Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

JKB · 30 Jul 2005

It is surprising to see that some Sikhs hate Hindus for no reason. If Some Sikhs are asking for a separate homeland, there is no reason to hate and say any bad things about Hindus. Also, looks like, some Sikh Gurudwaras in Canada are preaching violence against Hindus and India. In the long run, Sikhs may be going in the direction of Muslims who now don't commad any respect and viewed as traitors living in Western countries. It is surprising to see that so many Sikhs serve and are proud of serving in the Indian forces and then there are so many Sikhs in Canada who are bad mouthing Hindus, their culture, religion, India. Why so much hate against Hindu way of life? But going forward, can we live and talk about Canada. If living in canada, we talk and worry about Punjab problems, you can't serve your adopted country. It is like, dhobi da kutta, na gar da, na ghat da. I think, there are enough Sikhs in Punjab who can handle their issues without Canadian Sikhs' involvements. Worry about Canadian problems, - worry about your son or daughter turning a gay or a lesbian, - worry about which country will take you back if Canadians kick all east Indians out - worry about future of jobs in Canada, as a programmer, the Canadian kids may have to work in India If RSS head says that Sikhs are similar in priniciples to Hinduism, what is the big deal. He is not advocating or recommending that the Sikhs change any of their beliefs or ways. Even if Sikhs achieve Khalistan in the next 2000 years, they still have to live, trade and do lots of other things as neighbours, they can't bring Khalistan to North America.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

**- · 01 Aug 2005

JKB ----------------- It is surprising to see that some Sikhs hate Hindus for no reason. ----------------- Many Sikhs feel that they have been let down by 'Hindus'. The events of 1984 was the main motivation. Even 21 years after this dreadful event, the victims and their families still have not received justice. This is not really the fault of Hindus or Hinduism but rather the fault of the Indian government. Unfortunately the Sikhs hatred for the Indian government has transformed into some Sikhs hating Hindus, Hindu culture and Hinduism in general. ---------- If Some Sikhs are asking for a separate homeland, there is no reason to hate and say any bad things about Hindus. ---------- I agree with you 100% here. I am a Hindu and I don't mind if Sikhs feel the need for self-determination but in most cases Sikhs tend to fall into the trap of Hindu-bashing. This tends to reduce their credibility both as a community and as a political entity. This view is not only shared by Hindus but by the wider community as well. ----------- Also, looks like, some Sikh Gurudwaras in Canada are preaching violence against Hindus and India. In the long run, Sikhs may be going in the direction of Muslims who now don't commad any respect and viewed as traitors living in Western countries. ------------ You are correct. The Sikhs in Canada and in the rest of the Western Hemisphere really need to do a lot of soul-searching and introspection about their own community leaders. No hate is good at all whether it be from a Hindu, Muslim, Sikh, Christian or Jew. ------------- If RSS head says that Sikhs are similar in priniciples to Hinduism, what is the big deal. He is not advocating or recommending that the Sikhs change any of their beliefs or ways. ------------- Quite frankly the RSS are the biggest embarrassment to Hinduism (one of their founding members was an atheist). This group does not have any authentic 'parampara' (traditional) system. They are making Hindus look like a bunch of weak idiots by trying to boot-lick the Sikhs. It is quite clear that Sikhs feel that they are much more superior to Hindus and don't want anything to do with them. Also as an aside, I read one poster on this forum stating that ‘Hindus are bending over backwards’ to prove that the Guru Sahibaan were Hindus. This is not true at all. This is only the case with Punjabi Hindu members of the RSS – who are quite frankly a confused bunch. Most Hindus are only vaguely aware of the Guru Sahibaan and couldn’t care less about the issue. Ask a Hindu from Andhara Pradesh, she/he probably wouldn’t know who Guru Nanak was. So please don’t give yourselves such a big self-assessment!

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Mehtab Singh · 01 Aug 2005

[i]It is surprising to see that some Sikhs hate Hindus for no reason.[/i] Yes I am surprised too. But not all Sikhs hate Hindus. In fact, those who hate anyone are not Sikhs in the first place. [i]If Some Sikhs are asking for a separate homeland, there is no reason to hate and say any bad things about Hindus. [/i] Yup, I agree. [i]Also, looks like, some Sikh Gurudwaras in Canada are preaching violence against Hindus and India. [/i] Yeah I heard that as well. [i]In the long run, Sikhs may be going in the direction of Muslims who now don't commad any respect and viewed as traitors living in Western countries. [/i] No don't worry, we won't. We will never brick alive little kids, we will never cut them joint by them, we will never boil them alive, or cut them to pieces bit by bit. We will never do anything like that. [i]It is surprising to see that so many Sikhs serve and are proud of serving in the Indian forces and then there are so many Sikhs in Canada who are bad mouthing Hindus, their culture, religion, India. [/i] Sikhs in India and Canada have their own way of thinking. [i]Why so much hate against Hindu way of life?[/i] I need the answer to that as well. [i]If living in canada, we talk and worry about Punjab problems, you can't serve your adopted country. It is like, dhobi da kutta, na gar da, na ghat da.[/i] hmmm...makes me wonder as well...but why shudn't we be botherd about Punjab? its our motherland after all! [i]I think, there are enough Sikhs in Punjab who can handle their issues without Canadian Sikhs' involvements. [/i] Right. [i]Worry about Canadian problems, - worry about your son or daughter turning a gay or a lesbian, - worry about which country will take you back if Canadians kick all east Indians out - worry about future of jobs in Canada, as a programmer, the Canadian kids may have to work in India[/i] We are currently working on that. [i]If RSS head says that Sikhs are similar in priniciples to Hinduism, what is the big deal. He is not advocating or recommending that the Sikhs change any of their beliefs or ways. [/i] They do it indirectly. They send fake saints to Punjab, like Ashutosh and others to distort Sikh history and beliefs and convince Sikhs that they are Hindus. [i]Even if Sikhs achieve Khalistan in the next 2000 years, they still have to live, trade and do lots of other things as neighbours, they can't bring Khalistan to North America.[/i] We will worry about that after 2000 years. Any other questions ? [%sig%]

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

miss kaur · 01 Aug 2005

wjkk wjkf lol..yea..mehtab singh..you've answered the questions very truthfully..and i totally..agree with you... If we really wanted khalistan we would go to india and get it. dont you think??? the same happens here in the uk...young kids go round shouting khalistan but they have no idea what it means! they have jus heard other kids shout it..and the cycle goes on.lol. most of them havn't even been to india. havn't even read about whats been happening ther. but still they ask for khalistan.is this right?? afterall we want whats best for our felloe brothers and sisters who live in punjab now...and to let them live in peace. if want that..then we should do something about it..instead of going to a protest in london..etc...and shouting khalistan...no? please corect me if am wrong. bhull chukk maaf wjkk wjkf

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

g · 01 Aug 2005

I dont hate hindu's... if anything I hate muslims... not all muslims just the fanatical ones... blowing up people suicide bombs all in the name of god... I think they are a big problem.... I hate them and bush the same.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

khalistani · 01 Aug 2005

to the guy who posted before methab veer je so hindus dont kno guru je eh then y is it congress who supports rss and y do ure holy books praise guru nanakd ev je so much? bhula chuka maf

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Aug 2005

Actually "some" Hindus hate Sikhs as well..just as some Muslims hate hindus and some Hindus hate muslims..some arabs hate jews and soem jews hate arabs...etc etc etc... Heck some "Blood Brothers" hate their own Blood brothers and kill them..i heard some mothers murdered their own children....??? People are people. As aGenral Rule..SIKHS as KAUM never hated anyone..not before and not now. I beleive the same of the Hindu kaum as well...But we have a few miscreants in all kaums....in India the Hindus rule..and it is those "RULERS" who spread thsi hate to keep their kursees intact. A few misguided or paid hindus on the street may get into the act orchestrated by the RULERS/POLITICIANS.. Even the AKALIS..who raise the slogan Panth in danger for their own political ends are not REal SIKHS..they are political animals and opportunists..wehn they are out of office they shout about sikh rights..but when they get CM post like badal they shut their ears/eyes/mouth..until the enxt election. We shouldnt generalise. the rest of the speciifc questions ahve been honestly answerd by veer Mehtab Singh and others. Jarnail Singh.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

singh · 01 Aug 2005

Which gurdvaras are preaching violence against hindus? I've lived in Canada my whole life and haven't seen this? Could you please cite examples?

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

**- · 02 Aug 2005

Veer Khalistani Ji --------------- so hindus dont kno guru je eh --------------- I didn't say Hindus don't know who Guru is, I said that most Hindus couldn't care less if the Guru Sahibaan were Hindus or not and I then proceeded to say that the majority of Hindus are very ignorant of the Sikh Guru Sahibaan. Khalistani, even Gujaratis, Tamils and Nepalese who live in the West are ignorant of the Gurus - what to speak of a Hindu simpleton who lives in Andhara Pradesh. -------------- then y is it congress who supports rss -------------- I don't know and frankly I don't care. These are both political entities and have nothing whatsoever to do with Vaidik Dharam - which is above mundane politics. ---------- and y do ure holy books praise guru nanakd ev je so much? --------- Which holy books? The Bhagavad Gita? Srimad Bhagawat Purana? Katha Upanishad? Please give me quotes. The only place where Guru Nanak is mentioned is in the Bhavishya Purana - but he is not praised but rather he is predicted. If he is praised can you kindly provide me the books and references (skanda, chapters and verses) and I will do my upmost to verify this. Anyway the arguements you have used in your quote above is exactly what the RSS and 'Sanatanisits' use as well. Plus I thought Guru Gobind Singh Ji relegated the Vedas and Puranas as being false scriptures; being the creations of proponents of false dharam - i.e. Vyas, SukhDeyv and Parasar. Regards Sitara

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 02 Aug 2005

I don't think that Sikh's hate Hindu's but feel disappointed and frustrated at the way they were treated as per 1984 and since. I also agree that the RSS are a confused bunch, however I fear that their attempts at trying to imply Sikhi is the same as Hinduism will create a lot of tension, and does make Hindu’s as a whole look rather sad. Rather than trying to consume Sikhi into Hinduism, which it does not fit anyway they should except it as what it is, a separate faith. This would ensure mutual respect rather than mistrust as present. The impression the RSS give is clear, ie that Sikh's are Hindu's, hence if you are a Sikh you can easily be forgiven for thinking "‘Hindus are bending over backwards’ to prove that the Guru Sahibaan were Hindus", as all we ever hear from Hindu's (RSS) is exactly that. Hence if Hindu's don't like what the RSS are doing and the strong impression they are giving Sikhs they should be vocal, however about from Sitara here I have never heard any Hindu arguing against the RSS's assertions. I also think people get easily confused due to their own narrow mindedness. Saying I am not a Hindu and Sikhi is separate than Hinduism, is not showing hate for Hinduism but being truthful. I strongly believe the above and have no reason to hate anyone let alone my good Hindu neighbours.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Mehtab Singh · 02 Aug 2005

[i]Which holy books? The Bhagavad Gita? Srimad Bhagawat Purana? Katha Upanishad? Please give me quotes. The only place where Guru Nanak is mentioned is in the Bhavishya Purana - but he is not praised but rather he is predicted. If he is praised can you kindly provide me the books and references (skanda, chapters and verses) and I will do my upmost to verify this.[/i] http://www.earthportals.com/Portal_Messenger/nanak.html 1. In the Hindu epic the RIG VEDA (i) In Mandala 7, Ush 5, Mantra 5 and Chapter 6 "Bee chakram prithoi aishai ta khestraaeh Vishnu mansai das sayaan throvaah so asaya keeryo janaas oeroo khashatra so janama chakaar (8)" meaning "when in the world the sinful ways will be on the rise and noble behavior will vanish, as the disappearance of the moon when on its wane on the darkest night, there will appear Vishnu as a prominent Prophet from the Keshatra Clan and will manifest in consecutive form through 10 Prophets to bring back the ways of virtue to the ailing world." (ii) In the same Vedas, in another part even in the name NANAK and the clan he belongs to is recorded thus - "Sri Nanak gureng vareng saklaath heythoo. Heitha samasth jagathaa va veithee kaetheng" meaning "For the preaching of religious ways and the earning of good karma, there will manifest Guru NANAK from the clan of the Veithees" (iii) At another position in the same Vedas is entered under Mandala 1 Soothak 5 and in the 7th Mantra thus - "Eeth eethei Vishnu reinn chakramei threihaa nathathei patham" meaning "The Prophet in the Kali Yuga will manifest three attributes. As an Avtar propounding Truth, as a Householder establishing family life and at the same time be a Raja Yogi" 2. The YUJAR VEDA As in the RIG VEDA quoted above, in the YUJAR VEDA also the Prophet in the Kali Yuga will manifest three main characteristics thus - "Vishnu bee chakrageih treithaa neikthei patham samudhseiaa paaeh serei swahaa" meaning "Vishnu will appear again, manifesting three main characteristics, Avtarhood, Householder family life and be a Rajah Yogi as well" Although in the above two quotations the name of Nanak does not directly appear, reference to being a householder family man, would point to him because he was among the first few Avtars (prophets) who was married and begetting children. Incidentally in Hindu mythology, VISHNU is the primordial Godhead Prophet, who incarnates on Earth taking many differing forms and the ensuing names thereto. 3. In the BHAVEKHATH PURANA "Baavekhath" means "future foretelling". There are numerous places in this famous Hindu epic where the advant of Guru NANAK is directly alluded to. These instances are listed hereunder - (i) "Theraa bhaareng thereshtwah keli krethem maha krethyaa. Aeveng vaee tharam parchaariang bhavekhthee thaa kalau. Thatha vei loka rakheiaartheng maleishana naas heithwei paschmeitlheng subh theisay vath wensei chei Nanaka naam nach rekhiang brahem geaanaik manas bhavekhet kaloe skunth thatar verth kaleaah har (35)." meaning "In the Kali Yuga when goodness in the world is deteriorating there will appear a Prophet from the Beithi clan named NANAK who from birth will be endowed with extra-ordinary spiritual power. He will preach on the nobility of life and the eradication of the sinful ways" (ii) In another portion of this book the following short cogent quotation supplies further pertinent information on the advant of Nanak "Guru thaa Brahma, Guru raa Vishnu, Guru raa dev maheshra saakhyaar Parbrehem Thasmei NANAK nameh" meaning "The Guru of the prophets, Brahma, Vishnu and Shiv ji is God almighty himself. This very Creator will manifest itself as a human, in the form of one whose name will be NANAK Note the clarity and explicitness in which the coming of Nanak is predicted. (iii) Further down in this book is recorded the following detailed assertiveness about Nanak and the type of mission and work he shall perform. It appears to emanate from the Godhead itself. "The Kali Yuga shall dawn on Earth with radical mainisfestation of destruction of Karma and Dharma to such an extent that every situation shall be colored by sinful activities. At that distressful moment, the Creator shall send down a spiritual liminary in the form of NANAK from the Khatria clan. He will spread the message of NAAM, the Holy life Force, by introducing the primacy of meditation and thus washing clean the sinful ways by the waters of love." Note the beautiful and comprehensive description of the happening. (iv) There is yet another quotation from this same Bhavekhath Purana indicative of Nanak and the 9 prophets that consecutively followed his lineage : - "When in the world there is the deteriorization of noble Dharma, then Vishnu will re-incarnate through 10 Prophethoods and will preach on the universal and omnipotent value of NAAM. (the Holy Life Force)" 4. In DHIGVAJEH PURANA "During the reign of the 8 Muslim rulers, Vishnu will incarnate in 10 human forms and after them will appear a (Mona) SILENT Guru (meaning the SGGS, the Sikh Scripture) who will only respond where the response is solicited." The word SILENT is of great importance - it refers to the Sikh Scriptural Book (SGGS). This is the first time in the history of Religion that a Sacred Book was elevated to the status of a Prophet. Unlike a Prophet in body form with the inherent capacity to make utterances, a Book has to be categorized as being basically 'Silent'. This is indeed a startling revelation, pinpointing the coming into the world of a (mona) Silent Guru, thousands of years before the actual occurrence. The eight Muslim Rulers were 1. - Sultan Lodhi, 2. - Babar, 3. - Humanyuh, 4. - Akbar, 5 - Jehangir, 6 - Shah Jahan, 7 - Aurangzeb, 8 - Bahadur Shah, These precisely were the Rulers in India during the period in which the 10th Sikh Guru came into being. This further emphasizes the authenticity of the revelation and the happening. 5. Through PATANJALI the great Indian (Hindu) Sage Patanjali, one of the top Indian Yogis of old, came 2180 years before Guru Nanak. In his Ashram while lecturing on the Prophets of the Kali Yuga, the Iron Age, he singled out Guru Nanak as the one who will be outstanding. When asked what will be his prime mantra, He replied. - "Wahyanti karyanti jathputi athak etwaha brahamadeya, teisah Gur et WAHEGURU" meaning "He will use a unique single syllable mantra which has not been utilized before at any Age or Era. This will be WAHEGURU." Waheguru mantra, which means "Lord of Wonderment" has since been popularised by Guru Nanak and all the nine other Sikh Gurus that followed him. 6. In VISHNU PURANA In the VISHNU PURANA there is recorded an interesting dialogue between VISHNU and a famous Rishi UMBREEK. Vishnu is said to have informed Umbreek that he will once again take birth in the Kali Yuga. The Rishi then enquired when about will that be and what will be your name then? Vishnu replied that this will happen when the Kali Yuga has proceeded for 4500 years and that I will take birth in the Shatri Sooraj Bansi clan, when I will be named, NANAK. In this same Purana it is further recorded: - "Sri Nanak santang saageaami Sri asech, sri asech, sri asech, sri asech" meaning "Sri NANAK will once again appear in the world in a variety of incarnations; this is for sure, this is for sure, this is for sure." Computing the date of Guru Nanak's birth from the above mentioned figure that took place when the Kali Yuga had proceeded for 4550 years, reckoning the total durations of Kali Yuga now to be about 5090 old. It is to be noted that this figure of 4550 is pretty close to the 4500 years predicted by VISHNU JI above. Incidentally, the clan in which Guru Nanak was born was also known as a Shatri Sooraj Bansi indicated above. CONCLUSION From the above it is evident that Guru Nanak must have had the largest number of premonitional references to his coming compared to the advent of the other Prophets in all the various Ages and Epochs. Therefore the Prophet Guru Nanak's advent into the world is indeed of millennial significance to even the coming future times. NANAK The word NANAK is a combination of two sanskrit terms. 'Na" and 'Anak'. The meaning attached to these words is "Not-but-One". The message conveyed by the Guru's name and the education imparted by him through the Sacred Scriptual verses, usually commence with the words "Ik Oengkar". This phrase too means Non-but-One. One God only. MOOL MANTRA There is a very interesting episode in Guru Nanak's illustrious life. When he was still very young, even before his `teens, he took a dip into the river alongside his house for his regular morning ablutions, but this time he dissapeared into the waters, missing for two days and nights. On the third day he re-appeared from out of the water with the following Verse on his lips, which is now called the MOOL MANTRA (the primordal Mantra ), which appers at the commencement of every Chapter and sub-Chapter in the SGGS, the Sacred Scripture of the Sikhs. It is one of the most comprehensive definitions of God and is amongst the most powerful of all the world's Mantras. This is how the Mool Mantra reads in its original version. - "Ek Oengkaar Satnaam Karta purekh Nirbhau Nirvair Akaal Moorat Ajoonee Sai- Bhang Gurparsaath" meaning "The True One and only Omnipresent Immortal Essence of Reality. The Creator, the Omniscient and Omnipotent, the Incomprehensible (the fearless). Before all Beginnings and after all Endings. Beyond Time, Space and Form (and enmity). Free from the cycle of Births and Deaths, the Self-manifested. The Loving Merciful Enlightener (Realised with His Grace through total Submission to His Will)." [u]Some may dispose this material as Hindu tactics to bring the Khalsa into the fold of Hinduism, however I find it pretty interesting to read. Guruji was not an avtar of Bhagwan Vishnu, and so some Sikhs do not believe in what I have just posted above.[/u] [i]Plus I thought Guru Gobind Singh Ji relegated the Vedas and Puranas as being false scriptures; being the creations of proponents of false dharam - i.e. Vyas, SukhDeyv and Parasar.[/i] Actually Bhagat Kabeer Jee said that don't call the Vedas as false, false are those who don't contemplate them. Someone please some more light on the shabad.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

**- · 02 Aug 2005

Veer Mehtab Singh Ji Many thanks for kindly providing these quotes to me. After briefly looking at these posts they seem to be self-defeating to the Sikh cause of seperatisim - but you have already stated this at the end of your posts. However, assuming the quotes that you have provided are true, this raises some very poignant questions and issues: 1) Their have been many great Vedic and Puranic scholars - both before and after the time of Guru Nanak. How can all of these scholars, Acharyas, Mahapurush, Sants, Bhagats and Paramahansas miss this fact that Guru Nanak was a 'Vishnu-Tattva'? Surely they would have advised the Hindu masses to follow the panth of Guru Nanak. However we don't find this occuring but rather they advise their followers to follow the path of all of the previous Bhagats, acharyas and Mahapurush etc. 2) The quotes above seem to be contridict Gurmat. Now this means that either Vedas and Puranas are false or that Gurmat is false. But in Gurbaani, Kabir Ji said that 'do not call the Vedas and Puranas false'. How do you get around this anomaly? 3) Guru Nanak stated that one should always tell a Hindu to be good Hindu. Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale also said something quite similar. Now assuming Hindus follow this advice (i.e. being a good Hindu) then being a good Hindu involves contemplating the Vedas and Puranas (as Bhagat Kabir Ji has stated). Now if by contemplating the Vedas and the Puranas Hindus are very likely, based on the quotes above, arrive at the conclusion that the Guru Sahibaan are avtars of Vishnu and that Sikhi is part and parcel of Vaidik/Hindu Dharam. Now by holding this view, Hindus risk getting into bitter conflicts with Sikhs and sometimes this can lead to violence (e.g. RSS etc). How do advise Hindus to resolve this matter? Many thanks Sitara [%sig%]

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 02 Aug 2005

JKB - what are you drivelling on about??? you wrote "worry about which country will take you back if Canadians kick all east Indians out" - that would surely not include Panjabis, as they hail from PANJAB- which is in the NORTH-WEST of India- so how can Panjabis be kicked out if the Canadians kick out EAST INDIANS??- that would surely be the baiyyay from Calcutta etc??? Also- JKB is an RSS/Bajrang Dal/Shiv Sena agent, trying to blacken the image of Sikhs- obviously there is a lot of monitoring going on these types of sites, following the heightened terrrorism alert worldwide.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

khalistani · 03 Aug 2005

ya and vedas a re contradicting if u look at above quotes they say the guru of the trinity willcome and then vishnu says he willt ake avataar how can the guru take avataar as himself thing is vishnu je had some hankaar i aaint tryin to be offeinsv veer je, please dont take it in wrong way but due to some hankaar he had because he was so powerful, he said a lot of wrong stuff, thas in hindu dharm there is so much devtha pooja instead of only one akaal and considering he had hankaar, it isnt surprsing that he wud call himself guru nanak dev je, the greatest power to walk this earth, even vedas say that and im saying he has hankaar, because guru je has said it and since guru je has said it, to me its true bhula chuka maf

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Gurbani makes it clear that the Hindu Trinity are not at the level of the Guru but seek the Guru. A popular shabad usually sung is "Gur Jesai Nahi Ko Dev", meaning there is no Devta equal to the Guru. The difference here is that the Hindu scriptures appear to be implying that Guru Nanak is an avtar of Vishnu, however this not claimed by the Guru. In-fact the Guru reveals clearly that Vishnu etc are nothing more but creations like us, and are also caught in the cycle of births and death as well as the ego etc like us. The three forms of Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva are trapped in the three qualities, lost in confusion. ||16|| Page 909, Line 16 -- Guru Amar Das He created Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva, who act according to His Will. Page 948, Line 14 -- Guru Amar Das I have considered Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva. They are bound by the three qualities - the three gunas; they are far away from liberation. Page 1049, Line 19 -- Guru Amar Das Hence just because the Hindu Scriptures see forth an avtar of Vishnu and some may claim this to be Guru Nanak (as is done with Buddha) this is not claimed by the Guru in any way and hence whilst interesting from a Sikh perceptive it is nothing more, as for a Sikh the words of the Guru bear more value. If Hindu's are adament that thier scriptures promote Guru Nanak which as stated earlier I really doubt as its only the RSS who go on about this and not other Hindu Scholars evenof the Guru's time, than perhaps they should deal with it by following the message of Sikhi?

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

**- · 03 Aug 2005

Veer Khalistani Jee, Don't worry brother I don't take any offence what you just said. Your criticisms about Vishnu can easliy be answered and defeated but I will not go into this here - it is a whole topic in itself but I doubt I will convince you or anyone else. What I will say is this. Where does Hankaar come from? Who created hankaar? Do you not agree that God is the source of everything, both good and bad? So if Vishnu does have - or appears to have - hankaar, this is not really an issue to me since I view Vishnu as God - who is the source of everything including Hankaar. Just think about it. Can you also elucidate on the 'wrong stuff' that Vishnu said. That means that the Vedic literatures are false since, according to the Vedas, the Vedic literatures come from the mukh of Siri Vishnu Bhagwan. This contridicts what Bhagat Kabeer says (i.e. do not call vedas false). Another point you should take into consideration is that Siri Guru HarKrishan Ji performed a miracle where he blessed a mute person (correct me if I am wrong) to be able to recite and contemplate Bhagavad Gita (there is a Gurudwara Sahib to this day in India to comemorate this event). Now if Bhagavad Gita is full of 'a lot of wrong stuff' why would Guru Ji lead him astray like this? Why would he not bless him with Gurbani Vidya rather than the false Bhagvad Gita. Anyway in conclusion no has been able to give a satisfactory response that Guru Nanak DevJi is praised in the Vedas. When they have provided 'quotes', they seem to be in direct contridiction with Gurmat philosophy which leads to the question: are the Vedas false? But Gurbani says: 'do not call the Vedas or Puranas false'. But Vedas are from the mukh of Vishnu which, according to Khalistani ji, has a lot of wrong stuff which means they are false. I don't think we are getting anywhere with this topic. My main contention was that if we exclude the RSS, Hindus in general do not really care if the Guru Sahibaan were Hindus or not since most of them are ignorant of the Sikh Gurus and so we are not 'bending over backwards' to make them into Hindu figures. It is only a misguided few that are doing it. Cheerio Sitara

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 03 Aug 2005

khalistani why can't you write properly, your posts usually make no sense and are hard to read. Ask your English teacher for help, not being funny just honest.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

amar · 03 Aug 2005

wat a dum question, its like sayin y do some ppl h8 ova ppl, its soooo vague, i doubt there a sikh hu says "i h8 evry hindu out ther"

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Dear Sitara "Your criticisms about Vishnu can easliy be answered and defeated but I will not go into this here - it is a whole topic in itself but I doubt I will convince you or anyone else. " I don't think we'll be able to agree here, as Guru Sahib makes it crystal clear that Vishnu was not God. This is where we differ and I don't think its of any worth arguing about it, as its an example of where Sikhi is distinct from Hinduism and vice versa. If you believe Vishnu is God, great good luck to you. Frankly I am not too bothered about any argument claiming Vishnu to be God, as from a Gurmat perspective which as a Sikh I am concerned with it is clear that none of the Trinity are God but are all under it's hukam. "That means that the Vedic literatures are false since, according to the Vedas, the Vedic literatures come from the mukh of Siri Vishnu Bhagwan. This contridicts what Bhagat Kabeer says (i.e. do not call vedas false)." I think we should read what Guru Ji says about the Veds etc in their full context. Guru Ji actually reveals don't call the Vedas and Katebs bad because its a worthless act, and waste of time. Why do we need to call anyone’s texts bad, as Jarnail Singh revealed be good whatever you are. However Guru Ji also reveals what he wants his Sikhs to follow which is why we are told: I have searched all the Vedas, Puraanas and Simritees, but none of these can save anyone. Page 477, Line 2 -- Saint Kabir Brahma studied the Vedas, but these lead only to debates and disputes. Page 231, Line 8 -- Guru Amar Das Reciting the four Vedas from memory, they do not obtain the Mansion of the Lord`s Presence hereafter. Page 216, Line 7 -- Guru Arjan Dev Therefore if you take the above and many more quotes in context with the quotes telling us not to call scriptures bad etc the conclusion is simple, don't call anyone’s text bad, but you don't need to spend time studying them etc. "Another point you should take into consideration is that Siri Guru HarKrishan Ji performed a miracle where he blessed a mute person (correct me if I am wrong) to be able to recite and contemplate Bhagavad Gita (there is a Gurudwara Sahib to this day in India to comemorate this event). Now if Bhagavad Gita is full of 'a lot of wrong stuff' why would Guru Ji lead him astray like this? Why would he not bless him with Gurbani Vidya rather than the false Bhagvad Gita. " The whole sakhi should be read to get the full picture. The Bhamin Pandit was full of ego and challenged the Guru called Krishan to make someone read the very difficult sanskriti Bhagavad Gita. Guru Ji agreed, however the Pandit brought forth not just an illiterate person, but one who was both dumb and deaf. The Guru than performed the real miracle of breaking the Bhamin Pandits ego (the real disease in the sakhi) by making him recite the Bhagavad Gita. The Pandit became a Sikh, and I think one of his direct descendants became an important SIkh in our history. The story has nothing to do with the value of the Bhagavad Gita but the breaking of the Pandits ego. If a Qazi brought forth the Quaran and Guru Ji did the same thing it does not mean the Quaran is 100% truth (not saying that it is not) it was simply the tool used for the required action. As for Guru Nanak being praised in the Hindu text, like I said I am not sure if this is true, and frankly don't particularly care what they say about Guru Nanak. As you have hinted Hindu's claiming Guru's being Hindu's are the actions of some fanatics, however these hold a lot of sway especially in North India. How can we be blamed for thinking that Hindu's are desperate to make Sikhi into Hinduism, when that’s all we hear time and time again from Hindu's in North India. It's a shame that the Hindu's in general do not appear to have a voice of any significance to oppose these peoples preaching which are not only wrong and create tensions (when we should and have lived very closely before) but also makes the Hindu faith look desperate. In return our justified anger at being labelled Hindu's (if I wanted to be a Hindu I would not have become a Sikh) makes us look like fanatics which we need to manage. Perhaps we could work with the Hindu mainstream?

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

**- · 03 Aug 2005

Singh Excellent reply. Yes Sikhi is a seperate religion - as evidenced by the quotes you kindly provided. I am at fault for letting this topic go of the rails. My original issue was the Khalistani - who stated that Guru Nanak was praised in the Vedas as being the greatest person to walk this earth. I asked for proof but got a plethora of so called quotes from Mehtab Singh which contridict Gurbani. This then turned into an issue of whether Gurbani is contridictory, but as you pointed out is should be read in context. However for every Tuk that seems critical of the Vedas one can always find Gurbani Tuks that are supportive of the Vedas, can you explain why this is? I know many Sikhs who claim that Gurbani is supportive of Vedas, but I suppose they will be viewed as being ignorant or misled. Regarding the Bhagvad Gita incident I think that you have made a valid point here, but I still have some unanswered questions. Perhaps it is best to leave for another time. In response to your last paragraph, I really do think Hindus and Sikhs should work close together and prevent the misinformation being made by the RSS and its likes, but I do think this is going to be a very difficult task. This is mainly due to the close ties that Sikhs and Hindus in Punjab have with each other and I don't think their is a straight forward solution to this. Best Wishes Sitara

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Mehtab Singh · 03 Aug 2005

wah wah!!!!! so much for Sikh warrior spirit! all "lions" ganging up on one person juz coz he is from another community and holds different views. woohoo. i m enjoying this. plzz carry on!!

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 04 Aug 2005

"However for every Tuk that seems critical of the Vedas one can always find Gurbani Tuks that are supportive of the Vedas, can you explain why this is? I know many Sikhs who claim that Gurbani is supportive of Vedas, but I suppose they will be viewed as being ignorant or misled." Please post the exact page refs from Guru Granth Sahib Ji where the above occurs, this will certainly makes things easier. Their are many tuks which talk about the Vedas, Quaran and Katebs in general which are certainly not negative. However it is wrong to simply take a tuk and make an assumption that Gurbani supports the Vedas etc without taking into account what is being said in the whole shabad (ie naam being the very essence of all texts, and all texts proclaiming God etc), as well as other shabads which specifically reveal that for a Sikh at least their is no need to study such texts. Whilst all texts essentially procalim spirituality, holy living etc which is what Gurbai would obviously support hence quotes which appear supportive, I do not think that Gurbani would support other aspects contained in certain texts which are against the fundamentals of Gurmat, ie caste, idol worship, fasting, pilgrimages, devta worship, infidel bashing etc. "Regarding the Bhagvad Gita incident I think that you have made a valid point here, but I still have some unanswered questions. Perhaps it is best to leave for another time." Feel free to ask what you want, no time like the present.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Hari Singh · 04 Aug 2005

>>> However for every Tuk that seems critical of the Vedas one can always find Gurbani Tuks that are supportive of the Vedas, can you explain why this is? >>> Please explain what you mean? Vedas, promiment Devtas etc. from the Hindu religion are referenced in the Sikh Scriptures on many occasions but I've yet to read a shabad which is supportive of the Vedas. Infact the feeling one gets after reading Gurbani is that many times Guru sahib is preching to the Hindus. He uses references they can understand to make them see that the dharam they are following has no value in Kalyug. Guru sahib is telling Hindus to adopt Gurmat. This is very clearly seen in Sidh Ghost.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

O · 04 Aug 2005

[gurbani]vydu pVY Anidnu vwd smwly ][/gurbani] He reads the Vedas, but he starts arguments night and day. [%sig%]

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

**- · 04 Aug 2005

Singh Ji, I think I have caused some confusion. When I say supportive I mean to say that the SGGS does not deginirate the Vedas as being false. The issue was this: Khalistani said that Vishnu said, in his words, 'wrong stuff'. Now I said that the Vedas are from the Mukh of Vishnu (there is an indirect reference to this in Gurbani [page 489, Line 8 - Guru Nanak Dev]). By implication this means that the Vedas are false but this contridicts Gurbani which says 'do not call the Veds false'. If the Vedas were not worth studying - as shown in the Gurbani Tuks Singh provided - why would GuruJi send five Sikhs to Kashi to study Vedas? Does this not sound contridictory? Let me illustrate this with an example: Suppose a new religion sprouts in Punjab and that it has its own sacred text. Now suppose that this particular religious text has quotes about the SGGS similar to the quotes SGGS has about the Vedas/Puranas - i.e. there is no need to study the SGGS. Now if the Guru of this new religion were to send his followers to Damdama Sahib in order to learn Gurbani/Gurmat, would this not send confused signals? Why send your followers to learn a text/philosophy which has already been declared as not being worth learning? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Hari Singh Ji, If you ask 5 Sikhs what Gurmat is saying to Hindus, you will get 8 different answers :-). [%sig%]

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 05 Aug 2005

Firstly Mehtab Singh I don’t know what your are going on about. I have never said anything against Sitara here nor would I as there is no need. Where have I been ganging up on him? Please do not narrow mindadly brush us all with the same brush when all I am doing as I am sure Sitara would agree is having a discussion. Dear Sitara, Thanks for your reply, I see where your coming from. You asked : “The issue was this: Khalistani said that Vishnu said, in his words, 'wrong stuff'. Now I said that the Vedas are from the Mukh of Vishnu (there is an indirect reference to this in Gurbani [page 489, Line 8 - Guru Nanak Dev]). By implication this means that the Vedas are false but this contridicts Gurbani which says 'do not call the Veds false'.” The full shabad which you refer to is as follows on ang 489; Goojaree, First Mehl: From the lotus of Vishnu`s navel, Brahma was born; He chanted the Vedas with a melodious voice. He could not find the Lord`s limits, and he remained in the darkness of coming and going. ||1|| Why should I forget my Beloved? He is the support of my very breath of life. The perfect beings perform devotional worship to Him. The silent sages serve Him through the Guru`s Teachings. ||1||Pause] His lamps are the sun and the moon; the One Light of the Destroyer of ego fills the three worlds. One who becomes Gurmukh remains immaculately pure, day and night, while the self-willed manmukh is enveloped by the darkness of night. ||2|| The Siddhas in Samaadhi are continually in conflict; what can they see with their two eyes? One who has the Divine Light within his heart, and is awakened to the melody of the Word of the Shabad - the True Guru settles his conflicts. ||3|| O Lord of angels and men, infinite and unborn, Your True Mansion is incomparable. Nanak merges imperceptibly into the Life of the world; shower Your mercy upon him, and save him. ||4||2|| Guru Sahib is using a well known story (not saying this did not happen) to demonstrate how even Vishnu (known as a great and powerful Dev by most in India) who beautifully chanted the Vedas could not find the Lords limits. Hence the Lord can not be fully understood by mere recitations of texts, even by those like Vishnu. The purpose of this shabad as seen from the Rahao (essence of the shabad) is devotion to Waheguru (can be called by other names) and not an account of who wrote the Vedas. Hence this does not contradict Gurbani saying don’t call them false, as here the issue of them being true or not is not the objective of the shabad. Guru Ji saying don’t CALL them false does not means they are in-fact false or not (not saying they are false), but reveals don’t go around bashing other texts as false or disgracing them etc. You further asked: “If the Vedas were not worth studying - as shown in the Gurbani Tuks Singh provided - why would GuruJi send five Sikhs to Kashi to study Vedas? Does this not sound contridictory? Let me illustrate this with an example: Suppose a new religion sprouts in Punjab and that it has its own sacred text. Now suppose that this particular religious text has quotes about the SGGS similar to the quotes SGGS has about the Vedas/Puranas - i.e. there is no need to study the SGGS. Now if the Guru of this new religion were to send his followers to Damdama Sahib in order to learn Gurbani/Gurmat, would this not send confused signals? Why send your followers to learn a text/philosophy which has already been declared as not being worth learning?” There is no harm in gaining knowledge about other texts and faiths, especially texts which are the source of faiths. In-fact from a religious point of view it is very important which Guru Ji obviously appreciated, as you can use this to converse with people of other faiths effectively etc. Hence I do not feel that Guru Ji sent five Sikhs to Kashi as the Vedas contained things vital for Sikhi. If so Guru Ji who was very fond of literature (52 poets etc in his Darbar alone) would have logically sent more than a mere five Sikhs from the entire Sikh Nation to learn about the Vedas, and would have made Anandpur Sahib into a haven for Vedic research and scholarship. I have studies the Bible etc and have spent time with Christian scholars not because there is truth in the Bible beyond Gurbani but to enhance my knowledge and gain a better understanding, which ultimately will benefit the Sikhs. In exactly the same way Sikhs who have knowledge of the Vedas etc would at the end of the day benefit Sikhi, by having people albeit only a few who not only have a deep knowledge of Gurmat but can compare this with the main and relevant faith of India (from which most became Sikhs). This would enhance the Panths conversational ability and standing. Knowledge is power and should be gathered from all sources regardless. I hope the above answers your queries, and would like to stress again that hurting anyone’s sentiments is not my intention on any level. p.s I will only be able to check this thread on Monday, so see you than.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

**- · 05 Aug 2005

Singh Ji I agree with you their is no harm in learning from other religious texts, but why focus explicitly on Hinduism? Why not send his followers to learn Islamic, Christian and Buddhist texts as well? After all Sikhi is a universal faith, is it not? The only reason I think GuruJi did this is that the SGGS alludes quite a lot to Hindu philosophy. Let me give you an example. If I was a European or African individual and I took a keen interest in Gurmat, my first port of call would be to learn Punjabi and read the SGGS. Now if, for example, I wanted to know what 'Kal-Jug' is, how it came about etc etc, would the SGGS be able to answer this? The answer is probably not. I would have to go externaly and find this out from Hindu philosophy (i.e. the Veds/Puranas). So in a sense I feel that Gurbani is reliant on Hindu philosophy - this being the reason why Guru Ji sent five of his Sikhs to Kashi. Guru Gobind Singh did create a haven for Vedic research and scholarship i.e. the Nirmalas. They claim to be a Guru-ordained panth. I have seen their Ashram in Haridwar and I can tell for a fact they are hugely respected by the Hindu masses (including Brahimns). Their conclusion on the Vedas may be different to other Sampradrayas but never the less sadhus and Brahmins still touch their feet. They have a good knowledge of Hindu and Sikh philosophy. In some respects one could say seem more Hindu than Hindus themselves.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Parikh · 05 Aug 2005

Hi, I respectfully take issue with one of the "concerns" raised in your discussion. Why should Sikhs be concerned with their children "turning" gay. It seems to me that we should accept all children, regardless of their sexual preference. I don't see this as a problem. Additionally, Guru Nanak's message seemed to me to be a clear message of treating others with respect and dignity. It seems that we should afford homosexuals this same kind of respect. Respectfully, Parikh

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Indian Patriot -Gaurav Sawhney · 05 Aug 2005

You guys & girls - some of you from Canada, US, UK - those of you who do not believe in the Hindu-Sikh unity & preach otherwise are ALL BASTARDS. I am a born Hindu but often go to a Gurudwar. Many of my friends are born Sikhs but they don't mind taking me to a Temple. All my family members believe in Guru Nanak Dev Ji & ALL the Hindus do the same because Nanakdev Ji is also a God for Hindus as is for the Sikhs. & NO Guru is a 'Trademark' for any particular community. Every Guru is extremely well respected not only by the Hindus, Sikhs, the Nation as a whole but probably by the whole world. Every Temple is a Guru's dwar & every Guru's dwar for me is a Temple. Please give it a thought. "I AM NOT an RSS PERSON" please... In New Delhi(where I was born in 1983 & continue to stay) & in Punjab, there is NOT A SINGLE GOOD HUMAN/ORGANIZATION who/which is against the Hindu-Sikh unity or preache/s anti Sikh or anti Hindu teachings. My surname is SAWHNEY a.k.a. Sahani, Sahni, Sahny etc. In my own family, many members are Sardars & many are Monas. Infact my 'fast' friend is a SAWHNEY & is a Sardar. I PRAY TO EVERYONE TO PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE be very clear & understand that in the period of Mughal rule in India in the centuries 19,18,17,16,15 etc., the parents then used to make 1 of their child (in my family it used to be the elder one) as a Sardar. Very briefly, this was done to protect the people as whole from the cruelty of Mughals. And this explains the fact that the Hindus & the Sikhs share the same surnames. I have read about the most unfortunate 1984 anti Hindu-Sikh riots (& about the attack on Akal Takht). But really DON'T understand the 'root' of the problems of the people of the faiths. My parents tell me of the aftermath of the attack on the holy Akal Takht & the assination of Mrs.I.Gandhi that the Congress people went on Ill-treating & killing anyone with a Pagdi & vice-versa - To say the least possible. It makes me cry. I really feel SORRY for all that happened. But now I find Hindus & Sikhs live in PERFECT PEACE AS ALWAYS, though I do also find that both the Hindus & the Sikhs hate most of the followers of Islam for they hate to learn that our gurus 'THAT' time were killed by their(followers of Islam) ancestors & our temples were demolished by them(followers of Islam); & then there are many many more reasons for the anti Muslim feelings - which should not be preached. IF STILL SOME INDIANS WANT KHALISTAN - THEY CAN TAKE WHOLE OF INDIA & CHANGE ITS NAME TO KHALISTAN. PLEASE don't spoil the peace in India by your irresponsible comments anywhere. (how are you spoiling the peace in india?????????? - because all these comments are read by the indians like me who really feel hurt by all this)... Indians are proud to be ONE. Indians are proud to be INDIANS. May God Bless... [%sig%]

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Mehtab Singh · 06 Aug 2005

Brother Gautam, a few years ago i shared the same sentiments as u. I fully agree with all what u have said except the first paragraph where u have labelled us all as bastards. But please try to look at it from the point of view of those who have been thru hell because of certain inhuman politicians. As you may well know, they have seen their families getting killed and raped before their very eyes. Its only natural that they have aggression filled inside them. And as far as hatred is concerned, I am 100% with you, and agree that it has to be subtracted out of this whole issue.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

dil · 06 Aug 2005

Dear sahney ji, "But really DON'T understand the 'root' of the problems of the people of the riots". I support your way of thinking. Hindu sikh hatred was the root cause of sikh riots. We must know that sikhs have roots in hindus and not in muslims. To preach our religion we adopt the policy of hindu-sikh unity otherwise our religion will disintegrate to further minority group in coming time. Now it self we find hardly any gursikh in public life. Bhool Chook Muaf.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

search for tat · 06 Aug 2005

this does seem like a old record. lets all hindus and sikhs get together and get the muslims, coz the mughal did this and that, and muslims are doing this today! Sorry it does not work anymore! In UK when hindus do the stirring and muslims and sikhs end up fighting, no hindus ever come. How can Sikhs ever be proud of hindus or of being Indians, when not one person has ever been convicted for involvement in the Delhi 1984 riots???? Can you give backthe izzat of even one of the sikh women who were raped? Can you give back one of the fathers who were burned? How can these acts ever be allowed to be forgotten!!!! Are we to forget our modern history? Why are hindus not condemning the vile actions of the VHP and RSS? I do not hate hindus,and understand the slick pschology behind the question, to makes us feel some sympathy with hindus. Divide and rule has always been hindu thinking from day one. But clearly I have learned never trust a hindu, unless he openly condemns the action of the Hindu far right! I note none of our representatives could give any proper answers to the post of why huindus hate sikhs......................hmmmmmm

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 06 Aug 2005

sawhney ji well said.it is sad there are some uneducated morons who call anyone that does not agree with them RSs gay etc.While in real fact these are the poeple who deserve to be called such. Many of these LOW LIFE HATERS CARRY CANADIAN OR BRITISH PASSPORTS AND LIVE OFF THE BENEFITS OF THESE COUNTRIES, BUT WILL SPREAD HATE LIKE THE MUSLIMS BOMBERS! THESE ARE JUST SAD PEOPL WHO DO NOT WANT TO MOVE ON OR See the others move on.Any that treis to explin the strategy gets called goar lover, hindu lover etc.While they gloss in all HATE and call themselves sikhs!Really they are no better than low life paasites who have no inkling about getting on and building the Sikh community stronger and stable. instead they spread hate .I have siad this before, if hindus can cal india hindustan, then the Sikhs should be able to call it Khalistan and live along side all. I am sure I will be called hindu l;over etc, so be it.but these haters of humanity are NO sikhs but agents of pakistan andhaters all things decent They wil not the tuukrri of khal;istan but a strong Khalistan strecthing from kasmir to assam and meghgalya. but which mother would have given these dreamers brains to think effectively?

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Indy D · 06 Aug 2005

Well said Mr Sawhney Jee. Sometimes some people need to see past their elitist views and adopt the truth of maharaj. This be pyaar and satkaar they fed into every man irrelevant of religion colour or creed. People need to think logically and realise that maharaj preached for all of us. And need to think to themselves why sooo many hindu brothers pay homage to gurdwara and sikhs to mandirs. We are inter twined in many ways and gurbani bes the defining factor in difference. We do Guru jees je je kar and adopt a lifestyle to their teachings. Please remember that Guru Nanak Dev jee never told their followers to change. Delve deeper to gurbani and u will find that maharaj did do siphta of Vishnu, Ganesh and Shiv jee maharaj. But yes They are under Nirankars command, such as Guru jee. Guru Nanak Dev jee had Nirankars darshan... hence to us are our closest to Nirankar. They are nirankar...... But think before you say something......Vishnu maharaj, ganesh maharaj and Shiv jee maharaj be truly great and are seen as god tooo so we should be respectful to them for they are far greater than I could ever acheive. Bhul chuk Marf karoo jee God bless

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

To Indian patriot · 06 Aug 2005

Why I am not an Indian By Beant Singh Saturday, April 19, 2003 - 08:16 PM GMT+5:30 "The first step in liquidating a people is to erase its memory. Destroy its books, its culture, its history. Then have somebody write new books, manufacture a new culture, invent a new history. Before long that nation will begin to forget what it is and what it was... The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting." -Milan Kundera Those who win the war write the history. Let's position our discerning eyes and pierce through the veil of illusion that has been designed to render us purblind. Plato's Republic might instruct that lack of opportunity inhibits insight into reality for those enslaved with chains in the pitch darkness of a cave. We, however, subsist in a free world and have no excuse for reputing falsehood disseminated by the Indian state. If we purport to be men and women of integrity, it behooves us to discover and propagate the buried truth - even at the expense of our trivial lives. Fifty years can effectuate consequential rewards for revisionists of history if they have appropriate state patronage. The myth engendered by the historians of India's first Prime Minister Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, for instance, informs us that an ancient nation-state, India, was vivisected to enable independence of Pakistan. In reality, many sovereign nations and monarchies were glued together to create what became the Republic of India as recently as 1947. Abraham Eraly's perspective on the fragile nature of India makes compelling reading. "The Republic of India is... today only a union of nations, not a nation-state. Nor has India ever been a nation-state in its long history, because we have never had the basic elements -- common history, religion, language, culture and ethnicity -- essential to forge national unity. In fact, India has no stronger basis for national unity than Europe has -- it has less basis, really, because of its greater diversity ... It is today politically fashionable to speak of a certain community and its culture as truly Indian, but the fact is that there are no pure native Indians, or any pure native Indian culture... All Indians today are descendants of migrants or invaders... So what defines an Indian today? Certainly not any ethnic, linguistic, cultural or historical distinctiveness... Later there came into existence, for short periods, a couple of pan-Indian empires, like those of the Mauryas and the Mughals, but these were established by conquest, and not by any national integrative process. Even the political unity that India enjoys today is the result of conquest, the British one..." [1] During his presidential address to the Muslim League on December 29, 1930, Mohammad Iqbal elaborated on the abnormal makeup of the Indian subcontinent that is today being governed as a uniform entity. He suggested that the Hindu majority is not willing to accept that "the units of India is a continent of human groups belonging to different races, speaking different languages and professing different religions. Even the Hindus do not form a homogeneous group. The principle of European democracy cannot be applied to India without recognizing the fact of communal groups." [2] This is the core problem that has always played as a critical factor in the turbulent, revolutionary undercurrents that have swept northeast tribal areas, Punjab, Kashmir and many other parts of the subcontinent. According to Cynthia Mahmood, "India, as a young and weak state torn up by centrifugal forces of linguistic, ethnic, and religious diversity, asserts its boundaries boldly (if extrajudicially) by eradicating those who step outside the line." [3] The Web of Brahminism In 1947, coinciding Pandit Nehru's tryst with destiny, hundreds of millions of people were subjugated and their fortunes were permanently fastened to the aspirations of a self-serving minority - Brahmins - overnight. This minority seeks to create a uniform, stratified caste-based culture, spearheaded with exorbitant fidelity by its Hindutva ideologues. Not necessarily a Sikh voice but a respected historian in the Indian eyes, Kushwant Singh, elucidates what this has meant for Brahmins and for those inhabiting this "world's largest democracy" over time. "During the British rule, the largest proportion of government jobs (40%) was held by Kayasthas. Today, their figure has dropped to 7%. Next came Muslims who were given privileges by the British. They had 35% of jobs in 1935. In free India their representation has dropped to 3.5%. Christians, likewise favoured by the English, had 15%; their figure has dropped to 1%. Scheduled castes, tribes and backward classes, who had hardly any government jobs, have achieved a representation of 9%. But the most striking contrast is in the employment of Brahmins. Under the British, they had 3% --fractionally less than the proportion of their 3.5% of the population. Today they hold as much as 70% of government jobs...In the senior echelons of the civil service from the rank of deputy secretaries upwards, out of 500 there are 310 Brahmins, i.e., 63%; of the 26 state chief secretaries, 19 are Brahmins; of the 27 Governors and Lt. Governors 13 are Brahmins; of the 16 Supreme Court judges, 9 are Brahmins; of the 330 judges of High Courts, 166 are Brahmins; of the 140 ambassadors, 58 are Brahmins; of 98 vice-chancellors 50 are Brahmins; of the 438 district magistrates, 250 are Brahmins; of the total of 3,300 IAS officers [the elite Indian Administration Service], 2,376 are Brahmins. They do equally well in electoral posts. Of the 530 Lok Sabha members, 190 are Brahmins. Of 244 in the Rajya Sabha 89 are Brahmins. These statistics clearly prove that this 3.5% of Brahmin community of India holds between 36% to 63% of all the plum jobs available in the country." [4] In addition, Patwant Singh's recent work reports that the Brahmin dominance is steadily on the rise. [5] This hegemony comes at the expense of all non-Hindus. What leads objective human beings to label India a democracy is a bewildering question. Calculated Assault Against Non-Hindu Minorities It seems almost comical that after five decades of consistent oppression suffered by scores of individuals and groups, including Dalits, Kashmiris, Christians, Nagas, Tamils, Oriyas and Sikhs - to identify a few - there appears to be an inordinate degree of allegiance to this recent political construct called India. For the Sikhs this loyalty and patriotism have come at a great expense to their own glorious past. The phenomenon of brainwashing has been busy at work. That young Sikhs in India today know little or nothing about their own history, in contrast to the exaggerated past of their Hindu brethren is common knowledge. I have interacted with many Sikhs in India and have found them to disavow knowledge of the critical time periods in which the Sikh Gurus, Banda Singh (Bahadur), Jassa Singh (Ahluwalia), Hari Singh (Nalwa), Giani Ditt Singh and Bhai Kahn Singh (Nabha) carried out their nation building works of great significance. Their school textbooks doctored by the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) do not even acknowledge, for instance, that Kashmir was a Sikh territory until the British annexed the Khalsa Commonwealth in 1849, or that Little Tibet was annexed by Sarkar-i-Khalsa, The Honorable Khalsa, as the name appears in the Treaty of 1842 with emperor of China and the Dalai Lama as the joint counter-party to the Sikhs. [6] Their recently revised CBSE textbooks, which have been translated in dozens of languages, slander the Tenth Nanak, calling him an employee in the court of Bahadur Shah, as reported by Abstracts of Sikh Studies. How insecure and malicious the ruling upper-caste has become that they must find every way to diminish the accomplishments of the Sikh nation! Sanskrit - an almost extinct scriptural language of the Brahmins -- has been announced to be a mandatory part of school curriculum by the Indian prime minister, while most urban Sikh school-goers have difficulty speaking their mother tongue, Punjabi. According to my communication with a Punjabi freelance writer who used to edit a journal at Harvard and lived in Patiala for some time, the newspapers of Punjab are fast abandoning Punjabi words in lieu of Hindi vocabulary. It is not surprising since in the 1961 Indian census many upper-caste Punjabi Hindus, who occupy positions of influence in the media, lied and reported their mother tongue to be Hindi. The state-controlled media in India has trampled upon the Sikh moral fiber. These days Sikhs pay to be humiliated. There is hardly an Indian movie or a television show that features the Sikhs and then does not proceed to mock them. Examples that come to mind are television shows such as Badal and Line Lagao. Even Sikh children are made objects of cheap jokes as in the movies Kuch Kuch Hota Hai and Khoobsoorat. An eyewitness reported that there was a round of applause in Indian theaters after the scenes that humiliated Sikh children. [7] This will amount to be insignificant after I discuss the physical torture of young Sikh "terrorists" by the Indian state. Why is it that in that Sikhs object to movies such as Dysfunctional Family, which are benign when compared with the Sikh portrayal in Indian movies, and not to the consistent propaganda against Sikhs emanating from Bollywood? When a Sikh male is projected as a protagonist in an Indian film, he is almost always shown to oppose Pakistani Muslims. This feeling of bigotry is nurtured and directed against another monotheistic people, 100 million of whom share the same Punjabi culture as Sikhs. The Sikhs have more in common with Pakistani Punjabis than with any "Indian" because they share the same language, cuisine and attire. [8] What has been the Sikh response to Indian films? A recent movie, Gadar, produced to create a rift between Sikhs and Muslims - as reported by various periodicals - was oversold in most theaters in Punjab, the Sikh Homeland. The movie denigrated the Sikh religion by showing the film actors purporting to be Sikhs but partaking in Hindu practices that are antithetical to Sikhism, making the Sikh identity seem insignificant. Just the fact that Sikhs residing in India, and abroad, continue to pay to witness their identity ridiculed, disgraced and belittled shows that they have been permanently enslaved like the "House Negro" of Malcolm X. I personally have boycotted all Hindi movies since 1997. My conscience does not allow me to support Bollywood's movies or music. Why pay to get humiliated? When the British oppressed Americans, the Americans boycotted British tea. Similarly, the SGPC boycotted British sugar at the Harmandir Sahib in Amritsar during the Gurdwara Reform Movement. Today's Sikhs have no self-respect. They continue to support an industry that is responsible for their defamation. If you go to a store whose employees humiliate you on each visit, would you still purchase goods from that store? Official Hate Speech: Declaration of All Sikhs as Criminals The Sikh struggle in India began with an official circular of the Indian state on October 10, 1947, barely two months after the creation of this new nation, instructing that "special measures" be taken against the Sikhs who, as a community, were a "lawless people and were thus a menace to the law-abiding Hindus in the province." [9] It was quite a reward for a religious community that made scarifies disproportionate to its size in the struggle to overthrow British imperialism from the subcontinent. [10] Kapur Singh, an Indian Civil Service (today's Indian Administrative Service) official protested vehemently to the ingratitude of the Brahmin leaders ruling India. The result was his unceremonious dismissal from a prestigious post. Decades of fighting in the Indian courts were of no use for Kapur Singh, even though he was guilty of no offence. Policy Implementation through Ethnic Cleansing The last two decades have taught us that the concentration camps of Hitler were far more benevolent than the milieu in which the Sikh spirit has been crushed. There are many villages in rural Punjab where all young men ages sixteen to thirty were systematically executed by the Indian police and paramilitary forces. Their only offense was that they were Sikhs. The Indian Army Bulletin, Baatcheet, Serial Number 153, June 1984, illustrates this point beyond any reasonable doubt. Some of our innocent countrymen were administered oath in the name of religion to support extremists and actively participated in the act of terrorism. These people wear a miniature kirpan round their neck and are called "Amritdharis" . . . Any knowledge of the "Amritdharis" who are dangerous people and pledged to commit murder, arson and acts of terrorism should be immediately brought to the notice of the authorities. These people may appear harmless from outside but they are basically committed to terrorism. In the interest of us all, their identity and whereabouts must always be disclosed. Compare the above with a Nazi poster that read, "Our most dangerous opponent is the Jew, and all who belong to him." There was even a more insidious public relations campaign by the Indian state to brand Sikhs as terrorists. The Indian consulates in all major cities around the globe, with Sikh concentrations, spearheaded an extensive propaganda operation to alter the established Sikh image of responsible citizens to that of reprehensible terrorists. The Indian intelligence also carried out many covert operations. For instance, an independent investigation strongly suggests that it blew-up an Air India plane with over 300 passengers to tarnish the Sikh image beyond repair. While the media conveniently blamed the Sikhs, the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) was able to identity the real culprit. The influence of the Indian government seemed to crop up practically everywhere CSIS agents investigated the Sikhs separatists either as national security threats or as suspects in the Air-India and Narita bombings. [11] . . . two senior CSIS officials in B.C. [British Columbia] described at a CSIS meeting their version of criminal flow of Sikh violence in Canada. At the very top they placed the GOI (the government of India), and in brackets beside it, the Secret Services Bureau, CBI-RAW, Third Agency. Below GOI were the names of Indian agents of influence and agents provocateurs . . . So convinced has CSIS become of the GOI connection [in the Air India bombing] that, at one Air-India task force meeting, a CSIS agent had seriously suggested that "if you really want to clear the incidents quickly, take vans down to the Indian High Commission and the consulate in Toronto and Vancouver, load up everybody and take them down for questioning. We know it and they know it that they are involved." [12] There, however, is a distinct difference between German and Indian propaganda. Germany restricted its propaganda to its own citizens, whereas India spent massive amounts of capital to taint the Sikh image worldwide. No group of people would appreciate being labeled vicious terrorists, as the Indian state has maintained in its communications when describing committed Sikhs. Operation Blue Star: Myth and Reality The attack on a cherished symbol of the Sikhs, the Golden Temple, in June 1984 is considered the most egregious error of the Indian government. The inhumane act severed the Sikh relationship with India permanently. The Golden Temple serves as the nerve center of the Sikhs. The Indian Army mounted its attack on a major Sikh holiday with the maximum visitors in attendance. The purpose was to destroy a major source of Sikh inspiration, to massacre thousands of innocent Sikhs and to torch the Sikh Reference Library, which contained irreplaceable Sikh history, artifacts and original texts, including those handwritten by the Gurus. Furthermore, the Indian Army looted the Sikh treasury and museum, Toshakhana. Thirty-seven other Sikh Gurdwaras were attacked on the same day. Did they all contain terrorists that needed to be blasted out of their hiding places? The Indian state has been unable to provide a satisfactory answer. Cynthia Mahmood sheds light on the counterfeit allegations of the Indian state. "When it [the state of India] attacked the Golden Temple complex at Amritsar in 1984, containing the holist shrine of the Sikhs, the ostensible aim was to rid the sacred buildings of the militants who had taken up shelter inside. But the level force used in the attack was utterly incommensurate with this limited and eminently attainable aim. Seventy thousand troops, in conjunction with the use of tanks and chemical gas, killed not only the few dozen militants who didn't manage to escape the battleground but also hundreds (possibly thousands) of innocent pilgrims, the day of the attack being a Sikh holy day. The Akal Takht, the seat of temporal authority for the Sikhs, was reduced to rubble and the Sikh Reference Library, an irreplaceable collection of books, manuscripts, and artifacts bearing on all aspects of Sikh history, burned to ground. Thirty-seven other shrines were attacked across Punjab on the same day. The only possible reason for this appalling level of state force against its own citizens must be that the attempt was not merely to "flush out," as they say, a handful of militants, but to destroy the fulcrum of a possible mass resistance against the state." [13] Joyce Pettigrew explains what became and continues as a regular occurrence in Punjab. "Illegal detention, disappearances, false encounter (a fictitious armed engagement as a cover up for police killing a detainee) became daily events. Such disappearances and illegal detention continue to occur." [14] "Extralegal groups operating on behalf of the [Indian] state engaged in the abduction of the following categories of person: political activists; persons suspected of having association with them; lawyers who defend families whose human rights have been violated; journalists who write about such violations; and human rights workers who record their complaints. However, the largest body of those held comes from a wide range of persons uninvolved with political activity. Once abducted, they are detained in unofficial interrogation centers which include schools, houses, forest bungalows owned by the Public Works Department (PWD), and a variety of official police buildings belonging to the Central Investigative Agency (CIA) of the Punjab police, the Central Reserve Police Force, and the Border Security Force (BSF). Informants and more recently some written reports have suggested, additionally, that Hindu temples provide facilities for cremation of political prisoners." [15] Torture and Genocide of Sikh Children The fascist nature of the Indian state is revealed through the atrocities it committed on innocent Sikh children. An independent civil liberties organization headed by Justice V.M. Tarkunde reported the situation in the villages of Punjab. The story of the [Sikh] children is the story of our shame. So gross and insensitive the political parties have become that not one of the 11 members of Parliament representing 10 political parties visiting Amritsar on August 1, 1984 felt like taking any action, when they were informed that 25 children between 4 and 12 had been detained in the Ludhiana jail under section 107/262 having been rounded up from the Golden Temple in the early July. It was Smt. Kamla Devi Chattopadhyaya -- old and very sick -- who moved in the matter and discovered the shocking fact that some of the detained children were blind and there were in the jail several women and old men; obviously they had been found too dangerous by the Army to be allowed to remain outside. She moved the Supreme Court with a writ petition and taking serious note of the state of affairs obtaining in Punjab the Supreme Court ordered the authorities to release "all children kept under detention in various jails and children's homes in the State of Punjab" immediately. The orders however were not carried out -- minors continued to remain in jails and being questioned the jail Superintendent, Patiala, admitted that there were many children still inside his jail also. The story of ghastly torture of young boys as well as of other arrested people has been revealed fully by Justice P.S. Cheema, Vigilance Judge, Sessions Division, Patiala, during his visit to Ladha Kothi (Sangrur Distt.) jail. This can be seen in the Annexure No. 1. Since violations of the rule of law is now the rule and the Armed Forces (Punjab and Chandigarh) Special Powers Act has made the Army supreme. Major Das picked up six children who were taking their examination in the Jaffarwal Village School in September. They were taken to the Military Camp at Tibri and tortured there. He came back to the village again and raided houses of 5 other boys -- 3 of them were arrested and tortured for 7 days. There was no FIR, no charge sheet, the only proof that the army had taken them and tortured them was the signs of the torture themselves; young Charan Singh who was a fine runner with ambition to represent his school in Punjab's Running Competition has become lame, he said, "I told them break my arm but don't twist my leg, they did not listen." [16] Many uninformed Sikhs, who have been indoctrinated by the Indian media and its propaganda machinery, are today living in a state of denial. They call what has happened subsequent to 1984 as an unfortunate work of the Congress party. If the successive governments had a different policy towards the Sikhs, why is it that thousands of Sikhs continue to languish in squalid Indian prisons without knowing the crimes they have supposedly committed? [17] Ironically, the law under which they were incarcerated without evidence, TADA, has long been repealed. [18] Why have criminals such as Sajjan Kumar, H.K.L. Bhagat, Narsimha Rao, K.P. Gill and Jilio Ribero not been prosecuted in spite of mountains of affidavits showing their role in genocide of Sikhs? Why does the Indian regime continue to bar human rights organizations such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch if it has nothing to hide? Those who claim that human rights abuses against the Sikhs have ceased in the past few years are invited to examine an Amnesty International report published in 2000. It clearly shows that the Indian state continues to pursue its policy of state terror against the Sikhs. In mid-1998, 35-year-old Kesar Singh, Block President of the Punjab Human Rights Organization (PHRO) and associated with the Committee for Coordination on Disappearances in Punjab (CCDP) had several false criminal cases filed against him. On 5 June 1998 a case was registered against him under section 406 and 506 of the IPC [criminal breach of trust and criminal intimidation]. He was threatened by a police inspector that if he did not stop working for the PHRO he would have further false cases filed against him. He was released on bail after six days. However, he was picked up again by the same police inspector on 28 July 1998 from his home in Kalewal village along with another man. The two were reportedly tortured by two police officials in the presence of the Superintendent of Police. They were reportedly stripped and dragged by their hair and their legs were stretched far apart. The next day, 29 July, they were taken to another police station and brought before more police officers who again asked him to desist from carrying out human rights activities. Kesar Singh, in a statement said: "when I replied that nothing is wrong in it he directed the policemen present over there to set me right. That when I again said that they should shoot me dead, the DIG (Deputy Inspector General of Police) said that they have not changed the policy and now they will eliminate the human rights activists by rafting them in jails." Kesar Singh was subjected to several periods of police remand during which time he was repeatedly threatened to cease his human rights work and not to depose in court against police officials in several cases of human rights violations. While he was detained, his house was searched and money, personal possessions, documents and his motorcycle taken away. A further case was filed against him under sections of the Arms Act and the Explosives Act. He was finally remanded to judicial custody on 1 September 1998 and sent to Nabha Security Jail. [19] Amnesty International's most recent report in February 2003, shows that torture is endemic in Punjab and human rights violations continue to take place without check. Governments or political parties cannot come to power in India unless they express and demonstrate anti-Sikh, anti-Christian and anti-Muslim sentiment, in concert with their allegiance to Hindutva ideology. The fascist BJP leadership, which has boldly encouraged and engaged in tearing down Muslims places of worship, [20] burning of Christian priests and raping of Christian nuns in broad daylight, has continued its state-sponsored terrorism against the Sikhs as well. According to Cynthia Mahmood, "The fact that some BJP leaders - who receive substantial electoral majorities - have explicitly equated being a Hindu with being an Indian, and hence not being a Hindu as being a traitor, is an ominous one." [21] The long-term design is to make the non-Hindu religions die out gradually by imposing permanent incentives for "national integration," as witnessed by the slow plummeting of Christian demography in Egypt or Syria, from over 90% in the 7th century via some 50% in the 12th century to about 10% today. To think that Sikhs committed to their religious ideals are safe today betrays truth and knowledge of current affairs in Punjab. Sikhs with even an iota of honor cannot help but consider India as their most significant enemy. No reasonable Jew during the Holocaust could possibly call himself or herself a German. William Heyen's My Holocaust Songs poetically describes this intense feeling of disgust and disassociation towards a nation that committed genocide against its own citizens. Dead Jew goldpiece in German eye, dead Jew shovel in German shed, dead Jew book in German hand, dead Jew hat on German head, dead Jew violin in German ear, dead Jew linen on German skin, dead Jew blood in German vein... Germany's orchestration of the Holocaust was a singular factor why Jews stopped being German. Malcolm X reminds us in his autobiography the dangers of assimilation and "integration" with the enemy. He also makes a case for identifying the enemy before it is too late. He [Jew] had made greater contributions to Germany than Germans themselves had. Jews had over half of Germany's Nobel Prizes. Every culture in Germany was led by the Jew; he published the greatest newspapers. Jews were the greatest artists, the greatest poets, composers, stage directors. But those Jews made a fatal mistake - assimilating . . . Their own Jewish religion, their own rich Jewish ethnic and cultural roots, they anesthetized, and cut off . . . until they began thinking of themselves as "Germans." And the next thing they knew, there was Hitler, rising to power from the beer halls - with his emotional "Aryan master" theory. And right at hand for a scapegoat was the self-weakened, self-deluded "German" Jew. [22] Jews have used nizkor, a Hebrew word that means "We will remember," to permanently etch this event in their collective memory. They have embarked upon innumerable initiatives such as The Nizkor Project "to refute or otherwise reply to those falsehoods, half-truths, and misinformation, with the aim of ensuring that they and their proponents remain firmly in the margin." The Sikhs can learn from Jews who held Germany accountable for its actions and refuse to forget what has happened to their people. They have not sought mere apologies from the German state; they have dragged the Germans responsible for the genocide to international tribunals, and have had them hanged. Let's be clear that India and the Sikh nation are at war. The goal of the Indian regime is to eliminate the Sikh identity. It is silly to seek apologies from someone who does not repent and instead is committed to killing you. If some Sikh apologists think that reconciliation with an enemy is possible, I remind them of Thomas Paine's famous words in Common Sense. Men of passive tempers look somewhat lightly over the offenses of Britain, and, still hoping for the best, are apt to call out, "COME, COME, WE SHALL BE FRIENDS AGAIN, FOR ALL THIS." But examine the passions and feelings of mankind, bring the doctrine of reconciliation to the touchstone of nature, and then tell me, whether you can hereafter love, honor, and faithfully serve the power that hath carried fire and sword into your land? If yon cannot do all these, then are you only deceiving yourselves, and by your delay bringing ruin upon posterity. Your future connection with Britain, whom you can neither love nor honor will be forced and unnatural, and being formed only on the plan of present convenience, will in a little time fall into a relapse more wretched than the first. But if you say, you can still pass the violations over, then I ask, Hath your house been burnt? Hath your property been destroyed before your face! Are your wife and children destitute of a bed to lie on, or bread to live on? Have you lost a parent or a child by their hands, and yourself the ruined and wretched survivor! If you have not, then are you not a judge of those who have. But if you have, and still can shake hands with the murderers, then are you unworthy the name of husband, father, friend, or lover, and whatever may be your rank or title in life, you have the heart of a coward, and the spirit of a sycophant. Dear reader, I know that it is terribly hard to form consensus around a solution to a complex problem - so I do not propose a panacea here and leave such an exercise for another day. We, however, must unite as dignified human beings and identify the enemy who is not just a cold-blooded murderer but is also guilty of ethnic cleansing and genocide. Let's agree that India and fascism are two sides of the same coin. Those with even a shred of dignity would have trouble being labeled an Indian. The apology-seeking, self-hating Sikh who still suffers from pangs of unrequited love with India is akin to the "House Negro" of Malcolm X, who has for long been at odds with the "Field Negro." The Black activist explains that the former lived with his master's home in the attic or the basement and got to eat the master's leftovers after meals. When the master felt cold, the house Negro exclaimed, "Masta! We cold." When the master was hot, the House Negro cried, "Masta! We hot." The House Negro was in love with his oppressor in spite of hundreds of years of tyranny directed against his race. The "Field Negro," on the other hand, was forced to labor in the fields. He was often subjected to his master's nefarious whipping without any good reason. He was acutely aware of his slavery. He would often go to the "House Negro" and suggest, "Nigga, we are slaves; we have gotta run away!" The House Negro, like some Sikhs today, could not commiserate with such a feeling of stark alienation towards his master. The Sikh nation will never forget India's egregious acts of custodial rape and torture, extra-judicial killings, ethnic cleansing and genocide. Thomas Paine and Malcolm X are turning in their graves, shrugging their shoulders, clamoring for the day when we will unite to etch - with the indelible blood of our martyrs - the name of our common enemy into our collective memory. Our fight in not against Hindus; it is against the Indian state. Because the Sikhs firmly oppose the apartheid that the horrific caste system promotes through stratification of society, those Hindus at the apex of the caste pyramid are certain to be disturbed. Buried under layers of argument, analysis and sophistry of the elitist, right-wing Hindus ruling India, the real issue is that the Indian state continues to treat Sikhs as useless, second-class citizens, subjecting them to grave humiliation in all spheres of society, implementing cataclysmic policies specific to Punjab to effect their collective nosedive and genocide by instituting draconian laws that encourage ethnic cleansing in the name of "national security." Anyone with even a slight penchant for truth could apprehend why Sikhs cannot be Indians. All one needs, in fact, is common sense. The writing is on the wall, chiseled by the firm hands of our enemy. "To preserve the unity of India, if we have to eradicate 2-kror [20 million] Sikhs, we will do so." - Balram Jakhar, former Indian Cabinet Minister [23] and Speaker of the Indian Parliament. When the very existence of the Sikh people is at stake, the sacred words enshrined in Gurbani are there to show us the way. They cannot be overlooked for the sake of our coming generations. fareedaa baar paraa-i-ai baisnaa saaN-ee mujhai na deh. jay too ayvai rakhsee jee-o sareerahu layhi. Fareed begs, O Protector, do not make me sit at another's door. If this is the way you are going to keep me, then go ahead and take the life out of my body. ||42|| - Sri Guru Granth Sahib, page 1380

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

A S · 06 Aug 2005

Indian Patriot you claim that we are responsible for spoiling the peace in India and we are the ones casuing a split between Hindu and Sikh unity.... You know the ones who are causing a split between Hindu-Sikh unity are those bastards who masterminded the attack in '84, it's those government led Bahmin mobs that killed thousands of innocent Sikh men, women and children in cold blood after Indira Kuthi's death, it's those RSS clowns claiming that Khalsa is just an armed wing of Hinduism, it's low lifes like ashutosh 'Maharani' spitting their venom, it's the fact that murderers like KP Gill are not rotting in jail, it's the fact that when someone who is a devout Sikh goes to India he or she gets harrassed at the airport, and i go on and on. There are a lot of wounds that haven't healed up yet. Don't think we've all forgot about what was done to us. Trust me those wounds won't heal until we get justice for everything that was done. We didn't start this, but I I swear to you, we will finish it. 'Hindu'stan the "so-called" world's largest democracy hahah ya right! That country is saturated with corruption right to it's core. God help 'em. I don't know what India's future's gonna be like, but I can tell you that the future of Sikhi is very bright and the Khalsa is flourishing all over the world. "Physical death I do not fear. Death of the conscience is a sure death." -Sant-Siphai Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 08 Aug 2005

Sitara - please see below the answers to your last post, sorry for the delay however as communicated earlier I could only respond on Monday. - “I agree with you their is no harm in learning from other religious texts, but why focus explicitly on Hinduism? Why not send his followers to learn Islamic, Christian and Buddhist texts as well? After all Sikhi is a universal faith, is it not?” I think perhaps you are reading too much into Guru Ji sending 5 Sikhs to Kashi. However I think the answer to your query is quite obvious and I actually hinted to this in my last post. India was even more than today a predominately Hindu country, hence it makes logical sense to research the very people who form the vast majority of the land where you are situated (and who are becoming Sikh’s). Albeit I do not think that Guru Ji was exceptionally concerned which is why he only sent five Sikhs out of millions for the task. I do not consider that Guru Ji was on any mission to compile major investigations on all the Worlds numerous faiths. - “The only reason I think GuruJi did this is that the SGGS alludes quite a lot to Hindu philosophy. Let me give you an example. If I was a European or African individual and I took a keen interest in Gurmat, my first port of call would be to learn Punjabi and read the SGGS. Now if, for example, I wanted to know what 'Kal-Jug' is, how it came about etc etc, would the SGGS be able to answer this? The answer is probably not. I would have to go externaly and find this out from Hindu philosophy (i.e. the Veds/Puranas). So in a sense I feel that Gurbani is reliant on Hindu philosophy - this being the reason why Guru Ji sent five of his Sikhs to Kashi.” I see where you are coming from but see it from an entirely different angle. Firstly Sikhi is not reliant on Hindu philosophy alone, as Gurbani further makes numerous references to Islamic philosophy. However as you have stated it is important to have a basic knowledge of Indian mythology etc in order to understand some points of Sikhi ie Kaljug. However this does not require in-depth research and studying of the Vedas etc (Kalyug etc can quite easily be explained). In-fact as shown by the hundreds of thousands of non Indian Sikhs like myself one can nevertheless understand Sikhi without going into in-depth research of Hindu Philosophy. Hence the idea of needing to have thorough knowledge of the Vedas etc does not hold. This is further confirmed by Guru Ji who reveals how no one obtains God, understanding etc simply by research, studying or reading etc: "No one is saved by mere talk and speech, nor by reading loads of books. Page 59, Line 4 -- Guru Nanak Dev" "He cannot be understood by reading scriptures; the deceitful pretenders are deluded by doubt. Page 66, Line 18 -- Guru Amar Das" "Reading and studying, the Pandits and the silent sages have grown weary, but attached to the love of duality, they have lost their honour. Page 70, Line 3 -- Guru Amar Das" "Brahma wasted his life away, continually reading the Vedas. ||1|| Page 478, Line 7 -- Saint Kabir" In-fact someone can have complete ignorance of Hindu philosophy and still be acceptable as per Gurmat. "The Pandits, the religious scholars, have been burnt to death, while the illiterate ones run to safety. ||172|| Page 1373, Line 14 -- Saint Kabir" Gurbani is reliant on Hindu philosophy to some degree in that by an large Gurbani specifically argues against major aspects of Hindu philosophy as communicated earlier. Therefore to understand what Guru Ji is preaching against ie Vishnu, Brahma etc, the caste systems is, idol worship in Hinduism, pilgrimages etc it is useful to have a basic knowledge. However I do not believe that in-depth and detailed knowledge of Hinduism is required by all Sikhs to understand Gurbani. Likewise Guru Ji mentions Islamic practises which he preaches against, however I do not feel it is vital to have an advanced level of knowledge of Islam to understand Gurbani. - “Guru Gobind Singh did create a haven for Vedic research and scholarship i.e. the Nirmalas. They claim to be a Guru-ordained panth. I have seen their Ashram in Haridwar and I can tell for a fact they are hugely respected by the Hindu masses (including Brahimns). Their conclusion on the Vedas may be different to other Sampradrayas but never the less sadhus and Brahmins still touch their feet. They have a good knowledge of Hindu and Sikh philosophy. In some respects one could say seem more Hindu than Hindus themselves.” What I was referring to in my earlier post was that if Guru Gobind Singh Ji was determined to learn about the Vedas etc he would have obviously done more than send a mere five Sikhs to Kashi, and that the base of Sikhi (Anandpur Sahib) would have become a haven of Vedic research etc. The Nirmalas as you see them today were in-fact not specifically created by Guru Ji in the fist instance. Guru ji simply sent five Sikhs to the base of Hinduism not just to learn the Vedas which he could have easily done at Anandpur Sahib but to investigate and observe the practises of the majority people of India. The Nirmalas as we see today evolved over decades and centuries and did not exist in Guru Ji’s time. Hence Guru Ji did not send those five to start a new sect but to gain knowledge. The Nirmala sect of today is a result of years of evolution and did not exist in Guru ji’s time as present. I sincerely doubt that Guru Ji was exceptionally interested in creating a haven or sect based on Vedic research, as in his own words Guru Gobind SIngh Ji clearly says: "But the Vedas, Shiva, Rudra and Brahma could not Know His mystery and the secret of His notions. Page71 Line 3" "Even Vishnu cannot know His end and the Vedas and Katebs (Semitic Scriptures) call Him Indiscriminate. Page81 Line 12" "Sinmrit(i) Saasta Bed sabhai bahu bhed kahai ham ek naa jaanyo|| Sriasipaan kripaa tumrikar(i) main a kahyo sabh tohe bakhaanyo||863|| The Simritis, Shastras and Vedas describe several mysteries of yours, but I do not agree with any of them. O sword-wielder God! This all has been described by Thy Grace, what power can I have to write all this?. Page599 Line 7" "Dev adev maheedhar naagan siddh prasiddh ba?o tap(u) Keeno|| Bed Puraan Kuraan sabhai gun gaae thake pai to jaae na cheeno|| The god, demons, mountains, Nagas and adepts practised sever austerities; the Vedas, the Puranas and the Quran, al were tired of singing His Praises, even then they could not recognize His mystery; Page1546 Line 3" "Bed Kateh pa?e bahute din bhed kachhoo tin ko tah(i) paayo|| Poojat thaur anek phiryo par ek kabai hiya mai na basaayo|| You have studied Vedas and Katebs for a very long time, but still you could not comprehend His Mystery; you had been wandering at many places worshipping Him, but you never adopted that One Lord; Page1550 Line 3 " "The Lord is Formless, Sinless and shelterless: He is the Primal Power, Blemishlless, Behinningless and Unborn; The fool claims boastfully about the knowledge of His secrets, which even the VEDAS do not know.391. The fool considers Him a stone (Hindu Idol), but the great fool does not know any secret; He calls Shiva “The Eternal Lord, “but he does not know the secret of the Formless Lord.392." The last quote is from Chapai Sahib which Sikhs read both in the morning and at night, as well as being one of the five banis used to make Amrit. Hence I think Guru Ji’s position is quite clear regarding the need to have in-depth knowledge of the Vedas. However I would also say that in no way am I saying the Nirmala’s are not Sikhs or anything even close to that. They have developed into walking encyclopaedias who have in-depth knowledge of Sikhi as well as other faiths, which has undoubtedly helped the Panth. A prime example being Sant Maskeen who was trained and utilised the Nirmala ways of knowledge gathering and research. This gave him an in-depth knowledge of Gurbani, Quaran, Bible and all the Hindu texts which he used to enlighten the Sikh massed as well as discourse with scholars of other faiths on behalf of Sikhi.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

**- · 08 Aug 2005

Veer Singh Ji Many thanks for your reply. I hope you had a good weekend. I have read your reply to my post and all I can decipher from it is that when Gurbani does refer to the Vedas/Puranas it only does so as to deride the Hindu religion. What about when Gurbani refers to Hindu stories such as Bhagat Prahlad or Ajmaila? Do you not think that SGGS will be able to explain this without having to externally to Hindu Granths? -------------- What I was referring to in my earlier post was that if Guru Gobind Singh Ji was determined to learn about the Vedas etc he would have obviously done more than send a mere five Sikhs to Kashi, and that the base of Sikhi (Anandpur Sahib) would have become a haven of Vedic research etc. ---------- He sent five Sikhs to Kashi and not only that; he ensured that they were disguised as Hindus (tilak, dhoti etc) due to the rigid admission policies that were in place. Why go to such extreme lengths?. Also India already had numerous institutions of Vedic study in existence so Guru Ji probably thought that there was no use in creating another one. Also he may not have had the resources available (these institutions take many years and use a lot of resources). Just out of interest, the quotes you provided about the Hindu texts (i.e. about them not knowing the full limit of God) can the same be applied to the SGGS? Or are these quotes merely emphisizing that simply by studying these texts one will not achieve God realisation - in which case I am in complete agreement. With regards Chapai Sahib quote you reproduced, I find it difficult to comprehend that a daily religious prayer calls people fools just because they follow a differing belief system. I have yet to come across a daily prayer from another religion that does this. What I am trying to say is this: Prayer involves devotion to God and the practioner's aim is to develop love or Bhakti and become humble in front of God. Now I fail to see how referring to Hindus as fools in a daily prayer achieves this objective. Instead this type of derision is likely to give the devotee a superiority complex. E.g. 'Look at those foolish Hindus praying to their Lingams and their Murtis, I am glad I am not like that'. Anyway I'd like to thank you for providing the Chapai Sahib quote. I think it goes a long way in explaining why Sikhs in general have a disdain for Hindu culture. Best of Luck, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

khalsa · 08 Aug 2005

what is khalistan? there are no true sikhs in punjab- only 1% as the rest are "pattit". sikhs in india are not asking for khalistan. it is only the uneducated, uneployed thugs who cannot earn an honest living who turn into 'khalistanis'. there were times when people felt safe when there was a khalsa present but now if a full uniformed khalsa is travelling on a bus at night every body is scared of him including the sikhs. every sikh is trying to leave india and punjab is fast turning into 'bhaiya-stan' the dream of khalistan has long been over - if khalistanis want a khalistan...then perhaps they would be better off fighting (arguing) for it in india - NRI's will never be taken seriously. do as the Babbar Akalis did when they went to fight for an independant india not hiding in western gurdwaras and shouting for khalistan. all mouth and no action only makes the speakers look foolish. hindus are human just like us. every kom has good and bad...so does sikhi.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Mehtab Singh · 09 Aug 2005

very well said khalsa ji

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 09 Aug 2005

Hi Sitara, - “I have read your reply to my post and all I can decipher from it is that when Gurbani does refer to the Vedas/Puranas it only does so as to deride the Hindu religion. What about when Gurbani refers to Hindu stories such as Bhagat Prahlad or Ajmaila? Do you not think that SGGS will be able to explain this without having to externally to Hindu Granths?” Gurbani makes references to well known stories known through out India in order to give a message/moral. These stories are/were known by all the common people who Guru Ji obviously wanted to interact with and teach. There is absolutely no need to dwell into Hindu Granths to get a very deep and exhaustive account of these stories as the aim of Guru Ji using them is to give a moral/parable, and not a factual account of any story. Bhai Gurdas even goes as far as using traditional Indian love stories to give a message and moral. Hence it is clear that one need not dwell into Hindu Granths as Gurbani is simply using and utilising popular stories re-written which common people already knew and could relate to, in order to give a message, rather than a factual account of Hindu stories. - “He sent five Sikhs to Kashi and not only that; he ensured that they were disguised as Hindus (tilak, dhoti etc) due to the rigid admission policies that were in place. Why go to such extreme lengths?. Also India already had numerous institutions of Vedic study in existence so Guru Ji probably thought that there was no use in creating another one. Also he may not have had the resources available (these institutions take many years and use a lot of resources). “ As per being disguised, this is not an extreme length by any means but common sense. It would have been pointless and a complete waste of time to send the five Sikh’s to Kashi’s if they could not even gain entry, hence the disguise. As per Guru Ji wanting to create an institute for Vedic research I think Guru Ji own words on the Vedas as communicated earlier make it crystal clear that this was not one of his interests or intentions. - “Just out of interest, the quotes you provided about the Hindu texts (i.e. about them not knowing the full limit of God) can the same be applied to the SGGS? Or are these quotes merely emphasising that simply by studying these texts one will not achieve God realisation - in which case I am in complete agreement.” Gurbani makes it clear from the outset that by simply reading any text God can not be realised. The Guru Ji himself in Gurbani states how he can not find God’s limits which is God’s greatness and beautiful. Guru Granth Sahib Ji does not hide this fact but celebrates and invokes it. - “With regards Chapai Sahib quote you reproduced, I find it difficult to comprehend that a daily religious prayer calls people fools just because they follow a differing belief system. I have yet to come across a daily prayer from another religion that does this. -What I am trying to say is this: Prayer involves devotion to God and the practitioner’s aim is to develop love or Bhakti and become humble in front of God. Now I fail to see how referring to Hindus as fools in a daily prayer achieves this objective. Instead this type of derision is likely to give the devotee a superiority complex. E.g. 'Look at those foolish Hindus praying to their Lingams and their Murtis, I am glad I am not like that'.” Chapaia Sahib is in-fact full to the brim with devotion, with Guru Ji starting with humble requests for the thirst of bhakti to God never to be quenched. As with most Gurbani it is unique as it contains all aspects of prayer, not just supplications but also teachings for the foolish mind. Whilst Guru Ji starts off with sincere devotion etc Gurbani always gives updesh (teachings) and is not a simple prayer. Hence Guru Ji calling people fools who believe in stones is his updesh teachings and one which all Sikh’s should follow (ie don’t worship Hindu idols/stones). The whole point of the Guru is to give teachings as well as bhakti towards God, without the Guru’s teachings their can be no Sikhi. Guru Ji does not mix his words and is clear on his position, which is very important as without it Sikhs would quickly loose his teachings (some have anyway). However whilst Guru Ji has clearly shown many Hindu and other faiths acts as not acceptable likewise anyone’s right to practise them is 100% practically and historically supported, as per Guru Teg Behadur’s martyrdom etc. I personally love Chapai Sahib as not only does it give a clear indication of what Gurmat is but is also full of true devotion and love for God. - “Anyway I'd like to thank you for providing the Chapai Sahib quote. I think it goes a long way in explaining why Sikhs in general have a disdain for Hindu culture.” You can see how Sikh’s feel irritation as when Gurmat is clear on certain issues, nevertheless real attempts are being made by certain groups (while everyone else remains conveniently silent) to call and label us as Hindu’s, when we are so clearly not. Bye

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

To Indian patriot · 09 Aug 2005

LOL i bet "khalsa" is one of those RSS hindu snakes that like to slither around on sikh websites Spread their "BS" "there are no true sikhs in punjab" "sikhs inm india are not asking for khalisatan" Seriousley, you realy need to GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT.-dont listen to the indian media, its incredibly biased. "it is only the uneducated, uneployed thugs who cannot earn an honest living who turn into 'khalistanis'." -this is the kinda s*** nonesense views the indian pro right wing hindustani governemt media likes to churn out, heard it all before nothing new here. You know thats funny' its only after a long while doing plenty of research on the cause have made me and my peers realsie khalistan is a mus, as for your last coments on speakers hiding in western gurdwaras, well they only ther to make people aware of the cause. words from beants singh 'why i am not an indian: "Our fight in not against Hindus; it is against the Indian state. Because the Sikhs firmly oppose the apartheid that the horrific caste system promotes through stratification of society, those Hindus at the apex of the caste pyramid are certain to be disturbed." "Anyone with even a slight penchant for truth could apprehend why Sikhs cannot be Indians. All one needs, in fact, is common sense. The writing is on the wall, chiseled by the firm hands of our enemy." "To preserve the unity of India, if we have to eradicate 2-kror [20 million] Sikhs, we will do so." - Balram Jakhar, former Indian Cabinet Minister and Speaker of the Indian Parliament."

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 09 Aug 2005

As for Khalistan the fact is that it is a reaction to Indian oppression, i.e. the Hindu anti Sikh riots, unjustified Operation Blue Star, Extra Judicial killings of Sikhs, torture, and Right Wing Hindu groups attack on the Sikh faith. It the above did not/is not happening their would be no demand, its as simple as that.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Siddharth · 09 Aug 2005

<> TOTALLY UNTRUE. Here is an article from Time Magazine dated July 1955. Sikhs were asking for Sikhistan as far back as 1950. time magazine - july 4, 1955 Sikhistan The idea of having their own home state became firmly fixed in the Sikh mind at the time of the partition of old British India, when some Sikh country was shaved off to make part of what is now West Pakistan. Forced to move out, the Sikhs left a trail of massacre behind them, and were furious when Nehru ordered their swords to be sewn into their leather scabbards. Said old Tara Singh: 'When the Moslems can get Pakistan, and the Hindus India, why not a Sikhs' Sikhistan?' But Nehru's Congress Party won over many of Tara Singh's followers to the idea of peace, and of a multiracial India. In the 1951 general elections, Tara Singh's Shiromani Akali party lost heavily. 'Ye unbelievers,' cried old Tara Singh from out the depths of a magnificent beard, 'there will come a time when you will need me and flock around me - for your very survival!' The time came when Nehru, reluctantly yielding to pressure from India's many language groups, appointed a State Reorganization Committee to advise 'on the realigning of states within India.' By skillful gerrymandering, Tara Singh worked out a scheme for a Punjabi-speaking state of 35,458 square miles, containing a population of 12 million, with the Sikhs in a slight minority. 'We multiply faster than Hindus and are more virile,' said Tara Singh. 'In ten years we will be in an absolute majority, leaving the soft-fleshed Hindus to trail behind.' Two months ago Tara Singh's party, regaining its popularity, began whooping it up for Sikhistan.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

khalsa · 09 Aug 2005

Indian patriot i'm not a hindu and also not a member of rss. get your facts right. every sikh youth in punjab is itching to leave punjab not because of hindus or indian government but they want to be par with you. majority of them are on drugs or other intoxications. how many of them do nitname? those who think they are sikhs they follow "bipran ki reet". there is no doubt you can have khalistah but become true sikhs first sikh of guru granth sahib ji. not sikhs of this baba or that baba or this jatha or that jatha.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

khalsa · 09 Aug 2005

to indian patroit i am an amritdhari sikh and probably much better read than you. i don't believe in babas and sants. i believe in my amrit and my gurus. i see the guru granth sahib as my leader and am no 'snake' come back and have this discussion with me when you have grown up..or better yet...learnt to open your eyes. khalistan is a long forgotten dream by the educated minority and an unattainable promised land for the uneducated majority. the people who stand in wesyern gurdwaras mouthing off don't want khalistan...they want donations and charity - that will never reach those who need it but will line the pockets of these so called speakers for justice. the arguements over khalistan amongst sikhs is exactly what the indian government wanted. it was the simple matter of divide and conquer - and they succeeded - don't believe me? punjab is still waiting for its independance...thats proof enough.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Singh · 10 Aug 2005

Siddharth My staemtnet is actually not untrue. I totally agree that the idea of Khalistan has been around for years, even pre-1947. However this is not what I meant when saying Khalistan was a reaction to Indian Oppression. The fact is that the idea of a Sikh homeland actually pre-dates India itself, and can even be said to go as far back as the 18 century. However I was referring to the modern and obviously more relevant Khalistan movement i.e. since 1984. Perhaps I should have made it more clear, apologies for that. I don’t think anyone can constructively argue that the demand for Khalistan (modern struggle ie since the 80s to be more clear) was not fuelled by the atrocities committed by the Indian State ie 84 riots, operation blue star etc. Even Jarnail Singh did not want a Khalistan which he clearly stated, and revealed that the foundation will ONLY be laid if we are attacked ie as a reaction to military force against the Sikhs.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

mussapuria · 10 Aug 2005

pyarey khalsa bhai lets put aside all debates political, social, financial. i have no idea about khalistan, its leaders how it will be but one thing is sure, we believe in karmic reactions hunah bhai? When a whole komb is targetted by state machinery, systematic rapes, murders, mass genocides, children ripped in half do you not feel the indian machinery has ammased a huge debt to pay to the sikh komb? imagine how much one individual police officer , such as kps gill will have to pay when he passes from this life? then think of sajjan kumar? then think of those who stood by and supported the gullokara, and finally singh ji think of the ruler king. The state machinery actively participated. I know we should not constantly say it is a hindu rule, let us call it a corrupt rule whatever it is, surely it will have to pay back a very heavy price in future. I recall bhai kulbir singh once mentioning karmic philosophy where if a person slaps another they pay back much more according to karam.

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

singh m · 10 Aug 2005

gurcharn singh ji very well said most of these snakes live on social security benifits and do not earn dassan nauhan di kirt those who work change their out fit when go to work or at weekend when go to the gurdwara. they change their colours like girgitt their uniforn change when they go to india they spread hatred nothing else [%sig%]

Re: why Some Sikhs hate Hindus

Indian Patriot -Gaurav Sawhney · 15 Aug 2005

To KHALSA & Others! Pal probably you are mixing ME (Indian Patriot -Gaurav Sawhney) with one 'To Indian patriot'. AFFIDAVIT! I have only posted ONE view before this, that on '08-05-05 16:07' & this 'To Indian Patriot' is NOT ME! To KHALSA & Others! Pal probably you are mixing ME (Indian Patriot -Gaurav Sawhney) with one 'To Indian patriot'. AFFIDAVIT! I have only posted ONE view before this, that on '08-05-05 16:07' & this 'To Indian Patriot' is NOT ME! Take care!