Did Ram and Krishna exist?
Mehtab Singh · 18 Jul 2005
This is to be treated only as a news piece. Don't turn this thread into another one of those Hindu or Hinduism bashing ones. Its a request.
http://www.khaleejtimes.com/Displayarticle...ent_july455.xml
[u]Did Rama exist? asks textbook[/u]
PATNA — The saying is history can’t be rewritten. Probably that’s why historians and governments go after rewriting history textbooks, triggering controversy each time.
The latest fracas is over the updated Class XI text — Ancient India — written by noted historian R.S. Sharma, who says there is no scientific evidence to prove the existence of “Rama” and “Krishna”.
Yesterday, pro-BJP activists burnt effigies of five Leftist historians — R S Sharma, Irfan Habib, Romila Thapar, Satish Chandra and Arjun Dev — here to protest an attempt to distort facts by negating the existence of “Rama” and “Krishna” and terming Prithviraj Chauhan as a “traitor”.
Sharma defended his take on India’s past. He told TOI on Tuesday that Ancient India was written on the basis of scientific application of history with the strong support of original sources.
http://www.khaleejtimes.com/DisplayArticle...bcontinent&col=
[u]Sharma reiterates stand regarding Ram, Krishna[/u]
KOLKATA — A leading historian has said that there is no historical evidence whatsoever that Ram or Krishna, two deities worshipped by millions of Hindus in India and elsewhere, ever existed.
"Faith is one thing. But hard evidence is another", R.S. Sharma, 82, said after BJP and Sangh Parivar cadres burnt his effigies in Patna, accusing him of insulting Hinduism.
BJP and other extremist Hindu groups are angry with Sharma because his observations shatter their political line that Ram was born in Ayodhya. Now, they have dubbed Sharma a communist not fit to live in India, let alone propagate his views to misguide ordinary people.
According to Sharma, the projection of Ram as one born in Ayodhya and who later ruled it is factually incorrect and inconsistent with facts. "A king needs an army, taxation system and legions of officials to govern his kingdom. There is not even a hint of evidence to show that a king called Ram or an administrative infrastructure ever existed. So where is the question of his birth in Ayodhya?" According to Sharma, archaeological evidence is far more important than the so-called family tree cited in the Puranas scriptures. "So what if Puranic content is being used to date Ram of Ayodhya around 2000 BC. It is not borne out by scientific digging and excavation in Ayodhya by experts", he said.
Making light of the virulent protests by BJP members, he remarked: "They have burnt me when I am still alive. Now there is no need to cremate me if I die tomorrow." Sharma said that the Hindi version of his book on ancient India, Prarambhik Bharat Ka Parichay, was viciously attacked last year by BJP leaders who accused him of taking liberty with facts.
"But they had not even read my book. Some politicians are so busy instigating trouble and dividing societies that they have no time to read or write. All they do is shoot their mouths off", he said.
His book was withdrawn from the NCERT syllabus when the NDA was in power on the grounds that it was the handiwork of a Marxist historian.
I am still wondering why I posted this on a Sikh forum...LOL!
Re: Did Ram and Krishna exist?
Mehtab Singh · 18 Jul 2005
<<< Author: **-
Date: 07-18-05 07:45
Mehtab Singh
These are communist writers. I think you also have them in the Sikh acedemic circles as well. No matter which country they are in, communists are always anti-religion (i.e. as Karl Marx on said: "religion is the opium of the masses").
Give it another thousand or so years, they [commies] will start to say the same thing about the Sikh Gurus.
Sitara >>>
No I don't think so. Because of this : http://www.realsikhism.com/testimonies/atheism.html
Re: Did Ram and Krishna exist?
Kulbir Singh · 18 Jul 2005
I don't have one iota of doubt that Chandervanshee Krishna and Suryavanshee Raam Chander existed. Just the fact that they are mentioned in Dhur kee Baani - Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, proves that they did exist.
In the time they came, they did important tasks. The followers of Sita-Raam and Radha-Krishna must remember that these great men were for Treta Jug and Duapar Jug respectively. They preached and promoted the Dharam appropriate for those ages and times. In Kalyug, one must follow the rules laid down by Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and other 9 Guru Sahibaan.
O Hindu brothers and sisters, Sodh dekho Ved Puraana (check out the Vedas and Puraanas). They talk about going to the true Guru. The true Guru has arrived and has brought the medicine to survive Kalyug. Now is the age for japping or reciting the true Naam. This true Naam is the Aan and Shaan of Guru Ghar only. You must come to the sharan of Guru Sahibaan and obtain the nectarous Amrit Naam from Punj Pyaaray.
Hearing the cries of this world, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee came to this world. Bhai Gurdaas jee has written about this very clearly in his first Vaar. If Guru Sahib had not come to this world, this world would have been destroyed due to the sins that were being committed in this world. The only reason this world is surviving is because of Naam Kamaayee of Gursikhs. Siri Sukhmani Sahib's 16th Ashtpadi and 5th paragraph makes it clear that the whole universe is being held because of power being generated by bhagats who japp Naam.
Under-estimated not, the power of Naam. "Raaj karega Khalsa" is not an empty slogan. It is a factual statement that is bound to come true. Let us work to bring Khalsa Raaj to this world. What you want to accomplish through Raam Raaj can only be accomplished through Khalsa Halemi Raaj.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did Ram and Krishna exist?
Mehtab Singh · 18 Jul 2005
Historians in India had already started penning down history a few centuries before Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Fortunately, every single thing about Sikh history is known to us as history was being written down during the times of the Gurus as well. All the evidences are authentic. But I don't think its the similar situation in the case of Shri Ram and Shri Krishna. Agreed they existed, but no first hand sources from their times are available. Even the scriptures of ALL major religions were interpretted AFTER their prophets, but Guru Gobind Singh Jee went a step ahead of everyone else and explained meanings of Gurbani to Baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji and some other Singhs before leaving His physical body. He is the only messenger from God who actually wrote down His own biography, something NO other messenger/prophet of God ever did. So the notion that future communists will say anything against the Gurus is very highly unlikely. We have communist leaders in Punjab who happen to be Sikhs. Bhagat Singh was also a strong communist. None had anything to say against the Gurus, the reason being that the entire history, the entire explaination of the scriptures, and all of the logic was already available foe all, leaving not an iota of doubt in anyone's mind about anything on which these guys could raise a finger.
Re: Did Ram and Krishna exist?
Kulbir Singh · 19 Jul 2005
-----------
It is well known that in the Itihasas (Mahabharat and Ramayana), Puranas and Vedas; deity worship, astrology and yagnas (havans/artee) is encouraged. Do you therefore agree that these were or part of bonafide methods of reaching VahiGuru in the other kalpas (ages) - except Kali-Yuga?
------------
I don’t think the methods you have mentioned above are bonafide methods of reaching Vaheguru. Deity worship is the worship of a deity i.e. a Devta or a Devi. Worshipper can reach only the level of worshippee (one being worshipped). If one is worshipping Agni Devta or Indra Devta, one can only reach the level of that Devta and cannot reach Vaheguru, who is above all Devtas and Devis.
Yagna or Havans again are a method of worshipping Deities. Hence one cannot use this mean to reach Vaheguru. In order to reach Vaheguru, one has to be targeting Vaheguru for worship.
You have misunderstood my original post. I did not mean that the means used in other yugs were bonafide. I meant that given the circumstances and probably the master plan of Vaheguru, the Dharma that the people of Treta and Duaapar used, under the guidance of spiritual teachers of that time, was appropriate for that age. Vaheguru intended only that much for that jug. For Kalyug alone, Vaheguru has planned elevation of beings from lower planes like Baikunth, Shivpuri, Brahmapuri etc. to Sach Khand.
-----------
My second comment is that it is well known fact that regardless of secterian differences, Hindus, in general, consider the Vedas and their associated literatures as the highest authority. [That is the main reason that you seldom find them performing puja to Buddha becasue even though he is considered an Avatara, Buddha rejected the Vedas]. Do you have the Sanskrit Slokas (i.e skandas, chapters and text numbers as well) to back up your claim. The reason I am asking is because I have seen scholars from other religions say the same thing. But when they quote specific verses they are usually taken out of context and are distorted when translated in order to suit their objectives [examples include: Dr Zakir Naik (Muslim) and Dr Zacharias (Christian)].
------------
First of all, you are mistaken that Buddha (Sidhartha) is recognised as one of the 24 (Chaubees) Avtaars. That Budh is different from this Buddha and the story of that Buddh Avtaar is written in Chaubees Avtaar translation by Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee.
---------
I also believe that the only way you are going to convince Hindus is to first convince the Brahmin scholars in places like Kashi, Beneares and South India etc. Then you will need to take the bold step of convincing Hindus that Sikhi is not opposed to Hinduism but rather a part of it, otherwise you will find only a handful of Hindus will adopt the Khalsa rehit. This is Kali-Yuga everybody (including Hindus) think that their path is right and so they will be too proud or unwilling to accept that their belief system is outdated, as you put it.
----------
There is no need to convince anyone from Kanshi or Mathura. They are not going to heed to simple debates. Just as the just Matt (religion) of Shankracharya wiped out evil atheist Buddhism from India, same way Khalsa Panth will be adopted by all residents where Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee did his udaasis. The travelling of Siri Guru jee will bring fruit and very soon. Raaj Karega Khalsa.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did Ram and Krishna exist?
Kulbir Singh · 20 Jul 2005
Sitara jee,
------------
This is merely your opinion based on you beliefs as a Khalsa Sikh and I respect that. But in Bhagavad Purana [Skanda 7, Chapter 5, verses 23-24] Siri Prahlaad Maharaaj lists this as one of the nine essential processes for Bhaktee (archanam). Incidentally, the story of Prahlaad and NaraSingha avataar is mentioned in the SGGS.
-----------
The beliefs that I wrote are not my opinions and my opinions don’t matter. It is written in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee that dharams of previous jugs are not valid in Kalyug. Jatt, Sanjam and Teerath etc has been rejected in Kalyug. In Kalyug, only valid mean is “Kal meh keerat Har Naama” i.e. Naam Japna.
---------
Regarding the worshipper being able to reaching the level of the one being worshipped – this is correct, but only for demigod worship. But isn’t this similar to what happens to GurSikhs when they merge with VaheGuru?
----------
I don’t know what you are saying here. My point was that the worshipper can reach only that level that his or her worshippee is. If you worship Agni Devta, the greatest you can become is reach where Agni Devta is. If you want to be with the Supreme God i.e. Akal Purakh, you have to worship him then. You can’t reach Vaheguru by worshipping Agni, Indra or Brahma.
------
This is not techincally true. There are sects within Hinduism who believe that God is formless and decry idol worship and the worship of Devi/Devtas – similar to Sikhi.
--------
Excellent point and I have respect for the sects who worship formless God. Followers of these sects go very far in getting close to Vaheguru but they too cannot reach the pinnacles of spirituality i.e. Sach Khand and be with the supreme God without the aid of the true Guru. This is a declaration in Gurbani that only through the true Guru, one can reach Vaheguru. Truth cannot be two. Truth is always one. There are not two Gods. Same way there cannot be two Satgurus. There is only one Satguru and only if one falls in the Sharan of that Satguru, one can reach Vaheguru.
---------
A classic example of this is the Arya Samaaj movement founded by Dayanand Saraswati. They base their beliefs purely on the four Vedas (i.e. the Rig, Yajur, Sama and Artharva Vedas).
----------
Arya Samaj movement is a very confusing movement. They consider Parmaatma, Aatma and Sansar as Abinaashi (eternal). I don’t know how true this is. Yes Aatma and Parmatma are eternal but this world is not eternal. This world was created, so it cannot be eternal.
I have read Satyarath Parkash and found Dayanand Saraswati’s knowledge phenomenal and many of his criticisms of Islam and Christanity are very true but he went crazy and even criticized the Sikh faith in his book. His criticisms are all ill-founded and have been duly answered by the Sikh scholars. He has used derogatory terms for Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee.
On the one hand Arya Samajis believe in formless God but on the other hand they perform Havans to please Agni Devta. This Gorakhdhanda is beyond my comprehension.
-------
Now this is the biggest problem I have with your version of Sikh philosophy. I simply cannot understand why the all-merciful VaheGuru would deny millions of people, thousands of years before the advent Guru Nanak, the opportunity of spiritual success.
---------
There are some things that you and I cannot understand. The ways of Vaheguru are unfathomable. It is not a must that we understand everything.
And Vaheguru is merciful but he also has a plan. Remember one thing. This is his khel. He is passionate but still this world is a khel for him. Just as a kid makes houses of sand on the beach and then destroys those houses without any remorse, same way Vaheguru has created this world many times and has pulled it back many times.
And Vaheguru has not denied the opportunity for spiritual success to others. All the great men of the past have taken janam in Sikh panth. Many great men in Sikh panth are rishis and great men of previous juggs.
--------
Buddha, the founder of Buddhism, is an avataar. This is confirmed in numerous literatures such as Bhagavad Purana, Bhavishya Purana and the Gita-Govinda written by Jaidev. But were are now going off the topic here.
-----------
How can an atheist be an avatar of Vishnu? Explain that. Did Vishnu take birth to spread Dharam or to destroy it? Buddhist Dharam is an atheist movement that cannot be classified as a religion. The Budh Avatar of Vishnu is someone else and I will write down his details soon.
--------------
Kulbir Singh, you said “ O Hindu brothers and sisters, Sodh dekho Ved Puraana (check out the Vedas and Puraanas). They talk about going to the true Guru.” You still have not managed to provide any verses whatsoever. Also I thought that Guru Gobind Singh said:
mahai na ganasai pritham manayao kisan bisan kabhoo na dhoayoo
raam rheem puraan kuraan anaik kahain mathe aik na manyaoo
And also didn’t Guru Gobind Singh state that Parsar Muni, SukhDeyv and Vyas created false scriptures and false religion. So you are therefore asking Hindus to consult a false scripture to validate that Khaalsa Dharam is the way forward. This seems very illogical.
-----------
Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee said that he does not subscribe to Koran, Bible, and other books of Middle East (all these books called Kateb) and similarly he does not look to Ved, Puraans and Simirites for spiritual guidance. I don’t see how this contradicts the early statements of other Guru Sahibaan that tell Hindus to refer to their own scriptures and realise that the Dharam of Kalyug is to come to the true Guru and Japp Naam. Here is a verse that I can remember on top of my head. I can produce numerous verses from Gurbani that are calling out to Hindus to come on the right path:
[gurbani]chu jugw kw huix inbyVw nr mnuKw no eyku inDwnw ][/gurbani]
chahu jugaa kaa hun nibaerraa nar manukhaa no eaek nidhhaanaa ||
Now in Kalyug, there will be NibeRa or settlement of Dharma. For all humankind there is only one treasure (Naam) worth going after.
[gurbani]jqu sMjm qIrQ Enw jugw kw Drmu hY kil mih kIriq hir nwmw ]2][/gurbani]
jath sa(n)jam theerathh ounaa jugaa kaa dhharam hai kal mehi keerath har naamaa ||2||
Celebacy, Sanjam (self discipline) and pilgrimage were the Dharma of previous ages (yugs); in Kalyug there is only one Dharam and that is doing Keerat of Vaheguru through the true Naam.
[gurbani]juig juig Awpo Awpxw Drmu hY soiD dyKhu byd purwnw ][/gurbani]
jug jug aapo aapanaa dhharam hai sodhh dhaekhahu baedh puraanaa ||
Every Yug had their own Dharam; check out Ved and Puraan to confirm this.
[gurbani]gurmuiK ijnI iDAwieAw hir hir jig qy pUry prvwnw ]3][/gurbani]
guramukh jinee dhhiaaeiaa har har jag thae poorae paravaanaa ||3||
Only those individuals who indulge in Naam, through the true Guru (Gurmukh), are accepted in this Yug.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did Ram and Krishna exist?
Bhopinder Singh · 20 Jul 2005
i agree with sharma ji finally pandit ji is looking at the reaility off ganesh and hunoomam
Re: Did Ram and Krishna exist?
stupid question · 20 Jul 2005
When Bani refers to japping 'naam', is this repeating Waheguru or do other things fall under japping naam?