Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Aug 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. When GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ABOLISHED..the ONE MAN SHOW...and empowered His beloved Guur Khalsa Panth with the PANCH PARDHAAN SYSTEM initiated by GURU NANAK JI SAHIB... we were given a Successful Model to Work With. Baba banda Singh bahadur reverted to the One MAN Pardhaan show..and that was why after such a successful campaign..he faltered and it stopped. But then the Khalsa Ji adopted the PANCH PARDHAAN MODEL...and formed 12 Misls or jathas These were INDEPENDENT Jathas...with their own leader, system etc BUT when faced by the COMMON enemy..they Came together like a solid Jigsaw Puzzle.....and the Enemy soon learned that this was no child's play.. The 12 MISL SYSTEM led to the establsihment of the Khalsa Raaj..but then unfortunately we agains slipped BACKWARDS into the ONE PARDHAAN...Maharaja Ranjit Singh took over sole control of the Khalsa Raaj. If He had kept Staunch and Brave Siksh like Hari Singh nalwa, Sham Singh Atariwala, Baaba Pholla Singh and others of thsi calibre at the FOREFRONT of His Governement..I beleive Ranjit Singh's Kingdom would have survived. At Present, why are we suffering so much. Simple answer. Today we have JATHEDARS at the PEAK..who have actually NO JATHAS to back them up. They are all Backed by the ONE PARDHAAN who holds their puppet strings from behind. The Sikh kaum has successful JATHAS all over the World. What we should do is BRING BACK the MISL SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL that has WORKED before and can Work again. What do I mean..I mean that in EACH COUNTRY... Malaysia, UK, Canada, USA, Germany etc the MAIN SUCCESSFUL SIKH ORGANISATION should Pick a Representative, who with the backing of His Organsiation will Sit together with the OTHER SIMILAR REPRESENTATIVES..from other countries....a SORT of MISL SYSTEM ( where the individual jatha in countries have the freedomn to run their Gurdawra society as per local sangat views..BUT when they Coem together at the INTERNATIONAL LEVEL..like the Misls they ACT as ONE BODY. Any Hukmanams reccomendations on maryada etc passed by this Gathering will have the automatic backing of their parent organistaions and thus work successfully. MINOR splinter groups who dont want to cooperate will soon see the light of day and realise their splinter status..and either join the MAINSTREAM..or remain splinters... History is PROOF that the SIKH MISLS defeated the biggest power..and within about 75 years established the Raaj...while still maintaining their indivuduality. I am of the view that this TRIED and TESTED SYSTEM should be adopted by the Sikh nation..we have the Winning Formula... Bestowed by GURU JI Himself.... to regain our lost glory. What do the readers think about this ? can this System be successful ?/ What are its Flaws or what can cause it to fail/falter ?? Jarnail Singh

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

The Khalsa Fauj · 22 Aug 2005

Missle system lead to all probs. How? Ego came in. Missle leaders fought each other for territory. Maharaja Ranjit SIngh was a product of mislle concept.

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

charanjeev singh · 22 Aug 2005

As a reader, i absolutely agree with this. This is an absolutely beautiful panthic ekta initiative that can prove absolutely promising. I do not believe such a system can fail. However, there is a flaw that can be encountered. In every country you have many groups of sikhs whom do not adhere to one set of principles. And this will again bring upon problems with electing representatives. Unfortunately, in many countries you have people whom are suppose to be working for the betterment of the panth, living their lives contrary to the principles that they are suppose to be preaching. And to worsen the matter, they are backed by like minded people. Unfortunately patits are backed by patits. And by the looks of commitees these days, patits outnumber sikhs by a lot, or so it seems anyway. There has to be a way to filter nominations of non-khalsas. If this can be achieved, i truly believe that Guru Sahib will bless this panth with such chardikala, that on lookers will be awed by the beauty of this Nirmal Panth. I believe that each country should send five representatives. The entire body should consist of five representatives for each country; and the gurmattas accepted by the body should be approved by the Akaal Takhat as the Gurmattaa for the entire panth. Bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

Singh · 23 Aug 2005

Khalsa Raj only occured when the Misls joined into one force under the leadership of Ranjit Singh.

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

S Singh · 23 Aug 2005

The Misal were not the perfect model Arshi Ji has painted. The Ramgharias were destroyed by a combined force of other Misals. The ramgharias also sided with the Mughals during battles (eventually Jassa Singh Ramgharia deserted the imperial forces during a siege situation). The Misals were always at logger heads with each other.

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Aug 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. I am not that much concerned with the "perfectness" or "less than perfectness" of the Misls per se.... As Veer Charanjeev Singh Ji has seen I am More interested in the SYSTEM...of MULTIPLE REPRESENTATION...The PANCH PARDHAAN SYSTEM....the Successful Model shown by the Misls. In the Era of GLOBALISATION..the Ego/territory conquering fears expressed by "The Khalsa Fuj" above have no relevance. The Jathedar of The Sikh naujawan Sabha Malaysia would have no means of "conquering" the place of the Jathedar of Singh Sabah Canada ( forexample purposes only)..SIKHS today have NO TERRITORIES to conquer. A little bit of "ego" may be involved in say "seating arrangements" at the International Conference whereby the Reps from the Bigger Singh Sabhas may jostle for place of "importance" etc but thats about it. What EGO can a Canadian Sikh rep show to a Singaporean Sikh rep ?? Yes the MISLS fought each other/had conflicts....but so did Prithiya with Guru Arjun Ji, the Ram Rais, the 22 Manjis of the GURUS at baab bakalla and the Active opposition to GURU GOBIND SINGH JI by the Hill Rajas etc..CONFLICT is a central part of any period..part and parcel of human organsiations..the MISLS were no less behind in this. It is a FACT that the MISLS led the way and ESTABLISHED the FOUNDATIONS of the Khalsa Raaj.... Baba banda Singh Bahadur alone or Maharaja Ranjit Singh ji alone couldnt have established this without THIS VITAL FOUNDATION. A "SINGLE" revolt like the one led by Guru Gobind Singh Ji could be easily "confined...a REVOLT by a ROVING BANDS of groups like the MISLS proved too much for the Mughals. In the GOBALISED WORLD...such a MISL SYSTEM would mean Reps from Different countries coming together at teh APEX to make weighted judgements reccomendations...and the ability to carry them out...implement them in their own countries. Thsi would be a PRACTICAL and well spread out SARBATT KHALSA. No one would dispute that despite all their Persoanl rivlaries, fights etc when the MISL SARDARS met in a SARBATT KHALSA they had a UNIFIED VOICE. The number of reps from the different countries is not fixed at "one only"..as veer chernjeev Singh ji has pointed out it can be FIVE from each country..keeping in mind the SIKH population in each...obviously bigger reprsentation should be given to a larger sikh population and less to a smaller one..40,000 Sikhs from Singapore cannot be representted by the same number of reps than say from the 500,000 from UK. Jarnail Singh

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

Grail Singh · 23 Aug 2005

S Singh Ji you are right, the Misals were not a rosey picture as painted by our glorious, pious and humble Giani. There were much infighting, much back stabbing, much deviousness. The misals fought each other almost as much as they fought the enemy. Many MisalDhars were killed in battle against other Misals. A bit like our situation today really ! [%sig%]

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Grail Singh and S Singh seem to have missed the point. I am NOT asking for the Original Misls to be REINSTATED ?? he is talking about the MISL SYSTEM of Representation in the Form of a SARBATT KHALSA which can resolve the conflicts and bring about Panthic Ekta. The Misl system worked once before and it can work again. Lets discuss the "SYSTEM" and not the character of the people in the previous misls like Jassa singh ramgharria or whether Maharaja Ranjit Singh ahd 500 wives. this is what i find most distressing..the moemnt someone puts forward an "IDEA"... we dont discuss the idea but take out our swords and microscopes to find fault with the "person who suggested the idea". In what way are the PRESENT 12 reps from Countries around the world getting together to impellement ekta in the Panth...going to be like "jassa singh siding with the mughals/running away from the battlefield or like Maharaja ranjit singh marrying 500 wives ??. In the early 1940's when the British Plan to leave India was first became known - maharaja Bhupinder Singh of Patiala ( biggest sikh state) approached the Akali leadrs like Master Ji and Gyani Kartar singh Ji about lettign him negotate with the British on the Sikh's behalf ( he promised he woudlnt sign anything without asking them first)..wehn these two went back to their people...a few members on the floor OBJECTED STRONGLY..this man Bhupinder is a rascal/married to 500 wives/blah blah blah....we cannot allow him to negotiate on our behalf. The Akalis allowed the REAL RASCAL BALDEV SINGH to SELL out the Sikhs Lock stock and Barrel to Nehru....the results of which we suffer till today. I am of the firm beleif that the Maharaja patial knew trhe British in and out and he would ahve negotiated a much better deal and we would ahve our own BUFFER STATE today. Even NEHRU was clever enough to use the Maharja Patials SIKH ARMY to Fight in kashmir and win back the LOST KASHMIR from PAKISTAN in 1949..if NOT for the SIKHS of Patiala..Kashmir would be in pakistan and not a problem today.( this shows Nehru was "tricky" enough to use the sikhs to save his own state..BUT the SIKHS were not Clever enough to USe their OWN ARMY to SAVE themsleves... There has to be SOME SYSTEM to Bring about a Worldwide SARBATT KHALSA...this MISL SYSTEM seems to be the BEST so far. Grail Singh and S Singh Ji..please suggest your own system. There has to be some change...the "hukmanamas" from the Jathedars at the takhats hold very little significace as we know they are puppets of badal..and they have no backing of their won among the world sangat. JSarshi

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

S Singh · 24 Aug 2005

Gyani Ji. Considering that Maharaja Bhupinder Singh of Patiala died on 22nd March 1938 it is incorrect that you have him down as approaching the Akali leaders in the early 1940s.

Re: THe MISLS SYSTEM..a SUCCESS MODEL

jagga brainch · 24 Aug 2005

plus its also a fact many muslim jatt brothers also partook in battles with the missals. Thus it had a sikh khalsa dominance but side by side a jatt revolution struggle against delhi moghul central authority. the muslim jatts of what is today pakistan were raided by afghans and had no support and joined hands with khalsas. this was not a khalsa raj but secured khalsa rights, it started with khalsa karbania and built on many centuries of khalsa spirit but ended up in a sole monarchy resting on one family. This became a tragedy that weas snowballing from the missals power. Monarchies will never work in sikhism. even the sgpc will one day be replaced by khalsa warriors creating a whole new system. the khalsa ideals are synonous with ancient punjabi ideals such as panchayt panj sarpanchi republiocan system where power goes to people living semi autonomously and uniting into village bands where the need arose. The unitary warfare can be best seen when muslim invaders from arabia came, the jatts united in sucha force they fought headless one century after the next. Dhulla bhatti a rajput punjabi fought and challanged the moghul empire by himself a robin hood figure in west punjabi pakistan.