False Representation of Sikhism in U.S. School
Singh · 21 Jul 2005
It seems this nonsense is beginning to spread. http://www.sikhnet.com/sikhnet/discussion.nsf/All+by+Date/D5D13B2423054DE48725704300783CF7!OpenDocument I have a question and what I think is a problem with a school teacher,any help and facts you can give me would be appreciated. Several times a year I go to visit my sister who lives in another state;when I visit I care for my nephews after school and help them do their homework.My oldest nephew is 13 years old, and in a private school where there is a course available on world religions.At the end of last school year, the teacher came to a discussion of Sikhism, and my nephew came home with some information from his teacher that was a big surprise to me-the information was supposedly about the Sikh religion,and some rituals. The teacher, who is from India, gave out a photograph he said he obtained from a website of a ritual sacrifice of a goat, and he claims that this is a ritual of Sikhism.All you can see in the photo is a picture of the lower part of a man's beard and his arm and hand.The arm has a blue color sleeve.The teacher apparently told the class that the Sikhs always sacrifice a goat at their major religious holiday.The teacher also told them that Baisakhi is celebrated with feasting and drinking ( meaning alcohol).The printed material the teacher gave out to the class also said that Sikhs do not accept conversion to their religion, and that they are not permitted to associate with people of other religions, and that no one from another religion can enter Gurdwara. When I was in college over 20 years ago, I made the acquiantance of many Sikhs, and all of them that I knew were vegetarian;I was invited to several holiday celebrations at the homes of my friends, and never even heard of such a ritual.I was never served anything in a Sikh home but a vegetarian meal.All the Sikhs that I have known did not smoke,or drink alcohol.I told my nephew that his teacher was wrong,and then went to my sister and showed her the information her sone received in school. In college I studied religion, and the department of religion at the college had courses in Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Christianity ( which was my major field of study), but had no Sikh religion classes.The same was true at the institutions where I attended graduate school,so my knowledge of Sikhism is limited to my own personal experience and what I have been able to learn on the internet and some very few books.I can say that what I have been able to learn does not support my nephew's teacher in any way,and I take a very dim view of someone trashing another religion on purpose,especially when that person is responsible for teaching children. My sister is quite upset about this teacher giving that terrible photo of a sacrificed goat to her son, and she complained to the school, but the head master has insisted that this is just a "fact" and that children see worse in movies!The headmaster will not agree to tell the teacher to change his lesson plan unless he sees something that comes from a factual source to indicate that the teacher is wrong.The attitude here is that since the teacher is Indian, he should know everything about every religious group that is present in India.The headmaster has also treated my sister and her husband as less than equal as she is a housewife and he a blue collar worker. School starts for my nephew at the end of next month, and at that time, I will once again be visiting.My sister has already made an appointment to go to see the headmaster of the school with her( although he doesn't yet know that I will be with her) as she thinks that he will respect another "academic"(I think he should respect the tuition paying parents whoever they are).When I go I want to be "armed" with the correct information about Sikhism. I hope that my request here does not give offence to any of you, it is genuine,and sincere.I have read about the attacks that have occured on Sikhs since 9-11, and I am horrified and sorry that ignorant people do such things, especially in the USA.I come from a conservative Christian family of middle eastern heritage;the women have always covered our heads and dress modestly in accordance to what we believe is biblical instruction,even though I was born in the US, I follow the same custom.Two weeks after 9-11, for the first time in my life, I was spit on by a man while walking down the street.There have been several other times since then when I have experienced racist remarks and behavior from people who I suppose take me for being Muslim. I do not know why this teacher is telling these children such things when he is hired to teach facts about world religions, not trash world religions.I can say that I did look over the materials my nephew received on Islam, Buddhism and Hinduism, and they are all factual and correct to the best of my knowledge;this is what leads me to believe that this man has done more than just commit an error of ignorance. Please recommend any books, films, whatever sources YOU as a Sikh think are the best for teaching someone the truth about your religion. Thank you in advance for your help.