akj's stance on sants
kaur · 09 Aug 2005
does all of akj believe the only sant is guru sahib or just a few people? PLEASE give an answer only (yes or no with a few FACTS), not your personal belief.
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
kaur · 09 Aug 2005
does all of akj believe the only sant is guru sahib or just a few people? PLEASE give an answer only (yes or no with a few FACTS), not your personal belief.singh · 10 Aug 2005
the akj doesnt have an official stance on sants. i would consider myself akj and i personally "believe in" sants and i think we shoulddo their seva. but i think the word sant is incredibly over used and should be used VERY sparingly. i think bhai or baba is fine for most people of elevated avasthas.Bhopinder Singh · 10 Aug 2005
Yes they believe sant is either GUru sahib or WAHEGURU himself or group of singhs only in the persence of GURU GRANTH SHAHIB This is fact and not personal beliefASengh · 10 Aug 2005
Why call yourself AKJ? Aren't you a Khalsa? Did you not take Dasmesh pita da Amrit? All these lables need to be removed.Kulbir Singh · 10 Aug 2005
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written a book on this topic. This book is called “Sant Padd Nirnai”. The books reviews the use of word “Sant” in Gurbani. The introduction part of this book is a must read. Bhai Sahib has used very stern words for bhekhi sants. Bhai Sahib says that many times we hear that so and so sant is the avatar of Siri Guru Gobind Singh, so and so person is the avatar of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. All this is pure fraud, he writes. Bhai Sahib has written that Guru Sahib will never adopt human form again. His Khalsa is alive and is capable of doing anything Guru Sahib wants it to get done. Guru Sahib now works through his Khalsa and will not come here physically. Further in this book Bhai Sahib writes that there are shameless persons who sit on thrones and seats and let sangat worship their feet. All this according to Bhai Sahib is against Gurmat and extremely detestable. Finally Bhai Sahib concludes that the word “Sant” in Gurbani has been used for both Guru Sahib, and Gursikhs. The rule of thumb to identify where the word has been used for Guru Sahib is when great praise is showered on “Sant” and the word is singular. Bhai Sahib writes such praises of Sants are for Guru Sahib only. No individual can claim that these gurbani praises are for him or her. If the word is a plural then most of the times it is for Gursikhs. Below are some examples of word “Sant” used for Gursikhs: [gurbani] nwnk dwsu iehY suKu mwgY mo kau kir sMqn kI DUry ]4]5] [/gurbani] Guru Sahib using the stamp of his name begs that he be made the dust of feet of Gursikhs (santan). So much vadiyaayee Guru Sahib gives to his gursikhs who japp naam. [gurbani] hir sMqhu dyKhu ndir kir inkit vsY BrpUir ] [/gurbani] O Gursikhs (Santo) look carefully. He (Vaheguru) resides very near to you and pervades everything. No doubt here the word "sant" is for Gursikhs. [gurbani] sMqw sMgiq imil rhY jip rwm nwmu suKu pwie ]1[/gurbani] Always reside in the sangat of Gursikhs (sants) and by reciting Naam obtain divine happiness. [gurbani] sMq jnhu imil BweIho scw nwmu smwil ] [/gurbani] O Gursikho (Sant Jano), get together and recite the True Naam. [gurbani] sMqW sMgiq pweIAY jy myly mylxhwru ] [/gurbani] Vaheguru is attained in the sangat of Gursikhs, if Vaheguru himself does kirpa. [gurbani] dYq sMGwir sMq insqwry ]7] [/gurbani] Killing the demons, Vaheguru has saved Gursikhs (sants). Below are some examples of word “Sant” used for Guru Sahib: [gurbani] hir kw sMqu sqguru sq purKw jo bolY hir hir bwnI ] [/gurbani] The Sant of Vaheguru, the true Guru is the True Being; and he utters the true Baani. In this pankiti clearly the word "sant" has been used for Guru Sahib. No shaqq. [gurbani] guru sMqu pwieAw pRBu iDAwieAw sgl ieCw puMnIAw ] [/gurbani] I met the true Sant Guru and did japp of the true Naam; all my wishes have come true. [gurbani] siqguru sMqu imlY sWiq pweIAY iklivK duK kwty siB dUir ] [/gurbani] Meeting the true Sant Satguru, all sorrows, sins are washed away. [gurbani] hir kw sMqu imlY gur swDU lY iqs kI DUir muiK lweI ]3] [/gurbani] May I meet the true Sant Saadhoo Guru, and may I place the dust of his charan on my forehead. Below are some examples of word “Sant” used for Vaheguru: [gurbani] siqguir sMqu imlwieAw msqik Dir kY hQu ] [/gurbani] Satguru let me meet Sant Vaheguru by placing his hand on my forehead. In this pankiti the word "Satgur" is Karta Kaarak Naav and the sihaari in the end of this word gives the meaning "ne". [gurbani] Bwgu hoAw guir sMqu imlwieAw ] [/gurbani] This pankiti from Shabad Hazaare also means the same as above. By great fortune the Guru let me meet Sant Vaheguru. The word "Gur" here too has the sihaari in the end. [gurbani] hmro Brqw bfo ibbykI Awpy sMqu khwvY ] [/gurbani] Here the word "Sant" can only mean Vaheguru. Bhagat Kabir jee says that his husband is a Great Bibeki and is called Sant. In the end, it wouldn't be incongruous to mention that there are sants in Guru ghar but these sants are Gursikhs. They don't separate themselves from Gursikhs. A true Gursikh is a Sant and a Saadhoo and a bhagat. Sant is not a position different from the Gursikh position. A spiritually elevated person is called a Sant, or a Bhagat or a Jann etc. But remember, these spiritualy elevated Gursikhs never stop being Gursikhs. They forever remain Gursikhs and all their life never let anyone call them anything other than Gursikhs. They stay dust of feet of Gursikhs all their life. They don't let people matha-tek to them. They are the true Gursikhs. The modern day fake white-clothed pseudo sants are nothing but Banaras ke Thugs. These deredaars are a fraud. Whether it is some Nanaksari saadh or some Dhadriaan guy. They are not sants in the Gurmat sense. Who gave Dhadrian the right to be called a sant? When was he showered this title? He is doing good parchaar but why as a sant? Why not as a Gursikh? These so called sants don't even recognise their guru, how can they be sants? They don't even know that padd-chhed saroop is not Guru and does not contain jyot of Guru Sahib. They continue doing kirtan in its presence and this way give the proof that they are fake sants since they can't even recognize the true Guru. At this time, only Jatha is strict on the issue of Laridaar Saroop. I have to say this with great regret that even Taksal has lost sense of who the true Guru is. Taksali Jathedar Sant Kartar Singh used to call Padd-chhed Saroop a big mistake and a manmatt. Sant Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwalay vehemently opposed the Padd-chhed saroop. Now they have started doing parkash of padd-chhed in Mehta Chowk. One of our Singhs saw this with his own eyes in the June of 2004. What to do? It is pure Kalyug now. Daas, Kulbir SinghK · 10 Aug 2005
Vaheguroo Jee Kaa khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! Well written Kulbir Singh Jee. Nevertheless, I dont understand, what is a Padd-chedd saroop? Why is it such a 'big mistake and a manmat'? A lareedar saroop is when all the akhar are joined up, no gaps, am I right? Vaheguroo Jee Kaa khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!... · 10 Aug 2005
Kulbir Singh wrote: --------------------------- "At this time, only Jatha is strict on the issue of Laridaar Saroop." --------------------------- Not really ... AKJ has Rehnsbaees all over UK, Australia, America and Canadas in Gurudwaras with Pad-Chhed Birs of Guru Sahib. Not sure about India. Absolute ManMatt and heresy!!!UK Nihang Singh · 10 Aug 2005
Did the shaheeds of 1978 check if the Saroop were padd-chhedKulbir Singh · 10 Aug 2005
------- Did the shaheeds of 1978 check if the Saroop were padd-chhed ------- A Sikh can give his life for even one pankiti of Gurbani. That is exactly what Shaheeds did in 1978. The question was not about Padd-chhed saroop or Laridaar saroop. It is a known thing that the Shaheeds of 1978 were very strict about Laridaar Saroop. One of the Shaheeds Bhai Raghbir Singh jee was doing sewa in Punj Pyaray once. Samagam in Patiala started in the presence of Padd-chhed saroop. When Singhs found out, they wanted to replace it with Laridaar Saroop. Some Singhs opposed it. Finally the case went to Punj Pyaray who were conducting Amrit Sinchaar at that time. The Punj Pyaray which included Bhai Raghbir Singh jee ordered that Laridaar Saroop be installed on the throne right away. If Padd-chhed Saroop is okay why did the following Gursikhs vehemently opposed this saroop in the 1950s and 1960s: 1) Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee 2) Sant Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwalay 3) Baba Jwala Singh Harkhowal 4) Baba Ishar Singh Rarewalay and many more. As I mentioned before Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranwalay called Padd-chhed saroop a manmatt. Daas, Kulbir SinghUK nihang Singh · 10 Aug 2005
OK then what can we do to make all the gurdware around the world use Laridaar Saroop ?A Singh · 10 Aug 2005
Gur Fateh! Two points: 1. Kulbir Singh, you are largely incorrect in claiming that ONLY the "Jatha" at this present time is insistent on Larivaar, this is NOT true, others like the Hazoori Singh of Nanded also share this believe just as rigidly. Yes it is Kuljug however the Jatha are not sole saviours of humankind - Gurmat however certainly is... 2. This fuss over the use of the word "Sant" and how it is more appropriate to use terms such as "Bhai" or "Gyani" or "Baba" is simply child's play and unnecessary. The fact is that we see in the bani especially of fourth and fifth Gurus addressing the fellow Sikhs as Sants or Hari Jan. For example: Santahu tis bin awar na koee (Sggs 626) O sants, there in none else but He. Santahu iha batavau karee. Jit haumai garb niwaree.(Sggs 616) O Sants, tell me the actions that might do away with ego and pride. Har dhiawauh Santahu jee sabh dookh visaaranhara.(Sggs 348) O dear Sants meditate upon Him who is capable of making forget all miseries. Sach kahai Nanak sunau Santahu Har vartai dharam niaiai (Sggs 542) Nanak says the truth O Sants, Har deals (with the world) according to the dharam and justice. Nit japiahu Santahu Ram Nam bhaujal bikh taaree (Sggs 586) O Sants, remember Ram Nam daily that enables you to swim across the poisonous waters of existence. Augani bharia sareer hai kiu Santahu nirmal hoi (Sggs 311) This body is full of evil qualities, how O Sants can it be purified. Gur Fateh! A Singhraj karega khalsa · 10 Aug 2005
i dun understand y padd-ched saroops is so bad...it contains the same gurbani dusnt itSingh · 10 Aug 2005
read the following thread [url]http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=2887&t=2887[/url] for why pad-chhed is wrong.... · 10 Aug 2005
Not all of Jatha is promoting Lareedaar saroop. As I said above, AKJ UK, Canada, Australia and America is complicit in allowing Pad-Chhed Saroops. Not sure about India, but probably. I think the real Jatha Singhs should sort those people masquerading as member's of Bhai Randhir Singh's Akhand Kirtani Jatha.charanjeev singh · 10 Aug 2005
Thats very true..The Akhand Keertan Jatha does not follow one maryada either. I am confident that Gurdwara Sahib Tapoban follows Tat Maryada of Akhand Keertan Jatha.khalsa · 10 Aug 2005
to kulbir singh you have mentioned all these so called sants. each of these sants have their own marajada they have caused division in sikhi. they have their own sangat. they do not mix with each other. bani is for every ordinary sikh or any body who wants to read it so they can read and understand not for few who denounce their family life live at sant's derra and do things which not permitted in gurbani. what difference does it make if it is padd-ched or larreedaar. the matter of fact is people should be able to read guebani. [%sig%]John Singh · 10 Aug 2005
Can you provide proof for the bottom named Sants. I have never heard of any stance taken by them on the issue. At least nothing published from there respective jathas. 3) Baba Jwala Singh Harkhowal 4) Baba Ishar Singh RarewalayKulbir Singh · 10 Aug 2005
--------- Can you provide proof for the bottom named Sants. I have never heard of any stance taken by them on the issue. At least nothing published from there respective jathas. 3) Baba Jwala Singh Harkhowal 4) Baba Ishar Singh Rarewalay ------------ I have a book at home on the life of Baba Jawala Singh Harkhowal. In that book it is written that Baba jee and other members of his samprada i.e. Rarewalay Sant and other sants of that time vehemently opposed the introduction of Padd-chhed. Master Tara Singh agreed to one of the demands on Mangals but did not agree on taking action against padd-chhed. Daas, Kulbir Singh... · 10 Aug 2005
------------------------ each of these sants have their own marajada they have caused division in sikhi. they have their own sangat. they do not mix with each other. ------------------------ "khalsa" you are correct to say that each of these jathas have their own maryada ... but so does nearly every jatha, as they follow the maryada which they perceive as "Tat Gurmat Maryada", whether it be Nanaksar, Rare Wale, AKJ, Taksal, etc. The purpose of the original Gurmukhs was not to cause splits in Sikhi, but to serve their Guru only as they thought best. But these Gursikhs always promoted unity and encouraged pyaar and satkaar for and between all Sampardhas, Jathas, Taksals, etc. The olden days Sants/Bhai Sahibs of every Sampardha used to mix loads. Eg you can see many diff photos of Nanaksar and Rare Wale Sants together. The sangats used to mix as well, as they all respected all the High Avastha-wale Gursikhs. It is only modern day "Sants"/Jathas, or "successors" of the original Kamaaye-Wale Gurmukhs, that have their own following, and encourage the sangat not to mix, becos of their own egoism, and they fear losing their status/following.Mr. Singh · 10 Aug 2005
A Singh said, "This fuss over the use of the word "Sant" and how it is more appropriate to use terms such as "Bhai" or "Gyani" or "Baba" is simply child's play and unnecessary." I disagree. The use of the word Sant as a title has caused many problems in the panth. It has been used and abused to turn normal people into god-like personalities. Simply putting the title sant in front of someone's name is enough to cause pooja and unthinking obedience by large segments of the public. This effect is not seen as much when the title 'Bhai' or 'Gyani' is used.Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Aug 2005
A Singh said, "This fuss over the use of the word "Sant" and how it is more appropriate to use terms such as "Bhai" or "Gyani" or "Baba" is simply child's play and unnecessary." NOW THAT is what I would call Child's PLAY and totally unnecessary. WHY are the so called "sants" so HUNG UP on being labelled "sants" ??..especially since there is NO WAY that this LABEL is NOT SELF ADHESIVE...it is applied by the Chelas , for the Chelas and is OF the Chelas...and its these chelas who are " engaging in child's Play"..Genuine GURSIKHS study GURBANI instead of running after mere LABLES ( especially those self adhesive ones) GURBANI is about MODIFYING ones OWN life accordingly...not about which sant has done how much kamiaii ( if any at all). IF Guru nanak ji , the TeN Guru sahibaans, the Hundreds of thosuands of Shaheeds..cannot "inspire me" in any way how can the "kamaii" of say Babba Ji Isher Singh" Chittee Pugg Waleh", "Haree Chadar waleh", "sukkeh Kareleh Waleh" " Laal Mircheean waleh" etc etc going to do that ?? These "sants" are tiny candles to the SUNS and Galaxies of the GURSIKHS and BHAI SAHIBS who went before them..A Singh · 11 Aug 2005
Dear Gyani Ji and Mr Singh Veers, For the record, and Veer Jarnail Singh Dhillon Jee, I believe you should know this from my other posts and discussions, that I am (a) not a follower of any Sant and for that matter Bhai Sahib, Gyani etc and (b) I am not here to promote any Jatha, Taksal, Sampradha etc. I concur the Sant issue has caused a lot of problems, however the same is also true of the Gyanis and Bhai Sahibs and Babas – these are simply terms, the net result isn’t too different, except we choose to focus one in particular. There are many cases where having “Bhai Sahib” or “Baba” etc also is “enough to cause pooja and unthinking obedience by large segments of the public”, have a look at the some of the literature written by followers of such individuals (as great souls they themselves may have been and/or are), there is no exception to having certain people putting them on a pedestal equating their life and jeevan with that of the Gurus when it comes to decisions concerning maryada / practice, just as we witness for “Sant” chelas. So, I conclude my stance, that as Gyani Ji alluded to, we seek inspiration and guidance only from Guru Sahib’s charan and through his kirpa we will be blessed with seeing and learning lessons through life – now if that extends to including Gursikhs, Sants, Bhai Sahibs or indeed just regular folk that is great, but on no account do the thoughts or practices of these individuals or groups exceed those of Guru Maharaj. Gur Fateh! A Singhcharanjeev singh · 11 Aug 2005
My bhenti to sangat. If we are talking about topics such as title 'sants', please still refrain from pointing at a certain Gursikh using their names. This is nindya. We must also know one thing. When Waheguruu gives Kirpaa to a Gursikh, the whole world in all ten direction do jai jai kaar of that Gursikh. It is Waheguruus Hukam. Lets not mention particular names, but only refer to the title 'sant'. We must not accidently do nindya of a Maha Gursikh because the sangat referred to them with this title. But for ourselves, we should not call anybody sant. The parampara that Guru Sahib started included Mata, Bibi, Baba and Bhai. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikikakhalsa waheguruujikiftehA Singh · 11 Aug 2005
charanjeev veer, i have shown above, that Guru actually refers to fellow sikhs as sant, so let's get over this and deal with the real issue: the pesonality cults behind all sants, babas, bhai sahibs etc followers. gur fateh! a singhsatnam · 11 Aug 2005
Regardless of wether someone is labelled as a sant or not, they are still a human being, a son of god. no need to disrespect someone. http://mistakesingh.blogspot.com/charanjeev singh · 11 Aug 2005
A Singh, i absolutely agree with what you have said. i do not understand why people follow other Gursikhs to the 'T'. some gursikhs make it their mission in life to mimmick other gursikhs as best they can. i do not feel that is the path of Gurmat. Here is what i feel Guru wants us to do. this is my humble opinion. Guru wants us to realize ourselves, who we are, our unique identity. I believe this only happens with a one on one personal relationship with Guru Sahib. For example; Bhai Kanaiya Jee realized himself, and he was a selfless sevadaar who would not even harm an ememy. He was a true Gursikh. Baba Deep Singh Jee realized himself, and he was a selfness sevadaar who would destroy all dusts. He was a true Gursikh Bhai Mani Singh Jee realized himself, and he was a selfless sevadaar who would live in bhaana and be cut to pieces, limb by limb, even though he possessed all the powers of a Gursikh. He was a true Gursikh. Other Gursikhs also include Baba Attar Singh Jee mastuanwale, Bhai Randhir Singh, and many more blessed souls. There are countless Gursikhs whom have realized themselves. Some find out that their mission is to help others, some to slay the enemies, some to serve through teaching others the path of Gurmat. Now here is the tricky part. The individual at hand who has realized themselves through the Grace of the Guru, had a personal relationship with Guru Sahib and Waheguruu, and they realized who they were through having direcet relationship with Guru and Waheguruu. This is what we must all do in my opinion. In my opinion, we should all realize who we are. We will all be different, but we will all be same. If we follow one Gursikh, we will be mimmickers, and not realized souls, there is a difference. We must all individually become realized souls, and to do this we must establish a direct relationship with the Sant of the sants, and the Guru of the Gursikhs. However, many people are also blessed to follow the teachings of others whom have been blessed with Waheguruus Grace. And perhaps it is their destiny to be followers of Gursikhs who followed the Guru. This is also a huge blessing, huge. However, i feel that the most blessed soul becomes a realized soul. This also i feel is the most sharp path that is as fine as the tip of a sword and as fine as hair. It is the most difficult path. But i believe this is the only way to become a realized soul by the Grace of the Guru. We have many sactions today who are devout followers of realized souls, and these followers are fortunate to follow realized souls, however it is my belief that they cannot become realized souls themselves. The path of a realized soul is a detached path with only Guru and Waheguruu as the companion. No one else. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh (if i do not reply to any more posts, i appologize in advance, i will be away for a few days) bhul chuk mauf [%sig%]simple singhani · 11 Aug 2005
Author: ASengh Why call yourself AKJ? Aren't you a Khalsa? Did you not take Dasmesh pita da Amrit? All these lables need to be removed. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- WELL SAID ASENGH!waheguru waheguru waheguru! they do need to be removed i 100% agree with you! not many epople understand that! stay in chardikala singh! if you call urslef akj..what does this mean..you are part of a certain jatha right..now thats not all that amazing..but listen..if you call urself...a khalsa...it means soo much more!! dont b rpoud of bein akj...b rpoud of being a khalsa!!!Khalistan Zindabad · 11 Aug 2005
wjkk wjkf is it all right to call sant jarnail singh ji khalsa "sant" or should we refer to him as "baba jarnail singh ji khalsa"singh · 11 Aug 2005
Call him whatever you think conveys the right amount of respect. Whether thats bhai, baba, shaheed, and even sant if you think thats right but like another person posted at this phorum calling him just a sant probably wouldn't do him justice as he was also a sipahi..... Its up to you what you want to call anyone.Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Aug 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Veer Charanjeev singh ji has hit a right note.... we all MUST strive to REALIZE our own UNIQUE Position Vis a Vis Vaheguru/Guru Ji. A simple example. All of us went to SCHOOL.... there we were taught by TEACHERS. Just Imagine IF each and every STUDENT in every School, had gone ahead and Mimicked the "TEACHER"...everybody in this world would be a TEACHER...and there would be NO Doctors, Engineers, Scientists, Nurses...ALL TEACHERS and ONLY TEACHERS. We respect the Teacher, we LOve the teacher, we know the Teacher is a REALIZED SOUL who Knows his Vocation... BUT we MUST DO OUR OWN THING and realise our own POTENTIAL. Same for the "sants" the Bhais, The Gurmukhs... we respect them, we love them, BUT we must LEARN from them and not MIMICK them and try to be exactly what they are...we must each one of us realise our own UNIQUE position as Waheguru meant us to be. ALL are TEACHERS BUT they have only ONE SYLLABUS..the GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB.... which we MUST strive to STUDY on our Own and find what Gurbani MEANS for us.....not go on and on about what Gurbani/kamaii some sant did or didnt do. It serves no purpose at all. Everybody "knows" the Teacher is FULLY QUALIFIED, he knows his stuff, he has the "kamaiiyee"..but THATS ALL..all his kamaiiyee, his qualifications etc are FOR HIS OWN USE ONLY...his "students" CANNOT be qualified/kamaiiyee etc from HIM by "transfer" !!! or magic. Each STUDENT will have to learn and study on hsi own for his own qualifications, kamiiyee etc. People especially the Youth get the misguided iidea that just be following a "sant" around and shouting slogans in his favour they will get his "kamiiyee"..this wont work..not for an ordinary teacher, not for an sant or whatever. Gurbani says WE MUST EACH DO HIS OWN WORK.A Singh · 12 Aug 2005
Khalistani, has Veer Charanjeev Singh as indicated, and I certainly concur with him, we are here to evaluate and improve our positions - as I stated above, merely calling someone a Sant or Baba or Gyani is no big deal, learning from that person is great, the problem arising when you get hung up on their personality - that's where all the issues begin (if you want a list of these problems and issues, do a search under Gyani Jarnail Singh Arshi's posts, he tends to cover and nail each of them pretty accurately even if a little too brutally honest for some! ;)