Sachkhand or Charaasi Lakh - only 2 options?
kaur · 05 Aug 2005
Is there something in the middle? another human life perhaps? If we're amritdhaari but dont reach sachkhand in one janam are we sent back into the cycle of birth and death?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
kaur · 05 Aug 2005
Is there something in the middle? another human life perhaps? If we're amritdhaari but dont reach sachkhand in one janam are we sent back into the cycle of birth and death?... · 05 Aug 2005
I think there is a lot in between. Dharam Khand is where we must all go. In Dharam Khand we'll be judged and have our account read to us. If there are good karma then we may be sent to Swarag and if bad, then narak. These are temporary places and after a stay there, the soul returns to chaurasi lakh joon. Perhaps in Dharam Khand people who were close to becoming Dharmi or were Dharmi are sent back to be humans again. Above Dharam Khand are Gian Khand, Sharam Khand, Karam Khand and Sach Khand. Gian Khand is above heaven and is all knowledge but again, not permanent. Sharam Khand is where we receive a totally new understanding of everything. Karam Khand is also where Bhagats reside and it is a permanent place. Then of course is Sachkhand. I think there are a lot of different outcomes in the afterlife. Though I suppose we won't know until we get there or do enough naam kamaiee to know while on Earth.vichar · 06 Aug 2005
amritdharees aren't born again, as long you have kept youre rehit, on leaving this body you will join with god.vichar · 06 Aug 2005
There are two types of mukti, both for gursikhs only 1) jeevan mukt - dead while alive 2)maran mukt - mukt once body dies it is explained in one of bhai sahibs books, could kulbir singh please expandees · 06 Aug 2005
jamaka(n)kar naerr n aavee gurasikh piaarae ||1|| rehaao || The Messenger of Death does not even approach the beloved Sikhs of the Guru.vivek · 06 Aug 2005
jin har naamaa har chaethiaa hiradhai our dhhaarae || thin jam naerr n aavee gurasikh gur piaarae ||14|| keeping naam-divine with loving devotion in ones heart, one is saved from yama, o beloved gursikhs of guru.;) · 06 Aug 2005
"Dharam Khand, Gian Khand, Sharam Khand, Karam Khand and Sach Khand" i always thought they were achived in this world while we are still in human form i thought Hell & Heaven are just states of mind, both can be achieved in this life, one can be in heaven if he/she has Naam i don't beleive we go to Hell or Heaven after death, where you get pleasures or pain.. i feel this type of Heaven/Hell goes against the fundamentals of Sikhi Bepending on your Kamai, you will be either be born again (the no. of lifes depends upon your kamai) but if you have reached Sach Khand in this life you are already one with Akal Purkh, this means to more birthsksingh · 06 Aug 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh if we get swarag for our good karmas and narak for our bad karma.then why we get pleasures and sufferrings on this earth. late gyani sant singh ji maskeen several times mentioned in his katha that there is no heaven and no hell. bhul chuk maafkaur · 06 Aug 2005
------ Author: vichar Date: 08-06-05 02:57 amritdharees aren't born again, as long you have kept youre rehit, on leaving this body you will join with god. ----- that's like saying every single amritdhari who keeps rehit is a sach khand vaasi. i dont think that's true... not all amritdhaaris who keep strict rehit have overcome the panj doot... i read somewhere that 99% of us are in dharam khand. how can we join with god if we're still in dharam khand?charanjeev singh · 06 Aug 2005
It is my understanding that Dharam Khand, Gyan Khand and Sharam Khand, are achieved by following the instructions of Sri Guru Sahib. However, Karam Khand is then only given as Guru Sahibs Kirpaa. And once Guru Sahib gives Kirpa into Karam Khand there is not turning back; you are in here for Good. And once you are in Karam Khand you are blessed into Sach Khand. This is my humble opinion and understanding bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikiftehvichar · 07 Aug 2005
many non-believers are known for mouthing "this world is the end, there is no hereafter. those who are enjoying worldly comforts here are indeed enjoying heaven. Those with a life of poverty and suffering here are verily undergoing hell" This kind of make believe does not hold - bahuth dhhanaadt achaarava(n)th sobhaa niramal reeth || You may possess vast riches, maintain virtuous conduct, have a spotless reputation and observe religious customs; maath pithaa suth bhaaeeaa saajan sa(n)g pareeth || you may have the loving affections of mother, father, children, siblings and friends; lasakar tharakasaba(n)dh ba(n)dh jeeo jeeo sagalee keeth || you may have armies well-equipped with weapons, and all may salute you with respect; chith n aaeiou paarabreham thaa kharr rasaathal dheeth ||7|| But still, if you do not come to remember the Supreme Lord God, then you shall be taken and consigned to the most hideous hell! ||7|| If heaven is enjoying worldly copmforts on this earth why should he have to go to hell in the hereafter?vichar · 07 Aug 2005
;) sed-i don't beleive we go to Hell or Heaven after death aaj maerai man pragatt bhaeiaa hai paekheealae dhharamaraaou || Today, it became clear to my mind that the Righteous Judge of Dharma is watching us. theh kar dhal karan mehaabalee thin aagalarrai mai rehan n jaae ||4|| His messengers, with their awesome power, crush people between their hands; I cannot stand against them. ||4|| heaven and hell is on this earth? lol have you not heard of jam dhoots? you really should spend time researching gurbani, stop walking around with youre eyes closed har kaa naam jin man n aaraadhhaa || One whose mind does not contemplate the Name of the Lord chor kee niaaee jam pur baadhhaa ||6|| is bound like a thief, in the City of yama. ||6|| JAM PUR is the region yamas (in other words hell)vichar · 07 Aug 2005
sabh ko laekhae vich hai manamukh aha(n)kaaree || All are held accountable, even the egotistical self-willed manmukhs har naam kadhae n chaethee jamakaal sir maaree || They never even think of the Name of the Lord; the MESSENGER OF DEATH shall HIT them on their HEADS NO SUCH THING AS HELL????????? jinee naam visaariaa bahu karam kamaavehi hor || Those who forget the Naam and do other things, naanak JAM PUR badhhae maareeahi jio sa(n)nhee oupar chor ||1|| O Nanak, will be bound and gagged and beaten in the City of Death, like the thief caught red-handed. ||1||vivek · 07 Aug 2005
;) sed theres no such thing as hell after death sree raam naamaa ouchar manaa || Chant the Name of the Supreme Lord, O my mind. aagai jam dhal bikham ghanaa terrible is the army of yamas in the hereafter ;) ji, you really should read some books, try bhai rama singhs, or unditti duniya.ees · 07 Aug 2005
many gursikhs have seen other regions like hell, eg- bhai rama singh ji, you should read his book, he describes hell and the jam dhoot administering punishmentksingh · 07 Aug 2005
wjkk wjkf so does it mean that it is a disputed subject in sikhism because gyani sant singh ji maskeen has said there is no heaven no hell in his katha many times.he several times mentioned that these places are on earth and i don't think panth ratan late gyani sant singh ji maskeen propagate lies about sikhism bhul chuk maafees · 07 Aug 2005
maskeen used to preach, which itself is against gurmat, as you may have read previous posts many gursikhs of high avastha have seen hell with their inner eyes, read undittti duniya, or bhai rama singhs book maskeen didnt lie, lies are intentional, he is not a guru, therefore not perfect and can make mistakestruthseeker · 07 Aug 2005
who cares what maskeen sed? look what youre guru has sed, - aagai jam dhal bikham ghanaa terrible is the army of yamas in the hereafter -------------------------------------------------------------- jinee naam visaariaa bahu karam kamaavehi hor || Those who forget the Naam and do other things, naanak JAM PUR badhhae maareeahi jio sa(n)nhee oupar chor ||1|| O Nanak, will be bound and gagged and beaten in the City of Death, like the thief caught red-handed ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ sabh ko laekhae vich hai manamukh aha(n)kaaree || All are held accountable, even the egotistical self-willed manmukhs har naam kadhae n chaethee jamakaal sir maaree || They never even think of the Name of the Lord; the MESSENGER OF DEATH shall HIT them on their HEADS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------truthseeker · 07 Aug 2005
jio jio chalehi chubhai dhukh paavehi jamakaal sehehi sir dda(n)ddaa hae ||2|| The more they walk away, the deeper it pierces them, and the more they suffer in pain, until finally, the Messenger of Death SMASHES his CLUB on their HEADS.South of surrey · 07 Aug 2005
there are different groups in sikh each having their own take...the respected gyani Sant Singh ji MAskeen was more aligned with SGPC thinking, hence the non-acceptance of heaven, hell, and other "super natural" stuff. if you follow Taksali maryada, you know that Sikhi believes in heavens, hells, khands, sachkhand, and devpuris(these are personal abodes of some devi/devta)*. Dharam Raj can flush you down into hell, put into the reincarnation cycle, give you your time in heaven, all depending on your actions. If you're headed for sachkhand, then you don't even need to see Dharam Raj. *not sure if devpuris are accepted by Taksal.vichar · 08 Aug 2005
kaur says- that's like saying every single amritdhari who keeps rehit is a sach khand vaasi. i dont think that's true... not all amritdhaaris who keep strict rehit have overcome the panj doot... i read somewhere that 99% of us are in dharam khand. how can we join with god if we're still in dharam khand? Guru Arjan Dev Ji says- sathigur sikh kaa halath palath savaarai || The True Guru arranges this world and the next for His Sikh naanak sathigur sikh ko jeea naal samaarai ||1|| O Nanak, Satguru extends all motherly care to the Sikh. ||1|| Maran Mukht- 5 dhoot are destroyed at death, SatGuru gives nectarian amrit naam to his devotee's who were unable to achieve naam ras in there life, this is explained in bhai sahibs book. by the way there are fewer amritdharees then you think, most need to go pesh for not having full isnaan (ie kesh) others eat from the hands of smokers (restaurants) in the west many many singhnees have done kesha di beadbi, and there husbands dont stop marrital relations with them so they too are peshi and the list goes on.....????? · 09 Aug 2005
i dunno if this is right but i heard that if ur amritdharee nd u keep ur rehit u dont go through all the charaasi lakh births nd deaths... u get another human life... another chance 2 get 2 waheguru well thats if u dont get 2 waheguru in this life.... thats what i heard... plz correct me if im wrong.... wjkk wjkfvichar · 09 Aug 2005
according to Bhai Sahib who based all his books on gurbani you are wrong gursikhs are not born againksingh · 09 Aug 2005
wjkk wjkf if sachkhand and chaurasi lakh are the only two options then where will persons with very low iq or mentally retarded go . these types of persons don't understand naam japna or amrit chhaknavichar · 10 Aug 2005
sachkand and chorasee lakh are NOT the only options ksingh try reading some of bhai sahibs books, i give up.........................