Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Story of durga

Story of durga

Raman · 19 Aug 2005

Ok i heard this story that once durga is hiding away from some 2 demons & gone to some mountains.Where Guru Tegh bahadur ji was on samdhi & he assures durga that nothing happen to her in his custody, then demons came Guru ji sitting on loin Skin.He standup from it put tht khal in hand te ohnu Chadiya ohde vich ik shakti nikli Jinna ne ohna Demons nu maar ditta, After this durga came out & thanku guru ji & saying that in future u will make a relegion who name as Khalsa (bec. it is loin Khal from which that shakti came) Is this from Dasam GRanth & if yes from which part so that i want to know katha of it plz put some light on this

Re: Story of durga

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Aug 2005

is your real name RAMAN or MEHARGAGS ?? WHY the DUALITY ?? This is a "simple" query..but you posted on two different forums under sifferent names ?? i am intrigued ?? why ?? I am also On that Forum...mehargags..or raman Ji ?? Jarnail Singh Gyani

Re: Story of durga

007 Singh · 20 Aug 2005

This is a bippar made up story - ignore it!

Re: Story of durga

raman number 2 · 20 Aug 2005

khalsa was created by Guru Gobind Singh ji according to bachittar natak he was sent to establish a creed that would punish the wicked protect the holy and something else i forgot, but theres no mention of durga mata. God basically gave guru ji the go ahead to create this creed, theres was no durga present when guru ji was at Wahegurus feet in his last life as dushtdaman.

Re: Story of durga

khalsa · 21 Aug 2005

raman or raman2 yes u r right the story is in vachitar natak but this not guru gobind singh ji's writing. it is a biper story. some sikhs believe it to be guru ji's but it is not true. this is our misfortune that sikhs are not prepared to accept this. [%sig%]

Re: Story of durga

fatjoe · 21 Aug 2005

guru ji was not an idol worshiper he was an idol breaker

Re: Story of durga

Singh · 22 Aug 2005

I have not read this story in Vachiitar Natak?? Which version is being discussed??

Re: Story of durga

A Singh · 22 Aug 2005

“Khalsa” or “The Khalsa Fauj” as you are known elsewhere…PLEASE stop with your nonsense Kala Afghana anti-Dasam Granth scheming!!! This is matter concerns the story of Samund Rishi, Dhust Daman and the Devi Mata and is NOT found in the Dasam Granth – which IS the writing of Guru Gobind Singh, as is the Bachittr Natak, contrary to your Bausauria Propaganda that you keep posting everywhere under the name of “khalsa” – disgraceful!!! There is no Khalsa without Dasam Bani!!! As per the story itself, as mentioned above, it is not in the Dasam GRanth – references to it are found in the Sau Sakhi and in “Sikh Lore” or as Roop Kaur put it elsewhere transferred over generations via “Haseena-Baseena” means. It is contentious and I personally do NOT buy into the Sakhi, despite the numerous Babas, Bhai Sahibs and Jathedars etc who have relayed it to the masses. The Sakhi was recently part of a “Sarabloh Granth Katha” by Akali Nihang Baba Santa Singh, Jathedar Budha Dal, (see Sikhawareness to download it) in which he tells the whole story from beginning to end – concluding that Mata Sahib Deva was indeed Adi Shakti herself. There are many reasons why I personally choose not to believe in this particular account, however as stated above it is not part of the Sri Dasam Granth Sahib, which is entirely composed of writings of Guru Sahib and makes no mention of Dhust Daman, Samudn Rishi or the Devi in such context. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Story of durga

Singh · 22 Aug 2005

It is arguable if the whole of Dhasm Granth is the writing of Guru Gobind Singh, even Dolat Rai of the Aryia Samaj who wrote Sahib E Kamal Guru Gobind Singh regards the Chavis Avtar etc as the work of the 52 poets, who obviously wrote poetry. Hence if someone does not accept the entire Dhasm Granth as the work of Guru Gobind Singh that is their personal view based on what they have read, which everyone should respect. "“Sarabloh Granth Katha” by Akali Nihang Baba Santa Singh, Jathedar Budha Dal, (see Sikhawareness to download it) in which he tells the whole story from beginning to end – concluding that Mata Sahib Deva was indeed Adi Shakti herself." Please an you elaborate, who is Mata Sahib Deva? Adi Shakti (primal power) is Akal Purkh.

Re: Story of durga

A Singh · 22 Aug 2005

Dear "Singh", Dasam Granth debate has been banned by the Akal THakt and this forum, so in the interests of continuing the wider discussion, I'll leave that topic, in any event, the views of Dolat Rai are hardly conclusive, nor important insofar as the Chaubis Avtar, if they are and one has a hard time dealing with these banis, then in addition to you Benti Chaupai Sahib, also refrain from reciting and believing in the Dohras and Savayaes that are taken from the 24 Avtars. As per the Katha - listen to it for yourself, the "Nihang" view is clarified in that Katha as to who they consider to be Durga, Adi Shakti etc and why they consider Mata Sahib Deva (again listen to the Katha and you'll understand who the Nihangs regard as Mata Sahib Deva) to be Adi Shakti. It seems to form the basis of what everyone is today keen to dub "Sanatan". As I quite clearly stated above, I personally do not ascribe to this account as there are far too many holes in it for it to add up. GurFateh! A Singh.

Re: Story of durga

The Khalsa Fauj · 22 Aug 2005

Hey Hey Hey! It wasn't me posting here before. Also, before you declare me kala afgana or whatever. Let me tell u on kala afgana. Kala afgana is new. He isn't the first one to write against it. It is not anti-panthic. Dasam Granth is anti-Panthic. No discussions allowed here. Fine, here: Use msn [address removed] We will see who is anti-Panthic. Tapoban Mods. Please allow this message to go through.

Re: Story of durga

khalsa · 23 Aug 2005

A Singh guru nanak ji said" murakh nal na lujiye" i don't want to discuss any thing with you because u r blinded by a tunnel vision. u r against kala afgana because he exposed too many personalities. dasam granth is a tpoic of controversy since it was composed. [%sig%]

Re: Story of durga

Singh · 23 Aug 2005

Khalsa Fauj I would love to read your views. Please can you cc me in concerning any discussions on the isse, my email is [address removed]