Laridaar saroop
? · 20 Aug 2005
Laridaar saroop what do u mean when u refer to a Laridaar saroop ???
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
? · 20 Aug 2005
Laridaar saroop what do u mean when u refer to a Laridaar saroop ???Lionking · 20 Aug 2005
A lareedhar sarop is one with words without space for example - ThissentancewoudlbelaridharifitwasinGurmukhi This sentance would not be laredhaar Laaridhar is in other words, Gurbani without any spaces between the words. This can be found in Puratan Saroops of Guru Granth Sahib Ji :)ManjitSingh · 20 Aug 2005
Guru Sahib JioJarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Aug 2005
all the letters are in one continuous line...no breaks except at major full stops. like this... ekoankaarsatnamgurparsaad. Wahegurujikakhalsa Wahegurujikifateh.singhstar · 20 Aug 2005
its true they should only be the laridhaar saroop, what an idiot who thought of placing spaces, again some brainless idea has defaced the Guru Granth Sahib Ji... if the great Gurus wanted it this way they would have changed the Guru Granth Sahib Ji themselves. who knows what they will do next ...but modern day Gursikhs know best !!!!charanjeev singh · 21 Aug 2005
Singhstar, please understand that you just did nindya of Shaheed Parupkaar Bhai Mani Singh Jee. The humble servant of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. Bhai Mani Singh Jee was given seva as Granthi Sahib Jee of Sri Harmandir Sahib by Guru Gobind Singh Jee Himself. The same seat of athority given to Baba Buddha Jee by Guru Arjan Dev Jee. People have no clue about the rangs of Guru Sahibs.Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Aug 2005
IMHO..Bhai mani Singh did not do "pad chhed"...all he did was to Re-compile Gurbani into smaller POTHIS for the LEARNERS conveneince. IMHO the PANJ GRANTH..DAS GRANTHI..BAII VARAAN BHAGAT BANI POTHIS vailable today were prepared by Bhai Sahib Jee. For this great "academic" act of Gurbani parchaar..misguided fools spread the "false sakhi" that since Bhai Sahib Jee had "Broken up/cut up" the BIRR of GURU GRANTH JI ( Guur Ji's BODY ) he would suffer the SAME FATE and be cut form limb to limb... SO GUYS...BEWARE....IF YOU "cut and paste" Gurbani Files/MP3s/Kirtan Files etc on YOUR COMPUTER.... that is the SAME as "cutting up Guru Ji's BODY"...and you too will suffer the same fate as Bhai Sahib Jee !!!..THATS HOW SILLY that tall tale is... JSsinghstar · 21 Aug 2005
nindya - are u feeling alright - listen next ul defend if someone changes the verses of the mool mantar - ive seen more old handwritten Guru Granth Sahib jis then you can imagine, never were they spaced - they always have the consistency of being in nagri script, who the hell is anyone to change such an important magniificent precious composition written by our Great Gurus even if its spacing the words out....there is no need for change of our Guru ji - its becuase granthis who are too lazy to read it joined up prefer it spaced out ......the Guru Granth Sahib ji is eternal...never never never need for any change in a nut shell - "never try to change Guru ji for your own selfish needs - change your self for Guru ji " - quote - Singhstar 22/August/2005Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Aug 2005
"never try to change Guru ji for your own selfish needs - change your self for Guru ji " - quote - Singhstar 22/August/2005 <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< I LOVE this quote. MY Students thought it is fantastic. Thanks Singhstar ji. THIS is the ULTIMATE cause of our descent into the PIT we are in today... We "seek to change" the GURU..while trying to MAINTAIN our bad habits and etc etc. We WANT MARYADA to change to suit us/our lifestyle/our laziness means we want less banis, later amritvela ( or none ), trimming our beards a bit here and there ( some want more)..Patka instead of the Fi=ull Size Dastaar/Dumalla ( some want ready made caps )..etc etc. Jarnail singhsinghstar · 22 Aug 2005
thank you Jarnail Singh Gyanirsingh · 23 Aug 2005
Vaheguruuu Q: Why doesn't the above HukamNama contain any spaces between words ? A: The HukamNama is displayed in the same manner as the Gurbani appears in the Puratan Saroop of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, at Sri Darbar Sahib. For more details, please read the article titled GURU GRANTH SAHIB - PAD-CHHED PRINTING section under Gurmat Articles. http://www.panthkhalsa.org/Hukam.phpsikh · 23 Aug 2005
sangat ji why is Guru Granth Sahib ji the original bir's written in laridaar? to me it seems really hard to read, why did Guru Sahib have it written in this way?Lionking · 23 Aug 2005
Whichsentancedoyouhavetofocusmoreontoreadthisoneorthenextone Which sentance do you have to focus more to read this one or ther above one?? You have to focus and concerntrate more, and th emind probably wanders less - might be a reason...I have Anbhavi Avastha · 23 Aug 2005
>>> why is Guru Granth Sahib ji the original bir's written in laridaar? to me it seems really hard to read, why did Guru Sahib have it written in this way? >>> This is like asking why did Guru sahib write Japji sahib? How is anyone suppose to answer this question?MBSingh · 24 Aug 2005
Regarding "Sikh" question; the one probable answer seems; Guru Sahib wanted us to face some hardness while reading Gurbani. Hardships made us strong.. · 24 Aug 2005
www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1Harjas Kaur · 25 Aug 2005
I think in it's pure form SGGS is the Guru without break. But for learnin Gurbani I need breaks. This doesn't hurt Guruji any. He takes a hundred steps to help u where u are at. Just like English translations and the like. But if people wanna break the original birs to mistranslate and corrupt the meanings, Guruji's gonna deal with them. Best is to learn to read the Gurumukhi without breaks I agree. "SO GUYS...BEWARE....IF YOU "cut and paste" Gurbani Files/MP3s/Kirtan Files etc on YOUR COMPUTER.... that is the SAME as "cutting up Guru Ji's BODY" That's silly. Guruji can't be hurt by somethin I do. My little brain can't learn Gurbani like to swallow the whole SGGS in one big giant unbroken word. Chill.sikh · 25 Aug 2005
mbsingh thank you for your replysinghstar · 25 Aug 2005
hARJAS kaura if we lived by ur ideas sikhi would no longer existdaas · 25 Aug 2005
[i]"SO GUYS...BEWARE....IF YOU "cut and paste" Gurbani Files/MP3s/Kirtan Files etc on YOUR COMPUTER.... that is the SAME as "cutting up Guru Ji's BODY" That's silly. Guruji can't be hurt by somethin I do. My little brain can't learn Gurbani like to swallow the whole SGGS in one big giant unbroken word. Chill.[/i] harjas kaur bhainji, bhai jarnail singh ji was joking and you're right - that is a silly thought as long as you're not cutting half of sukhmani sahib mp3 and adding it to half of jap ji sahib mp3 or something like thatns · 25 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Jarnail Singh Ji and others , you point out: " For this great "academic" act of Gurbani parchaar..misguided fools spread the "false sakhi" that since Bhai Sahib Jee had "Broken up/cut up" the BIRR of GURU GRANTH JI ( Guur Ji's BODY ) he would suffer the SAME FATE and be cut form limb to limb..." Silly tale one may callit , but it's well documented in the Panth Parkash by Rattan Singh Bhangu. If it wasn't Bhai Mani Singh as you rightly meniton, then who is the culprit behind pad shed?singhstar · 25 Aug 2005
Jarnail Singh Gyani ji and my self singhstar ji the great are 1000% correct in what we say - under no circumstance should you alter the Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The spaces came around 1900 - 1910. Every book - manuscript was in nagri script (joined up) prior to that. Please remeber Sikhs could read the joined script for 300 + years until the 1900s. you can argue or debate about several issues on sikhi - but there is no debate or any reason to even contemplate altering Guru Ji people who do in my mind should be EXECUTED ADMIN this is my view as I feel that Guru ji is simply flawless and timless and deserves the upmost respect. SinghstarHarjas Kaur · 25 Aug 2005
The Christian and Muslim missionaries are way outsourcing you and reaching your children with translations written in a way they can understand. It's one thing to preserve and protect accuracy, and another thing to prevent people from learnin the Gurbani the best way they can. All u do is create a highly trained exclusive priest class who ALONE can quote and read the Gurbani. Then u have political specialists and separatists who split the Panth between the gianis who learn laridaar saroop and the rest of us. Personally, u can't destroy Guruji by sincerely tryin to learn what He says. U think my views will be the demise of Sikhi? If this generation of Punjabi kids who know Punjabi as a second language and sure can't read SGGS in laridaar saroop will be totally lost if u forbid them learning any gurbani at all. And only ones who can read SGGS are the political gianis. Now Im not sayin people shouldn't do their best to learn the proper way. Im sayin don't shut out the Sikhs of the guru from reaching their Guru the only way they can. And this includes English translations and translations in every other language. Otherwise there will NEVER be a hope of Khalistan without the whole world able to come to the feet of Guruji. [%sig%]ns · 29 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Harjas Kaur Ji 100% spot on beautifully said, no wonder when walk around in Hounslow I see people who are from Sikh families and have adopted Christianity and these are numbers are not small they are growing especially in the upcoming generation whose first language is English. oh singhstar Ji, you are way doing overtime on this point... narrow mindedness will not do any favours to Sikhe, it has never has in the past and will never do in future. Oh and don't worry about admins they allow anything through anway.Harjas Kaur · 29 Aug 2005
[quote]people who do in my mind should be EXECUTED[/quote] Well if the Panth starts killing each other, no one will be left to worry about it. FYI, I am an American convert and can't READ in Punjabi. So I struggle to read Paat in Roman, listen to CD's in Punjabi, and read English versions for understanding. But go ahead and kill me Singhstar if you need to protect Guruji from evil people like me. Just remember, without reaching out to people with Gurbani, you silence the voice of the Guru to make an impact in their lives. They will not "hear" Him in a way they can understand. [quote]Please remeber Sikhs could read the joined script for 300 + years[/quote] To my knowledge, Sikhs are still reading in joined script. How does making Gurbani available to those who can't read it in laridaar saroop a crime punishable by death? Would killing all the English speaking converts for reading Gurbani in English help? This is not the right way to reach out to people you should call "sister" and "brother." I lost one job for wearing keski. Half my family no longer speaks to me for becoming a Sikh. What a joke to be killed by a "Singh" who thinks I deserve to be executed for reading Gurbani in English. And you wonder why people become Muslims. Khalistan Zindabad! [%sig%]Sakhi · 29 Aug 2005
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh I agree with Harjas Kaur, even though the ultimate goal of every sikh should be to be able to read from Laridaar saroop, it is okay to use pad ched "gutka sahibs" or "pothis" to learn Gurbani. I don't agree with printing or reading of pad ched saroops of SGGS just gutkas or pothis. Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji maharaj, our living, loving Guru should only be in laridaar saroop.Sikhi Piari · 03 Sep 2005
I heard that the reason Guruji's saroop is lariwaar is that everything written in Sanskrit is written lariwaar, adn that Guruji adn teh likharis of Bir Sahiban were just follwing that tradition. So, doesn't that mean if we push lariwaar saroop we're behaving like Hindus or following Hindus ways? Bul chuck maaf, not tryin to do down any jatheebandee just askin because I thought we're supposed to try to not to be Hindus.Kulbir Singh · 03 Sep 2005
----------- I heard that the reason Guruji's saroop is lariwaar is that everything written in Sanskrit is written lariwaar, adn that Guruji adn teh likharis of Bir Sahiban were just follwing that tradition. So, doesn't that mean if we push lariwaar saroop we're behaving like Hindus or following Hindus ways? ------------ So if Hindus believe in Reincarnation, we are to abandon it lest we become Hindus? If Muslims believe in praying to God, are we to abandon praying lest we become Muslims by praying to God? Same way, if Sanskrit Granths are not padd-chhed, that does not mean that we ought to do padd-chhed in order to become distinct from them. We should not do padd-chhed of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee because doing so is overturning to doing of Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib made it laRidaar. Who are we to change this and do padd-chhed. Above all, the padd-chhed that have been done are all wrong. No one can do the correct padd-chhed of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Only Guru Sahib has that capability. Kulbir Singh. · 03 Sep 2005
www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1singhstar · 14 Nov 2005
well said Kulbir Singh Ji