Forum
Golden temple hasnt changed much
Golden temple hasnt changed much
ghuman · 14 Aug 2005
I was just on ebay and saw this old engraving of the golden temple ..its an engraving dated 1836 apparently is the oldest depiction.
ebay item number - 7343497771
- it hasnt changed much over the years...does any one know when the gold was put on by Maharaja Ranjit singh, as the gold has recently been replaced.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Amandeep Madra · 15 Aug 2005
Quite a lot has changed around the Darbar Sahib since that engraving in 1836.
For example, the parkarama was previously surrounded by the ancient bungas that we speak of in Ardas. These were buildings that surrounded the parkarma and gave access from the street right to the edge of the sarovar. IN the Gurus time (and right up until the turn of the century) the sarovar was accessible from any direction rather than a particular entrance.
The Darshan Deori was also lavishly painted above the marble work on the ground level - now it is whitewashed (in fat the paint was still evident in the 1970s) I think that the whitewashing was done in the 1980s.
Of course the Akal Takht has changed dramatically. The newly built Akalt Takht is quite different to the original design that Guru Hargobind deemed fit - it is much larger with an additional floor space and four more minarets.
The gold plates that Ranjit Singh adorned the Darbar Sahib were made by the artisans of the time that Ranjit Singh acquired when he took the artisan villages on the pahari region. these were the best in India and had acquired skills honed over generations. These have been torn off and replaced with shoddy copies. Some of the copies are so poor that they are starting to go green.
You will note that there are no Neon Signs in 1836, today of course the city planners do not stand in front of hotels and tacky restaurants putting glaring neon signs that are visible in the evening to pilgrims on the parkarma. You will also notice that the view from the Parkarma does not take in a 200ft concrete water tower in the shape of a UFO! This ugly monstrosity was built just a few years ago and is visible in almost every angle from the Darabr Sahib.
Virtually all of the ancient trees that once adorned the parkarma have been cut down. those majestic old and historic ones that remain are trampled over on an almost monthly basis by dozens of men as they throw electric lights all over them to celebrate gurpurbs. Ancient and irreplacebale branches have succumed to these assaults. I was in Nankana Sahib just thi march and witnessed the Sikhs there cutting down 8 ancient Bher trees in the entrance way ! and replacing the planting with cactuses !
You can also assumes that in 1836 the buildnig was not taking in water like a sponge as it is today. The britlliantly foresighted design of the darbar sahib is made to actually soak in water from the sarovar and then evaporate it through a membrane of lime plaster through teh roof. This gives a damp free building without the need of a damp proof course. the Gurus understood this, Ranjit Singh understood this (when he had the building plated) and I suspect that most people reading this have understood this but civil engineers from the UK cant seem to understand this and have capped the lime plaster with modern cement and now teh building is waterlogged.
just a few changes then
aman
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Kulwant Singh Sandhra · 15 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
> does any one know when the gold was put on by Maharaja Ranjit singh, as
> the gold has recently been replaced.
Ghuman Sahib, there is a plaque above the front entrance to Harmandir Sahib, commemerating the seva Maharaja Ranjit Singh did. It is written in Gurmukhi (in larivaar) and reads as this (in Punjabi):
Ek Onkar Satnam Karta Purakh Nirbhau Nirvair Akal Murat Ajooni Saibhang Gur Prasad ]] Jap ]] Aad Sach Jugad Sach Hai Bhi Sach Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach ]] Sri Maharaj Guru Sahib Ji ne apne param sevak Sikh jaan kar Sri Darbar Sahib Ji ki seva Sri Maharaja Singh Sahib Ranjit Singh Ji par daya kar ke karai ]] Samant 1889
So 1889 Bikrami Samant = 1832 A.D. - which is when Harmandir Sahib was gilded.
Eventhough this is engaved upon Sri Harmandir Sahib, I am suspicious about it, because it states that Guru Sahib blessed Maharaja Ranjit Singh to do seva for Sri Darbar Sahib which he did by gilding the Gurdwara. If Akal Purakh wanted Harmandir Sahib to be glided, then why didn't He bless Guru to Arjan Sahib engage upon that task when he built it in the first place. Obviously, if Guru Arjan Sahib knew that Harmandir Sahib should be gilded, then He would've done so...
What do other people think?
[%sig%]
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
S Singh · 15 Aug 2005
Amandeep has raised a lot of valid points. The like of Dr Rai and co went out there way to stop WHS but are now silent over the issue of heritage protection and sorting out the disaster the birmingham jatha have done through their shoddy gold plating effort.
The birmingham jatha know about the magnitude of the problems they have casued but rather than address them, they like to pretend they do not exist.
From there reluctance to accept the problems they have casued it would appear that they have hidden long term motives. Perhaps they want the Darbar Sahib to crumble away so they can replace it with a modern structure designed in birmingham. What even Indira Gandhi did not do during bluestar the birmingham jatha have started the process of destroying the Darbar Sahib.
I hope Bhai Sahib Mohinder Singh Ji can take his blinkers off before it is too late. He should be a man admit mistakes were made and put them right before it is too late.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
singhstar · 15 Aug 2005
brilliant old engraving
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
singhstar · 15 Aug 2005
Amandeep firslty Siques tigers - a great book.
Now do you have proof of what you wrote regarding the new gold plates are going green - do you have pics - images as i assume you must have seen...also can u elaborate on the part where u wrote about the dampness.
If we can bring up this issue in the UK - USA media im sure something will be done about it - im sure a headline like 'golden temple will be no more in the next ten years' which may not be the truth but will cause enough uproar and omething will be done to remove the recent rubbish they have put on.
Also Amandeep, is it possible the original gold plates of Ranjit Singh could be placed back on ??? Also I know these are in a storage room at he complex, what are the plans for these plates, should they be given to museums as i cant think of any use in a store room, knowing the sikhs in charge they will probably do something like MELT THEM DOWN AND MAKE MODERN JEWLLERY like kara etc..why is it the Sikh religious authorities are the most uneducated and really just a bunch of pendus....
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
singh m · 16 Aug 2005
singhstar
the sikh leaders in punjab are those who can shout more abuse does not really understand gurbani or is a murderer e.g.jathedar ranjit singh, vedanti, name a few that is why sikhi is going backward we need highly educated (in sikhism and gurbani not maths or science) people to lead the panth most of our bhais are uneducated. they are unable to respond to gallat propoganda by anti sikh people. their answer as always is "sanu ki lorrh hai jhakran di waheguru aape hee sajaa deyu"
[%sig%]
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
S Singh · 16 Aug 2005
singhstar Ji,
The issue of the poor quality plating and damp is know to the birmingham jatha but they are in total denial and refuse to accept the truth.
A radio program was aired by the bbc in which Mohinder Singh Ji of the Jatha went into denial.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Amandeep Madra · 16 Aug 2005
This is a direct quote from the BBC investigation into the re-guilding problems. I am not sure why he conflates the anniversary of the "holy book" (as he puts it) with the restoration but he has clearly stated his reluctance to accept either a problem & woudl rather blame the critisism for defiling the Darabr Sahib!
"Mohinder Singh, the Chairman of the Guru Nanak Nishkam Sevak Jatha, said: "History will record that I was responsible for doing the gold gilding. My conscience is clear. This is the 400th anniversary of our holy book, a very important anniversary. But, for people who made objections for nothing, the Golden Temple remains un-cleaned inside. This is the damage that was done."
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
singhstar · 16 Aug 2005
mohinder singhs comes across very arrogant and proud with that statement...last thing u wanto see is those nuts running the golden temple...keep the east africans out !!!!!!
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
A Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Birmingham is in the UK I though not in East Africa?
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
S Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Amandeep is the radio program or complete transcript available online ?
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
..... · 16 Aug 2005
Amandeep Madra Ji i'v just got a question for you
Yes its vital that the SGPC & birmingham lot don't eradicate the authentic design/structure of the Darbar Sahib complex by doing a 'dojjy job' but (as asked earlier by someone) why did Maharaja Ranjit Singh deem it necessary to add Gold to Harmandir Sahib, couldn't Guru Arjan Dev Ji maharaaj have added it if necessary, didn't he (Ranjit singh) change Darbar Sahib?
I know im contradicting myself in the question but i understand what your saying but on the other hand i don't understand why you don't say, lets rip off all the Gold and go down to the physical structure (before maharaja Ranjit Singh) which Guru Sahib gave blessing to.
On one hand you say we need to preserve yet on the other hand you say Maharaja Ranjit Singh had expert craftmen who themselves changed Darbar sahib (they may not have damaged it but certainly did change its physical appearance)
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
S Singh · 16 Aug 2005
>>lets rip off all the Gold and go down to the physical structure (before maharaja Ranjit Singh) which Guru Sahib gave blessing to.
Not possible anymore thanks to the brummies using the disgusting technique of bonding the gold plating to the inner structure using a cement based mixture.
As for the structure which Guru Sahib gave their blessing to this was destroyed over the centuries. Ahmad Shah Abdali is said to have blown up the structure.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
,,,,,,,,,,, · 16 Aug 2005
at least when ranjit singh improved Harmandir Sahib..it stayed in good nik for the next 150 years..but these modern day sikh idiots took just a year ruining it..i mean its the most hoiliest shrine of the Sikh people..one of the greatest landmarks on this planet !!!!
yet sikh being sikhs dont give a hoot and havent objected...
Amandeep your in a great position to bring this to light, u talk the talk !!!! but thats it !!! lets see u do something about these mahants...contact the media, dont be frightened or scared by Monhinder singhs mob..
Mohinder singh should be held accountable for his actions and should admit to the trashy job he carried out......he just wanted to go down in history as the man who plated the Harmandir Sahib...pure ego....
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
,,,,,,,,,,, · 16 Aug 2005
nice engraving though
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Singh · 16 Aug 2005
"For example, the parkarama was previously surrounded by the ancient bungas that we speak of in Ardas."
These are NOT the Bungay we speak about in Ardaas. I don't know where you got this from. These 'ancient' bungay were not around during the times of our gurus and certainly aren't 'jugo jugo aatal.' The bungay we talk about in our ardaas are bungay such as Sri Akal Bunga (today known as Sri Akal Takht.)
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Princess · 16 Aug 2005
Gurmukh piaaryeo! it's Harmander Sahib not Golden Temple.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
A Singh · 17 Aug 2005
Princess,
It's HarImandir Sahib not Harmandir Sahib.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
dont know · 17 Aug 2005
good observation princess
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Amandeep Madra · 17 Aug 2005
There are lots of questions here - let me offer a few answers from my perspective:
1. Transcript of Navdip Dhariwal's radio piece for the BBC on the seva carried out by the GNNSJ. This is not available any more - the BBC puts the file up for 7 days on its "Listen Again" Service and then takes it down. I know Navdip and I will email her and ask if she can send me a transcript.
2. Can the plates be put back on? Yes they can and that’s exactly what should happen. I am sure that some have gone missing and I am sure that some are damaged beyond repair now. Those that remain and are in storage should be sent for immediate restoration and stabilisation. They should be conserved and then put back onto the building. At the same time all evidence of the intervention by the GNNSJ (including the extremely damaging cementing of the upper floors and the rubber membrane on the roof should be removed and natural materials that will prolong the life of the building used. The panels made by the GNNSJ can be out into storage or they can rebuild their copy of the Darbar Sahib in Birmingham (UK) or Kenya or wherever they want to do it.
3. You asked me to do something. Well I make a fuss and make a noise (in return I get threats like "we know where you live" and "be careful crossing the road") However I do try to raise the issue with the press (i.e. 1999 Peter Poppham article in The Independent, the Gold Service Radio piece and more recently an interview with The Observer (not yet published). Patwant Singh and Gurmeet Rai are the real experts and they have tried extremely hard to get things changed on the ground in India. Patwant is now quiet ill and Gurmeet has been distracted by the antics of Jasdev Rai and his politicising the UNESCO dossier. Without some kind of external protection the PHYSICAL FABRIC of the Harimandir Sahib is in the hands of the SGPC & the kar seva babas. Nothing now will change.
4. Interventions made by Ranjit Singh. This is a really excellent point. Was Ranjit Singh the greatest Sikh vandal by gilding the original Harimandir in the first place? He did the same all around his Punjab - Nankana Sahib, Dera Sahib etc etc. All these places have lost their original structures and were replaced by marble and gold. In the conservation world there is a debate raging about that and it will continue I guess. However, conservators and architectural historians are pretty well agreed that the remain many different types of intervention. For example sometime you can add modern materials in a sensitive way to a highly sensitive site e.g. the new Grand Court at eth British Museum - a masterful job. Sometimes (in history) interventions have been made to buildings to "beatify" them - if done with artistic integrity then the intervention while regrettable (from a historical perspective) is legitimate especially after it has acquired its own sense of historical importance ( The gilding of the Darbar Sahib in 1830s being an excellent example). But what about those really tacky marble tiles that the SGPC used on the floor of the parkarma in the 1970 as a money making scheme (the ones with peoples name on them and how much money they gave) have these now become legitimate?
Sometimes interventions are "marks of history" a good Sikh example are the bullet holes from 1984 in the Darbar Sahib and the destruction of the front face of the Akal takht. here there is real differing opinion on what to do. Personally I would say that on a building we should leave those marks there, but where does that leave the Akal Takht?
However, there is a unified position on restoration and conservation - this cannot and should never be an attempt to simply produce a replica version - at all times the original materials/marks should be retained. IN the case of the 99 seva by the gnnsj there was a deliberate policy to simple replicate the original panels and replace them with shiny new versions - most of which were really poorly produced and lack both the antique patina of the originals or the artisitc beauty and brilliance of the 19th century ones that they were copying. This is simply inexcusable. Another example is the destruction of the Chamkaur Sahib Gharri - a mud fort that was one of the very few surviving examples left in India. Because it was made from "mud" it absorbed cannon shot and was unassailed by either Mughals or the British - it was the last fort of the Sikh Gurus left in existence and obviously extremely important in the life of the tenth Guru. What the Mughals failed to do in the 18th century the SGPC carried out in the 1970s by tearing it down and replacing with a bog-standard marble gurdwara - another nail in the coffin f Sikh heritage.
At the end of the day there remain lots of unanswered questions about the 99 seva:
Why did they take off the originals when this was totally unnecessary and an unparalleled act of vandalism?
Why were the wall paintings under the panels white washed and cemented over?
Why do the GNNSJ not listen to the advice of architectural historians and conservation architects and do something about the damp in the building?
Why did the GNNSJ hide the fact that the gold panels were stored and not destroyed (as they had maintained to me in 1999)
What is the GNNSJ/SGPC going to do about this?
Amandeep
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Sikh Singh · 17 Aug 2005
Amandeep Singh, do you have a picture of the original Chamkaur Sahib Gharri when it was a mud fort?
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
khalsa_force · 17 Aug 2005
Author: Singh
Date: 08-16-05 20:36
"For example, the parkarama was previously surrounded by the ancient bungas that we speak of in Ardas."
These are NOT the Bungay we speak about in Ardaas. I don't know where you got this from. These 'ancient' bungay were not around during the times of our gurus and certainly aren't 'jugo jugo aatal.' The bungay we talk about in our ardaas are bungay such as Sri Akal Bunga (today known as Sri Akal Takht.)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WORDS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
,,,,,,,,,,, · 17 Aug 2005
why dont the akj confront mohinder singh about this issue - ie seen all you lot worried about the sorry state of affairs of sikhi...put your money where your mouth is !!!! u to amandeep lets all sign a petition that will go to every sikh ......lets see what mohinder singh has to say when he sees 100 000 signatures, whether he admits he made a hash of it or not we should get the Golden temple back to its original glory.
Get that Navdeep reporter to do a documentary on the temple ....she can go to soho rd gurdwara and challenge him...it could be then shown on newsnight and in every Gurdwara in the world..lets see his reaction, if he ignores her or they refuse to talk then we all know he had the wrong intentions..
Amandeep its up to you - u pull this off, ul be the greatest singh on the planet and ud saved the the Holiest shrine ..and not like mohinder singh who just wants to be remembered because of the shody gold plates he put on.
ps - ul probably get more book sales (joke)
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
member · 17 Aug 2005
In addition to the destruction of the Harimandhar Sahib, the SGPC and their cronies have desecrated Baba Atal by tiling over frescos and paintings.
The expansion of roads into Anadpur Sahib prior to the '99' celebrations destroyed many parts of old Anandpur. When Gurmeet Kaur Rai protested publicly in India, she was met with death threats! In addition Kila 'Anandgarh' has been downsized no end. The original boundary of the fort varies greatly to what we see today.
When I last visted Anandpur Sahib (2003) I was shocked to see the internal design of the fort plastered with nasty grey plaster, applied in a slap dash approach. To top it off they had 2 employed bhaiye destroying the base of the Nishan Sahib opposite.
Singh wrote' These are NOT the Bungay we speak about in Ardaas. I don't know where you got this from. These 'ancient' bungay were not around during the times of our gurus and certainly aren't 'jugo jugo aatal.' The bungay we talk about in our ardaas are bungay such as Sri Akal Bunga (today known as Sri Akal Takht.)
Amandeep - Did Jeevan Deol not mention 13 bungey in existence around Harimandhar Sahib in one of his talks?
Now we have 2 left. One has already been destroyed with modern bricks and the other one is half standing.
This destruction of Sikh History is shocking. No other faith has systematically destroyed its own heritage in such a way than the Sikhs.
We are lucky that the British have preserved some of our history in their museums and other private collections.. Imagine Maharajah Ranjit Singhs chair in the hand of Badal..By now he would have melted it down for his Mrs!
Staying on the note of collections, I would urge everyone to visit the Wallace Collection (London, UK), before they remove the display of Maharajah Ranjit Singh personal talwar and shield. They are simply brilliant. A prior warning though...you will feel like stealing all of the exquisite shashtars in display!!!!
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
ghuman · 17 Aug 2005
[URL=http://imageshack.us][IMG]http://img333.imageshack.us/img333/198/3b39km.jpg[/IMG][/URL]
[%sig%]
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
ONE · 18 Aug 2005
In response to the question about the 'Bungas' - here is a list of 68 Bungas and 12 'akharas' recorded by Giani Gian Singh in his 'Twarik siri Amritsar' published in 1889 .
These Bungas were famous centres of learning as well as mansions of Sardars - these Bungas taught Gurmukhi, Sanskrit, Gurmatt Sangeet (rabab,Sarangi), gurmukhi calligraphy, and even ayurvedic medicine -- in other words they were like a University of Sikhi - with the Gurdwaras Act of 1925 all these Bungas and properties were transfered to the SGPC - In 1943 the SGPC decided to widen the parikarma and almost all these Bungas were demolished.
Thereby setting a precedent for the subsequent wholesale demolition of Sikh Heritage by SGPC.
GurFateh,
Ranjit Singh 'Freed'
[IMG]http://img365.imageshack.us/img365/1981/bungas1up.png[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img365.imageshack.us/img365/7966/bungas26zb.png[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img365.imageshack.us/img365/6850/untitled3bungas35ok.png[/IMG]
* Taken from The Encylopaedia of Sikhism - Harbans Singh 2002 - Vol 1 pp 415
[%sig%]
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Amandeep Madra · 18 Aug 2005
THanks Ranjit Singh - great job.
THe last remaining Bungas are of course the Akal Bunga (the original building was completely demolished to the floor level in 1986) and teh Rangharai Bungas (which were 'renovated' a few years ago in Disneyland pink with white piping)
Brahm Buta Akhara was in existance as a physical structure until the late 1990s but it has now been torn down completely
aman
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Bhopinder Singh · 18 Aug 2005
Bunga question has been setteled
These are NOT the Bungay we speak about in Ardaas. I don't know where you got this from. These 'ancient' bungay were not around during the times of our gurus and certainly aren't 'jugo jugo aatal.' The bungay we talk about in our ardaas are bungay such as Sri Akal Bunga (today known as Sri Akal Takht.)
___________________________________________________________
very good answer
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
singhdicate · 18 Aug 2005
simply a brilliant disscusion
a great job by all..... especially amandeep
best topic in weeks
45th Rattray's Sikhs
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
A Singh · 18 Aug 2005
Perhaps a little dated, however on Amandeep’s last point, here’s one of many news clippings covering the “renovation” of the Ramgarhia Bungas by the SGPC and the opposition it has faced even in India to their shoddy work.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh
Sikh heritage: Ramgarhia body, SGPC lock horns
Varinder Walia
Tribune News Service
Amritsar, October 1
The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC) and the Sardar Jassa Singh Ramgarhia Federation have locked horns over the restoration work being carried out at Ramgarhia bungas in the Golden Temple complex and at Gurdwara Baba Atal through kar seva.
Mr Bhagwant Singh, president of the federation, said earlier the kar seva of historic Ramgarhia bungas was carried out by the Ramgarhia Federation. He said services of reputed architects, historians and engineers were requisitioned to restore the two minarets to their original shape and structure. As regards the Ramgarhia bunga itself, which is a fine piece of architectural marvel and civil engineering expertise, is structurally supported on parabolic arches decorated with cornices and the projections are supported by architraves and brackets.
Expressing concern over the handing over the kar seva to the traditional ‘babas’, the Ramgarhia Federation said the age-old Sikh history might be damaged in the process. The federation expressed a apprehension that after the siege of ‘Lal Quila’ (the Red Fort) Sardar Jassa Singh Ramgarhia got the marble seat of the Mughal throne removed and brought it to Amritsar which is now-a-days placed on the ‘barandari’ on the first floor of the Ramgarhia bunga which could be damaged by the kar sevaks without knowing the historical significance of the slab. In such a way the rich Sikh history would be damaged for ever as they (babas) are putting in reinforced concrete beams and rafters in place of the arches which are the basic characteristics of the Sikh School of Architecture.
The Ramgarhia Federation alleged that the kar seva undertaken in the Golden Temple complex by unskilled workers was causing irreparable loss to the Sikh School of Architecture, aesthetically and destroying the Sikh history. The federation further said that the Sardar Jassa Singh Ramgarhia Federation had taken up the work of repair and restoration of the main building of the ‘bunga’, got the bricks chiselled, cut and ground as per the original design and repaired two or three panels, unfortunately the ‘kar seva’ was withdrawn by the SGPC authorities for reasons best known to them.
The federation had approached the SGPC for restoration of the kar seva but to no avail.
Taken from: http://www.tribuneindia.com/2002/20021002/punjab1.htm
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
,,,,,,,,,,, · 18 Aug 2005
Amandeep lets us know what the course of action is, are you going to draw up a plan of action, or are we just going to type until we are blue in the face and as normal nothing happens - and 3 months later ull say the same thing.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
JN Singh · 18 Aug 2005
Amandeep Singha, what do you suggest the Sikhs in the west should do to prevent further "renovation" of our heritage by the Karseva Sants?
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
,,,,,,,,,,, · 18 Aug 2005
quite astonishing, so many bungas destroyed, very interesting to know what they were used for.
The Golden temple is way to commercial, the mahants running it see it has a business, i mean there must be huge amounts of money involved as milions visit every year. They probably need to accomodate the large crowds hence demoilsh everything...one day there will be just the temple and akal takht standing. Its sad that there isnt much anyone can do.
I agree with Inderjit, thank god for the british museum, v&a for preserving the sikh heritage, god knows what would happen if it was in these mahants hands. The Ranjit Singh sword is brilliant, you should also look at the sikh items at the british library, they have many images online. Heres the link http://www.imagesonline.bl.uk/britishlibrary/
type in sikh, singh, punjab etc...ull see some beatiful sikh relics.
Amandeep, i have some questions
1. can you please point out if there is any image, painting of the Golden Temple without the Gold plating..before Maharaja Ranjit Singh plated it with gold. - circa pre 1820
2. Why is there very few paintings of Hari Singh Nalwa, you see many portraits of sikh courtiers such as dhian singh - sher singh etc
3. The solvyns sic - 1790s...would you say these groups of sikhs are nighungs ??..its an amazing scene i think as captures a true likeness of what i imagined sikhs would look like, very warrior like, it reminds me of the conversation betweem nadir shahs and his governor, where the governor said to him..these sikhs eat less..sleep less..their saddles are their horses.
4. Regarding manuscripts - what is the oldest punjabi/sikh manuscript, there should be so much out there, during the period from Guru Nanak Ji -to- Guru Arjan dev ji , there must have been alot written, even if sikhism was relatively new. Do you know of any old sikh literature pre Guru Arjan dev ji. ?? even if by th bhagats like Kabir, farid etc.
Sorry for going of the topic, but Id appreciate if you could kindly answer my queries.
Thank you
[%sig%]
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
read article · 20 Aug 2005
everyone read the artcicle below - very depressing article...especially the 19th century frescoes of Guru Nanak, scrapped of and replaced by green avocadoe green tiles. i cant even use words to express my anger. this is so terible, every day sikh heritage is being destroyed...i mean are these guys nuts ...what are they doing, who on earth would scrape of such precious depictions of Guru Nanak. Sickening
Headline: Brummies bodge Sikhs’ holy shrine
Journalist: Peter Popham
Date: 25 September 1999
Source: The Independent
Story:
IN THE middle of an artificial lake gleams a golden pavilion. It is the holy of holies of the Sikh religion, and an architectural masterpiece to rival the Taj Mahal. But unlike the latter, this is a shrine throbbing with life.
Day and night, plangent Sikh hymns roll across the water. Every day thousands of Sikh pilgrims from all over the world stream through, bathing in the holy waters and prostrating themselves before the holy book. Outsiders are welcomed: two years ago the Queen and Prince Philip were given a tour of the complex, and a model of it to take home as a souvenir.
But despite all the love and attention, the Golden Temple in the northern Indian city of Amritsar is under dire threat - ironically, from pious Sikhs who devote all their spare time and money to the shrine.
In the name of renovation and improvement, groups of karsevaks, or volunteers, throw themselves into doing their bit for the temple. Prominent among them is a group of British Sikhs from Birmingham, the Guru Nanak Nishkam Jatha. But nobody in the temple exercises informed control over the renovation work that gets done, with the result that this 200-year-old masterpiece is being steadily defaced, distorted and vulgarised.
In an octagonal nine-storey tower erected 200 years ago in memory of a nine-year-old martyr, 19th century frescoes depicting the life of Guru Nanak, the religion's founder, have been scraped off the walls and replaced by avocado green bathroom tiles.
The holiest spot in the complex is the Harimandir Sahib, the Abode of God, in the centre of the lake, reached by a 200-yard causeway. This is where the holy men sit continuously singing hymns, while devotees troop in and out. The upper part of the Harimandir gleams golden: the copper plates it is made of are thickly covered in gold leaf. The entire roof has recently been renovated by the Sikhs from Birmingham, a work that took four years to complete.
But experts in Sikh architecture charge that, in their zeal, the craftsmen hired by the Birmingham devotees have done irreparable damage to the roof, plastering cement over paintings which lay underneath the original copper sheets, thereby destroying them.
The Akal Takht is the other holy spot in the complex, the building to which the holy book, the Granth Sahib, is ritually carried every day.
The original structure, a delicate brick pavilion, was blown apart by Indian army tanks in 1984, when Indira Gandhi demanded that secessionist Sikh terrorists who had seized it should be killed. Afterwards the pavilion was razed to the ground and rebuilt - but the replacement is a hulking ferro-concrete building with none of the grace of the original.
The stream of believers and the singing of hymns ensure a serene mood inside. But the canopy suspended over the holy book, garish pink and fringed like a bedcover, alerts one to the fact that Sikh aesthetics are not what they once were.
Upstairs on scaffolding, Harbhajan Singh and his sons, local artisans, are painting the ceiling. Their work is precise and highly detailed, but the colours they use - cream and orange and blue and yellow and pink - would look more at home on a carousel in a fairground. "Did you have this colour scheme approved by the temple authorities?" I asked
him. "No, no, I chose it myself," he replied. "I don't have to get permission from anyone. I've been painting here since 1955. Nobody tells me what to do."
For many years, educated Sikhs have kept quiet about the stealthy, well-intentioned desecration that is overtaking the Golden Temple and other of Sikhism's historical treasures. But now they are making their indignation known.
"These people are showing utter lack of sensitivity towards our heritage," says Patwant Singh, a noted authority on Sikh art and architecture. "Despite the resoluteness with which Sikhs have risen to every challenge, our generation has not been able to face the challenge of conserving its heritage."
Gurmeet Rai, an architectural historian who has made a systematic study of the historic buildings of Punjab for Unesco, said: "They are killing the essence of what the religion is. People are concerned - believers are concerned about it - but nobody is organised to make
their voices heard."
The crux of the problem is the way the Golden Temple and all other historical gurudwaras - or temples - are run. The controlling body is an organisation called the Shiromani Gurudwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC). But it is said to be riven by factional politics, and has no conservation experts to guide its policy.
Patwant Singh said: "The SGPC has more money than they know what to do with. They must stop all physical intervention by outside bodies like the Birmingham group. They have to establish that no historical gurudwaras will be touched unless the work is vetted by them."
Most of the Birmingham Sikhs have left Punjab now. One who remains, an elder named Mehnga Singh with a kindly face and a magnificent long white beard, complains of false accusations. "It was quite wrong to blame us for putting bathroom tiles in the Babar Atal," he said. "That was nothing to do with us. We only did the gold leaf work in the Haramandir. And we have nothing whatever to do with the SGPC."
Both SGPC spokesmen were out of town and unavailable for comment.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
ONE · 20 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh !!
The Original question in this thread asked if the Darbar Sahib and its surroundings had changed much over the years - Here is a collection of pictures which show the drastic changes that have 'occured' over the years - while many are understandable as all environments change with time and increased sangat, many changes are downright shocking - evenmore so as many of the 'changes' have occured very recently - therefore some of these pictures are extremely upsetting.
These first two pictures are 'before' and 'after' pictures of the small 'pavillion' on the roof terrace of the Darbar Sahib.They show the room before the recent "renovation" and after - it can be seen that the work it not at all sympathetic to the original - very garish acrylic paints have been used - not the more muted 'organic' paints of the original . The same 'restoration' would have happened to the Shish Mahal and Main Darbar if experts such as Gurmeet Rai (Thankfully) had not prevented it.
[IMG]http://img370.imageshack.us/img370/1949/roofdomebefore9nc.jpg[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/5462/roofdome7we.jpg[/IMG]
These next two picture show the Minars of the Ramgarhia Bunga - first after the 1984 Attack and today after the "restoration"
[IMG]http://img399.imageshack.us/img399/8526/ramgarhiabunga2pz.jpg[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img378.imageshack.us/img378/4733/amritsar0058cg.jpg[/IMG]
These next pictures show the courtyard between the Akal Takht and the Darshani Deori - The first is from around 1997 and shows the parikarma with intricate geometric patterns - much of it donated by Rich Sardars and Maharajas.
The second picture shows the same parikarma today - paved with plain patterns - all that priceless work lost.
[IMG]http://img369.imageshack.us/img369/4015/parikarma5gp.png[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img369.imageshack.us/img369/4247/amritsar0081so.jpg[/IMG]
This next picture show Darbar Sahib in the 1880s from a photgraph by Craddock - note all the trees and the Bungay that surround the Sarovar.
[IMG]http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/8360/craddockgeorge1880s3cn.jpg[/IMG]
These next pictures are by Baker from the 1870s - in the first note the lack of 'jungley' or barriers - and also the dome on the Ramgarhia Bunga this was lost in an earthquake in 1905
[IMG]http://img397.imageshack.us/img397/5052/bakerwilliamhenry1870s2eh.jpg[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/6648/bakerwilliamhenry1870s25bm.jpg[/IMG]
This picture is from 1903 - you can see the domes on the Minars and the Bungas
[IMG]http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/6333/19031fs.jpg[/IMG]
This pictures shows the Baba Atal tower and the many trees
[IMG]http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/3628/19057cf.jpg[/IMG]
In this picture taken in 1903 from the Baba Atal tower you can see all the Bungay, trees and the Gothic clock built by the British.
[IMG]http://img369.imageshack.us/img369/4163/amritsarthecentreofsikhreligio.jpg[/IMG]
The Gothic clock can be seen better in this picture
[IMG]http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/1167/babey5ib.jpg[/IMG]
The Bungas can be seen in this picture
[IMG]http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/1817/bathersinthetankgoldentemple2v.jpg[/IMG]
In this postcard the painting on the Darshani Deori can be seen clearly - today it has been covered in gold plates, marble or whitewashed.
[IMG]http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/8895/postcard2en.jpg[/IMG]
This picture shows the Akal Takht in 1967 - note how it is part of the city not separated like today by the government's 'Galiara Project' - houses and the bazaar came up to the parikarma.
[IMG]http://img370.imageshack.us/img370/6674/fatehsinghjanuary419676ap.jpg[/IMG]
The Original 'Thara' of the Akal Takht - this was discovered after the Government rebuilt Akal Takht was demolished in 1984 - it is believed to be the original as built by Guru Hargobind Sahib - replete with mughal motifs and 'Nanakshahi' bricks
[IMG]http://img370.imageshack.us/img370/2291/originalakaltakhtwork5ss.jpg[/IMG]
These two panoramas show the Darbar Sahib as it is today
[IMG]http://img375.imageshack.us/img375/8192/panorama6yk.jpg[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img370.imageshack.us/img370/8126/panorama28ye.jpg[/IMG]
This last picture shows the new gold work on the walls of the Harimandir Sahib - it can be seen that the panels lack the ages old patina, priceless craftsmanship and history of the originals.
[IMG]http://img370.imageshack.us/img370/6279/windows8ik.jpg[/IMG]
GurFateh !
Ranjit Singh (Freed)
[%sig%]
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Amandeep Madra · 22 Aug 2005
Thanks "Freed" for another excellent posting. Really enlightening stuff
Can you also find a picture of the Akal Takht before Bluestar
And after the 1986 Seva to show the redesign please?
I think that would illustrate another point too.
There have been a number of Qs recently. I want to offer
a few of my personal thoughts:
1. Are there any paintings of the Harimandir pre-1820s?
Not that I know of. That is why it was so vital to document what was
under the plates when the GNNSJ did take them off. Instead the precious
wall painting that were under the plates were simply whitewashed or
concreted over
2. Why so few paintings of Hari Singh Nalwa?
Most of the paintings of the Sikh court and courtiers date from the
time of Sher Singh - by that time Hari Singh was long gone (he died
earlier than Ranjit Singh had. there was obviously a desire by the
patrons of the arts to concentrate on figures that they respected and
were politically aligned to. Maybe Sher Singh was not as close to Hari Singh
as his father was?
3. Are the Sikhs painted by Solvyns NIhangs? I don’t know - I am sure
that the Nihangs would say that they are
4. A question about the oldest Sikh MSS. I am not an expert in this
area. I recall a thread on this message board from Singhdicate about
this very topic?
5. What can we practically do about Sikh Heritage
My personal view is that there is little point raising this issue in the media.
The BBC Radio documentary had no impact on Sikh masses. Sikh simply
don’t care about their heritage on a mass level . Those of you who
are reading this thread and are affected are very much in a minority. Sorry
to sound do negative,.
I also don’t think that the answer lies in battling against the GNNSJ,. any
correction of their work at eth Darbar Sahib will not be done with them
it will be done despite them. they are proud of what they have done
(witness for example their forthcoming smagam in Northolt where they
are presenting an exhibition and video of the gold seva) they will not
see that being replaced. The press attention and any other kind of pressure
is positive in ensuring that they don’t do it again on any other Sikh
monuments (they have designs on all kinds of other places)
So what can practically be done. Personally I think that the answer lies
in several strands:
1. Stop giving money to people who destroy heritage eg the GNNSJ, The
SGPC etc. I don’t put money in gholaks of bodies who conduct this kind of
seva and I tell others not to either. don’t give cash give something else.
2. Start giving money to positive programs of conservation and heritage
preservation. Few are happening so keep saving until one comes along.
3. Educate yourself and others about our Sikh heritage. Buy books, give
books to others on birthdays etc - there are lots of great books on Sikh
arts and heritage. Otherwise read these threads and pas the message
on.
4. Start documenting what is around you. There are few pictures of the
Chamkaur Sahib GHarri for example. Please start to document what is left
in your villages and tehsils. Even modest little things. document
them and label them = they will be precious archives in the future. The
act of documentation also gives local people a sense of value of what
they have
5. We have to work at an international level to get protection for our
Sikh heritage. Unfortunate the first attempt at doing this was viscously and unnecessarily politicised and is now all but dead. This was a great mistake
by Sikh bodies. Without external influence the Sikh community, SGOPC and
Sikh institutions simply wont change because there really isn’t either a mass
movement asking for change or a bottomless bin of money to make the change outside of the institutions.
Do others on this thread want to add to this list ?
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
singh · 22 Aug 2005
amandeep madra
you are ranting about loss of sikh heritage from guru sahibs times
a simple question
is the todays harimandir sahib building the same what guru arjan dev ji constructed?
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
singh · 22 Aug 2005
madra ji
let us see a picture of the new panels going green
comon guys
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Amandeep Madra · 22 Aug 2005
Dear "singh"
No please read this thread properly. I am "ranting" about the loss of heritage full stop. A simple answer to your simple question is that the harimandir is not the same as what Guru Arjan constructed - its a stupid question becuase every one knows that it was rebuilt during Misl times after Abdali had the darbar blown to pieces.
However, that does not give anyone the licence to further destroy our rich architectural heritage by doing shoddy conservation work . Are you saying that it is OK to carry out substandard work simply becuase the building is not completely of the time of the Guru? (see the rapidly tarnishing panles in Freeds pictures for example, or the garish recolouring of the internal paintwork with modern synthetic paints)
If the Harimandir's amrble continues to discolour and goes rusty brown or a mouldy green colour becuase of teh damp problems, will you simply shrug your shoudlers and say "oh, that's OK becuase it wasnt from the Guru's time" or woudl you even prefer to have kar sevaks whip the old marble off and replace with them sythetic formica replicas?
aman
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
ONE · 22 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh !
Here is a collection of pictures showing the way the Akal Takht has changed.
It can be seen that after the 1984 Army Attack the Akal Takht changed from the original delicate design to one which is much larger and higher.
The pictures also show the lost intricate marble courtyard and the houses and bazaars behind and surrounding the Darbar Sahib Complex which were demolished by the Government in the 'beautifcation' Galiara Project
The Akal Takht in the 1960s
[IMG]http://img371.imageshack.us/img371/7793/at14qy.png[/IMG]
In the 1970s
[IMG]http://img371.imageshack.us/img371/2650/at20tx.png[/IMG]
The intricate marble floor in front of the Akal Takht in the 1970s
[IMG]http://img229.imageshack.us/img229/9093/at30ey.png[/IMG]
The Akal Takht in the 1980s before the Army Attack
[IMG]http://img363.imageshack.us/img363/8927/akaltakht4bo.jpg[/IMG]
The Akal Takht after it was repaired in the "Sarkari" Kar Sewa and just before it was demolished (in 1986 I believe)
[IMG]http://img378.imageshack.us/img378/2816/at72rz.png[/IMG]
Rebuilding underway
[IMG]http://img292.imageshack.us/img292/4829/at60fp.png[/IMG]
A Birds eye view of the rebuilt Akal Takht - in this picture it is apparent that although it appears as if the Akal Takht faces the Darbar Sahib- it infact is at a slight angle and tradition says it faces the Throne of the Red Fort and is in fact Higher than the Delhi Throne - a Direct Challenge to the authority of Delhi.
[IMG]http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/4720/birdseyeat1mi.jpg[/IMG]
The Much bigger wider and taller Akal Takht - note the marble floor and 'roundel' have been replaced with a much simpler design - while this floor was damaged by Indian Tanks in 1984 - it was not 'beyond repair' - the old design was so Gorgeous and intricate it deserved to be restored to its former glory.
[IMG]http://img4.imageshack.us/img4/4756/at58im.png[/IMG]
A closer view of the new Akal Takht
[IMG]http://img197.imageshack.us/img197/7476/at43qq.png[/IMG]
The Interior of the Akal Takht
[IMG]http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/6619/internalat4vg.jpg[/IMG]
A selection of views
[IMG]http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/917/atak9zc.jpg[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img352.imageshack.us/img352/1036/at20028pm.jpg[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img356.imageshack.us/img356/26/akaltdusk4yy.jpg[/IMG]
During the Nishan Sahib Sewa of 2003
[IMG]http://img299.imageshack.us/img299/4531/atsewa7jz.jpg[/IMG]
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
ONE · 22 Aug 2005
GurFateh !
This Photograph shows the painted wall surface of the Darshani Deori - It is now covered in Gold Plates as can be seen in the second picture.
Giani Gian Singh claims in his 'twarik-siri-Amritsar' that the Darshani Deori was built in 1776AD - this would mean it was built during the Last rebuilding after the final Abdali destruction - and means it is at least 54 years older than the Darbar Sahib as Gold Plated and 'built' by Maharaja Ranjit Singh.(completed around 1830)
Perhaps this painted surface gives a clue as to what the 'original' - or the 'rebuilt' earlier Darbar Sahib looked like ??
Ranjit Singh (Freed)
[IMG]http://img368.imageshack.us/img368/264/paintdeori1hv.png[/IMG]
[IMG]http://img369.imageshack.us/img369/4247/amritsar0081so.jpg[/IMG]
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
Amandeep Madra · 23 Aug 2005
freed,
another great job. take a look at this picture on guruustuk's blog that shows that the wall paintings on the 18th c darshan deori were still there in the 1970s. Also you can see remnants of the old wall frescoes under the cornice on the upper floor ofthe Darshan Deori in the last pic you posted. (MAybe they ran out of paint!)
http://www.mrsikhnet.com/hello/1328287/700/Gurumustuk_Walking_Around_the_Golden_Temple-2005.07.18-12.45.13.jpg
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
S Singh · 23 Aug 2005
In the last picture notice the lovely clock that has been hung in the middle of the Darshani Deori arched entrance. Shows the total lack of respect towards Sikh heritage, can you imagine such clocks being hung at the Vatican, Westminster Palace ?
It is time these white washing kar seva wale baba were told to go away. They have done nothing but destroy heritage over the years. They raise lots of money and then use the cheapst thing they can find (white wash) to paint over priceless heritage. I wonder where the rest of the money goes.
Re: Golden temple hasnt changed much
singh · 24 Aug 2005
*************
Dear "singh"
No please read this thread properly. I am "ranting" about the loss of heritage full stop. A simple answer to your simple question is that the harimandir is not the same as what Guru Arjan constructed - its a stupid question becuase every one knows that it was rebuilt during Misl times after Abdali had the darbar blown to pieces.
***************
Madra ji this question was asked beacause in your posts you mentioned about the construction of darbar sahib and said that the water seepage problem was not there at the times of guru sahib when you state
***************
by madra: The britlliantly foresighted design of the darbar sahib is made to actually soak in water from the sarovar and then evaporate it through a membrane of lime plaster through teh roof. This gives a damp free building without the need of a damp proof course. the Gurus understood this, Ranjit Singh understood this (when he had the building plated) and I suspect that most people reading this have understood this but civil engineers from the UK cant seem to understand this and have capped the lime plaster with modern cement and now teh building is waterlogged
******************
**************
madra: (see the rapidly tarnishing panles in Freeds pictures for example, or the garish recolouring of the internal paintwork with modern synthetic paints)
**************
Madra ji can you kindly mark the green areas on the pictures as you have stated that panels are going green. I hope I am not color blind.
************************
madra: If the Harimandir's amrble continues to discolour and goes rusty brown or a mouldy green colour becuase of teh damp problems, will you simply shrug your shoudlers and say "oh, that's OK becuase it wasnt from the Guru's time" or woudl you even prefer to have kar sevaks whip the old marble off and replace with them sythetic formica replicas?
************************
can you please shed light who put this marble in
and where was the marble brought from
and what is the life of marble stone
looking forward to seeing the green areas in the plates and getting some gyan from you about the marble