Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

why do hindus hate sikhs so much

why do hindus hate sikhs so much

search for tat · 03 Aug 2005

now that we have resolved that sikhs do not hate hindus, maybe the hindus here can now answer why hindus hate sikhs so much? why do they disrespect any sardar with sardar jokes? why the constant reference to sardar jokes? why call sikhs "sikhre"? why when so many sikhs gave shaheedi for indian independance, why are none of them recognised? why do hindus not accept the distinct independant nature of sikhism, and that it is not part of hinduism? why are sikhs not allowed a sikh marriage act, but are forced to use the hindu marriage act? why when thousands of sikhs were killed and raped in the delhi riots, why has not one person been brought to justice? why did hindus revel in mass genocide in punjab? why are punjab waters being stolen from it? why is the electricity created by punjba not used by punjab, but used by delhi, and punjab has to buy its own electricity back from delhi? why are hindus intentionally encouraging anti-sikhs groups like narakdaris, noormalhis, etc? why did the indian government intentionally make punjab a drug den to defuse sikh militancy? why are the sacrifices of Guru Tegh Bhahdahur ji not commemorated nationwide in India? why do hindus even lets the ultra right wing RSS exist? are they not embrassed by its activities? ( such as Godhra riots) why were sikhs not allowed radio stations in punjab for so long? why are still thousands of sikh youth languishing in jails without charge? why do so many hindu group openly preach hatred against any minority group? just a start...........

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

**- · 03 Aug 2005

----------- why do they disrespect any sardar with sardar jokes? ---------- This is out of order when Hindus do this. But I don't think Hindus do it out of hate. It is like when the English make jokes about the Irish. However this can get out of hand. ------- why call sikhs "sikhre"? ------- Never heard of this. ----------- why when so many sikhs gave shaheedi for indian independance, why are none of them recognised? ----------- I think they are. So many films have been made about them. Anyway what are you after, a Hindu seal of approval? --------- why do hindus not accept the distinct independant nature of sikhism, and that it is not part of hinduism? ----------- I don't know. I wish they would but it is not as simple as that. Many Hindus and Sikhs intermarry and they have a very close and connected relationship. We are very similar to each other in our habits and customs. But I have found that when Hindus do exclude Sikhs in their events, we also get criticism from Sikhs such as Namdharis, Nirmalas etc. --------- why are sikhs not allowed a sikh marriage act, but are forced to use the hindu marriage act? ------- This is a political issue not 'Hindus hate Sikhs' issue. -------- why when thousands of sikhs were killed and raped in the delhi riots, why has not one person been brought to justice? -------- What about the thousands of Hindus that were raped and killed in Punjab? Hindus have apologised for the actions of a few but Sikhs are not willing to acknowledge their wrongs. The arguement we usually get is that the did not have 'Jeevan' or that they are not Sikhs. Anyway I as a Hindu apologise for the actions of the evil individuals that did this in 1984. ----- why did hindus revel in mass genocide in punjab? ----- The same reason why some US citizens revel at the bombings in Afghanistan. Hindus were led to believe that the GoI were targetting terrorisits and nothing more. It was nothing to do with destroying Sikhi. ------- why are punjab waters being stolen from it? ------- I don't understand this. It seems that it is only Sikhs that have an issue with this. I have never heards a Hindu Punjabi complain about this. Water is a natrual resource - Sikhs do not have a monoploy on who can drink water etc. Water is a birthright of every individual regardless of creed. I don't see why you have to bring religion into this matter. It makes you look merciless - i.e. that you hate Hindus so much that you don't want them to have drinking water. ------- why is the electricity created by punjba not used by punjab, but used by delhi, and punjab has to buy its own electricity back from delhi? ------- This is a government policy issue and nothing to do with 'Hindus hating Sikhs'. ------ why are hindus intentionally encouraging anti-sikhs groups like narakdaris, noormalhis, etc? ------ We don't encourage them. So what if a few Hindus follow them, it is their choice. I found Nirankaris to be the one of the most peaceful, intelligent and spiritually elavated individuals I have ever met. I could also argue that why did Sikhs collaborate with anti-Hindu Islamic millitants in Pakistan during the late 1980's to early 1990's. ------ why did the indian government intentionally make punjab a drug den to defuse sikh militancy? ------ Every state has its issues with the GoI but Punjab is the only one that seem to always bring religion into it. ---- why are the sacrifices of Guru Tegh Bhahdahur ji not commemorated nationwide in India? ---- Becasue India is suppose to be a secular nation. Anyway many Hindus do celibrate the commemoration of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji but they are always accused of trying to merge Sikhi with Hinduism. What do you want from us: treat Sikhs as a seperate religion and let them celibrate their own festivals or Hindus to celibrate Sikh festivals with the likely risk of being accused of swallowing up Sikhi? -------- why do hindus even lets the ultra right wing RSS exist? are they not embrassed by its activities? ( such as Godhra riots) -------- I am embarassed of thier activities, I can't speak for others. Godhra riots is a Hindu-Muslim issue. It has nothing to do with Sikhs. ----- why were sikhs not allowed radio stations in punjab for so long? ----- Again this is government protocol. I think you are looking to deep into this issue and looking for a conspiracy theory. ----- why are still thousands of sikh youth languishing in jails without charge? ---- why are still tens-of-thousands of hindu youth languishing in jails without charge? Go to Bihar and see if you don't believe me. ---- why do so many hindu group openly preach hatred against any minority group? ----- Apart from RSS, VHP, Shiv-Sena and Bajrang-Dal - who by the way are political organisations - can you tell me which groups are doing this? Does ISKCON do this? What about Swaminarayan? Does Shankaracharya matt do this? The Sri Vaishnavas of South India? Is it our Katha-Vachaks such as Ramesh Bhai Oza? Kirit Bhai Ji? Morari Bapu? who? I have heard a lot of Sikhi/Gurbani Kathas spoken by eminent Sikhs personalities who deride Hindu religion to such an extent that it I found it very upsetting. Sant Singh Maskeen is a start.... [%sig%]

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

manjh payara guru ko · 03 Aug 2005

hindus are pather-poojk(shiv-ling)but sikhs are not. thats why hindu hate sikhs.hindu have so many devte(33-caror)but sikhs have only siri guru granth sahib ji. thats the reason hindu hate sikhs. mr sitaram you said marriage is political issue no its not it is a power issue now hindus in power but when sikhs will in power it will solve automaticly. [%sig%]

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

Singh · 03 Aug 2005

I think that it is not Hindus, but politicians who make communities hate each other.

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

Bhopinder Singh · 03 Aug 2005

sitaravan de How come marriage is political issue terming a moslem as hindu in a written law is communalism not politics

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

**- · 03 Aug 2005

manjh payara guru ko I am a pather-poojak and I don't hate Sikhs. I also believe in 33 crore devtas but still I don't hate Sikhs. Its all in you immagination brother. Mehtab Singh is a Hindu convert to Sikhi and his parents still love him despite being pather-poojaks. Sitara

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

**- · 03 Aug 2005

Bhopinder Singh Ji Please address me with my proper name as I do so with you. You know it is a great insult to a person when you do this and it degrades your character. I have not shown you nor anyone else on this board any disrespect so please kindly pay me the same token. I think that you are right, this marriage law should be re-named - there! Are you happy now! But what can I do, I am a nobody. Best Wishes Sitara

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

Bhopinder Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Sitaravan ji What about the thousands of Hindus that were raped and killed in Punjab? Hindus have apologised for the actions of a few but Sikhs are not willing to acknowledge their wrongs. The arguement we usually get is that the did not have 'Jeevan' or that they are not Sikhs. Anyway I as a Hindu apologise for the actions of the evil individuals that did this in 1984 ____________________________________________________________ Please check your facts every murder was accounted for in PUNJAB every incident resulted in killing of Sikhs in fake encounters and Hindus were given justice Not even one police encounter for Delhi riots We need our own country we dont need anything from you also incidents of punjab were individuals but your hindu side was a state ( police, parmilitary, military , statesmen very similar to the nazi extermination of the jews)

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

**- · 03 Aug 2005

Veer Bhopinder Singh Ji, It is obvious that you do not respect me. If really wanted an honest dialogue you would have addressed me with my proper name but instead you have opted for the immature way. I would have had more respect for you if you had admitted your error and rectified what you have done but you have failed to do this. Therefore my dialogue with you ends here. I wish you the best of luck in the future and hope you can look into yourself and ask your self why do you show an individual disrespect simply because he has different view and a different religion to yourself. Best of luck, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

Bhopinder Singh · 03 Aug 2005

I show no disrespect to you as a individual but you views are cunning and shrewd on the one hand you spew venom on sikhs and at the same time cornered in questions your answer is I can do nothing ( mockingly) it seem clear I think no Hindu forum would let a Sikh say such things ___________________________________________________________ Please check your facts every murder was accounted for in PUNJAB every incident resulted in killing of Sikhs in fake encounters and Hindus were given justice Not even one police encounter for Delhi riots We need our own country we dont need anything from you also incidents of punjab were individuals but your hindu side was a state ( police, parmilitary, military , statesmen very similar to the nazi extermination of the jews) ___________________________________________________________ You never answered this

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

manjh payara guru ko · 03 Aug 2005

Not even one police encounter for Delhi riots . sitara ji answer this [%sig%]

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

?? · 03 Aug 2005

maskeen jee does beautiful katha..dont knock it.

Re: why do hindus hate sikhs so much

Mehtab Singh · 03 Aug 2005

yayyyyyyyy!!! lets bully this one single hindu on this forum and show we are lions!!! bbbrrrruuuuaaahhhh...grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr