Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Rakhri??

Rakhri??

Droplet · 06 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Sangat ji, what are your views and gurmat views on rakhri??? is it wrong to tie it out of respect fro parents who believe in it?? as i personally don't see the significance of a thread. bhul chuk marf karni ji. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: Rakhri??

A S · 06 Aug 2005

Rakhri is a Bahmin ritual, just like Holi, Lorhi etc. They have no place in Sikhi. Let's not do "Bipran ki Reet" Let's cut it out.

Re: Rakhri??

... · 06 Aug 2005

Why do Nihungs have Holi colours all over them at Holla Mohalla?

Re: Rakhri??

Opinion · 07 Aug 2005

If you view it in its historical sense, the tradition of rakhri seems to dis-empower women as solely reliant on the men of the house-hold for protection. In this light, rakhri is not holding with Sikh values which treats both sexes equally. However, I have not met anyone in my generation who carries this outdated view of rakhri. Pretty much everyone I have met takes this as a day to celebrate brotherly-sisterly love - a day much like a birthday or an anniversary. Is a string needed to show this love or affection? Of course not but as a special day for celebrating this sibling relationship, I can see no harm in a string either. Think about it and decide for yourself. [%sig%]

Re: Rakhri??

manjh payara guru ko · 07 Aug 2005

nihung singh celebarate hola after one day from hindu holi. thank you [%sig%]

Re: Rakhri??

,,, · 07 Aug 2005

Nihungs are wrong. They are uneducated.

Re: Rakhri??

itty · 08 Aug 2005

ur moms wrong

Re: Rakhri??

Singh · 08 Aug 2005

Author: ,,, Date: 08-07-05 10:03 Nihungs are wrong. They are uneducated. How are they wrong? In what sense are they wrong? Your uneducated. Guru Gobind Singh Ji was Akali Nihang. Guru Hargobind STARTED the Akali Nihangs so were they to not educated? Look again at proper Nihang Singhs, they may not have the knowledge of the crap we learn BUT they have education which we can only dream of! Gurbani, war tactics and to be one in pure medidation with Vaheguru. Are they wrong for the fact the recite a Bani for almost everything they do? or are they wrong coz they actually follow through maryada? Also, Rakhi, really, is a money makin thing man!! sister ties a piece of thread on a brother and gets a gift in return. OK makes sense!! No wonder mothers are hell bent on makin their kids do it!!! Coz as far as they are concerned!! their daughters and them are getin something in return but reluctant for their sons to get one tied... Good business venture, but no sikhi relevance.

Re: Rakhri??

**- · 08 Aug 2005

Quite a few Nihangs consider themselves as being part of Hindus. This is a fact that I have learnt first hand in India when I lived there. There are quite a number of Nihangs settled in Maharashtra and the local Maharathi Hindus view them as being "aapne bandhey" that is why you find that they [the Maharathi Hindus] give their daughters away to them in marriage. Please note that I am not using this as an arguement to sat Sikhs are Hindus as I have clearly stated in my other posts that I believe Gurmat to be seperate from Hindu Dharam. I am just stating a fact of life. Regards Sitara

Re: Rakhri??

khalsa · 08 Aug 2005

this is in reply to the 'nahung posts' and not rakhi. how can modern nahungs be compared to both guru hargobind sahib ji and guru gobind singh ji? nahungs are dishonest, fight over petty issues and have more displaced 'crodh' (anger) then anybody else, drink sukhaa - made from intoxicating items and bhang (cannibis) - they never buy rail tickets in india and are out for what they can get- in a dishonest way. how can you compare this 'dhaag' on sikhi with the gurus who set an example by showing us how to live respectful lives? you need to get your facts straight. this is a case where many ruin the reputations of a few. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Rakhri??

. · 08 Aug 2005

this thread is about rakhri not nihangs

Re: Rakhri??

Bhopinder Singh · 08 Aug 2005

Sitara Please note that I am not using this as an arguement to sat Sikhs are Hindus ______________________________________________________ This guy is to smart .He is trying to say the same by denying it later on He is making us get used to the line and not react smart move , but the panth should keep fighting offence should be taken to the above line and lekhs like HUM HINDU NAHI should keep comming

Re: Rakhri??

chillll · 08 Aug 2005

i dont see anything wrong with rakhri its just prem and piar, between a bro and sis. if u wanna tie it i dont see no harm

Re: Rakhri??

A S · 08 Aug 2005

u can say that about Christmas then too. We give gifts out of prem and piar too don't we. Christmas commemorates the the birth of Christ when the 3 wise men came from the East, bearing gifts to the "Messiah" We need to know the origins of these pointless rituals, liek rakhri, because if we don't, then it just means that we are blindly supporting them which I don't think is a very smart thing to do. But... what do I know?

Re: Rakhri??

SinGh · 09 Aug 2005

Rakhri is a simple festival that should be respected by both brothers and sisters.It is harmless and i see no harm in my sister tying a rakhri on my arm.There again itz upto you how you feel, so decide for yourself what you think is too be right.

Re: Rakhri??

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 09 Aug 2005

"rakhay rakhanhaar aap ubaarian gur kee payree paae kaaj savaarian" :)