Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Question about Khalistan

Question about Khalistan

Blues · 04 Jul 2005

I browsed lot's of websites to understand the background of the Khalistan and rational behind a separate nation. I am still not able to find an answer. I've few question to all the readers of the website: 1. Before 1984, when was the last time there was communal roit between Sikhs and Hindus? 2. In Golden temple who took the arms inside first - Indian Army or Bhinderwale? 3. If for a moment we assume Indian "Hindu Army" didn't have respect for the Granth Sahib. But, what about the sikhs holding the arms inside the Golden temple. They knew what the outcome will be if Indian Army marches in. For them what was more important - there arrogance or Granth Sahib? 4. Say after getting Khalistan (today's pubjab), minorty hindus refuse to live with Sikhs. Would they get a separate nation? Where would this divison end? With that said, I completly agree that no justice has been done till date to the killing of my fellow Indian sikhs in delhi. All Indian should be shamed of the killings of indians in 1984 (Delhi) or 2003 (Gujrat) in their own motherland. [%sig%]

Re: Question about Khalistan

Rain drop · 05 Jul 2005

All the four points raised, seem ultimately to justify saying " no to Khalistan". Blues lacks Khalsa Spirit.

Re: Question about Khalistan

Sikhi · 05 Jul 2005

1. I don’t think that the riots have taken place at all. In books like Gallant Defender the author mentions that the killing if Hindus somehow raised in April until the end of May. The government did this so that the excuse to attack Darbar Sahib would be stronger. (The cover-up lie made by them is that Sant Ji would announce to all the Sikhs in Punjab to start killing the hindus) 2. Sant Bhindranwala and his men did have a small amount of weapons (see photos/videos) however he did this to bring back the Sant-Sipahi attitude in the Khalsa Panth which almost was gone. He didn’t do anything wrong with this. Shri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji introduced this, so who should we listen to a pandit or to our own Guroo when it comes to this point? Anyway, when the attack was over the army 'found' many weapons. Gen. Arora wrote in the book "the Punjab story" that in a fight or a war weapons used to get lost. In this case however all the weapons that the Sikh fighters used were brand new! 3. Yes there indeed Sikh soldiers who attacked the Darbar Sahib. According to AR Darshi in Gallant Defender he claimed that they were not Sikhs but Sant Nirankaris. But can you call someone a Sikh if he attacks the Darbar Sahib? There were also many Sikh Soldiers who muted against the army. Many of them were shot dead an imprisoned for years. Read about in the book Dream of Freedom. 4. Why they don’t want to live with the Sikhs? If this true then we know for shore that the Punjabi Hindus have betrayed the Sikhs for the last 50 years!!!

Re: Question about Khalistan

Singh · 05 Jul 2005

This may be quite controversial what I am about to say. We all respect the Karku Singhs and their efforts but at the same time there were mistakes they made and we need to recognise these in order to improve. I think most will agree that whilst Sukhdev Singh Babbar was the greatest general and tactician of the 20th century as well as a Gursikh it was a mistake to boycott the Punjab elections. In the same way, whilst 1984 popularised the Khalistan movement, it was a tactical blunder; I don't think anyone truly deep down in their hearts doesn't know this. Sant Jarnail Singh fortified the Akal Takht up to two months before the attack - it was obvious what was coming. A small group of Singhs vs the entire Indian Army, plus tanks, helicopters, etc is ALWAYS eventually going to be won by the Army. The Singhs should have shifted away from Darbar Sahib. Remember that tanks were only brought in (and most destruction caused) when the Army found it difficult to remove the Singhs with just men. We all know the Shaheeds of the 80s and 90s were great but we have to also be realistic - not every thing they did was 100% perfect! If they did then we would already have a Khalistan now!

Re: Question about Khalistan

yahoo · 05 Jul 2005

1) 1960 pepsu division. the run up to 84 hindu fanatics held samagams mocking sikhi using threats. Hindu terrorists like pavan kumnar were allowed to have 10 000 grenades licensed in their name. the first question is a bit unfair as hindus in history had no choice but to back sikhs for their own safety otherwise they would get their chitter bashed by moghuls. Hindus in punjab some used to be sikhs and converted back into hindus when ranjit singhs raj went. The jaat cowards in the cow belt did not even have a religion and try to link themself to saki sarwar following before the samaj plain opportunists to appease hindu ram raj granted to brahmin india in 47. Thus the hindu move was to assert "in the same bed" cow belt jaats with brahmin ram raj position to gain the cow belt favours. However the cow belt itself is now realising the brahmin raj was never interested in the jaat, but to split punjab. Yet the same cow belt is over aggresively patriortic to a country that doesnt favour them. 2) This is the house of arms Our Guru commanded sikhs to bring arms weopons, dashing youth into darbar sahib . what does it proove to say sikhs bought weopons there? Bearing a weopon is no offence defending yourself is no offence. Offence is to stand there silently and watch a whole community raped tortured and not speak blue ji. 3) News leaked out the army (hindu or not in my estimation political) would attack darbar sahib. If somebody is coming to bombard your house what choice have you got but to defend your house with your family inside? Is it arrogant to defend your family and home? Whether Darbar sahib was armed or not would have been attacked as 35 other gurdwaras across punjab were attacked same time. If sant bhindrawala was the main cause then why was he not arrested outside darbar sahib complex on his frequent travels outside darbar sahib, punjab, and even india? why did rajeeb ghandi call sant jarnail singh bhindrawala a saint 3 days before thegolden temple attack? 4) hindus in punjab can do what they want, punjab belongs to everyone but if they are not happy inside it only they can decide what they want to do. Hindu raj in punjab has given us today sponsored multi sects preying on sikhs, water diversions to hindu majority areas turning punjab eventually into deserts. We need a system that favours development of punjab and permits the growth of sikhism. This growth of sikhism has been stunted by post 84 gov oppression with fear of opression lashing across sikh youths to afraid to even live like sikhs. To my estimation hindus in punjab live peacefully in punjab with sikhs, but hindus outside in the cow belt cause trouble magnifieing a sikh hindu confrontation to a level that does not exist in punjab. If khalistan came i am sure hindus in punjab would not do anything. In fact they themselves will support a caste free, corrupt free, egalitarian society that khalsas want to flourish. indians should be ashamed of a lot of things sitting as mere spectators. If your own mother was killed your father boiled alive and your neighbours watched on the merit of being a different religion to you i would like to see how you percieve the magnitude of this silence? [%sig%]

Re: Question about Khalistan

--- · 05 Jul 2005

1. I believe the term communal riot to mean the violence between two different groups. The November 1984 Delhi riots were not a communal riot but outright genocide against the Sikhs. Prior to this in 1978 over a dozen unarmed Sikhs were gunned down at Amritsar whilst protesting against a hertical cult the Nirankaris (funded by GOI). 2. Neither Sant Jarnail Singh or the Indian Governmnet placed weapons in the Golden Temple Complex first, they have been there for centuries. Guru Gobind Singh Ji's muskets lie in the Complex Library, canons and guns from the Misl and Maharaja Ranjit Singh's times lie there too. You clearly need to educate yourself further on the Sikh religion and history. 3. Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji run away from Chamkaur knowing an attack was planned??? What a stupid question, some people never cease to amaze me. 4. If they do not want to live with Sikhs in Khalistan then they can pack their bags and f*** off to Hindustan. Any that choose to stay will be treated like brothers and given equal status.

Re: Question about Khalistan

098 · 05 Jul 2005

Agree with SINGH and --- 1984 riots were not communal but a organized genocide, most experts on south asia agree on that. Also agreed that Karku singh's were not 100% right, the boycut was a blunder which caused the death of lot of singhs and end of the movement. Their need to have a better political approach to this issue along with militancy as no justice can be awaited from Indian Government.

Re: Question about Khalistan

01br45w4ley · 05 Jul 2005

blues ji punjab is different from india. land that consists of punjab from what i read somewhere about 80% is privately owned majority by sikhs in khettivari. hence hindus getting a homeland out of punjab highly unlikely unlike kashmir where sikhs and hindus blatently outnumber muslims in jammu and buddhists in ladakh outnumber muslims hence muslims would only get the valley while hindus and sikhs would get jammu and ladakh for buddhists. The land is not owned by muslim majority outside kashmir valley but punjabi land is majority owned by singhs. Most people in any religion do not have a problem with each other. Sikhs certainly do not have a problem with hindus, but these govs create problems. essentially sikhs have not demanded a homeland for no reason. They have done this after trying to live as equal citizens, then facing genocides against them, financially ruined by indian policies on water, farming produce pay middle man pandit lal becvome bankrupt and starve, police injustices, army injustices, devalued assets from 1947, lack of opportunities many more.... but even if hindus wanted a homeland on what basis? the sikh argument is not on one because we feel we are independant, Sikhs have fought for indias independance defended its borders upto this day, fought 3 wars for indias defence, been its agrarian bread basket, and serves locals in gurdwaras for langar we do not look at the status of religion or social we feed homeless all kinds all over north india, been at the front of disasters in gujrat distributing aid food and water while hindu groups themselves were not willing to help low caste waley. Sikhs have a case on their hands under the united nations resolution. Sikhs have not oppressed hindus so why wold hindus try to make a homeland out of punjab when they will be treated as equal citizens? Although i agree violence is not the answer but if sikhs wished to democratically seperate without use of arms do you object? how could you object when most punjabs land is privately owned by sikhs? [%sig%]

Re: Question about Khalistan

Blues · 10 Jul 2005

Thank you everyone for sharing his or her thoughts. From reading all the posts, here is what I concluded: 1. There has never been a communal riot between Hindus and Sikhs before 1984. Regarding 1984 being an organized genocide, I am not sure about it. For organized genocide to take place needs years of planning. 1984, although wrong, was a mindless reaction rather than a planned attack. Indian government failed its citizens by not protecting them. It is my understanding if there is an intense cultural, emotional and family bound between Hindus and Sikhs. They have lived together for centuries and will together forever. 2. It was Bhinderwale who took the arms inside the golden temple first. Indian army took the arms inside the temple to clear out the siege. I read lots of post blaming that Indian army destroyed the temple and it was wrong to take the arms inside the darbar sahib. Indian army is not a political wing (unlike Pakistan). They did what the Indian government asked them to do. What country will allow a separatist to keep hostage a religion? 3. Bhinderwale and other Sikhs holding the arms inside the temple knew what the outcome would be if they refuse to give-up the arms. May be they miscalculated that Indian army would never attach them. Unfortunately Binderwale wanted to exploit the Sikhs and keep the religion under hostage. He was an ambitious man and did have some thought provoking viewpoints. But for him his arrogance was more important than the sanctity of the darbar sahib. 4. There is no end of the partition. If today Khalistan were carved out of the India, then tomorrow it would be Hindu Punjab from Khalistan. What about Nirankaris? When there is a partition it doesn’t matter if Sikhs or Hindus own land. During the 1947 partition lots of people lost their land. Bottom-line, there is no justification of separate country Khalistan. Both Sikhs and Hindus need to work for the betterment of Punjab and India - that they already are doing. We need to fix what we have rather than creating new entities and fixing them. India is a democratic country where everyone has opportunities - may not be equal. That's what all of us has to work towards - equal opportunities for everyone. Our prime minister is a Sikh, our army chief is a Sikh, our main financial advisor is a Sikh - all these indicates that we are going in right direction.

Re: Question about Khalistan

Singh · 10 Jul 2005

The hindustani government had been planning an attack on darbar sahib even before 82. They had a fake model of darbar sahib which they practiced on. Sant baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa was just a reason they found so they could "justify" the attack by labelling him as a terrorist

Re: Question about Khalistan

Amritpal Singh · 11 Jul 2005

Pray for khalistan Vaheguru VaheguruVaheguruVaheguru VaheguruVaheguruVaheguruVaheguruVaheguruVaheguru VaheguruVaheguruVaheguruVaheguruVaheguruVaheguru [%sig%]

Re: Question about Khalistan

R singh · 11 Jul 2005

You relly think sikhi is going in the right direction!!!!!!!!!! look at the amount of sikhs there are in India. Everyone is mona. I don't believe that sikhi is going in the right direction. After 1984 sikhs are afraid to stand up for thereselves. IT is purly pathetic how ht eindian gov't ddestryoed darbar sahib ad 37 other gurdwara's. i never seen the Italiamn gov't attack the vatican. The saudia arabian gov't attack mecca. Why is it that this is the first time the anyu gov't attacked the Akal takht. A place of religous worship. Were inncocent people came to pray and do drshan of dabar sahib. People are going away from sikhi more and more each day. Why is it so bad the sikhs can't have there own country. Hindu- HINDUSTAN (INDIA), jewish- Isreal, muslims- saudia arabia. Please think about yourself. Why was it that Jewish people made there own country after world war 2. They were being killed in enormous numbers by hitler. And they needed freedom. The 1984 riots how can u say it not originized. How can larg mobs gather over all of dhelhi and start killing innnocent sikhs. children women and men. FATEH

Re: Question about Khalistan

sucha soorma · 11 Jul 2005

putt dont be silly hindus could nver get anything from punjab its plain and simple punjab is jatt territory.

Re: Question about Khalistan

Blues · 12 Jul 2005

"Hindustani government was planning attach since 82" ...this is the most ridiculous rumor I have ever heard. What is government? Who forms the government? It's the people from all walks of life. Its Hindus, Muslims, sikhs ...people from all religion. There were so many sikhs on the top bureaucratic position in 82. 10-15% of top army generals were sikhs. All these sikhs were silent spectators while the "government" was planning the attack. Khalistan is alive only outside of India - in US, UK and Canada. Sikhs living abroad thinks that using their money they would be able to exploit the sikhs living in India. They know they and their families are safe abroad and would rather prefer the sikhs in India to fight the bloody battle. But, I am not sure sikhs in India wants the Khalistan.

Re: Question about Khalistan

Jas · 13 Jul 2005

LOL the so called 'Sikhs' responsible or had anything to do with the massacre of any inocent person is NOT a sikh, Honestly Go and Do some in-depth research into Sikhism And get Your facts straight. also why would any sikh want their felow brothers and sister have their hands tied up behind their backs and shot at point blank...WHY WOULD ANY SIKH WANT THEIR GURUS SCRIPTURES BURNT TO ASH... Thats what happend. you think the people partly responsible are sikh?...maybe by name and image but no by heart. "Hindustani government was planning attach since 82" ...this is the most ridiculous rumor I have ever heard. WHY Is this Ridiculous romuor...EXPLAIN

Re: Question about Khalistan

anmol ratan · 13 Jul 2005

As a hindu jat i have come to know the great deeds done by the sikhs before and after india's independence. The blood flowing in the veins of jats across the jat belt is the same though the hindu jats have lagged behind due to conservatism of the hindu society though they dont give brahmins a damn. I can feel the pain sikhs have suffered after the 84 riots but I personally feel that the religion which espoused the philosophy of "hind-di-chadar" is doing no good by trying to separate the chadar from the body; the chadar and body are meaningful only if they stay together. I think it is time for an active lobbying campaign to punish the perpetrators of the riots of 84 thru suitable judicial intervention. Having a sikh PM in india is the right climate for this thing. While sikh brothers who feel alienated to the idea of india after the barbarism of 84 may tend to see the whole hindu society as enemies this is not a correct picture; we are the same people as evidenced by the saying of the tenth guru who claimed they fought for the preservation of the sanatan religion of india. I am ashamed at the happenings of 84 and would like to apologise unconditionally for the same. It is even more shameful that the perpetartors of those crimes are roaming free in the Indian nation which aspires to attain the equality of humans despite anything. I dont care if the demand for khalistan is there or not in future because i think after understanding the history and sacrifices made by sikhs the whole of india can take up the name of "khalistan" to acknowledge their sacrifices and honor them.

Re: Question about Khalistan

gaddar_sikh · 13 Jul 2005

It is upto Waheguru to decide when the formation of Khalsa raj takes place.But INDIA HAS COMMITED SUICIDE IN 1984.Our Hindu brothers have hatred,intolerance for sikh APPEARANCE(dont have that big problem with clean shaven or those keshardhari sikhs singing at mandirs).THey tried to eliminate SIKHS who stood for them for centuries.So if we believe that Waheguru exists and His Hukum and Justice is infinite,days of Hindustan are numbered.It was never one coutnry and will disintegrate one day. Sikhi has gone through many ups and downs and the last few years have been "down"but its again going up.I am from Punjab and things are improving in the last 1 year.One baba ranjit Singh dadrian wale is doing EXCELLENT work and the present jathedar sahib of Damdami taksal is a good soul too.People are taking amrit.Sikhi will rise in Punjab again because if proper parchar of sikhi starts to happen people will get dissolved in sikhi as its true and the only source of peace in this burning Kalyug. So guys hold on,make ur life of a gursikh and play your part.Leave it to the waheguru when khalistan is formed.His designs are great and true,He will do justice.The kurbani of our Shaheeds wont go wasted brothers.Slaves will be slaves once again as they dont deserve to rule. BOLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE SOOOOOO NIHAAAAL SAT SRI AKAL! KHALISTAN ZINDABAD

Re: Question about Khalistan

gaddar_sikh · 13 Jul 2005

Dear brother Blue You are either a non sikh or a brainwashed sikh youth.There are many like you.There is no point telling you something because people like you dont care to listen.You have lots of ego in ur mind and act clever and knower of everything in ur mind.But brother,you will face the reality during your life time only.WE will rise and we will rule and SLAVES WILL BE SLAVES ONCE AGAIN AS THEY DONT DESERVE TO RULE. KHALISTAN ZINDABAD!

Re: Question about Khalistan

gillmandi · 13 Jul 2005

anmol ratan if the same blood flowed through the veins of the hindu jats then why they cut off their mother tongue punjabi for hindi to make a hindu land from punjabi land?

Re: Question about Khalistan

Jas · 13 Jul 2005

" we are the same people as evidenced by the saying of the tenth guru who claimed they fought for the preservation of the sanatan religion of india". Sorry, but are you trying to say that sikhism abnd hinduism are the same or something? If you think both religions are the same, i Strongley recommend you do some research into sikhism, and DO NOT listen to the SHOCKING LIES being published by ScumBag Hindu Right-Wing organizations, such as the RSS, BJP, SHIV SENA.

Re: Question about Khalistan

**- · 13 Jul 2005

gaddar singh The emotional response that you have written in this post is typical of someone who does not have any sound logical arguements. The type of behaviour you have demonstrated is very much prominent amongst the current Sikh leadership and it is a real shame on the Sikh community. This type of characterisitic results in your position- no matter how genuine your arguements may be - weakening. I think a start maybe to improve your written communication skills. [%sig%]

Re: Question about Khalistan

anmol ratan · 13 Jul 2005

Dear Gillmandi: Am i answerable for everything that took place in india before i was born? Sorry i am not or i will become a wreck; especially i cant answer why certain political outcomes took place. A few extra dollars/rupees in the pockets of sikh jats and the fact that they have been wearing turbans for a few centuries cant deter a poor brother from reminding where our roots lie. It would be against the the egalitarian sikh teachings to create divisions among people of the same fold, sharing the same water and breathing in the same air. I am sure the spirit of the Gurus would be ashamed of what some people in sikh society have been trying to do. I can disown my leaders but not go against the true message flouted by the gurus because of the high regard for their acts which saved the day for hindustan. The tenth "guru" forbid you to follow a living person and follow the teachings of the guru granth only. The very mistake which makes nirankaris your enemies has been unknowingly been adopted by the so called true sikhs of today. Now you have many gurus who teach you things besides those in the guru granth. After nursing the political aims championed by the people heading the seperatist sikh movement can you claim you have followed the word of the tenth guru?

Re: Question about Khalistan

gaddar_sikh · 13 Jul 2005

Dear **- I must say some of you hindus have so much time visiting sikh discussion forums,some of you post as sikhs,try to be cunning and sarcastic and try to distort the facts.You have always been doing like this,thats why you remained slaves and thats why Muslims used the mouth of your ansestors to spit(you have been successful to change your history books so many of you might not know this),your women were also sold in afghanistan markets and you were busy pissing in India. Instead of following your religion Hinduism,you are trying to interfare in others religions,occupy other people area and then claim it to be yours by giving childish excuses like Bharat Ki Akhandata etc.YOu are kids who got rule by luck and now you are behaving like kids.BUt brother,just hold on,ur time will come soon and slaves will be slaves once again. regarding my written communication skills,my first language is gurmukhi(punjabi) and I know that very well and thats the most important thing for me.We people dont run after foreign languages and foreign cultures like you people.These days most of the hindus have become Puuuunnjaabis and sing punjabi songs,alas no culture,confused religion, slave genes. Instead of wasting your and our time on this forum,better go to some mandir and *****admin cut**** May God Save you Amen Khalistan Zindabad

Re: Question about Khalistan

gaddar_sikh · 13 Jul 2005

Anmol Ratan Dont try to have jatt jaat thing over here.In sikhism all are same(though many people dont follow this due to their bad destiny written on their foreheads). There is huge difference between jaats (smoking beris all day)and us.Jatt Sikhs have gone to all parts of the world and have been successful contrary to you ,even with so much help from centre to Haryana you still are backward and jealous of Sikhs. MOst of the jaats have special hatred with sikhs in delhi and then you try to get jatts with you.Sorry we wont take this bluff any more. Go and follow your great religion and worship sexual organs of your gods(with the help of brahmins,I know you people dont like brahmins too) and dont try to bring casteism in our religion. Khalistan Zindabad

Re: Question about Khalistan

gaddar_sikh · 13 Jul 2005

Dear brother Anmol Ratan <> Really?????????? India is aspiring to attain equality of human beings....????????? If Simranjit Singh Maan raises slogan of Khalistan,he is behind bars. If VHP and RSS openly disrespect Sikhism and call sikhs part of hindus in Amritsar,there is no charge against them. 1.Why dont you allow Amnesty international to enter Punjab. 2.Why dont you stop killing innocents in Punjab,Kashmir,Manipur,Nagaland etc. 3.WHy dont your right wing hindus stop raping christian nuns? 4.Why dont you jaats stop using punjab water which is the right of punjab according to Internation law. 5.why doesnt New delhi stop interfaring in sikh religious organisations? 6Why dont you stop giving funds to anti sikh religious organisations like noormahlias,nirankaris? 7.Why dont you stop making fun of sikhs and making jokes on their identity? 8.Why dont you give the right to self determination to sikhs,kashmiris,nagas etc which is the fundamental right according to UN(instead you try to scare people who ask for freedom and soveireinity)? Is this your democracy,is this your secularism? Shame on you and your country. Want to see Human Rights in Great Hinduuuuuustan check this out http://www.maboli.com/Sikh_HR/index.html Boleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee sooooooooooooooo nihaaaaaaaaaaaal Sat Sri Akal Khalistan Zindabad

Re: Question about Khalistan

singh · 14 Jul 2005

>>dont care if the demand for khalistan is there or not in future because i think after understanding the history and sacrifices made by sikhs the whole of india can take up the name of "khalistan" to acknowledge their sacrifices and honor them<< Damm enough respect to anmol ratan.

Re: Question about Khalistan

anmol ratan · 14 Jul 2005

Dear Gaddar_sikh: How much of a sikh is left in you cant be answered after reading your sloganeering which is not suited in this time. Hindu jaats are slaves? of what? We own the land in plenty where we live and we are second to no other caste , so whose slaves we are? The jats of mathura/bharatpur taught "aurangzeb" as much a lesson as shivaji and others; wake up to the egalitarian reality of life as written in your granths. Dont water your soul with hatred as much as it clouds your judgement and sanity. May the gurus grant you some wisdom. Anmol. [%sig%]

Re: Question about Khalistan

Jas · 14 Jul 2005

"The jats of mathura/bharatpur taught "aurangzeb" as much a lesson as shivaji and others;" The piece of history in QUESTIONABLE

Re: Question about Khalistan

someone · 14 Jul 2005

SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JI KHALSA BHINDERAWALE ZINDABAAD KHALISTAN ZINDABAAD dont do nindyia of sant ji i saw it on a few of the messeges saying that it was his fault for taking arms inside Darbar Sahib i no this isnt relevant to the most recent posts but i wanted to say it anyways WJKK WJKF

Re: Question about Khalistan

anmol ratan · 14 Jul 2005

If you go to agra fort the guide tries to negate the struggle waged by Gokul, Rajaram and the hindu jaat clans of Mathura/ Bharatpur who later consolidated to form the kingdom of Bharatpur; the fact remains that agra fort was attacked many times over in a struggle that spread over 80-100 years. You are encouraged to refer to any authentic source that you may trust to confirm this. As far as the sayings of guru govind singh which i have sited have been questioned please do not put me to shame by making a claim that this is true. You should know your religion better than an "outsider". Anmol.

Re: Question about Khalistan

ksingh · 15 Jul 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh gaddar sikh a hindu is apologising and you are writing derogatory remarks against him. i am a sikh living in gurgaon(haryana) and there is no problem for sikhs here. anmol ratan all i want to say thank you and sorry to you [%sig%]

Re: Question about Khalistan

Iqi Tarar · 15 Jul 2005

gaddar singh that is hurtful downright slander and misrepresentation of muslims. There may have been some instances where corrupt moghuls were harsh on hindus by and large muslims did not do these things. Its convenient to forget the good relationship between muslims and hinsu rajputs/ muslim nizams and south indian hindus. As far as i know jatts of punjab and pakistan are the same. Hindus i am not sure about but its what flows on the inside that counts. If a man gives you fellowship what is your problem? this is where jatt muslims are more accepting and liberal to others this is what we are renwoned for. In lahore we are proud of our punjab history. If you do not understand the jatt mentality of our jatt brothers via anmol rattan then do not respond to it. As far as im aware ratan is not a jatt clan but where he is extending his hand culturally possibly with some mistake correct the man for goodness sakes. Jatts are brothers whatever religion they come from. A good number of muslim jatts also do not believe this but a good number do and its what the truth is that matters. Please do not impliucate muslims to commit such horrible acts like spitting into hindus mouthes that makes you no better than sky news and cnn who claim all muslims are terrorists.

Re: Question about Khalistan

Iqi Tarar · 15 Jul 2005

if iz khalastan da senghs want then pakistan and all jatt muslim wish you the best. But common slagging manz off won get it nah? so do something bout it like how you mant to tamek it? 90% of the sikh cut their hair, most ya gurls in club drunk with guys so like how will khalsatn come?

Re: Question about Khalistan

manjh payara guru ko · 15 Jul 2005

dear blue for your kind information amritdhari khalsa have right to keep(sashter)arm.sri guru govind singh ji gave us that right.with that arm(you called)sashter sikhs protected hindu in past as you well know.so indian hindu army took weapon in darbar shib not baba jarnail singh ji khalsa. khalisstan zindabad babar khalsa zinda bad

Re: Question about Khalistan

gaddar_sikh · 15 Jul 2005

Dear IQI TARAR I have met some real good lahore jatts.I was born in a jatt sikh family and yes when it comes to culture and punjabiyat,there is good relation between jatts in both punjabs. But when it comes to religion,a hindu is a hindu and a muslim is a muslim,we wish both of them gud luck but thats it! Some sections of muslims in Uk etc do create differences between sikhs and muslims by targetting young naive sikhs girls(we all know a 16 or 17 year old girl belonging to which ever faith can be misguided).Regarding you saying sikhs cuttin hair and sikh girls drinking,well brother in this Kalyug thats true with every faith and religion. 1.your sheikhs in middle east have multiple wifes and sleep with any women they find appealing. 2.many muslim girls(especially iranian girls brought up in europe)sleep around may be more than european white girls. 2.many muslims youth in west drink,i personally have drank aside muslims. 3.they do adultery too as many of the jatt sikhs etc also do. 4.we sikhs are just 2% of india and during our freedom struggle we eliminated key targets like Indian PM,Indian army chief,Punjab chief minister and many more.YOu in kashmir have not been able to even do something about ur biggest TRAITOR farook abdulla(either u kill innocents or gnererally some poor and badly ****admin cut**** low ranked soldier of indian army). 5.There are more muslims in india than pakistan but still you dont hv any voice and are badly killed in riots by hindus(people whom you treat as cowards).(sikhs were also killed in 84 but that was a genocide,not a riot.Hindus can never dare to have a riot with sikhs as they know their pants will be removed and their arses coloured black and red if they do so,all they can do is attack from behind or attack in a mob) There are many things going wrong wiht muslims and you shud work for it instead of telling sikhs what to do. If you feel that 1 day all 2.5 crore sikhs will become true sikhs of guru and only then we have to form khalistan,its an unrealistic and foolish way of thinking.Yes there is need to be improvement and there are enough blessed souls everywhere who are playing their part. And also to make sikhi strong in Punjab we need RULE.Untill we have rule ,indian central agencies ,indian media will keep on playing dirty tricks inside the table. Regaring the muslims ****admin cut**** poor and SLAVE hindu,thats a reality.You need to read some good hisorians( i dont say historians are some standard we must surely belive but there is quite a bit of evidence).Poor hindus were so badly ****admin cut**** that they were not allowed to go to barber to cut their hair,their women were sold in afghanistan markets(its a known fact).Most rajput(hindu warrior class)gave their daughters to mughals to save their province(aurangzebs mom was a rajput) and most hindus fought among themselves and many of them supported mughals to kill each other.Most of the present muslims in india(there are more muslims in india than pakistan)were once hindus who were thrashed,****admin cut**** and converted to Islam.There has to be some reality into this brother. Take care bro Khalistan zindabad LIVE WITH DIGNITY AND DIE FOR FAITH Sant baba jarnail singh khalsa AMAR raheee

Re: Question about Khalistan

gaddar_sikh · 15 Jul 2005

Its a ****admin cut**** reality that jaats in haryana were the most hostile to sikhs in 84 and after.They attacked in mobs and shaved off beards and hair of sikhs(how can we forget that waheguru..). Yes I agree jaats try to relate with jatts as brothers,but WE DONT WANT THIS BROTHERLY FEELING AT THE COST OF THE SIKHI. Most of the haryana jaats hate Baniyas and they dont even call delhi sikhs as sikhs.They include delhi sikhs as baniya only.DEar sikh broters this is a reality, you can verify it if you want to.Haryana jaats treat our delhi sikh veers as baniya and make fun of them and HATE THEM. These harjana jaats are still holding many shops and properties of sikhs after 84. FORGIVE BUT DONT FORGET MY SIKH BROTHERS AND SISTERS khalistan zindabad "physical death I dont fear but death of conscience is a sure death" Sant baba jarnail singh amar raheeeeee boleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee soooooooo nihaaaaaaaaaaaaal sat sri akal!

Re: Question about Khalistan

**- · 16 Jul 2005

Dear gaddar_singh Chill out man! jah paanee peekeh phir aajanah. Why are you getting so emotional? Your fustration is so apperent that it has taken over your abilty to reason and your intelligence. After reading your posts what do you think Iqi Bhai is going to think of Sikhs now? You should learn a thing or two from Kulbir Singh who is able to articulate his points across in an intelligent manner. You wrote: "Most rajput(hindu warrior class)gave their daughters to mughals to save their province(aurangzebs mom was a rajput)" That is not actually true. It was only the house of Jodhpur that did this act and it was Aurangzeb's par daadi (great grandmother) who was a Rajput princess. She was married to Emperor Akbar - you know; the one who was vegaterian, who would only drink water from the Ganges and who had a Murti of Lord Krishna installed in his palace. [%sig%]

Re: Question about Khalistan

ritesh_malik · 16 Jul 2005

Hey sikh brothers and sisters, this guy Blues is a Punjabi HIndu living in New Delhi,he contacted me via private email and has been discussing all these crap and calling sikhs who demand a separate state as traitors.Dont treat him as a sikh but a compromised and morally corrupt Punjabi Hindu. I have a question for this hindu. 1.If I and some of my friends take some light guns and enter inside mathura, ayodhaya temples,will the Indian Government attack these places with tanks,and bombs on say shivratri when lakhs of hindus have come to visit these places? 2.If sant jarnail singh khalsa had arms inside,was he killing innocents inside?What harm could 50 armed people inside a temple could do unless they are keeping people inside at gun point? 3.Why was the attack planned on one of the most busiest days in the sikh calendar? 4.Why 37 other gurdwarras also attacked?WAs SAnt jarnail Singh Khalsa at those gurdwaras also? 5.WHy precious and irreplacable pieces of sikh history were taken by the army from the sikh library when their objective was to only kill Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa. 6.Many people might not know but few weeks before Bluestar,SAnt Jarnail Singh Khalsa walked from Amritsar to Chandigarh with his followeres.Why was he not arrested then??? 7.Bluestar was not to assasinate Sant JI but to kill the confidence of sikhs(the people who once fought for these people and this country). Khalistan zindabad

Re: Question about Khalistan

Admin · 16 Jul 2005

Thread Closed. No more posts will be approved under this thread. Admin