Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Ek Singh · 24 Aug 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! Sorry for my ignorance, but im not sure, do Sikhs respect Udam Singh and Bhagat Singh Shaheeds or is it just Hindus releasing all them films for Sikhs who do not know their history that well to make it look like Sikhs died for Indian Independence and why should they ask for Khalistan. Also, those of you who have been going India lately may have noticed that Shaheed Bhagat Singh photos are everywhere now - from lorries to motorcycles, a lot of the youth are into it as well, whereas you also may know that other more recent Sikh leaders such as Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale are unknown to the youth and obviously the stupid government has banned all photos of Sant Ji in India!!! I've also heard some dfferent arguments about Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji not visiting Bhagat Singh in jail because he cut his hair or something. I am sorry if I have offended anyone, because im not really sure to which extent Sikhs take pride in the sacrifices of Shaheed Udam Singh and Bhagat Singh. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! [%sig%]

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

confused · 24 Aug 2005

bhai sahib didnt visit him because he used to keep kesh and then cut it...he agreed to meet bhagat singh eventually and then convinced him to grow his hair again and embrace sikhi

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Siddharth · 24 Aug 2005

Dear Ek Singh, 1. Indians died for the Indian independence. Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians all included. This is a fact, not some fantasy created out of thin air by "Hindu film producers". Another conspiracy theory. 2. There were films made on Bhagat Singh much before the concept of Khalistan was even born. In 1965, Manoj Kumar released Shaheed which was made after extensive research Bhagat Singh's mother and his brother were chief contributors to the story) so this is not a new phenomenon. 3. Why do you conveniently forget that Sukhdev and Rajguru were hanged with Bhagat Singh? Is it because they were Hindus? 4. I went to India in March 2005 and nowhere did I see Bhagat Singh's pictures on motorcycles and lorries. Sure, people respect him but that has always been the case. Now, you could have visited cities that I did not go to but your point that his pictures are everywhere is moot. 5. The pictures of Mr. Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale are not banned in India. Please stop throwing around statements like these unless you have facts to back them up. 6. As for Bhai Randhir Singh's views on Bhagat Singh, this has been discussed in a previous topic but Bhai Kulbir Singh and Gyani Jarnail Singh Arshi may be able to help you with details. Regards, Sid.Ek Singh wrote: > Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! > > Sorry for my ignorance, but im not sure, do Sikhs respect Udam > Singh and Bhagat Singh Shaheeds or is it just Hindus releasing > all them films for Sikhs who do not know their history that > well to make it look like Sikhs died for Indian Independence > and why should they ask for Khalistan. > > Also, those of you who have been going India lately may have > noticed that Shaheed Bhagat Singh photos are everywhere now - > from lorries to motorcycles, a lot of the youth are into it as > well, whereas you also may know that other more recent Sikh > leaders such as Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale are > unknown to the youth and obviously the stupid government has > banned all photos of Sant Ji in India!!! > > I've also heard some dfferent arguments about Bhai Sahib > Randhir Singh Ji not visiting Bhagat Singh in jail because he > cut his hair or something. > > I am sorry if I have offended anyone, because im not really > sure to which extent Sikhs take pride in the sacrifices of > Shaheed Udam Singh and Bhagat Singh. > > Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! >

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

S Singh · 24 Aug 2005

I respect Udham Singh Ji as a Punjabi figure (not Sikh). We should also remember that Congress hijacked his name when his remains were returned to India (he was buried in an unmarked grave along with many others so it is not even 100% certain his remains were sent back to India) but during his trial people like mahatma G were denouncing him. I have never had much respect for Bhagat Singh or Kartar Singh etc. It is a fact that Bhagat Singh killed an innocent person so his action was that of a common criminal. He was a stauch communist as was kartar singh. They never respected the Sikh dharam (bhagats family are on a channel 4 documentary confirming he did not believe in God). These communists were turned into indian stars by the congress for political purposes. The families did not oppose the idea as they could then freeload on the indian state through free electric, pensions etc. The real heroes were well before Bhagat Singhs times. Great Shaheed like Shaheed Sham Singh Attariwala are ignored by India as they fought for the state of Lahore (and not for pseudo Indian independence). Bhang addicts like Mangal Pandey are converted by India into indian freedom fighters but our true heroes who battled against the British are conveniently ignored.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Mehtab Singh · 24 Aug 2005

<<>> actually that could very well be true <<< I've also heard some dfferent arguments about Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji not visiting Bhagat Singh in jail because he cut his hair or something.>>> Bhaisahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji did meet Shaheed Bhagat Singh after the latter promised to keep his kesh uncut. He also admitted that he didn't shoot Saunders ([i]if u dunno what i m talking about, watch the movie...lol[/i]) but took the blame on himself for glory. At the end of the day, I have full respect for both these shaheeds, and all other martyrs who sacrificed their lives for their religion, country, or any just cause ([i]i said martyrs and it doesn't refer to those lunatic suicide bombers coz they aint no martyrs for me[/i]), no matter what country or religion they belonged to. <<>> Just because the very first martyr of the Indian independence movement was a non-Punjabi Hindu Brahmin is no reason to throw mud on someone's character. Are we expected to believe that such a man used bhang? A man who sacrificed his life and declared war on the British empire just because his religious sentiments were offended after he used greased cartridges made of animal fat (of cows and pigs)? Instead of appreciating his dedication to his religion and country we are labelling him as a bhang addict! Is it because he was the very first martyr of the Indian independence movement AND was a non-Punjabi AND was a non-Sikh AND was a Brahmin? Nations stand on the sacrifices and blood of their martyrs. "Ek Singh" calls the Indian government stupid for not allowing Sant Jarnail Singh Jee's pictures who is highly regarded by us. Yet we insult their martyr regarded all over India. So where is the difference between us, and those we despise and call stupid?

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

S Singh · 24 Aug 2005

Mangal Pandey admitted in his court martial that he was under the influence of bhang. Even Indian historians like Rudrangshu Mukherjee in his book Mangal Pandey: Brave Martyr or Accidental Hero, also mentions this. So it is not a case of throwing mud but of stating facts. I could not give two hoots if it was Mangal Singh from Punjab or Mangal Ali from Mumbai. A bhang addict is a bhang addict. Mangal Pandey’s action took place in Barrackpore. There is no proof that the real mutineers from Meerut who marched to Delhi and fought the British by declaring Bahadur Shah Zafar as their emperor, had even heard of Mangal Pandey, let alone be inspired by him. There is documented battle accounts of Sham Singh Attariwalas bravery and shaheedi. As for your lunatic suicide bomber remarks I guess you think the shaheed who blew beant su (CM of punjab) was also a lunactic.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Mehtab Singh · 24 Aug 2005

<<>> The difference between believing books written by KPS Gill where he badmouths Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh and Sant Jarnail Singh Jee, and books by Mr Darshi (a Hindu) describing the might of the Singhs defending Sri Darbar Sahib during Operation Bluestar! Which books would you believe? <<>> And a martyr is a martyr. <<>> Which is why all hell broke loose soon after his execution? His British friend officer William Gordon participated in the fight against the East India Company. The man's martyrdom inspired a British officer to go against his own people who had turned oppressive! <<>> Did any innocents die? NO. Did innocents die when WTC was attacked? YES. Suicide bombing has never been an integral part of the Sikh struggle. At times jujhaaroo Singhs did use it, but even then maximum effort was made to avoid an innocent's death. The "regular" suicide bombers I am referring to specifically target innocents.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

S Singh · 25 Aug 2005

<<>> And a martyr is a martyr. Wheres the martyr aspect come into this. The chap consumes bhang and opium gets high and shoots an officer. Most people would see such a person as a criminal rather than falling victim to half baked theories about promoting such people into martyrs. The mutiny was planned a few weeks before Mangal Pandey committed his crime so I do not see the reasoning for trying to elevate him into a martyr and major player in the mutiny. Even the mutiny was just that, a mutiny it was no war for independence. The rhani of jhansi was not concerned about independence but about her right to adopt a successor. If you want to buy into all this Indian congressi garbage about the mutiny being a war of independence then you do so. I can give you indian education texts that openly state Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji was a criminal. It is books from the same people who claim Pandey was a great hero. If you want to buy into this garbage then that is your prerogative.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

power to all singhanis · 25 Aug 2005

if your bro died for a cause would you not feel some kind of compassion towards that? in those tims the brits became tyrannical. innocents die and get killed in revolutions and jangs thats life. bopth these shaheeds believed in their cause. just cos shaheed udham singh cut his hair he actually avenged an attack on the golden temple which is farf more than i can say for any and i mean ANY critics whether religious or not whether kesdari or not drssed in blue and orange dumalle or not sitting pretty comfortably in canada and uk behind computers eating popcorn and having their bills payed by moimmy ji and dadda ji. the aspects of such heroes goes beyond common causes of freedom. I personally do not give a damn what bhagat singhs view on religion was, he was a sher punjabi who fought back the way he knew, so what exactly have hgis critics done on life? what madhaan have they fought that is comparable to rucking with an empire? jack kushnaii! shaheeds jinda sukha also cut their kes to bring their enemies to justicethey are two very rfespecvted heroes in khalistani movement. yet we deny the same respect to shaheed udham singh because he did not have the oppoprtunity to grow his kes back in time. what a shallow thought. our brothers lived rough, often on the hard front line of battles. one other thing when your sakha brother does something for a cause you look at the cause and what he did. For the sandhu clan we always respect our veers. udham singh did something that most critics would be scared of leaving the land of 5 rivers to punish his enemy on the enemiues ground. whoever has a problem with punjabi heroes and i really get peed off with somne of these anti punjabi attituides go find yourselves another religion cos punjab and sikhism go together, many of sikh values are founded oin ancient punjabi practices which predate religion.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Bhudysut · 25 Aug 2005

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh Veer Ji Mehtab Singh I think you are a bit deluded by ultra creative bollywood drama rather than actual historical fact. I know this might seem as though I am slightly changing the argument. But have you ever thought about the reasons for the mutiny? They say it started from cartridges (or kartoos) that were given to Hindu's (were covered in cow fat) and cartridges given to Muslim's (were covered in pork fat). That seems far too contrived. It just seems a bit too appropriate that those soldiers got those cartridges that would offend them most! The East India Company at that time and even now, the majority of historians reject the idea that animal fat was used to grease the cartridges. The whole cartridge issue was jumped upon by poorly advised people who thought they could use it to gain political leverage and/or more money from the British. Hence the emergence of the mutiny of 1857. To treat the mutineers as any kind of martyr's or heroes would be an insult to the names of genuine hero's such as Sham Singh Attariwala, Bhai Maharaj Singh and Bibi Balbir Kaur. Real heroes DO NOT go around massacring innocent women and children (as seen in Cawnpore and other places). Name dropping William Gordon does not hold any merit either. At best, there are unconfirmed accounts that a British officer was seen fighting with the mutineers in Delhi and at worst, he was a figment of someone's immagination. If you do not believe me, this is what Geoffrey McNabb (a reporter) says about him: "Nor is there much information about William Gordon. There are accounts of an unnamed British officer seen in Delhi, fighting with the rebels against the British army. The real Gordon is mentioned in letters and diaries written during the Indian Mutiny as being sympathetic to the Indians, but these don't provide enough material with which to build up any kind of portrait." He even goes on to state that: "The fact that so little is known about Mangal and Gordon enabled Mehta and his screenwriter Farrukh Dhondy to weave together their own riproaring narrative. The Rising is as much bodice-ripper as dry, historical study." I think films like the Rising is another attempt to deminish the efforts put in by Sikhs at our role in India's independance. I think others by dismiss these comments as either delusion, or that I am attempting to back some sort of conspiracy theory against Sikh's role in history. In fact, all I will say is that: DO NOT use bollywood as historical fact, because it has shown time and time again that it cannot differentiate between fact and fiction (Don't believe the hype). Again please forgive me for going off slightly here. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Dass Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Kulwant Singh Sandhra · 25 Aug 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I just wanted to clarify one thing: these famours freedom fighters like, Bhagat Singh, Udham Singh, Kartar Singh Sarabha were all PUNJABI heros...and are nor will not be considered shaheeds of the SIKH kaum because they were all patit (they cut their kes). Personally, I have NO respect for Bhagat Singh, and the fact that people consider him a great freedom fighter is a real laugh. First of all, he killed an innocent person, a police officer named Inspector Saunders. Bhagat Singh had actually plotted out to murder the person who was responsible in the killing of Lala Lajpat Rai (though it is highly doubtful that Lala Lajpat Rai did die as a result of suffering blows to the head). Anyhow, Bhagat Singh ended up killing a peron who he mistook for someone else. Upon realization of the fact that he had killed someone else, Bhagat Singh responded with "chalo, ek gora ta maria". Now tell me...where is the Bahaduri in this? where is the bravery in this? Second, the reason why Bhagat Singh cut his hair...was possibly because he was a nastik, though the REAL reason behind it was for popularity purposes. Lets face it, if Bhagat Singh had thrown the bombs in the assembly as a Singh he would not of created as much of a media frenzy. Thirdly, lets not forget that Bhagat Singh was immensely impressed by the propoganda of the Arya Samaj and their leader Lala Lajpat Rai. Arya Samaj was a conservative extreme right wing kattarpanth Hindu political party. These people were responsible for distorting Sikhism and trying to integrate it into Hindusim, just read their literature. If you ask me, who the real hero was, then I would have to say Shaheed Udham Singh. Why? Because he dedicated 21 years of his life to serve justice to the innocent people who died in the bloody massacre of Jallianwala Bagh. Think about it...for 21 years his life revolved around one goal, to kill the tyrant who spread havoc around Punjab. Again, I don't consider him a martyr of the Sikh kaum but, a great Punjabi hero. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

**- · 25 Aug 2005

The views expressed by S Singh are typical of the view of what the majority of Sikhs have about Hindu freedom fighters. People like him are continually expecting Hindus to appreciate the sacrafices Sikhs have made in the past but show utter contempt for Hindus that have also sacraficed their lives. Respect is a two way thing S Singh.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

don be so weak · 25 Aug 2005

gorei werenot in india to say @ you indians are equal to us@ they ruled over them they were not innocent. They had sections for white only, punjabi women were raped by british soldiers. If one gora went down then anaylse the context was not rtacist but certain conditions at the time. 90% of the punjabi world do not give a toss about any punjabi shaheed having 3 or 6 more hairs on their head or not as far as we are cncerned they are punjabi heroes from the bloodlines that fought for khalsa rights. If bhagat singh and udam singh were here today i have a feeling they would have been at the fron to fkhalistan struggles. The writings of bhagat singh about god seem to point to a want or attension protesting to God do something.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

S Singh · 25 Aug 2005

**- Yes respect is a two way thing. Out those involved in the mutiny I have the up most respect for Tantia Tope. He is one of the real heroes who was betrayed in the end. I also respect the likes of Kunwar Singh the zamindar of Jagdishpur and his brother Amar Singh. I also respect many other Hindus like : Mahadji Scindhia (and his Muslim general Rane Khan) for everything he achieved, Malhar Rao Holkar and Raja Suraj Mal. Raja Suraj Mal liberated hundreds of Hindu women from Ahmad Shah Abdali and I respect him for that. I have no respect for drug taking criminals like Mangal Pandey who are fraudently elevated to a position he did nothing to deserve. If you then think I live in a world where I put down Hindus on the basis of their religion then you are mistaken. If you read what I wrote you will see I do not respect Bhagat Singh (this destroys your view of me having an anti Hindu agenda). I give credit where it is due and refuse to accept all this rubbish about Mangal Pandey. You may be easily fooled by bollywood but I certainly am not.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 26 Aug 2005

Udham Singh undoubtebly did a great service to the Sikh AND ALSO Indian nation, by giving justice to the evil gora general, O'Dwyer. But don't forget, Udham Singh was an orphaned as a child and had really no immediate family. Wouldn't that make him more careless when it came to giving his life? On the other hand we have great shaheeds Beant Singh and Satwant Singh- who were doing the well paid and well respected, powerful jobs as security officers of India's PM- they had families and were happy, but gave it all up. BUT, were Beant Singh and Satwant Singh amritdhari -NO. Beant Singh was of communist beliefs, before he (allegedly) took amrit, just before getting rid of Indira. I have read that he drank alcohol also. So why are these shaheeds thought of as Sikh martyrs, when the likes of Udham Singh are not? I think it is really to do with the climate at the time of the respective sacrifices. When Udham Singh became shaheed, India was trying to gain independence from Britain, so there were not really any religious issues- it was a case of freeing India, with sacrifices coming from all- Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians etc etc. But more recently, in the case of October '84, this was a totally different situation and the great service done by Beant Singh and Satwant Singh, was for Sikhs only (I don't think too many Brahmins were happy) to avenge everything that had gone on at Amritsar. Just my thoughts. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

**- · 26 Aug 2005

S Singh, Apologies for being so pre-judgemental about you. Regards, Sitara

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

gabbar singh · 27 Aug 2005

When it comes to punjabis there is a whole galaxy of martyrs we are not juist a sikh nation we are also punjabis with a long history of martyrdom. The results of free india might be really screwed but the spirit of punjabis and sikhs that went into it was amazing. There is no excuse of bravery of martyrs that comes from time to time in punjab. The same land soaks more blood of fighters from one generation from one century to next from one millenium to the next. There is a deep warrior connection to punjab. Let us say for a moment udham singh was careless about his life what about other punjabi fighters who gave their li9vs passionatly? where did this come from? this has always been the case in punjab, the fiercest jatt clans kicked the moghuls and defeated them for hundreds of years if not for one naval battle and screwed up alliances they would have defeated the whole of arabia if they ever united into one nation. Punjabiat and its effect on people rears a whole new spirit.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

.... · 28 Aug 2005

Bhagat Singh & Udham Singh are Indian heroe's, they are Shaheeds who died for justice for azadi But i wouldn't call them Sikh shaheeds because as you know both committed kureihts and were not Amritdhari. Shaheeds - yes Sikh Shaheeds - NO!

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

ekta · 28 Aug 2005

udham SINGH waged his war from a sikh POV. he was a sikh, who cut his hair 2 reach the insides, and revenge.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

ekta · 29 Aug 2005

accorind to some ppls logic about 35% of the the shaheeds for khalistan who sacrifcied thier lives, and tortures were not sikh shaheeds for they were forced 2 cut their hair or commit a "khurait" if u can call it that in such a situation so that they can do their actions with full force, for without the would have not done so.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Gurpreet Kaur Bajwa · 30 Aug 2005

udham singh was a sikh shaheed greatly remembered by the sikh nation. bhagat singh althouygh more of a national hero was certainly a punjabi hero and also had a spiritual side to him where he quitly did simran and his father or grandad was amritdhari. May waheguru keep both shaheeds in chardi kala and bring them back into the panth for troubled times ahead.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

S Singh · 30 Aug 2005

How was Bhagat Singh a shaheed ? He shot an innocent man (by mistake), played with a few bombs and got hung. It is like calling Mangal Pandey a shaheed. No way can you compare his crimes with what great Punjabi Shaheed like Shaheed Udham Singh Ji did.

Re: Shaheed Udam & Bhagat Singh - Sikh Views

Singh · 30 Aug 2005

A Sikh Shaheed is one who is amritdhari, naam abhiyasi and has not done any of the kurehits and keeps Guru Sahib's rehit. This Shaheed will die for a Sikh principle and Guru Sahib promises him jot vigaas at his last moments and a place in Sach Khand with the other Shahidi Faujan. The standard for a Shaheed is very high and only somone very lucky is blessed with it. Many spritual Gursikhs have said that they wish they could be given the chance for it. If someone is not able to meet these standards but still dies for the Sikh cause I feel they will be born again and have the opportunity to live a Sikh life and be blessed.