Are Dhaarnas better than Ilahi gurbani ??
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Jul 2005
Dear sangat ji..
Guru ramdass ji writes in gurbani...
"jithey jaheh baheh mera satgur..so thaan sohava raamrajeh...
[gurbani] ijQy jwie bhY myrw siqgur so Qwn suhwvw rwm rwjy[/gurbani]
BUT our Dhaarna singers DONT LIKE this ...and prefer to Sing their own two liners..
Oh jitheh baeth ge kalgiaan waleh..dharteean nu bhaag lagg ge...
[gurbani] aie ijQy bYT gey klgIAW vwly..DrqI nUM Bwg l`g gey[/gurbani]
[gurbani] bolo jI sMgqo..bibIa bolo rsnw pivqr krlo...koeI rsnw rih nw jwvy...pr gurbwxI dy kIrqn nwl rsnw pivqr ikau nhI huMdI ??[/gurbani]
The GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB contains many many Hundreds of types of "gurbani that is essentially KAVITA in Raag Form...we are spoilt for choice... BUT we IGNORE this and "sing our own kavitas...dhaaranas... ?? WHY ?? ABSOLUTELY NO REASON except HAUMAII and LAZINESS.
Why do Hindus buddhist etc etc have to resort to writing their own Bhajans, kavitas....religious songs hymns.. ?? Because in their own Religious books..there is NO such POETRY in Raag form... so we can excuse them if they sing their own bhajans...hymns..songs..
BUT with the 1429 AAngs of Guru Granth ji Full to the Brim with so many myriads of ilahi kavita in raag form, religious geets, and for every ocassion...WHAT reason do we have to justify the Kacheh geet of our own writing..
IF we just sing just ONE PANKTEE of Gurbani....it can last us a LIFE TIME of kirtan.....we have no time for any kachee dhaarna..except to FEED our HAUMAII.
Re: Are Dhaarnas better than Ilahi gurbani ??
charanjeev singh · 26 Jul 2005
veerji, without debate, but with reverence to panthic obligations, and obedience to Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, are there not 1430 angs to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee?
Furthermore, on the topic of dharnaa; i have a short story here to narrate, a very interesting point was made.
I was with my cousin; and he brought up a very good point. Note: he is on the path of sikhi, and still has some issues with fully dedicating himself to Amrit Principles. So this was the point he made; a very valid point.
'How can they ask us to 'sing' the dharnaa, or kutchi baani, in sangat. I do not know what is Gurbaani and kutchi baani'. It awed struck me. I understand how someone might use it as katha, but asking the sangat to sing kutchi baani, hmm. I do not know the games of Waheguruu, maybe by singing these words, they get closer to Amrit? But as a sikh of Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, only the Baani of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, Bhai Gurdaas Jee and Bhai Nand (Singh) Lal Jee can be sung in GurDarbaar.
I am an advocate for Amrit Parchaar. However, the guiding rules of the Darbaar of Waheguruu Satguruu cannot be manipulated.
Re: Are Dhaarnas better than Ilahi gurbani ??
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Jul 2005
dandilion ji,
could the same advise act on you.... for example.
Mooh tutt jandeh..IF a "sant supporter" will ever open his mouth even against a pehova/dhanvantaa,ashutosh etc...sant supporters mooh are also GLUED SHUT with Super GLUE...they wont say a word agaisnt anything bad done by a sant....even if proven..
WHICH "SANT" will you speak out against ? Take your pick...many are in JAIL due to proven RAPES, one is in Chicago being sued by his legal Amrtidharee wife for ADULTERY....another is shareh aaam married to TWO woemn..and claiming he is following GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's Example...Many have SHOT at each other for GOLUK...blah blah blah...
Show me ONE STATEMENT from the Other "sants in sant samaaj" ( their TRADE UNION for political POWER as they fought Elections ??? isnt that for MAYA ??) expressing DISGUST at these rapes and all.
REAL SANTS/MAHAPURASH are GUPT. PERIOD. ( even if they exist )...OR they come out with GUNS BLAZING like baba Jarnail Singh Ji khalsa following the example of GURU NANAK and Babar !!!
Re: Are Dhaarnas better than Ilahi gurbani ??
khalsa_force · 27 Jul 2005
i was listening to ranjit's dharna ( mistakenly),
at first i was like " is it quali or something"
then after 3-4 minutes i came to know its him , lol
and abt dhadhi and kavishar >>>. they r for BEER RAS, HISTORY not parchar.
Re: Are Dhaarnas better than Ilahi gurbani ??
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Jul 2005
A Singh Ji...
THIS AGE GROUP is the one i am worried about.... WHY ??
Because these GEETS masquarding as "GURBANI" have become so common that some of the YOUTH dont even know the Difference. I have heard it umpteen times.... requests to Raagis.... PLease Gyani ji..sing that Sarson kee maaala wala SHABAD... This geet (Kachi bani) sung by Harbans Singh raagi is very famous...and this cd sells every day in Gurdawras..ALONGSIDE similar CDS of GURBANI KIRTAN. Can anyone blame the poor misguided youth who think this is also GURBANI ??
How many times have I heard requests for..OH Kalgiaan waleh ne dharrtee nu bhaag layeh wala SHABAD gao Ji..blah blah blah...
I receive EMAILS asking me for this SHABAD and that SHABAD....and Which AANG of Guru Granth Ji sahib...and what SHABADS ?? SHABADS like "AA giya baba vaid rogiaan da..."
SHABADS like..Lotteh geyeh laal tere looteh giyeh laal oiye..
I ask for "proof" that in which way is... Jithhey jaie baheh mera satguur....Harder/more difficult/not simple enough etc.... as compared to... Jithhey kalgiaan waleh dhartee nu bhaag lagehe...
This is NOT a sant bashing thing... its the PRINCIPLE of GURBANI is SUPERIOR and we MUST read ONLY GURBANI. DO Katha in your own words BUT NO KAVITAS...."masquarading" as GURBANI or equal to it. Dhaddi Vaars are OUT completely because of the simple FACT thta EVERYONE KNOWS it is DHADEE VAAR not GURBANI.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Are Dhaarnas better than Ilahi gurbani ??
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Jul 2005
Guru Darbaar is for the NIROLE KIRTAN of GURBANI.
ANY other form of KAVITA sung in the GUISE of GURBANI ( that is not easily identified as DHADEE Vaar for example...which everyone is aware of is NOT GURBANI)...is KATCHEE "BANI". Those who side track this isssue by Playing on words... I have heard ranjit Singh Ddariwala say this tricky dialogue as well...There is NO such thing as Katchee bani..bani is all pakkee..Bani katchee kiven hoiee..blah blah blah. He is making a mockery of GURU JI's..words... SATGUR BINA HOR KATCHEE BANI....kahnede kacheeh, sundeh kacheh kachee aakh VIKHANNEE.
IF there is NO such thing as "KB" and all bani is Pakki..then WHAT does GURDEV mean by "KATCHEE BANI" in the above panktee .
IT is aFACT that Gurdev is AGAINST all such KATCHEE BANI/KAVITA/GEETS such as Sarson kee malaa etc to be sung at a GURU DARBAAR by a SANT who is promoting GURMATT. Its just not right.
The SANTS and everybody else is 100% RIGHT in using such IF they Hold a "DHAARNA DARBAAR"...or Kavi darbaar.... and they can SING 100% of such dhaarnas..no one would be FOOLED into thinking these are SHABADS...and go around asking..what AAng is this "shabad" on ???
Let me be understood that I am NOT agaisnt "dhaarnas" per se... my dad wrote a few thousand and used to read them out to us....ONLY agisnt MIXING and MATCHING such dhaarnas with GURBANI panktees...sort of REMIXES so popular today. Very soon no one will know the difference.. Already so few are really INTO GURBANI..
jarnail Singh
Re: Are Dhaarnas better than Ilahi gurbani ??
search for tat · 29 Jul 2005
a singh ji,
if dharnaas are geets, then what is your definition of kattche bani?
Re: Are Dhaarnas better than Ilahi gurbani ??
Common Sense · 29 Jul 2005
Gyani ji, I am with you but we have to realize that a lot of these sadh-sants are extremely good entertainers. Most people suffer badly form the lack of Gurbani knowledge and they just love to listen to feel good stories and simple punjabi kavita-katha type music. These babey acheive super-star status. They offer good clean guilt free entertainment and people who come to see them have lot of sharda and pyar for Guru Sahib, but it's a sweet-poison nevertheless. All the made up stories and katha-kavita praising Guru Sahib can only take them so far. Only Gurbani can elevate people spiritually.
We need to understand what these sadh-babey offer that people flock to catch a glimpse of them in thousands and thousands. Why can't pracharaks with nirool Gurbani vichaar can generate same kind of excitement? Why are people dreaded to go to some nirool Gurbani smagams? Is it because they feel extremely insecure and uncomfortable with the treatment they receive from some people. These sadh-baabey receive them with open arms, make them feel good and ask them to become gurmukhs with pyaar. Oour sachiyaar singhs, on the other hand, demean them and call them horrible nasty names to make sure they never show up again.