Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
BANA - Please educate me?
BANA - Please educate me?
A Singh · 12 Aug 2005
Gur Fateh!
We have all heard of the mess created by Kala Afghana here in Canada and all forums are full of discussions (or “tu-tu-mai-mai” depending on your view) concerning AKJ vs Taksal vs SGPC vs Nihang Singh and particularly vs UK Nihang Singhs –usually all about what each perceive to be our authentic itihas and maryada.
All seem to be accusing each other of allowing ‘dhil’ into the rehit, all seem to be claiming ‘Tat Gurmat Maryada’ and accuse others of British –influenced or Hindoo RSS influenced propaganda. The one thing that seems to be common however amongst all these various sampradhas, jathas, institutions etc is the view on clothing or supposed “BANA”.
I would like to know more about this concept of “Bana”, as I don’t think I have the buddhi to fully appreciate what this really is – I’ve always believed that the Bana of a Gursikh was the Punj Kakkar (or Treh Mudra as per older texts, which as I and others have mentioned elsewhere on this forum is the same thing not the 5 items reduced to 3). Hence, in terms of clothing, the only requirements placed on a Sikh was a Dastaar and Kachera.
However, all of the aforementioned groups and also many others (like Nanaksar, Nishkam Sevak Jatha etc etc) all seem to have quite a different take on what is “bana”, namely some sort of long tunic (chola) and a round flat across the forehead style turban (Dumala). From time to time, I have also noted that some people feel that a Hazooria is just an important part of “Bana”.
On top of this, one often hears about appropriate colors for each of these items, namely that a Chola and Dumala should be BLUE (occasionally white is considered by those affiliated with Sant Deras, however the visible trend is that Nihangs, who claim BLUE as the authentic color of the Khalsa are joined on this front by the Taksal and AKJ, who all favor blue as well) and on no account should a hazooria be Orange. More recently, we even hear about restrictions on the length and size of these items and whether or not the Chola should cover the Kachera or if it should be allowed to be visible etc etc.
As witnessed above, many of these groups (Nihangs and Taksal in particular) also have presented supposed lineages to tie themselves back to Guru Gobind Singh and the creation of the Khalsa Panth, and use this as a basis by which to claim superiority over newer groups like the AKJ. In reality, no such lineages exist as has been shown amply in the case of Taksal many times [for the record, this is not nindiya of the Taksal, they are a formidable institution with excellent vichar of Gurbani] and numerous times here for the Nihangs, who are in fact a movement that begun far after the passing of Guru Gobind Singh [who for the record, contrary to the views expressed by the UK Niangs, was not himself an Akali Nihang – perhaps they should consider reading texts more carefully before relying solely on selected and misquoted / mistranslated passages – that too from modern-era texts!!!] – again this post is not intended to be nindiya of Nihangs or AKJ or any group – all have amazing Gursikh founders, it seems certain zealous chelas have made the movements into something quite different from that started by their initiators.
More recently, the Bana issue has been taken to newer heights when over-zealous Bibis have stated that they wish to dress EXACTLY like their male counterparts and wear Cholas with no pyjamas. From this, I have seen many conclude that there was a time when during Amrit Sanchar even Bibis would be asked to remove their pyjamas and be present in Kacheras, however this all changed when “kaam” arose in the participants!
[If this was the case, where is (a) the proof or reference and (b) if during such an important ceremony, an neophyte falls foul of kaam, then surely he is not worthy of the initiation? Moreover, would the Bibis who wished to wear Cholas without pyjamas incite the same response as they walked about religious places like Gurdwaras?]
In retaliation to the various critiques, we have witnessed unnecessary name calling and nindiya (such as that above “'Budha Dal of Santa Singh NANG'”) – the Akal Thakt has pardoned this individual, surely we as Sikhs should respect their decision? Besides, he and his Tarna Dal counterparty Baba Nihal Singh are also proponents of the BLUE bana thought and the view that the original Khalsa was formed ONLY of Nihang Singhs – as increasingly we witness amongst even the AKJ and Taksal Youth, here in Toronto and Canada and
If this is the case, why do we have SO many exceptions to this supposed rule from even Guru Gobind Singh’s time (post 1699) as recounted by his own Kavis in their texts and subsequent authors of the early 18th century? Why do these accounts (texts, pictoral representations, clothing relics etc etc) not coincide with the supposed “BLUE DRESSED CHOLA and DASTAAR BOONGA” of the modern day enthusiasts? Why do these texts not speak of items such as Chand-Toras and even Dumalas? Those who support the view that this is the original form of the Khalsa and that their institutions have the TRUE TAT traditions also criticize other Sikhs of distorting history and adopting foreign (Malech) traditions – if this is the case, on what basis do they claim to be the upholders of true traditions, to date all the humdrum available on the net, from Kathavachiks, presentations etc seems point to only a couple of half truths cooked up from misquoted selections and the opinions of this Baba or that Sant and this Jathedar.
Gurbani is very clear on the matter of “Bhek” and its relevance to true religiosity, perhaps we should on this case actually rely on the words of our Guru Sahibs as contained within the Sri Guru Granth Sahib and Sir Dasam Granth Sahib – as both speak of this matter amply.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh.
Re: BANA - Please educate me?
RoopKaur · 13 Aug 2005
I am not sure what you are trying to prove here, but I think you have gotten too caught up in politics and have missed the total essence of Sikhi bana.
You claim that there are no references to the blue bana and boonga, but if you read the descriptions of Akaalis in early British records, you will find they mention either navy blue or black clothes with turbans full of different shasters. There are even cholaas available of Guru Sahibaans, so there is no doubt that they did indeed wear them. What relics are you talking about that say they wore something else?
As for the four colours, this tradition is a seena baseena rehit passed down from the punj to abhilakhees for generations. The fact that so many different jathas beleive in this reinforces its importance, and does not go against it.
By saying the Sikhs are only to wear dastaar and kacheraa is a blatant attack on the Sikh rehit of the panj kakaars. This goes aganst one of the fundamental rehits of a Sikh, and perhaps you should provide proof of this before blindly attacking an important Sikh rehit.
As for bani, we read in Anad Sahib everyday, jio mailey baro nirmal, which is what I think you are talking about. But if you read the next pauri, it says, jeeo nirmal, barho nirmal, indicating that you must be nirmal from the inside AND outside as well. What words are you talking about that we should rely on that go against wearing bana?
Re: BANA - Please educate me?
Um.. · 14 Aug 2005
yea
it does say jeaho baroh nirmal , baroh nirmal
that means pure from outside and inside
it is good to wear bana?
but its most important to wear kakaars
if someone doesnt wear a chola right now
does that make them less of a sikh?
does it lower their avastha?
i think not
u can find a gursikh in a pant shirt or even kurta pajama
avasta is more important
Re: BANA - Please educate me?
John Singh · 14 Aug 2005
Good Post A Singh, I think that sums it up pretty good. I see your point here seems to be what really is the Bana?
I would say it is just that the kakkars and dastaar. These things visually distinguish us from others.
Does it include a chola,chand-toraa, bungaa? For certain people yes and others no. For example one working in an office usually does not keep a chola on and prefers pants, on the other hand a Nihing who is in the jatha all day is bound to adopt Nihung Bana.Both are still doing there Sikh duty of remaining distinct, and they both were the 5 Kakars and Datsaar and are bothes known as Sikhs.
Re: BANA - Please educate me?
A Singh · 15 Aug 2005
VahegurooJiKaKhalsa VahegurooJiKiFateh!
Dear RoopKaur, “Um” and John Singh,
Thanks for your posts and answers. I would like to answer and discuss some of the points you have all made and shall try to do this in the order presented in your posts.
1. BhainJi Roop Kaur it is precisely to get the politics out of Sikhi that I have asked the above questions, as one can easily see the cliques that are formed by various groups in the community on this one issue, which is one of the reasons we have so many splinters within ourselves.
2. I refer you back to my post and ask you to note that there are NO references to blue bana made in sources which would be considered most contempory to Guru Sahib and the events of 1699…AND lo and behold, you cite “Early British Records” – this is precisely my point, this is the period when SUDDENLY the Blue Cholas and Dastaar Boongas become the mandatory Sikh dress. Yes there are relics of Guru Sahib’s clothing, but you’ll find that they are not ALL Blue (for the record, in case it is not obvious, I am not opposed to this method of dressing, just that I find no real basis to conclude that it is the ONLY dress acceptable for a Sikh) and nor are all of them Cholas. Its just surprising that despite the numerous anti-Nihang and anti-Sanatan views echoed by the AKJ and others, that they have chosen to adopt this one tradition prevalent amongst those who they consider as “Nangs” because it “looks” Chardi Kala.
3. As per other references, take a look at texts pre-Rattan Singh Bangoo (the so-called “Nihang Bible”) and those of Gyani Gyan Singh (the favourite digest of those who love all things Sanatan) – these two texts are far from being contemporary. Take look at Sri Guru Sobha, Gur Bilas P10 and / or Banasivalanama P10 ka – you’ll find in them descriptions pointing to Sikhs being dressed in all white, or all kesri and even RED!!! Of course, for some this will be too hard to stomach and they’ll simply write this off as some “Brahmin conspiracy”).
4. The fact that so many believe a certain thing is not conclusive at all – look at the views of the majority of Sikhs during the 18th century, you’ll find nearly all “jathas”, “Taksals”, “misls” etc etc had affirmative belief in the DEVI and her role within the formation of the Khalsa – I presume that you would therefore argue that this is correct, as per the logic of the Sanatan Sikhs? This too was a “seena baseena rehit passed down from the punj to abhilakhees for generations” as per your definition until the reforms that occurred under the Singh Sabha movement. The case against “Red” colors started out simply as a response to counter the Nakli-Bandai Khalsa, over time this has undergone some considerable ritualization.
5. Roop Kaur Ji, I ask that you please calm down and not react to simple statements, your accusation that I have issued a “Blantant Attack on the rehit of the panj kakaars” is outrageous. I have done no such thing!!! In fact I have stated quite clearly my belief in the 5 Kakkars/treh mudra of the Khalsa – you have simply not read the post carefully. The items within this rehit (i.e. Kanga, Kirpan and Kara) are NOT clothing items, the comment that I made concerned BANA (i.e. Clothes) of which Kachera (from the Kakkars) and Dastaar is the only conclusive items which would qualify as mandatory BANA as opposed to the ever increasing list which started with cholas, then colours, then hazooria and then its colours etc etc (Kakkars are of course mandatory!!!). I hope this makes things clear and we do not need to revisit this one statement taken out of context.
6. Roop Kaur Ji, you have later quoted Guru Amar Das Ji’s Anand Sahib and stated “(this) is what I think you are talking about” – so indicating that you do have feeling for what I was trying to discuss contrary to your opening paragraph. In any event, your next assertion that the next pauri reads “jeeo nirmal, barho nirmal” somehow implies wearing what is today considered by some as Bana doesn’t really add up. The pauri is talking of those who talk of being nirmal or act like they are nirmal: external – barho is not limited to clothing! This is reference to all sorts of actions which Gurbani time and again speaks of as futile, such as giving in charity whilst still being proud, being vegetarian yet carrying out the murder of innocent people or extorting another, performing religious ceremonies and prayers, yet still being deceitful, it no where mentions robes or dress code, whereas many other shabds from both the Guru Granth Sahib and Dasam Granth clearly do and point to the futility of linking a mode of dressing to one’s spiritual progress or development.
7. You end by asking “What words are you talking about that we should rely on that go against wearing bana?” which clearly shows that perhaps, Roop Kaur Ji, you have indeed mistaken and misunderstood my post entirely. I am NOT against wearing Bana or for that matter anything. I am asking, that given references to the futility of dressing up in various bheks mentioned in Gurbani and given the orders within the Sikh Rehit Maryada and also Sikh itihaas (and not some British Account or something that Baba so and so said etc etc) the only conclusive and mandatory requirements for a Sikh is to wear the 5 Kakkars – from which the Kachera is an item which could be regarded as Bana together with the Dastaar of the Sikh (for which various rehitnamas and literature suffice to deem mandatory). I have no objection to any of my veers or bhain jees wearing Bana, Dastaar Boongas or Chand Toras etc etc (this may surprise you, but I also wear such items!) – but those who do wear this dress and claim that it is Bana from Guru Gobind Singh, perhaps need to reconsider that statement and also those that are levelled at others who they deem to be wearing ‘malech’ bana, simply because they wear a Kurta-Pyjama or Pants and Shirts.
“Um” you have hit the nail on the head – “if someone doesnt wear a chola, does that make them less of a sikh? does it lower their avastha?” –if it did, then how are we any different to the Dhoti and Janeau wearing Brahmins that everyone here loves to hate?
John Singh, thank you so much for reading and understanding the questions asked. I am in agreement with your conclusion (i.e. “kakkars and dastaar) and also that “one working in an office usually does not keep a chola on and prefers pants, on the other hand a Nihing who is in the jatha all day is bound to adopt Nihung Bana - both are still doing there Sikh duty of remaining distinct, and they both were the 5 Kakars and Datsaar” – the issue I have is that somehow people have taken this a step further and claim that the Nihang Singh saroop is the original and only valid saroop of the Khalsa (i.e. Dumala, Neela Bana / Chola etc) and encourage people to wear this to the Gurdwara even if they are the pants and shirt type outside of it – this, is nothing more than playing dress up. There is no conclusive proof to support the notion that the Nihang Singh saroop is the same one that Guru Sahib gave the Khalsa in 1699, excepting the Kakkars and Dastaars and certainly no proof to indicate that Guru Gobind Singh was an Akali Nihang!
Other prominent leaders who adopt this view of Neela-Bana have gone as far as suggesting that one cannot fight wearing White Bana, presumably they do count Sham Singh Attariwala or Ram Singh Namdhari as warriors then and / or are unaware of their efforts?
Gur Fateh!
A Singh.
Re: BANA - Please educate me?
Singh · 15 Aug 2005
A Singh,
I see your name and right away my "sanatan-alert" goes off.
Bana, like a lot of other parts of rehit has been passed down. Where will you find descriptions of it? You can find descriptions in Gyani Gian Singh and Rattan Singh's works.
I have a lot to say but unfortunately not the motivation to sit here and type for hours and give example after example for you. So I'll give a simple piece of evidence. If we want to know what bana is, the best place to look, is in amrit sinchaars at what the Punj Pyare wear. No matter what the jathebandi, all Punj Pyaray look more or less the same. they all have cholas, with no pyjama. They have white hazurias. They all have kamarkassas and 3 foot sri Sahibs. The colours of the cholas are generally orange or blue but white is also used by some. I'm not sure of any jathebandi that doesn't follow this general appearance for the punj pyaare. So that is a good indication of what Singh Bana should look like.
Rattan Singh Bhangoo also writes about what kinds of clothes Singhs wore before their shahidis or going to battle and he says they were usually blue (blue is stressed in that work) and some others wore orange or kesri. Again we're back to these three colours. The 2nd Bhai Gurdas wrote that Singhs dressed in "neelambar". Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh also said the blue dress was the Khalsa's traditional dress.
The GUru Sahibs were generally thought to have worn white. Guru Gobind Singh is said to have changed his blue bana to white after leaving Machiwara.
I say don't over-complicate things. We all know what Singh Bana is. Sikhs have a distinct dress. This dress is a good tool to help us remember our committments and preserve our "niara" nature. If we can't wear our traditional dress outside all the time, we should at least wear it to Gurdwara Sahib. It is Guru Sahib's uniform.
Re: BANA - Please educate me?
A Singh · 15 Aug 2005
“Singh”,
You wrote “A Singh, I see your name and right away my "sanatan-alert" goes off.”
Perhaps you could explain this statement and also then re-read this post and many of my others in which I have been critical of the co called “Sanantan” thought –which at the end of the day comes from nothing other than a single line of Gurbani (which can be easily taken out of context) and Harjot Oberoi’s book.
Like you stated, I will not sit there and type for hours and give example after example for you, particularly since you are keen to cite the very texts that I have discussed above as being irrelevant to this discussion and use examples which don’t really add up or address the issue. You appear to have misunderstood the question as well – I am not against the concept of Bana, but to argue that Neela Bana, Nihang Singh Dal Panth Shiv-Saroop etc is the ONLY acceptable bana for a Sikh is simply not correct.
In any event, please kindly explain your “sanatan alert”.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh.