Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Singh · 17 Sep 2003

Waheguru Jee Khalsa! Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh! http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?act=ST&f=2&t=1152&s=5275649e996521c4adf72a1862f58c5f Please visit the link and read the question put forward. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >WAHEGURU SATNAM > >DON'T U THINK THAT SIKHISM IS DRIVED FROM HINDUISM ? > >"The founder of the Sikh religion was Guru Nanak who was born in 1469" >SOURCE:- http://sikhi.waheguroo.com/ > >BEFORE 1469 THERE IS NO SIKHI? WHAT DOES IT MEANS? OUR ROOTS ARE >FROM HINDUISM? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> I'm sort of confused. Can anyone give a constructive answer with possible reference to Gurbani

Re: Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

fool · 17 Sep 2003

" That Sikhism is not a Hindu sect should be clear to any body who understands what a Hindu sect is and how it arises. Only superficial observers or presumptious non-Hindu scholars [OR ANTI-PANTHIC DUSHTS] airily assert that Sikhism and Sikhs are a Hindu sect. In a recent book (50), its author convincingly argues out that the characteristics that finally and absolutely distinguish the religions of the West and the religions of the East that have "their birth in India," and yet, with the typical self-assurance of a European scholar, fails to distinguish the religions that had "their birth in India," and Sikhism, which even through arising in India, essentially partakes of the characteristics that distinguish the religions of the West. This author points out that the "religions of the West" are (a) anti-idoltrous, (b) prophetic and (c) revelatory, while those of Indian origin are (a) iconographic, (b) introspective and (c) mystical. By this test Sikhism, though born in India is "a religions of the West" in texture and temper, being non-idolatrous, prophetic and revelatory and thus, by implication, a non-Hindu religion. " - page 33 "There is no doubt that, when Guru Gobind Singh declared that the religion which he was finalising and the religion which the Gurus had revealed was the tisar panth, "the third religion," as distinct and different from Hinduism and Islam, aryan and semitic religions, complete in itself and distinct from both of these, aiming at the final synthesis and convergence of both of these religions and cultural streams into itself, it was in this sense that the above assertation was made." - page 34 SOURCE: PARASARAPRASNA by Bhai Sahib Sirdar Kapur Singh (prounounciation phonetic - PAA - RAA - SUH - RUH - PRUH - SNAA) (50) - Zaehner, R.C., The Concise Encyclopaedia of LIving faiths, pp. 15-16. [] - Square bracket commentary by "fool" (me). For more convincing arguments please read Bhai Sahib Sirdar Kapur Singh Jee's writings including Parasarprasna, Sikhism: The Oecumenical Faith, and more.

Re: Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

fool · 17 Sep 2003

by the way the person who posts with the greeting "WAHEGURU SATNAM" there are i think two of them their writings are mostly anti-panthic and anti-gurmat i have strong suspicions they are RSS or something similiar read if you like, but do not believe their writings. their writings have no spiritual, gurmat, scholarly or other basis.

Re: Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Waheguroo! Network · 18 Sep 2003

Sangat Jeeo, We have been tracking the users "pari_singh" and "honey81online" for some time now. They have been posting things that are obviously copied and pasted and are known to be used to try and brainwash vulnerable sikh youth. These types of people are DISGUSTING. We beleive they are most likely part of some radical hindu group such as RSS etc. We have now banned their ip address and will keep a lookout for anymore of this. The user "arash" was also using the same ip as them. RSS is NOT welcome on SikhSangat.Com or ANY Waheguroo! Network site. If you come there, you will be Exposed and banned. We will also be sending your ip addresses and user names to other Sikh message boards to make sure they know who you are. If you DARE come there again and post your anti-sikh propoganda, you will be shut down.

Re: Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Singh · 18 Sep 2003

Waheguru Jee Khalsa! Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh! Sangat Jee, Its obvious that these messages are sent by those with rss links, however can someone give an explanation or an answer. My Understanding: Guru Nanak did parchaar and spread the fragrance of Truth. Those who who were willing to speak, preach and live Truth are Sikhs, no matter what their what their background, sex, religion or caste is. Can anyone again elaborate on this or state whether i am right or wrong. "fool jee" thanks for your message but didn't really understand it. I'm just trying to gain knowledge so that i can stand up and say something against these paapis within and without sikhi who are constantly trying to bring it down. Waheguru Jee Khalsa! Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh!

Re: Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Kamal · 21 Sep 2003

Sikhism is not linked within Hinduism. The question alone is stupid to start with. There is no SIKHISM before GURU NANAK DEV JI. Guru Nanak STARTED Sikhism.

Re: Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

la la la · 22 Sep 2003

kamal, i think ur a little wrong sikhi has always existed - but it was never made into a panth until guru nanak through guru gobind singh made the khalsa

Re: Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

SINGH · 23 Sep 2003

I think the whole concept of a Sikh-ISM is ludicrous. We are not supposed to be this indoctrinated completely centralized bureaucratic faith. Instead we should strive to be SIKH, students seeking spirituality. Now it’s obvious that we do have connections to the Hinduism. Just as Buddhism is connected to Sikhism and just as Jainism is, etc etc etc. We are all part of the eastern philosophies search for enlightenment. We are simply the latest and the greatest of this evolution of spirituality. The end goal of Hindu belief is the attainment of Moksha….or enlightenment…..being absorbed into the creator Brahma. The end goal of Buddhism is to quite one senses in order to achieve a state of complete balance….nirbbana The end goal of Jainism is through mediation reach “God like status” and liberation of reincarnation. Now when I see these faiths and their end goals I see strong connection to many Sikh ideologies. But our ideology does emcompass more and strives for a higher state of spirituality….yet that still does not show that there is no connection and that we have no roots in other faiths. Bani continual makes allusions to Buddist and Hindu Folklore….be it through criticizing or using it as examples, allusions are still made nonetheless. All things are created by Vaheguru…all things are Vaheguru ……The Hindu….Jain….Buddhist….and Sikh Path all are an evolution of spiritual thought.

Re: Sikhism before Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Kulbir Singh · 23 Sep 2003

Singh, You wrote: >>>>> All things are created by Vaheguru…all things are Vaheguru ……The Hindu….Jain….Buddhist….and Sikh Path all are an evolution of spiritual thought. >>>>>> I beg to differ. Sikh Panth is not a result of some evolution of someone’s spiritual thought. This Panth Khalsa has been created by Vaheguru himself under his special orders. He not only created this panth but he also declared that this panth of his Gur-Jyoti – Guru Nanak Sahib will stay till eternity. Here is the pankiti that says so: SIRI GURU RAAJ, ABICHAL ATTAL, AAD PURAKH FURMAAIYO|| The force in this pankiti is unbelievably strong. It is an immensely strong force. Just read the pankiti again. Siri Guru Raaj, Abichal Attal; Aad Purakh Furmaaiyo|| Feel the power this pankiti has. Feel the assurance you get after reading this pankiti. Aad Purakh has declared (Furmaaiya) that Guru Nanak Sahib's raaj is for eternity. Khalsa the child of Guru Nanak should be overjoyed at this. The meanings are so simple. There is no room for misinterpretation. This has been taken from Bhataan de Saviyye. Akaal Purakh himself Furmaa that “Siri Guru Raaj – Abichal Attal” i.e. Siri Guru jee’s raaj, Siri Guru jee’s (Guru Nanak Sahib’s) kingdom is Abichal (not destroyable) and Attal (not movable). Two things are clear from this pankiti: 1) That there is Raaj of Guru Nanak Sahib as per ordination of Aad Purakh – Vaheguru. 2) That this Raaj is forever. In the light of all this, your statement that Sikh faith is merely an extension of other faiths is erroneous. Sikhi is an original faith and not an extension of Islam or Eastern religions. If it had been an extension of Eastern religions, Gurbani would not have rejected these faiths. Two religions – Buddhist and Jain Dharam cannot be compared to Sikhi. These faiths don’t believe in the existence of Vaheguru. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee writes that these two faiths are lowest of all faiths, for they don’t believe in Sikhi. He even goes as far as appreciating Shankrachariya’s efforts in eradicating these faiths from India. Guru Nanak Sahib himself has used the most harsh words when he writes about Jain Dharam. He calls them Shaitaans i.e. apostles of evil. Anyway, coming back to the original discussion, I again ask you “Singh” jee to not consider Sikh panth as an extension of any faith or continuation of any Eastern religion. Gurbani does not support this. Daas, Kulbir Singh