Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Aug 2005
Nothing great..a lot of people get up at amritvela....BUT ONly the Hindu Vedas..and then the Sikh GURU SAHIBAANS described the Importance of Amrtivela and SIMRAN (naam japp). "Simran" may not all be the same...Gurmatt lays emphahsis on NAAM JAPP...japio Har Jaesseh..and just sitting quietly meditating is NOT Naam japping.
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 Aug 2005
singhstar and jss ji,
have you read your own posts ?? the "nimrata" dripping from them is drowning the people of Mumbai...God save us from such COPIOUS nimratta folks.... just a tiny weeny bit is enough ji. ( no body wants the floods as in Mumbai )
MY post is straightforward....and I stick by every word..ONLY SIKH GURU SAHIBS told the world about the Concept of NAAM JAPP/SIMRAN and its the ONLY ONE way to WAHEGURU....Jesus Christ Son of Man or son of God...notwithstanding. Our GURMATT/GURBANI is UNIQUE...ONLY ONE of its KIND...No apologies and no exceptions. There is NOT a single line in the Bible New or Old testament about NAAM JAPPING as a way to God....Jesus' way is THROUGH HIM ONLY....IF you take ME into YOUR HEART says Jesus YOu are SAVED....and I will TAKE care of ALL YOUR SINS...
Excuse me but GURBANI says the DIRECT OPPOSITE....NO ONE..repeat NO ONE can take care of MY SINS except ME.
Singhstarr !! You have INSULTED GURU SAHIBS by calling me a "Sri GURU" ( maybe you are trying to show an exaggerated sense of "nimratta"..but trust me I am NO GURU..just a GURUSIKH. ( I am NO "STARR" either...just a SINGH.)
Sorry folks that about all the "false nimratta" that i have today.....maybe soem other time !!
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
actually... · 15 Aug 2005
actually, i think Jesus may have always wore a Turban on his head, and i think the covering of the head may actually refer to puting his Lohi (shawl) over his head.
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 Aug 2005
Singhstar and jss and others,
Could you please quote a few lines from the bible saying Naam japping of Waheguru IS the WAY to REALISE HIM ?? It would have been nice to give some "facts" of YOUR own !!
The Word NAAM occurs a few THOUSAND times in Gurbani.... from Bhagt namdev to Guur Gobind Singh Ji.....Again and Again.. and Again....and also that NAAM JAPP is the ONLY WAY to REALISE WAHEGURU....not through sewa, greebee, poverty, donations, selfless service blah blah blah ( although these are good values that help one to Naam japp but they ALONE will NOT get anyone to REALISE WAHEGURU.
This is a sheer stupidity to say that Naam japp of Waheguru. as the ONLY WAY to REALISE WAHEGURU...somehow NEGATES the Gurmatt teaching that ALL religions etc are ONE...Humanity is ONE...all come from the SAME SOURCE.
Waheguru created ALL...Jesus, Moses Abaraham and Indira gandhi Tytler and Sajjan kumar...also..ALL came from WAHEGURU....BUT are THEY ALL "SAME" as GURU NANAK JI SAHIB... I beg to Differ..NO WAY. IF Jesus was THE WAY and the ONLY WAY..GURU NANAK JI would have SAID so in His GURBANI ?? We wouldnt have to wait for you to tell us.
ONLY GURU NANAK has this NAAM METHOD PERFECTED. It existed in HINDUISM...BUT doesnt exist in Christianity/Islam/Buddhism.Hebrewism etc. In fact the CONCEPT of naam japp cannot be Translated into ENGLISH at all...it is NOT "NAME"...no way !!! People translate it wrongly as "repeating the Name"....and thats why it is wroingly understood by all others as they beleive "God will get fed up" of people constantly calling his name !!! I know many humans would..BUT then NAAM JAP is not about this meaningless name repetition at all.
Why do people like you out of a sense of "inferiority complex" become "apologists"..and keep repeating like a broken record..."all religions are the SAME..blah blah blah.." IN WHAT way is GURMATT "SAME" as Christianity ??
I manitain that GURMATT is a UNIQUE and One of a KIND Path to Realise GOD. Sikhs of Guru ji are NOT at all interested in going to "heaven" wherte Jesus is supposed to be sitting on a throne....neither are we interested in going to Bahishat where Muhmmed is sitting on his throne. IF..ALL RELIGIONS were the SAME...hundreds of thousands of SINGHS wouldnt have DIED as Martyrs...it is stupid to die when the "destination" is the SAME ?? IF Bhai mani Singh could have realsied WAHEGURU as a MUSLIM...why did he insist on being cut from limb to limb BUT NOT "leave SIKHI? ??..But this is NOT to DENY that Sheikh Mian Mir "did not" find his MUSLIM BAHISHT or that he failed to realise Allah by remaining a MUSLIM. He was such a Good friend of Guru Arjun ji BUT he didnt become a SIKH..But Aurengzeb was also a Muslim..beleiving in the SAME allah as Main Mir !!
Gurmatt is the ONE and ONLY RELIGION that not only Allows other religions EQUAL POSITION..but GURU TEG BAHADUR JI also Gave His HEAD for this Freedom to practise your own religion. ISnt that SACRIFICE UNIQUE as well... show me one such from any other religion ?? If after THOUSANDS of YEARS the Other religions COMBINED cannot produce even ONE GURU TEG BAHADUR JI....how can they be the SAME ?? Sikhe produced Guru teg bahadur Ji just after 220 YEARS..and just after 250 Years Produced MORE MARTYRS than ALL other World Religions Combined !!!
Give SOME FACTS..and not just hot air. I am one gursikh who is not afraid to be "unpopular" and i stick to my guns...calling names never broke any bones before and it wont do now. We have enough 'apologists"..so called sikhs not brave enough to call a spade a spade.
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Aug 2005
and PLEASE refer to MY FULL NAME... "Singhs" of today like you should KNOW BETTER than to call another by His HALF NAME and so arrogantly leave out the NAME bestowed upon me by MY FATHER..( so much for their nimratta/humility...a load of "****" if ever there was one...). Dont study astronomy so much that you leave the ground...I am "Arshi" too.
Jarnail SINGH....the other "poochaans" can be left out BUT NOT "SINGH".
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji ak khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh.
Dera singhstarr and psingh ji,
why are you drivelling on and on making conclusions on my behalf.
I asked you for QUOTES from the Bible/Koran...NOT bring in Sheikh farid whose GURBANI is IN GURU GRANTH JI..which is the Vehicle of NAAM JAPP. Asking me stupid questions about whether I bow to This GURBANi and THAT Gurbani is self defeating. I BOW to the ENTIRE GURU GRANTH SAHIB from AAng 1 - 1429 as GURBANI..(and aang 1430 becasue it is there.)
Havent you even read this GURBANI.... Bhagat Prehlaad, Bhagat Dhru..long long ago THOUSANDS of YEARS before GURU NANAK JI..in SATJUG....already Japp Naam...and GURBANI is proof of it... Raam japo ji aisseh aisseh DHRU Prehlaad Japio HAR Jaisseh.
I am NOT concerned..with what happens to millions or Billions of "others"..YOU can take that SEWA. What I know for a FACT is THAT MY GURU JI....GURU NANAK JI walked Hundreds of THOUSANDS of MILES through the most dangerous wild jungles, deserts, climbed the highest mountains, went through the coldest winters and blizzards...Taking HIS DIVINE MESSAGE to all the Four Corners of the Known World. NO other PROPHET of any other religion even walked more than 100 MILES from his own HOME. Jesus stayed in ISRAEL ONLY, Muhammed Ji never went further than Mecca medina..Krishan Ji stayed put in his own Capital and so did Raam who stayed in Auythia ( He went to Sri lanka to get his wife back and not for Parchaar) Even the Bhagats in Gurbani stayed put in their own places and GURU NANAK JI collected their GURBANI..and they ALL INSIST on NAAM JAPP...as THE WAY TO REALISE WAHEGURU.
1. NO where in any ONe Panktee of any Contributor of GURBANI do we find the Phrase..I AM THE WAY ( to REALISE GOD). If you have come across any such Panktee please enlighten ME and the Rest of us. EVERY Panktree in the entire Guru Granth jI talks about NAAM'JAPP as the WAY to Waheguru.
Does Bhagat namdev say''I AM THE WAY..BELIEVE IN ME and I WILL WASH YOUR SINS.... DOES Bhagat kabir Ji, Bhagat ravidass Ji, ANYBODY SAY THIS ?? in GURBANI ???
I am still WAITING for YOUR quotes form BIBLE/KORAN insisiting like GURBANI that NAAM JAPP is the WAY to REALISE GOD/ALLAH/CHRIST/JEHOVAH....and NOT "beleif" in JESUS as SON OF GOD..and in Muhammad as the LAST PROPHET of ALLAH.
Let me tell you that GURBANI is NOT the same thing as "Astronomy"...astronomy needs a binoculars to look at distant stars... GURBANI needs a MICROSCOPE to "read closely" and PRACTISE it. I put it to you that you have been seeing too many "stars"...from down here on earth..EACH star looks the SAME...hence your "conclusion" that every religion is the SAME !!! How WRONG ...when you GO UP CLOSE..you will see that they are all different !!! ( P singh - you are under no compulsion to read my drivel )
Jarnail Singh
You "limited" me to 150 words..i limit you to JUST ONE QUOTE !!! should be very easy..NO ??
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Excellent post Arshee Giyani jeeo.
And it is interesting to read that article on Christian clergy keeping full hair.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Aug 2005
1. It was never contended that others besides Sikhs revere LONG UNCUT hair. Moses, Jesus, Samson and Prophet muhammed ji all had long uncut hair. Rishis munis in india also had that.
2. It was never contended that others never wore Turbans or didnt cover their head hair. Even Today Arabs cover their heads..Arafat always covered his head..and many others wear turbans.
3. It was never contended that others DONT meditate/do simran. Yogis do that. Bhagwan Rajneesh's followers, Hippies, Yogis, and many other do that.
4. It was never contended that others Cannot or Dont go to heaven/Bahisht/God's Presence etc etc. How can I say such a thing when NO ONE has been there and then come back here to confirm... ONLY Guru nanak ji describes SODAR Tera SOGHAR Keha jit beh sarab Samalleh. There is no reason for anyone to be concerned who is there or who isnt there.
The ONE and ONLY point of contention is that NAAM JAPPING AS THE ONLY WAY TO REALISE GOD is a UNIQUE SIKHE CONCEPT. The stress is on "ONLY WAY". NONE others lay stress on this. They HAVE their OWN WAYS ( mubarak howan).. BUT THAT is the SIKHE/GURMATT WAY..and as I am Sikh..its the WAY for ME.
Gurbani is very very clear that NO teerath bathing, no daan giving, NO silence, no Fasts, No penances, NO acts of charity, no simran/meditation/silence/body kashts...etc etc etc is a WAY to REALISE GOD....ONLY way is NAAM-JAPP...and ONLY SIKHE has this.
What GOD does with the other billions, ( how many galaxies full of how many trillions of trillions who knows ??) is not our concern. GURU JI came, GURU JI Gave us GURBANI/NAAM JAPP/GURMANTAR/AMRIT of Khanda Batta/Kakaars etc and THATS all that matters for me. WHY should I forego this GIFT of Guru ji and go "mooh marring in other KHURLiaan"..and in the end i becoem like they say Dhobee da kutta na ghar da na ghaat da !!!
I am GURU Nanak ji da kutta and that is all i know..and need to know.
Jarnail Singh.
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
If Mian Mir was a Sikh of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee, then he may have become a Brahmgiyani. Otherwise never.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
JSS JI:
I REQUESTED for SCRIPTURAL SOURCES from the Bible/Koran/Buddhist texts. You have NONE as there are None to offer.
About your point...monks "doing "simran" at Jesus's grave. What is there for me to disprove ? or prove ? I didnt "gloss over" due to my "egocentric ego" or whatever....I just DONT READ things that dont concern me..I have so little time for Gurbani as it is. This is a GURMATT Forum and my chief concern is for SIKHS to Learn something about GURMATT of GURU JI...."matts" of others take a back seat. ( Sorry if that seems like "my egocentricity" to you..let it be. you can take the time to study your monks )
I live almost next to a huge Buddhist Temple....and there is a sort of "simran-chanting" of their mantras Going on almost 24/7 !! so what do you wnat me to do ?? Prove they are "naam japping SIKHS of GURU NANAK JI...?? OR even better that they "knew" Naam japp long before Guru Ji even came to this earth ?? or something else. What they do or dont do is none of my concern. The Buddhists are soem of the most "famous" mantar jappers known today...BUT GURU Ji never even mentioned them once in our GURBANI...neither did GURU Ji visit their Holy Places/Chief theologians. SAME for Christianity. IF Guru Ji had thought they were important...surely GURU Nank Ji would have gone to JERUSALEM !!! IF Guru Ji can go to MECCA why not Jerusalem...and as I am a SIKH of that same GURU JI... I dotn give much "time" to this "monk story" of yours. sorry.
MY One and ONLY Concern is to Follow what GURU JI came to teach.
A singh Ji.:
Your article is of academic concern. I read it and it is intersting. Thanks.
Msingh Ji:
Grateful for bringing me down...."Farshi". Sometimes i get carried away too !! ha ha.
Charrdeekalla always
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Aug 2005
Dear "thank You" and "dont know"....hidden gems are just as valuable as the ones "visible"... a little "voice of sanity" also brings us down when we get lost...
This is why i like this Forum...it caters to all..and gives each poster the respect and love all of us deserve as Gursikhs.
Keep on posting....every one's views count and are important ( at least for me..because i read all posts..whether i agree with them or not is besides the point...but to just "see" soemone's name on a post and "ignore" it is foolhardy to say the least..)
Thanks to all posters for enlightening us
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
gurmukh singh · 20 Aug 2005
eman ruoy
i perfectly agree. also I suspect many posts are deleted by admin for opposing views of Kulbir Singh and Jarnail Singh, they should be aware of this
its very sad that Jarnail Singh and Kulbir Singh basically run this forum, its like a heirachy system where these guys if about to loose an argument, admin stops posts.
ive taken note of these two individuals views- and will be posting on all sikh related websites where we can have an even debate, I have also contacted Christian intellectuals who are prepared to debate this topic and others..
I will even post thee messages and the topic thread to all sikh lectures in the USA - UK - Canada so it can be disscused fairly.
Jarnail Singh and Kulbir Singh i will let you both know where and when these discuusions will take place.
i hope admin allow this post through..
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
oh deary moi · 20 Aug 2005
this is too the people that 100% believe that the only way to attain god is through sikhi:
This is the view of a gurmukh, not some random person on a forum.
When ever someone came too sant baba nand singh be it muslim, hindu, christian or whatever he could have easily made them into sikhs but he didnt infact he showed them the path in there religions.
have a good think about it jarnail & co.
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Aug 2005
eman ruoy...
and I am sad that you dont have much influence on readers of this forum....what can we do about that ?? you see the "sad" fact is that the readers have their own set of BRAINS bestowed upon them by Waheguru/God/Allah/Jehovah....and they use them wisely..of course many would like everybody to "follow" them but it just doesnt happen that way..how sad..eh ?? What can I do to STOP my "influence" ? BUT here you are sadly..very sadly mistaken my friend..the readrs of this Forum are NOT INFLUENCED by ME....NO SIR..they are INFLUENCED by GURU NANAK JI ( whom i shamelessly quote/rely on/beg from..all that i write...) So if you really want to catch the "culprit" behind my writings and stop all this undue influence which saddens you..PLEASE GO AFTER GURU NANAK JI !!!..Because it is HE who First Wrote..SABH TE WADDA SATGUR NANAK JIN KALL RAKHEE MEREE !!! GUSTAKHEE MAAF....I am a SIKH of this same GURU NANAK and for me He is INDEED the GREATEST..the GREATEST..the GREATEST...even if I say so a Trillion times that is not enough.
We my friend are NOT on a JOURNEY..we have reached the END..the DESTINATION...the TRUE GURU is BEFORE US in all his GLORY....so your "good luck" and wishes are wasted on us...go look for someone who is looking for a "donkey to ride on to begin his journey...GOOD LUCK.
It is the DUALITY..that keeps people like you in DOUBT...the other fellow just might have something worthwhile for me ?? is he right ? am i wrong ?
Sorry mate..we have left that DUALITY far behind..we have found the TRUE GURU..and need not search NO MORE. When we are RIDING the "QUEEN MARY"...why we should even bother thinking..maybe that small "fisherman's boat" is better...wont sink...etc etc...
I hope the words "Donkey rider" and "fisherman" sink in. Good luck following him..on your journey behind the son of man.. GOOD LUCK because you will need it.
Re: Jesus Christ woke up at Amritvela & did Simran!!!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Aug 2005
Author: learner
Date: 08-20-05 10:28
look at your remarks veer Jarnail Singh Ji, you just come across as arrogant as everyone has said
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
YOU are WRONG veer. I am sad that you have STOPPED LEARNIG so FAST !!!
Consider this. Bhai lehna Ji wandered all over...visiting devis, mountian peaks, volcanoes, mandirs and teeraths...When He came to GURU NANAK JI's DOOR..HE STOPPED..and SAID THIS IS THE DOOR FOR ME. From then HE NEVER MOVED an INCH....and finally became GURU ANGAD..a PART (aang) of GURU NANAK JI.
Are You saying GURU ANGGAD JI is "ARROGANT" in Openly DECLARING..ONLY GURU NANAK JI IS MY GURU, MY WAY, MY PATH...NO ONE ELSE.
Can YOU provide an EXAMPLE from Any other GURU Ji's LIFE whereby GURU JI..went arounf "Looking" at OTHER religions/paths/mandirs/teeraths/prophets...for Salvation WHILE having Found the Hosue of Nanak ?? Do you know how OLD BHAI AMARDASS JI was weh he finally ARRIVED at GURU ANGAD's DOOR after having Wandered the whole WORLD from pillar to post..from door to door..and Once He reached GURU ANGAD JI..he never MOVED an INCH...until He became GURU AMARDASS JI.
IS GURU Amardass Ji also IGNORANT and ARROGANT...by just Following ONLY and ONLY GURU NANAK JI..when there is JESUS..Mohammed..Blah Blah blah to Follow... Paaths up the PEAK as P singh says so eloquently ???
GURU AMARDASS JI declares from the ROOF TOPS that HE ONLY BELIEVES IN GURU NANAK...there is NO OTHER WAY for Him. Do you think that is ARROGANT ??
Do YOU want me to QUOTE from the THOUSANDS of QUOTES in GURBANI where the GURUS DECLARE DANKKEH DEE CHOT TE...ONLY GURU NANAK IS THE WAY...Will that be ARROGANT ??
You people have TWO FEET in TWO DIFFERENT BOATS..a sure fire way to SINK ( if that is MY ARROGANCE..good luck ) I am ON GURU NANAKS OCEAN GOING LINER....no way it will sink..it doesnt even "wallow" (Doalnna) SOLID as a ROCK....only FOOLS leave such a SHIP for a boat ???
P Singh Jss and the rest are PURPOSELY putting words in my messages...and MISINTERPRETING by saying that I am arrogantly "deriding" other religions....all are good all lead to God blah balh blah..and that Sikhe Gurmatt is the ONLY way just as the Christians claim for Jesus and Muslims claim for Muhammaed blah blah blah.
WE have said many Times..ALL other RELIGIONS are MUBARAK to their Followers....BUT for a SIKH...GURMATT is the ONE and ONLY WAY. A SIKH shouldnt and neednt "wsate" his time looking over his back and wondering..is that christian all right ?/ is that jew making it up the path...is that so and so following his path....sikhism is for all blah blah. The OTHERS cjhose thir Paths..MUBARAK to them. GURU NANAK JI said the SAME THING. NOBODY here is "CONVERTING" anyone....all we are saying is SIKHE-GURMATT-is the BEST and ONLY WAY for a SIKH. PERIOD.
Why the difficulty to understand such a simple logical answer. I HAVE CHOSEN GURMATT. NO way i am going to even give one second to Jesus/Muhammaed/or anyone else. P Singh Jss can read the Bible Koran all they like MUBARAK. "Learner" can go learn all those religions..also MUBARAK.
Thank you.
jarnail Singh.