Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
JSGyani "Arshi" · 10 Jul 2005
I must add that for the real true benefit of such sadhsangat...would accrue manyfold if the Kirtan were to be followed by GURBANI VICHAAR. I honesltly beleive the GURU SAHIBAANS did BOTH - Kirtan with raag and Instruments..and then VIAKHIYA-GURBANI VICHAAR. These two go hand in hand. The trend now adays is to let the Raagis have a free hand...they sing shabad after shabad continuously until their allotted time is up. This becomes mere kaan rass only as not everyone is well versed wth GURBANi to know what was sung.
IF a Raagi does GURBANI VICHAAR of his shabad, it is really beneficial...ad we can return home satisfied we have learnt something.
Sometimes when a Katha wachak has time allotted after a raagi jatha..a good Kathawachak will pick up the shabads just sung for his explanations..this then becomes Gurbani Vichaar. A less knowledgeable Kathawachak will stick to his own "prepared rattiah hoiyah" lecture...but thats still ok because that would also be gurbani vichaar albeit of different shabads.
A christian friend who once attended a Gurdwara Programame was surprised by what he saw....he "saw" a "band of hymn singers" doing their thing..and then full stop. He asked me..How does that hymn singing translate to LEARNING...for the congregation/youngsters ?? He also didnt see any classes for the youths/etc etc...as the Diwan ended and langgar began.
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
charanjeev singh · 11 Jul 2005
Dear Arshi Veerji,
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
I whole heartedly agree with you that veechar of the shabad should be done along side with the keertan. I also believe this is Guru Sahibs' teachings, that keertan and katha go hand in hand.
It would be most beautiful if the akhand keertan jatha would also do this; having so many veecharvan gursikhs and not doing katha of the shabad being sung is such a loss to hungry souls.
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
JSGyani "Arshi" · 13 Jul 2005
My take on "Akhand Keertan" is when we have developed so much Pyaar with Guru Ji.... the real Akhand Keertan begins inside us.....the Nectar of Amrit in gurshabd starts dripping from the dasam duaar..dass gets such a sweet taste off and on...looks like my wire to Guru ji is not in good condition yet and sort of "flickers" off and on....but i am getting there.
The other Akhand Keertan of Jatha style that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh ji developed is the Non-Stop JOYOUS KEERTAN of GURBANI that envelops the entire sangat in its Warmth like a blanket...Sudh Budh Vissar Gayee..type of stage..this is actually public practise of the same thing i emntioned in para one above which is personal.
The traditional type of Kirtan where the raagi jatha plays the tunes, sings the Gurbani..and the rest just listen...or participate privately on their own level..is what we see in most Gurdwaras today
The last type i would attend ( if given a choice) is the ***** type of diwan where the katahwachak tells the sangat long tales about this and that..interspersed with Boloh Satnaaaaam waheguru.....Waddeh baba ji kehndeh hundeh san.....Boloh Satnaaaaaaaaaaam...and then a two lines of HOME MADE KAVITA JINGLE that everyone is supposed to sing along..and then more boloh satnaams and waddeh babajis "true stories"....
This is not to deny anyones kirtan or knowledge..I listen to Bhai Pinderpaal Singh Jis Katha regularly, Bhai harjinder Singh jis katha, Gyani kartar Singh, Gyani Jarnail Singh Jis Kathas..and they are good even though i personally dont agree with soem interpretations..but at least they talk on GURBANI, quote Gurbani and Singh gurbani Panktees.
In any case GOOD SANGAT is VITAL....anyone..no matter how HOLY,Naam abhiyassee CANNOT PROGRESS if he stays at home alone...He/she MUST go to SANGAT to participate and grow along.....Listen, Take HOME what is GURMATT, discard what is NOT Gurmatt....and then FOLLOW GURMATT.
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
charanjeev singh · 13 Jul 2005
Taran, Katha is veechar; please refer to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee about the importance of veechar. Keertan and Katha (katha of the shabad) go hand in hand. Without veechar, a sikh cannot be a true sikh. The keertani also must understand the shabad before they sing it; or it is just a ritual then.
Please also refer to the post by Admin. about Guru Amar Daas Jees' Satsangat; where Gursikhs would do Katha of Gurbaani in the presence of Guru and Sangat.
So you should bother because it is the teaching of the Guru.
http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=9877&t=9877
It is not about reading and memorizing. It is about contemplating and realizing.
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
charanjeev singh · 14 Jul 2005
in case you decide to come back amarjeet, please re-read the link. Gursikhs would be doing katha-veechar.
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
charanjeev singh · 14 Jul 2005
I absolutely agree with you ns
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
JSGyani "Arshi" · 14 Jul 2005
Dear Lord Singh ji,
Satbachan Ji.
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
charanjeev singh · 16 Jul 2005
you need english katavachiks to let the english speaking youth know why it is essential to learn Gurmukhi and join in the Panth via the double edge sword.
bhul chuk mauf
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
PARAMPAL SINGH · 16 Jul 2005
WAHE GURU JEE KA KHALSA
WAHE GURU JEE KI FATEH
GURU PYARI SANGATJEE SAT SANGAT ISH LAYE JARRORI HAI. "VICH SANGAT HAR PRABH VASHE JEEO"..SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE SANU DASDE HAN.
SAT SANGAT KARAN NAAL MANN SAHEJ AWASTHA WICH POHOUNCH JANDA HAI. BARR BARR SANGAT KARAN NAAL UKHAREYA HOYEA MANN WAHEGURU PRMESHAR DEE YAAD WICH JURR JANDA HAI.
Re: WHY?? satsangat is important
simple gursikh · 17 Jul 2005
wjkk wjkf
tarran bhenji, The guru katha is highest and no1 can match it i agree with u. however the gurbani was written b ythe gurus who were one with waheguru. that is why until our soul gets to that level we need spiritual guidence from gursikhs and gianis. for example maskeen jee a famous kathadar, translated part of the japji sahib 20 years ago. Then 5 years ago he translated the japji sahib again and it was totally different from the first translation. the sangat asked him the reason for this and his reason was.....As the spiritual soul gets cleansed and a person becomes spiritually pure the translation of gurbani changes. when we get to that stage we wil not need the kathadar from the gurudwara because we have gone far from that stage but until then we need these gursikhs to guide us as gurbani is very very hard to understand. The inner meaning changes as the inner soul changes.
To increase oneselfs spiritual level it is very important not to condenm. look at wahegurus creation, look at the beautiful things that waheguru has created! we need to focus on the postive side of people and forget the bad points, as noone is perfect except waheguru.
A child needs aids to walk(baby walker, parents hand.) because it cannot walk on its own. Once it starts walking stage by stage it gives up the aids.Thats is a perfect example of our lives. we need to get to that stage where we do not require the aids( kathedars).
bhull chuk maaf
wjkk wjkf