Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

BHATARER

BHATARER

proud to be sikhan de kuri · 04 Aug 2005

Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ke Fateh Sat Siri Akal Ji, I just wanted to come on this site to express my feelings and attitude towards 'bhatarer'. Basically having looked at various sites on the net, i feel greatly saddened to what our fellow brothers and sisters have to say about them. Therefore i would like to say a few words.... YES - bhatarer did serve meat in Gurdwara's (i know, in Sikhi its forbidden) BUT, i think the number of Gurdwara that now serve tea, samosa's and porkorer for the Bharats breakfast has SIGNIFICANTLY increased. Now on weddings, when breakfast (in the minority of cases) is to be served it is served in the SEPERATE community centre, NOT in the Lungar hall. Another point i would like to make is, as future generations carry on, obviously they will be more modern and more educated in Sikhi, then the previous generations. Due to books/Literature, television/documentaries, radio stations & Gurmat camps etc i think there will be gradual improvement in the conduct of Bhatarer. There will be a greater understanding of sikhism then what our great Dader Ji's had. Do you see where i'm sort of coming from? Sadh Sangat Ji, i don't want to sound like a hypocrite, as i know in sikhs were even supposed to have castes, but being raised as a bhatari, i just felt the need to express my views. Personally i would have never ate sausage and bacon etc at a Gurdwara, which is why i think its wrong to paint everyone with the same brush. I'm really sorry if i've offended anyone by writing what just have done, but i hope it sheds some light on the question of 'Do Bhatarer still serve meat at Gurdwara's?' Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ke Fateh

Re: BHATARER

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Aug 2005

I AM NOT PATRONISING OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT...but what the heck..dont worry about what others say..PRACTISE SIKHEE and make the GURU Happy. Charreedeekalla ALWAYS is my MOTTO.

Re: BHATARER

Singh · 04 Aug 2005

Bhainji, Isn't it sad that you should feel the need or compulsion to come here on this message board and defend yourself for being born in a Bhatra family? Did you have any control over the fact? Need you justify your blood? No. If you are amritdhari then your only Jaat Paat is Satguru. You are Khalsa and that's it. Even if you aren't amritdhari, there is no reason for you to feel insecure about your forefathers. Whatever they are and did should have no bearing on you. When we find out someone's caste, it will be a great day when we can reply, "who cares?"

Re: BHATARER

Singh · 05 Aug 2005

What is a bhatarer?

Re: BHATARER

no one · 05 Aug 2005

What is bhatarer? Never heard of this before.

Re: BHATARER

hmm · 07 Aug 2005

wjkk wjkf bhatarer is a caste..like jatt and..hmm..takhan. we don't believe in them! stay sikhi and dont go wondering off into hindu beliefs.caste systems are anti-gurmat therfore no sikh should believe in them. i agree when bhajee sed that if you have taken amrit..then you are part of the khalsa, you gave your HEAD TO GURU JEE...you are not part of watever you were before..even who your mother and father and place of birth has changed!gurooo! dhan dhan siri guru gobind singh sahib jee! wjkk wjkf

Re: BHATARER

dont know · 08 Aug 2005

arshi u speak so elegantly haha

Re: BHATARER

sikh · 08 Aug 2005

i think meat and pork is just an excuse to cuss the old battras down. Other gurdwaras to do exactly th same thing to this day which are not bhattra. One day i went to singh sabha southall, a very old tall sevedar with a blue pagh just shouted out in the langar "oh s4l.. papa p... ch... whil reffering to a convo he had with someone. These are not one offs they are revolting part of life the bad side we experience in gurdwaras. We also harbour some kind of grudge against rajputs eventhough many famous gursikhs hailed from rajput backgrounds. I think we needto critically scrutinise the use of some terms and words on our religious textbooks and authors. Like rather than say rajput why not royals? there are many rajput sikhs who will feel offended when sikhs here will keep on saying remember those rajput women married to muslim men? its not a nice thing to keep saying. Sometimes people ask are they even sikh for having seperate gurdwara? Instead why not understand why they went down that road to start with? Plenty of reforming is needed to bring us all closer together so we do not walk the same way as our grandads did in splitting us all up. i understand what our phenji said at the start, and let us hope and pray we all become one.,

Re: BHATARER

sikh · 08 Aug 2005

n when i said othr gurdara do same i mean seperate langar halls away from premises, but they seem to escape the caste wrath.