Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

news · 08 Aug 2005

Nanavati pins Tytler for ’84 riots Points finger at Sajjan Kumar, H.K.L. Bhagat, D.D. Shastri R. Suryamurthy Tribune News Service New Delhi, August 8 The Nanavati Commission of Inquiry into the 1984 riots, terming it as an organised attack on the Sikhs, has indicted Union Minister Jagdish Tytler saying there was “credible evidence” against him, that he had “very probably” had a hand in the organising attacks and demanded that the government should take “further action as may be necessary”. The 339-page report said the riots were organised involving Congress leaders and could not have taken place “but for the backing and help of influential and resourceful persons, killing of Sikhs so swiftly and in large number could not have happened.” It came down heavily on police officials too and the failure of the authorities to call the Army immediately to control the situation. “The commission considers it safe to record a finding that there is credible evidence against Jagdish Tytler to the effect that very probably he had a hand in organising attacks on Sikhs. “The commission, therefore, recommends to the government to look into this aspect and take further action as may be necessary,” said the report of the commission, headed by retired Supreme Court Judge Mr Justice G.T. Navavati, set up by the NDA government. The report of the commission, which points fingers at several “local” Congress leaders, including Sajjan Kumar, MP, late Dharam Dass Shastri and H.K.L. Bhagat, however, absolved the party saying there was no evidence to suggest that former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi or any other high-ranking leader had “suggested or organised” the attacks in which nearly 3,000 persons were killed. However, the action taken report of the government on the commission’s findings, rejected the recommendation against Mr Tytler saying: “It is clear from the remarks ‘very probably’ that the Commission itself was not absolutely sure about his involvement in such attacks.” In criminal cases a person cannot be prosecuted simply on the basis of probability, said the ATR tabled by Home Minster Shivraj V Patil. Both the commission’s report and the ATR were tabled in Parliament today on the last day of the six-month period by when the documents should have been submitted. Mr Tytler was not named as an accused in cases registered in connection with the riots. “In view of the fact that the commission itself is not certain that Mr Tytler had a role in organising the attacks on Sikhs and in the context of the judicial verdicts on the incidents mentioned in the commission’s report, any further action will not be justified,” the ATR said. On the role of Congress leader Sajjan Kumar in the riots that followed the assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, the commission recommended examination of only those cases where the witnesses had made accusations against him specifically. “There is credible material” against Mr Kumar and another Congress leader Balwan Khokar that they were “probably involved as alleged by witnesses”. However, the ATR said Mr Kumar’s name did not figure in the list of accused in several of the cases, including an FIR in the Sultanpuri police station nor was his name mentioned by any of the 118 witnesses whose statements were recorded during investigation of the case. Mr Kumar was acquitted by an Additional Sessions Judge in 2002, the ATR noted saying: “No fresh material or evidence has been produced before Justice Nanavati Commission against Sajjan Kumar in connection with incidents of riots covered under an FIR in Sultanpuri police station. Therefore, it will not be just to reopen this case.” The commission was of the view that there was “credible evidence” against Congress leader Dharam Dass Shastri and recommended that the government examine the relevant material and direct investigation or further investigation as may be found necessary. Pointing out that Shastri was not named as an accused in this case, the ATR said the government would examine the factual position for appropriate action. The commission came down heavily on the failure of the Delhi police and also criticised the role of the then Police Commissioner S.C. Tandon and the then Lt Governor of Delhi P.G. Gavai. The ATR said the government noted with concern the conduct of police officials mentioned by the commission. “However, since these officials have retired from service there are legal difficulties in initiating any departmental proceedings at this point of time.” “Further, action under the pension rules is possible only in respect of an event which took place within four years before institution of the proceedings,” the ATR said. On Mr Gavai, the commission described the explanation given by him as “not satisfactory” and observed that Gavai “was the person responsible for the maintenance of law and order in Delhi and, therefore, he cannot escape the responsibility for its failure”. The ATR said the government had taken immediate administrative action. Mr Gavai was replaced by M M.K. Wali as LG of Delhi on November 4, 1984.” Regarding Mr Tandon, the commission observed that “it is no explanation to say that he was not properly informed by his subordinates.....He should have known that the policemen on the spot were ineffective and in spite of the curfew, mobs indulging in violence were moving freely and were committing acts of looting and killing freely.” The action taken report said the government had taken serious note of the Commission’s observations and would taken necessary action to ensure better leadership qualities among senior officers. On the commission’s views regarding “delay in calling the Army” to quell the riots, the ATR said, “the government accepts these views of the commission. Accordingly, state governments, union territory administrations and the Delhi Police will be advised to take necessary action.” Accusing Delhi Police personnel of remaining passive and not providing protection to the people during the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, the commission said if “timely action” had been taken by the police against rioters, probably many lives could have been saved. It said police personnel had “remained passive and did not provide protection to the people”. The government, the ATR said, had noted all such general observations for taking appropriate remedial action and to advise the Delhi Police and state governments to ensure that police personnel performed their duties properly in such situations in future. The ATR said the government had accepted the panel’s recommendation on providing uniform compensation/assistance to the widows/families of the riot victims, including allotment of slum flats, kiosks/shops and house sites besides monetary compensation and monthly pension.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

news · 08 Aug 2005

No action to be taken against Tytler, says govt Tribune News Service New Delhi, August 8 Despite the hue and cry in different sections of society on the Nanavati Commission Report and the ATR, the Centre today defended its decision not to go ahead with the prosecution of Union Minister Jagdish Tytler on “mere probability” of his involvement. The government also indicated that there would be no further inquiry or commission on the 1984 anti-Sikh riots. The Centre did not go ahead with the prosecution of Tytler as recommended by the Nanavati Commission because it cannot proceed on “mere probability” as was held by the Supreme Court, Special Secretary (Union Territories) in Home Ministry K P Singh told reporters. He said the Commission did not give any specific recommendations and the government had to cull out 10 specific recommendations after going through the details of the incidents given in the report and the government has accepted nine of them and only in the case of Tytler, it was “decided that it cannot proceed on mere probability.” Asked why the government did not go ahead with the prosecution of Tytler, the Special Secretary said: “The Supreme Court is very clear about the law on probabilities. We cannot go ahead and prosecute anyone only on the basis of probability.” In his (Tytler’s) case, the Commission itself was not absolutely sure of his involvement. The Commission says that “very probably” he had a hand, he said, adding “the incident mentioned in this regard has been investigated and tried in a Court of law. “Out of 45 persons who were accused in two separate cases relating to this incident, 13 were convicted and the remaining were acquitted,” he said and added Tytler was not an accused in this case for want of evidence. The government had, therefore, decided that any further enquiry or investigation in this regard will not be justified, he said. In the case of Congress MP Sajjan Kumar, he said the Commission has recommended examination of seven FIRs. “The government examined them and found that two of the seven did not relate to 1984 riots. In respect of four other FIRs, all the papers connected with the investigation were examined and it was concluded that there was no justification to re-open these four FIRs,” he said. In respect of one FIR, it has been decided to further look into the affidavit of one Surender Singh and take further necessary action, he said. He said the Commission has recommended that such riots should be kept under check and control and that police should function independently and that all complaints should be registered and investigated by independent agencies. “Government has accepted this recommendation and will be advising states and Union territories separately,” he said. About the passive role of the police, he said the Commission had recommended departmental action against 10 police personnel, five out of which had already retired. “In the case of the remaining five, it is seen that departmental enquiries were initiated against them in the past but the charges could not be proved,” he said and added that the government had decided to examine this matter further in consultation with the Ministry of Law. He also denied reports that the Home Ministry had tampered with the Nanavati Commission report and made it clear that no other Commission would be constituted to probe the 1984 riots. “How many Commissions are needed to go again and again into this? Somewhere an end has to be put?” he said. Govt puts up brave face, defends police officers Manoj Kumar Tribune News Service New Delhi, August 8 Apart from defending the union minister Jagdish Tytler and the Congress MP Sajjan Kumar for their alleged role in 1984 anti-Sikh riots, to government today put a brave face while defending the guilty police officials, who have been strongly indicted by the Nanavati Commission report for dereliction of their role during riots. The Commission has recommended action against them. The commission has strongly indicted the then police commissioner, S.C. Tandon Lt. Governor P.G. Gavai and lower rank police officials for dereliction of their duty that resulted in pogrom of more than 3000 Sikhs, looting of property worth hundreds of crores and injury to innumerable number of persons. In the Action Taken Report presented in both the Houses of the Parliament on Justice Nanavati Commission of Inquiry, set up in May 2000 to inquire in to matters connected with 1984 riots, Home Minister Shiv Raj Patil said, “The government has noted with concern the conduct of the police officials mentioned by the Commission. However, since these officials have retired from service, there are legal difficulties in initiating any departmental proceedings at this point of time.” Defending the role of police officials, government’s ATR said, “Disciplinary action under the CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965 can be taken only against a serving government servant. Further, action under Pension Rules is possible only in respect of an event which took place within four years before institution of the proceedings.” However, to wriggle out of the any accusation of defending the guilty officials, the ATR said :”Government would examine this matter in consultation with the Ministry of Law for appropriate action.” Reacting on government’s response former Chemical and Fertilizers Minister Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa said, “ It is the saddest day of our life. Congress government is shamelessly defending the guilty police officials saying that action cannot be taken against them for brutally murdering innocent Sikh children, raping women and killing youth.” Regarding consultation with the Law Ministry, the Opposition leaders wondered what was government doing for the past six months as the Commission had submitted its report on February 9 this year. The Commission observed that “ Dr Chander Prakash, DCP South District at that time, O.P. Yadav, SHO, Srinivaspuri, Rohtas Singh SHO, Delhi Cantt, Ram Phal, SHO, Hazrat Nizamuddin, Ved Prakash SI, Srinivaspuri, Shakti Singh, Head Constable of Jangpura Police post and Mahinder Singh of police station Sriniwaspuri, SI Hoshiar Singh, and SI Mange Ram had not performed their duties properly.” Justice Nanavati recommended that government should consider even now if any action can be taken against them. He noted, “ If all the relevant material is taken into consideration there can be no doubt in the mind of any reasonable person that they and other police officers and the policemen in charge of areas where these incidents had happened “were negligent in performance of their duties.” Indicting the then Police Commissioner S.C. Tandon for dereliction of duty, the commission said, “ there was a colossal failure of maintenance of law and order and as the head of the police force, he has to be held responsible for the failure.” The report further added, “The course of events do disclose that the attitude of the police force was callous and that he did not remain properly informed about what was happening in the city.” What is government’s response? Government has taken serious note of the observations of the Commission and would take necessary action to ensure “ better leadership qualities among senior police officials.” As regards any action against Mr Tandon, the ATR said,” He was replaced on November 12, 1984 and he has since retired. As mentioned earlier, there are legal difficulties in taking departmental action …….” Recommending uniform compensation to the affected families, the commission said, “ It appears that in some states the High Courts have directed payment of higher compensation of Rs 3.50 lakh for the loss of life to the dependents… But in some states smaller amounts have been paid. The Commission recommended uniform compensation and “providing employment to one member of that family if that family has lost all its earning male members and it has no other sufficient means of livelihood.” On this government has assured action. Government ready to discuss report Tribune News Service New Delhi, August 8 The government today said it was ready to discuss the Nanavati report during the ongoing monsoon session of Parliament. Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Suresh Pachauri informed the Rajya Sabha that the government was prepared for a discussion on the report of the Nanavati Commission and the accompanying Action Taken report on any day stipulated by the Business Advisory Committee. Earlier, the Bharatiya Janata Party and the Shiromani Akali Dal members demanded that the House discuss the report and the ATR. Soon after Minister of State for Home S Regupathy tabled the Nanavati Commission Report and the ATR, the BJP and the SAD members were on their feet raising slogans and demanding a discussion. BJP member S S Ahluwalia said “justice has not been done to the victims of the anti-Sikh riots of 1984.” Leader of the Opposition Jaswant Singh demanded that the Chair should direct the government to have a discussion on it in the current session itself. Chairman Bhairon Singh Shekhawat sought a reply from Mr Pachouri, who responded by saying that the government was ready for a discussion. In the Lok Sabha, noisy scenes were witnessed in the post-lunch session as Akali Dal MPs trooped into the well of the House, demanding action against those “named” in the Nanavati Commission Report. As soon as the House reassembled after the lunch break, Akali Dal MPs, led by Mr Sukhbir Singh Badal, showed copies of the Nanavati Commission Report shouting slogans like “we want justice.” They also raised slogans against union Minister Jagdish Tytler. When the noisy scenes persisted, Deputy Speaker Charanjit Singh Atwal adjourned the House till 3 pm. The report of the commission was tabled in the House earlier in the day by Home Minister Shivraj Patil. The report was tabled along with the Action Taken Report on the last day of the expiry of the six-month deadline for its presentation in Parliament.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

news · 08 Aug 2005

10 commissions, panels probed ’84 riots R. Suryamurthy Tribune News Service New Delhi, August 8 Since the 1984 anti-Sikh riots that followed the assassination of the then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, in which over 3,000 persons were killed, the government had appointed 10 commissions and committee to inquire into the incident. However, the victims claimed that none of those who perpetrated the crime and instigated the mob have been punished. Here is the chronology of different committees and commission, which the government had set up from time to time and their results. Marwah Commission: This commission was appointed in November 1984. Ved Marwah, Additional Commissioner of Police, was assigned the job of enquiring into the role of the police during the carnage of November 1984. Mr Marwah almost completed his inquiry towards the middle of 1985 when he was directed by the Central Government not to proceed further as Misra Commission had been appointed by then. Complete records of the Marwah Commission were taken over by the government and were later transferred to the Misra Commission. However, the most important part of the record, namely the handwritten notes of Mr Marwah, which contained important information, were not transferred to the Misra Commission. Misra Commission of Enquiry was appointed in May 1985. Justice Rang Nath Misra, was a sitting judge of the Supreme Court of India. Justice Misra submitted his report in August 1986 and the report was made public six months thereafter in February 1987. In his report, Justice Misra stated that it was not part of his terms of reference to identify any person and recommended the formation of three committees. There was only one term of reference to this commission, i.e. whether the violence was organised? Kapur Mittal Committee was appointed in February 1987 on the recommendation of the Misra Commission to inquire into the role of the police, which the Marwah Commission had almost completed in 1985 itself, when the government asked that committee to wind up and not proceed further. After almost two years, this committee was appointed for the same purpose. This committee consisted of Justice Dalip Kapur and Mrs Kusum Mittal, retired Secretary of UP. It submitted its report in 1990. Seventytwo police officers were identified for their connivance or gross negligence. The committee recommended forthwith dismissal of 30 police officers out of 72. However, till date, not a single police officer has been awarded any kind of punishment. Jain Banerjee Committee: This committee was recommended by the Misra Commission for recommending registration of cases. It consisted of Justice M.L. Jain, former Judge of the Delhi High Court and Mr A.K. Banerjee, retired IGP. The Misra Commission held in its report that a large number of cases had not been registered and wherever the victims named political leaders or police officers, cases were not registered against them. This committee recommended registration of cases against Mr Sajjan Kumar in August 1987, but no case was registered. In November 1987 many press reports appeared for not registering cases in spite of the recommendation of the committee. In December 1987, one of the co-accused along with Sajjan Kumar, namely Mr Brahmanand Gupta filed a writ petition in the Delhi High Court and obtained a stay against this committee. The government did not oppose the stay. The Citizens Justice Committee filed an application for vacating the stay. Ultimately, the writ petition was decided in August 1989 and the high court quashed the appointment of this committee. An appeal was filed by the Citizens Justice Committee in the Supreme Court. Potti Rosha Committee was appointed in March 1990 as a successor to the Jain Banerjee Committee. This committee also recommended registration of cases against Sajjan Kumar. Jain Aggarwal Committee was appointed in December 1990 as a successor to the Potti Rosha Committee. It consisted of Justice J.D. Jain, retired Judge of the Delhi High Court and Mr D.K. Aggarwal, retired DGP of UP. This committee recommended registration of cases against HKL Bhagat, Sajjan Kumar, Dharamdas Shastri and Jagdish Tytler. This committee was wound up in August 1993. However, the cases recommended by this committee were not even registered by the police. Ahuja Committee was the third committee recommended by the Misra Commission to ascertain the total number of killings in Delhi. This committee submitted its report in August 1987 and gave a figure of 2,733 as the number of Sikhs killed in Delhi alone. Dhillon Committee headed by Mr Gurdial Singh Dhillon was appointed in 1985 to recommend measures for the rehabilitation of the victims. This committee submitted its report by the end of 1985. One of the major recommendations of this Committee was that the business establishments, which had insurance cover, but whose insurance claims were not settled by insurance companies on the technical ground that riot was not covered under insurance, should be paid compensation under the directions of the government. This committee recommended that since all insurance companies were nationalised, they be directed to pay the claims. However, the government did not accept this recommendation and as a result insurance claims were rejected by all insurance companies throughout the country. Narula Committee was appointed in December 1993 by the Madan Lal Khurana government in Delhi. This committee submitted its report in January 1994 and recommended registration of cases against Bhagat, Sajjan Kumar and Jagdish Tytler. Nanavati Commission was appointed by a unanimous resolution passed in the Rajya Sabha. This commission was headed by Justice G.T. Nanavati, retired Judge of the Supreme Court of India. The commission submitted its report in February 2004. The report said there was “credible evidence” against the now Union Minister Jagdish Tytler that he “very probably” had a hand in organising attacks on Sikhs and recommended to the government to take further action as may be found necessary. The ATR report, while exonerating Mr Tytler, said, “a person cannot be prosecuted simply on the basis of probabilities.”

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

news · 08 Aug 2005

ATR on Nanavati panel mere eyewash: SAD Tribune News Service New Delhi, August 8 Akalis today decried the action taken report on the Nanavati Commission on 1984 anti-Sikh riots as a “mere eyewash”, and blamed Prime Minister Manmohan Singh for his failure to secure justice to the members of the community even 21 years after more than 3,000 persons were killed in an organised manner by Congress leaders in the heart of the Indian capital. “Prime Minister had a clear image. But, his failure to secure justice to the members of his own community would always remain as a black spot,” said Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa, leader of the Shiromani Akali Dal in the Lok Sabha. Talking to reporters after the report was tabled today, Dhindsa said, “The members of the community had high expectations that they would finally get justice with a Sikh at the helm of affairs. That hope has been dashed.” SAD leader Sukhbir Singh Badal said, “The commission’s report and the action taken report on it are an eyewash aimed at protecting senior Congress leaders.” He said 21 years have passed and nine inquiry commissions have submitted their reports but none of the guilty has been punished. Denying his involvement in the riots, Union Minister Jagdish Tytler told mediapersons that he was ready to face inquiry if any evidence comes up. He said the evidence on which the commission based its observations was withdrawn by the accuser. “The Commission has based its remarks on me on the basis of an affidavit filed by one Surinder Singh, which was later withdrawn by him,” Tytler said. He said, “do not attach my name to other Congress leaders (who have been named in the report).” The Nanavati Commission has observed that there is a “credible evidence” to the effect that he was “very probably” had a hand in organising attacks on Sikhs. Apart from Tytler, Congress leaders Sajjan Kumar and late Dharam Dass Shastri have been accused of the involvement in the riots. BJP leader S.S. Ahluwalia took objection to the use of word riots to describe killings of Sikhs in the wake of assassination of Indira Gandhi saying that it was “genocide.” He said the Nanavati Commission report has tried to exonerate those involved in the killings of thousands of Sikhs and wanted action against all those mentioned in the report. “Prime Minister Manmohan Singh himself was a Sikh and the ATR of the government on the report has dealt a blow to his image,” Ahluwalia said. Meanwhile, Sikh organisations have decided to take out a protest march to Parliament tomorrow and copies of the action taken report would be burnt. “It is strange that for the killing of 3000 people, not a single person has been held guilty. The report has given a boost to the morale of rioters. Anyone can commit a crime and can easily get away,” said Akali Dal (Panthak) President Manjit Singh. “We are trying to bring all Sikh groups under single umbrella for launching the protest on a big scale,” he said. The pro-Congress Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee President Paramjit Singh Sarna said, “The government should reconsider its stand. If it fails to deliver justice, it would amount to murder of democracy.” Akal Takht rejects report Tribune News Service Amritsar, August 8 The Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti today completely rejected the Nanavati report tabled in Parliament . Jathedar Vedanti said the community had lost faith in such commissions. He said the findings had given an impression that the Sikhs could not expect justice by constituting commissions. The victims including the families who were tortured and butchered, had been waiting for the past 21 years to see those directly involved in the anti-Sikh riots hanged. He said everybody in the country including the judiciary, knew that innocent Sikhs were killed mercilessly. However, all those involved in the riots had been roaming scotfree. Jathedar Vedanti said the denial of justice to the riot victims had destroyed the basic tenets of democracy. Minorities panel not satisfied with report Tribune News Service New Delhi, August 8 Unsatisfied with the Nanavati Commission report, the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) will hold a detailed discussion on the report on Wednesday. Calling it a complete let down of hopes of the victims, the NCM chairperson, Mr Tarlochan Singh, said the report, like all similar efforts in the past, would also end up in archives without any action being taken. Also criticising the Action Taken Report (ATR) of the government, he said the purpose of the ATR seemed only to dilute whatever little recommendations had been made by the commission.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

Singh · 08 Aug 2005

21 years later and no "justice" from Brahmin India. What are India-Panthi Chapplie de Sikh going to say now? More Hindustan Zindabad? Are there any doubts left why Bhai Jagtar Singh Hawara had made a hit list of these goons? What are Guru Gobind Singh jee's sons going to do now? Wait for another Commission? [i]When all other means have failed, it is righteous to take up the sword." -Guru Gobind Singh jee

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

singh · 08 Aug 2005

The thing that irks me is when people say - It was a long time ago, Sikhs need to move on. What kind of spineless community would move on without justice? The events are called riots. Riots are when property is looted and set ablaze, not when human are systematically murdered. That is genocide. Riot: ri·ot - 1. A wild or turbulent disturbance* created by a large number of people. 2. Law. A violent disturbance* of the public peace by three or more persons assembled for a common purpose. Genocide: gen·o·cide - The systematic and planned extermination of an entire national, racial, political, or ethnic group. *By terming it as riots they are suggesting that it was a mere disturbance. [%sig%]

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

A S · 08 Aug 2005

I agree. We need to learn from the Jews. Look, it s been over 50 years since World War II and the Holocaust. Have they forgotten about all the horrors? No they haven't! But you know what, they even take it a step further by making sure that the rest of the world hasen't forgot either. And they actually saw some justice (Hitler blew his brains out, there's no more Nazi Germany, many people have been charged with genocide by the UN). Sikhs haven't seen an ounce of justice and operation blew Star was only 21 years ago. Let's build museums, memorials, let's make sure that what happend on bloody June 4th is in our history books and is taught in all schools so our kids know about what happened. Let's not forget the thousands of innocent men women and children who were massacred in Amritsar, in Delhi, and all over Punjab. Let's not let them die in vain. We owe to them. What's really sad is it seems like our own "so called" leadership hasn't done a damn thing yet. The SGPC has soooo much money, power, resources yet their to busy debating over own selfish non issues. But that's another can of worms that I won't really open right now. Let's all become true GurSikhs, gather under one banner of the Khalsa, and become ambassadors of our Guru. Let's not let forget and let's not let others forget. Don't worry the people responsible for the carnage will get their's, whether it's here in the here after. "Physical death I do not fear. Death of the conscience is a sure death" -Sant-Siphai Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale PANTH KI JEET DEGH TEGH FATEH

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

Tribune News Service · 08 Aug 2005

Akal Takht rejects report Tribune News Service Amritsar, August 8 The Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti today completely rejected the Nanavati report tabled in Parliament . Jathedar Vedanti said the community had lost faith in such commissions. He said the findings had given an impression that the Sikhs could not expect justice by constituting commissions. The victims including the families who were tortured and butchered, had been waiting for the past 21 years to see those directly involved in the anti-Sikh riots hanged. He said everybody in the country including the judiciary, knew that innocent Sikhs were killed mercilessly. However, all those involved in the riots had been roaming scotfree. Jathedar Vedanti said the denial of justice to the riot victims had destroyed the basic tenets of democracy.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

Your Name:Author · 08 Aug 2005

This people were involved in the attack on Takhat Shri Akal Takhat SAhib and the killing of Sikhs in delhi. u cant take any action on these people and its a law or something.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

A Singh · 09 Aug 2005

Dear A S Thanks for your comments and thank you for not resorting to the standard and much MISQUOTED “when all others means have failed, it is righteous to draw the sword” and the very UNSIKH like “Blood for Blood” chanting we hear at the rallies in London and Toronto. No one is asking for anyone to be “chaplie” types to “Hindustan”, the issue is simple and the example of the Jews shines through, rather than argue with “brawn” they have used their brains – their commercial power as a cohesive community excelling in enterprise and other areas is what has allowed them to shine through again and again and not be forgotten. Holding rallies and campaigns are all very well and have their place, but the real issue is one of cohesiveness – amongst Sikhs, this seems to be nonexistent, largely because we choose to fight over ritual variations (bibek, colours, maryada, etc etc) rather unite under the banner of Sikhi (collectively whatever stage of that journey –sehajdhari, keshadhari or amritdhari – our brothers and sisters maybe). We are more keen to oppose Dr Manmohan Singh and others, because they are not appearing to do enough, rather than using their status as a means by which to excel and move forwards – again, the Jews have ensured their success in maintaining their dignity as a community through enterprise and outstanding contribution to their chosen areas of settlement, alongside this, they maintain their strict traditions and naturally as leaders of commerce, charity, politics, media and numerous other discipline, they win the admiration and respect of others enough to voice, and very regularly and loudly at that too, their grief and concern over the holocaust. In contrast to this, Sikhs have managed to hold riots in the UK and Canada and rub shoulders with ‘terrorists’ with accusations of air bombings and other activities – be these factual correct or not, it is clear that Sikhs have acquired more than their fair share of bad press at their own hands – the Vancouver Gang Land slayings being a prime example. People may say now, oh but these negative elements are sensationalised by the media and those involved aren’t really Sikhs – but this is a typical response one can expect from Mohammedan communities in the world who are constantly shouting about “Islam being in Khatra” and still talk of being the fastest growing religion, much like the Sikhs of today, yet still claiming to be AKAL PURAKH KI FAUJ!!!– afterall, the Jews have a plenty of bad pressed aired at them with numerous anti-Jew movements and actions as well – let us really look at what the Global Jewish community has done and how. Yudh (physical) really is not going to get us very far at all and will only serve to weaken the community further (through splinter groups, splits, actions against Sikhs and sever global bad press, PARTICULARLY in today’s climate – this was really surprises me with some people on this forum, we have bombing going on the world over and people are sympathetic to supposed Gursikhs who are accused of carrying out the same terror tactics?). We hear a lot about this word, and whilst it may sound cheesy for some, or a mere ‘ideal’, it is what will get us through and that is EKTA. [For the record, I personally believe we do need to ensure more and more the requirement for Sikhs, particularly during Amrit Sanchars to train in martial arts – in whatever way they can, but train they must: MEN AND WOMEN alike, as a preventative measure not as the primary means by which to resolve matters]. Let’s hold memorials, monuments, akhand paaths etc etc, without the unnecessary and incorrect “Hinduism equals Nazism” banners and ‘blood for blood’ chants. This type of action is what weakens our demands for justice and further splits the community internally. With the increasing presence of Sikhs in media, politics, community relations, these efforts will be made on a grander scale, but ONLY if we have EKTA and are not going to jump up and down if the Sardar Jee politician, community leader, media person has a tied beard, or wears a “samosa” pagg, or red clothes, isn’t a Jatt Prar (brother) etc etc – it’s these type of (in the grand scheme of things) “Petty” arguments which have broken us down as a community and why we can’t raise our voices loud enough as a cohesive and collective community. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

moorak · 09 Aug 2005

I WATCHED A SPECIAL PROGRAMME ON STAR NEWS BROADCAST LIVE FROM TRILOCKPURI DELHI TO HERE THE ACCOUNTS LOUD AGAIN WAS TERRIBLE FOR THE VIEWER LET ALONE THE VICTIM, THERE IS NO JUSTICE AND THE SUFFERERES WERE SAYING THEIR CHILDREN WILL BE THE NEXT FIGHTERS

India riot inquiry sparks protest

Bhudysut · 09 Aug 2005

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/4134054.stm Both houses of India's parliament have been forced to adjourn due to protests following the release of a government inquiry into the 1984 anti-Sikh riots. Opposition members are demanding the prosecution of members of the governing Congress Party over the riots in 1984. The government says there is not enough evidence to prosecute a serving minister named in the report. The riots, sparked by the assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi by Sikh bodyguards, left more than 3,000 dead. The 339-page inquiry report by former Supreme Court judge, GT Nanavati, was tabled in parliament on Monday. It said that accounts from witnesses and victims of the rioting indicated that "local Congress leaders and workers had either incited or helped the mobs in attacking the Sikhs". MPs from the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party and regional Sikh party, the Akali Dal, have called for the removal of Congress Minister for Non-Resident Affairs, Jagdish Tytler. They also say that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh should resign because he had failed to take action against those held responsible for the riots. The government has rejected the opposition demand, but says that it is prepared to hold a parliamentary debate on the issue. 'Credible evidence' The investigation found "credible evidence" against Jagdish Tytler, "to the effect that very probably he had a hand in organising attacks on Sikhs". The inquiry recommended further investigation into Mr Tytler's role. Mr Tytler on Monday denied any involvement, saying all previous commissions into the riots had failed to mention his name. "The Nanavati Commission has held the Congress party responsible for the killing of Sikhs," Sushma Swaraj, BJP spokeswoman said in the Upper House of Parliament. Kuldip Singh Bhogal, leader of a group of victims of the 1984 riots, was not satisfied with the report. "We have lost all faith in government. We were denied justice 21 years back and no justice has been given now," he said. This inquiry is the latest of nine that have looked into the riots. It was begun in 2000 amid dissatisfaction, particularly among Sikhs, with previous investigations.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

Singh · 09 Aug 2005

A Singh wrote: "No one is asking for anyone to be “chaplie” types to “Hindustan”, the issue is simple and the example of the Jews shines through, rather than argue with “brawn” they have used their brains " As I recall, the Jews went after the Holocaust pereptrators across the globe. They sent a hit squad to Argentina to kidnap Eichman and brought him to Israel to HANG HIM. The Jews chase after Holocaust deniers and former Nazis to this day even though they are old and feeble now. And as I understand, Israel has one of the best trained and equipped armies in the world. So much for your "brain not brawn" argument. You can have as powerful a brain as you want, but if you don't have a stick to back it up, you'll be crushed. The Jews learned that the hard way. They had even before WW II the brightest and most succesful members of society. When the Nazis decided it was over, what could all those intelligent people do? Nothing. Guru Sahib gave us a kirpan. Have the guts to use it.

s

A Singh · 10 Aug 2005

Dear Singh, Having the guts to use a weapon is no big deal – there is plenty on the TV and News testimony to this fact, a KIRPAN is not for such use, but for the deliverance of mercy and protection. It is the brains and not the brawn behind the gift of the Khalsa’s Kirpan that make it a Kirpan otherwise, it is nothing but a Knife or a Weapon wielded by a person. But anyway, let’s go with your thought process, where exactly do bombs and hijacking planes feature in this “having guts” to use the Kirpan? No where am I suggesting that we don’t use the Kirpan – in fact I have indicated clearly the need for being Shadtardhari and kelaris of shastar –if we were, then the Delhi Riots would have been countered more effectively – however the actions being supported by some Sikhs today –namely bombing and hijacking etc, are NOT the actions of a Yodha (Warrior) – this is where the ‘brains’ come in and distinguish, I would hope, the Khalsa from other so called ‘freedom’ fighting groups from the Semetic World in particular as well the fundamentalist right wing hindu extremists – are we not to be PARDHAN and UCHA over these matters? Look at the success that the Israeli Army and action has had compared to that of the Jewish communities elsewhere in the world who haven’t resorted straight away to the use the right of Yudh? Clearly the majority of success that the Jewish world has had in ensuring that the entire world is aware of the holocaust has not come at the hand of the Israeli Army! It comes back to the point I was trying to make above, they are far more cohesive in their unity than us – Jews the world over, be they practicing, moderates, strict or fanatical, ALL come together on this one point – alternatively within Sikhs, we bicker and bitch about our dress-codes, eating habits, degree of strictness, styles of turbans, caste etc etc and place all of these –in the grand picture, lesser important topics – above that of bigger issues that face us – this one point (1984) is clear proof in itself as to how much the Sikh community is divided, despite experiencing one of the most despicable state-sponsored crimes against it at the hands of the Indian regime. So before we start drawing our Kirpans (and particularly dropping bombs etc), perhaps we should exercise just a little bit of our God-given Brains and not simply resort to violence, because ALL OTHER MEANS have not as yet FAILED!!! Khalsa practices CHARDI KALA, which makes the Khalsa the most patient people on earth; we know “Raj” will be coming, let’s prepare ourselves appropriately and be truly cohesive before jumping any more guns. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

singh · 10 Aug 2005

Look at how "the world's largest democracy" handles peaceful protesters.. [img]http://us.news3.yimg.com/us.i2.yimg.com/p/ap/20050810/capt.xsd10108101011.india_sikh_killings_xsd101.jpg?x=380&y=265&sig=dfG7NZzGstVyhxYG8ODpXg--[/img] [img]http://us.news3.yimg.com/us.i2.yimg.com/p/ap/20050810/capt.xsd10308101013.india_sikh_killings_xsd103.jpg?x=380&y=253&sig=MHDqmO5dknZ2fDPkFnMqdA--[/img] [img]http://us.news3.yimg.com/us.i2.yimg.com/p/ap/20050810/capt.xsd10208101012.india_sikh_killings_xsd102.jpg?x=380&y=270&sig=sOXBVusj09s6QVfAlCeFXw--[/img] [i]Protesters face water cannon as Sikhs demonstrate against the Indian government's refusal to prosecute a federal minister implicated in the killings of thousands of Sikhs following the 1984 assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi by the recently released report of Nanavati Commission, in New Delhi, India, Wednesday Aug. 10, 2005. The ninth such commission constituted to comment upon the riots of 1984 that targeted the Sikh community found there was credible evidence that Jagdish Tytler, the current minister in charge of nonresident Indian affairs, was 'very probably' involved in organizing attacks on Sikhs in New Delhi.[/i]

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

Singh · 10 Aug 2005

A Singh, The reason we don't have ekta is the 'India-Panthi Chapplie de Sikh.' There may be differences in the way different sikhs practice, but these differences have been put aside when the need arises. The problem is that the chapplie sikhs will always rise up at these moments and destroy any sense of unity. The Jews don't have this problem. There really are no Chapplie Jews. Unlike what you're trying to portray, the Jews have many divisions and internal frictions, just like sikhs. And like good sikhs, they will unite against a common threat. However, where-as in Sikhs, the chapplie sikhs will arise at these moments and stand shoulder to shoulder with the foe, the chapplie jews don't exist. What we need to learn from the jews is how to get rid of the chapplie sikhs. Only then will we see real success.

Re: Sajjan Kumar, Bhagat, Tytler and Shastri Implicated

A Singh · 11 Aug 2005

Dear "Singh" Veer, I am very much aware of the division amongst Jews, growing up amongst them during my youth - funnily enough, the old Jatt-Tarkahn thing features even amongst them too! I agree that during the late 1980s when things were abosoultely dire, some attempts were made to put aside differences in practice, but even then there were holes. The point is, that the "Chapplies" as you put it, will only buy into the ‘movement’ when those claiming to be leaders at the forefront actually present some cohesive unity and direction. To use the Jewish example again, not all are in favor of Sharon and Israeli military activity, yet they all come together in chorus on the Holocaust issue – this is what we need to focus on rather than having to convert each every Sikh to support Sant Jee or Bhai Sahib – unfortunately when most conventions or rallies are held, they inevitably get hijacked by ultra-Khalistanis with their hard-core chants and protests and that’s where the buck usually stops and breaks down to the countless differences highlighted – then we come full circle back into labeling each other as pankhandis, pro-Raagmala followers, anti-raagamala followers, nangs and chapplies. Gur Fateh! A Singh