Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

T.O.Singh · 29 Jul 2005

I know Sikhs are not supposed to worship statues and idols, but is it ok to make a statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, not as an object of worship, but as a piece of art? The 3Ho Sikhs have a life size statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, which I am assuming is just a piece of art. I have the picture but I don't know how to upload it. So what do you guys think? Is there a possibilty that sometime down the road more and more people will start making statues of our Guru Sahibs?

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

**- · 29 Jul 2005

T.O.Singh Sikhs are going down the same route as Buddhists are. Buddha/Buddhism strictly forbids image worship since their religion is based on 'Sunya' i.e voidness. With that in mind, we find Buddhists are the biggest constructors of statues. A fine example is the Bamiyan Buddhas in Afghanistan and the huge reclining Buddhas that you see in South East Asia. Jains are also the same as well. Regards Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

S Singh · 29 Jul 2005

Idols/statues invariably lead to worship. Take that Gurdwara in Punjab built like a mini theme park with statues everywhere representing the torture etc inflicted on the Sikh Quam. You get people walking aorund doing matha teyk to the statues there. A similar statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji Mahraj will also encourage people to matha teyk. Sp please refrain from making or buying such statues and falling into anti Gurmat practices.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

charanjeev singh · 29 Jul 2005

wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 29 Jul 2005

THAT GURDWARA is Built and maintained by the NANAKSAR BABEH. Shows just how GURMATT oriented the Nanaksar babas are. Truth is stranger than Fiction

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

singh · 31 Jul 2005

Statue is a statue and sikhs do not worship statues. Once it is there people will do mathatake to it. Majority of the Sikhs do mathatake to anything which is associated with sikhism. Statue of any guru is wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong. It is against sikhism.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Min Singh · 31 Jul 2005

we already have people who worship gurus through pictures, if statues were to be made, people are going to worship that too.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

AVTAR · 01 Aug 2005

Gyani Ji, You are making false statement. This gurudawara is Metiana in moga. it is not run by Nanaksar. Pls get your facts right. not just make accusation. it is maha paap to do this.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Bhopinder Singh · 01 Aug 2005

Sitaram ji Shankra charya was against idol worship and preached the concept of one god but his sucessor Natarjuna started the idol thing of many gods shiva , vishuna and 33 crore gods

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Lakhvir Singh Khalsa · 01 Aug 2005

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh. We are all aware of the instruction of the Guru on 'bipran ke reet'. The Sikh who falls in it is no Sikh of the Guru. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

ManjitSingh · 01 Aug 2005

How about the movie "Sahibzadey" which is shown in almost all gurduaras in Toronto area. This shows Mata Gujjar Kaur Ji and both younger Sahibzadey in animation, is it acceptable? If it is acceptable then animated Guru Sahiban will be there soon.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

**- · 01 Aug 2005

Bhopinder Singh Ji, Sripad Shankaracharya was a proponent of advaitia siddhanta – i.e. that God is ultimately formless and that the aim of the jiva (soul) was to merge with the Brahamjyoti. This concept is very similar to Sikhi/Gurmat philosophy. To say that Shankaracharya was against deity worship or ‘murtee puja’ is highly inaccurate. Shankaracharya and his sampradraya believe that murtee puja is a preliminary process of realising God and achieving mukthi. When the practioner advances, he/she no longer needs an aid of the deity form. I think that you should also be aware of the fact that it was Shankaracharya who was responsible for establishing what is today known as the ‘char Dhaam’ . The char Dhaam are the four principal holy sites and temples in India. It is similar to the panj Takhts that you have in Sikhism. For your information the char Dhaam are: Siri Badrinath Dhaam up in the Himalayas, Siri Dwarka-puri Dhaam in Gujarat, Siri Rameshwaram Dhaam in Tamil Nadu and Siri Jagganath Puri Dhaam in Orissa. If you cared to read the history of Shankaracharya, rather than relying on distorted facts, you will find the Shankaracharya established many hundreds of mandirs across India. He even personally perfomred murti prathishtha ceremony (deity installation ceremonies) at these temples. BTW: Shankaracharya was not the founder of Hinduism since Hinduism doesn't have a single individual founder; he is just a representative of another darshana (school) of Hindu thought and philosophy. Best Wishes Sitara (not Sitaram) [%sig%]

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 02 Aug 2005

Dear Avtar Ji, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Thank you for the correction. MY apologies. Gurbani doesnt teach us - Paap-Punn...that is a HINDU belief.. so paap-maha paap..no value in Gurmatt. Can you please elaborate on WHO then runs this Gurdwara ?? Is it run by the SGPC or a derawallah sant ? Thanks again. jarnail Singh.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

suki singh · 03 Aug 2005

The Darkhan (Ramgaria) Gurudwara in Slough England has a more than life size statue of jassa singh ramgaria (who was actually a JAT!). Many women can be seen doing mata teek to this statue...

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

avidya · 03 Aug 2005

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh Dear **, The original author was correct that Adi Sankaracharya does not support idol worship. Simply read his commentary on Gaudapad's Karikas. Only in Turiya is their moksh. To accept cause and effect, creation, individual identity, deities and individual humans is part of vikalap or illusion. Nirgun brahman does not have any positive qualities that can be comprehended from within the illusion of maya, therefore the process if of negation ('neti neti' say the Upanishads). The very existence of an idol is a mental event arising from prajna or self imposed ignorance. Therefore Bhupinder Singh is absolutely correct. The existence of murti pooja in dasnami samprda no doubt came later, although when it did is admittedly still a debate.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

**- · 05 Aug 2005

Veer avidya ji Adi Shankarachrya was not against muti puja per se. He preached Advaitia siddhanta i.e. that Gods, Goddesses and demigods all come from Nirgun Brahman. He supported muti pooja as a preliminary process, or as a stepping stone, to reach/merge with Nirankar Brahman. It is a well established fact the Adi Shankarachrya established many temples accross India and he had personally performed the 'murti pratishtha' (deity installation) ceremony at these Mandirs - the most notable being the deity of Siri Nar-Narayan Dev at Siri Badrinath Dhaam. This topic about Shankarachrya, his philosophy and his position is a very deep but interesting subject and I feel that it is beyond the scope of this message board. Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

avidya · 06 Aug 2005

Dear Sitara, If you study the different upsamprdas of the Dasnamis you find a variety of opinions, with most orthodox being absolutist. I have yet to meet a advait sannyasi who initiates others into murti puja. In the essential requirements of all prakarangranths, right at the beginning for studying Advait it is the shat sampati. Looking at the most authentic works of Sankaracharya, Updeshsahasri, Brahmsutrabhasya, Vivekchuramani there is no reference to bhakti or murti pooja, but srvanan, mananan and nididhyasan (internal practice). Remember that in advait an experiential state of union with a sargun deity is termed 'vikalap' or illusory. The fact that centres related to Sankaracharya have arisen over time is no doubt in response to advaitmat becoming orthodoxy. So I would agree that in advait practice some see murti puja as acceptable for those of lesser potential (a line taken with regard Om in his commentary on Gaudpaad's karikas), but in essence murti puja is sustaining the upaadhi, and thus not advised in Sankarcharya's advaita.

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

**- · 06 Aug 2005

avidya ji, I agree with your comments. Ultimately advaitya vaadis do not support murti puja since they define everthing in this cosmos as being maya or illusory. But advaitia is only one of the many darshanas (schools of thought) in Hindu dharam. I must commend you on the vast knowledge that you have about the siddhanta of Adi Shankaracharya. You are obviously a very well read an intelligent personality - certainly WaheGuru has blessed you. Regards Sitara

Re: Statue of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Kal · 21 Sep 2005

women will bow down to ANYTHING!!! i've seen it so many times how gullible can somebody become!!!