Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

singh · 24 Jul 2005

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khaalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh I was speaking with a purtaan and kamae vaahn Singh this morning after amrit vela. The discusion of youth camps cropped up after i asked him to attend a camp with me. He stated that Bhai Sahib was very much against mixed sex camps and has stated in one of his books - he could not recall which one - that youth camps should be single sexed only. I would be interested to learn the views of the Tapobaan Singh's on this. Especially since i understand that mixed sex camps occour at Tapobaan and also Tapobaan has sent Singhs to attended camps abroad as well. Rather than having people respond with their thoughts please only post on this thread if you have a Gurbani or factual based response. Hopefully some of the Singhs will respond to clarify this point.

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

Singh · 25 Jul 2005

Interesting. can someone plz reply?

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

search for tat · 25 Jul 2005

The majority of youth that are coming into sikhi are males. If you do not have mixed sex camps, then the education available to bibian would be very poor. I think some people need to look at the bigger picture. We interact with all sexes at work, school, etc. Kaam can come at any time, why just at camps? We need more bibian in sikhi as they are the mothers of the future generation.

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

dog · 25 Jul 2005

i agree with "search for tat". if one attends a single sexed camp then may find it hard to adjust when surrounded with the opposite sex or may not not know how to react. mixed sex camps are onli dodgy if you make them so. even, for instance at rhensbai's alot of dodgy mixed sex interactions take place.does mean, that rhensbais should be made single sexed, and hey this even happens at the gwara.so how far are you willing to go? Mixed sex camps are brilliant in picking up on viewpoints from both males and females.both sexes learn an awful lot from each other. i would like to know in which book bhai sahib rhandhir singh stated that mixed sex camps shouldnt be attended, as bhai rama singh ji had no objection to them-he attended a huge number.

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

vivek · 25 Jul 2005

please give the book an page number where bhai sahib says he's against mixed sex camps

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

apple · 25 Jul 2005

yeh

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Jul 2005

I agree with Search-for-tat. This would betaking a very narrowminded view and discriminate agaisnt bibian who already have so little parchaar among them. And where is the SANT-SIPAHINESS in "running away" from the Kaam..Gurbani teaches us to be like the Lotus in the MUD...not aLOTUS on Top of Mt everest.

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

. · 25 Jul 2005

very true not alot of girls come into sikhi simply because of the fashion aspect i've spoken to many girls in india asking why they do not choose to follow sikhi most say they are attracted to monai the type they see on tv the heros and also because they would not be able to cut their hair wear fancy clothes etc. basically i believe if we had more gursikh bibian we wud have more singhs because thats the reason alot of guys are cutting their hair to please the girls

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

Daas · 25 Jul 2005

I have been going to camps for a few years now. I have been seeing a lot of boys and girls been flirting with in guru ghars. So I personally think that we should have seperate camps for each gender. This flirting distracts them from learning. So i agree 100% with bhai sahib! A singh should'nt even talk to singhnis, unless its you sister or counsin. Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa, vaaheguroojeekeefaateh!!singh wrote:

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

anony · 25 Jul 2005

LOL dodgy, my camp experience has confirmed that camps you learn alot but the youth motive is dodgy. the majority of the youth are there to make "friends"/contacts. its a shame and u know its a certain group who are doing it and making yonger ones think its acceptable. It like saying its fine to do this so that u can sleep with a clean concious as "everyones doing it" Its sad but its true. Sevadaars might try there best but the older youth they get involved seem to be in on it. soooo i dunno wot u can do. [%sig%]

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

apple · 25 Jul 2005

"A singh should'nt even talk to singhnis, unless its you sister or counsin." hmm.i think not. maharaj sez treat all singhnis like your sisters, mothers, grandmothers..... not..stop talking to all singhneeas.

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

story teller · 25 Jul 2005

Orginal poster 'Singh' Jee ... i to date have not come across anywhere in Bhai Sahibs books that camps should be single sex etc. If someone has bad intentions they will have them no matter where it is.. be it at a camp, Gurdwara, Walking down a street. Camps are a source of education... just like School/College etc are. If we can have mixed sex schools and Khalsa Colleges.. whats wrong with mixed sex camps? We are not Muslims... we live in the real world and fight the 5 theifs.. we have the ultimate weapon against these theifs.. Gurmantar. [%sig%]

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

Kulbir Singh · 25 Jul 2005

I have read in the book called "Singhaan da Panth Niraala" that there should not be co-education schools. Bhai Sahib writes that contrary to our Tehzeeb (civilization, culture), they are opening co-education schools and colleges in Punjab. He writes that these co-education schools have trampled the izzat (dignity, self-respect) of many Sikh Sardaars because their daughters and sisters and getting into "Khuliyaan yaariyaan" (open boyfriend girl friend type relations). Bhai Sahib has not written about camps but he has written about schools and colleges where there is co-education. In Punjab, in those days and still to this day, many schools and colleges are not co-education. There are many women only or men only colleges and schools there. I personally favour such insititutions which don't allow mingling of opposite sexes. We are already witnessing a disaster at Kirtan Samagams, which are serving as "hook-up centres" for some youth (by far not all, just a minority, but it is growing). They go to kirtan samagams and then go downstairs to langar halls to meet up. It is the responsibility of organizers to ensure that such 'khuliyaan yaariyaan" don't happen in the samagams they organise. To just sit in kirtan with closed eyes and not monitoring your responsibility is no Bhagti. Before Sikhi, there were many Tapees who used to segregate themselves from the world to do tapp. Gurmat has introduced a complete human who not only does bhagti but also carries out the required social responsibility. It is important to do Naam Abhyaas and Kirtan but if you are the organizer of a samagam, then it is your duty to ensure that such "badmaashiyaan" don't happen in the samagam you organize. It is more the fault of organisers than the innocent youngsters who make these mistakes. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Jul 2005

vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!!! i agree with bhai kulbir singh ji's post having attended camps held by west coast sikh youth alliance for the last 6 years, i have seen many individuals flirting with each other and many young girls and guys leaving camp only to get involved in temporary infatuation and girlfriend/boyfriend relationships that leave them confused, upset, depressed, and disconnected from sikhi. this is not the desired outcome from a week at a sikhi camp! unfortunately even some of the counselors have had issues of their own as far as infatuation / kaam and if the counselors themselves don't keep rehit / do nitnem / keep kes / or can't keep their mind on the camp instead of on the opposite gender, how will they help the campers? on that topic i think such organizations for singhs / singhnia should have more than one camp each year and more naam-abhyaasee gurmukhs should take part in it. the more rehitdhaaree naam abhyaasee gurmukhs take part in it, the better the quality of the camps will be in the future. i like the idea of kaurs united camp hosted by guru nanak academy, and other such camps, where singhnia strengthen their faith in sikhi without the social pressures of impressing the opposite gender. the same type of camps should take place for singhs. how about a singhs united? hehe.. vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!!!!!

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

Daas · 25 Jul 2005

"maharaj sez treat all singhnis like your sisters, mothers, grandmothers....." Yes thats true. But you get some people out their who can't control their lust. So isnt it just best to avoid them? I am sorry if I offended anybody Phul chuck maaf Vaaheguroo jee khaalsaa, Vaaheguroo jee kee Faateh!!

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

charanjeev singh · 25 Jul 2005

Have to agree that having seperate camps is a good idea. Where social activity takes place, seperating the sexes is a good idea; however this must never happen in the Gurdwara. Unfortunately, we have some people who do not have bibek buddhi, and after certain rules are enforced and becomes a norm (seperate camps, schools, etc.) they might start saying, oh we should also seperate the saad sangat. This should not happen. So hopefully as a panth we have bibek buddhi and be able to discriminate through Gurmat principles, and not personal views. Unfortunately, today, we have people who people treat as Gursikhs, but in reality have lost fundamental principles of sikhi. I believe we should all become better Gursikhs ourselves through the guidance of Guru Granth Sahib Jee and Rehat Maryada, and never need to look to others for how to dictate ones life. Having seperate camps, excellent idea. Seperate schools, excellent idea. If this happens, i am confident there will less emphasis on fashion and trying to impress others; and that would lead to concentrating on ones own life; and that would lead to better people. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

-------- · 26 Jul 2005

totally agree with chiranjeev singh. having separate camps will reduce fashion competition.

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

search for tat · 26 Jul 2005

what would be next then, separate rainsbhais? spearate akhand paths? At what point would you realise that you as a individual need to act as a responsible Gursikh, and treat all like sisters, mothers and daughters. You cannot ran away from problems, you have confront them.

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

singh · 26 Jul 2005

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khaalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh Thanks to Bhai Kulbir Singh and his post. As expected there are only two posts based in factual or Gurmat evidence rather than personel opinion. I agree with Bhai Kulbir Singh in that it is the responsibility of the organisers to control matters. However Bhai Sahib Ji must have wrote what they did for a reason. Therefore will Tapoban re-think thier stance on mixed-sex camps? What is wrong with having a male only camp followed by a female only camp. You may even get more bibia into sikhi rather than less with more parents preapred to send ther daughters!!!!!! Perhaps the Tapoban Singhs can write about thier experiences at the UK camps and if 'khuliyaan yaariyaan' occoured. If it did are they going to attend again this year????

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

rain drop · 27 Jul 2005

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji is certainly correct, when he points out the wrongs of co-education ( and for that reason, problems of Co-camps). But society has changed a lot after Bhai sahib Ji. Role of women have changed. Guru Nanak has given no idea of separate sangats. "Tara Rani goes for ren sabhai kirtan alone at mid night" (ref. Bhai Gurdass Ji). Our approach should be very practical. If both together, learn & yearn nothing about Gurmat, try them separate. If organisers are confident about the motives & results; they can move on with Co-camps.

Re: Camps and Bhai Sahib's Advice

reality check · 27 Jul 2005

'singh' next time your at school or college can you please write about the experiences you had and if 'khuliyaan yaaruyaan' occoured... and if they did, will you be attending school or college again?