Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

Blackblueandorange Singh · 24 Jul 2005

i hav been told that panj pyare are panj pyare are regardless. "panj are panj even if they say you can eat meat" some 'panj' say - you can eat meat, - you dnt have to do isnaan nitnem, jus do moolmantre - you dont have to wear panj kakkar - all you have to do is meditate on god to me this is rubbish, panj pyare must be 5 amritdharee singhs who themselves follow khalsa rehit, as it is in the khalsa that guru gobind singh resides is it true that without rehit guru gobind singh said dont call youreself my sikh? does guru ji really reside in the khalsa? when 5 amritdharee rehitdharee sikhs are together does guru ji stand amongst them? can you call 5 'sikhs' who eat meat and dont follow khalsa rehit, khalsa?

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

S Singh · 25 Jul 2005

The Akal Takht Jathedar issued a hukumnama which said there was nothing wrong with meat. So I guess he was not a Khalsa according to your standards.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

miss HKG · 25 Jul 2005

i think not - to the last question.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

Dandilion · 25 Jul 2005

Any jathedar who advocates meat is not a Gursikh. [%sig%]

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

A Singh · 25 Jul 2005

The meat question is one that is largely unnecessary, the Akal Thakt maryada is clear and precise on this point and all others. Whilst some feel I have a bad habit of pin pointing "rules" and rehits, the fact remains that the Akal Thakt and all those who claim to support it, has set the "minimal" standards on aspects such as Kakkars, Banis, Diet and rehani (daily living). These are not up for negotiation, if other jathabandis and sant-deras have their own Maryada, that is fine, for any closer inspection of these will clearly show these to be simply expansions upon the Maryada (minimal) set by the Akal Thakt and are not opposed to this -if they are, then why do they claim to be supportive of the AKal Thakt or clearly they wish to be splinter groups from the mainstream Panth. Whatever one's view is on the SGPC is irrelevant, the Akal Thakt is the Akal Thakt, so before passing judgement on the 'jeevan' of the Punj Pyare (we are not afterall Bhramgyanis to have the power to do this in any event), let's look at our self and our commitment to the Panth, both individually and at the corporate level (i.e. support of the Akal Thakt). The Akal Thakt Maryada does not say anywhere that you HAVE to eat meat, nor does it say you CANNOT wear a Keski, nor does it PREVENT you from reciting 5 Banis in the Morning etc etc. It has simply set the minimal standards and we individually or collectively in jathas, organisations etc have no authority to challenge the Panth. The arguments people have over these issues is exactly what weakens the Panth today, for people are too keen to have their "matt" tied up with their Sant, Jatha, Bhai Sahib, Jathedar rather than the Guru Khalsa Panth.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

amar · 25 Jul 2005

u cant eat meat, wateva the akaal takht say. u still cant eat meat, its against gurmat and u cant call urself a sikh if u eat meat. panj hu say u can eat meat obviously cannot be true panj pyareh as true panj pyareh represent guru gobind singh ji,and guru ji would not tell us to eat meat

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

singh · 25 Jul 2005

How arrogant to think you know better than the Akaal Takht !!!

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

BirRaas Singh · 25 Jul 2005

Anyone ever thought whats the point of the Akaal Takht nowadays??? Not like anyone follows its hukam, unless it is in their favour.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

charanjeev singh · 25 Jul 2005

A Singh, excellent!

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

RoopKaur · 25 Jul 2005

The decision by Akal Takht says a Sikh cannot eat Kuttha meat. Kutthaa means killed. So yes, a Sikh can eat meat that is unaviodable, such as bacteria and germs in the air, but we cannot take the life of another creature to satisfy our tongue. This has been manipulated to mean that Sikhs cannot eat halal meat. This opinion is based on manmat. a Sikh should be following gurmat, and their guru ji, not manmat. There are various pankitiaa in gurbani where it is clearly stated that eating meat is wrong. If it was ok, why would guru ji himself condemn this. What kind of Sikhs are we if we do not listen to gurbani, but happily listen to guru ji? As for the jeevan of panj pyarey, it is a good point that the panj should be tyaar bar tyaar rehitvaan Singhs. They are to represent Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji after all. Although most of us are not brahmgyannis, the amount of rehit a person keeps is usually a good indicator as to how tyaar bar tyaar they are, and if they promote doing a bujjer kurehit (e.i. by saying eating meat is ok), then that also shows how tyaar bar tyaar they really are. To say this is not to challenge the panth, because this decision that all Sikhs can eat meat is not made by the panth but minority people. Infact, I know for sure that if you were to poll the panth right now, the majority would infact be against eating meat.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

BirRaas Singh · 25 Jul 2005

RoopKaur, why would you add a word before "meat"? I never knew you could eat "unkilled meat" lol

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

A Singh · 26 Jul 2005

Roop Kaur and Amar, Please kindly refrain from twisting words and notions to suit your own matt. I am a strict lacto-vegetarian, however the words of the Panth are clear on this matter, it is exactly Halal Meat and Kosher Meat (i.e. Kuttha) which is banned. It is exactly this type of thought which weakens the panth today. I’ll try to avoid the ‘verbal gymnastics’ that people have previously accused me of (as clearly Roop Kaur in her post has demonstrated amicably the true verbal gymnast in this case). When the Akal Thakt issued the infamous Hukamnama concerning “Tables and Chairs”, we saw the “Gursikhs” of Canada on national wide TV explode into violence over the manner in which one eats Langar, on the grounds it is maryada. Clearly, beating up other Sikhs (which is forbidden in all puritan rehitnamas) and that too in the Gurdwara Sahib is not a disgrace of maryada! [Before anyone starts, I am not supporting the Tables and Chairs, simply raising the example of the ‘matt’ of today’s Sikhs]. Similarly, when the Akal Thakt indicate it is OPTIONAL to read the Raagmala, anti-Raagmala supporters revel the opportunity to now ‘align’ themselves with the Akal Thakt on this one issue, yet when the same Akal Thakt has also indicated clearly that non-Halal/Kosher (i.e. Kuttha) meat is permissible for an Amritdhari Sikh to eat, we have people up in arms. We have people suggesting that this is against the orders of Guru Gobind Singh (please read some history and you’ll clearly find it is not, moreover, have a look at the post concerning the “vangaar” of Guru HarGobind Sahib wear he clearly beckons the Sikh Youth to go hunting) or citing Gurbani as the true Hukamnama. This pro-vegetarian argument has even gone to the extent that some Singhs (like the gentleman from the Martyr Jarnail Singh House in Coventry and many others like him in the UK and Canada) indicate that wearing leather is inappropriate for Sikhs, however when it is pointed out that Guru Sahibs own shastars incorporate the use of leather as do items such as Nagaras, Tablas, Dholaks and instruments such as Dilrubas and Sarangis which are integral to the Gurdwara Sahib, they simply state we don’t believe that Guru Sahib did this and that Sikh instruments are made from dead animals!!! Well, perhaps history for these people is that simple and their imagination even better given that I have yet to come across a store selling instruments made from ‘naturally’ dead animals! Again I point out that I am a strict lacto-vegetarian, but the Guru’s word is the Guru’s word, Dasam Bani, Rehitnamas and various texts and evidence indicate clearly that jatka meat was consumed by Singhs and the restriction applies strictly to Halal meat. This is not however an obligation to consume meat, just like it is not an obligation to recite Raagmala. The Akal Thakt maryada, I will state again is the Sikh Rehit Maryada – it unites everyone, however certain individuals and groups which to place their own matt above that of the Panth and then complain about splinter groups and the Panth not being united! The funniest thing being that we are disunited on the most ridiculous of things - i.e. diet, how we eat our food, re: tables and chairs, colours we wear and/or style of turban – one would think that those on a spiritual quest would lift their matt above such trivial concerns. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

Singh · 26 Jul 2005

"The decision by Akal Takht says a Sikh cannot eat Kuttha meat. Kutthaa means killed. " How stupid, Because you cannot accept that meat is not banned according to the Sikh Rehat Maryada you have to try and change it in some other way. Why would puraatan sources and even the Sikh Rehat Maryada say Kutha meat if that means cut/killed. If it is meant to means cut/killed why bother saying you can't eat cut/killed meat as all meat is cut/killed. You would simply say you can't eat meat full stop. Its like saying you can't eat picked apples, exactly you wouldn't, you would simply say you can't eat apples. We all really know what Kutha refers to. "To say this is not to challenge the panth, because this decision that all Sikhs can eat meat is not made by the panth but minority people. " First of all you need to do some research. Literally hundreds of Sikh organisations and individuals across the World were involved in the Sikh Rehat Maryada which does not ban meat. Every draft was openly issued to the Panth for deliberations, and finally passed in a resolution. The whole process took a number of years The Sikh Rehat Maryada is the voice of the Panth and is greater than any group or Baba. People foolishly argue that their Baba did not signe up to it, well who cares as the Guru Panth is greater than any single Baba or so called Jatha Bhendi

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

A Singh · 26 Jul 2005

here here for "singh" above...

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

amar · 26 Jul 2005

you are not supposed to eat meat full stop, there is no arguing against this fact. if the akaal takht say otherwise then they must be rong, anyway this aint a duiscussion about meat, any person with half a brain cell knows that meat is forbidden in sikhi, its about wether panj hu say u can eat meat are panj, and i say they are not, because if representing guru ji they would say gurmat and true things only, whereas eating meat is false and manmat

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

A Singh · 26 Jul 2005

"amar" it is those with your mindset who continually weaken the panth in unity, the Akal Thakt has laid the boundaries for the practice of Sikhi at both individual and corporate levels, if we wish to operate at the boundary or within them, that is up to us -but to argue that one complying with the SIKH rehit maryada is doing something against Sikhi is plain futility. The rehitnamas of old all indicate one thing: "Take that as your rehit which the 5 Singh tell/reveal to you". We are not here to judge the 5 Pyare -what the hell are we, Brahmgyanis!!!

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

S Singh · 26 Jul 2005

Amar It looks like you have been brainwashed by the brahmin lobby. We are not brahmin that we cannot touch meat. The Akal Takht Hukumnama is clear. I am a vegetarian but that is out of personal choice nothing to do with my religion.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

g · 26 Jul 2005

this is why I dont believe in the panj anymore if one panj can be currupted they all can... they all put their own opinions into it, instead of going with the basic's thas why I wont got to the panj anymore

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

Lionking · 26 Jul 2005

lol @ Roop Kaur Bhenji Personally against meat, but in the end KUTHA does not mena KILLED, c'mon face it! Bhai Vir SIngh ji defines kutha as hallal. Baba Jarnail SIngh ji could esealy have the maryada at Akal Takhat changed, nahi, he said Taksal Di maryada Taksal, Akal Takhat di Maryada Akal Takhat. So just ge ton with your lifes, we're not getting anywhere in this discussion but in the end i'm pretty sure this post is gonna be ignored , cause it's asking you to stop argueing about something

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

RoopKaur · 26 Jul 2005

If one opens the mahaan kosh and looks up the word kutthaa, the first meaning given for it is in fact killed. The secondary meaning, which is halaal, is given after this first meaning. Who are we Sikhs of? THe few individuals who cannot give up their taste of the tongue or Sri GUru Granth Sahib Ji? Bhagat Kabeer Ji says Kabeer bhaang maachli suraapan jo jo prani khahe, teerath barat nem keeai sabhai rasaathal jaahe. Those who consume fish, As for Sri Guru Hargobind Singh ji's vangaar, it is also a fact that ALL of Sri Hargobind Singh jis hukamnaamaas say maas machee dey nayrey nahee aavnaa. As for history, there is no authentic sakhi that supports meat eating. Some modern historians, to cover up for their own dhill, add lies to history to excuse thier weakness of not giving up meat. THis same thing happens for drug addicts, they start saying Guru Gobind Singh Ji did opium so that they too can go on with their opium addiction. I would personally follow gurbani, not modern historians. For more information on why meat is not allowed please refer to the gurmat section of this site. Guru ji bakhshed us with bibek budhi, and gurbani also states that meating is not allowed. Let us all once again start using bibek budhi instead of falling to the false rases of this world, and not comprmise on Sikhi asools just to please our tongues.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

amar · 26 Jul 2005

+"Take that as your rehit which the 5 Singh tell/reveal to you". right then smarty pants, if one set of panj say meat is gr8 and another panj say never eat meat, then which is the correcr rehit? they cant both be rehit, guru gobind singh ji wouldnt give 2 different rehits. so wat u sed is obviously wrong. S singh i have not been touched by any brahmin, waeva tht sposed to mean, but i know meat is paap in sikhi, if u dont know that then i feel sorry for ya man

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

... · 26 Jul 2005

Singhs in the past hunted carnivourous animals like bears, tigers, etc. These were a menace to local areas. No one eats the meat of these animals. Whenever Guru Sahib killed something like a rabbit, the Sikhs were shocked and confused. Like at G: Shikar Ghat where the Sikhs asked why Guru Gobind Singh had killed a rabbit and Guru Sahib explained it was Moola Khatri and he was releasing Moola from that joon.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

R singh · 26 Jul 2005

"THe few individuals who cannot give up their taste of the tongue" Thats funny you know because your telling me you don't have th craving for pizza? Or what ever food you like the taste of. If taste is nothing to you then why don't you go eat hay or grass. They both have no taste. Or seriously do you really like to eat daal every single day. C'mon your telling everyone that you don't have taste in your mouth LOL. Get real.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

vivek · 27 Jul 2005

kabeer bhaa(n)g maashhulee suraa paan jo jo praanee khaa(n)hi || Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine theerathh barath naem keeeae thae sabhai rasaathal jaa(n)hi ||233|| - no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. ||233|| lets leave meat aside, if 5 sikhs dnt have daily isnaan an do nitnem, do they count as panj??

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

T.O.Singh · 27 Jul 2005

When Baba Ranjit Singh Ji came to Toronto, in one of the diwans he said that Bhai Gurdas Ji used the word Bhaa(n)g to mean meat. Because Bhai Gurdas Ji's bani is considered the key to understanding Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, he said that the word Bhaa(n)g used by Kabeer Ji in, kabeer bhaa(n)g maashhulee suraa paan jo jo praanee khaa(n)hi, in fact does not mean marijuana but also means meat.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

Common Sense · 27 Jul 2005

----- any person with half a brain cell knows that meat is forbidden in sikhi ----- Amar "tera baap", Sant Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa Bhindrawale didn't question Akaal Takht's decision on kuthaa meat. Now use your quarter of a brain cell paati pants and contemplate on that. You think no life is killed to provide you the food you eat!! Come on, smell the pesticides, lol.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

,,, · 27 Jul 2005

Plants are killed for food. As for the rabbit story. It is wrong. What does Karmi Aappo Aapnee mean? These meat haters talk a lot of crap. Everytime, I talk to outside people, they tell me information on these meat haters. Some go to jails for rape. Some get caught in corruption. Some leave girls pregnant. These things are countless times worse than meat. They think flesh of animal is wrong but human flesh isn't. Foold living in foolishhood. People saying meat is banned period. Are you people Guru? These people are nothing but pakhandis. These people don't even take long to cut their hair and leave Sikhi but they will die debating meat. Pakhandis. I know countless Akjs and others who talk against meat but can't stop going after girls. Hanging with wrong people and cutting hair. Even watching dirty films. Kabeer Bhaang Machuli doesn't ban meat. It is about people who take bhaang and meat and other drugs and increase their kaam and go to brothels but attend religious functions and act religious.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

;] · 28 Jul 2005

Heres one for the people who like to eat meat: Why don't you take your rehits and shove em where the sun dont shine. Good day all!

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

A Singh · 28 Jul 2005

Once again, we can see the true matta of those who name-drop and use terms such as bibek-budhi and cannot simply handle the fact that history and evidence does not support their own personal views resort to cheap name calling and accusations against scholars of being “dhil”. As indicated by the Sajjan above, this thread is simply going nowhere. To use the much quoted term “anyone with half a brain” can see why the panth is so disunited today when Sikhs consider their personal opinions or those aired by some Baba over and above the institutions (i.e. Guru Granth and Guru Panth) established by Guru Sahib himself. In another 100 – 250 years time when veganism comes the norm, particularly for those of a spiritual bend of mind, people will turn around and say, ‘gosh the Malech back then, they would use animal milk meant for the calf for themselves, that too as adults’ and no doubt numerous babas would turn up to further misquote texts and Bani (and of course alter key traditions such as Karah Prashad, since that would not be compliant with their new Vegan thought/ spiritual norm) and try to indicate that all the Guru Sahibs were Vegans and what not. This may sound far fetched, but that’s the entire point: We are arguing about diet, when clear precedence has already been set by the Akal Thakt, imagine if Singhs 200 years ago were told that in the 21st century Sikhs would be split upon matters concerning diet, colour of clothing and style of dastaar, what they would have thought!!! There are so many more important things to be addressing and we argue about tables and chairs, not only argue, but see fit to resort to violence and that too in the Gurdwara Sahib, dishonoring the sanctity of the place and also each others dastaars – this is the Chardi Kala Singhs of today??? I sure hope not, because if we are now challenging the Punj Pyare, that’s exactly what we’ll end up doing more and more of… Gur Fateh! A Singh p.s. Perhaps those who are so insistent that no meat whatsoever, will do the seva of eradicating the use of Nagaras, Tablas, Sarangis etc from Gurdwaras and replace these with your modern day cheap keyboard for some proper pakhandi kirtan.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

amar · 28 Jul 2005

using skin for tabla isnt not the same as eating meat is it smart ass? as for plants being killed, yeh and wa, im sayin that meat is drity, its jooth, planta arent, by eating meat you are eating some of the waste prducts in that animal, FILTHY. and this thread isnt about meat, as most people with common sense no that meat is prohibited in sikhi, so stik to the thread or make ur own bout meat

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

vivek · 28 Jul 2005

kabeer bhaa(n)g maashhulee suraa paan jo jo praanee khaa(n)hi || Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine theerathh barath naem keeeae thae sabhai rasaathal jaa(n)hi ||233|| - no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. ||233|| those who dont accept gurbani, for the sake of you're tongues relishes, dont call yourself sikh.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

S Singh · 28 Jul 2005

amar, , there are synthetic alternatives to animal skin on tabla so yes it is the same. You are killing the animal just to use the skin even though there are alternative. smart as you obviously think you are above the Akal Takht. Go preach your brahmin inspired ideas elsewhere.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

singhstar · 28 Jul 2005

Amar wrote :using skin for tabla isnt not the same as eating meat is it smart ass Amar god knows what religion you are follwing but its certainley not Sikhi.

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

ksingh · 28 Jul 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh who are to you decide what we are.this is the duty of akal takhat not yours. bhul chul maaf

Re: panj who say u can eat meat are not panj

Admin · 28 Jul 2005

Thread now closed. Admin.