ?? I am really surprised at the way people are equating JINGLEs with Sant Ji's sacrifice. WHY DIDNT GURU JI sing any such Dharnaas ?? Didnt they have this "knowledge" ?? Couldnt they also write such dharnaas...just for fun ?? WHY did they WRITE ONLY GURBANI ?? WHY did GURU JI just CHOOSE those "bnais" of Bhagats and Sheikh that FITS GURBANI STANDARD ?? Bhagats, Ravidass Ji, Ramanand Ji, Sain Ji....and Bhagat Kabeer especially wrote HUGE AMOUNTS of "kachee Bani"..GURU JI REJECTED ALL THAT.....just go ask any kabeer Panthi and they will show you what a huge "granth" of bani they have of Bhagat Ji's poetry..Some of this poetry is SUNG as BHAJANS...in Hindu Mandirs ?? I would think a piece of "Kachi Bani" type of Bhajan/poem/dharnaa written by a Brahmgiani type of the standard of KABEER would be of a HIGHER STANDARD than any dhaarna sung by any SANT JI??? BUT GURU JI REJECTED it ?? WHY ?? Bhagat kabeer has a LOT of GURBANI in Guur Granth Ji..Which of the Dhaarna singing "sants" has any such BANI included in the GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB ?? Lord Singh Jio answer these questions satisfactorily. I can support you wholeheartedly on.. even 110%.... "Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kaum Jugaee" This NO one can dispute.