Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

i need evidence

i need evidence

k · 16 Jul 2005

where is there evidence that guru sahib tied a dastaar on mata bhag kaur?

Re: i need evidence

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Jul 2005

for what ?? do you need the evidence before you will tie one ?? Do you do everything after checking the evidence ?/ Which "evidence" will pass your standards ?? be elaborate.

Re: i need evidence

Bhudysut · 20 Jul 2005

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh What I have been taught K Ji, is that Mata Bhag Kaur was a great mystic (even before the events of the battle of Khidrana/Mukhtsar). Contemporary reports about Mata Bhag Kaur (or Bhago as she was commonly referred to), say that she would do Naam Abhiaas for days and that she would chant very loudly. So loudly in fact that some villagers were scared of/by her. It is said that it was Mata Bhag Kaur who scolded Mahaan Singh (leader of the then 40 deserters) and gave him a rolling pin, a flour bowl and some bangles and stated that they (the 40 deserters) should stay at home and carry-out the 'womenly' duties, whilst the women folk prepared for battle. As you can imagine, this both riled and humiliated the 40 deserters to go back into battle (led by Mata Bhag Kaur Ji) where they all became Shaheeds and were from that moment onwards known as the 40 Muktay. However before leading the leading the charge, it is said that she had approached Desmesh Pita Guru Gobind Singh Ji and had asked him to change her form from female to male for the ensuing battle. However Guru Ji declined her request stating that her female form was more than appropriate and had nothing to do with her leading others into battle. It is at this moment when it is said that Guru Gobind Singh Ji tied a crown (Dastaar) on Mata Bhag Kaur Ji's head. From here she went and led 40 brave warriors into battle. Mata Bhag Kaur Ji was injured in the battlefield and Guru Ji is said to have personally attended to her healing. When she recovered, she never returned to her own village, and then became one of Guru Ji's own personal bodyguards. She did this up until her death. The spear she used at the Battle of Mukhtsar is still preserved at Sach Khand Sri Hazur Sahib. I understand that this narration may contradict some people's understanding of events, so please forgive if anyone is offended. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Dass Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: i need evidence

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Jul 2005

Dear Akal sahaii Singh Ji..your narration is quite up to the normally accepted version. Thanks.

Re: i need evidence

k · 20 Jul 2005

thanks akaal sahai singh!!!! thtas wicked and to you Jarnail Singh..... Author: Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Date: 07-20-05 06:41 for what ?? do you need the evidence before you will tie one ?? Do you do everything after checking the evidence ?/ Which "evidence" will pass your standards ?? be elaborate. ....................................................... talk about assumptions, how do you know if im a girl or a boy? Sometimes things are based on facts or even stories. Im sorry but you preach to other people all the time but u need to be kinder in ur dealings.. im not being rude..just stating some cold hard Facts

Re: i need evidence

Harvinder Singh · 21 Jul 2005

Veer jee, It is better to have bibian in ur ''own'' tie dastar first before you start bashing others.So I have to say this but the way you talk to others is very rude....very rude.As far as I know you don't even believe in keski as being as a kakkar.......then why lecture others when they have some questions in them to know about it?

Re: i need evidence

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Jul 2005

k.. Talk about assumptions...eh..?? where in my mail did i state that you are a boy/girl/man/woman/lady ?? Cold hard facts are sometimes colder if self applied...anyway chill out man/woman whatever..no hard feelings..reality check sometimes helps people like me too you know... Another assumption you made is that I "preach"...I DONT. I just put MY VIEWS across....I DIDNT PREACH to you to wear a dastaar did I ?? Anyway cool.. I am.

Re: i need evidence

note · 21 Jul 2005

i agree with harvinder singh jarnail singh u are very rude no offense

Re: i need evidence

singhstar · 21 Jul 2005

Jarnail your extremely arrogrant and rude. K posed a perferectly normal question.You came across as very abrupt. you wrote "Do you do everything after checking the evidence ?/ Which "evidence" will pass your standards" Is this how Guru ji would have replied. You have a wealth of knowlegde even you were ignorant at one point, its only through knowlegde you obtain wisdom.

Re: i need evidence

ASengh · 22 Jul 2005

singhstar Could you please call Giyani Jarnail Singh, Jarnail SINGH and not just Jarnail which is just half of his full name. I think calling a Singh by his first name instead of using the full name (Jarnail Singh) is rude.

Re: i need evidence

singhstar · 22 Jul 2005

asengh - who are you to impose ur rules - i dont see you saying jay was rude in his comments -

Re: i need evidence

satwant singh · 22 Jul 2005

my son says he loves sikhi but does not like dastar and after some days he found out a way he would go out with pony tail no haircut he says In sikhi men and women are equall and keski is not kakar.

Re: i need evidence

ssingh · 22 Jul 2005

IOI hahahahahah

Re: i need evidence

ASengh · 22 Jul 2005

Singhstar veer, forgive daas for his dumbness... But can I piont out it was you the one who said 'Jarnail' and not Jarnail Singh, please accept the mistake and learn from it, please could you tell me who is Jay??? :s And veer im not imposeing my own rules, please don't be stupid and say im makeing my own rules, it is respect that one singh calls the other Singh by his full name, ESPECIALY if you don't know them, can I ask do you know veer Jarnail Singh that you call him 'Jarnail.' If I have said anything out of Gurmat someone please correct me. WJKK WJKF

Re: i need evidence

miss HKG · 22 Jul 2005

hahahaha! what an argument asengh..waheguru waheguru waheguru.

Re: i need evidence

charanjeev singh · 22 Jul 2005

waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh ASengh, you have said nothing out of Gurmat as of my understanding. It is Hukam that sikhs refer to sikhs by their whole name including Singh and Kaur. This also applies in the home, and is not a formal calling but a Gurmat Hukam. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: i need evidence

note · 22 Jul 2005

yeah instead of standing up for Jarnail Singh, we should all teach other what's right and wrong . The way Jarnail Singh ji replied was RUDE. No question

Re: i need evidence

Tera Baap · 22 Jul 2005

note wrote: > yeah > instead of standing up for Jarnail Singh, we should all teach > other what's right and wrong . The way Jarnail Singh ji replied > was RUDE. > No question so now u too will sink to his 'level'?

Re: i need evidence

..... · 23 Jul 2005

tera paap you are clearly a racist by the previous comments u made on the other thread regarding papey

Re: i need evidence

singhstar · 23 Jul 2005

teera baap hows he sinking to his level

Re: i need evidence

Gurus Son · 23 Jul 2005

Wjkk WJkf What are u people going on bout, I dont feel Bhai sahib Jarnail singh said anything RUDE. I guess its just the peole that read it who have bad thoughts........so I advise that U look at ur selves before pickin out others....hmmmm Whats the point of havin this posts.....consentrate on ur sikhi and become a beter singh or kaur! I dont have 1% of a idea of what u people are going on bout..... pul chuk maf, dont make it a big deal! Wjkk WJkf

Re: i need evidence

Tera Baap · 23 Jul 2005

sinstar it requires about 10% mental effort and 90% common sense. U have to be able to read between teh lines.

Re: i need evidence

singhstar · 24 Jul 2005

teera baap its not only me look at other peoples posts - when someomne poses a question - you go to handle it the right away. You shouldnt appear arrogant like a know it all - some people come here for genuine advice about Sikhi..u shouldnt be negative in way or scare them off

Re: i need evidence

Tera Baap · 24 Jul 2005

..... wrote: > tera paap > > you are clearly a racist by the previous comments u made on the > other thread regarding papey papay arnt a race u doorknob, first u shud lern prper terminolgy b4 u open ur mouth.

Re: i need evidence

Bhudysut · 25 Jul 2005

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh As per usual, it seems as though certain individuals want to corrupt perfectly good topics and replace them with pathetic individual attacks. This all seem's somewhat sinister to me. Please forgive me, but I find it difficult to believe that individuals using this message board are so sensitive that they feel obliged respond on their apparent sense on soneone talking down on them! Please grow up and accpet any criticism or censure as an opportunity to learn and grow. Finally Tera Baap the statement made above 'papay arnt a race u doorknob, first u shud lern prper terminolgy b4 u open ur mouth' I think is the most immaturist thing I think I have heard anyone say! I would expect something like that from my 6 year old nephew. Please everyone, a little maturity goes a long way. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Akaal Sahai Singh