Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Would MORE sikh organsiations increase the sikh delusions?

Would MORE sikh organsiations increase the sikh delusions?

Dr G Singh Kulim; · 19 Jul 2005

....there appears to be a grandoise delusion, among some UK sikhs that the more Sikh bodies are the more the numbers of Sikhs will increase...certainly continues to live in the beseized mentality of individuals....such is the clamour by individuals living in a cocoon from the real world of politics. With such deluded individuals,I beg to disagree with the claim that many fragmented organisations are good for Sikhs, who number no more than about 500,000.The Englsih comparison will just not hold . There are 45 million English people,and it is impossible and hardly practical that they can be served with one organisation or even two or three.Despite that, and their number of organsiations, a number of SIMPLE points or values,hold them together,hold their organsations within an organsied brief of order, not the number of organisations -who have all enshrined the relevant points/values and principles into their own agendas with intent to serve the community. The 1066 declaration of union in this nation was the result of long time bonding and cohesion of the BRITISH people, which when searched for in Sikhs, is totally absent , not forgetting that we are only at the most as claimed by many, with no supported evidence to number about 700,00.0, The bonding as similar to the English is missing totally,despite many shared cultural values and views of the Sikhs.I do not wish to infringe into another area, but the fragmentation of Sikhs and their gurduaras based on castes and religious differences among so called sects of Sikhism are ample evidence of the fragmentaion of the Sikh power and ability, and the negative results as such. Since the declaration in 1066, the level of maturity among the English has been woven so strongly, that under the current wave of differences of views and political affiliations , a number of issues like the monarchy, the parliamentary process,that the Englishman's home is his castle,that the law is for the ordinary man on the street, and democracy at its best is ingrained and accepted without any chance of argument within the English, and for that matter despite the call for limited self rule; even by the Scots and Welsh.No such comaparable maturity and level of loyalty to a certain central organisation exists within sikhs. Even the central code of sikhi is constantly under question by sikhs themselves.There is no uniformed agreement or ingrained understanding even under the different affiliations to organisations or political thinking about the basic principles that matter in sikh community, without any doubt of their intentions. For example,when confronted by external threats ,one e.g. that of the French turban case, the different views and interpretations and approaches shows up the cracks within the community, where claims and counter claims by different individuals and organisations have in actual effect weakened the sikh thrust into the french arena, or made any impactupon the french government of public opinion to make any difference.Quite the contrary many different versions and declarations have been seen forth comming both from the Sikhs and the French, and the situation has not improved one iota, more likely that it has worsened when flies like certain self made chairs of human rights have been falunting themselves more for self prestige than for a panthic notion and aim. In another contrast to the Sikhs, the English have under the vast multi flow of political patronage a close number of priniciples that binds them , and binds in maturity, even as many of these remain the unspoken values of the Englsih mentality and culture.The English political maturity supports their general values, and their form of democracy supports the existence of many more organisations than the smaller sikh population could accomodate to support. Their maturity in the art of democracy and willingness to discuss openly the PROS and CONS of any situation, provides and actually helps in flourishing of many more organisation,because under it all, the core values are strongly underpinned by them. This is totally absent in Sikhs,and to complicate many of the Sikh organisations are totally confused about their values and objectives and that combined with confused political and confused allegience loyalties does more harm and confusion than anything positive. Sikhs given the inability to accomodate the westminister style openess and democracy are simply not geared to think like the English, but more like the regional, tribal and narrow political and lately the newly emerged dera politics that have also destroyed the sanctitry of the Akal Takhat.The 'sarab uch' Akal takhat has become a pawn in all these intricate back stabbings and manipulations of organisations and individuals, by the very sikhs themselves, who individually and often in group of three to five claim every and each to be the sole representative of the Sikh view point. The values of democracy may have been learnt by the Sikhs ,and are practised often, but certainly not mastered just as yet, or as the English.The fact they hhave not mastered, is seen in the poor third rate gurduara politics practiced by sikhs in most Gurduaras-where any discussion is likely to concluded with the use of dandas ,even in the darbar sahib, with no regard to the Living Guru sahib-Guru Granth Sahib Because of such the defrgamention, organisations cannot be healthy and positive , or at the most are certainly not delivering at the pace they should, given the numbers and money power of the sikh community. For a small community, to ensure some power weilding muscles, the lesser organsiations there are , the more healthier it is to engage with the powers be, to barter for positive action and a recognised role.It is also easier to facilitate for the powers to be to dispense their own duty towards the community, that makes powerful one voice one representation impression upon them. The multi organisations may be beneficial to work within the community, but certainly to barter with outside power a united base and projection is sensibly more important and impressive. Hence we see the EU, within own countries with own governments, but fighting the threats of trade with powers from outside as one EU entity! Sikhs while hereditarilly seeking their own home grown political intricacies,must learn to represent as ONE Voice. The fact we are not taken seriously enough,but only a number of muslim organsiations are dealing with the government and being taken more seriously shows a pointer from which we should learn. The excuse our numbers do not count are old and unsubstantiated.Encouraging is the fact groups like APPG are a positive start, also means we need to start looking more united and assertrive with ONE voice, rather than continuing with our antics of more organisations than Sikh numbers.Otherwise we will continue to loose the plot. More later , Gurcharan SINGH Kulim, Dr

Re: Would MORE sikh organsiations increase the sikh delusions?

Billa · 19 Jul 2005

i agree with mr kulim. Sikhs must rise above all their differences, as much as this seems a repeated mantra it is not effective until uniformaly in the present amongst factions give way to larger bodies. I like to model on the idea of the new afghan regime. Prior to that afghani tribes fought daily battles that really sadden me. Thank you to the loya jirga union allowed a large group representing all parties under a coallition headed by a sensible leadership. maybe sikhs could work on somethingof that effect. The grass may look green on our side but us muslims have our fair share of problems too. But so much can be achieved double treble quadrauple when people unite to speak. They need to first decide what it is they want. Numbers sikhs do not lag behind much. 700 000 is a very big number, but the groups liasing with british authorities need to determine how they represent rally under one banner this 700 000 figure. I do believe the potential is there for sikhs to have a lot on their plate if they really are one group. Maybe the sikh leadership needs to work on building more bridges between sikh groups so they strenghten and work for one agenda. warmest wishes to sikhs from pakistan [%sig%]